View Full Version : In retrospect, was Tales v. 2 (2004-2010) actually good?
CyberCubed
09-07-2013, 10:42 PM
Back when the second volume of Tales was coming out I remember a lot of people preferring it to Volume 4. But did we like it back then simply because we were getting new TMNT comics not connected to Volume 4's ongoing, or because they were actually good comics?
I've been going through my Tales V. 2 collection recently and I realized why I didn't remember many of the stories......many of them simply weren't all that good or memorable. I loved Tristan, Dan Berger's and some of Lawson's issues...but when they were bad...they were really bad. A lot of Murphy's stuff especially fell kind of flat.
Any thoughts on this? The series lasted a whopping 70 issues plus the 16 issues of the Turtle micro's...so it was the longest lasting Mirage run ever.
Cipher
09-07-2013, 10:48 PM
Ranged from mediocre to wonderfully subversive. I always felt they were worth the cover price, which I can't say for a lot of comics. Many of the best issues of the entire Mirage series are in this run.
There are definitely some that I could never recommend to non-fans, though, just based on how mired in the continuity of a twenty-year-old, previously very difficult to read, series they are. The book was at its worst when trying to fill in those holes as well, a la "Mind Games" and a few others.
Coola Yagami
09-07-2013, 11:22 PM
The Hun stories were awesome. I also liked two Shadow issues, one when she was a kid starting school, and one as an adult in a messed up future. It is depressing that she isn't even an old woman, just a normal adult... so the world goes to hell by the time she hits adulthood??? Depressing.
Although I didn't think much about the April being and drawing deal... but the issue about her dealing with it was really cool for me. I also loved the one of the TMNT's normal life sometime before TMNT issue 1 and the one that dealt with a random Foot Ninja's life.
Powder
09-07-2013, 11:53 PM
Many of the best issues of the entire Mirage series are in this run.
This is all I have to say. :)
DrSpengler
09-08-2013, 12:01 AM
We got a lot of great stories out of it. Some crap, too, but that's how anthologies go.
I think if anything hurt Tales Vol. 2 it would be the lack of dedication or direction from the editors. Storylines would be introduced and then summarily dropped with no resolution. If you're going to start a plot then you need to see it through to the end, you can't just leave a cliffhanger unresolved because you don't "feel like" telling the rest of the story. That's rather unfair to your audience.
It could be very frustrating, especially considering Tales Vol. 2 was the sister title to TMNT Vol. 4, another book that had trouble finishing anything it started. It was a rather... ungratifying time to be reading TMNT comics, all things considered.
THAT SAID, when Tales Vol. 2 hit gold, it struck it rich. Some of my favorites are in there running an impressive gamut of styles and genres (comedies, dramas, horror stories, straight action adventures and so forth). For all the stories it started and never finished, it also gave us closure and interesting followups on long lingering threads from older volumes.
And on an industry level, the fact that the title existed to give new, hungry talent an opportunity to show their work and put a big name franchise on their resume is truly commendable. Wasn't Tales Vol. 2 Rick Remender's first gig? Things have worked out pretty well for him, since. And Dario Brizuela's been popping up everywhere since Tales Vol. 2.
So yeah, looking at Tales Vol. 2, there are things about it that get on my nerves, but I don't think the negative necessarily outweighs the positive, either. For every contemptible dud like "The Value of Gold" or "The Pantheon", there were a good two or three modern classics like "The Path", "Cold, Cold Ice" and "Dark Shadows" to wash the taste away. And even the more middling issues like "Schooled" are still highly enjoyable.
Cipher
09-08-2013, 11:36 AM
there were a good two or three modern classics like "The Path", "Cold, Cold Ice" and "Dark Shadows" to wash the taste away.
No "Scars," "Blind Faith," "A Day in the Life"? I think the list of seminal Mirage issues in the volume runs higher than two or three.
DrSpengler
09-08-2013, 01:40 PM
No "Scars," "Blind Faith," "A Day in the Life"? I think the list of seminal Mirage issues in the volume runs higher than two or three.
Wha?
I didn't say there were *only* 2 or 3 good stories in Tales, but that for every bad one, there were 2 or 3 good ones.
Leo656
09-08-2013, 01:57 PM
At the very least, it was more fun to read than Vol. 4. I'd say it was better overall. I kind of consider Tales to be the "main" book and Vol. 4 to mostly be some kind of "What If" book, since nothing ever really got resolved anyway.
I really didn't care for Vol. 4 but Tales always made me feel good about buying and reading it.
Cipher
09-08-2013, 02:07 PM
Wha?
I didn't say there were *only* 2 or 3 good stories in Tales, but that for every bad one, there were 2 or 3 good ones.
Oh, woops. Reading comprehension. Difficult.
CyberCubed
09-08-2013, 11:33 PM
I actually rather liked all the Shadow stories in Tales, except for the one with the werewolf's. That whole goth phase Shadow went through in her teens was a turnoff.
But aside from that, I enjoyed all the stories where Shadow was either a kid or an adult.
Coola Yagami
09-09-2013, 05:31 PM
I actually rather liked all the Shadow stories in Tales, except for the one with the werewolf's. That whole goth phase Shadow went through in her teens was a turnoff.
But aside from that, I enjoyed all the stories where Shadow was either a kid or an adult.
I kinda liked her goth phase... mostly that it was a phase. Kinda shows she went through a lot, from perky blonde, to goth chick, to bad-ass ninja.
Blossombrooks
09-09-2013, 06:02 PM
^Agreed, I thought it made her more relatable.
Didn't really enjoy the one with Shadow and Raph in the Catacombs tho, that never grabbed me but on the whole I loved the Tales run.
raphael_is_cool
09-10-2013, 04:42 PM
Funnily enough, I've been rereading these recently. Only got up to about #32 or so (and missing a couple in he 20s). Honestly, I've probably only really enjoyed about half of them. I can't remember names but I really liked Lawson's work with Blind Sight and the Krunk one, and there have been others that felt close to what I remember of the 'classic' Mirage style. Really disliked the Shadow stories I read, outside of the 'protective uncle' Raphael angle anyway.
Otherwise, there are just a load where it felt like the ninja turtles themselves were just guest stars and the plots really went nowhere. It was probably that way for many old comics before though, so what do I know? :tconfuse:
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.