PDA

View Full Version : Anyone not enthused about Dark Leo yet?


CyberCubed
08-21-2013, 07:48 PM
I know we're only two issues into Dark Leo, but I've not really that enthused about this direction. The idea of a Turtle being brainwashed to work for Shredder works perfectly for the cartoons, I would have loved to see this happen in either the original cartoon or Nick show, but in the comics that aren't aimed at kids it just seems a bit cliche.

I loved the brainwashing sequence of all the past artists so I think that's what sold a lot of us on Dark Leo at first.

But I'm not really enthused about seeing Leo "evil" for just the next few issues which will probably be reversed when Cityfall comes to a close. Thoughts?

Toby Barrett
08-21-2013, 08:11 PM
Well of freaking course he's going to be back to his senses at the end of City Fall. You honestly expect them to just have Leo stay evil for several years in the book?

Powder
08-21-2013, 08:13 PM
I've dug it thus far, certainly the design is cool as hell but
in Karai's Micro, seeing that he's doing missions and psychologically brutalizing her, man... TOO COOL. Love it.

Grimlock
08-21-2013, 08:34 PM
Pretty lame and predictable. And since we know how it will end, it really isn't all that gripping. But if it makes for Leo developing as a character further down the line, what the hell. Whatevs.

Coola Yagami
08-21-2013, 08:56 PM
I like it. In the cartoons it would been resolved in the same episode. Even Back to the Sewers had the turtles turned back to normal before they did all that much. Comics are better for this since it can actually last a few days and not just a half hour.

AquaParade
08-21-2013, 09:22 PM
So far it seems pretty uninspired. The crew behind the series seem to emphasize that they don't plant story seeds just for the hell of it, so I am hoping it develops into something more interesting.

CyberCubed
08-21-2013, 09:33 PM
I like it. In the cartoons it would been resolved in the same episode. Even Back to the Sewers had the turtles turned back to normal before they did all that much. Comics are better for this since it can actually last a few days and not just a half hour.

I think stories like this are better for the cartoons, because its fun to see an evil Turtle episode for a half hour....not stretched over a comic arc aimed at adults.

I'll give IDW the benefit of the doubt however as we're still early on, hopefully it gets more interesting.

ToTheNines
08-21-2013, 09:35 PM
Yeah, the concept is fun and the design is hella cool, but I can't get too overly psyched about it.

I mean, we know he's back to normal for the Northampton arc, so that kinda sucks some air out of it. Plus it's just going to make Shredder look incompetent when it blows up in his face.

Coola Yagami
08-21-2013, 09:42 PM
I think stories like this are better for the cartoons, because its fun to see an evil Turtle episode for a half hour....not stretched over a comic arc aimed at adults.

I'll give IDW the benefit of the doubt however as we're still early on, hopefully it gets more interesting.

But it's lame for half an hour. One doesn't do anything really evil, and everyone forgets it ever happened by the end of the episode and definitely by the next one.

here the characters have more time to dwell on it and it will have bigger ramifications whenever he does turn back to normal.

And what's with the aimed at adults garbage. The Turtles have been to space and fought an alien brain in a robot body. Logic and 'aimed at adults' left the building after that. Besides, seeing Leo break his father's heart like he did right now is something a kid's cartoon would probably not dwell on.

ObiWanFan4life
08-22-2013, 07:48 AM
Yeah, the concept is fun and the design is hella cool, but I can't get too overly psyched about it.

I mean, we know he's back to normal for the Northampton arc, so that kinda sucks some air out of it. Plus it's just going to make Shredder look incompetent when it blows up in his face.

I know, right. Even if the Brainwashed thing hadn't been done before, confirming that he'll be back to normal in the next arc alleviates any tension.

DrSpengler
08-22-2013, 07:52 AM
I know, right. Even if the Brainwashed thing hadn't been done before, confirming that he'll be back to normal in the next arc alleviates any tension.

Unfortunately... yeah.

Even though Leo returning to normal was a foregone conclusion, the real suspense was in how long the change would last. When IDW's solicitation/hype machine effectively killed that surprise, well, the Dark Leo arc is left with nothing to do now but go through the motions.

I'm still going to enjoy it, as I'm sure there's plenty left to dig with City Fall. But I do wish IDW would play things closer to the chest when it comes to their teasers and solicits.

ObiWanFan4life
08-22-2013, 07:56 AM
Unfortunately... yeah.

