PDA

View Full Version : What Mirage TMNT comics would you erase/retcon?


CyberCubed
08-27-2013, 10:52 PM
If you became Peter Laird for a day, but had your own personal preferences and not his, what Mirage TMNT comics would you retcon/erase?

- I'd gut a good chunk of Volume 1, but far from all of it. I'd also move Soul's Winter out of the main volume and into a separate, "Tales" series. Any zany/goofy stories would be erased, and any stories that wound up being dull or pointless (like #44 with the black girl, or #41 with Turtle dreams) would be gone.

- Volume 2 would have simply continued from Volume 1 in black and white, and without the rushed ending.

- All those TMNT specials like, "The Haunted Pizza," "Times Pipeline" "The Maltease Turtle," and "Casey Jones" would be gone.

- Image would removed that terrible, "Johnny Raeborn" story...that small segment where they crossover with Image superheroes, I think it was #11-13...that arc was awful.

- Volume 4 would be extremely condensed and all that padding would be gone.

Powder
08-27-2013, 11:00 PM
I'm with you for the most part. Though I like Turtle Dreams quite a lot.

Leo656
08-27-2013, 11:51 PM
I'd have to read all of it again, but definitely April's "Secret Origin" from Vol. 4. Nothing else in the whole thing bugged me as much as that did.

Cipher
08-28-2013, 12:05 AM
I'd have to read all of it again, but definitely April's "Secret Origin" from Vol. 4. Nothing else in the whole thing bugged me as much as that did.
I'm of two minds about that.

The issue itself -- Vol. 4 #22 -- is one of the most disturbingly effective entries in the whole of TMNT canon. It works. I swear we were working toward some real payoff through Leo's discovery of the Battle Nexus as well.

Unfortunately that payoff never came, so we're just left with this bizarre footnote that really does undermine April's fundamental role as a character -- that of the Turtle's connection to normality (despite her life being anything but normal from the time she meets them). I suppose, current state, the series would probably read better without it. It wasn't doing much thematically either.

If you became Peter Laird for a day, but had your own personal preferences and not his, what Mirage TMNT comics would you retcon/erase?

- I'd gut a good chunk of Volume 1, but far from all of it. I'd also move Soul's Winter out of the main volume and into a separate, "Tales" series. Any zany/goofy stories would be erased, and any stories that wound up being dull or pointless (like #44 with the black girl, or #41 with Turtle dreams) would be gone.

- Volume 2 would have simply continued from Volume 1 in black and white, and without the rushed ending.

- All those TMNT specials like, "The Haunted Pizza," "Times Pipeline" "The Maltease Turtle," and "Casey Jones" would be gone.

- Image would removed that terrible, "Johnny Raeborn" story...that small segment where they crossover with Image superheroes, I think it was #11-13...that arc was awful.

- Volume 4 would be extremely condensed and all that padding would be gone.
I disagree almost unilaterally with these, except the Volume 3 bit, where I absolutely, one-hundred percent agree.

Those bizarre guest artist stories, while I'm sure they were excruciating to sit through on a longer-than-monthly basis, are part of what gives Mirage its tone for me. I like to imagine that they mostly happened, too, as far as the Turtles' world is concerned, if not quite as wacky as depicted on-page.

The colors on Volume 2 are great. Shame about the art and writing in the last half, though.

The Lucindra issue and "Turtle Dreams" are both boss. Some of the better character issues in Volume 1, though both still definitely riding the wave of the surreal guest artist era.

And the specials, while I'm not crazy about any of them, don't do anything offensive enough to make me wish they didn't exist.

There are a few issues of Tales Vol. 2 I feel that way about, though. Chief among them #35, "The Pantheon," which really kills the Rat King's character. I could probably live without the Moo-Mesa crossovers as well.

CyberCubed
08-28-2013, 12:11 AM
To be honest alot of the Volume 1 guest issues that aren't silly...just tend to be boring.

Take #29 for example, the one with the vampires and the kids. The issue had great art, but the story was a snoozefest. The issue introduces a new male lead character where it seems the Turtles are guest characters in their own book (many of the Volume 1 issues do this, relegate the Turtles to secondary status), and it results in a 35 page story where nothing much happens.

The only thing the issue establish is that there were vampires in the Turtle universe, something that later continues into Volume 4.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-28-2013, 11:50 AM
I'm of two minds about that.

The issue itself -- Vol. 4 #22 -- is one of the most disturbingly effective entries in the whole of TMNT canon. It works. I swear we were working toward some real payoff through Leo's discovery of the Battle Nexus as well.


