View Full Version : TMNT Villain Microseries #5: Karai Discussion
AlZarkovski
08-16-2013, 01:47 PM
Preview here (http://www.comicvine.com/articles/exclusive-preview-tmnt-villain-micro-series-5-kara/1100-147029/).
Great issue!
CyberCubed
08-16-2013, 05:05 PM
Karai looks so cool in this artwork.
corvus
08-16-2013, 05:15 PM
Karai has recently started looking like my ex girlfriend.
Technogeek29
08-16-2013, 06:55 PM
Wow whoever is drawing this, I would love to see them do the main series. I love how the humans look in this book so far, and its only the 2nd time we'd seen Karai as a child.
Erik Burnham
08-16-2013, 07:40 PM
The artist is Cory Smith (with Ian Herring on color) and he finished this IN THE NICK OF TIME... to go off and get married!
This book is beautiful -- my only regret is that Ghost Shredder is spoiled in the preview! (That was one of the elements that stuck through every iteration of the story... well, that, and young Karai reading the Ashi no Himitsu with a flashlight under the covers.)
I would work with Cory again any time, any where.
And I LOVED writing Karai again!
ToTheNines
08-19-2013, 06:44 AM
Can't wait!
Looking forward to this one. :)
MikeandRaph87
08-19-2013, 12:11 PM
Karai has recently started looking like my ex girlfriend.
Is that a good thing or a bad thnig?:lol:
As per the spoiler Erik, it does not detract from the book at all because it does not explain it only teases it and entrices us to read the whoole thing.
Martin
08-19-2013, 12:54 PM
So excited for this. I looked up the artist when I found out about the issue and was impressed. The way he usually draws the turtles isn't that much to my liking but everything else is awesome. The dark leo design he posted on twitter a while back was really cool though, so I guess I'll have to wait to make up my mind about whether or not I like how he draws the turtles till I read the issue. Only thing I wish he would draw differently (as I usually do with most artists) is the way he makes people hold their sai. Just a minor nitpick; not really that important.
I'll link to his profiles on DA and Twitter in case someone wants to go through his work:
https://twitter.com/_corysmith_
http://csmithart.deviantart.com/
Overall pretty great artist. Wouldn't mind seeing him again in the future (:
His stuff is great!
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-9_KZQnJTGwQ/UHNaTI9cwcI/AAAAAAAAAl4/8oXIw4oY3EY/s1600/TMNT.jpg
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-dbpOUF7m7rA/Tlux4n_FMmI/AAAAAAAAASo/d9WAu10JjB0/s1600/Leonardo-final1.png
I like how he draws the turtles, and this issue will probably feature Dark Leo... will be great! :)
corvus
08-20-2013, 10:36 AM
Shouldn't this come out today?
MikeandRaph87
08-20-2013, 10:43 AM
Shouldn't this come out today?
I think you mean tomorrow 8/21. As for Ninja Turtles#25 I beleive with the reworked shipping schedule it will be out 8/28.
Venom
08-20-2013, 10:15 PM
I like the little "MUTANIMALS LIVE!" graffiti on page 5 there! :twink:
Also, I love how these latest Micros feature stories that lead directly into the next issue.
Will the dude with the face tattoo show up later on, or is he just fodder for the finalist fight?
corvus
08-21-2013, 10:40 AM
Ending made the whole issue great.
Technogeek29
08-21-2013, 12:02 PM
Wow Leo know how to hit where it hurts. So will this guy be doing the main series soon? I really like the artwork in this book.
So will this guy be doing the main series soon? I really like the artwork in this book.
Nah, that's Ross Campbell who did the previous Leonardo & Alopex microes.
Thorneyeagle
08-21-2013, 03:26 PM
I really enjoyed this issue. I wont go into detail for those who haven't read it yet. However, I thought this issue really fleshes out Karai's character and explains her frustrations well.
