View Full Version : Do you think the Nick cartoon will or has influenced the IDW comics?
Andrew NDB
09-30-2013, 03:08 PM
Not in the sense of Nickelodeon giving the IDW guys heads up about whats to come or telling them what they need to include (as I'm pretty sure that's not what's going on), but more in the sense of... you know, let's say -- as an example -- IDW planned to make Baxter into a fly at some point, but then they learned along with the rest of us that Nickelodeon is going to be doing the same thing on the show.
Would that then influence IDW to reverse course on that, or do you feel that would rather make them go full steam ahead with it? Would they just kind of shrug and mentally block out what Nick is doing and just let the chips fall wherever they were planning anyway? I'm pretty sure Ciro and Nick can't be bothered about what IDW is or isn't doing (they're running a multimillion dollar cartoon for a major network tied to toys and merch), but I'm wondering what the flip side of it might be at IDW.
And last question: how conscious should IDW be of the Nickelodeon cartoon, or should they at all?
DrSpengler
09-30-2013, 03:38 PM
Well, the IDW comic began before the Nick series did with little frame of reference as to what Nick was going to do; it's series mythology, characterization and relationships are wildly different from what Nick is doing. I just don't see the IDW series as really giving a hoot what the Nick series is up to.
I mean like or hate New Animated Adventures, that title works to absorb any corporate demand for a comic version that reflects the current cartoon version, freeing IDW's ongoing series to do whatever it wants. Likewise, I'm sure it satisfies any personal desires from a creative team to "keep it consistent with the cartoon" rather than any corporate decrees, too.
Looking at the IDW series, I honestly haven't detected any influences, large or small, from the Nick cartoon even a year after that series has been on the air. So I'm not too concerned with anything like that happening in the future.
On the surface, one might think Santolouco giving each Turtle a unique look in terms of their physique is a concession to the Nick series models. But even then, his renderings don't reflect Nick's (no freckles on Mikey or tooth gap on Donnie, etc). And having looked at Santolouco's older stuff on DA, he was making the TMNT physically distinct long before any Nick influences could have been felt.
Would I *like* to see concepts from the Nick cartoon adapted into the IDW ongoing? I dunno, maybe. But only if it felt organic (ie; if all of a sudden Donnie was madly in love with April with no catalyst, THAT would feel terribly inorganic).
The Nick cartoon is still young and we should probably give it some more time to actually develop ITS OWN concepts before other media like the IDW ongoing jumps the gun and begins integrating said concepts.
corvus
09-30-2013, 04:10 PM
Almost all the incarnations of TMNT have influence on each other.
raphael_is_cool
09-30-2013, 04:25 PM
I know Santolouco mentioned that he was told by Nickelodeon to make subtle changes to his turtle designs, though I think he'd already chosen to incorporate some of the animated series' features (body shape differences, Donnie's gap tooth), so I know there is some sort of supervision going on.
Writing-wise, I could see why it's useful for Nickelodeon to offer a 'heads-up' but from what I understood, Waltz & co. have 4-5 years' worth of stuff mapped out before the show began. Given the way things are developing and being built on, it would be counterproductive to make unanticipated changes.
Andrew NDB
09-30-2013, 04:54 PM
Beyond some design approvals stuff (and it's a little weird to me that they'd even bother themselves with that, but whatever... you spend 63 million dollars to acquire a thing I guess you bought the right to do so) I don't think Nick is doing much with the IDW books aside from saying "No" to a lot of things.
What I'm really talking about/asking is if IDW is being reactionary to anything Nickelodeon is doing, and if not... should they be.
raphael_is_cool
09-30-2013, 05:01 PM
Well, like I said, if they've got a lot planned out I don't think they would or should pay any attention to what the Nick show is doing.
While I like both, they're different enough that even some of the shared touchstones/established history would be handled in unique ways.
Crabfight
09-30-2013, 05:35 PM
Kinda torn on question 2. I'd like the universes to be separate for the sake of a larger variety of interesting stories, each keeping their respective audiences in mind.
