Evanescence -VS- T.A.T.U.

[redsai4lex]

I think this is rediculous, but I was arguing w/ a friend about this,

I think tatu sounds like 3 year old girls(or mice)

Evanescence should win by a long shot!!!!!!!!!!

[GK Punk]

Don't even get me started on Tatu....

I dont think the two bands should be compared, Evanessance(sp) are actual musicians as where Tatu were hired to act like lesbians and make out on stage.

Musically speaking, Evanessance wins

Tatu just has a better gimmick.
You heard me, gimmick.

[Kid Icarus]

Don't even get me started on Tatu....

I dont think the two bands should be compared, Evanessance(sp) are actual musicians as where Tatu were hired to act like lesbians and make out on stage.

Musically speaking, Evanessance wins

Tatu just has a better gimmick.
You heard me, gimmick.

Coulden't agree more.

'Cept I don't like Evanessance either from what I've heard. Maybe that will change if they get a new single out :-? .

[GK Punk]

Yeah they tend to grow on you, I really hated them at first :lol:
Amy's voice is slightly annoying in long periods of time also

[That Matt Guy]

I've never heard of either groups.

[Silver Turtle]

I must agree Evanescence is a lot better than tatu. I think they can't song worth crap. And Amy from Evanescence, her voice on some parts seems too high pitched, or something like that.




- Silver Turtle

[Raven]

Evanescence all the way not those little bitches from russia tatu!
but after awhile eve here starts to get on my nerves and I feel like taking that microphone and pushing it down her throat! same thing to tatu I hate both if you cant tell but i'll goe with eva i guess

[Brodie]

I like the lesbian gimmick. It's nice on Mute.

[Raven]

:lol:

[Mars-Chan]

:lol: :tlol:

[Reznorite420]

I dont think the two bands should be compared, Evanessance(sp) are actual musicians as where Tatu were hired to act like lesbians and make out on stage.THANK YOU!!!!!!

Nobody gets it when I try to tell them that the whole "lesbian" thing is totally fake and their attempt at appearing as such is totally lousy. Trust me, I live with 2 lesbians, I know what they really are, and they're NOT that. This whole sexuality "craze" thing is getting out of hand IMO.

[Reznorite420]

I like the lesbian gimmick. It's nice on Mute. :D

Um, ditto.

[Moomintroll]

OH MY GOD! I HATE TATU!
Fist of all, they have been around for a while, being russian, i knew of them for ages, and now they made it by pretending to be lesbians. I mean, they are not gay! They can't sing worth ****, and they are not atractive, and I despise the fact that they use the shock value of "lesbian cathlic school girls" to get popularity. And pretending to be gay to gain the gay community? So ****ing sad and fake. Army Of Lovers has the national gay anthom "Crucify" since like 1989, no one knows that, suddenly it's T.A.T.U. the "gay pride" band. Argh, and they also wear those shirts that mean "**** war" and I happen to support the war... but thats nor here nor there.
:(
Jack off Jill, THAT's a good girl band.

[Leo656]

I don't like either, though I do kinda like "All the Things She Said", but mostly cuz it's Victoria's theme music in WWE.

Evanescence really annoyed me because when the Daredevil soundtrack came out suddenly everyone was like "OMG Evanescence is soooo awesome!!!" when they'd only had ONE song out that anyone had heard so far. I hate when that happens, it's like hear more than one song before you pledge undying loyalty to a band, y'know?

Personally, I think they both suck and the fact one of the girls in TaTu had sex with their manage when she was like 14 or 15, and that the guy admits he likes underage girls, really bugs me.

[Reznorite420]

I'll be honest: I'm not really into female vocalists, PERIOD.

Call me crazy, but that's true.

[Moomintroll]

yeh, i forgot to say, I don't like the other one, well, ok, i don't KNOW the other one.

Personally, I think they both suck and the fact one of the girls in TaTu had sex with their manage when she was like 14 or 15, and that the guy admits he likes underage girls, really bugs me
thats very common in russia

there was a singer i liked as a kid, Natasha Koroleva, and she only got famous cause she screwed her manager/famous singer who was like 40, and she was 16.

It just bugs me that they are faking the lesbian thing, i mean, it would be an awsome thing for the gay community if they were, but they aren't. Posers

[That Matt Guy]

Ok, now I'm glad I don't know who these people are.

[Reznorite420]

Freddy Mercury, HE was non-hetero.

Elton John, HE is gay.

The lead singer to Judas Priest, HE was gay (am I wrong in assuming he's dead?)

Melissa Ethridge...is she? I thought she was...

But TATU...they're not even doing a good job at POSING as lesbians.

[That Matt Guy]

Rob Halford from Judas Priest is not dead.

[Reznorite420]

Excuse me.

[Moomintroll]

Melissa Ethridge...is she? I thought she was...

But TATU...they're not even doing a good job at POSING as lesbians.


yes, she is

and yes, they are doing a bad job, thats why they piss me off

[Brodie]

OH MY GOD! I HATE TATU!
Fist of all, they have been around for a while, being russian, i knew of them for ages, and now they made it by pretending to be lesbians. I mean, they are not gay! They can't sing worth sh**, and they are not atractive, and I despise the fact that they use the shock value of "lesbian cathlic school girls" to get popularity. And pretending to be gay to gain the gay community? So f***ing sad and fake. Army Of Lovers has the national gay anthom "Crucify" since like 1989, no one knows that, suddenly it's T.A.T.U. the "gay pride" band. Argh, and they also wear those shirts that mean "f*** war" and I happen to support the war... but thats nor here nor there.
:(
Jack off Jill, THAT's a good girl band.

Yeah, Jack off Jill is good, but .....the...lesbians.....

I hadn't heard of Tegan & Sarah before but while loking through Hawksley Workman songs I found them, they're ok.

Better than that BJork chick. She creeps me out. Isn't she like a Keebler Elf or something?

[InsaneZane]

It should be illegal to compare them... thats just rediculous.
Evanescence...............Amy Lee is so sweet :wink:

[GK Punk]

There are actually pics of Taty with their boyfriends floating around on the net... THE JIG IS UP! lol

And I actually liked their russian music (well a little anyways, it was never my favorite) But it does NOTHING NOTHING for me in english.

[U2WaTCHer]

even thou TATU sucks i'd prob do the blond one hehe :goofygri:

[cqb101]

Evanescence is far better.

[Caster_Troy]

The goths -vs- the 'lesbians' in an all out brawl to the death, this sunday, sunday, SUNDAY!

[Raven]

:lol: good one!

[U2WaTCHer]

id still do amy and the blond tatu chick! lol :roll:

[Raven]

id still do amy and the blond tatu chick! lol :roll:

um im I the only one that cant think of wich ones the blond one?