PDA

View Full Version : Oroku Nagi: Who needs him?


Jester
08-09-2013, 06:57 PM
So....even in stories that use Tang Shen and Yoshi's relationship in stories, they seem to scrap Oroku Nagi, Shredder's older brother who's murder at the hands of Hamato Yoshi for crimes against his beloved sparked the whole feud between the Turtles and Shredder in the first place.

Since he's easily supplanted by his own brother (in the 1st movie and most recently the Nick toon.) or some generic orphan "brother" to Yoshi himself, does the Turtles lore even need Oroku Nagi?

Slade
08-09-2013, 07:06 PM
I'm going to say no, seeing as until early last year, I never even knew about him.

Joey Kamikaze
08-09-2013, 07:10 PM
Well, the original Mirage TMNT #1 was supposed to a one-shot parody of Daredevil, right? The Shredder dies in the first issue, and I don't think Eastman and Laird thought through any kind of personal rivalry between Oroku Saki and the Turtles when they wrote that first issue. They were trying to tell a tongue-in-cheek story about a ninja clan, honor, revenge, etc., and the little details weren't supposed to matter much outside setting up the fight in the climax. So Oroku Nagi fit into that story when it was a one-shot, but once the series came into its own, he became a footnote. Later, when different TMNT universes built on Oroku Saki's character and made him more of a focal point in the mythology, it made sense to streamline the narrative and give him a more personal vendetta against Hamato Yoshi, and Oroku Nagi officially became extraneous.

So no, in the context of an ongoing series, I'd say the mythology doesn't really need Shredder's brother. It's one of those false starts you see a lot at the beginning of stories that grow with the telling.

CyberCubed
08-09-2013, 07:17 PM
I think it was so Shredder killed someone Yoshi loved (Tang Shen), then Yoshi killed someone Shredder loved (his brother Nagi), and then Shredder killed Yoshi.

...And then Splinter has the Turtles kill Shredder. In the Mirage universe the vengenence cycle works well.

Of course in other universes he's not really needed which is why he is dropped. Also I found it amusing the original toon made Shredder's brother into a Tokyo police cop.

Warboss74
08-09-2013, 07:19 PM
I think the dynamic his place in the origin brings to the character of the Shredder and subsequently Splinter and the turtles is something I'd like to see explored in future turtle universes.

Jester
08-09-2013, 07:32 PM
Well, the original Mirage TMNT #1 was supposed to a one-shot parody of Daredevil, right? The Shredder dies in the first issue, and I don't think Eastman and Laird thought through any kind of personal rivalry between Oroku Saki and the Turtles when they wrote that first issue. They were trying to tell a tongue-in-cheek story about a ninja clan, honor, revenge, etc., and the little details weren't supposed to matter much outside setting up the fight in the climax. So Oroku Nagi fit into that story when it was a one-shot, but once the series came into its own, he became a footnote. Later, when different TMNT universes built on Oroku Saki's character and made him more of a focal point in the mythology, it made sense to streamline the narrative and give him a more personal vendetta against Hamato Yoshi, and Oroku Nagi officially became extraneous.

So no, in the context of an ongoing series, I'd say the mythology doesn't really need Shredder's brother. It's one of those false starts you see a lot at the beginning of stories that grow with the telling.Well said sir. I'm surprised that Mirage never tried to expand on him. I mean, there's gotta be some story potential there. Do something with Nagi's relationship with Saki. Show the human side that made his death change Saki. (Well, that and supposedly the Foot's training.)


Off topic, but something just dawned on me....How does Splinter know about events that happen to Saki in Japan while he and the Hamato's are in NY?

Sorry....over thinking.

I think it was so Shredder killed someone Yoshi loved (Tang Shen), then Yoshi killed someone Shredder loved (his brother Nagi), and then Shredder killed Yoshi.

...And then Splinter has the Turtles kill Shredder. In the Mirage universe the vengenence cycle works well.

BUT that's not how it works.

Yoshi killed Nagi to protect Shen, THEN years later Saki kills BOTH Shen and Yoshi in an act of revenge. The Turtles killing Shredder does close the loop, but there's no Shredder killing Shen so Yoshi kills Nagi.

I think the dynamic his place in the origin brings to the character of the Shredder and subsequently Splinter and the turtles is something I'd like to see explored in future turtle universes.

As I said above, me too. So much untapped potential. May have to come up with a "fanon" story about Nagi.

tmnt transformer
08-09-2013, 07:41 PM
I think that he was removed because it would make yoshi look like a bad guy...

Jester
08-09-2013, 07:55 PM
I think that he was removed because it would make yoshi look like a bad guy...
Thought crossed my mind. Heck, I've often thought it'd be cool to see a Turtle story that was just that, seeing Yoshi killing Nagi from the eyes of his little brother, the man who would be Shredder.

Coola Yagami
08-09-2013, 07:59 PM
It would make things so much more intense. Especially if we sprinkle some flashbacks as Saki and Nagi chillin as bros during 'the good old days' before they ever met Yoshi and Shen.

Imagine how much more violent and insane 2012 Shredder would have been if Yoshi did kill his brother...?

Cipher
08-09-2013, 08:45 PM
While Nagi's easily the most expendable element of the origin story (hence his never making it out of the comics), he does play an important role in Mirage.

