View Full Version : TMNT #29 Preview/ Discussion
DONATELLO DUZMACHINES
12-13-2013, 07:26 PM
From comic vine
http://www.comicvine.com/articles/exclusive-preview-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-29/1100-147742/
BabyTurtles
12-13-2013, 08:22 PM
ahhh!! cute turtles!! XD
I mean--this looks cool........love the art.
Plasticplayhouse
12-13-2013, 08:23 PM
Looks fantastic! Can't wait till Wednesday!
Technogeek29
12-13-2013, 08:29 PM
Like the little touch of drool from Raph.
BabyTurtles
12-13-2013, 08:37 PM
Like the little touch of drool from Raph.
...on a totally unrelated note...
I love your sig! the animation is cool!!
Technogeek29
12-13-2013, 08:39 PM
...on a totally unrelated note...
I love your sig! the animation is cool!!
Why thank you. apparently on Tumblr Don and Alopex are either an item or frenimies.
BabyTurtles
12-13-2013, 08:47 PM
Why thank you. apparently on Tumblr Don and Alopex are either an item or frenimies.
say whaaaat? O_o
Donnie's getting all the ladies on tumblr~ lol XD
CyberCubed
12-13-2013, 09:46 PM
I remember Bobby saying Nick shot down the idea of IDW using Pigeon Pete so it feels like this bird mutant was the alternative.
DONATELLO DUZMACHINES
12-13-2013, 11:44 PM
Im really digging Cambells art, I didnt know how I would feel after Santolouco killing it on City fall, but from these preview pages I really like it. I read an interview post City Fall that said hints for the new mutant being introduced in this arc could be seen in City fall, anyone have any guesses of who it will be?
Dirty Blond
12-14-2013, 12:19 AM
who it will be?
Check the March 2014 Solicitations thread.
Cipher
12-14-2013, 12:31 AM
This is Ross' best work on the series, and this small preview already puts him just behind Dan Duncan as my favorite artist on this series so far.
I love the way he draws April, and the Turtles all look great as well.
CyberCubed
12-14-2013, 12:43 AM
This is Ross' best work on the series, and this small preview already puts him just behind Dan Duncan as my favorite artist on this series so far.
I love the way he draws April, and the Turtles all look great as well.
True. Which blows my mind that when you click the link and read the comment section, so many people there are saying Ross' art is "horrible."
I don't understand those people. At least here in the TMNT fandom he gets nothing but love.
BabyTurtles
12-14-2013, 01:14 AM
True. Which blows my mind that when you click the link and read the comment section, so many people there are saying Ross' art is "horrible."
I don't understand those people. At least here in the TMNT fandom he gets nothing but love.
I looked at those comments!
I know everyone has their own tastes.....but still T^T
he's by far my favorite artist for the turtles~ everything is so clear and simple when he draws
funatic
12-14-2013, 01:25 AM
So psyched for this arc (and not just because I'm from Northampton and sent Ross some pics for reference). :trazz: Santolouco is amazing, and was perfectly suited for the epicness of City Fall, but Ross is equally phenomenal, and his softer style is a great match for this story of respite and recuperation. IDW has really done a commendable job of matching artist style to story tone in this series.
Casey
12-14-2013, 03:14 AM
Echoing what others have said about how fitting this style is. I'd like to also point out how great the color palette is for this setting. It's slightly softer (such as April's skin tones) and I think it gives everything a surreal almost dreamy quality. I was gonna save cash and switch back to trades, but after reading this preview Idk.
spookycookies
12-14-2013, 03:35 AM
Coming from someone who really enjoys the rest of the art, I'm not a fan of the way April is drawn here. It looks like she has a doll's head... It's sort of creepy in a way. Just her hair and face aren't really clicking with me. She looks years younger than she appeared an issue ago. I'm not hating on Ross or anything I think he does a great job with the TMNT and the beautiful countryside surroundings but I'm hoping the rest of his humans don't look so odd.
Cipher
12-14-2013, 10:04 AM
Echoing what others have said about how fitting this style is. I'd like to also point out how great the color palette is for this setting. It's slightly softer (such as April's skin tones) and I think it gives everything a surreal almost dreamy quality. I was gonna save cash and switch back to trades, but after reading this preview Idk.
Yep; really digging that.
Coming from someone who really enjoys the rest of the art, I'm not a fan of the way April is drawn here. It looks like she has a doll's head... It's sort of creepy in a way. Just her hair and face aren't really clicking with me. She looks years younger than she appeared an issue ago. I'm not hating on Ross or anything I think he does a great job with the TMNT and the beautiful countryside surroundings but I'm hoping the rest of his humans don't look so odd.
Agree to disagree then. I like the body type he gives her, and her expressiveness really stood out even in this small preview. This is actually my favorite visual take on April in the IDW series so far.
Casey looks a little wonky in the panels he's in, but there's not much to go on yet. Come to think of it, given that the Leonardo Micro consisted of 90-percent identically clad ninjas, this might be the first time I've seen Ross do a lot of work with human characters.
DONATELLO DUZMACHINES
12-14-2013, 10:11 AM
Check the March 2014 Solicitations thread.
Thanks for pointing me in that direction, hadn't seen those yet.
Plasticplayhouse
12-14-2013, 10:21 AM
True. Which blows my mind that when you click the link and read the comment section, so many people there are saying Ross' art is "horrible."
those comments are by the same ass pirates who hate on the art every time TMNT has an artist change. since day one those people were saying how much they hated:
Dan Duncan - how his work was "scribbly" and looked like garbage.
