View Full Version : Let's List All the Mirage Elements in Barron's TMNT.
Jester
11-01-2013, 08:09 AM
We all know the big stuff like the origin being the Mirage telling...save the removal of Oroku Nagi and that Raph's one-shot as well as Leo's were adapted, only with Leo being changed to Raph....
BUT...could Mikey and Donnie's conversation about not having Splinter anymore be a reference to Raph and Mikey's discussion in Crack in a Hard Heart? The only reason I wonder is because in rereading the story for Saba's motion comic, it reminded me of the scene from the movie...only with Raph swapped for Donnie (ironically...since Raph was THE Turtle in the 1st movie). Though Turtle Soup was released AFTER the movie but Farley's story dates back to 89...which still might be too late...but the theme of the short and that scene are very similar...well...except for Mikey's final response.
So what all was Mirage about the 1st movie down to even specific scenes?
Welmanshire
11-01-2013, 07:06 PM
I've always thought a lot of the farm stuff was pulled from the City at War run.
Cipher
11-01-2013, 07:20 PM
BUT...could Mikey and Donnie's conversation about not having Splinter anymore be a reference to Raph and Mikey's discussion in Crack in a Hard Heart? The only reason I wonder is because in rereading the story for Saba's motion comic, it reminded me of the scene from the movie...only with Raph swapped for Donnie (ironically...since Raph was THE Turtle in the 1st movie). Though Turtle Soup was released AFTER the movie but Farley's story dates back to 89...which still might be too late...but the theme of the short and that scene are very similar...well...except for Mikey's final response.
I'm definitely going to chalk that up to coincidence. It's just an easy theme to explore.
I've always thought a lot of the farm stuff was pulled from the City at War run.
Are you thinking of another arc? "City at War" doesn't have the Turtles on the farm until its resolution. And it wasn't out for another two years.
Anyway, a few little things:
*April's "stoneage" van makes an appearance
*Don and Casey's insult game, along with fixing the truck, is culled nearly word for word from a scene between Casey and Raph in TMNT #11. Someone must have been a fan of this, because it's the only farm scene to receive such a direct adaptation.
Aaaaand ...
Look, that's honestly about it. The first TMNT movie adapts the early Mirage story lines in broad strokes (origins, Raph meeting Casey, Turtles staying with April while Splinter is missing, antique store fire and retreat to the farm, rooftop battle with the Shredder), but it's not overly faithful or concerned with being a direct adaptation.
CyberCubed
11-01-2013, 07:41 PM
April's frizzy hair in the movie resembles her Mirage counterpart, only its more reddish/brownish to look like the cartoon.
Raphael says, "Damn!" in the movie like he said, "Damn!" in one of the Mirage comics.
Jester
11-01-2013, 08:44 PM
Aaaaand ...
Look, that's honestly about it. The first TMNT movie adapts the early Mirage story lines in broad strokes (origins, Raph meeting Casey, Turtles staying with April while Splinter is missing, antique store fire and retreat to the farm, rooftop battle with the Shredder), but it's not overly faithful or concerned with being a direct adaptation.
Yep, because most comic book movie adaptations are panel for panel remakes of the source material...
Say what you want about the 1st movie only broad brushing the Mirage canon, it's about as faithful as any comic book adaptation flick.
April's frizzy hair in the movie resembles her Mirage counterpart, only its more reddish/brownish to look like the cartoon.
Raphael says, "Damn!" in the movie like he said, "Damn!" in one of the Mirage comics.
I really can't believe I didn't see this coming....it's the Easter Eggs thead all over again.
Cipher
11-01-2013, 09:09 PM
Say what you want about the 1st movie only broad brushing the Mirage canon, it's about as faithful as any comic book adaptation flick.
It just doesn't have that many direct references. I literally think they've all been counted in this thread, and it could be done one hand. That's really all I was getting at. Slavish homages or easter eggs weren't its thing. For that matter, there wasn't much Mirage material to homage; about half the series by the time this came out had been tongue-in-cheek, characterless pastiche.