THIS!!! There was going to be an alternative reality Splinter of sorts.

Plasticplayhouse
08-28-2013, 01:23 PM
i liked the majority of v1. turtle dreams was entertaining and i like Howarth's art style. the only ones i didn't care much for were #38, 39, 40 (they weren't bad, just had and Archie feel to me. i much preferred #34 from that duo). i liked the art in #44 and the story was decent, but i didnt care for how much raph kept getting his butt handed to him from Lucindra. for her to be challenging - cool, but to basically be out of raph's league was a little too much. i did love all the early 90's lingo/references that was captured in it. the way they talked and the person rockin the triple fat goose made me feel like i was back in junior high/high school :)

CyberCubed
08-28-2013, 02:16 PM
the only ones i didn't care much for were #38, 39, 40 (they weren't bad, just had and Archie feel to me. i much preferred #34 from that duo).

LOL, what? How did #38-40 feel anything like Archie?

The Archie series was never a bunch of zany craziness that didn't make sense. What the hell are you talking about?

snake
08-28-2013, 02:45 PM
LOL, what? How did #38-40 feel anything like Archie?

The Archie series was never a bunch of zany craziness that didn't make sense. What the hell are you talking about?

Cuddly The Cowlick.

Powder
08-28-2013, 04:47 PM
LOL, what? How did #38-40 feel anything like Archie?

The Archie series was never a bunch of zany craziness that didn't make sense. What the hell are you talking about?

I think he means the Archie Specials.

ToTheNines
08-28-2013, 07:55 PM
The Zulli stuff can't be retconned... it's not even canon.

Anyways, while I think the guest era stuff is cool, it must have been a chore to put up with that stuff being the monthly series for any devoted TMNT fans back then.

I actually really liked the second half of the Moo Mesa crossover, Tales #52 and #58.

As a timeline nitpick, I would have volume 4 take place further in the future. The way I have the timeline broken down, Shadow would only be 11 or 12 in the year 2001.

CyberCubed
08-30-2013, 11:17 PM
I've forgotten about a lot of the Tales V. 2 stories most likely because I've only read them like once or twice. Aside from the Rat King origin issue, I can't think of any others that I would erase from existence.

Sure a lot of those Tales stories were "just there" and not really memorable, but there wasn't anything particularly horrible about them either. They just felt like filler.

Andrew NDB
08-30-2013, 11:50 PM
What would I retcon apart from what already has been or obviously is not canon? I would zap out the Shredder Shark trilogy from Tales V2, the Leo-Radical issue from Tales V2, and... I dunno, I guess that's about it.

I could do without all the Moo Mesa stuff but none of it flies in the face of anything.

CyberCubed
08-31-2013, 12:18 AM
I would zap out the Shredder Shark trilogy from Tales V2, .

I didn't dislike that story but it really cheapened Shredder's death at the end of RTNY. They tried to play it off by saying the worms turned into a totally different creature by then (since it was merged with a shark and such), but still.

shuriken
08-31-2013, 12:42 AM
I didn't dislike that story but it really cheapened Shredder's death at the end of RTNY. They tried to play it off by saying the worms turned into a totally different creature by then (since it was merged with a shark and such), but still.

Although I enjoyed that arc it really does cheapen the physically and emotionally draining task of defeating the Shredder a second time.
The only ones I'd retcon are April's origin and the Pantheon. That one was just so bad it leaves a terrible aftertaste after reading it. UGH
The Savage Dragon Crossover was also terrible. I'd retcon that weird Hedden Mcweeny arc, although I did Enjoy Toitle anxiety quite a bit. Volume 2 was fine.
Theres so much I'd retcon in Volume 4 but if I were Laird I know I wouldn't.

Krang100
09-03-2013, 08:46 PM
I retcon the Mirage Comics Vol 4, #9. I wasn't necessary to make Stockman to henious as well, it lead to his death. Instead, i prefer Donatello would force Baxter to help April, the Baxter would be spared.

Powder
09-03-2013, 11:41 PM
So in other words "Mirage would have been better if it were more like the OT!"?

Go home.

Krang100
09-04-2013, 01:46 AM
I enjoy the comic from volume 2. I remember the Fish woman in the issue 4 and 5 who died in the end protecting her egg. I prefer the fishwoman in some way survives from the fall with its egg.

shuriken
09-04-2013, 01:53 AM
Krang100 do you know the meaning of the words erase/retcon? Not trying to sound like a dick but read the title dude (ette?).
If you want you can start your own thread on and title it "How to improve the Mirage run of the TMNT" or " My/ Your Perfect TMNT Mashup world" or whatever. Plenty of us do what you're talking about, but its usually in the fan works section.