He sets up the idea the Shredder is simply taking revenge against Yoshi, who wronged him, albeit with the guidance and manipulation of the Foot high-ups spurring him on. It makes Splinter's subsequent revenge on Shredder a little uglier.

We get: Saki avenging Nagi by killing Yoshi > Splinter avenging Yoshi by killing Shredder (through the Turtles) > A resurrected Shredder taking revenge upon the Turtles for his death (mixing April and Casey into things) > The Turtles returning to take revenge upon Shredder > The Foot and Foot Elite vowing to take vengeance upon the Turtles > Karai making the Turtles promise to help her avenge her daughter (while finally breaking the chain)

Which is all a lot more interesting and morally cloudy than it is when Saki is just stone-cold bad-guy. While he's not essential, Nagi is a huge benefit to any version attempting to look at the consequences of Splinter and the Turtles' vengeance, as Volume 1 of Mirage does. Saki only ever wanted the same thing Splinter did.

AquaParade
08-09-2013, 11:46 PM
While Nagi's easily the most expendable element of the origin story (hence his never making it out of the comics), he does play an important role in Mirage.

He sets up the idea the Shredder is simply taking revenge against Yoshi, who wronged him, albeit with the guidance and manipulation of the Foot high-ups spurring him on. It makes Splinter's subsequent revenge on Shredder a little uglier.

We get: Saki avenging Nagi by killing Yoshi > Splinter avenging Yoshi by killing Shredder (through the Turtles) > A resurrected Shredder taking revenge upon the Turtles for his death (mixing April and Casey into things) > The Turtles returning to take revenge upon Shredder > The Foot and Foot Elite vowing to take vengeance upon the Turtles > Karai making the Turtles promise to help her avenge her daughter (while finally breaking the chain)

Which is all a lot more interesting and morally cloudy than it is when Saki is just stone-cold bad-guy. While he's not essential, Nagi is a huge benefit to any version attempting to look at the consequences of Splinter and the Turtles' vengeance, as Volume 1 of Mirage does. Saki only ever wanted the same thing Splinter did.

Great summary.

That everlasting thread of revenge provided the Mirage series with a very rich texture throughout it's existence. Am I losing anyone?

Tazi
08-10-2013, 04:25 AM
...and there's also Pimiko and Lady Shredder.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-10-2013, 12:23 PM
I think Splinter is just able to assume that Saki was fueled by vengeance, and since New York is so far away and its hard to keep an eye on whoever they send, they're going to make SURE they send someone who is competent. So Saki had to train hard if he wanted the opportunity for revenge. I don't think its so much that Splinter is privy to what is happening in Japan as it is that he is simply insightful/able to put two and two together.

Birdman37
08-10-2013, 08:11 PM
Off topic, but something just dawned on me....How does Splinter know about events that happen to Saki in Japan while he and the Hamato's are in NY?

Sorry....over thinking.



Am I mixing things up here or was Splinter not Yoshi's pet in Japan and he brought him to NY with him?

Mr._Mutant_Man
08-12-2013, 01:30 AM
I think Nagi works with the satire aspect of the first issue. Having that extra character makes the backstory that much more convoluted.

Jester
08-12-2013, 01:44 AM
Am I mixing things up here or was Splinter not Yoshi's pet in Japan and he brought him to NY with him?
He was....but the fled when Saki was still a boy.

Lampy
08-12-2013, 02:31 AM
honestly, i believe that nagi isn't so important. his omission in recent turtles lore has only been positive and made the story less convoluted. in the original story, the nagi-yoshi-shen love triangle was fine. but it felt more like their respective brother/pet are fighting someone else's battles. then again... they were a clan and they are family members respectively. so it was fine. but it felt like a game of tag that spanned generations to me.

tang shen is tagged by nagi who is tagged by yoshi who is tagged by saki who is tagged by the turtles who were trained by the one who was supposed to tag saki.

nagi's omission made the feud simpler and in the nicktoon and idw's case, really personal... as they are the players that started the game (so to speak). and that to me makes more sense than spending 15 years preparing to kill the person who killed your master's master who killed your intended target's brother.
on the other hand, i liked the concept saki avenging his brother. also, with nagi gone, saki looks less like an avenging brother and more of a jealous prick. "if i can't have her, no one can!" i'm glad idw avoided that.

Powder
08-12-2013, 06:07 AM
I'm with Lampy on this 100%, they've worded it well.

Bry
08-12-2013, 05:18 PM
I think it was so Shredder killed someone Yoshi loved (Tang Shen), then Yoshi killed someone Shredder loved (his brother Nagi), and then Shredder killed Yoshi.

...And then Splinter has the Turtles kill Shredder. In the Mirage universe the vengenence cycle works well.

I've always liked this aspect of the Mirage run. All those moments where the cycle of vengeance is recognized/renewed really struck a chord with me. Vengeance perpetuates vengeance, and it never ends - it only brings hatred and death to everyone it touches. Heavy stuff!

This theme is lost a bit when you cut out Nagi and fold Splinter and Yoshi into one character, but it also makes sense for most adaptations to simplify the backstory. Ultimately it works either way, but I'm of the opinion that Nagi does have a strong narrative purpose.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
08-12-2013, 05:37 PM
He was created for the first story, to be published once (as all of the other characters were). Not to fit within a major franchise 30 years later.

Lampy
08-12-2013, 10:45 PM
I've always liked this aspect of the Mirage run. All those moments where the cycle of vengeance is recognized/renewed really struck a chord with me. Vengeance perpetuates vengeance, and it never ends - it only brings hatred and death to everyone it touches. Heavy stuff!

best way to explain it.

