View Full Version : Anyone thinking of switching from singles to trades for the main IDW?
CyberCubed
09-15-2013, 04:06 PM
I have all the single IDW comics up to now but what I realize is this series is much more enjoyable when read in batches or collections than singles. Sometimes with single issues I don't feel as satisfied since its only 22 pages but when read with the other issues it gets much better.
Not to mention the trades save space when stored. What I do wonder is how far the trades are behind the main ongoing and how delayed I will be reading the story from everyone else.
Anyone thinking of doing this? IDW TMNT feels like collections work better.
The Fifth Turtle
09-15-2013, 04:18 PM
I have all the single IDW comics up to now but what I realize is this series is much more enjoyable when read in batches or collections than singles. Sometimes with single issues I don't feel as satisfied since its only 22 pages but when read with the other issues it gets much better.
Not to mention the trades save space when stored. What I do wonder is how far the trades are behind the main ongoing and how delayed I will be reading the story from everyone else.
Anyone thinking of doing this? IDW TMNT feels like collections work better.
After selling my entire tmnt comic collection and making a butt load of money I felt bad not having the stories. I decided to get the trades and Im very happy with my decision. I just hope we end up getting complete volumes. I'd hate to have like 3/4 of say the Archie series and they give up. So here's to hoping they keep pumping these suckers out while the turtles are hot.
Redrumh2o
09-15-2013, 05:13 PM
That's what I have done....and what I have done with the walking dead for years....plus they look great on a shelf. Sure I am a little behind but its fun to read a bunch at once...plus they are so cheap on Amazon
Cipher
09-15-2013, 05:20 PM
Started that way, switched to singles, thinking about switching back.
Have already switched back for the micro-series issues.
Master Splinter
09-15-2013, 05:34 PM
Nope, I plan on sticking with the singles.
-ms
Powder
09-15-2013, 07:31 PM
Nope, I plan on sticking with the singles.
-ms
Likewise. While I like the idea of trades, it bugs me that they're grouped by number & series rather than order of continuity. Plus I enjoy letters columns, adverts, & being up to date. People aren't too considerate about spoilers.
Toby Barrett
09-15-2013, 07:43 PM
I had already switched to tpbs due to it being easier on me. Hunting down issues out of town was a tremendous waste of gas.
Ordering the books online just makes more sense, and they're sturdier too.
Cipher
09-15-2013, 07:57 PM
Likewise. While I like the idea of trades, it bugs me that they're grouped by number & series rather than order of continuity. Plus I enjoy letters columns, adverts, & being up to date. People aren't too considerate about spoilers.
The trick to being a collected-edition reader is to not care about spoilers. I go by the philosophy that if a series isn't still worth reading after hearing spoilers, it wasn't worth reading to begin with.
Or, the quality is in the execution.
Or, to quote Kurt Vonnegut: "To hell with suspense."
I always prefer trades or hardcovers for comics-reading, so I reserve single issues for series I really enjoy or want to financially support as much as possible (and I'm still doing that for the main IDW Turtles series). But even then, I plan on selling off my singles in bulk once the corresponding trades come out
Powder
09-15-2013, 08:04 PM
Why should I not care? For most readers that's the point... Many of us had the entirety of Mirage brought to our attention before we read it, but this book gives us a fresh start. I'll be damned if I'm not gonna enjoy that the way it's meant to be enjoyed.
funatic
09-15-2013, 08:49 PM
I've often considered making the switch, especially because the trades collect most of the covers in the back, and the "which cover do I choose" dilemma becomes an embarrassingly big one every month, especially if I don't wind up with my preferred cover at my LCS and have to track it down by other means, but I digress...
I don't think I can quit the single issues - I love the immediacy and the ground zero support for one of my favorite franchises. Trade sales don't keep a comic series in production, issue sales do, so it feels good to do my part, even if the single issue prices often seem a bit higher than what they're worth. I think I'm also still in the groove of the old Mirage days where the comic book was often the only format you'd ever see produced! Plus, it's nice to have the letter columns there too.
I hope that they release some sort of omnibuses (omnibi?) in the future collecting a good chunk of the trades in hardcover. They'd be a different enough format from the singles to warrant a double-dip, and I agree this series reads better arc to arc rather than issue to issue.
Plasticplayhouse
09-15-2013, 09:03 PM
i love the singles. i like my tmnt unspoiled and this makes it easier. plus, it just gives my monthly fix :D i am thinking about picking up the trades too. i can finger through the trades and keep my singles nice and pretty ;)
Fourcylinder
09-15-2013, 09:13 PM
I never had a chance to collect comics when I was a kid, so when I saw that there was a new tmnt series out I knew I wanted to collect the issues as they were released. I have not regretted it at all. Sure, its a little more expensive, and yeah you don't get the full story arc all in one book, but I think the experience of having that monthly cliff hanger is part of what makes comics worth reading! To me, getting singles is part of the comic collecting experience, and I certainly intend to stick with it!
