View Full Version : Vote for "City at War" on Comic Book Resource's 100 Best Story Lines
Cipher
10-13-2013, 03:40 PM
Comic Book Resources sub-site/blog "Comics Should Be Good" is currently holding open voting for their top 100 comic-book story lines (http://goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/2013/10/07/comics-should-be-goods-top-100-comic-book-storylines-2/).
Here's what you should do:
1. Go to the link pasted above.
2. Vote for "City at War" and nine other story lines. I guess you could also throw in "Return to New York" or some other Turtles story, but expect aspersions to be cast at you if you place it above "City at War." Personally, I also included "Soul's Winter." Why wouldn't you do that? Do you have bad taste or something?
3. Wait and hope your vote gets this excellent work the recognition it deserves as one of the top runs in a semi-mainstream book.
Do it to it.
PApagreg
10-13-2013, 04:03 PM
Sorry but Chew has my vote
Cipher
10-13-2013, 04:04 PM
Sorry but Chew has my vote
You can/have to vote for 10, though. I couldn't actually in good conscience include it in my #1 spot either, but I did list it as my #2.
CyberCubed
10-13-2013, 05:00 PM
That whole list will be filled with overrated DC and Marvel storylines from 30-40 year old comic book nerds who have been reading comics since the 70's.
TMNT has no chance.
Cipher
10-13-2013, 05:13 PM
That whole list will be filled with overrated DC and Marvel storylines from 30-40 year old comic book nerds who have been reading comics since the 70's.
TMNT has no chance.
Yeah, so vote for it and get it some exposure. "City at War" legitimately deserves to be somewhere in the top 100, especially top 100 among mainstream or genre comics. With that large a list and the voting/point system they're using, a decent number of Turtles fans weighing in actually has a chance of placing it.
CyberCubed
10-13-2013, 07:07 PM
Yeah the problem is that there's like only 50 of us on this forum who read Mirage, and in terms of other forums there's even less.
Most TMNT fans are actually only just reading the Mirage material for the first time due to the IDW reprints, and the second half of City at War isn't even released yet.
Cipher
10-13-2013, 07:11 PM
Even fifty people with it in the top half of their list would probably get it to place somewhere within the list of 100, but ugh, okay, fine; don't.
CyberCubed
10-13-2013, 07:13 PM
Even fifty people with it in the top half of their list would probably get it to place somewhere within the list of 100, but ugh, okay, fine; don't.
I did my part. But there are too many DC and Marvel fans out there who will choose the worst story over any TMNT series.
Jester
10-13-2013, 07:36 PM
You really are a glass half empty kinda guy, ain't ya?
CyberCubed
10-13-2013, 07:49 PM
You really are a glass half empty kinda guy, ain't ya?
You're underestimating the sheer mass of DC/Marvel fans who have been following comics since the 70's, which represents the bulk of people buying comics in the first place.
If any independent comic storylines get on the list, it won't be TMNT, but rather stuff from Dark Horse like Star Wars or Usagi Yojimbo, or stuff from Image like Spawn or Savage Dragon.
We TMNT fans are a vocal minority, not to mention the cartoons overshadowing the comics too. Just look at the way the Nick cartoon is so much more well known and popular than the IDW comic too.
snake
10-13-2013, 08:28 PM
You're underestimating the sheer mass of DC/Marvel fans who have been following comics since the 70's, which represents the bulk of people buying comics in the first place.
If any independent comic storylines get on the list, it won't be TMNT, but rather stuff from Dark Horse like Star Wars or Usagi Yojimbo, or stuff from Image like Spawn or Savage Dragon.
We TMNT fans are a vocal minority, not to mention the cartoons overshadowing the comics too. Just look at the way the Nick cartoon is so much more well known and popular than the IDW comic too.
Savage dragon had good storylines?
CyberCubed
10-13-2013, 11:33 PM
I never read it so I wouldn't know, but the series is up to its 193rd issue which came out this month. I can't think of any other series that has 193 monthly issues that is not a DC or Marvel comic and hasn't been canceled besides Usagi.
Jester
10-13-2013, 11:43 PM
I don't think you're giving the general comic book fan much credit.
CyberCubed
10-14-2013, 04:51 PM
On that note, I'm going to list the Usagi yojimbo Grasscutter storyline which was probably its best arc.
Anyone on this forum who doesn't buy the 27 Usagi trades should feel ashamed of themselves. Usagi Yojimbo is better than any TMNT comic ever written.
Jester
10-14-2013, 04:58 PM
Or...and I know it's a stretch, they either can't afford it or as this is a Turtle specific forum, they don't care that much about Usagi, despite his ties to the Turtles themselves.
Maybe this will help: "Only a Sith speaks in absolutes!"
For me it's the former.
CyberCubed
10-14-2013, 05:02 PM
It's not really that expensive to follow the Usagi trades. I have almost all of them except for 4 because they're out of print. I only spent close to $300 but that was over the span of like 12 years.
Usagi has amazing storylines, they actually made me realize how good an independent comic book could be. Stan Sakai is everything Laird/Eastman are not, an actual competent storyteller.
Redeemer
10-14-2013, 06:59 PM
Yeah the problem is that there's like only 50 of us on this forum who read Mirage, and in terms of other forums there's even less.
Most TMNT fans are actually only just reading the Mirage material for the first time due to the IDW reprints, and the second half of City at War isn't even released yet.
This is my problem trying to finish the City at War arc via ultimate collection set, but unfortunately ive been left on a cliff hanger for the past few months....:ohwell:
CyberCubed
10-14-2013, 07:54 PM
We TMNT fans are but a mere pebble compared to the mountains that are DC and Marvel fanboys.
