PDA

View Full Version : Tmnt 28 preview/discussion


TomWaltz
11-25-2013, 07:05 PM
A little preview of Wednesday's pre-Thanksgiving festivities!

http://www.comicvine.com/articles/this-week-s-essential-comics-11-25-13/1100-147641/

(You'll have to scroll down a bit to find TMNT #28.)

Talk soon...

Tom W.

CyberCubed
11-25-2013, 07:20 PM
Bebop and Rocksteady look to be a forced to be reckoned with. Glad they won't be pushovers like they were in the original cartoon. As long as they keep their funny/goofy personality but are strong in battle I'll be looking forward to seeing more of them.

boywonder26
11-25-2013, 07:34 PM
wow!the art is absolutely amazing.i cant wait to read and see what all happens.. :tgrin:

CyberCubed
11-25-2013, 07:37 PM
I still prefer Ben Bates designs for Bebop and Rocksteady, I think they looked far funnier there, but I have to say their designs here are good too.

I think Ben Bates designs for Bebop/Rocksteady should be used for comedy issues.

pingclang
11-25-2013, 07:46 PM
I can not WAIT to read this.

corvus
11-26-2013, 09:01 AM
too small i cant read any of it...

DONATELLO DUZMACHINES
11-26-2013, 09:42 AM
I still prefer Ben Bates designs for Bebop and Rocksteady, I think they looked far funnier there, but I have to say their designs here are good too.

I think Ben Bates designs for Bebop/Rocksteady should be used for comedy issues.

I agree Bates design did have a comedic edge, and if B&R ever get another micro I would love to see him do it. I think I like both designs equally, there so awesome. Cant eait for tomorrow!

TomWaltz
11-26-2013, 11:11 AM
too small i cant read any of it...

Try this one, my friend... a bit easier to read:

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=preview&id=19178

Talk soon...

Tom W.

Blossombrooks
11-26-2013, 12:28 PM
Beyond excited for this issue!! :D

Plasticplayhouse
11-26-2013, 12:45 PM
this issue is looking fantabulous! can't wait to pick it up!

Rooish
11-26-2013, 07:39 PM
Suddenly, I very much approve of the portrayal of female characters in this comic.

Casey
11-26-2013, 11:52 PM
That was an awesome preview! Than you Tom. I am ready for it to be tomorrow already.

Jeff
11-27-2013, 10:33 AM
This issue only proved that not only is this one of the best TMNT stories ever told, its one of the best comics being published right now. What a GREAT ending!

Veg
11-27-2013, 01:53 PM
Wow city fall ended amazingly. Such a great story. So many cool touches (slash at the end!)

One to be remembered for a LONG time

Andrew NDB
11-27-2013, 01:56 PM
Not my cup of tea. But not poorly written, either.

MikeandRaph87
11-27-2013, 02:20 PM
I will give it a solid 92 B.

It had a nice fight with Bebop and Rocksteady for the ones of us who have '87cartoon first in fandom.

There was a nice sequence between arnold Sr. and Jr. or Casey Jones vs Hun for the 2003 cartoon crowd. Though some may not care for the different relationship between the two. Also, Angel's inclusion.

There is the Kirby inspired weapons holding off Bebop and Rocksteady and the retreat to the farmhouse to work through the ordeal as a family while Shredder hunts for them for the Mirage perferred crowd.

Meanwhile, IDW lovers get Old Hob shaking off another injury and Alopex saving Splinter which I admit surprised me. Her defection was coming its just a way I did not expect. I suppose she is hitching a ride to Northampton with the guys and April to hideout as she went from being Shredder's #3 to his most wanted list.

Bravo,IDW, bravo on weaving everything so nicely!

The dragon decorated throne looks odd in what looks like a warehouse but I take that in stride. So how will Heisenburg,The Warriors and the mob act under Shredder? Big Louie show up in Shredder's cooperation,PLEASE?

Andrew NDB
11-27-2013, 02:28 PM
It had a nice fight with Bebop and Rocksteady for the ones of us who have '87cartoon first in fandom.

The '87 cartoon was "first in fandom" for me... but that fight was decidedly not for me.