Andy Kuhn - that it was too blocky and the turtles had horse teeth.
Ben Bates - his stuff was "too cartoony" and "sucks" and his drawings had no life.
Mateus Santolouco - a stink was made over the stylized masks and how the turtles were so different looking from each other and even about mikey's teeth.
heck, even Kevin Eastman wasn't saved from those haters. they commented how "all of his new stuff sucks".
later, many of the haters would warm up to the changes of style. that's really all it takes. artist's change, styles change, EVERYTHING changes. like the collected trade says...change is constant. there is no greater truth.
to all the haters, give something a chance. allow yourself some time to warm up to it before you start making ignorant comments and make yourself look like a buffoon. you wont like everything and that's cool, but you can learn that everything has it's great points. like others have commented, IDW has done a fantastic job pairing styles to the various archs of the story. we have really been blessed thus far with this series.
I think critism is okay, and might mean there are some improvements needed on a certain area, like the way Kuhn draws the teeth of the turtles (btw, I really love Kuhn's art style), but the way those people criticize it on Comic Vine is ridicolous, they can't even tell the difference between the art the don't like, and art that is bad and a bungle. Ross is definitely not a bungler, his art is clean, the proportions are right and consistant, his style is unique, etc. They should see that, even if they hate his art style... But they really shouldn't hate it.
About the prev, I love it, can't wait to see what happens to Leo. I bet the way he treated Splinter at the end of City Fall wasn't just about the brainwashing. I mean, he has every right to hate Splinter: As the past, ha was murdered by Saki as an innocent child, and now his father and brothers left him to the Foot again at City Fall pt.1. It's obvious that Splinters intentions were never bad, but would you want to stay with your father even if you end up murdered? I'm not sure.
So I'm looking forward about how Leo will explain his experiences with the Foot to his and bros, and how he will move on.
Also, it's impossible to not point out that April has grown some fine booty. ;)
Vegeta
12-14-2013, 02:57 PM
I'm liking how April got the wet moon treatment with the thickness. :D
Vegeta
12-14-2013, 02:58 PM
So psyched for this arc (and not just because I'm from Northampton and sent Ross some pics for reference). :trazz: Santolouco is amazing, and was perfectly suited for the epicness of City Fall, but Ross is equally phenomenal, and his softer style is a great match for this story of respite and recuperation. IDW has really done a commendable job of matching artist style to story tone in this series.
Agreed, the frequent artist shifts has actually become exciting because they have all been so great and relevant to the story. One can't miss an artist too long either as they will probably be back for a micro. I love IDW.
BabyTurtles
12-14-2013, 04:33 PM
I'm liking how April got the wet moon treatment with the thickness. :D
I know right!
someone said she looked fat, but she looks curvy~ :D
True. Which blows my mind that when you click the link and read the comment section, so many people there are saying Ross' art is "horrible."
I don't understand those people. At least here in the TMNT fandom he gets nothing but love.Well I'm not a fan. Than again I wasn't going to buy the comic anyway.
Rooish
12-14-2013, 09:35 PM
I think the style is pretty good. I think Santolouco was better for drawing April and Casey, but I like Campbell's Turtles way better. He keeps the different body shapes/sizes but doesn't make Mikey and Donnie look like wusses. I'm really excited for a mellower arc.
The preview mentions a stowaway... given Ross's Deviant art, I'm guessing Alopex?
The preview mentions a stowaway... given Ross's Deviant art, I'm guessing Alopex?
Look at the March Solicitations thread at the cover.
yup, Alopex :)
ProphetofGanja
12-15-2013, 09:08 PM
this whole arc seems like its going to be awesome. I'm looking forward to seeing the Turtles have some downtime. and the conclusion looks like it'll be pretty exciting!
BabyTurtles
12-15-2013, 09:28 PM
I never buy comics (unless it's a book with a bunch of issues in it)
but I might buy these!! *_*
Rooish
12-15-2013, 10:21 PM
Does anyone else think it's funny that Raph and Mike are sitting on the couch in the van, leaving their broken-legged father to huddle on the floor?
Technogeek29
12-16-2013, 04:44 AM
Did anybody notice Donnie has a bruise where some of the bandage covering his leg is coming undone? Also the giant overview of the far shows the various places the covers following #29 take place.
Loving it just cant wait. :)
BabyTurtles
12-16-2013, 02:05 PM
Does anyone else think it's funny that Raph and Mike are sitting on the couch in the van, leaving their broken-legged father to huddle on the floor?
maybe he was uncomfortable sitting....on the couch...with his leg? XD
Blossombrooks
12-18-2013, 04:58 AM
I absolutely love the art in this issue but then I'm a sucker for RC's style. I'm also loving...
The inclusion of Alopex, she's an intriguing character and I can't wait to see her involvement in this arc. I wonder if she has a message for Leo too?
Not loving Raph's temper, I know he's a hothead but feel it was a tad overdone, still maybe it's justified considering what they've been through. I just wanted him to back off on his own merit and be the bigger person but perhaps that'll come later.
corvus
12-18-2013, 10:10 AM
arts good, story was disappointing, seemed short. Huge cliff hanger at the end
Redeemer
12-18-2013, 02:42 PM
I absolutely love the art in this issue but then I'm a sucker for RC's style. I'm also loving...
The inclusion of Alopex, she's an intriguing character and I can't wait to see her involvement in this arc. I wonder if she has a message for Leo too?