Venom
08-13-2013, 12:25 PM
Personally, I'd like Nagi to pop up in IDW as Karai's father, once again placing him back into the mythos as well as connecting him to Saki.

Andrew NDB
08-13-2013, 12:29 PM
Well, the original Mirage TMNT #1 was supposed to a one-shot parody of Daredevil, right?

Wrong.

I've always liked this aspect of the Mirage run. All those moments where the cycle of vengeance is recognized/renewed really struck a chord with me. Vengeance perpetuates vengeance, and it never ends - it only brings hatred and death to everyone it touches. Heavy stuff!

This theme is lost a bit when you cut out Nagi and fold Splinter and Yoshi into one character, but it also makes sense for most adaptations to simplify the backstory. Ultimately it works either way, but I'm of the opinion that Nagi does have a strong narrative purpose.

Yep, without Nagi you lose a pretty important chain link in the (ultimately self-defeating) cycle. Hamato Yoshi wasn't a saint... he should have blood on his hands, too.

Matches Malone
08-14-2013, 05:08 PM
While Nagi's easily the most expendable element of the origin story (hence his never making it out of the comics), he does play an important role in Mirage.

He sets up the idea the Shredder is simply taking revenge against Yoshi, who wronged him, albeit with the guidance and manipulation of the Foot high-ups spurring him on. It makes Splinter's subsequent revenge on Shredder a little uglier.

We get: Saki avenging Nagi by killing Yoshi > Splinter avenging Yoshi by killing Shredder (through the Turtles) > A resurrected Shredder taking revenge upon the Turtles for his death (mixing April and Casey into things) > The Turtles returning to take revenge upon Shredder > The Foot and Foot Elite vowing to take vengeance upon the Turtles > Karai making the Turtles promise to help her avenge her daughter (while finally breaking the chain)

Which is all a lot more interesting and morally cloudy than it is when Saki is just stone-cold bad-guy. While he's not essential, Nagi is a huge benefit to any version attempting to look at the consequences of Splinter and the Turtles' vengeance, as Volume 1 of Mirage does. Saki only ever wanted the same thing Splinter did.

Totally agree with the sentiment that Nagi's existence gives Saki that extra dimension in which he is motivated by revenge which is manipulated by the Foot rather than just being evil for the sake of evil. However, it still feels a bit superfluous to add another character just to give Sak his motivation. Perhaps rearranging elements of issue #1 (Nagi's love for Tang Shen and Saki's desire for revenge), The Foot manipulates Saki into seeking vengeance against Splinter for Tang Shen's death? Sounds kind of like fan fiction at this point and it retains Tang Shen's role as just a means to motivate another character (or now two) but at least it's a bit more streamlined this way with one less extraneous character.

Coola Yagami
08-14-2013, 05:20 PM
Wrong.



Yep, without Nagi you lose a pretty important chain link in the (ultimately self-defeating) cycle. Hamato Yoshi wasn't a saint... he should have blood on his hands, too.

I would have loved a casual flashback of Saki and Nagi as teens together or something. Sad thing is, noone of the Oroku family is alive to have said flashback.

Jester
08-14-2013, 05:29 PM
But wasn't Saki over 10 years Nagi's junior?

Coola Yagami
08-14-2013, 05:39 PM
But wasn't Saki over 10 years Nagi's junior?

Oh wow. You're right. Then I don't know... Maybe Saki showing young Nagi a few katas? I don't know. Fishing by the lake? Just anything with those two hangin before Nagi ever decided to join the Foot.

I forgot if Saki was already a Foot member or if he joined it as a means to get his revenge.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
08-15-2013, 06:38 AM
Yep, without Nagi you lose a pretty important chain link in the (ultimately self-defeating) cycle. Hamato Yoshi wasn't a saint... he should have blood on his hands, too.I couldn't have said it better myself. This is also why I disagree with people saying that the addition of this character makes things "convoluted".
Totally agree with the sentiment that Nagi's existence gives Saki that extra dimension in which he is motivated by revenge which is manipulated by the Foot rather than just being evil for the sake of evil. However, it still feels a bit superfluous to add another character just to give Sak his motivation. Perhaps rearranging elements of issue #1 (Nagi's love for Tang Shen and Saki's desire for revenge), The Foot manipulates Saki into seeking vengeance against Splinter for Tang Shen's death? Sounds kind of like fan fiction at this point and it retains Tang Shen's role as just a means to motivate another character (or now two) but at least it's a bit more streamlined this way with one less extraneous character.Do things even NEED to be streamlined, though? I don't understand what's so superfluous about the addition of Nagi. He isn't just tacked on as he serves a very important purpose, and taking him out of the story changes the story greatly, even with the revision that you were suggesting.

The way I see it, if a version of TMNT uses Nagi or not seems to depend on how they want to portray the other characters. Nagi may seem like a very minor aspect, but make no mistake: just because he's a minor character doesn't mean that the effects he has on the story are minor. A character can be minor and still have major effects on the narrative.

Matches Malone
08-15-2013, 12:43 PM
Do things even NEED to be streamlined, though? I don't understand what's so superfluous about the addition of Nagi. He isn't just tacked on as he serves a very important purpose, and taking him out of the story changes the story greatly, even with the revision that you were suggesting.