Green Machine
11-27-2013, 02:53 PM
I really liked:

The end when Leonardo gives his black bandana to Slash. Such a simple gesture. I also like the fact that Leo still doesn't completely trust Splinter or the other turtles yet. It would have been too weird if he just flipped the switch to being completely normal again.

MikeandRaph87
11-27-2013, 03:11 PM
GM-I wonder if Leo will fully be freed or perhaps be a plot device used later on to have seeds Kitsune used to turn him remain and later resurface.

The next arc will most likely see him accept his family and the others see him as himself again.


A request for the creative team,please don't switch lairs anytime soon. Shredder is hunting for the turtles but that does not mean he has to locate the lair and the turtles have to change homes. The lair is the best one yet.

Jeff
11-27-2013, 03:29 PM
The '87 cartoon was "first in fandom" for me... but that fight was decidedly not for me.

87 was first for me, too, and i hate bebop and rocksteady. i thought the fight in 28 was fine, but it went on too long.

Red Mask
11-27-2013, 03:36 PM
I liked the stuff with Casey and his dad, and I liked the last few panels. This wasn't one of my favorites though,
the fight with Bebop and Rocksteady was a bit of a letdown for me. Overall I liked City Fall, most the issues were very good and a couple were great. This last issue was done well enough, but personally, I think the arc wrapped up without much of the weight or consequences that the first few CF issues seemed to foreshadow. Leo didn't really do anything except hang out with the Foot for awhile, maybe I wanted him to do something he'd really have to wrestle with morally. But maybe turning on his family is enough, and I am interested to see how he'll act in the next arc. This issue is a good set-up for Northampton and for Shredder being a powerful bad-guy, but I guess I was hoping something...unexpected would happen?

But that's me judging it for what I want it to be, which may not be fair. Judging it for what it IS, CF is a really good arc (with alot of momentum- I can't wait to read it all at once!) in a really good book. I'm real glad it's out there- lookin forward to Northampton!

Andrew NDB
11-27-2013, 03:38 PM
I've been buying and skimming the past couple months. Does anyone actually die in "City Fall"?

Jester
11-27-2013, 03:43 PM
Aside from the leader of the Savate...I dunna. Have yet to read the last issue.

Lord Nightwalker
11-27-2013, 04:02 PM
Enjoyed the issue tremendously. I'm not going to nit pick the little things, but enjoy it as a whole, That's why I am re reading the issues back to back later tonight for a feel of the story arc. Really dug those last few panels.That was kind of an " I knew it!" moment. lol.

I was hoping that Casey would have chided his father for aiding the creep who put him in the hospital, but hey! who knows what the future holds! I am looking forward to future story lines.

Red Mask
11-27-2013, 04:04 PM
I've been buying and skimming the past couple months. Does anyone actually die in "City Fall"?

Victor...and Victor kills one of his own. Also I think Karai kills a couple Savates. That's all I recall, no main characters bite it. Some people get wounded, so it's not without violence, but not much death.

Coola Yagami
11-27-2013, 06:35 PM
I've been buying and skimming the past couple months. Does anyone actually die in "City Fall"?

The Savate leader and random nameless Savates and Foot throughout the series. But I know what you really want to know, none of them die by the Turtles' hands, not even evil Leo.

DrSpengler
11-27-2013, 06:53 PM
Here's my full review of TMNT #28 at TMNT Entity (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2013/11/tmnt-idw-28.html)

It's a long review as I had a bit to say about this arc as a whole.

To summarize, while Dark Leo fell flat for me, it was an exciting and bombastic event with some gorgeous art all the way through. I do, however, think the Villain Micro chapters are essential, not just to the plot, but to the characters. I know they won't be included in the trades and that's a tad problematic. But as someone who read the whole shebang, I thought most of it paid off.

Just not Dark Leo. Sorry, guys.

Veg
11-27-2013, 06:54 PM
I roared with laughter when it took a god damn GRENADE to slow down Bebop and Rocksteady.

MikeandRaph87
11-27-2013, 07:11 PM
Veg, I like to think that Hob pulled it off of Bebop's vest. I laughed at that possibility. I also wonder what Shredder would have said to Bebop,Rocksteady, and Arnold Sr. Before he spoke to Karai.

Desslok
11-27-2013, 07:45 PM
I enjoyed it. I love how it pulled all the stories that have been going on for the past few months and brought them together in such an explosive manner.

