PDA

View Full Version : Is the Mirage Series More Accepted by Casuals Than 4Kids is?


Konchadunga
08-05-2013, 05:29 AM
I decided this thread should go in Comic Discussion because, though it may have been cut short, the Mirage series remains a staple of TMNT merchadice (maybe even is to an unprecedented degree) due to its republication by IDW, and also is now second only to the Fred Wolf show in terms of getting referenced subsequently; meanwhile, the 4Kids series is over and not really an object of nostalgia yet.

I could be wrong, but it seems to me that, assuming TMNT fandom still consists primarily of old Fred Wolf fans, they're a lot more interested in the comics than they were in 4Kids. I've heard plenty of people dissing 4Kids for being "different," but when they see a Mirage book in stores, they're all over it and calling it awesome. Similarly, James Rolfe, who started as a Fred Wolf fan, has also read and really liked some of the Mirage stories recently, but so far as I know he hasn't been interested in the 4Kids show. Then, though I hate to cite CheshireCatStudios' angry, ill-informed, and frankly homophobic review of Turtles Forever, the reviewer notably was repulsed by the film's portrayal of the Fred Wolf Turtles, and found the 4Kids Turtles' arbitrary acrobatics and constant use of "what the shell" to be annoying, but loved the Mirage Turtles.

Now, if I'm wrong, that's that. If anyone else has noticed this phenomenon, though, what are your explanations for it? Is the 4Kids show just so much like the Mirage series it is usually viewed as redundant? Is it stigmatized for being made by a widely-despised company? Are people who were children in the 1980s just more into graphic novels than cartoons these days?

The Sewer Lord
08-05-2013, 05:34 AM
It always seemed to me that some people just didn't want to say that they now like the show they used despise.

CyberCubed
08-05-2013, 12:16 PM
Uh, most "casuals" never read a Mirage comic in their life. These are people who were introduced to the franchise with the OT, the movies and the toys/videogames.

I don't know where you're getting the impression that casuals are buying the Mirage comics.

drewizzle88
08-05-2013, 01:32 PM
I know for me personally the 4Kids show just hit at the wrong time, I was in college and really too busy and not thinking about anything TMNT at that point in my life. I grew up an OT fan then moved more to the movies once the first one came out, and then a few years ago got into the Mirage comics which really refueled my love of the turtles as an adult. I have nothing against the 4Kids show I've just never really seen it so have never much desire to watch it.

pingclang
08-05-2013, 01:47 PM
Like Cyber said, I don't know any "casual" who has any interest in the comics. 4kids, at least what I've seen, is decent and I can see casuals getting into it more since the comics are not for everyone. So to answer your question, I would think a "casual" would be more into the animated stuff.

slashpieturtlemix
08-05-2013, 02:06 PM
I like the 4kids show a lot but I think it was just on tv with the wrong shows. I loved turtles but sonic was not helping their lineup in my book. I do not know a single show, besides from here, who are reading the comics. I love the comics but the show is extremely close. Except with the time episode missing Cerebus lol

CyberCubed
08-05-2013, 02:17 PM
I like the 4kids show a lot but I think it was just on tv with the wrong shows. I loved turtles but sonic was not helping their lineup in my book. l

Wait, what? Sonic X was 4kids highest rated show along with TMNT.

slashpieturtlemix
08-05-2013, 03:54 PM
Wait, what? Sonic X was 4kids highest rated show along with TMNT.

And Bleach was one of Japan's highest cartoon success. Not everything with a good rating is worth more than the production cost. Think of it like Popeye with pretty colors.

CyberCubed
08-05-2013, 03:58 PM
And Bleach was one of Japan's highest cartoon success. Not everything with a good rating is worth more than the production cost. Think of it like Popeye with pretty colors.

What does this have anything to do with the show airing though? Kids watched Sonic X which was on the same channel as TMNT and most stuck around for it.

If anything Sonic X probably helped TMNT get more viewers.

slashpieturtlemix
08-05-2013, 04:10 PM
What does this have anything to do with the show airing though? Kids watched Sonic X which was on the same channel as TMNT and most stuck around for it.

If anything Sonic X probably helped TMNT get more viewers.

I guess the same thing can be said about dbz and everything in that time slot. I usually build a show on its own merits.

CyberCubed
08-05-2013, 04:15 PM
I guess the same thing can be said about dbz and everything in that time slot. I usually build a show on its own merits.

I don't even know what kind of point you're trying to make here anymore.

slashpieturtlemix
08-05-2013, 04:24 PM
I don't even know what kind of point you're trying to make here anymore.

