View Full Version : Tales of the TMNT Collected Book #3 is Out
Cipher
10-12-2013, 11:03 AM
Just FYI, since I haven't seen a thread for this recently. Collects Tales Vol. 2 #1-4. There are some truly bizarre coloring choices here, and this is one of the first volumes where I really feel the color was added at a detriment to the black-and-white artwork, but it's still worth having.
Go get it and begin your journey to greatness. The era of many of the greatest TMNT one-off stories begins here.
Ninjinister
10-12-2013, 11:29 AM
Just FYI, since I haven't seen a thread for this recently. Collects Tales Vol. 2 #1-4. There are some truly bizarre coloring choice here, and this is one of the first volumes where I really feel the color was added at a detriment to the black-and-white artwork, but it's still worth having.
Go get it and begin your journey to greatness. The era of many of the greatest TMNT one-off stories begins here.
I picked it up because I wanted to read one of my favorite early Tales 2 stories (Murphy and Remender's "Worms of Madness") in color. I just didn't expect Shredder-Shark to be so... tan. It's like he went to a salon after becoming that thing. Oddly enough, the wee bit of him we get to see on the cover is gray like the shark was. Hm.
(btw if someone can provide a scan of his "reveal" page from this book, I'd greatly appreciate it. I can't get my own scanner to get the page looking right).
Other odd coloring choices were Shredder's helmet (red and gold!?) and the fact that the non-mutant turtle they find is clearly stated to be albino, is normal-colored.
I don't know what IDW's process is, but from this and other offerings it seems that they get color artists that are both unfamiliar with the source material (to an absurd degree at points) and are not given the script at all.
Makes me wish Breckel was on all of these books. At least she knows her TMNT well enough and she's great at her job to boot.
CyberCubed
10-12-2013, 12:39 PM
More ridiculous coloring errors? Why on earth is this not being overlooked?
DrSpengler
10-12-2013, 01:21 PM
I picked it up because I wanted to read one of my favorite early Tales 2 stories (Murphy and Remender's "Worms of Madness") in color. I just didn't expect Shredder-Shark to be so... tan. It's like he went to a salon after becoming that thing. Oddly enough, the wee bit of him we get to see on the cover is gray like the shark was. Hm.
(btw if someone can provide a scan of his "reveal" page from this book, I'd greatly appreciate it. I can't get my own scanner to get the page looking right).
Other odd coloring choices were Shredder's helmet (red and gold!?) and the fact that the non-mutant turtle they find is clearly stated to be albino, is normal-colored.
I don't know what IDW's process is, but from this and other offerings it seems that they get color artists that are both unfamiliar with the source material (to an absurd degree at points) and are not given the script at all.
Makes me wish Breckel was on all of these books. At least she knows her TMNT well enough and she's great at her job to boot.
Yikes.
I mean, I'm not one to pass judgment on something I haven't seen yet, but that description sounds pretty dire.
Ninjinister
10-12-2013, 01:36 PM
I very much prefer Cipher's take on Shredder Shark that he did at my request:
http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3390/3296094101_889c2f94be_z.jpg?zz=1
Cipher
10-12-2013, 07:04 PM
Yes, the tan Shredder Shark is ... unfortunate. As are the inconsistencies between the cover and content in different issues. I'm also not a fan of how moodless the lighting and color choices are in "Worms of Madness" in particular. It's set up like a horror story and the cover shows this purple, darkened sewer, only to to have the colors in this issue display brightly lit brown stone.
Again, while I've been on board with a lot of the Classic Collections' colors, and thought they were an active improvement over Lawson's early art in the first two Tales books ("I, Monster" maybe not withstanding), they actually seem to be a hindrance here. Actually, Dario Brizuela's issue works pretty well. Lawson's later style should look good with color, but it needs flatter tones and smarter choices than what we're given here. "Worms of Madness" suffered.
All that said, in no way should that discourage you from buying what is otherwise an excellent <$15 collection, especially if you haven't read any of these before. I'm just psyched to get a collected run of these.
CyberCubed
10-12-2013, 07:40 PM
There is no quality control with these reprints it seems. Between Ultimate collection #4 having no duotones and these comics being poorly colored, what is the point?
And although I know nobody cares about issues #38-40, the two little aliens were colored green in the collection even though on the original covers they're gray. But again, nobody cares about those little two aliens in those issues, but it blows my mind that the colorists didn't look at the cover.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.