Not loving Raph's temper, I know he's a hothead but feel it was a tad overdone, still maybe it's justified considering what they've been through. I just wanted him to back off on his own merit and be the bigger person but perhaps that'll come later.
I was thinking this as well...I wonder if she will reveal to Leo the fact that shredder did brain wash him???
DrSpengler
12-18-2013, 07:29 PM
Here's my review of TMNT #29 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2013/12/tmnt-idw-29.html)
Well, I'm hoping that with the book slowing down we can get to know the characters again. They were kind of getting lost in all the story during "City Fall".
Alopex was the big surprise, as I wasn't anticipating seeing her so soon. Ought to be interesting to see how her relationship with the Turtles changes. I liked how Raph was the one to totally hate her guts and brought up how she lied to him about her origin in the past. Nice little pull there to make his resentment and suspicions toward her feel more legit (as well as pointing out that Leo's defense of her could just be residual Foot brainwashing).
The stuff with Alopex was the most interesting bit of the issue. There was some stilted dialogue (April's mom's melodramatic speech at the end) and as much as I love Campbell, he can get maybe a little *too* cute with the characters from time to time, but all in all it was a nice change up.
Dunno if the book'll be staying in Northampton for more than just the 4 issues, but I hope the characters will get to start growing again.
Coola Yagami
12-18-2013, 07:45 PM
http://markandpaigerodriguez.blogspot.com/2013/12/idw-tmnt-29-northampton-part-1.html My own review. I literally turned off my comp to make sure I wouldn't get spoiled by Spengler or anyone else before I got to read this. It's about time we see April with both her parents.
MikeandRaph87
12-18-2013, 07:47 PM
Here's my review of TMNT #29 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2013/12/tmnt-idw-29.html)
Well, I'm hoping that with the book slowing down we can get to know the characters again. They were kind of getting lost in all the story during "City Fall".
Alopex was the big surprise, as I wasn't anticipating seeing her so soon. Ought to be interesting to see how her relationship with the Turtles changes. I liked how Raph was the one to totally hate her guts and brought up how she lied to him about her origin in the past. Nice little pull there to make his resentment and suspicions toward her feel more legit (as well as pointing out that Leo's defense of her could just be residual Foot brainwashing).
The stuff with Alopex was the most interesting bit of the issue. There was some stilted dialogue (April's mom's melodramatic speech at the end) and as much as I love Campbell, he can get maybe a little *too* cute with the characters from time to time, but all in all it was a nice change up.
Dunno if the book'll be staying in Northampton for more than just the 4 issues, but I hope the characters will get to start growing again.
The solicit for #32 states they were being chased out of Northampton just as they were New York City. Most likely has to do with Shredder's pet hawk now a mutant giving them trouble.
I wonder if all the way back with Raphael one shot that the IDW gang knew Shredder's ritual would back fire and she would make nice with the TMNT or if it came into play later?
April's father retired from StockGen on disability I see. Interesting and makes inspiration for April's interest in biology. What do her parents know of the ooze variant of mutagen that seems to be a big deal?
Ninjinister
12-18-2013, 09:16 PM
It's good to have a nice "breather" episode after such a giant event. Even if we do have Alopex skulking around and Koya butting in eventually, this is destined to be much slower than the previous arc.
MikeandRaph87
12-18-2013, 09:25 PM
Here is a better look at Koya,Shredder's pet hawk. I did not realize the mutant was already named and was female. That helps diversify the gender of mutants more.
http://mooncalfe.deviantart.com/art/TMNT-Koya-419904422
CyberCubed
12-18-2013, 10:18 PM
Was IDW not allowed to name April's Dad, "Kirby" because they can't use Nick created characters outside the cartoon comic?
Coola Yagami
12-18-2013, 10:20 PM
Was IDW not allowed to name April's Dad, "Kirby" because they can't use Nick created characters outside the cartoon comic?
No, they just wanted to make an entirely new and completely different character.
CyberCubed
12-18-2013, 10:22 PM
No, they just wanted to make an entirely new and completely different character.
The reason I ask is Kirby appeared in episode 1 back in 2012 and this comic was written at least a year later. Tom Waltz would obviously know of Kirby.
Kirby technically counts as a new Nick created character so I wonder if they didn't want IDW naming April's dad the same thing.
Cipher
12-18-2013, 10:22 PM
Was IDW not allowed to name April's Dad, "Kirby" because they can't use Nick created characters outside the cartoon comic?
Why should they name him Kirby when that has always been a completely separate character in the TMNT mythos outside of the Nick cartoon?
There's nothing wrong with it either way, but there's no reason to follow suit just because Nick did it. My guess is we'll see a separate "Kirby" again at some point in the TMNT franchise; no reason to conflate that name with April's dad forever.
Speaking of which -- Was April's dad unnamed throughout the entirety of Mirage? He's a plot point in the first few issues and in "City at War," and there's the flashback to April's origin in Volume 4. While I don't remember us getting a name at any of those points, I could be wrong.
Coola Yagami
12-18-2013, 10:26 PM
Why should they name him Kirby when that has always been a completely separate character in the TMNT mythos outside of the Nick cartoon?
There's nothing wrong with it either way, but there's no reason to follow suit just because Nick did it. My guess is we'll see a separate "Kirby" again at some point in the TMNT franchise; no reason to conflate that name with April's dad forever.
Speaking of which -- Was April's dad unnamed throughout the entirety of Mirage? He's a plot point in the first few issues and in "City at War," and there's the flashback to April's origin in Volume 4, and while I don't remember us getting a name at any of those points, I could be wrong.