Even though Leo returning to normal was a foregone conclusion, the real suspense was in how long the change would last. When IDW's solicitation/hype machine effectively killed that surprise, well, the Dark Leo arc is left with nothing to do now but go through the motions.

I'm still going to enjoy it, as I'm sure there's plenty left to dig with City Fall. But I do wish IDW would play things closer to the chest when it comes to their teasers and solicits.

I too will enjoy it and look forward to seeing Hun Return. But as I mentioned previously, we're not waiting to see IF he'll be a good guy again, we're just waiting to see WHEN.

Red Mask
08-22-2013, 09:44 AM
It'll be cool to see how this period haunts him after he changes back. Like if he ends up killing someone who doesn't deserve it, living with it would be a crisis for good Leo later on.

Crabfight
08-22-2013, 11:09 AM
I don't think we've been given a whole lot of time to sink our teeth into bad Leo yet. It's only been two issues, really.

That being said, I really did like how they used him in Karai's micro issue. Leo is clearly very devoted to his new persona on a conscious level. He had no issue making threats and using force and fear to get what he wanted. On the other hand, however, Karai also mentions that his resolve seems to be shaken on an unconscious level.

Clearly Leo is conflicted about his new role, but not in the usual surface level way. I think it's pretty cool!

pingclang
08-22-2013, 12:52 PM
I'm not so much excited about dark Leo as I am for the effect it has on the other Turtles. How they handle themselves without leadership. That should be fun.

Powder
08-22-2013, 01:32 PM
I'm fairly certain the brainwashing will have a permanent effect (at least until someone down the line can reverse it with some mystic ish) that will really change Leo's character. Maybe he'll be sorta like Leatherhead, in that every once in a while something will snap within him and he'll become super violent or whatever. Sort of a split personality thing. Could be very interesting.

Plasticplayhouse
08-22-2013, 02:10 PM
i'm riding this train till the final stop and so far i'm enjoying the view!

Rooish
08-22-2013, 02:22 PM
I'm fairly certain the brainwashing will have a permanent effect (at least until someone down the line can reverse it with some mystic ish) that will really change Leo's character. Maybe he'll be sorta like Leatherhead, in that every once in a while something will snap within him and he'll become super violent or whatever. Sort of a split personality thing. Could be very interesting.

Aww that's Raph's thing!

ObiWanFan4life
08-22-2013, 02:43 PM
Aww that's Raph's thing!

Didn't stop them from doing it in the 2k3 Show.

Eiko
08-22-2013, 05:55 PM
It def wiil take time for Leo to go back to normal after City Fall. he will prob go like he did in the 2k3 series. Leo looks so darn cool in that foot uniform.

Jester
08-22-2013, 06:01 PM
I think the bigger issue is how with the other Turtles and Splinter deal with taking Leo back into the fold after all this.

Eiko
08-22-2013, 06:09 PM
I think the bigger issue is how with the other Turtles and Splinter deal with taking Leo back into the fold after all this.

I'm sure Splinter will forgive him. Raph on the other hand.

Jester
08-22-2013, 06:14 PM
I'm sure Splinter will forgive him. Raph on the other hand.
Exactly, Raph is gonna have issues. Maybe Donnie given their previous heated debates. Mikey's heart is soft and kind, I'm sure he'll be the first to forgive Leo...though he might be scared of him...I dunna. I'm no writer.

Coola Yagami
08-22-2013, 06:41 PM
Leo should fly off the handle once he turns back to normal and kill Kitsune or seriously injure shredder.

ToTheNines
08-22-2013, 06:49 PM
Leo should fly off the handle once he turns back to normal and kill Kitsune or seriously injure shredder.

That would be awesome. I hope he does wig out.

CyberCubed
08-22-2013, 07:30 PM
With the Northampton arc coming up, its quite likely Leonardo gets badly injured or beaten to death at the end of Cityfall, and the Turtles retreat to Nortampton to heal him.

It'll be similar to the Mirage/4kids Leonardo situation, and was loosely adapted with Raphael in the first movie.

I'm pretty sure April's shop will be burned down in this series too.

zbowen
08-22-2013, 07:54 PM
Unfortunately... yeah.

Even though Leo returning to normal was a foregone conclusion, the real suspense was in how long the change would last. When IDW's solicitation/hype machine effectively killed that surprise, well, the Dark Leo arc is left with nothing to do now but go through the motions.