Candy Kappa
09-16-2013, 12:57 AM
I buy the floppies my LCS gets and the rest over comixology.
Rat_King
09-16-2013, 07:22 AM
I will always get one of every TMNT printing to be complete but I have decided to sell all of my DC singles and switch to trades. The single issues just take up too much space that I need for my ever expanding turtles. To avoid spoilers with Walking Dead, I buy the individual issues to be up to date and then sell the story arcs when the trades come out.
Red Mask
09-16-2013, 08:42 AM
I got into this comic a little late, so I got trades to catch up- I see your point that it's more gratifying to read the whole arc at once.
But now that I'm issue to issue, I love that I have something to look forward to each month, and I really wanna help contribute to their monthly sales. For me, the good outweighs the bad when you buy each issue.
I'm loving having a micro, an Animated Adventures and the main ongoing to look forward to each month- one for almost each week. It's pretty much my entertainment budget for the month. It's a bit tough doing that and trying to save up for the Ultimate Collections at the same time, though.
Redeemer
09-16-2013, 09:17 AM
i love the singles. i like my tmnt unspoiled and this makes it easier. plus, it just gives my monthly fix :D
Exactly!!!!!!!!!!
DrSpengler
09-16-2013, 09:25 AM
Nah.
I write for Adventures in Poor Taste, so I get advanced review PDFs of most IDW titles, including TMNT. But even then, I still buy the singles. Most comics live and die by how the monthly issues sell and I want to show my financial support.
And just for personal matters of space, it's easier for me to store singles in stacked long boxes than to try and find bookshelf space for trades. My apartment isn't cramped or anything, but I can only have so many book shelves.
Coola Yagami
09-16-2013, 02:02 PM
Singles. I can't wait until all if city fall is over and then buy the trades. I only bought two trades cause I missed a lot of issues when I moved out of town and had to get a new job, get my finances built up and find a new LCS. But singles all the way.
corvus
09-16-2013, 02:29 PM
I'm too into Idw to wait. as it is, I buy all the comics on comixology the morning they come out. I'd do it at midnight(since I'm awake with nothing to do) but they're not up til like nine.
shuriken
09-16-2013, 03:06 PM
I was thinking about doing that too. I've been thinking about selling some of my earlier issues and just getting the trades. The letters and art are neat but they are a far more enjoyable read in sets.
Sabacooza
09-16-2013, 03:21 PM
I thought about getting the trades instead of the singles but I'm a pretty impatient person so that just wouldn't work for me. I may just pick up the trades as well just because of the nicer presentation.
CyberCubed
09-16-2013, 04:50 PM
That's what I notice, I'm generally not "as excited" reading IDW month after month because the story moves slowly when you only read one issue at a time.
This series is designed to be read in arcs, one issue a month barely moving the story forward is hard.
Sabacooza
09-16-2013, 05:12 PM
That's what I notice, I'm generally not "as excited" reading IDW month after month because the story moves slowly when you only read one issue at a time.
This series is designed to be read in arcs, one issue a month barely moving the story forward is hard.
I agree. it would be nice to sit down and read the story arc in full but if you skip the singles and wait for the trades, the wait is excruciating.
Andrew NDB
09-16-2013, 05:21 PM
The solution is clearly to travel to the future when the IDW series is completed, collect them all, and then travel back to the past.
Sabacooza
09-16-2013, 05:25 PM
That could work. Now, where do we get a time machine?
Heather Breckel
09-16-2013, 08:19 PM
TMNT I get singles+the trades. I prefer the format of trades, but I like to keep up to date too. Most series I do follow strictly through trades though.
Cipher
09-16-2013, 08:37 PM
TMNT I get singles+the trades. I prefer the format of trades, but I like to keep up to date too. Most series I do follow strictly through trades though.
Stop it, Heather! You're ruining your industry!
CyberCubed
09-16-2013, 10:39 PM
IDW TMNT simply doesn't work in 22 page formats. I know there's nothing they can do about it due to costs but I think that's why some people lost interest in the series...one short continuing story a month isn't that satisfying.
I just wish there was some way the trades wouldn't be so far behind.
BODYCOUNT
09-16-2013, 11:05 PM
just picked up the Secret History of the Foot Clan in TPB. Now because i got a late start i have to search the net to buy City fall. i got a few but im missing 21 22 24. i think imma wait till it drops next month
Andrew NDB
09-16-2013, 11:11 PM
IDW TMNT simply doesn't work in 22 page formats. I know there's nothing they can do about it
They can do shorter story arcs and a few "done in one" kind of stories.
Heather Breckel
09-17-2013, 12:00 AM
Stop it, Heather! You're ruining your industry!
I only have so much shelf space! haha I live in a pretty small 1 bedroom apartment, so I only have room for so much stuff.