Exactly. It's just a different version. Same reason we don't see Angel with the Purple Dragons or Old Hob in the Nick toon. Same reason we don't have Snakeweed in the IDW comics. They're both doing their own thing.
Bobby Curnow
12-18-2013, 10:32 PM
Tom named the character, so he is the one who should speak to the question, but when I think of Kirby in regards to TMNT, I think of the Mirage Don micro Kirby (aka, the King, Jack Kirby), and this obviously isn't that character. Had nothing to do with Nicktoon.
Coola Yagami
12-18-2013, 10:37 PM
Tom named the character, so he is the one who should speak to the question, but when I think of Kirby in regards to TMNT, I think of the Mirage Don micro Kirby (aka, the King, Jack Kirby), and this obviously isn't that character. Had nothing to do with Nicktoon.
Am I the only one that thinks of a flying pink blob that eats everything when I heard the name Kirby?
TheJ-manTurtleMan
12-18-2013, 11:26 PM
I LOVE Raphael's expression on page 14! Ross Campbell is the best!
Tinus
12-19-2013, 03:18 AM
Great issue! I love the art on this one...so different than the previous arc.
Leo is having a hard time in this one. I liked his line when he was talking to Splinter: "you're not my master Yoshi". :o
Living Silver
12-19-2013, 03:39 AM
Since I'm new here, I don't know what the rules are regarding how long after an issue is released that we are expected to use spoiler tags. I'll play it safe and put them up for now. I agree with whoever above said that this issue seemed too short- but I think that's because it was so good! Campbell's art is very easy on the eye and super simple to follow. There was even a bonus TWO pages beyond the modern industry standard (20), and even with that the book felt short.
I can't get the "multi-quote" buttons to work, but I was intending to reply to people talking about how April is drawn "curvy" here. One of the awesome things about Campbell's art is that he can draw many types of women. If you've ever read Glory, he really demonstrates his versatility in this domain. It's kind of a rarity these days, when every woman in mainstream comics generally have the same body type.
I hope that Aloplex becomes a good guy. I love her. I'm pretty pissed at Raph for being such a dick to her. I realize that it's in character for him, but he goes a little overboard here.
FoxZerro
12-19-2013, 10:03 AM
Regarding Raph's temper you need to consider his view on this whole thing. He was on his own for a year and when he found his family again he embraced them with open arms. Not only that but based on what he has seen from his time with Splinter and his Brothers family is the most important thing.
When he sees Leonardo, basically cast aside his family, because of what happened to him that is going to incense him and naturally eventually he is going to have a reaction to the anger. Family is a paramount of the IDW series and considering how deeply ingrained in the Raph story it has been (him first being welcomed into the family and then watching as Splinter accepted his friend in as member of the family as well) his actions due to Leonardo being so against the help of them is completely in line with his character.
Not to mention that Splinter being the only one who could truly get him to stop spoke volumes about paying attention to character development since the entire conversation during issues 13 and 14 was about anger and learning to control it. I believe that Leonardo forsaking him as a student and son is making Splinter as angry as it is making Raphael but age and wisdom are allowing him to keep it in check.
Coola Yagami
12-19-2013, 10:31 AM
Regarding Raph's temper you need to consider his view on this whole thing. He was on his own for a year and when he found his family again he embraced them with open arms. Not only that but based on what he has seen from his time with Splinter and his Brothers family is the most important thing.
When he sees Leonardo, basically cast aside his family, because of what happened to him that is going to incense him and naturally eventually he is going to have a reaction to the anger. Family is a paramount of the IDW series and considering how deeply ingrained in the Raph story it has been (him first being welcomed into the family and then watching as Splinter accepted his friend in as member of the family as well) his actions due to Leonardo being so against the help of them is completely in line with his character.
Not to mention that Splinter being the only one who could truly get him to stop spoke volumes about paying attention to character development since the entire conversation during issues 13 and 14 was about anger and learning to control it. I believe that Leonardo forsaking him as a student and son is making Splinter as angry as it is making Raphael but age and wisdom are allowing him to keep it in check.
Plus look at Leo's attitude. He's still not completely there and still treats his brothers as outsiders It makes him look bad to be defending alopex and for all they know Leo and alopex could be leading the foot to them. Plus alopex did introduce herself with a fake sob story so it makes sense that raph wouldn't be so quick to believe it a second time. Remember just cause we know alopex is slowly turning a new leaf doesn't mean the characters have to be idiots and blindly take her in. I'd say Raph's anger is completely justified given the situation.
Redeemer
12-19-2013, 10:32 AM
Since I'm new here, I don't know what the rules are regarding how long after an issue is released that we are expected to use spoiler tags.
Considering many members live overseas and have to either wait for their local shop to aquire the book, have it shipped to them from the states or even wait for the trades I would wait a month at least. I personally always use spoiler tags no matter how old the book is.
TomWaltz
12-19-2013, 11:50 AM
Plus look at Leo's attitude. He's still not completely there and still treats his brothers as outsiders It makes him look bad to be defending alopex and for all they know Leo and alopex could be leading the foot to them. Plus alopex did introduce herself with a fake sob story so it makes sense that raph wouldn't be so quick to believe it a second time. Remember just cause we know alopex is slowly turning a new leaf doesn't mean the characters have to be idiots and blindly take her in. I'd say Raph's anger is completely justified given the situation.
Plus, you know, Leo KICKED him! It's hard not to blow your top when someone sucker kicks you, even your brother. :)
Thanks for the cool discussion, folks! I promise, we have plenty more interactions coming between all these characters. Really excited for everyone to see issue #30 -- Ross and Ronda have upped their already awesome games and then some… it's beautiful!