I'm still going to enjoy it, as I'm sure there's plenty left to dig with City Fall. But I do wish IDW would play things closer to the chest when it comes to their teasers and solicits.

I completely agree. IDW has ruined any tension with their solicitation. It's hard to be engaged when I'm more curious about what the next big reveal from
IDW is going to be. I would really prefer to be more surprised with stories as they evolve.

Plasticplayhouse
08-22-2013, 08:15 PM
I completely agree. IDW has ruined any tension with their solicitation. It's hard to be engaged when I'm more curious about what the next big reveal from
IDW is going to be. I would really prefer to be more surprised with stories as they evolve.

here's an idea...how about you guys stop reading the solicitations. i specifically avoid them for that purpose. it makes everything more enjoyable. heck, some times i even skip the issue previews.

Powder
08-22-2013, 09:14 PM
I always skip previews and never read solicitations either. Unfortunately, even the covers they reveal spoil certain things, but I just can't help but to look at those. They get me excited not only as a reader, but as an artist who thrives on dope TMNT work and uses it for inspiration. :trazz:

Coola Yagami
08-22-2013, 10:32 PM
It's still kinda stupid. We just saw the Turtles and Splinter discover evil Leo... and already there's a solicit for issue whatever starting with 'after Leo turns back to normal....'

It's ridiculous. Yeah, preview a few issues ahead, but the end of the arc. It reminds me of Dragonball Z. 'Will Yamcha survive...? don't miss the next episode 'Yamcha dies!'.

Davetello
08-23-2013, 12:33 AM
Nah, I am enjoying his depiction thus far. Perhaps it seems a little 'far-fetched' for him to be brainwashed, but it certainly adds a different dynamic as the others are caught off guard - they don't want to fight their own brother, but what choice do they have?

'City Fall' has been great and I can't wait to see how it concludes.

CyberCubed
08-23-2013, 09:37 PM
I would love to see Dark Leo do something terrible, like actually kill an important character and have to suffer the consequences after he's normal again...but I don't think IDW will do it.

For one thing they already faked out with Leonardo almost killing Slash back in #16, so I can't see them repeating it.

Likewise with Casey already being seriously injured I can't see them doing the same to another main character so soon...so its probably not going to happen.

Martin
08-23-2013, 09:44 PM
I would love to see Dark Leo do something terrible, like actually kill an important character and have to suffer the consequences after he's normal again...but I don't think IDW will do it.

For one thing they already faked out with Leonardo almost killing Slash back in #16, so I can't see them repeating it.

Likewise with Casey already being seriously injured I can't see them doing the same to another main character so soon...so its probably not going to happen.

Well he did look all depressed and kind of 'haunted' by his actions in some covers Ross Campbell (who is working on the arc that follows City Fall in case someone didn't know) posted a while back on DA. Not really sure if that's an indication of anything though...

http://fc06.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2013/203/7/a/fire_by_mooncalfe-d6emrh6.jpg

Notice the 'foot' shaped fire?http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2013/203/b/e/katana_by_mooncalfe-d6enq24.jpg

CyberCubed
08-23-2013, 10:03 PM
Maybe Dark Leo does injure Splinter in some way? It would be a good payoff then a simple, "hero turns evil, then he's good again" after one arc without any major event happening out of it.

Martin
08-23-2013, 10:19 PM
IDK. Maybe...

You know, I'm still bummed out about dark leo. There was so much potential for character growth in all this... *sigh*

Maybe next time.

Martin
08-25-2013, 12:03 PM
http://24.media.tumblr.com/269424b7cace0dabb2a79e2ef69ce030/tumblr_ms2g7cLiJX1qgf3oqo1_500.jpg

http://31.media.tumblr.com/d5496831b68519d71b1ee03f2d683a3d/tumblr_ms2g7cLiJX1qgf3oqo2_500.jpg

http://31.media.tumblr.com/c52fa50e69473e9ed412f3e0f367fb13/tumblr_ms2g7cLiJX1qgf3oqo3_500.jpgOk, now I'm all excited again... :D

These images might be just Ross' imagination running loose, but I really hope some of them will make it to the book.

zbowen
08-25-2013, 12:31 PM
here's an idea...how about you guys stop reading the solicitations. i specifically avoid them for that purpose. it makes everything more enjoyable. heck, some times i even skip the issue previews.

