PDA

View Full Version : Your thought on the idw karai


MikLeo
08-24-2013, 06:44 PM
I've always really liked Karai from the 2003 series and mirage karai and her Nick counterpart. She's a fascinating character who dances on the line of anti-hero and villain. She works for the bad guys, but has a sense of honor and tries to treat the turtles decently.

My problem with IDW Karai while she's still pretty badass and has a much better character design than her Nick counterpart, but she just comes off as one-note and bland. IDW Karai is stripped of all the qualities that made 2003 Karai a multifaceted character--the father-daughter bond that mirrored the turtles' relationship with Splinter and the position of authority in the Foot Clan that made her a force to be reckoned with, and the frenemy relationship with the turtles that made it hard for them to see her as pure evil.

Its to soon to tell what Karai relationship with the turtles will be particularly with Leo. Among the turtle, Leo is the one she has the most interaction with. The only good thing about IDW Karai that I can say that she is hot and have lot of ambition...and not much else.

zbowen
08-24-2013, 07:04 PM
Karai has the potential to become interesting during City Fall. One if the bigger themes is disfinctional or broken famlies. Leo and the Turtles, Casey and his Dad, Karai and Shredder. That being said, her story is the most boring. So far, Karai has been little more than a whiny child that Shredder tells to shut up and to do her damn job. It also doesn't help that especially after the finale, I find Karai to be one of the more interesting characters on the Nick show.

Powder
08-24-2013, 07:19 PM
With no disrespect to anyone at IDW, I think their version is just as plain as any other at this point in time. I do think she's got the best character design, though.

Eiko
08-24-2013, 07:23 PM
With no disrespect to anyone at IDW, I think their version is just as plain as any other at this point in time. I do think she's got the best character design, though.

Yes i my thoughts exactly.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-24-2013, 09:16 PM
With no disrespect to anyone at IDW, I think their version is just as plain as any other at this point in time. I do think she's got the best character design, though.

Plain in what sense? Do you mean kind of flat, like there isn't much to her?

The micro book REALLY made me hate Dark Leo as a person (not as a character), which was clearly intended. I still think though that there is a "shred" of the real Leo in there somewhere, which is why he didn't kill Karai. So maybe Leo is still in there, and it won't necessarily take magic or science to bring him back.

Powder
08-24-2013, 10:26 PM
Yeah, that's what I mean.

Technogeek29
08-24-2013, 10:36 PM
She hasn't struck me as evil for say. In fact if it wasn't for Saki I doubt Karai would even bother with the Hamato family. she's much more intreasted in leading the Foot Whether she does it herself or manipulates Saki into doing it for her. Kitsune seems to have disapeared and I wonder what IDW plans for her? And I said this in another thread but I wonder how a Team up between Karai and Don would play out? Not working togethor willingly for say but with each other in a micro.

Mr._Mutant_Man
08-25-2013, 10:23 AM
I think the micro-series issue has given the character an interesting background. She may have started off as being a granddaughter Shredder pushes around, but this issue shows how driven she was to restore the Foot Clan, and has given her a motivation to show she's better than Dark Leo.

To sum up my thoughts on this version of Karai, I didn't think much at first but this past issue made me take notice.

Tazi
08-25-2013, 10:44 AM
To be honest, Karai so far was only part of the "supporting cast", that's why her story and background wasn't fleshed out, I think. We had two Shredder releated story arcs so far, before City Fall. The one where the turtles beat Shredder who kidnapped Splinter, and Secret History. The first of them focus on Shredder vs Splinter and their shared past, and the second one is on Shredder's origin story with Kitsune, while in Mirage she was a major player in City at War, and in 4kids she was the villain replacing Shredder for a long period.
So I think it's understandable, why she is underdeveloped. Or I'd say, she was. Her micro adds to her character, and it seems like she starting to grow a bitter rivalry with Leo (already happened before the micro). We also know how dissappointed she is with her Gramps taking over the Foot, and treating her like a dog, I think this will lead into more character development, and I think she will become more interesting in time.

tl;dr: For her limited appearences, the development level of the character is ok.

corvus
08-25-2013, 11:06 AM
Her relationship with Leo? She hates him. What I like about her is that there's no softness towards the turtles and there's no question of her loyalty towards the foot. She cares only for building the foot clan to its former glory.

Tazi
08-25-2013, 11:34 AM
no softness towards the turtles and there's no question of her loyalty towards the foot. She cares only for building the foot clan to its former glory.
I think this is why she will eventually join forces with the turtles in IDW too. She is loyal to the Foot, but not to Shredder, and basically she wants the same thing as Splinter: To kill/remove Shredder.

corvus
08-25-2013, 02:33 PM
I think this is why she will eventually join forces with the turtles in IDW too. She is loyal to the Foot, but not to Shredder, and basically she wants the same thing as Splinter: To kill/remove Shredder.

Did I miss this or something? Cause I have yet to read anything about that.

FlogginMcMurryZombiePizza
08-25-2013, 02:43 PM
I would think she would remove Shredder so she can take ruling control of the Foot.
Not to join the Turtles. Not everyone who's enemy is the same will join together.

Tazi
08-25-2013, 03:44 PM
Did I miss this or something? Cause I have yet to read anything about that.

I might be mistaken, but in Karai micro she says that she can't challenge and beat Shredder, and she also can't leave Foot.

corvus
08-25-2013, 04:02 PM
And her main problem with the foot is Leonardo. I don't think I need to use spoiler tags when I say he isn't gonna be with the foot forever.

Tazi
08-25-2013, 04:15 PM
Hm, good point. but I wonder if Karai's making Leo leave somehow, will be enough for the Shredder to make Karai into chunnin again. After all he said to her, that she is unsuitable for the leader's role, and not ready yet.
From all that I kinda jumped into the conclusion, that she'd kill him, if she were skilled enough fighter to do that, because I somehow beleived her desire was actually leading the foot, that she herself rebuilt.

pingclang
08-26-2013, 01:45 PM
Hm, good point. but I wonder if Karai's making Leo leave somehow, will be enough for the Shredder to make Karai into chunnin again. After all he said to her, that she is unsuitable for the leader's role, and not ready yet.
From all that I kinda jumped into the conclusion, that she'd kill him, if she were skilled enough fighter to do that, because I somehow beleived her desire was actually leading the foot, that she herself rebuilt.

You're right. Karai worked hard to rebuild the Foot and then Shredder takes the leadership and she isn't happy so now she wants his seat but can't manage it. This Karai is still sort of bland but I'm liking what they're doing with her.

shuriken
08-28-2013, 05:44 PM
I like that she's sort of split between ruling the Clan with Saki and controlling it herself. Aside from that the best interpretation of Karai is in the Mirage books.