I don't see an issue with the Shredder's appearance. There is a level of "magic"/"spirit" play in the series thats not explained. The lack of explanation and its presence is enjoyable. it's just enough without taking over.
corvus
08-21-2013, 04:41 PM
I'm really glad about one thing in this issue and its the fact that Karai has not indicated any intention of betraying Shredder, so we can put that on the "things that may happen but probably won't" shelf along with Verminator X Hob and the mutanimals. Also the end is really badass. I hope the Bebop and Rocksteady micro explains their recruitment into the foot
DrSpengler
08-21-2013, 06:50 PM
Here's my review of the Karai Microseries at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2013/08/tmnt-villains-microseries-5-karai.html)
I have to confess that I was a bit disappointed by this one. Karai is a character who has evolved over the past 20 years (moreso in the past 10 years), and while she's always changing, I think the qualities time has added to her character are better preserved than discarded.
Without her devotion to the Shredder or her sympathetic attitude toward the Turtles, what substance does she have left to her name? All that's left is a bitter second-in-command out to overthrow the leader and seize power. While it's certainly a different take on Karai, and I appreciate the desire to avoid retreading old ground, there's nothing to her now but generic villainy. And coming on the heels of the Alopex microseries, which ALSO ended with the scorned second-in-command vowing to overthrow the Shredder, Karai can't even claim a unique niche among the villain to herself.
This was a fine followup to The Secret History of the Foot Clan mini and I appreciated the filling in of the narrative gaps. Concerning the narrative of the Foot Clan, this issue is certainly enlightening. But as a Karai centerpiece, I felt it did her more of a disservice than a favor; draining her of all her notable qualities rather than energizing her with any strong characterization.
I'm sure that Karai will proceed to grow as a character, and I'm sure there are more layered stories in her future, but as things stand here in the present, she feels only superficially like Karai.
Smith's art was a treat, though. Lots of great action layouts, but that page where Karai nails Nakamura with an arrow was the centerpiece. Dynamic stuff. Hats off to Herring's colors, too; particularly the dream sequence. Nice subtle work without overdoing it on the dreamlike vibe.
Powder
08-21-2013, 07:12 PM
I really enjoyed this issue, as like Spengler said, it seems to be a perfect follow-up to SHOTFC. Art was great, writing was dope. Loved Leo making Karai butthurt. But yeah, it didn't seem to develop her all too much. But I can see they're definitely trying to give her more of a backstory than she's had before, so I hope to see them elaborate on that.
ToTheNines
08-21-2013, 09:26 PM
Ok read. Felt kind of short, especially for a Burnham script. Smith was awesome though.
As has been said, it filled in some blanks nicely, but it didn't work any wonders for Karai herself. I'm glad they're finally following up on her stolen mutagen though. Although if feels kind of jumbled at this point, making mutants was her initial plan to capture Leo way back during "Krang War". I guess Shredder just got tired of waiting once Kitsune was resurrected.
All this talk of "Chunin" makes me want to reconsider the chronological placement of the Alopex issue. Can a clan have multiple Chunin? Or is there only one who is the undisputed second in command? I think I'll ask Bobby.
I wonder if Toshiro was a nod to Tatsu actor Toshishiro Obata...
Plasticplayhouse
08-21-2013, 09:34 PM
i really enjoyed this issue. i dont think it felt short at all. it did fill in the gaps nicely though.
Erik Burnham
08-21-2013, 09:52 PM
Well, Spengs, Karai is in a slightly different spot than Alopex. She doesn't want to challenge Shredder OR quit. She just thinks the decisions being made are undermining what's been done.
So how does she fix that? She's got some ideas, but that's part of what plays in with City Fall. This issue is more directly connected to later beats of that larger story. But her question to Toshiro was if she can't leave and she can't challenge, what should she do? She'll try to excel in another way.
The biggest down side to Karai is that we had enough back story for way more than 22 pages, and believe me, we were exploring a lot of ideas... but when you only have so much space...! (: I'm still happy with it.
Second, Toshiro wasn't a nod to the actor behind Tatsu (whose name was Toshishiro) so much as it was a nod to Toshiro Mifune. (:
***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-21-2013, 10:24 PM
Toshishiro Obata is sometimes credited as Toshiro.
Edit: According to Wikipedia,
Since 1986, Obata has appeared in several Hollywood films, including Black Rain, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and its sequel, Showdown in Little Tokyo, Rising Sun, The Shadow, The Hunted, and Demolition Man. He has also appeared as himself in martial arts documentaries.