I do my best to avoid them for this reason. Just being on the Internet in general, I typically find about about future arcs in general. I agree, it makes the story less fun when you see what's coming.

This is more if a general complaint, but with all companies now writing for the sale if a TPB release, I know how long a story is going to last. It needs to be wrapped up in X number of issues.

Jester
08-25-2013, 05:14 PM
I really wasn't sold until the Karai one-shot. His attitude in that kinda won me over.

corvus
08-25-2013, 05:26 PM
I'm more excited about the aftermath. Of Dark Leo and city fall as a whole.

Cipher
08-25-2013, 06:20 PM
I can only imagine "City Fall" would feel a lot stronger without he cliched nonsense of a brainwashed, eeeeevil Turtle thrown into the mix.

So, yeah, mark me down for one step beyond "not enthused" to "feeling it's an active deterrent."

I was really hoping "City Fall" would be a shot in the arm. Instead it's been a Saturday morning cartoon.

IDK. Maybe...

You know, I'm still bummed out about dark leo. There was so much potential for character growth in all this... *sigh*

Maybe next time.
One can only hope.

I too was expecting it would be more interesting. Of course, I also imagined going in that there would actually be motivation for Leo's joining the Foot, or at least something more nuanced than, "Now you're a good guy, now you're not! Whizz! Poof! Here's your black headband and here are your pouches!"

Worse still, it's obvious from both the setup and solicits that he'll make a quick recovery, at which point we can look forward to being subjected to continued internal conflict over:

1) How he might have the potential to be EVIL(!) (when ... manipulated by an ancient fox demon, I guess ...)
2) How he might even have ENJOYED(!!) it
and 3) Whether it should provide motivation to KILL(!!!) the Shredder in revenge, or whether that would make him JUST AS BAD(!!!!)!!!!!????

Which, yikes, sorry. See you in eight months.

(Full apologies to Bobby, Tom and co. I hope to be proven wrong, but, no filter, I've been really leery of where the book has been headed recently.)

CyberCubed
08-25-2013, 06:38 PM
I hope they have Raphael take over the mantle of Shredder instead like in Volune 3. Raph was working with bad guys but wasn't bad himself.

Cipher
08-25-2013, 06:46 PM
I hope they have Raphael take over the mantle of Shredder instead like in Volune 3. Raph was working with bad guys but wasn't bad himself.
I won't say they needed to ape that idea directly (in fact, they absolutely shouldn't, as the series is at its best when it's at its most original) but I think like one of the reasons this feels like such a let-down/cop-out is because of just how good IDW was at setting up that kind of organic, unexpected character growth a year ago.

You had the Leonardo/Donatello conflict introduced in the first six issues, which was a hugely interesting take on the characters and which still hasn't been fully explored.

You had Raph rejoining the team and meeting his brothers for the first time, feeling some of his morals chaffed against theirs while also still appreciate of the family.

You have the whole thing about whether they finally need to kill Shredder, and the various Turtles' reactions to that idea.

Etcetera, etcetera.

And when we finally get a story line that proposes to bring those issues to a head, we get ... this. Straight out of left field, straight out of, again, a Saturday morning cartoon, just like all of IDW Shredder's plans. Plots are moving forward but they're also getting increasingly ridiculous, and increasingly overshadowing the enjoyable character setup we saw during the series' foundations.

If they really wanted one of the Turtles to join the Foot, there were any number of more organic ways to do that. Donatello and Leo seem to have fewer compunctions about killing. Raphael feels like an outsider. Splinter's origin story is still somewhat suspect. Any of those aspects could have played with loyalties. Or not, and the story could have moved on just fine.

But, hey, oh well. Hopefully they stick the dismount.

Jester
08-25-2013, 06:49 PM
I hope they have Raphael take over the mantle of Shredder instead like in Volune 3. Raph was working with bad guys but wasn't bad himself.

Yes, let's have everything always be the way it was somewhere else...

Martin
08-25-2013, 08:23 PM
I too was expecting it would be more interesting. Of course, I also imagined going in that there would actually be motivation for Leo's joining the Foot, or at least something more nuanced than, "Now you're a good guy, now you're not! Whizz! Poof! Here's your black headband and here are your pouches!"Don't forget our 'this week only' special: Shredder's trademarked gauntlet!