The Bebop and Rocksteady fight was pretty good IMO. While there could have been a bit more to it, It's pretty clear that the turtles are heavily outgunned compared to these "secret weapons." I also appreciate that they have so much personality, that's what made them fun in the OT and I'm enjoying it here.

And man, Hob is such a fun badass.

I loved it when he lobbed that grenade at Rocksteady and Bebop.

AquaParade
11-27-2013, 07:48 PM
I'd like to echo Dr. Spangler's statement that it was a fun event, despite "Dark Leo" falling flat.

Earlier issues shined brightest when focused on moral bouts, such as Leonardo and Donatello's disagreements concerning the importance of searching for Raphael, as well as friction regarding whether or not to Spare enemies while endangering their family.
I thought "Dark Leo" would pack a punch of ethical dilemma's along with some meaty revelation's dealing with Saki and Yoshi's checkered past. There is obviously still room for the Dark Leo plot line to spread into something more meaningful, but it's probably taken up enough of our time as is.

Positively, the art was freakin fanstastic in this issue - if only Mateus 's rendition of Mikey wasn't so...baby'ish.

I'll report back once I've read the arc as a whole, but I can't say at this point that the story did much for me. It was well told, as complimented by the art, and had some nice beats - Raph and Casey being jumped by the foot and the Foot Clan ambush on the Savati were both pretty fun! Also, Old Hob is a blast to be around. Unfortunately, this drawn out arc didn't leave me with any potent feeling.

corvus
11-27-2013, 07:56 PM
You absolutely have to read the Karai, Hun and Alopex micros to get this arc.

ToTheNines
11-27-2013, 08:26 PM
Nothing super crazy happened, but it was a good arc. Obviously B&R weren't going to kill the turtles, so that fight had no chance of being as fun as the murder spree that was their micro.

Hob and Slash were awesome, obviously digging Slash's look by the end :)

I really liked Karai's arc, I'm glad Shredder won't be treating her like sh*t anymore. Alopex though, I feel like everyone knew that was going to happen. I'm glad they didn't just let that plot point stew for months and months like they usually do (I'm annoyed that Casey brought up the fact that Shredder stabbed him, but didn't finish up and tell Hun), but at the same time it would have been a little more shocking if she turned on him in a more unexpected situation.

I also agree about the whole Dark Leo thing. I liked Shredder's scheme behind it, mainly the idea that he was going to use him to get to Splinter, but it was too convenient that he didn't kill anyone. This book gets pretty violent, they need to quit pulling punches with the Turtles. Could be a Viacom restriction though, I don't know.

Either way, I like the book and it keeps me driving that hour round trip at least once a month. Can't wait for Northampton and Conspiracy!

Rooish
11-27-2013, 08:26 PM
Excellent issue. I was really pleased with the multiple female characters bursting in to save the day (either for Shredder or for the good guys): first Karai last issue, then April, Angel to a minor extent, and Alopex! (Although Bebop/Rocksteady, Hob sort of, and Slash had bursting in moments, too.) Finally the female characters in the series are becoming less bland, although I agree that the Micros were really required to add depth and characterization to City Fall.

I liked the fight with Bebop and Rocksteady and love Santolouco's rendition of them, but I did think their dialogue was sort of lame. Also anytime someone calls someone else a "fool," you lose me. Why did people not like the fight?

Alopex's attack of Shredder was awesome and actually kind of emotional, I thought.

When did Hob become like the best character in this series? Love him. But I did notice that the actual turtles lost a lot of characterization in such a busy action-packed plot.

It still bothers me that Santolouco draws every character amazingly except the Turtles. Namely Don and Mike, but I also miss Duncan's milder version of Raph (which did look the same as all the other Turtles, but I prefer the same to wildly disparate). I wonder how much the art has changed the characterization of the Turtles? Raph acts rougher, Don milder, and Mike more childish than when Duncan and Bates drew it. It's annoying. When I read the comics I don't want kid Mike all over again.

And what is with that god damned buck tooth? Can someone besides me please protest this?

Also--why does no one tell Hun that Shredder stabbed Casey? Why didn't Angel?? Why didn't Casey?? I mean they can see he's working for Shredder!