It reads almost as if Showdown in Little Tokyo is the sequel to Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles :tlol: :tlol: :tlol: :tlol:
corvus
08-21-2013, 11:55 PM
Where do people keep getting this "she's gonna betray shredder" vibe. He's a Dick to her but she's still loyal to him. This issue shows the exact opposite.
DrSpengler
08-22-2013, 07:46 AM
Where do people keep getting this "she's gonna betray shredder" vibe. He's a Dick to her but she's still loyal to him. This issue shows the exact opposite.
While my presumption that she had designs on killing the Shredder may have been wrong-headed, I don't think there's any question Karai intends to betray him. She refers to him with contempt, questions his leadership and has implemented secret measures of her own to undermine his authority. That's betrayal, if you ask me.
Red Mask
08-22-2013, 09:37 AM
I don't see an issue with the Shredder's appearance. There is a level of "magic"/"spirit" play in the series thats not explained. The lack of explanation and its presence is enjoyable.
This may be my favorite element of the IDW Turtles. In SHOTFC there are alot of mystical/magical elements that we're kept a little in the dark about (keeping it intriguing), but also Kitsune believes that the Utrom is a demon, while we know better. The ooze can be seen as mystical life force or a science expirement. I really love the blurring of magic and science in this, it's too cool...so in this micro I was happy to see Shredder's dream appearance and the scars on her hand when she woke up. I'm all for the supernatural apect, if it's not overdone. I think I do agree that she doesn't seem like a very nuanced character at the moment, but if all they want of her is a cold, determined ninja for now, they wrote a good story for that purpose, in my opinion. I also liked how they hinted that Leo, even when evil, can't escape the part of him that won't kill.
Erik Burnham
08-22-2013, 11:03 AM
While my presumption that she had designs on killing the Shredder may have been wrong-headed, I don't think there's any question Karai intends to betray him. She refers to him with contempt, questions his leadership and has implemented secret measures of her own to undermine his authority. That's betrayal, if you ask me.
She's young and irritated with a choice he made -- and definitely disagrees about Leo.
If she were going to betray Shredder, the smart thing would have been to kill Leo, not say "hang on, I'd better not." (: She thinks Leo is the weakest link, not Shredder.
As for the secret measures; are you *sure* she's undermining authority? Could just be a failing of the writing coupling with assumptions about the characters to lead to a wrong interpretation. (:
Or maybe not. You never know!
This issue has elicited some really fun theories about Karai and her plans (both from folks who loved the book and those who thought it came up short) for that alone, I'm taking a win. Some GREAT ideas trotting around. (Some wrong, some right, some weird, but all eloquent!)
DrSpengler
08-22-2013, 11:25 AM
Hey, I'm not gonna argue with the guy writing the thing!
But speaking in terms of my own interpretation of the events, I took Karai sparing Dark Leo not as a concession to the Shredder's authority, but as her finally understanding the lesson she'd been missing (and later verbalized to Toshiro near the issue's end).
She'd been so mired in the past that she'd been failing to plan for the future (hence her sense of being without direction). Karai took a calculated loss in battle against Dark Leo, but knew she could use it to her advantage at a later date; essentially thinking several moves ahead and planning for the future like she hadn't been before.
It fit with the lesson Karai learned in the issue; to start looking forward. And in that regard, she did grow as a character by illustrating some ambition.
But again, just going by my interpretation as a reader, the message I got was that Karai felt she made a mistake in resurrecting Shredder. That by embracing the past so extremely (literally reviving ancient history), she put the Foot Clan in the wrong hands (she's shown nothing but contempt for Saki throughout her past appearances and in her inner monologue from this Micro and seems to only follow him out of fear rather than a sincere respect). Now that she's learned a lesson about looking forward, she's taking steps to regain her own lost power, operating behind Saki's back.
That's what I came away with. Obviously, you know the real low down.
Heck, thinking about it some more, on a metatextual level, it seems like you IDW guys are trying to encourage the reader to apply Karai's lesson about stepping out of the past and looking to the future. Your Karai is not much like any of the Karais fans are familiar with, but instead of clinging to past incarnations and writing off this new one, we should instead be considering how she will grow over time. Fair enough.