Talk soon…
Tom W.
Technogeek29
12-19-2013, 12:08 PM
Plus, you know, Leo KICKED him! It's hard not to blow your top when someone sucker kicks you, even you brother. :)
Thanks for the cool discussion, folks! I promise, we have plenty more interactions coming between all these characters. Really excited for everyone to see issue #30 -- Ross and Ronda have upped their already awesome games and then some… it's beautiful!
Talk soon…
Tom W.
2nd favorite Turtle is on the cover, I'm sold!
got this issue #28 animated #6 and Ultimate collection number 5 all in all a good day. I did like that the Turtles didn't take what Alopex said out of blind faith and Splinter pretty much said "I owe you , but I don't trust you" Casey meeting April's parents went as well as mine did with my girlfriends parents. Informal, very comfortable around strangers so long as their daughter says he's cool. and ended with me staying the night even though I only live 15 minutes away. was a little bit of a quick read but I burn through novels pretty fast so a comic is lucky if it takes me 3 minutes to read.
Edit: Anyone notice in Mirage April's dad died from the stroke but here he fought the good fight? could be coincidence but just thought I point it out.
Coola Yagami
12-19-2013, 02:15 PM
I was wondering if his stroke was cause something at stockgen or if he will die during this storyline.
AquaParade
12-19-2013, 03:27 PM
This is the first issue in the main series that I haven't picked up on day one. Decided to save myself a drive and order it from an online store. Somewhere in the last year this book has sort of lost me. I'm still along for the ride, I'm just not sure for how much longer.
MikeandRaph87
12-19-2013, 05:28 PM
Plus, you know, Leo KICKED him! It's hard not to blow your top when someone sucker kicks you, even your brother. :)
Thanks for the cool discussion, folks! I promise, we have plenty more interactions coming between all these characters. Really excited for everyone to see issue #30 -- Ross and Ronda have upped their already awesome games and then some… it's beautiful!
Talk soon…
Tom W.
How about some teaser images after the new year? Nothing makes me more eager to get to the shop during my lunch hour on the release date!:D
Can you give any info on how Koya was created, as far as "hey there could be a bird mutant to indirectly replace Alopex, how about a hawk?" or something else?
Cant wait to read this issue loving the series. tmnt is the comic I look forward to the most each month. I wish Sonic would pick up tho I'm losing interest in that series fast went downhill for me when it had the crossover with megaman.
TomWaltz
12-19-2013, 07:13 PM
How about some teaser images after the new year? Nothing makes me more eager to get to the shop during my lunch hour on the release date!:D
Can you give any info on how Koya was created, as far as "hey there could be a bird mutant to indirectly replace Alopex, how about a hawk?" or something else?
Teasers after the New Year, I promise!
In the meantime, a bit of trivia for you (and an answer to your question). I was inspired to bring Koya into the mix after I found this amazing fable online:
http://zeluna.net/japanese-fairy-tales-thetheswordedfalcon.html
We were planning on creating a new mutant eventually, and this was the story that gave me the idea to turn Shredder's feathery pet into our newest baddie. All design credit goes to Ross Campbell, though, and what an awesome design it is!
Talk soon…
Tom W.
MikeandRaph87
12-19-2013, 07:35 PM
Teasers after the New Year, I promise!
In the meantime, a bit of trivia for you (and an answer to your question). I was inspired to bring Koya into the mix after I found this amazing fable online:
http://zeluna.net/japanese-fairy-tales-thetheswordedfalcon.html
We were planning on creating a new mutant eventually, and this was the story that gave me the idea to turn Shredder's feathery pet into our newest baddie. All design credit goes to Ross Campbell, though, and what an awesome design it is!
Talk soon…
Tom W.
Awesome! Thanks again,Mr. Waltz! Also, for clarification on is Koya a hawk or falcon.
http://www.killthehydra.com/wp-content/uploads/waynes-world-cool-story-bro-meme1.jpg
Powder
12-19-2013, 09:16 PM
Maybe I'm strange but I honestly feel like this was one of the best issues of the entire book. Aside from loving where Ross has settled style-wise, I loved this number because of its focus. It had one setting, one cast. I'm so sick of the typical format where it goes back and forth with different groups and scenarios every two pages, that pacing irks me to no end. Here we finally get to take a breath, and actually talk about things instead of grazing over them. It's a blessing to have something mellow and text-heavy, that has depth without being melodramatic or cliche. It didn't feel like a written for trade issue for once. As I said in the beginning of my post, now that Ross seems to have found his groove with his version of the IDW turtles, I'm really really digging it. The character designs for April & Casey are particularly nice (as Vegeta said, it's nice to see her lookin' thick, too). I liked his Leonardo issue, but in all honesty, it fell a little flat for me in comparison to his past work and assorted fan art pieces. This, however, man... I want him to be the main artist, period. I love Mateus' work, I REALLY do, but I feel like it's just a little too commercial for the turtles, personally. Everything about their past books has always screamed indie, and so I've been a bit put off by the "big 2"-esque art... Ross really gives it that underground feel, despite how polished it is. It doesn't conform to industry standards, where all humans have this same comic booky face & such. It's unique, and soft, but still packs a punch. & I hope neither RC or MS take offense should they see these comments, I adore them both. Anyway, really really solid stuff here.