I agree with DrSpengler's analysis of Dark Leo to an extent, although I think he did enough to make himself feel pretty tortured and guilty. He served and looked up to Shredder, who killed his whole family in the past. He was an accomplice to a lot of killing and to Shredder becoming "in control" of the city. He didn't just attack his family, but he spoke hatefully to them. Also, he is a control freak who probably thought he had control of his mind until this point. As anyone who has had a psychotic break could tell you, losing control of your mind assaults your very core of being. Leo also had a bunch of visions of his dead mother. I can see him being a bit traumatized. Loved his closure moment with Slash.

At first I was a bit annoyed that Raph, of all people, brought Leo back. Raph and Leo do not have the rivalry-bromance in this series yet. But then I remembered how Don and Mikey told Raph that Leo was the only one who held out hope that Raph was alive (besides Splinter). So maybe that really triggered Raph's loyalty. Also--Raph admitted that Leo would beat him in a fight normally?? I'm glad that this version of Raph has less of his trademark ego so far.

I am glad so many plot threads have been tied up with City Fall, leaving room, I hope, for more characterization again. It was an absolutely action packed and cinematic story. The Turtles have been through so much and I can't wait for the Northampton "breather."

I was really happy for Karai! I kind of forget why people think this Karai is pure evil and psychopathic. Can someone explain?

As for Shredder's reasoning on why he brainwashed Leo--well, at least he, and everyone else in the series, has motivations that are taken to account and kept hidden until the perfect moment. That's cool.

MikLeo
11-27-2013, 08:57 PM
I feel Shredder was lying to Karai, he wasn't testing her.

Casey
11-27-2013, 10:23 PM
I like how we see the turtles really struggle to hold their own once again. They aren't quite superheros yet. Northampton will probably give them the time they need to heal and learn to work better as a team. They're gonna have to do something to take on The Shredder - not to mention Bebop and Rocksteady. I hate to say it, but I wouldn't have minded that grenade killing those two off. I love that they were brought into the mix, but I've had enough. They're a little too much at times.

Loved the issue though and I enjoyed the arc as a whole. I'd like to echo the remarks about Dark Leo and the necessity to read the micros.

Panda_Kahn_fan
11-27-2013, 10:48 PM
There was some letdown elements in this whole story arch- but to me, Rocksteady and Bebop were definitely NOT IT. These versions are definitely NOT the jokes they're OT selves were, despite being almost as dumb. In their micro they KILLED a whole platoon of foot soldiers that Karai ordered to kill them- that is a whole group of trained ninjas, mind you, against the OT's two 'dumb thugs'. AND they defeated the turtles and Splinter- it took April's magic punchy gloves and a freakin' GRENADE to even slow them down enough for the turtles to escape. I for one hope these two stick around, and we see more of them.

Andrew NDB
11-27-2013, 10:54 PM
I like how we see the turtles really struggle to hold their own once again. They aren't quite superheros yet.

If they ever quite become that, I will officially hold no interest in the future of the book. But I don't think that's the plan at all.

pingclang
11-27-2013, 11:12 PM
I just finished it and have to say, I liked it. I didn't love it, but it was good. Am I the only one who felt like it was a huge build-up to a "meh" ending? I had expected more, it wasn't bad, I just felt like it was gonna be a huge ending.

Dirty Blond
11-28-2013, 01:01 AM
You can totally tell Shredder read The 48 Laws of Power.

Also, Karai can be my chunin any day.

:tlove:

JPP
11-28-2013, 12:35 PM
I just finished it and have to say, I liked it. I didn't love it, but it was good. Am I the only one who felt like it was a huge build-up to a "meh" ending? I had expected more, it wasn't bad, I just felt like it was gonna be a huge ending.

I felt the same way. It didn't feel like anything really got accomplished at the end of the arc. The conclusion felt predictable at best with no solid resolution to the conflict that had been building. Yeah Bebop and Rocksteady were finally mutated, Casey got a couple of shots in on his dad, and Slash got a couple new digs, but overall I wasn't blown away by this. For something that lasted 7 issues, there were about 2 that felt like filler until the next month's issue. With that kind of suspense building it felt like the ball got dropped for any real resolution in this final book.