That being said, if IDW is doing a careful job in planning its series (which, love or hate 'em, it definitely seems like they are), then I don't want them to change anything in their vision due to fear of redundancy. I would, instead, hope that the variety I seek would come from IDW's more sophisticated or mature approach to the same scenario.
My two cents!
***First of Two Latin Kings***
09-30-2013, 05:46 PM
I don't ncessarily think it should. The IDW series is already far more infested with mutants than it should be. Can you imagine FishFace and DogPound showing up next? Snakeweed could be interesting, but it is a very slippery slope. Besides, the whole point of the IDW book is to reference what came before, whereas the Nick show incorporates a lot of new characters.
DrSpengler
09-30-2013, 06:29 PM
What I'm really talking about/asking is if IDW is being reactionary to anything Nickelodeon is doing, and if not... should they be.
If you mean that IDW is either adopting ideas to align themselves with Nick or rejecting ideas to differentiate themselves from Nick, then I don't think I see it either way. (Well, aside from Santolouco's character redesigns, which others have pointed out really WERE done to marginally align with Nick's models, which I didn't know)
It's more that, well, the major concepts that set Nick TMNT apart from other incarnations are almost entirely incompatible with what IDW has already established. Like, even if IDW *wanted* to import some of the major Nick ideas, they've already written their characters into a place where that would be impossible.
General Krang cannot be anything like Kraang Prime because they've already setup General Krang's appearance and back story.
Likewise, Sgt. Tragg cannot be anything like Traag because IDW beat Nick to the punch of establishing their version of the character.
Slash may end up befriending the Turtles at the rate his character is changing in IDW, but I don't see that lugnut suddenly acting like the Feldmesiter and having bro times with Raph.
Isn't April's dad dead in IDW, too? So that rules out whatever Nick's been doing with Kirby O'Neil.
And then there's Nick Karai and IDW Karai... no WAY to make those two align in terms of parentage.
And so on. IDW got a head start on Nick and plotted out its characters and storylines years in advance. If they HAVE been changing anything fundamental in reaction to Nick, it's all been very subtle.
As Corvus pointed out, though, just about all incarnations of TMNT have absorbed and adapted elements from other incarnations. IDW on its own feels like an "Ultimate TMNT", bringing in characters and concepts from Mirage, Fred Wolf and 4Kids. I'm sure more obvious elements of Nick will eventually show up, but they haven't yet.
Regarding IDW ditching ideas so as to keep from being too similar to Nick... I really don't think anyone here but Waltz or Curnow are privileged enough to comment on that.
Shark_Blade
09-30-2013, 06:43 PM
IMO IDW takes influence on the OT more than anything, which is all good for me. :tcool:
They don't parallel their universe with Nick (for example, Karai being Miwa and all that jazz).
Lord Nightwalker
09-30-2013, 07:51 PM
Honestly Andrew, I had hoped that any info on Nicks part would only affect the cartoon based comic. I would rather IDWs' main title carve it's own path. But I am sure they are aware of one another to some degree. Hopefully Viacom doesn't get to greedy and try to reign IDW in.
ToTheNines
09-30-2013, 09:18 PM
What I'm really talking about/asking is if IDW is being reactionary to anything Nickelodeon is doing, and if not... should they be.
I say hell yes. The IDW title kind of prides its self on being a combination of all things TMNT, (mostly) picking and choosing the coolest stuff from each different version and making it their own, all while bringing in brand new ideas too.
So the Nicktoon shouldn't be left out of that just because it's current.
Main thing I'd like to see someday would be Bradford and Xever, but keep them humans.
Coola Yagami
09-30-2013, 09:45 PM
IMO doing stuff having April dress like an adult version of 2012 April and having Don and Leo use the same straps they do in the shown should kinda be enough reference to the new show for a while. It's letting the comic do it's own thing, while giving a little acknowledging nod to the new series. I kinda don't wanna randomly see Chris, Xever, Snakeweed, etc just suddenly crammed in there for no reason.
CyberCubed
09-30-2013, 10:49 PM
I'd like to see IDW take a crap character with an awful design like Spidebitez and somehow make it work.
Good god would that be a challenge.