CyberCubed
09-04-2013, 08:50 PM
Surprised nobody said #15 which introduced the Justice Force. Bringing superheroes into the Turtles world never did make much sense.

I can accept Nobody since he was just a police officer who became a vigilante, but the full superheroes like Stainless Steel Steve, Battling Bernice, Raptarr, and others were lame. Such a shame it affected the 4kids show so negatively too, with Mike's characterisation and all those episodes.

Andrew NDB
09-04-2013, 11:33 PM
Surprised nobody said #15 which introduced the Justice Force. Bringing superheroes into the Turtles world never did make much sense.

I can accept Nobody since he was just a police officer who became a vigilante, but the full superheroes like Stainless Steel Steve, Battling Bernice, Raptarr, and others were lame. Such a shame it affected the 4kids show so negatively too, with Mike's characterisation and all those episodes.

I could have done without the Justice Force too but my policy with any kind of retconning would only be to retcon away things that rubbish really good stories or fly in the face of other stuff established before it or the ideals of Kevin and/or Peter.

For me that kind of just leaves the Shredder Shark trilogy (it retroactively reduces all of Return to New York to an encounter with a confused monster who was not Oroku Saki) and the Radical-Leo thing (which Peter has said on his blog he would have vetoed himself had he been actively approving Tales V2 at that time).

Jeff
09-05-2013, 01:11 PM
Surprised nobody said #15 which introduced the Justice Force. Bringing superheroes into the Turtles world never did make much sense.

I can accept Nobody since he was just a police officer who became a vigilante, but the full superheroes like Stainless Steel Steve, Battling Bernice, Raptarr, and others were lame. Such a shame it affected the 4kids show so negatively too, with Mike's characterisation and all those episodes.

i can't disagree more. i really like the justice force, and thought that the inclusion in 4kids was great. Turtle Titan and Silver Sentry? Hell yes.

Tazi
09-05-2013, 01:27 PM
I agree with Cubed on this one. Well, I actually wouldn't mind superheroes, Nobody was great, but Justice Force was just an uninteresting ripoff/parody of JLA, and the result of it were those annoying 4kids episodes, and Mikey acting like a 5 year old fanboy.

I also agree about the Shark-Shredder issues. Sure, worm-shredder was a clone, but this shark thing, and that the worms relalised, they're a seperate person, it's kinda made Return to New York less impactful... Andrew already described this much better than me, I think.
Well, Shredder's fall at Return to New York had a very long build up, and it was the end of an era for Mirage TMNT when Leo slayed Saki finally. The Shark story wasn't that much of a great arc imo, and it doesn't worth it, to revive Shredder just for that, and basically retcon "Return to New York", for a much weaker storyline.

CyberCubed
09-05-2013, 01:35 PM
Would have been interesting if shark Shredder turned into Armaggon.

plastroncafe
09-05-2013, 01:35 PM
Haven't re-read the various volumes/series in a while, but off the top of my head the only thing I'd excise out completely is April's Origin.

I quite enjoyed all the weirdness and things that didn't quite fit in. If anything what I'd do is add more stuff to bridge the gaps where possible. Find a way to build a more solid base, and a more linear timeline.

Andrew NDB
09-05-2013, 01:47 PM
All I want to see with April's new origin is for Peter Laird to complete the character arc he began with it to give it a purpose. As is, I don't have a problem with it but... it's just, there.

CyberCubed
09-05-2013, 01:51 PM
The only thing interesting about it is if April finally fades away into the Kirby dimension like all the other drawings.

Shadow was obviously all alone in the future, so something happens to April/Casey.

Andrew NDB
09-05-2013, 02:14 PM
The only thing interesting about it is if April finally fades away into the Kirby dimension like all the other drawings.

I believe Peter Laird was specifically asked that and he said that that would not be possible since she was a Real creation of the crystal, not a pseudo one.

I dunno, I don't see the big deal about it, really. The crystal has been an accepted part of canon since the Donatello special and the Vol. 4 story doesn't make April "fake" or less human... it just makes her origin an unconventional one. It's not like anyone that was conceived as a "test tube baby" is thought of as less than a human, are they?

plastroncafe
09-05-2013, 04:30 PM
I don't like the inclusion because it strips from April one of my favorite parts of her characterization, namely that she's a normal person who finds herself in abnormal circumstances. I always did wish there was more meat to her story with the turtles, and more focus on what living on the run/off the grid entails.