Andrew NDB
11-28-2013, 01:30 PM
Pretty sure the team made "City Fall" as gritty and violent as they were allowed to, so I can't fault them. I really wish Nick/Viacom would bugger off when it comes to what's supposed to be a comic for a somewhat older audience than the Nicktoon. They shouldn't be ashamed of the Turtles' roots.

909 Turtle Fan
11-28-2013, 01:48 PM
Man, Leo's got issues. I got 2k3 flashbacks when splinter called shredder a demon. Kinda funny how the best way to stop bebop & rocksteady is to drop something heavy on them, its like a shout out to the OT. Where were the foot soldiers during the brawl and wsup with kitsune and that look she had on her face? I gotta say Hob is freakin cool as ice. Bring on the shredder micro!

Andrew NDB
11-28-2013, 02:01 PM
I will say I've come to like Old Hob a lot more now that's become more of a fully realized character.

the_soub
11-28-2013, 02:24 PM
Like many other's I thought it was good, but not great. Kind of anti-climactic.

I feel like it was one panel shy of being really good. For all of the build up, having something substantial happen, would have been a nice pay off.

Any one of the following things could have happened, and I feel that the issue/arc would have been better for it:

-Shredder kills Karai
-Donatello loses a hand(then replaced with the Gravity gauntlet)
-Casey saves Angel, but as a direct result Hun is killed
-Raph seriously kicks Leo's shell (I was expecting a sai through the shoulder or something
-Splinter is crippled

corvus
11-28-2013, 04:54 PM
-Shredder kills Karai
-Donatello loses a hand(then replaced with the Gravity gauntlet)
-Casey saves Angel, but as a direct result Hun is killed
-Raph seriously kicks Leo's shell (I was expecting a sai through the shoulder or something
-Splinter is crippled

You don't need to put spoiler tags on something that didn't happen. Shredder killing Karai, that'd be um, really unexpected and not make much sense, Casey killing a freshly introduced and highly anticipated a
character would really piss people off, Dons hand? I could dig that, more brutality in the Leo/Raph fight? I think that's a censorship thing but I'd dig thy too, splinter was pretty badly damaged but being crippled would be a bit much.

CyberCubed
11-28-2013, 05:01 PM
I've been buying and skimming the past couple months. Does anyone actually die in "City Fall"?

You've just been flipping through the pages without actually sitting down and reading it then? Couldn't you do the same thing in the comic store and save yourself $4?

I'm waiting for the trades myself so I can't comment on the story yet.

Weapons@theready
11-28-2013, 05:24 PM
Anyone else think upon first glance, that Shredder had cut off Splinter's tail, rather than break his leg

the_soub
11-28-2013, 05:35 PM
You don't need to put spoiler tags on something that didn't happen. Shredder killing Karai, that'd be um, really unexpected and not make much sense, Casey killing a freshly introduced and highly anticipated a
character would really piss people off, Dons hand? I could dig that, more brutality in the Leo/Raph fight? I think that's a censorship thing but I'd dig thy too, splinter was pretty badly damaged but being crippled would be a bit much.

Karai went behind Shredder's back in creating B&R along with everything else. And I didn't mean that Casey would kill Hun, just that he would have to choose between Angel and his dad in who he saves. (which is what I thought happened initially)

But yah, in short. It needed something bigger in the conclusion.

corvus
11-28-2013, 09:18 PM
Eh. I liked the climax. Big fight involving a ton of mutants, big betrayals and revelations.

Casey
11-29-2013, 11:10 PM
So, when Alopex lashes out at The Shredder yelling about her family, is this saying she is reincarnated from Yoshi's crew? I was a little thrown off. Thoughts?

Coola Yagami
11-29-2013, 11:58 PM
So, when Alopex lashes out at The Shredder yelling about her family, is this saying she is reincarnated from Yoshi's crew? I was a little thrown off. Thoughts?

No. Alopex was a normal fox before. Shredder took her to the forest where he found her and had it burned down, including her original family of non-mutated foxes. It was some sort of test of loyalty or like, saying you're leaving your family and past behind when you join the Foot. Alopex obviously didn't see it that way.

pingclang
11-30-2013, 08:26 AM
I felt the same way. It didn't feel like anything really got accomplished at the end of the arc. The conclusion felt predictable at best with no solid resolution to the conflict that had been building. Yeah Bebop and Rocksteady were finally mutated, Casey got a couple of shots in on his dad, and Slash got a couple new digs, but overall I wasn't blown away by this. For something that lasted 7 issues, there were about 2 that felt like filler until the next month's issue. With that kind of suspense building it felt like the ball got dropped for any real resolution in this final book.