Leo656
09-30-2013, 10:58 PM
So far I haven't seen any new or unique ideas from the Nick show that would be worth incorporating or expanding into IDW or any other TMNT-verse. All they could really do to make them closer is add some of the Nick mutants, and as others have said there's already a bunch of mutants in IDW. It's not really necessary. I say keep them separate, at least until some of the Nick show's ideas are shown to have staying power.
Lord Nightwalker
10-01-2013, 05:24 PM
I'd like to see IDW take a crap character with an awful design like Spidebitez and somehow make it work.
Good god would that be a challenge.
Now that would be cool.
Powder
10-01-2013, 05:31 PM
I'd love to see IDW use a character or two without fear, there's no reason not to. Spiderbitez (maybe with a new name) & Snakeweed especially.
Coola Yagami
10-01-2013, 09:40 PM
Spiderbytes will be a tough sell. What reason do IDW Shredder and Karai have to capture a middle-age fatass and turn him into a mutant spider? Plus he'd have to look like a mutant spider... not a pokemon...
A mutant spider might work.. but not Spiderbytes... Similar to how we got a mutant ninja fox that wasn't Ninjara.
PApagreg
10-01-2013, 10:01 PM
I would love to see a non mutant Xever
Powder
10-01-2013, 10:57 PM
What reason do IDW Shredder and Karai have to capture a middle-age fatass and turn him into a mutant spider? Plus he'd have to look like a mutant spider... not a pokemon...
Your logic is flawed. Who says he has to be the same old dude? Hun is Casey's dad for Gods sake.The turtles are reincarnated children from Japan. Obviously things can play out differently. I'm sure it could be done.
& he looks NOTHING like a Pokemon-
http://i39.tinypic.com/10qlbp5.png
Bobby Curnow
10-01-2013, 11:30 PM
Nick has asked us not to do anything with the Nicktoon in the IDW universe. They'd prefer to keep the 'adult' separate from the more kid-centric cartoon. They definitely didn't ask Mateus to alter his character designs, that was actually a point of minor contention, but one they were ultimately cool with.
I found all of this out as I wanted to show a failed mutation— a half man/half pigeon who died during mutation, that would have been an homage to Pigeon Pete. They asked that we please not do that. I understand their logic, so it was cool on my end. I'd love for our universe to embrace and incorporate all forms of TMNT, but I get it. Maybe one day.
Venom
10-01-2013, 11:34 PM
I found all of this out as I wanted to show a failed mutation— a half man/half pigeon who died during mutation, that would have been an homage to Pigeon Pete.
Do an homage to Guerilla Gorilla instead then! :trazz: Or, or, have an arachnid-like dude with spider-arms for a double-homage (Spidey and Spyderbytes).
On another note, perhaps whoever this Nick source is needs to see where the IDW TMNT comic is shelved/solicited/promoted - as an "all-ages/kids comic". Shoot, Bleeding Cool featured it nicely in their kid-friendly comic magazine spotlight.
Erg, it's about as goofy as seeing the Mirage reprints labeled as "intended for mature readers".
Powder
10-01-2013, 11:43 PM
Nick has asked us not to do anything with the Nicktoon in the IDW universe. They'd prefer to keep the 'adult' separate from the more kid-centric cartoon. They definitely didn't ask Mateus to alter his character designs, that was actually a point of minor contention, but one they were ultimately cool with.
I found all of this out as I wanted to show a failed mutation— a half man/half pigeon who died during mutation, that would have been an homage to Pigeon Pete. They asked that we please not do that. I understand their logic, so it was cool on my end. I'd love for our universe to embrace and incorporate all forms of TMNT, but I get it. Maybe one day.
Damn, as a major fan of the Nick series that is a HUGE bummer to me. At the very least we can think of the turtles' designs as reference to the Nick-verse, but still... I'd love more. & that nod to Pete would've been pretty funny, I think!
On another note, perhaps whoever this Nick source is needs to see where the IDW TMNT comic is shelved/solicited/promoted - as an "all-ages/kids comic". Shoot, Bleeding Cool featured it nicely in their kid-friendly comic magazine spotlight.
Erg, it's about as goofy as seeing the Mirage reprints labeled as "intended for mature readers".