She was the lab assistant to a brilliant engineer, and...we see her waiting tables in a small town Western Mass diner.

To me, her reworked origin story just felt as though Laird had no idea what to do with her. I found it lazy.

Andrew NDB
09-05-2013, 04:34 PM
namely that she's a normal person who finds herself in abnormal circumstances.

She is a normal person who finds herself in abnormal circumstances. She's not, like, superhuman or anything... she just has a different origin than you and I.

Leo656
09-05-2013, 09:00 PM
I could totally do without her being a roach during her time travel excursion where she discovered her "secret origin". I'm pretty sure that she would be traumatized after f*cking roaches and eating sh*t for however long she was inhabiting a roach body, assuming she retained most of her memories. If I thought it was gross, I'm sure she'd be pretty much broken, mentally.

Why we were forced to endure that particular part of the story, I'll never understand. They just as easily could have used "Scrooged" rules where anyone going back in time exists outside the timestream and can only observe, and saved us all that stupid, gross, pointless piece of the story. I think that soured me towards the entire origin story of her, although I still find all of it unnecessary.

Jeff
09-06-2013, 01:17 PM
I agree with Cubed on this one. Well, I actually wouldn't mind superheroes, Nobody was great, but Justice Force was just an uninteresting ripoff/parody of JLA

i can see that, but that's what makes TMNT great, no? Started off as a stupid parody of other better comics and turned into something glorious. Justice Force was fun, and thats all I expected them to be.

Tazi
09-06-2013, 01:31 PM
Dunno, they never felt entertaining to me, they felt like... uhm... filler material.

Casey worked as a parody, because he was an agressive drinker jock, who watched too much action movies, and that made him into vigilante. It was a fun concept, and later he turned into much more, a really likable character with a faulty personality.
I couldn't say the same about Justice Force, they were just generic superheroes, with generic design inspired by JLA, and obviously, they were too numerous, there were just not enough time, to really expand their characters.
(and obviously, I hated Mikey's fanboyism)
For example I wouldn't mind Silver Sentry debuting in IDW (other than on that cover, in the early issues), if they would retool the character, and would make him interesting.
...but for a group of generic superheroes? No thanks.

Jeff
09-06-2013, 01:42 PM
Dunno, they never felt entertaining to me, they felt like... uhm... filler material.

Casey worked as a parody, because he was an agressive drinker jock, who watched too much action movies, and that made him into vigilante. It was a fun concept, and later he turned into much more, a really likable character with a faulty personality.
I couldn't say the same about Justice Force, they were just generic superheroes, with generic design inspired by JLA, and obviously, they were too numerous, there were just not enough time, to really expand their characters.
(and obviously, I hated Mikey's fanboyism)
For example I wouldn't mind Silver Sentry debuting in IDW (other than on that cover, in the early issues), if they would retool the character, and would make him interesting.
...but for a group of generic superheroes? No thanks.

gotcha. thats why a lot of superhero movies don't work out. with ensemble casts its hard to give a crap about any of the characters if its not executed PERFECTLY.

CyberCubed
09-07-2013, 10:38 PM
Any issue of Tales V. 2 with influences from the cartoons:

- Mystic Foot with 4kids designs appearing in the issue Casey proposed to April

- Battle Nexus in Volume 4

- An Utrom with a Ch'rell design appears in one of the Tales issues as Don is revealing his history

- Cowboy of Moo-Mesa 4-parter


Also most of Murphies Tales issues from 2004 onward weren't very good. "Rock of Ages" he admitted was an unused Archie script.

Likewise the Raph and Don 4-issue Tales micros were both awful.

Konchadunga
09-08-2013, 03:12 PM
The Birth of Ca-Ocho. Yet another example of the "no-kill" policy and
"anger is bad" attitude I despise heroes having, plus its lesson is taught in the same piss-poor way Spider-Man 3 does--taking revenge on a murderer is wrong, as they put it, because that murderer had a sympathetic side and regrets it. That is simply not going to be the case with many murderers; isolated examples don't prove anything.

Then, the pretense got even worse when Leonardo fights Ca-Ocho, breaking his sword using only a knife, for no other apparent reason than because Leo is the "hero" and gets a morality promotion. The final insult, though, is that despite trying to build up Leo as the paragon of ethics, the only thing he does is fight Ca-Ocho and gloat about his moral superiority; he still lets him get away with killing a man, when he was in a perfect position to knock him down, tie him up, and leave him for the police.

I thought the Mirage series was better than that. I like that its turtles can see the value of killing people.