Been busy so a bit late in replying but yeah, exactly. I think Andrew had a good point with it being only as violent as Nick will let it get and so instead of the huge brawl we were expecting we got a quick couple of bouts and the Turtles fleeing. There isn't much development other than Leo's problems so I'm hoping that Northampton will bring some sort of resolutions to some of the things developing in City Fall. I did really like the book it just wasn't the mindblow I was hoping for. Not the creative teams fault, just my own expectations I guess.

Redeemer
11-30-2013, 01:46 PM
Really loved this issue. I am happy to see karia being rewarded for her faithfullness to the foot. Its interesting how shredder defines family. I am also wondering where ALopex will go from here???She is hands down my favorite "new" from IDW. Also I am loving slash's action scenes!!

Cant wait for the North Hampton arc. I am wondering if Ross will deliver on his art sense he has had so much practice (Fan comic) drawing the turtles. His cover looks awesome!

Cipher
11-30-2013, 09:49 PM
Like others, I could've done with a little more oomph here. Unlike others, although this is a further issue with the story line, this is the kind of ending I foresaw months ago, and was only vaguely hoping we might avoid. When it came down to 22-pages left for a fight, it was clear we weren't getting much. Dark Leo petered into exactly what you'd expect (Shredder only wanting to test Karai and break the Turtles), the characters gathered for a fight (as expected), and the Turtles were forced away while still not being hit with any devastating impact.

Unfortunately, only Alopex's actions came as a surprise, as I expected that plot line to simmer a bit longer. I was also unsure how Casey and Hun's interaction would play out, but it looks as if they've been broken up and Hun put squarely in the villains camp sooner rather than later. For the best, I suppose.

As a storyline, it falls a little limp, especially in comparison to the frenetic, unpredictable "Secret History of the Foot Clan," before it (something I only find better upon revisits). On the other hand, only Dark Leo was an utter failure as a subplot, the rest of the events were largely interesting, the fight this issue was enjoyable, and, as DrSpengler pointed out, the entire board of lingering plots has been wiped clean. The series should be much more exciting and unpredictable now that this second act (if #1-12 was the first) is over.

There was a lot to enjoy about this particular issue as well. Bebop and Rocksteady are great (and foot in my mouth for harping on their first preview pages), provided a credible threat to the Turtles, and continued their characterizations as totally despicable people from their Micro-Series issue. To hell with Shredder and Krang, who come across as too cartoonishly supervillainous in comparison (sorry, Tom, the end of this arc has done nothing to mitigate that particular criticism) - Karai and her mutants are truly miserable, and I look forward to seeing more of them as villains in the future.

Redeemer
11-30-2013, 10:05 PM
Like others, On the other hand, only Dark Leo was an utter failure as a subplot, the rest of the events were largely interesting,

I agree completely I loved Dark Leo and I dont think we got nearly enough of him, I would have liked to have seen him stay dark at least to the end of the North Hamptom ark. Another thing I did not like is the fact the made dark Leo weaker when in fact he should have stronger than his regular personna especially sense he is not held back by the code and expections splinter set for him, as shredder lets him fight as he pleases.

Other than that this arc was great.

Dirty Blond
11-30-2013, 10:13 PM
Even though he was in every micro during this arc, I would have liked to see a Dark Leo villains micro.

Powder
11-30-2013, 10:34 PM
Underwhelming. Great art, dull story.

I most enjoyed Slash's brief contributions, such as saving Casey's ass and getting Leo's gear.

Cipher
11-30-2013, 10:44 PM
You know what would have made Dark Leo work?

1) Had he actually done something irredeemable

or

2) Had he not been brainwashed

And even then, jeez, did this arc really need that at all? Karai's frustrations and acceptance were interesting, but they could have been achieved in so many other ways.

CyberCubed
12-01-2013, 12:32 AM
I tend to think Dark Leo was inspired by that one episode of the 4kids cartoon where Oroku Saki tried to lure Leonardo into joining him and thinking he was on the good side...pretty sure it was in, "Shredder Strikes" from Season 1.