Plasticplayhouse
12-20-2013, 10:50 AM
man i LOVED this book! this is going to be a great arch. i agree with powder that it is refreshing to see a more mellow issue/arch that is rich in story and depth after the last action packed arch (which was also amazing!). the art is amazing. i love April's new look and am just thrilled in general :)
Rooish
12-20-2013, 11:23 AM
I liked this issue too. It did feel a little short for some reason--but maybe all comics do. Personally I'm a much bigger fan of character development than action. I enjoyed the first 5 or 6 issues of IDW where there was lots of talking--and I'm glad there has been talking moments throughout, because books feel way too short if they are all action.
I love Campbell's art. I can see how the detail Santolouco provides looks more "mainstream," and I prefer his humans, whereas Campbell's art is almost "cute," but I like that although Campbell draws the Turtles with different builds, they don't look too different. They looked too unequal with Santolouco and Mike's buckteeth were practically ruining the comic for me.
I am seriously worried about Alopex ending up with one of the Turtles though. I'd rather they stay single. Their in-family interactions are not fully developed yet.
It's fun that Raph is developing into the pissy turtle we all remember, but Don has lost his IDW edge! I hope it returns.
ProphetofGanja
12-20-2013, 02:02 PM
I loved this issue! While I prefer Santolouco's art I think Ross Campbell's is perfect for the issue. One question about April: does anyone really still wear top pony tails like that??
I didn't expect to be so damn intrigued by the end of this issue. I'm going to be wondering all month how April's parents and Stockgen tie in to everything
liugeaux
12-20-2013, 03:35 PM
You really can't beat the action sequences drawn by Santolouco, or Bates, but Campbell's art carries so much more emotion that so far his style fits the somber unsteady nature of the story that's being told.
This issue was a breath of fresh air...not that City-Fall was bad, it was just so tense and fastpaced.
Mr._Mutant_Man
12-21-2013, 08:49 PM
It's been a while since I participated in comic discussion, but I just read this issue and I wanted to come in and say that I loved it!
I like the character development with Alopex, and seeing Leo have to overcome his brainwashing. Campbell nailed it on Splinter's expression after Leonardo's comment. I really felt for the poor rat.
I really liked the way April was drawn in this issue. It's good to see that it wasn't just my imagination that she was drawn to be curvy. It's nice to see that April has a different body type than the average comic book girl. I hope any future artists on the book stick with April being a little heavier. It reminds me of the Invincible comic where Atom Eve gained some weight. I almost expected Mrs. O'Neil to point it out.
I also liked the little details, like the way April is pressing her toes down on the floor during the meeting with her parents. Maybe she's supposed to be a little nervous with how her parents meeting meeting Casey goes? It was a good way to express emotion through the character's body language.
Can't wait until part 2!
Raven
12-21-2013, 10:33 PM
This book has became a must read, it feels like you guys have struck your groove and are moving away from the typical "Hey guys, heres another TMNT character from the past were updating".
While thats fun, this issue really sucked me into the characters and drama that you have been amazingly crafting. Just when I think you guys are hitting the bottom of the well, you keep coming up with more gold for us to cherish!
Keep it going, this is in my must read for anyone out there.
Redeemer
12-22-2013, 07:23 AM
I like the character development with Alopex, and seeing Leo have to overcome his brainwashing. Campbell nailed it on Splinter's expression after Leonardo's comment. I really felt for the poor rat.
I also liked the little details, like the way April is pressing her toes down on the floor during the meeting with her parents. Maybe she's supposed to be a little nervous with how her parents meeting meeting Casey goes? It was a good way to express emotion through the character's body language.
Can't wait until part 2!
Great observation I thought Ross nailed it on character's facial expressions!
I also agree with Raven, The series is really hitting its stride.
DONATELLO DUZMACHINES
12-22-2013, 09:44 AM
Loved this issue! Really great stuff, I really loved Campbell s art as everybody says it really fits the story. I like what he' s done with April reminds me of what Ryan Ottley did on Invincible when he made Adam Eve thicker, I think it gives a more realistic depiction of varying body types. I cant wait for Santolouco's return but this is some good work from Campbell. I cant wait to see what Aprils mom has to say about Mr. O'Neil's time working at stockgen. Really looking forward to the focus on Mikey next issue, I also the #30 has the best cover of the entire series so far with #28 running a close second .
BabyTurtles
12-24-2013, 12:16 AM
I got it! woot!
:3 I loved it~ I like the way Campbell draws Alopex! I also like curvy April! can she always be curvy? cause it's cute.
can't wait for #30 cause Mikey! *__* (he's a lefty!!)
Mr._Mutant_Man
12-26-2013, 01:36 AM
I also like curvy April! can she always be curvy? cause it's cute.
I've always liked the art on the IDW books, but this past issue has the best design for April O'Neil. I'd like to see it as an aspect of IDW's April O'Neil, that she's a little "bottom heavy". It doesn't have to get brought up all the time, but it finally gives her a distinct look.
Redeemer
12-26-2013, 01:52 AM
I got it! woot!
:3 I loved it~ I like the way Campbell draws Alopex! I also like curvy April! can she always be curvy? cause it's cute.
can't wait for #30 cause Mikey! *__* (he's a lefty!!)
Ross does draw an awesome Alopex :D
Powder
12-26-2013, 02:08 AM
It doesn't have to get brought up all the time,
No?
Interesting to see this thread again, especially since I just got done discussing the way April was drawn in the latest issue of the IDW comic. The current artist is drawing April with a curvier figure.
It's kind of getting me thinking, there are so many different versions of April over the years, why not one that's plus sized? They tried it out with Invincible's girlfriend in that comic, and it was interesting to see a character with a different body type than the usual superheroine.