Jester
10-14-2013, 08:05 PM
And...just for comparisons sake...how large is the Usagi Yojimbo/Stan Sakai fanbase?
Cipher
10-14-2013, 09:45 PM
This thread sucks. Everything sucks.
Andrew NDB
10-14-2013, 11:06 PM
Pound for pound I found "Return to New York" to be a more powerful story. I love "City at War"... but even I can see they could have trimmed quite a bit from that to make it a leaner, meaner but just as poignant piece.
CyberCubed
10-14-2013, 11:10 PM
And...just for comparisons sake...how large is the Usagi Yojimbo/Stan Sakai fanbase?
Large enough for Dark Horse not to cancel Usagi in over 15 years.
Leo656
10-14-2013, 11:32 PM
Enough with demonizing people who prefer DC or Marvel, also. TMNT and other "indie" books don't exist in a vacuum. People know about them. People read them. MOST people don't give a sh*t about them, or they'd sell better. Hate to point out an inconvenient truth, but there it is.
I argue with friends about music like this, also. So many people act like anything "mainstream" sucks compared to anything "indie" and "pure". F*ck that, lots of "underground" stuff is good and lots of "mainstream" stuff sucks, but niche stuff stays niche because **people don't care about it or like it enough to make it more popular**, not because they don't know it exists or they're "misinformed" or "uneducated" or whatever. There's a reason Mercyful Fate don't sell as many albums as Metallica, it's because most objective people think they suck by comparison.
I love TMNT. I do. But not really the comics. I've only read a very small handful of stories that I'd call "great", compared to ridiculous amounts of excellent stories with Superman, Batman, and other "mainstream" characters. As overrated as DC/Marvel books can be, the same is true (and the sin exponentially greater) of any TMNT books, because frankly none have ever been *that* great. TMNT fans overrate the books because many of them admit - yourself included, CC - that they're almost the only comics they even read, so they approach the subject with *extreme* bias.
A Top 100 is a pretty wide list, so I could see some TMNT stories maybe fitting in, but nowhere near the Top 50. Sorry, but them's the breaks. If the quality of each TMNT series wasn't so meandering over the last 30 years maybe they'd have a shot at reaching "true" success in the comic book arena. It's not that people have a "mainstream bias", it's that people who are objective genuinely haven't given much of a sh*t about the TMNT books, because there isn't a whole lot that's terrific about them. Some good, sure, but a whole lot of boring, pointless, and flat-out bad, too.
But let's not go around implying anyone who truly, honestly prefers the Big Two is some kind of uncultured heathen, especially if the person saying so doesn't even read f*cking comic books to begin with, and thus has zero right to an opinion at all. :roll:
CyberCubed
10-15-2013, 12:08 AM
^ Well you're right because DC and Marvel have been going on for decades longer than TMNT, and have about a million different series. Of course there will be tons of excellent storylines, its what made those superheroes popular in the first place.
This thread sucks. Everything sucks.
I think the word you're looking for is, "asinine." Everything is asinine, Cipher.
Leo656
10-15-2013, 12:15 AM
To be fair, I've kind of been cranky all day, too.
Jester
10-15-2013, 12:22 AM
I think the word you're looking for is, "asinine." Everything is asinine, Cipher.
If anyone knows what "asinine" means it's you, Cybercubed.
CyberCubed
10-15-2013, 09:47 AM
If anyone knows what "asinine" means it's you, Cybercubed.
I ruin every thread I post in, don't I?
In all seriousness I did vote for City at war on the site so who knows what will happen.
discordiatookie
10-15-2013, 03:05 PM
Anyone on this forum who doesn't buy the 27 Usagi trades should feel ashamed of themselves. Usagi Yojimbo is better than any TMNT comic ever written.
Pfft. I have a one year old son and am a newlywed. This month my wage was short by £40 to cover all our bills, meaning we're relying on my wife's £90 a week bar wage to live on (£50 of which goes to paying for the car) so that leaves us £40 a week to get food, nappies, wipes, toilet roll, petrol and whatever else we need to live on. I've had to extend my overdraft by £200 just for a short term solution.
I can barely even afford the comics I do have on my pulls list ( haven't been to the comic shop this month due to the short wage, meaning I'm going to have a double stack next pay) so there's not a chance I'm ever going to be able to afford to start buying 27 and counting tpbs.
I feel ashamed that this month I can barely feed my family, I certainly won't feel ashamed that I'm not reading a f**king comic book on your say.
****************
I too prefer RTNY over CAW, but when I get round to sending this off (I'm still compiling my list) I'll place it above for the good cause.
snake
10-15-2013, 03:31 PM
Large enough for Dark Horse not to cancel Usagi in over 15 years.
Image comics has been running since the 90s and look at how terrible those are. Even their turtles ones were pretty bad.
Jester
10-15-2013, 05:20 PM
Pfft. I have a one year old son and am a newlywed. This month my wage was short by £40 to cover all our bills, meaning we're relying on my wife's £90 a week bar wage to live on (£50 of which goes to paying for the car) so that leaves us £40 a week to get food, nappies, wipes, toilet roll, petrol and whatever else we need to live on. I've had to extend my overdraft by £200 just for a short term solution.
I can barely even afford the comics I do have on my pulls list ( haven't been to the comic shop this month due to the short wage, meaning I'm going to have a double stack next pay) so there's not a chance I'm ever going to be able to afford to start buying 27 and counting tpbs.
I feel ashamed that this month I can barely feed my family, I certainly won't feel ashamed that I'm not reading a f**king comic book on your say.
So much this. Hopefully things will get better. I know the frustration, sir.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.