If they really wanted one of the Turtles to join the Foot, there were any number of more organic ways to do that. Donatello and Leo seem to have fewer compunctions about killing. Raphael feels like an outsider. Splinter's origin story is still somewhat suspect. Any of those aspects could have played with loyalties. Or not, and the story could have moved on just fine.I agree 100%. So many possibilities that went unused :ohwell:

I'm more excited about the aftermath. Of Dark Leo and city fall as a whole.

Me too. I can't believe I'm actually looking forward to this arc's ending so we can see some of the repercussions of this whole ordeal.

Which, yikes, sorry. See you in eight months.Goddamit xD

Bobby Curnow
08-25-2013, 08:54 PM
No need to apologize to us. Fine if you're not digging it. All i'll say is that some readers have presumptions about what will happen and are treating those presumptions as fact, which are way off base. Not saying you'll like what is actually in store more, maybe you'll hate it.

I'm curious about how exactly Shredder is coming off as a saturday morning cartoon character. I think there are plenty of valid criticisms to make, but i'm not seeing that one. Maybe it's because I know where things are heading, and that's coloring my opinion.

I just wish people who have negative opinions would write a letter or write the editor thread at the IDW forums. We never get any negative response in those places (and i know those negative response exist!), it would be nice to have a discussion about them. (although it may be difficult to have that discussion, without spoiling things).

Regardless, hearing what does and doesn't work is hugely beneficial. Say what you want about us, but we're always going to strive to make the book better.

Jester
08-25-2013, 08:58 PM
Can't have those discussions where the negativity is? Like...here?

Cipher
08-25-2013, 09:19 PM
I'm curious about how exactly Shredder is coming off as a saturday morning cartoon character. I think there are plenty of valid criticisms to make, but i'm not seeing that one. Maybe it's because I know where things are heading, and that's coloring my opinion.
For me, at least, it's several things that are probably easier broken out as such:

1) His goal is city-wide domination. Not a huge thing; that's what any underworld leader should want. But it's specifically the way he phrases it, a la "embrace our destiny, etc."
2) Related to the above, his dialogue as a whole. I'm thinking of the time he corrects Kitsune, saying it's "his destiny," rather than "ours," which is just a really stock supervillain line. In general I find the dialogue on the book to be overwritten (usually just by a word or two, but it makes a difference), which I've just chalked up to Tom and Kevin being idea men more than prose or script writers (and that's begrudgingly fine), but that instance, and several others like it, stand out in particular.
3) His nonchalant approach to underling loyalty, which we've now seen lay the seeds for at least two mutinies. Not hard behavior to swallow for a stock supervillain, but a little beyond the pale for someone we're to believe is a genuine underworld threat and who once operated an entire ninja clan.
And 4) All the little things. Stopping Leo from killing Splinter because he wanted him for himself, for example. All justifiable, to an extent, but all anything but pragmatic and, in the case of the specific example above, clearly one of those Bond-villain-esque setups that allows the heroes to escape for no other reason than the idea that his hubris must allow the plot to continue.

This might all be offset if we knew a little more about him, I suppose. But so far nearly all our time spent with him has seen him engaging in that standard kind of supervillainy. The "dark Leo" arc probably isn't helping much either, but I made my feelings clear on that earlier this thread. There are plenty of things I do like about this Shredder. I like his history with Yoshi. I like, particularly, his relationship with Kitsune. But in both those cases it just makes his approach so far more disappointing; he's nothing more than a cartoonish arch-nemesis for Splinter and the Turtles, and it's clear he and Kitsune are on a collision course, which is ego-maniacal villainy 101.

I just wish people who have negative opinions would write a letter or write the editor thread at the IDW forums. We never get any negative response in those places (and i know those negative response exist!), it would be nice to have a discussion about them. (although it may be difficult to have that discussion, without spoiling things).

Hm, you know, I do have an account on the IDW Forums. I should probably use that sometime. Maybe I'll submit a letter just to even out those pages for you guys.

Regardless, hearing what does and doesn't work is hugely beneficial. Say what you want about us, but we're always going to strive to make the book better.
Yep, and I definitely appreciate that! Thanks for being cool with it. While my opinion on this arc so far still stands (not great), I definitely don't take the fan-creator interaction for granted and know you guys care about what you're doing with the book.

Can't have those discussions where the negativity is? Like...here?
I'm not that negative, right? Where's Andrew?

Bobby Curnow
08-25-2013, 09:37 PM
Cool, I appreciate the honest dialogue, Cipher.