The way I see it, if a version of TMNT uses Nagi or not seems to depend on how they want to portray the other characters. Nagi may seem like a very minor aspect, but make no mistake: just because he's a minor character doesn't mean that the effects he has on the story are minor. A character can be minor and still have major effects on the narrative.

I guess it's up to debate whether the TMNT origin needs to be streamlined; it might just be my preference. Like I said, I do agree that Nagi serves an important role as elaborated by some of the other posts, but I think it's arguable that his character only exists to provide that motivation for Shredder and Splinter; he's not really his own character, so either flesh him out or find another way to carry out his purpose.

If the idea is to have blood on Splinter's hands, I'd say the killing of Shredder is a portrayal of that. Anyway, ultimately I don't have a problem with Nagi, just expressing that I think there could be some workarounds so that there are fewer undeveloped and expendable characters.

Andrew NDB
08-15-2013, 01:04 PM
It would be interesting if Oroku Nagi somehow survived the Hamato Yoshi encounter.

Matches Malone
08-15-2013, 01:31 PM
It would be interesting if Oroku Nagi somehow survived the Hamato Yoshi encounter.

Definitely unrealized story and character potential with Nagi. It would definitely be interesting to see Saki's reaction.

Andrew NDB
08-15-2013, 01:37 PM
Definitely unrealized story and character potential with Nagi. It would definitely be interesting to see Saki's reaction.

That the whole genesis of the circle of vengeance... would have been originating from a lie.

Would definitely make for a compelling story.

Lord Nightwalker
08-15-2013, 09:02 PM
That the whole genesis of the circle of vengeance... would have been originating from a lie.

Would definitely make for a compelling story.

That it would have. Imagine the potential repercussions...

***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-15-2013, 11:33 PM
The argument has already been made that Splinter in the Mirage universe is kind of a shady guy, so...

Andrew NDB
08-16-2013, 03:14 AM
The argument has already been made that Splinter in the Mirage universe is kind of a shady guy, so...

Doesn't really affect Splinter's character or morality at all unless we're to assume that Splinter knowingly omitted that Nagi survived Yoshi's beating somehow... though why would he do that? His whole case hinged on selling the Turtles on them needing to kill Saki to avenge Yoshi... it'd behoove him to point out that Nagi survived and tell the truth, to paint Yoshi (his owner) in a better light than basically a cold-blooded killer who got what was coming to him when little Saki grew up.

I'm just saying, what if after Yoshi and Shen walked away, Nagi wasn't really dead. And years later he shows up.

Krang100
08-16-2013, 11:43 AM
I understand his absence in FW catoons, to simplify the story, as well, Hamato Yoshi killed Nagi, was too dark to show up in the OT's. In 2k3 Shedder wasn't human, is way it was impossible to put Nagi, although the other Oroku Saki who is Tengu Shredder, could have a brother named Oroku Nagi. In cartoons again, if Hamato Yoshi is Splinter, again to simplify the story Nagi was abstent. But in IDW, i don't see any problem to put Oroku Nagi, this time in another situation.

Jester
01-25-2014, 08:46 PM
Yep, without Nagi you lose a pretty important chain link in the (ultimately self-defeating) cycle. Hamato Yoshi wasn't a saint... he should have blood on his hands, too.
I know it's odd coming back to this, but in rereading the thread this post rang a bell to me. By removing Oroku Nagi from the equation there are 2 results that are less than stellar:
1. Oroku Saki is made PURE EVIL. He's a attempted rapist and a murderer. Not a grieving brother out for revenge.
2. Hamato yoshi is made PURE GOOD. Yoshi just acts when threatened and never actually kills anyone. Sure even Mirage Yoshi acts because Nagi attacked Tang Shen, but he flat killed a dude. It's still a murder that makes him less than just "The Good Guy."

Coola Yagami
01-25-2014, 08:50 PM
I know it's odd coming back to this, but in rereading the thread this post rang a bell to me. By removing Oroku Nagi from the equation there are 2 results that are less than stellar:
1. Oroku Saki is made PURE EVIL. He's a attempted rapist and a murderer. Not a grieving brother out for revenge.
2. Hamato yoshi is made PURE GOOD. Yoshi just acts when threatened and never actually kills anyone. Sure even Mirage Yoshi acts because Nagi attacked Tang Shen, but he flat killed a dude. It's still a murder that makes him less than just "The Good Guy."

Dang... those are two very fine points. It's easy to forget Shredder was out to avenge his brother all along.

Jester
01-25-2014, 08:58 PM
Yeah, points to Mirage for making the morality of the Cycle of Vengeance very grey for a black and white comic compared to other Turtles media.

Andrew's probably tenting his fingers like Mr. Burns as I type.

Leo656
01-25-2014, 09:18 PM
Blame/Thank the property becoming more mainstream. For the sake of movies and TV aimed (primarily) at kids, the protagonist and antagonist need to be much more cut-and-dry.

Although his brother getting killed hardly justifies Saki trying to rape Tang Shen in any way, let alone kill her. And I'm not a huge fan of Splinter as a douche. So I've always looked at the changes as improvements, really.

So much of Mirage #1 would likely have been written differently had they known they were building the foundation for another 30+ years of stories, instead of a one-shot parody book.

Candy Kappa
01-26-2014, 04:23 AM
Saki was around 8 years old when Nagi was murdered, the trained 'til he was ca 18 to avenge his older brother.