Erik Burnham
08-22-2013, 12:11 PM
Hey, I'm not gonna argue with the guy writing the thing!
But speaking in terms of my own interpretation of the events, I took Karai sparing Dark Leo not as a concession to the Shredder's authority, but as her finally understanding the lesson she'd been missing (and later verbalized to Toshiro near the issue's end).
She'd been so mired in the past that she'd been failing to plan for the future (hence her sense of being without direction). Karai took a calculated loss in battle against Dark Leo, but knew she could use it to her advantage at a later date; essentially thinking several moves ahead and planning for the future like she hadn't been before.
It fit with the lesson Karai learned in the issue; to start looking forward. And in that regard, she did grow as a character by illustrating some ambition.
But again, just going by my interpretation as a reader, the message I got was that Karai felt she made a mistake in resurrecting Shredder. That by embracing the past so extremely (literally reviving ancient history), she put the Foot Clan in the wrong hands (she's shown nothing but contempt for Saki throughout her past appearances and in her inner monologue from this Micro and seems to only follow him out of fear rather than a sincere respect). Now that she's learned a lesson about looking forward, she's taking steps to regain her own lost power, operating behind Saki's back.
That's what I came away with. Obviously, you know the real low down.
Heck, thinking about it some more, on a metatextual level, it seems like you IDW guys are trying to encourage the reader to apply Karai's lesson about stepping out of the past and looking to the future. Your Karai is not much like any of the Karais fans are familiar with, but instead of clinging to past incarnations and writing off this new one, we should instead be considering how she will grow over time. Fair enough.
With her attitude, I was trying to also be somewhat consistent with how she's given Shredder lip on panel in the past. (:
corvus
08-22-2013, 12:12 PM
I think she's gonna try to impress shredder with Bebop and Rocksteady. The end of the issue kind of indicates that.
Bebop's ending panels were totally OT-ish, I enjoyed it. :)
Issue nice too, it was great to see Dark Leo again.
In my interpretation: Karai wanted to rise/rebuild the foot clan, and Shredder was one of the indgredients, except he took control of the clan, and removed her from chunin position. I think she regrets bringing back Saki, but as it was said, she can't leave, and can't challange him (already happened, anyway, and she failed), so the only thing left to do, is manipulating him, and making him realise that Leo was a bad choice, so at least she could be a chunnin again.
Honestly, no idea how R&B comes into the picture. How will they even change to mutants? Karai has the Ooze not the Mutagen right? Will it be ooze mixed with animal blood, injected into their body, or something like? Well, we we will know it anyway, in next week... :) (hopefully)
Redeemer
08-22-2013, 08:48 PM
This issue was definately better than expected!
Loved getting a glimpse into Karia's past! Total badass. Also that fight between Leo and Karia was bad ass!!! The last panal has me excited as well for the Rocksteady and Beebop issue :D
LittleBlueHero
08-23-2013, 11:55 AM
Personally I think Karai is attempting to build mutant troops to impress Shredder. I also think the whole thing will backfire when Bebop and Rocksteady turn out to be morons :)
With Bebop's regular "So, what is the plan?" question, I have no doubt about it. :lol:
The 'Karai bitchslapped by gramps' counter will rise again at the end of City Fall, that's for sure...
Martin
08-23-2013, 01:57 PM
With Bebop's regular "So, what is the plan?" question, I have no doubt about it. :lol:
The 'Karai bitchslapped by gramps' counter will rise again at the end of City Fall, that's for sure...
http://i.imgur.com/WwBnE4e.pngSorry, couldn't resist...
About the issue, I really enjoyed it. As many of you said it filled a lot of gaps from SHOTFC nicely, though maybe due to that we didn't get to explore Karai's mindset that much, which is something I believe some people were pointing out. The thing with these micros is that the writers only have so much space in the issue to portray their point, and if you add a story on top of that that has to match up with the ongoing, things start getting tricky lengthwise. Overall, I like IDW's take on karai, though I really hope we can get a bit more into her head in the future.
The thing that (still) kind of disappoints me is dark leo. I know he was brainwashed and all, but I don't see how changing a couple memories to make Splinter the devil and Shredder his new daddy inside his head, would lead him to become an asshole. Don't get me wrong, I loved seeing Karai buthurt, but it struck me as really odd that Leo, even in his emo stage, would do something like that.