Leo656
09-17-2013, 12:26 AM
I do like the ease of having and reading trades, but I also enjoy sitting down with a stack of books 20 or 30 deep, having a cold beer or two, cracking my knuckles and digging in for a long weekend afternoon. It was fun when I was 8 and it's still fun. I love to sit down and say "this is gonna be a project" over a stack of comics. Having a couple trades doesn't feel quite the same. Especially with old books. There's a certain irreplaceable romantic quality about the scent of aged newsprint of decades-old comic books. Especially badly-lettered '70s books where the inking was too thick and you can't tell Ps from Ts and Is from Js unless you squint. I love that sh*t.
Some stories I do collect both singles and trades, but most of my TMNT stuff is singles. I can't collect monthly right now for financial reasons, but my store holds certain books for me and I pick up a few times a year in big chunks, like when I was a kid. I prefer monthly or better weekly trips, but right now I can't. But it's cool to drop $100 on a stack, come home, and blow a Saturday reading all of them at once. I mostly only get TPBs for books I have a hard time tracking down, or stuff so old I can't afford it. The few TMNT issues I'm missing are still within my budget; I'd rather have a complete singles run (minus variants, I'm not insane) than a couple TPBs, especially since I'm only missing a few at this point.
DaVinci
09-20-2013, 04:02 PM
I wish I could get singles, but they're not reliably available where I live.
I particularly wanted a full set of Santolouco covers for City Fall, but all I have is #23.
So, it's already trades for me.
Lord Nightwalker
09-20-2013, 05:12 PM
I will buy both. Always do. I read the issue, save it, and then go back and reread the complete story in the trades. over and over. I like to take the trades on trips and such.
Martin
09-20-2013, 07:16 PM
Singles and trades here. Though I might drop the singles eventually since it's ridiculously expensive to get all that stuff shipped down here, plus is quite possible that a couple of shipments that were recently sent to me have gotten lost somewhere along the way. I get my trades on amazon so shipping for those is actually quite reasonable.
CyberCubed
09-26-2013, 09:22 PM
I've honestly grown bored with following the series monthly so I think I'm pretty much going with trades now. I realized after not buying any issues for like 3 months that I didn't feel like I was missing anything special or so important that I needed it as soon as it came.
I'm probably going to stick with trades now. The series is more enjoyable that way, and to be blunt, if I wasn't such a hardcore TMNT fan I probably wouldn't be following the series in the first place.
I'll go with the trades for IDW, because the single issues can no longer hold my interest.
Mr._Mutant_Man
10-06-2013, 09:08 AM
Still getting the single issues and don't plan on changing. TMNT is one of the few books I still look forward to every month. Unless it becomes difficult to get to the LCS on a monthly basis, I don't see myself making a switch.
They can do shorter story arcs and a few "done in one" kind of stories.
I think that applies to the comic industry as a whole. There are a ton of story arcs that get padded just to sell a trade. I wouldn't mind a graphic novel that had multiple stories in it. There are a ton of trades that are like that, so I don't get the logic of always writing with the TPB in mind.
CyberCubed
10-06-2013, 12:55 PM
I've really gotten bored of the singles but I don't want to lose interest in the story.
discordiatookie
10-06-2013, 04:18 PM
Singles for me. I used to collect both but my priorities with money have fairly recently changed so I'm only getting the singles nowadays. The only IDW trade I've picked up was the first deluxe book, and it was because it collected Eastman's layouts. Unless it's got spectacular extras, I can no longer justify buying the same story twice, and I much prefer the individual comics than the trades.
I can't say I've ever gotten bored with waiting for next month's issue to be released - it kinda comes with the territory of buying monthlies...
Bossa Nova
10-06-2013, 05:19 PM
I only ever buy trades. Sure, waiting for them to be released gets kinda old after awhile, but I'm not so hellbent on seeing what happens that I can't wait. The trades just feel more satisfying to read, plus they look nicer on my shelf-like an actual collection of books and not a pile of magazines. I think if maybe there was a physical shop nearby that actually sold the singles in person I might be more willing to purchase them, but since I buy them all online I'd just much rather go for the trades instead.
Blossombrooks
10-06-2013, 06:49 PM
I buy the singles digitally day of release, I can't wait! But as there are no comic book shops near me I buy trades when I can, they're easier to get hold of here and like Nova says, they look great on the shelf. It also means I still get to have a physical copy, digital is good but nothing beats a comic you can hold in your hand. If it was financially viable for me to get the singles in print I would though.
milesflex
10-21-2013, 09:23 PM
I started out buying only TPBs, like I do with other comics. But I really liked so many of the covers, I wanted to display several on the wall. I was buying so many covers I liked, I decided just to collect (at least) one of each. Now, I buy both the TPBs and single issues. It is the only comic I do that with, and it is also the only one I'm caught up on reading.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.