Given Tom has obviously watched a good chunk of 4kids it wouldn't surprise me.

Casey
12-01-2013, 01:55 PM
No. Alopex was a normal fox before. Shredder took her to the forest where he found her and had it burned down, including her original family of non-mutated foxes. It was some sort of test of loyalty or like, saying you're leaving your family and past behind when you join the Foot. Alopex obviously didn't see it that way.

I've read her micro, so I'm aware of all of that. I'm referring to her phrasing when she attacks The Shredder. To be fair, the turtles were "normal" before as well. They just happened to be reincarnated. My question is if anyone else thinks maybe Alopex is too.

Casey
12-01-2013, 01:58 PM
You know what would have made Dark Leo work?

1) Had he actually done something irredeemable

or

2) Had he not been brainwashed

And even then, jeez, did this arc really need that at all? Karai's frustrations and acceptance were interesting, but they could have been achieved in so many other ways.

I lean strongly towards #1. While I was a little annoyed at the whole brainwashing plot device, I got over it, but seeing him do something irredeemable would have made it all so much easier to stomach. Don't get me wrong, I'm a fan of the whole story arc, but this would have been nice.

Tazi
12-01-2013, 02:25 PM
I thought he would have his old memories back, after he kills one of his enemies in a battle, so then he starts remember to almost killing Slash, his brothers, Splinter, etc...
Well it was pretty similar actually, it's just not Leo, but Shredder killing Victor. Still it would have worked better if it was Leo.

ProphetofGanja
12-01-2013, 07:55 PM
loved the conclusion! I did have some critiques, but overall this was one of my favorite story arcs.

Redeemer
12-01-2013, 08:41 PM
loved the conclusion! I did have some critiques, but overall this was one of my favorite story arcs.

The ending was ok, it is actually my least favorite, bc it made dark Leo so weak.

Loved slash though. its interesting that Slash is actually a good guy now though.

Correct me if I am wrong, but this is the first incarnation were Slash is actually on the turtles side.

MikeandRaph87
12-01-2013, 08:52 PM
The ending was ok, it is actually my least favorite, bc it made dark Leo so weak.

Loved slash though. its interesting that Slash is actually a good guy now though.

Correct me if I am wrong, but this is the first incarnation were Slash is actually on the turtles side.

In Archie he starts off as a criminal banished to a prision planet for his crimes and his people and planet gone. Krang a fellow crminal convinces him that there is more out there for him and eventually after a draw with the TMNT the alien turtle is redeemed by the Mutanimals and aides the turtles sacrificng himself.

In the '87 cartoon he is a bad guy throughout all three of his appearances and in Nick is still ongoing and may just be tainted by the mutagen. At this point in the comics he seems to be a reformed villain/anti-hero while he is a villain in the cartoons though its early in the game in the Nick cartoon so it may change as it does seem to be the mutagen tainting his mind.

ctt4lfecw
12-01-2013, 08:59 PM
Wonderful book! Thank you TMNT staff!

Redeemer
12-01-2013, 11:15 PM
At this point in the comics he seems to be a reformed villain/anti-hero while he is a villain in the cartoons though its early in the game in the Nick cartoon so it may change as it does seem to be the mutagen tainting his mind.

Hmmm... interesting some of my favorite characters in the comic universe are anti-heroes.
I am curious if Slash will become smarter with time like in the OT, bc quite frankly I hate Re-tard slash. I dont mind a more animal like slash like he is in IDW, but in his first appearance of the OT he was stupid.

ToTheNines
12-01-2013, 11:30 PM
I am curious if Slash will become smarter with time like in the OT, bc quite frankly I hate Re-tard slash. I dont mind a more animal like slash like he is in IDW, but in his first appearance of the OT he was stupid.

I'm hoping Old Hob will hook him up with the psychotropic serum and up his IQ. Of course Stockgen is all exploded, but I remember Hob having a vile of Splinter's blood way back in the epilogue of Blood Brothers.

Vegeta
12-04-2013, 12:59 AM
I really have enjoyed how city fall helped develop hob into one of the most intriguing characters in the series. It is pretty much impossible for me to not like the hob and slash duo. Also i am going to miss the turtles church lair as it was such a fresh take on the typical sewers surroundings.