I will say that you're working under false assumptions for a couple of your points. One of them should be at least partially disabused next week, another by the end of the arc & Shredder micro. I won't say which is which to maintain some element of surprise.

I will also say that one of your four points I think is completely legitimate and I agree with, and is something I personally think we could have done a better job of.

And I do recognize that it can be a cop out to say 'wait four more months!'. Obviously the story should be working on some level in the here and now, and if it's not— well, you're probably not going to dig how things end. It's not like the creative team is changing. We've either convinced you we're capable of some legitimate surprises and that would hopefully buy some benefit of the doubt as to how one ASSUMES it will end, or we haven't. It sounds like we haven't in your case, which is fine. Can't win 'em all.

And Jester— of course you can, and should have those conversations here. I'm just speaking personally— 1) I check the IDW forums more often, every day, and 2) I feel like a heel butting in and responding to stuff here, because that just sounds like i'm defensive. (i actively tell creators not too rebuke criticism too much on forums, because it usually doesn't end well and people should feel free to have places where they can talk about a book without creators jumping all over them... something i'm guilty of right now!) So long story short— it's easier to for me to get a gauge of things on the IDW forum/letters, where I see everything, and it's a way to engage the discussion directly and immediately. But by all means— talk away wherever you want!

Jester
08-25-2013, 09:46 PM
No, I'm just saying from the way Bobby put it the IDW Turtle forums (and I guess letters) are free from negativity, and he wishes we'd move the discussion there...just seems odd when that same discussion could be held where the "negativity" (as mild as it is) is actually taking place.


As for Shredder's dialogue being overwritten, could that be chalked up to his grasp of English and his age? Kinda like how Thor is written with all the thees and thous?

Bobby, I welcome the input from the creative team. Sometimes, despite the fact we're obsessive fans, we do miss the minutia...the forest for the trees. As long as you're here and not getting put off by the "negativity" then you're welcome. I know tons of us were more upset to lose Ciro because he got upset than because he in some way upset us.

Cipher
08-25-2013, 09:49 PM
I will also say that one of your four points I think is completely legitimate and I agree with, and is something I personally think we could have done a better job of.
I'll try not to speculate on which those were.

And I do recognize that it can be a cop out to say 'wait four more months!'. Obviously the story should be working on some level in the here and now, and if it's not— well, you're probably not going to dig how things end. It's not like the creative team is changing. We've either convinced you we're capable of some legitimate surprises and that would hopefully buy some benefit of the doubt as to how one ASSUMES it will end, or we haven't. It sounds like we haven't in your case, which is fine. Can't win 'em all.
I do want to say that, while I've espoused some negative predictions even in this thread, I am trying to keep an open mind while reading the series month to month, as I really do believe in the strength of the concept, and even previous output from the IDW team.

If I've written about trepidation in regards to future events here, it's only because, and you alluded to this in your response as well, it's serialized fiction and that's how we respond to it as readers. It's faced with the unenviable task of having to work not only long term, but also in a way that maintains expectations and excitement month to month. It has to hold enough back to allow for development and twists, while also not keeping readers in the dark to the point that it seems elements aren't working purely by mistake.

I do hope future installments improve in my eyes. I like it enough to want to enjoy it more. I can only, when opining and predicting, go with what I've been given, of course, but I still go in with fresh expectations each month.

So, absolutely, here's hoping. And if not, c'est la vie.

2) I feel like a heel butting in and responding to stuff here, because that just sounds like i'm defensive. (i actively tell creators not too rebuke criticism too much on forums, because it usually doesn't end well and people should feel free to have places where they can talk about a book without creators jumping all over them... something i'm guilty of right now!)
I just want to say -- While I understand the IDW forums being a safer spot on you guys' end for fan-creator interaction, and completely understand trying to limit writer interaction on here (as it puts IDW in a tight spot if a lone member of the team goes off), please don't feel that measured responses like yours are unwelcome! Part of the reason I've always liked posting here is knowing that members of the creative team can pop in for responses at any time (was true during the Mirage era and has held true under IDW as well). I think it keeps all parties civil and makes posts worthwhile, without cutting down on any freedom to post negative opinions.

As for Shredder's dialogue being overwritten, could that be chalked up to his grasp of English and his age? Kinda like how Thor is written with all the thees and thous?
Putting this in the nicest way possible, I think that's a bit of a No-Prize. I think all the dialogue is a little (like, really slightly and it's hard to seem constructive about this just being some guy reading the book with nothing other than an amateur writing background and not having specific examples) overwritten. Shredder's just happens to be supervillainish as well. The particular "You mean my destiny" moment was actually, if I recall correctly, supposed to be translated for the reader from Japanese anyway.