After #23 it became apparent that the point that Shredder (or Kitsune; don't really know who it really was since it all happened in-dream) was trying to get across was that strength was all that mattered... and that Splinter was a jerk, but that's beside the point. I would have preferred to see a dark leo who was kind of obsessed with strength, and whose actions would be motivated by that, but who would still stick to his other 'good' values, and not so much this one who is just going around threatening people and acting strong. I might be getting it all wrong though. (There are other reasons for which Dark Leo kind of disappoints me which are related, but I already explained those on other numerous posts. I don't really think anyone wants to read all that again here :lol:)
Also kind of related to what I just wrote, what's up with him trying to prove he is better than Karai? Why does he need/think he needs to do that? Man, I'd kill for a second Leo micro right about now.
Also, Spengs I read your review and at some point you wrote this:
As they fight, Karai senses something different about Leo; that he’s holding back his killer instinct. He has many opportunities to kill her, but passes them all.I agree with the part about him being held back by his past self, but did he really had many, or even better, any opportunities to kill her before Karai dropped the fight? His restrained killer instinct hindered his overall fighting skills (hesitation, etc), thus putting him in a disadvantage. To me, Karai seemed to have been in control during that whole fight sequence, and I believe Leo knew it as well. I really don't think he bought for a second that he actually defeated her. He just played along due to his pride.
Something I didn't quite grasp the meaning of, and this might have to do with language barriers and the fact that it was pretty late when I got to read this, was this line between Karai and the old man:
"He didn't had the resolve to kill me."
"And if he had?"
"Then we both would have deserved our fates."By this, what I gather is that if Leo wouldn't have been being held back by, let's call it his 'good' side, he would have defeated her fair and square during the fight since he is a better martial artist than her. This however strikes me as odd since I don't think Karai to be the kind of person to admit Leo is better than her. The other scenario is that she said that because of the opportunity she gave Leo to kill her, which of course he didn't take. I don't really think this would be the case since there would be no need to kill the old man as well... though he might have done it because of how bad the new recruits were. I don't know.
Finally, I wanna say that the art by Cory Smith was phenomenal. The way he draws people and action sequences is just great. I was also impressed by his Leo design. Before the issue I was kind of hesitant about it, but now I gotta say that I really liked it. Great stuff.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-26-2013, 05:59 PM
I find it interesting that Shredder and Karai are only interested in choosing the strongest of the bunch to become mutants in this universe in order to conserve mutagen since Shredder spent it like it was water in the Fred Wolf series, and Mirage Shredder never had access to it. If Rocksteady and Bebop can actually hold their own against Karai, maybe they will be somewhat formidable in this universe/worth taking seriously. When you think in terms of sheer strength, they shouldn't have been quite as incompetent in the cartoon as they were. If Rocksteady and Bebop aren't complete idiots in this universe, and have both "street smarts" and animal instinct, they might truly be dangerous, unless they decide to change sides or go rogue.
Blossombrooks
08-26-2013, 06:15 PM
If Rocksteady and Bebop aren't complete idiots in this universe, and have both "street smarts" and animal instinct, they might truly be dangerous, unless they decide to change sides or go rogue.
Hmmm, I think they'll be loyal like they were in the OT and besides Old Hob has already done going rogue and the ol switcheroo (kinda).
I agree with you though that they would make a formidable force and I'd really like to see that. The end quote didn't bode well for an intelligence upgrade but if they were very loyal to say, Karai, now that could be interesting. Their original incompetence was in part down to poor instruction, I don't think that will be an issue this time.
Panda_Kahn_fan
08-26-2013, 10:47 PM
I think maybe Torshiro is IDW's version of Tatsu? (maybe his full name is Torshiro Tatsu:lol: )
Strangely there is already a Toshiro, in the TMNT franchise. He was in Mirage issue 17, though he was a fictional character created by Mike.
electric_sheep
08-30-2013, 09:44 AM
what an awesome issue, art is just beautiful, i love his turtles design...
i hate what are they doing in a regular issue with the turtles, they draw them like Nick turtles with weird snouts, this guy draws them like more detailed version of Eastman turtles...
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.