I couldn't agree more. While I do understand their POV, it's not like they'd let the IDW team do anything adult to the point where it'd be a terrible thing for kids to see. As it is, the book is low on blood and when there's any at all it's black, not red. & heck, including stuff from that world could possibly draw in some of the nostalgia blind guys who refuse to give the new show a shot. :tsad:
Andrew NDB
10-02-2013, 01:15 PM
Nick has asked us not to do anything with the Nicktoon in the IDW universe. They'd prefer to keep the 'adult' separate from the more kid-centric cartoon. They definitely didn't ask Mateus to alter his character designs, that was actually a point of minor contention, but one they were ultimately cool with.
I found all of this out as I wanted to show a failed mutation— a half man/half pigeon who died during mutation, that would have been an homage to Pigeon Pete. They asked that we please not do that. I understand their logic, so it was cool on my end. I'd love for our universe to embrace and incorporate all forms of TMNT, but I get it. Maybe one day.
Interesting. What do you think they would say if you one day tried to do a crossover between IDW TMNT and Nicktoon TMNT in comic book form?
Whatswiththeheadbands?
10-02-2013, 01:26 PM
Your logic is flawed. Who says he has to be the same old dude? Hun is Casey's dad for Gods sake.The turtles are reincarnated children from Japan. Obviously things can play out differently. I'm sure it could be done.
& he looks NOTHING like a Pokemon-
http://i39.tinypic.com/10qlbp5.png
looks like a Pokemon from a creepypasta
Andrew NDB
10-02-2013, 01:33 PM
Or a Goombah. That is literally the most uninspired design I've seen in the Nicktoon... there are literally a million ways they could have gone with a mutant spider that could have been both striking and visually horrifying.
Dunno, the Nick show is not bad, but right now I feel like every good characters from Nick are already present in IDW, well except Mutagen Man. Mutagen Man could work with IDW as a villain with a tragic backstory, similar to the Nick-version but with more seriousness, and (obviously) The Pulverizer not being his base human form.
People talked about how Woody could turn into Mondo Gecko in an other topic... but how bout turning him to Mutagen Man?
He already got ambushed by Slash before, he no more trusted Mikey, then later, he gave their friendship another chance. Now if he would end up having a mutagen-releated accident, thanks to hanging out with Mikey, and it would turn him into a mutant blob, that would really give him a reason to hate the turtles. This would be even more tragic than that retarded kid, Pulverizer.
And this kind of Nick influence would be okay, I guess, since Mutagen Man came from OT.
Andrew NDB
10-02-2013, 02:08 PM
Mutagen Man could work with IDW as a villain with a tragic backstory, similar to the Nick-version but with more seriousness, and (obviously)
I dunno... the very presence of Mutagen Man would sort of mean the mutagen/ooze would need to start doing nonsense in IDW. Unless he receives a radically different origin than anything told before.
Though like with Bebop and Rocksteady, if you have to bend over backwards to twist Fred Wolf characters to suit a thing... why bother?
I dunno... the very presence of Mutagen Man would sort of mean the mutagen/ooze would need to start doing nonsense in IDW. Unless he receives a radically different origin than anything told before
Hmm, it would easy to explain I think... Waste remained after unsuccesful mutagen synthesizing, then it makes contact with the 'victim' and turns him into Mutagen Man.
I think something similar was his OT origin: postman dropped in an unfinished/unstable mutagen... something like.
CyberCubed
10-02-2013, 02:32 PM
Mutagen Man isn't a Nick character anyway, so they could use him if they wanted. Any original toon/Playmates character is free game, it doesn't matter if Nick uses them.
Case in point, Slash is appearing in both the Nick cartoon in Season 2 and is already in the IDW comic. And he's an old Fred Wolf/Archie/Playmates character.
Toby Barrett
10-02-2013, 09:37 PM
That's a shame. An IDW Cockroach Terminator could be creepy as all hell.
CyberCubed
10-02-2013, 11:03 PM
That's a shame. An IDW Cockroach Terminator could be creepy as all hell.
They might as well just use Scumbug if they want a mutant roach. Its practically the same thing just without the cyborg attachments.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.