That's dedication on a Batman level.

LeotheLateBloomer
01-26-2014, 07:20 AM
I hope one day we see Oroku Nagi in other TMNT media. Hopefully in the next cartoon or in direct-to-video animations.

corvus
01-26-2014, 10:09 AM
I'm pretty sure theres a huge portion of TMNT fans who don't know Nagi existed

Warboss74
01-26-2014, 10:40 AM
Blame/Thank the property becoming more mainstream. For the sake of movies and TV aimed (primarily) at kids, the protagonist and antagonist need to be much more cut-and-dry.

Although his brother getting killed hardly justifies Saki trying to rape Tang Shen in any way, let alone kill her. And I'm not a huge fan of Splinter as a douche. So I've always looked at the changes as improvements, really.

So much of Mirage #1 would likely have been written differently had they known they were building the foundation for another 30+ years of stories, instead of a one-shot parody book.

It's that kind of attitude towards characterization that results in making Greedo shoot first instead of Han.

Leo656
01-26-2014, 10:53 AM
I didn't make the rules. Doesn't change the fact that, with rare exception, they exist. In this case, in turning TMNT into a cartoon/toyline/movie, there really wasn't any room at all to imply Saki is anything less than bad and Yoshi is anything less than good. The lines have to be drawn a lot thicker when you're marketing a product to kids and families. That's just how it is.

Panda_Kahn_fan
01-26-2014, 11:12 AM
Nagi was important to the Mirage comics, but he is of little to no importance anywhere else. The cycle of vengence is exlusive to the source material, every other version has gone the Saki=Bad, Yoshi= good route. It become the 'common mythology' of turtles lore. If a writer has a story to tell with Nagi in a particular version, then he can be used. If not, he should not be shoehorned in by the magical words 'source material'. Like any other concept, the cycle of vengence hould only be brought into a version if it suits the intended narrative of the storyteller.

And I've said it before and I'll say it again, if you look across many diffrent stories and mythological cycles, the only signifgance the 'source material' usually has is it's the first version. A 'common mythology' ususally develops out of all the various adaptations, retellings, and additions later storytellers add. If you resticted storytellers to going back to the 'source material' well, the aurthian cycle, Greek/Roman mythology and the superman mythos would all be very, very diffrent. Once the 'common mythology' of 4Kids, Fred Wolf, the movies, archie, and all the others entered the public consiousness, it can be argued that Mirage simply became another ingredient in the 'common mythology soup' that superceeded it's primacy.

Tazi
01-26-2014, 11:16 AM
Saki=Bed Yoshi= good
wtf is a 'bed yoshi'? :trolleye:


ah figured, never mind.


but google thinks something else:
http://fc01.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2013/290/2/7/tell_yoshi__a_bed_time_story____by_raygirl12-d6qs1q2.png

Panda_Kahn_fan
01-26-2014, 11:17 AM
Thanks, fixed.

And yes, there are the exceptions of bad adaptations, but bad aspects are usually ignored in the 'common mythology'. I would point to Harley Quinn, Jimmy Olsen, Kryptonite, and Sir Lancelot as not originating from the source material in thier rspective fictions, and migrated into the 'common mythology' from andaptations/retellings

Warboss74
01-26-2014, 11:38 AM
I didn't make the rules. Doesn't change the fact that, with rare exception, they exist. In this case, in turning TMNT into a cartoon/toyline/movie, there really wasn't any room at all to imply Saki is anything less than bad and Yoshi is anything less than good. The lines have to be drawn a lot thicker when you're marketing a product to kids and families. That's just how it is.

I understand drawing that distinction in the cartoons even though 2K3 dabbled in it, but I don't think that's the case given the way comic book movies are made today. Loki's probably the most interesting character in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and has a fairly large following. Large enough that they likely went back and changed his fate in Thor 2 when they did the reshoots with Hiddleston.

The Fifth Turtle
01-26-2014, 12:18 PM
I'm pretty sure theres a huge portion of TMNT fans who don't know Nagi existed

You can say that with confidence not uncertainty.

Cipher
01-26-2014, 02:38 PM
Although his brother getting killed hardly justifies Saki trying to rape Tang Shen in any way, let alone kill her. And I'm not a huge fan of Splinter as a douche. So I've always looked at the changes as improvements, really.
Where did this rape thing come into play? Nagi was definitely being aggressive with Tang Shen (although the story only ever portrays him as beating her), but Saki just shows up at her door years later and kills her.

So much of Mirage #1 would likely have been written differently had they known they were building the foundation for another 30+ years of stories, instead of a one-shot parody book.
Would it? I don't know; if the idea was to create something with more mainstream, good-vs-evil appeal, definitely. And that's what's been done, time and time again as the franchise has been reinterpreted in new media and under different publishers.

But the Mirage series stuck to its guns on the content of the first issue and later (some fifty issues later, but still), pulled things together thematically so well that you could be convinced it was planned from the start.

Powder
01-26-2014, 05:35 PM
In a panel of the origin her robe is open up top a bit which could vaguely imply sexual abuse was on the horizon. At least I think so. Been a while since I read it.

Cipher
01-26-2014, 07:57 PM
In a panel of the origin her robe is open up top a bit which could vaguely imply sexual abuse was on the horizon. At least I think so. Been a while since I read it.
Yeah, that's the panel with Nagi. I guess it's possible either way, but it doesn't much change the end result, nor our assessment of Nagi (who was beating her to death regardless). He's holding her up by her robe, by the way, which is why it's fallen open.

