PDA

View Full Version : Why do the colorized versions of Mirage look so awful?


Casey
12-28-2013, 12:23 AM
First, I am referring to the IDW colorized volumes that fill in the gaps between their ultimate volumes. Not the "Color Classics" that they released as well.

I understand that the black and white duo shade paper is what possibly gave these outlandish characters their grit and allowed them to be silly without being stupid, but why do the recently colorized versions look so goofy and cartoonish?

Any thoughts?

Powder
12-28-2013, 12:41 AM
Because the guys coloring it are not fit for the job & whoever is supposed to do quality control is in a coma.

Casey
12-28-2013, 12:49 AM
Because the guys coloring it are not fit for the job & whoever is supposed to do quality control is in a coma.

This is what I was afraid of. It's been so confusing because the idea is kind of fun. I'd almost just rather wait until we get a real "Ultimate Collection" that can print them all together. I can't even look at that poorly colored trash.

Cipher
12-28-2013, 12:52 AM
I think part of it -- and I won't get into the conversations on how "such and such character was supposed to be colored such and such", as even the largely excellent "Color Classics" have those issues -- is that there doesn't seem to be a different approach to the coloring based on the art. It's all brightly colored, digital sheen.

Which means that while sometimes, in the case of the first two Tales books, for example, it looks pairs well with the art and looks quite good, it also means those occurrences are basically happy accidents. Just as often, it doesn't gel. Post-2000s Lawson artwork demands flatter, bolder solid colors to compliment it, and we don't get that on Tales Vol. 2 #2, leading to a washed-out-looking bit of cartooning. Remender's "Worms of Madness" art had a perfect marriage with the colors assigned to it on its covers -- all solid and purple-hued. The brightly lit, shaded, brown sewers of its colorized version, while they would look fine with any number of other stories, consequently feel out of place. Finally, and particularly in the Vol. 1 material, you have stories which made use of their own duotones, an element not incorporated nearly as skilfully as it is into the "Color Classics" volumes because, again, there's no change up from the standard digital sheen (example, Vol. 1 #44, "The Violent Underground").

I'll go on record as saying that I think complaints with the coloring in these volumes are vastly overstated. I own every one, and for every issue that completely misses the mark, there's one that works quite well. Some even look excellent. But none look as good as new color material or even the "Color Classics" volumes, and that, I think, speaks to the fact that more care and variation could be put into the way the team approaches each issue.

Casey
12-28-2013, 12:58 AM
I think part of it -- and I won't get into the conversations on how "such and such character was supposed to be colored such and such", as even the largely excellent "Color Classics" have those issues -- is that there doesn't seem to be a different approach to the coloring based on the art. It's all brightly colored, digital sheen.

Which means that while sometimes, in the case of the first two Tales books, for example, it looks pairs well with the art and looks quite good, it also means those occurrences are basically happy accidents. Just as often, it doesn't gel. Post-2000s Lawson artwork demands flatter, bolder solid colors to compliment it, and we don't get that on Tales Vol. 2 #2, leading to a washed-out-looking bit of cartooning. Remender's "Worms of Madness" art had a perfect marriage with the colors assigned to it on its covers -- all solid and purple-hued. The brightly lit, shaded, brown sewers of its colorized version, while they would look fine with any number of other stories, consequently feel out of place. Finally, and particularly in the Vol. 1 material, you have stories which made use of their own duotones, an element not incorporated nearly as skilfully as it is into the "Color Classics" volumes because, again, there's no change up from the standard digital sheen (example, Vol. 1 #44, "The Violent Underground").

I'll go on record as saying that I think complaints with the coloring in these volumes are vastly overstated. I own every one, and for every issue that completely misses the mark, there's one that works quite well. Some even look excellent. But none look as good as new color material or even the "Color Classics" volumes, and that, I think, speaks to the fact that more care and variation could be put into the way the team approaches each issue.

I agree about the duoshade. I was gonna mention that, but got sidetracked. It totally changes the whole concept when you remove it.

CyberCubed
12-28-2013, 01:20 AM
This is what I was afraid of. It's been so confusing because the idea is kind of fun. I'd almost just rather wait until we get a real "Ultimate Collection" that can print them all together. I can't even look at that poorly colored trash.

What on earth do you mean by a, "real Ultimate collection?"

The only Mirage issues IDW printed in black and white were the Eastman/Laird issues of Volume 1. Everything else will be reprinted in color, and I don't ever expect to see black and white trades of the other issues.

Also I don't think the coloring is that bad. It actually helps me appreciate some of the duller Volume 1 stories.

Casey
12-28-2013, 08:58 AM
What on earth do you mean by a, "real Ultimate collection?"

The only Mirage issues IDW printed in black and white were the Eastman/Laird issues of Volume 1. Everything else will be reprinted in color, and I don't ever expect to see black and white trades of the other issues.

Also I don't think the coloring is that bad. It actually helps me appreciate some of the duller Volume 1 stories.

Meaning that they would include a straight run without licensing issues. The color thing is clearly a personal preference, but I think they look like crap. Of course they won't make trades. They already made the hardback ultimate editions. It would be years before they would print them again.

Coola Yagami
12-29-2013, 12:08 AM
Possibly because they were never meant to be in color...? Aren't things handled differently when you're working on something intended to be colored than when you're (at the time) planning it to only be in black and white with duo tones and such?

Cipher
12-29-2013, 01:54 PM
Possibly because they were never meant to be in color...? Aren't things handled differently when you're working on something intended to be colored than when you're (at the time) planning it to only be in black and white with duo tones and such?
Yes, but it could be done more successfully.

I still think "awful" is an overblown way to describe these, but there could be more attention put into them. The "Color Classics" issues look largely excellent, for example.

Casey
12-29-2013, 02:00 PM
Yes, but it could be done more successfully.

I still think "awful" is an overblown way to describe these, but there could be more attention put into them. The "Color Classics" issues look largely excellent, for example.

Agreed. I love most of the Color Classics I have seen. Raphael one shot looks awesome in color.

Casey
12-29-2013, 02:02 PM
Possibly because they were never meant to be in color...? Aren't things handled differently when you're working on something intended to be colored than when you're (at the time) planning it to only be in black and white with duo tones and such?

I think we all get that, but they don't have to do such a careless job and just throw ugly tones all over everything. It makes it look too comical.

CyberCubed
12-30-2013, 03:40 PM
I just got Classics #7 and the coloring looks awesome. Probably the best colorized collection I've seen yet.

I just hope they don't re-color Volume 2 as its already in color.