CyberCubed
08-25-2013, 10:01 PM
Cipher what other comics are you reading that you're comparing the IDW run too? I notice you have an account on those comicbook websites forums, (I recognize your posting style, I know its you), and you seem to think what's going on in the current Batman run is more interesting?

Bobby Curnow
08-25-2013, 10:10 PM
Cool, all good... we've all got pretty tough skin! In regards to IDW forums/letters... I definitely don't want people posting here LESS! Was just saying I'd love to get all different reactions over in those other places as well. The letters column has become a bit of a bore recently!

Cipher
08-25-2013, 10:22 PM
Cipher what other comics are you reading that you're comparing the IDW run too? I notice you have an account on those comicbook websites forums, (I recognize your posting style, I know its you), and you seem to think what's going on in the current Batman run is more interesting?
Taking this discussion to PM for relevancy's sake, but it's certainly not the current Batman book, which I have very few good things to say about.

And for whatever unreasonable reason I think I may hold TMNT to a different standard than Big Two books, which are sort of my brain-off reading material to begin with (that, and some of the more cliched tropes I'd bemoan in IDW are inherent to their genre). Probably not fair, but there you go.

Powder
08-25-2013, 10:46 PM
I think all the dialogue is a little (like, really slightly and it's hard to seem constructive about this just being some guy reading the book with nothing other than an amateur writing background and not having specific examples) overwritten. Shredder's just happens to be supervillainish as well. The particular "You mean my destiny" moment was actually, if I recall correctly, supposed to be translated for the reader from Japanese anyway.

I'm completely with you on this. It was one of my biggest complaints with the book in the early days. Old Hob's dialog seemed like it was taken directly from Team Rocket or some other Saturday morning cartoon villain. Some of the slang would be dated, too. I do think it's gotten a LOT better since then, though Shredder does still occasionally have hint traces of it.

Red Mask
08-26-2013, 11:28 AM
You had the Leonardo/Donatello conflict introduced in the first six issues, which was a hugely interesting take on the characters and which still hasn't been fully explored.


I'm enjoying City Fall and the rest of the IDW books, but I totally agree with this.

As for Shredder- I get the issues, but I do like a little bit of cartoon camp in TMNT, even in the more adult-aimed stuff like IDW. I think City Fall's Shredder is a pretty good balance.

This is an aside from any issues brought up here, but I like that he's ruthless and threatening, but because of an overwhelming need to be the most powerful and strong, he can be a bit dumb/blind, but doesn't care. He trusts his brute strength and intimidation to carry him...I get the impression he's an elemental evil, like a bullying force of nature. Makes him kinda scary.

Andrew NDB
08-26-2013, 11:51 AM
I will say that of all of the possible ways and reasonings behind one of the Turtles actually joining the Foot/joining Shredder... brainwashing is probably the most uninspiring way to go about it and can only end in fairly predictable fashion (i.e., Leo will snap out of his funk at a key moment, pretending to be Dark Leo just long enough to get the upper hand on Shredder again, etc. etc.).

But then to be fair, I haven't really sat down and properly read the past 3 or so months of IDW TMNT comics yet. Just skimmed. I guess I keep waiting for some big course-changing, character defining moment or event that will make me go, "Ooh! Yes! Now we're talking" but it hasn't quite happened yet.

CyberCubed
08-26-2013, 01:53 PM
I figure its still mandates from Nick/Viacom that makes the comic not go as far as it should. They know kids watching the Nick show will stumble upon the comic and they want to make sure kids don't get turned off the Turtles if they see blood all over the walls or The Turtles spewing forth curse words.

I like the IDW comics quite a bit but I can see why some feels like its only slightly more mature than a Saturday morning cartoon. It actually feels a lot like the 4kids series as an example.

ObiWanFan4life
08-26-2013, 01:57 PM
I agree, The IDW Comics are TV-PG (Dark, but accessible to children of age.) in comparison to Mirage, which is very TV-14 (Darker, and meant for teens/adults.)

pingclang
08-26-2013, 03:28 PM
IDW has the Animated Series comic, which is great for kids. Maybe now would be a good time to up the ante on the regular ongoing? Start pushing some boundaries and telling stories completely new and more adult?