Powder
01-26-2014, 08:59 PM
Ah, right. Well, clothes work that way, I suppose. At the end of the day I doubt E&L put much thought into the issue. He was portrayed as a bad guy, and was taken care of as such. While things can be left to interpretation, they weren't meant to be analyzed I'm sure.

shuriken
01-26-2014, 09:06 PM
Although his brother getting killed hardly justifies Saki trying to rape Tang Shen in any way, let alone kill her. And I'm not a huge fan of Splinter as a douche. So I've always looked at the changes as improvements, really.

So much of Mirage #1 would likely have been written differently had they known they were building the foundation for another 30+ years of stories, instead of a one-shot parody book.

I don't think Saki (in the movie or original comic) ever tried to rape Tang Shen. I think he just straight up killed her.
Nagi on the other hand probably did or tried to. Saki was doing his duty as an agent of the Foot Clan, which was perfect for him since his target was Yoshi. I would have liked to see the building tension between Nagi and Yoshi, with little Saki maybe even looking up to both of them. But in his grief stricken state he garners a ball of rage within that culminates in him becoming that deadly ninja.

Leo656
01-27-2014, 01:00 AM
Could be open to interpretation. I honestly only kind of accepted that there was an attempted rape after seeing other people say it over the years. I'm not the Mirage guy.

Candy Kappa
01-27-2014, 03:17 AM
In #1 Saki only killed Shen, some implies or theorize that Nagi might have tried to do more then Just beating Shen up, not Saki. Saki was 7 years old and not present when Nagi attacked Shen and Yoshi intervened.

We never see Saki do anything with Shen to imply he raped her. Shredder kills Shen, waits for Yoshi to come home, introduce himself as Oroku Saki and kills Yoshi.

With Nagi in the story, it gives Shredder a proper motivation, Shredder is the hero in a different story. He is the young brother that avenges the death of his beloved older brother that got murdered by Yoshi and Shen.

Yoshi and Shen never stuck around to explain what happened.

DrSpengler
01-27-2014, 08:47 AM
With Nagi in the story, it gives Shredder a proper motivation, Shredder is the hero in a different story. He is the young brother that avenges the death of his beloved older brother that got murdered by Yoshi and Shen.

Yoshi and Shen never stuck around to explain what happened.

Aww yeah, this guy right here.

It was an underdeveloped plot point for the original Mirage Shredder, admittedly, but he had a sympathetic or empathetic angle to his origin story. Beyond just wanting to avenge his brother, the text even explicitly states that he was misinformed and manipulated by the Foot Clan hierarchy, making him a "victim" in his own right.

There's a lot of material in that original Mirage Shredder back story that could be used to flesh out the character. While I appreciate that Mirage didn't want to overuse the Shredder and employed him sparingly, at times it felt like a missed opportunity to mine some genuinely fascinating characterization from him.

I think it was... Tristan Jones (?) who said he even pitched a Shredder prequel story to Tales and got it shot down (might have been Ross May; my memory is foggy). Mirage editorial seemed pretty strict in their decree to leave the Shredder alone (save the Shark-Shredder, but that was explained in excruciating detail as not being the "real" Shredder). I get why they wanted to stick to that angle, but there were so many stories that could have been told that couldn't not be explored in other continuities (since, as noted, all other continuities have eliminated Nagi from the formula).

Kurai
01-27-2014, 11:08 AM
He seems to be pretty interchangeable, seeing as I didn't even know the character existed until I actually read the first issue. I do agree that it'd be interesting if they used him in a story.

Masterpiece
01-29-2016, 03:58 AM
First of all, Nagi deserved to die.
He almost killed Tang Shen because she didn't love him.
Having Nagi killed by Yoshi doesn't make Saki sympathetic either.

Nagi was a jealous it's-all-about-me thug.
Saki just refused to see his brother's faults.

Nagi is an unnecessary character.
And the Oroku bloodline are a bunch of unsympathetic, arrogant fools.

I'm glad the Original Movie edited Nagi out of the script (yeah, Nagi was in the script for those of you who want to know). All you need is Saki as the Shredder and that's it.

PS: You know how Saki trained for a decade before he went to kill Yoshi?
Yeah, Splinter would have already died by the time Saki arrived in New York.
The longest an un-mutated rat has ever lived for was 7 years. And even then that is 4 years over the average lifespan of a rat (3 years).

So it's also more realistic that Saki is the one who is Yoshi's rival for Tang Shen's love. Makes the story flow more quickly and Splinter would not have lived an abnormally long life as an un-mutated rat.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
01-29-2016, 08:00 PM
Maybe there were already trace elements of mutagen in the sewer water that caused him to exceed his normal life span.

Candy Kappa
01-29-2016, 08:05 PM
It's been mentioned a few times, but there was a story planned that explained why Splinter had such a long lifespan unmutated. He wasn't a regular rat to begin with or something.

Duke Nukem
01-29-2016, 08:32 PM
I'm glad the Original Movie edited Nagi out of the script (yeah, Nagi was in the script for those of you who want to know). All you need is Saki as the Shredder and that's it.

I'm pretty sure he's in the Mirage comic adaption of the film, but it's been a while since I've read that.