Redeemer
12-04-2013, 01:42 AM
^Have to agree Hob is quickly becoming one of my favorite Anti-Heroes :D

Rooish
12-04-2013, 11:30 AM
I just reread the Blood Brothers issues myself. It was quite surprising, the change in Hob's voice. He was very angry and psychotic sounding in those issues--now he is pretty laid back.

martinitolove
12-04-2013, 04:26 PM
The ark was good. To the creators I'd like to point out two subplots, that were not optimal from my point of view.

1. It was very surprising for me to see Alopex jump into the fight between Shredder and Splinter. Why did she save him? I've read all the previous issues and micros but still feel that this sudden reaction isn't organically coming out of the character's story.

2. I'd wish Casey had told his father that Shredder has stabbed him. This would be appropriate to slow Hun down for the tmnt to flee and let him ponder about the backstabbing boss he has. (But I suppose it will be revealed to him in a later story)

Otherwise I see Alopex entering Hob's Mutanimals very organically. They all have mutated from pure animals. And Alopex as this series' Ninjara will soon be Raphael's lover, I suppose.

Bebop & Rocksteady were the best in their own mini. Santoluco's design of them was way worse. They were much better in Shredder's mini as well. IDW should take care, that certain elements like R's feet or B' jacket stay the same under each artists feather.

So far Hob & Slash and Bebop & Rocksteady are my favourite characters. Please keep up the good work - you have the best turtle series EVER!!! :tgrin:

Toby Barrett
12-04-2013, 04:57 PM
Alopex wasn't saving Splinter. Shredder struck a nerve with her when he spoke of family, after just slaughtering her family in the Alopex issue.

TomWaltz
12-05-2013, 06:41 PM
The ark was good. To the creators I'd like to point out two subplots, that were not optimal from my point of view.

1. It was very surprising for me to see Alopex jump into the fight between Shredder and Splinter. Why did she save him? I've read all the previous issues and micros but still feel that this sudden reaction isn't organically coming out of the character's story.

2. I'd wish Casey had told his father that Shredder has stabbed him. This would be appropriate to slow Hun down for the tmnt to flee and let him ponder about the backstabbing boss he has. (But I suppose it will be revealed to him in a later story)

Otherwise I see Alopex entering Hob's Mutanimals very organically. They all have mutated from pure animals. And Alopex as this series' Ninjara will soon be Raphael's lover, I suppose.

Bebop & Rocksteady were the best in their own mini. Santoluco's design of them was way worse. They were much better in Shredder's mini as well. IDW should take care, that certain elements like R's feet or B' jacket stay the same under each artists feather.

So far Hob & Slash and Bebop & Rocksteady are my favourite characters. Please keep up the good work - you have the best turtle series EVER!!! :tgrin:

Hi, martinitolove!

Working on issue #32 as you read this, so gotta be quick:

1. Alopex is following through on her vow for revenge (for her family) at the end of her micro-series issue.

2. We haven't forgotten that Shredder stabbed Casey... and that info can be held away from Hun for only so long... tease, tease.

Thanks for reading! Back to Northampton for me...

Talk soon...

Tom W.

Rooish
12-05-2013, 07:29 PM
Otherwise I see Alopex entering Hob's Mutanimals very organically. They all have mutated from pure animals. And Alopex as this series' Ninjara will soon be Raphael's lover, I suppose.

Ew, I hope not. I don't really like one Turtle dating and the others being single... also dating a different species... also I like them being kind of angsty and alone, especially Raph. That's kind of his thing.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
12-07-2013, 10:54 AM
I like how Karai referred to Bebop and Rocksteady as mutant "hybrids". I guess in this universe, that's what you'd call mutants that were originally humans prior to being mutated. To be honest, I'm hoping that Bebop and Rocksteady are the only "hybrids", though, to keep them unique. That and I prefer mutants that started off as animals, but Bebop and Rocksteady would be the only characters where I'd make an exception for that (and I think it works best for them, anyway).

That being said... I wouldn't mind seeing some more mutants (of the "started off as animals" variety) come into the picture, in the future. We still need to see Leatherhead come in, at some point. :D