You are right. I will stop. No use trying to prove anything.

Konchadunga
08-05-2013, 08:32 PM
I credit getting up to watch Sonic X as the reason I also got into Turtles and Ultimate Muscle, but I also concluded that Sonic x was abysmal after just a few episodes.

CyberCubed
08-05-2013, 08:48 PM
Some people are getting into Mirage now because IDW is putting out new collections. However they can't get into 4kids because the show isn't being re-released on DVD.

If Nick ever bothers to release the 4kids series on DVD in proper sets, then maybe you'll see a whole bunch of people finally get into it. You can't blame people for nothing trying what isn't available.

MikeandRaph87
08-05-2013, 08:59 PM
I do not think so. Ninja Turtles (2003) is a cartoon while Mirage is a comic series. The cartoon is much more mainstream sicen it has the mask color right incoroprate some other elements from fellow other media and has many more products than the black and white version could ever hope to have. Just because its largely sitting this ride out does not mean the Mirage comic is accepted more at this current time. Cartoons are always more accepted than a comic and most of the time done better reaching out to a much wide audience than the much smaller circle of comics. The 2003 cartoon adapted issues of the Mirage series I will never care enough to read the same goes for those that are not major fans not vice versa. Before moving from long time lurker to registered member and went to the comic section I can count on one hand the fellow turtles fans I know that have actually given a look at the comics beyond Archie and actually liked the black and white comics.

CyberCubed
08-05-2013, 09:05 PM
Well comics in general are a hard sell. Most people who go to see all those Marvel movies in theaters will never pick up a Marvel comic.

I am a huge Batman fan because of the cartoons/movies, yet I have never picked up a single Batman comic in my life. I do skim through some Batman comics while at the shop, but I never bring it home.

Honestly if I wasn't such a hardcore TMNT fan, I probably would have never gotten into the comics.

MikeandRaph87
08-05-2013, 09:09 PM
Well comics in general are a hard sell. Most people who go to see all those Marvel movies in theaters will never pick up a Marvel comic.

I am a huge Batman fan because of the cartoons/movies, yet I have never picked up a single Batman comic in my life. I do skim through some Batman comics while at the shop, but I never bring it home.

Honestly if I wasn't such a hardcore TMNT fan, I probably would have never gotten into the comics.

You really should take a look at the Earth-One era Batman comics,Cyber. That is where a large chunk of the other media has adapted from and has the biggest stable of notable creators ever. Its not campy yet his not hopelessly dark, the poridge was just right if you will. :)

Coola Yagami
08-05-2013, 10:32 PM
Yeah... casuals don't read the comics. Casuals walk around with Hot Topic TMNT shirts on barely remembering an 80's episode, and diss the 2K12 TMNT for not being 'their ninja turtles' again, without ever seeing a single episode.

I assume you're not a hardcore enough Batman fan as you are a TMNT fan, Sir Cubed? I loved the 88 (or whatever year it was) Batman so much, it got me curious about a Batman more bad-ass than the Adam West version and picked up a comic. Stuck on em ever since.

CyberCubed
08-05-2013, 10:41 PM
I've seen every Batman TV incarnation and all the movies, but the interest just isn't there to get into the comics. I should probably pick up some collections at some point.

I guess it depends on what your #1 fandom is. Mine is TMNT with secondary interest in DC and Marvel, then Star wars, then Pokemon, etc. The further down my list goes the less I have to see everything.

Coola Yagami
08-05-2013, 10:44 PM
I've seen every Batman TV incarnation and all the movies, but the interest just isn't there to get into the comics. I should probably pick up some collections at some point.

I guess it depends on what your #1 fandom is. Mine is TMNT with secondary interest in DC and Marvel, then Star wars, then Pokemon, etc. The further down my list goes the less I have to see everything.

Mine is also TMNT, but second goes to Batman, with DC being mostly the Batman related stuff. I just got really lost in the Marvel shuffle. The movies are easier since they start at the beginning, and I at least know enough about most of the characters to get what was the same and what was changed or updated.

bjaxx87
08-06-2013, 08:00 AM
I've seen every Batman TV incarnation and all the movies, but the interest just isn't there to get into the comics. I should probably pick up some collections at some point.
If you watched the "Year One" and "The Dark Knight Returns" animated movies, you at least know very, very accurate adaptions of some of the greatest Batman comics of all time.

Maybe you should check out "The Man Who Laughs" and "The Killing Joke" if you like the Joker.

Venom
08-06-2013, 03:52 PM
I've seen every Batman TV incarnation and all the movies...

What are your thoughts on the 40's serials?