I don't think Oroku Nagi is necessary. IDW and 2k3 both did a great job with Shredder as a character with different origins (that are still the same in a lot of key ways) where Nagi wouldn't have fit. With that said, I don't have anything against the character either, if Mirage had expanded more on their early years that probably would have been good also.

Allio
01-29-2016, 10:01 PM
I wouldn't mind seeing Nagi again, but just in a "we have the whole Oroku family." Nagi as his brother, his father from IDW and his mother from the 87 cartoon, and Pimiko or Karai depending on your mood

plastroncafe
01-30-2016, 10:23 AM
While Nagi does make Splinter's age a problem, it does make Saki closer to the turtles age by comparison. This is good for a couple of reasons, it makes him a more formidable foe. Less an adult beating on children.

In addition it helps to solidify just how needless all of the violence is to begin with.
Saki and Splinter are personally removed from the feud between Yoshi and Nagi, and by extension the turtles even more so.
And yet the cycle of violence continues anyway. Less for personal grief, and more for some intangible sense of honor.

Masterpiece
01-31-2016, 03:54 AM
While Nagi does make Splinter's age a problem, it does make Saki closer to the turtles age by comparison. This is good for a couple of reasons, it makes him a more formidable foe. Less an adult beating on children.

Not really.
I did my calculations upon reading the original issue of TMNT Mirage and Saki would be around 35 by the time the Turtles (aged 15) first faced him.

plastroncafe
01-31-2016, 09:53 AM
You're absolutely right, I just broke out my Vol 1 #1 to check.
Though...the turtles are 13 in that issue, and not 15....which only serves to weaken my case further.

D'oh!

miru
10-02-2018, 11:10 PM
Nagi was important to the Mirage comics, but he is of little to no importance anywhere else. The cycle of vengence is exlusive to the source material, every other version has gone the Saki=Bad, Yoshi= good route. It become the 'common mythology' of turtles lore. If a writer has a story to tell with Nagi in a particular version, then he can be used. If not, he should not be shoehorned in by the magical words 'source material'. Like any other concept, the cycle of vengence hould only be brought into a version if it suits the intended narrative of the storyteller.

And I've said it before and I'll say it again, if you look across many diffrent stories and mythological cycles, the only signifgance the 'source material' usually has is it's the first version. A 'common mythology' ususally develops out of all the various adaptations, retellings, and additions later storytellers add. If you resticted storytellers to going back to the 'source material' well, the aurthian cycle, Greek/Roman mythology and the superman mythos would all be very, very diffrent. Once the 'common mythology' of 4Kids, Fred Wolf, the movies, archie, and all the others entered the public consiousness, it can be argued that Mirage simply became another ingredient in the 'common mythology soup' that superceeded it's primacy.


Indeed, and yet, Nagi is still potentially more important than Mr. McAdam, a character not even seen in the Movie Adaptation comic. Every version has something that is forgotten in the end. Mr. McAdam seems generic enough as to be easily replaced with someone new, whereas every other character in that first issue is at least revisited within Mirage's pages. Such as Nagi returning as a vengeful phantasm haunting Shen's home, battling his brother's slayers one final time before being exorcised from this plane by them.

A-ha! Nagi actually works pretty well as a vengeful undead of some sort. Especially as a poltergeist haunting a house in Chihaya… or maybe more than just a house, what about the Chihaya Castle? Or Mount Kongo itself? How would he react to the Foot staying with him? Just imagine a mountain coming to life... Even your idea for him as Shredder II is valid to me, and I agree with it. A "The Joker with Ninjutsu" portrayal may be just as valid as the "poltergeist" one, much like how Wyrm is great either as a garbage collector, magical space jinn, or ferocious beast.


McAdam? I honestly have no clue.:tconfuse:

Tetsu Deinonychus
10-06-2018, 12:30 PM
I'm pretty sure he's in the Mirage comic adaption of the film, but it's been a while since I've read that.

I don't think Oroku Nagi is necessary. IDW and 2k3 both did a great job with Shredder as a character with different origins (that are still the same in a lot of key ways) where Nagi wouldn't have fit. With that said, I don't have anything against the character either, if Mirage had expanded more on their early years that probably would have been good also.
Interestingly enough. I had the storybook adaptation of the movie as a kid, and Nagi's included in that.

clockstomper
10-06-2018, 10:54 PM
Nagi plays really well into the idea of the multigenerational conflict, the endless cycle of revenge, etc. Splinter and Saki have a lot in common the Mirage continuity, it's a shame they never even spoke.

Although I prefer when the conflict is between Saki and a Hamato Yoshi who IS Splinter in some fashion (be it through mutation or reincarnation.) It seems to lead to better stories that way, it just feels the most personal. I've warmed up to Utrom Shredder over the years but I still feel disconnected from the conflict because there's too many degrees of separation. He seems pretty content to just leave the Turtles alone in Exodus, he probably wouldn't have made his way back to Earth in their lifetimes.

Andrew NDB
05-25-2023, 12:09 PM
I think as soon as you remove Nagi, you take a big step towards making Oroku Saki into cardboard. Because then he's not avenging anybody or anything, or you then have to concoct something new for him to be pissed about.

neatoman
05-25-2023, 05:02 PM
Yeah… Not gonna lie, "most adaptations ignore him" isn't really a strong argument for why he shouldn't exist at all. I think the closest any adaptation got to including him was Mashimi in the 4Kids show, but only in so far as depicting Yoshi's rival as a separate character from Shredder himself, the fact that he obviously didn't mean anything to the Shredder beyond a failed means to an end gives him a very different role in the story aside from the love triangle.