That said, it's about as faithful a Mirage movie as could be made in 1990, but that's taking into account not only the relative lack of source material at the time, but also the state of comic book movies and the hugely popular, kid-friendly cartoon it had to keep in line with. Again, its broad plot line, character interpretations and even a lot of its emotional beats are excellent representations of the source material. And a lot of it's not.
Ninjinister
11-01-2013, 10:15 PM
BUT...could Mikey and Donnie's conversation about not having Splinter anymore be a reference to Raph and Mikey's discussion in Crack in a Hard Heart? The only reason I wonder is because in rereading the story for Saba's motion comic, it reminded me of the scene from the movie...only with Raph swapped for Donnie (ironically...since Raph was THE Turtle in the 1st movie). Though Turtle Soup was released AFTER the movie but Farley's story dates back to 89...which still might be too late...but the theme of the short and that scene are very similar...well...except for Mikey's final response.
There's a new motion comic?
DaVinci
11-04-2013, 12:47 PM
There are a couple more little things from #11. Like Mike smashing things in the barn and Raph standing in front of a rooster weather-vane on the roof. I can understand why they cut the bit where he flips to the other side...
CansecoBat
11-04-2013, 01:43 PM
The 1990 film isn't a direct beat for beat imitation of Mirage, it does it's own thing. It also incorporates the more well known phenomenon type stuff the 80's cartoon and action figures presented.
Barron's 1990 TMNT film is more Mirage like in it's essence. Which IMO is why it is the pinnacle, and greatest achievement in the TMNT lore. It's almost the perfect balancing act between the Mirage and Wolf Toon. Takes the strongest elements of both.
It's for the most part mature, gritty, dark atmosphere, and pretty serious. It isn't over the top gratuitous violent like the Mirage comic. But then again, it doesn't really need to be. The characterization of the turtles is more Mirage like than that of the OT. Popular Mikey like elements from the OT included, aside. Don is smart, without being a comically over the top techno / gizmo genius he is in the original toon.
Night Watcher
11-04-2013, 01:50 PM
Story elements used for 1990 film were from Mirage 1-3, Myself and I, What Goes Around...Comes Around!, Silent Partner, True Stories, and Return to New York, which had the turtles at the farm house for a little while.
the fixer
11-12-2013, 04:19 AM
There was an nice Mirage comic/movie comparison on the Batman-Online forum months ago...
http://www.batman-online.com/forum/index.php?topic=2282.msg32732#new
An interesting read! :)
Technogeek29
11-12-2013, 04:45 AM
There was an nice Mirage comic/movie comparison on the Batman-Online forum months ago...
http://www.batman-online.com/forum/index.php?topic=2282.msg32732#new
An interesting read! :)
Nice read. I would love to see an IDW based movie in a similar fashion, loosley based but a few pannel to pannel shots here and there.
Venom
11-16-2013, 06:40 PM
There are a couple more little things from #11. Like Mike smashing things in the barn and Raph standing in front of a rooster weather-vane on the roof.
Watch that scene again - that's actually Mike up there.
Technogeek29
11-16-2013, 06:49 PM
Watch that scene again - that's actually Mike up there.
Even after you hear Raph screaming SPLINTER~ at the top of his lungs?
Venom
11-17-2013, 10:00 AM
Even after you hear Raph screaming SPLINTER~ at the top of his lungs?
Yep, it was dubbed.
MsMarvelDuckie
11-18-2013, 03:16 PM
Actually, I believe Mike was the one punching the bag in the barn. Raph was on the roof. Hmm, turtle on the roof- sounds like a wierd musical!
Ville Leskinen
11-18-2013, 03:57 PM
Mikey was on both of the scenes. They just dubbed Mikey with Raph's voice when he's on top of the barn. See?
Plasticplayhouse
11-19-2013, 08:33 AM
Say what you want about the 1st movie only broad brushing the Mirage canon, it's about as faithful as any comic book adaptation flick.
Truth to that!
Mikey was on both of the scenes. They just dubbed Mikey with Raph's voice when he's on top of the barn. See?
I always thought that was Raph! :teek:
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.