My interest has been rekindled with issue #29. Looking forward to where things are going with the characters.
I also think that this issue is the best April O'Neil has been drawn in the series so far. I hope they stick with the "pear shape" she had in this issue.
I really liked the way April was drawn in this issue. It's good to see that it wasn't just my imagination that she was drawn to be curvy. It's nice to see that April has a different body type than the average comic book girl. I hope any future artists on the book stick with April being a little heavier. It reminds me of the Invincible comic where Atom Eve gained some weight. I almost expected Mrs. O'Neil to point it out.
It's all you've been doing. :tlol:
ah, Powder got you hard :lol:
Mr._Mutant_Man
12-26-2013, 08:04 AM
No?
It's all you've been doing. :tlol:
:toops: Got a wee bit carried away. I guess I was really interested in getting other 'Dromer's opinions on it.
I meant in the context of the story, like they don't necessarily have to have to make it a constant soapbox thing on April being full figured and proud.
Rooish
12-26-2013, 10:25 AM
I love a full figured April, as well as a black April as Eastman originally intended it. But I barely noticed that she was full figured.. she just looks normal to me!
too much talk bout booty, for a change, let's make 3 new topics about judith hoag's legs :lol:
BODYCOUNT
12-27-2013, 12:01 AM
They got April pushing 150. Looking good AF. Thick thighs an booty. Mmmm. Nice way to slow down the series let other things develop and put them in a setting where anything can happen...but I just have a feeling come summer time *kevin hart voice* "its about to go down".
jerome
12-29-2013, 07:20 PM
I don't post very much in the forums but this issue really made me want to come on here and let Tom know how much I enjoyed it. I was sorta let down by city fall...It didn't really have the emotional weight I was hoping for and it just felt like a bunch of things happening for no real reason and there wasn't much city falling going on. I was beginning to think this book had lost me. But not now. I'm back on board and can't wait for issue 30! And I hope Ross stays around for a while. I think he is my favorite TMNT artist ever.
DONATELLO DUZMACHINES
12-31-2013, 11:32 PM
I love a full figured April, as well as a black April as Eastman originally intended it. But I barely noticed that she was full figured.. she just looks normal to me!
I didn't know that Eastman originally intended April to be black. Out of curiosity what changed?
LittleBlueHero
01-03-2014, 11:25 AM
Aside from the book itself being a wonderful little gem. I want to personally applaud the cover.
The Point of View, the depth of field and the colors all work here making it quite possibly my favorite cover so far. There is just something about the turtles in a Fall Setting that makes me feel calm and retrospective. Just like the book itself.
Casey
01-03-2014, 11:39 AM
I didn't know that Eastman originally intended April to be black. Out of curiosity what changed?
I've seen ppl on here deny that she was, but one can clearly see by her hair type and facial features that she is most likely African American. I never knew that Eastman said this. I think her skin tone on some of the covers is that of a light-skinned black woman. I am under the assumption that other artists interpretation changed her slowly and the OT probably solidified her change in race. The last name beckons to red hair for sure.
Bring on the fiery disagreements.
Dirty Blond
01-03-2014, 12:23 PM
Also, it's impossible to not point out that April has grown some fine booty. ;)
I bet the stress of the events of City Fall caused April's thyroid to go out of balance, resulting in her weight gain. She probably needs to go on hormone therapy or something.
Just watch, they will address this in the next issue.
Andrew NDB
01-03-2014, 12:33 PM
I've seen ppl on here deny that she was
And I've seen Kevin and Peter deny she was, so that's all I really need to see. Perhaps she was a "fake and baker," such as was the rage in the 80s. Who knows.
She seemed africanish to me, but the hair explains nothing, that was a common popular type of hairdo in the 80s.
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_4w4ap__Zl90/TI7peR__wMI/AAAAAAAADU4/GVZnYIXu9Es/s1600/cher80s10.jpg
I can't put in words how much I hate Cher.
resulting in her weight gain. She probably needs to go on hormone therapy or something.
Doesn't that work the opposite way? Like people gain weight as the negative result of hormone therapy?
Casey
01-03-2014, 01:42 PM
And I've seen Kevin and Peter deny she was, so that's all I really need to see. Perhaps she was a "fake and baker," such as was the rage in the 80s. Who knows.
Thanks for the confirmation. I never knew they denied it. It's weird how many ppl say she looks African American. Do they ever discuss how she has black facial features and hair-type? I guess that big curly hair was popular with white women as well in the 80's.
Casey
01-03-2014, 01:44 PM
She seemed africanish to me, but the hair explains nothing, that was a common popular type of hairdo in the 80s.
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_4w4ap__Zl90/TI7peR__wMI/AAAAAAAADU4/GVZnYIXu9Es/s1600/cher80s10.jpg
I can't put in words how much I hate Cher.
Doesn't that work the opposite way? Like people gain weight as the negative result of hormone therapy?
Sorry, just saw your post. Nice reference haha.
Casey
01-03-2014, 01:47 PM
But seriously though...
RaphaelsIsolation
01-03-2014, 05:10 PM
I really enjoyed this issue... it wasn't intense really.. very laid back, the atmosphere is perfect. My fav time of the year is basically the end of september to the middle of Feb or so.
This book is in the fall time and it was just killer art. I do like Mateus' art, but I actually like Campbell's art the best.
All of the artists that have been on this book have been really really good. Campbell's art is probably my favorite. Duncan is up there too, I like his Turtles a lot, but just overall... I love the way Campbell draws them. It has a older feel to it for me.