I get why he's not really used much, most of the adaptations are made with a child audience in mind and giving the villain a legit reason to beef may seem… Uncomfortable for children or parents. Ultimately though, Nagi is probably important to understand the Shredder's motives, otherwise he'd either fall into cartoon megalomania or become a confused mess like in the 2012 show.

TheLabRat
05-25-2023, 06:46 PM
I think as soon as you remove Nagi, you take a big step towards making Oroku Saki into cardboard. Because then he's not avenging anybody or anything, or you then have to concoct something new for him to be pissed about.

Maybe it's something like an infighting between the foot clan families. Nagi is also a victim of this infighting. His death made things worse for the Oroku family, because before that, the Oroku family had already declined, and Nagi was once highly expected to revive the family. Saki wants to take over his brother's unfinshed duites while taking revenge on other Foot elders.

DrSpengler
05-26-2023, 05:53 PM
Aww yeah, this guy right here.

It was an underdeveloped plot point for the original Mirage Shredder, admittedly, but he had a sympathetic or empathetic angle to his origin story. Beyond just wanting to avenge his brother, the text even explicitly states that he was misinformed and manipulated by the Foot Clan hierarchy, making him a "victim" in his own right.

There's a lot of material in that original Mirage Shredder back story that could be used to flesh out the character. While I appreciate that Mirage didn't want to overuse the Shredder and employed him sparingly, at times it felt like a missed opportunity to mine some genuinely fascinating characterization from him.

I think it was... Tristan Jones (?) who said he even pitched a Shredder prequel story to Tales and got it shot down (might have been Ross May; my memory is foggy). Mirage editorial seemed pretty strict in their decree to leave the Shredder alone (save the Shark-Shredder, but that was explained in excruciating detail as not being the "real" Shredder). I get why they wanted to stick to that angle, but there were so many stories that could have been told that couldn't not be explored in other continuities (since, as noted, all other continuities have eliminated Nagi from the formula).

Rereading my original response from 2014 (sweet lord), I stand by it.

THAT SAID, I think the adaptations that have strayed the most from Mirage have found interesting avenues to fill that motivational void once Nagi is eliminated from Shredder's origin.

4Kids had Ch'rell, who was so far removed from any incarnation of the Shredder, with his own crazy origin and motivations, that there really was no room for a sad brother story for him. He had his own nutty stuff going on and I loved all of it for what it was. Wholly unique.

2012 Nickelodeon Shredder, I think in terms of intent (and not always execution), had something going there. Saki and Yoshi fighting over Tang Shen was there, but with the added bonus of Karai having been born to Tang and Yoshi, but abducted by Saki. He raises her as his own daughter as the ultimate F U to Yoshi, but in that span of time comes to genuinely love her as his own, as well as for her being the last piece of Tang Shen left (whom he genuinely cared for).

All the amazing pieces were there, they just didn't always get explored as well as they could. The abuse Shredder often put Karai through to keep her by his side eliminated most any sympathetic qualities to his plight. Still, there was something really unique there which filled the emotional and personal role that an Oroku Nagi would have left behind.

So I don't think removing Nagi for the sake of streamlining origins is entirely bad, I just think his personal weight has to be replaced with something. Anything.

miru
09-22-2023, 11:17 PM
I ageee that yes, to replace Oroku Nagi, another form of drama is needed to fill the void, and I think Miwa hits the spot. Alternatively, as with Ch’rell or the various Shredders of demonic origin (2k3 Tengu Shredder, Rise Shredder), one can even downplay the Saki stuff, and have a different “Yoshi and Shen” story. However, those who don’t necessarily replace that story but merely ignore this often have weaker Shredders, like the Baytles version. And also I think perhaps using Nagi as well as another dramatic element like Miwa would provide even more poetic elements to the origin story.

MikeandRaph87
09-23-2023, 07:48 AM
His significance has expired so...

ToTheNines
04-16-2025, 04:18 AM
I think as soon as you remove Nagi, you take a big step towards making Oroku Saki into cardboard. Because then he's not avenging anybody or anything, or you then have to concoct something new for him to be pissed about.

Totally agree. Stuff like 4kids and IDW got creative and reinvented Shredder’s origin enough to where it doesn’t apply. But stuff like 1990 and 2012… Saki’s just a jealous ex-boyfriend.

Which is all Nagi ever was, but he wasn’t the big bad. I think that buffer is important to keep Shredder from ultimately being a big ol’ pussy.

clockstomper
05-08-2025, 03:23 PM
Nickelodeon is really particular about questions of paternity, like how they couldn't tell the full story of Zuko's mother because it involved questioning who his father was. I always got the vibe that Saki really thought Karai/Miwa might be his and that would have made for a more interesting story if it's an unresolved question of who's in the right.

Coola Yagami
05-08-2025, 03:45 PM
Nickelodeon is really particular about questions of paternity, like how they couldn't tell the full story of Zuko's mother because it involved questioning who his father was. I always got the vibe that Saki really thought Karai/Miwa might be his and that would have made for a more interesting story if it's an unresolved question of who's in the right.

True, but isn't Avatar an original Nick creation? It's not like TMNT which is based on or homaging a previous version. They could just.... not have Zuko's mother not knowing who his father was and avoid something to tightrope around.