Tazi
08-26-2013, 03:32 PM
To be honest, it's not like mirage had that much blood. And there were zero cursing. Well, Tales v2 issues by Tristan have cursing in them and they're all censored.
What Mirage really had are ocassional adult topics, like how Casey deals with the death of her wife, or Splinters stuff with survival instintincts (and cannibalism), etc.
I love City Fall so far, but I agree with the others. Shredder really souldn't be written that much over the top, cartoonish way, even if he was like that in many TMNT incernations. Sure, he is evil, but being evil is not a character trait, it's a judgement on a character's actions. I love the 4kids series, but their Shredder was really not a good example for a well written character. The Utrom Shredder was evil for the sake of being evil, without real motivations, I hope IDW will keep distancing their version from him.


I think we should really have a here a "feedback to idw creators" or some similar topic here, so it would be much easier to communicate with the staff like that, because they were always known, where to look at.

Andrew NDB
08-26-2013, 03:38 PM
To be honest, it's not like mirage had that much blood.

Outright, no, not always. But death was very real and very present... each battle had real consequences.

And there were zero cursing.

Re-read them. Plenty of "damns" and "hells" and even a spattering of "sh*t" in a few places early on.

TomWaltz
08-26-2013, 03:45 PM
I'd respond to all this, but don't want Cipher accusing me of overwriting on this thread.

:P


Talk soon!

Tom W.

Tazi
08-26-2013, 03:55 PM
Well, IDW had "crap", that's about the same level as "damn", or anything censored. (Or I could be wrong, my english is not native, so I can't really feel how much weight those words actually have compared to each other.)

You're right about permanent deaths and consequences in Mirage, I ment the average level of gore and violence, I think last IDW issues are really not that far from mirage.
I think about IDW, it's not just about killing characters or not, but they kinda do a "superhero-comic style" of aproach where villains are recurring, instead of the more consequence-heavy Mirage approach, which had no rogues gallery.

CyberCubed
08-26-2013, 09:24 PM
Well the Mirage Turtles always seemed, "depressed" and their world seem much more real as in they weren't always looking for the next big adventure or supervillain to stop. They just lived their lives like ordinary people until something happened.

IDW TMNT is a lot like the 3 cartoons, (Original, 4kids and Nick), in that it feels like an action superhero-y series where the next big bad is always coming up and the Turtles have to stop them. This of course is fine and I like it here and in the cartoons, but it is a stark contrast to Mirage.

Cipher
08-26-2013, 10:13 PM
I'd respond to all this, but don't want Cipher accusing me of overwriting on this thread.

:P
http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lrh7hqNIM51qii6tmo1_500.gif

It's true, though: I only like pictures and I'm impossible to please.

Panda_Kahn_fan
08-27-2013, 04:09 PM
A thought occured to me- we are only seeing glimpses of the actual city take over, and I wonder if that's not intentional. What if Shredder's plan isn't bainwahing and making Leo his lieutenant at all (despite what he told Karai), but rather the whole 'Dark Leo' fiasco (along with the minor attacks on the other factions Leo is involved in) is something to keep the turtles distracted with trying to get Leo back, that his true conquest of the city goes on all around them unhindered? The street gangs fall under thier control with Hun's coup of the purple Dragons, taking away leadership from Angel. And the Savate are ethier beaten or scared into submission, while deals are cut with the mob. This is all part of Shredder's elborate takeover plan, unbenknowst to even Karai, one which forces the rescued leo and the others to flee the Shredder-controlled new york?

Meh, I'm probably just thinking too much. :tlol:

Rooish
08-28-2013, 11:38 AM
Guys, what if the mind control didn't work and Leo is just faking it?

ObiWanFan4life
08-28-2013, 11:39 AM
Guys, what if the mind control didn't work and Leo is just faking it?

Why would he do that?

Tazi
08-28-2013, 12:18 PM
Why would he do that?

This:

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/23327853/leotrick.png

ToTheNines
08-28-2013, 08:23 PM
That scene has made me wonder... but #25 kinda rules out him faking it since we get a look inside his head when he has a flashback to his parents when seeing Saki and Kitsune together.

Rooish
08-28-2013, 08:31 PM
He could still have a flashback even if he's faking it. Maybe that was meant to mislead us.

Edit: Oops, unfortunately my idea is probably a fail. I guess "faking it" Leo would not be sending ninjas to kill others.