The 4 covers I've seen are just amazing... #29 which I have in hand is probably in my top 5 covers. There's a lot of pretty covers in TMNT too! It is definitley top 10
Sorry to rag on about this, I'm almost 30 years old... and TMNT makes me feel like a little kid again lol
Even though I love Ross' art, I still wouldn't want him permanent. I think a artist change every 4-8 issues is good anyways. I hope to God he comes back later on.
The Alopex B cover from Ross is just amazing too.
Dying for #30
MikeandRaph87
01-03-2014, 05:49 PM
Yeah, I am dying for #30 too. What is the release date for it again? Tom did promise me we would get a teaser panel or two within the next week. So we have that to keep us guessing and appease us at the same time.
As for black or white April,why not ask Peter Laird on his TMNT blog? If not I can save it to ask Kevin in person in a few months.
Casey
01-03-2014, 06:04 PM
Yeah, I am dying for #30 too. What is the release date for it again? Tom did promise me we would get a teaser panel or two within the next week. So we have that to keep us guessing and appease us at the same time.
As for black or white April,why not ask Peter Laird on his TMNT blog? If not I can save it to ask Kevin in person in a few months.
I didn't consider asking Peter. If others are saying that they have already confirmed that she was white though, I can't see any reason asking.
tiger
01-08-2014, 12:12 PM
Dromers, what were your favorite pages from #29?
Mr._Mutant_Man
01-08-2014, 09:49 PM
Dromers, what were your favorite pages from #29?
Page 18. I mentioned it before, but I like the way Campbell drew April's foot pressing on the floor. It's such a little detail, but to me it shows that she's nervous about Casey meeting her parents. I like little body language things like that.
Redeemer
01-08-2014, 10:47 PM
Page 18. I mentioned it before, but I like the way Campbell drew April's foot pressing on the floor. It's such a little detail, but to me it shows that she's nervous about Casey meeting her parents. I like little body language things like that.
Have to agree I love Ross's art in this book, I hope he has improved on his fight scenes since the Leo One Shot:D
RaphaelsIsolation
01-08-2014, 10:58 PM
there's a lot of pages that are my fav, but a couple that stand out would be..
the overview scene of the farm and the lake... the splash look if you call it that...
it's both pages.
also the scene of splinter talking sense into raph and such
lastly I really liked the alopex last page, her staring at leo.
really neat feel for that
RaphaelsIsolation
01-08-2014, 10:58 PM
Have to agree I love Ross's art in this book, I hope he has improved on his fight scenes since the Leo One Shot:D
I thought that book was great... loved it.
nimajneb
01-15-2014, 03:47 AM
It looks like Northampton is a fantastic bookend for City fall, after reading this it certainly seems that way.
IDW can do wrong. No. Wrong.
You can really feel the tension boiling of the page between the turtles after everything that'd happened.
I also like the similarities between the 2003 cartoons 'hampton eps and #29 too.
ToTheNines
01-20-2014, 10:20 PM
Got this on release date, but never got around to writing up a little blurb.
First of all, Campbell rocked it. His layouts, especially the first 5 pages or so were SO cinematic. Awesome stuff.
Story wise, I liked it even though it was the calm after the climax of the previous arc. Two major gripes though: Leo and Alopex. I understand Leo is messed up or whatever, but I can tell I'm gonna get real tired of his mood swings. I know we're not supposed to understand what is going on in his head, but contradictions are just weird.
Alopex... wtf. I was really digging her following them to Mass, but then out of ****ing no where she's just like "I don't need you" and walks away right after Splinter reached out to her. Ugh.
Everyone else was good though, despite April's mom being corny. I'm interested to see where the Stockgen connection goes.
One more nitpick: I've given up on trying to trace the passage of time as far as a calendar year goes, I know a chunk of time passed over the course of City Fall, but there's no way it's Fall already. Yet Campbell has the O'Neil house decorated with Halloween stuff. Oh well.
skylord
01-21-2014, 05:35 AM
Alopex... wtf. I was really digging her following them to Mass, but then out of ****ing no where she's just like "I don't need you" and walks away right after Splinter reached out to her. Ugh.
It makes sense. It looks like she was just going to run away until Raph spotted her. While Splinter reached out to her, her presence only made matters worse. I doubt she felt welcome and it's more realistic that it takes time for her to warm up to them. I would've hated for her to just become friends right away.
Was it rude? Yes, but it was a little necessary to keep her in character.
Candy Kappa
01-21-2014, 05:44 AM
I didn't consider asking Peter. If others are saying that they have already confirmed that she was white though, I can't see any reason asking.
She was in one of the mirage colored issues colored as African American, but as far as I know, that happened only once. And the canon is highly debatable since she was a news reporter in that issue.
ToTheNines
01-21-2014, 09:38 AM
I would've hated for her to just become friends right away.
That wouldn't have worked either, but she goes from her little "I gots no place to go" sob story and does a complete 180 in the matter of like two panels.
skylord
01-21-2014, 03:22 PM
That wouldn't have worked either, but she goes from her little "I gots no place to go" sob story and does a complete 180 in the matter of like two panels.
I wouldn't call it a complete 180. I never got the vibe that she was trying to become friends with them/join them by telling her story. She was just explaining why she was there and that she wasn't there to fight them. I assume that she planned to hide away in the forest or something and find a new life far away from the foot clan. That will definitely change because we know she is sticking around. We will see more of her intentions in the next issue.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.