Cipher
09-08-2013, 06:17 PM
The Birth of Ca-Ocho. Yet another example of the "no-kill" policy and
"anger is bad" attitude I despise heroes having, plus its lesson is taught in the same piss-poor way Spider-Man 3 does--taking revenge on a murderer is wrong, as they put it, because that murderer had a sympathetic side and regrets it. That is simply not going to be the case with many murderers; isolated examples don't prove anything.

Then, the pretense got even worse when Leonardo fights Ca-Ocho, breaking his sword using only a knife, for no other apparent reason than because Leo is the "hero" and gets a morality promotion. The final insult, though, is that despite trying to build up Leo as the paragon of ethics, the only thing he does is fight Ca-Ocho and gloat about his moral superiority; he still lets him get away with killing a man, when he was in a perfect position to knock him down, tie him up, and leave him for the police.

I thought the Mirage series was better than that. I like that its turtles can see the value of killing people.
Did you miss two of the key points of this issue? One being that Leonardo specifically says he's learned the pointlessness of revenge after seeing all the pain it brought them (his post-"City at War" characterization), and the second being that Cha Ocho makes a bunch of condemnations about Leo's moral superiority, sheltered life and narrow world view at the end that are completely dead-on and that the story never refutes.

Give it another look; the story hardly moralizes. I'd rank it as one of the must-reads of Tales Vol. 2.

EDIT --

And really, do you want it to actively support the idea that killing for revenge is awesome? The Turtles spend the better part of their lives believing that to be the case and it brings them and their friends nothing but pain. Cha Ocho initially feels relieved at having killed his wife's killer, but it doesn't lessen his misery one bit. Both of those are more real approaches than just being like, "Yeah! Awesome!" Killing is a serious thing. An eye for an eye is a serious thing. The story gives us a character who's learned that through trial and error, but who still isn't the moral paragon he thinks he is.

shuriken
09-09-2013, 05:58 PM
Did you miss two of the key points of this issue? One being that Leonardo specifically says he's learned the pointlessness of revenge after seeing all the pain it brought them (his post-"City at War" characterization), and the second being that Cha Ocho makes a bunch of condemnations about Leo's moral superiority, sheltered life and narrow world view at the end that are completely dead-on and that the story never refutes.

Give it another look; the story hardly moralizes. I'd rank it as one of the must-reads of Tales Vol. 2.

EDIT --

And really, do you want it to actively support the idea that killing for revenge is awesome? The Turtles spend the better part of their lives believing that to be the case and it brings them and their friends nothing but pain. Cha Ocho initially feels relieved at having killed his wife's killer, but it doesn't lessen his misery one bit. Both of those are more real approaches than just being like, "Yeah! Awesome!" Killing is a serious thing. An eye for an eye is a serious thing. The story gives us a character who's learned that through trial and error, but who still isn't the moral paragon he thinks he is.

This was one of my fave Tales Vol 2 books.

Coola Yagami
09-09-2013, 07:15 PM
Any issue of Tales V. 2 with influences from the cartoons:

- Mystic Foot with 4kids designs appearing in the issue Casey proposed to April

- Battle Nexus in Volume 4

- An Utrom with a Ch'rell design appears in one of the Tales issues as Don is revealing his history

- Cowboy of Moo-Mesa 4-parter


Also most of Murphies Tales issues from 2004 onward weren't very good. "Rock of Ages" he admitted was an unused Archie script.

Likewise the Raph and Don 4-issue Tales micros were both awful.

Naw, you trippin with the Battle Nexus. That was actually a cool part of Volume 4 and should have been seen to its end. And seeing this Oroku Yoshi character was awesome. Just remove his stupid 2K3 kids Shredder design.

One thing I would retcon from Vol 4/Tales 2 is turning Mikey into what Andrew calls 'dudeMikeyTM, It's like they finally gave in to peer pressure from outside media and said 'the hell with it. Let's throw in some surfer slang chillax duuuude'.

Lord Nightwalker
09-09-2013, 09:25 PM
I don't believe I would retcon anything.The stories that I didn't consider cannon are just that, entertaining stories. Certainly I preferred some over others, In particular the more serious elements over some of the sillier stuff, but I still enjoyed reading it. The genre breaking aspect of the turtles is one of their biggest assets, They can fit into just about any combination of story elements.
And I believe the comics really drove that home.

jbeeman85
09-19-2013, 11:23 AM
I would get rid of the Haunted Pizza story and all the ones that were drawn in that same style. I didn't like the over the top obsurdity of it.