View Full Version : What about Mirage?
Cowabunga Carl
01-30-2014, 01:15 PM
So I was looking at my comics and organizing them just looking at what I had. When I was going through my IDW stuff I started thinking about how they brought back the Marvel universe of GI Joe comics, started thinking what it would be like for them to bring back Mirage.
Then I was on FB and Tristian pointed out they are bringing out the trades of Tales Vol 2 and I just mentioned that I'd love for him to finnish The Gang War arch. He said he would be up for it, and up for playing more in the Mirage Universe. Which of course got me thinking about other authors/artist that might want to play in that universe.
Would it be possible for IDW to do something like that with TMNT like they did with GI Joe? Better yet would people want to see it happen?
CyberCubed
01-30-2014, 01:17 PM
Aside from Tristan's arc I'd rather not see Mirage return outside of Peter Laird.
He still needs to finish Volune 4.
Cowabunga Carl
01-30-2014, 01:26 PM
But why? I understand Peter didn't finnish volume 4, but is it imperative he be the one to finish it or could another artist/writer team take the notes and finnish it up and continue on? Surely a Tales book set in Mirage would be a great read for those of us who grew upo with or are fans of Mirage.
TristanHuwJones
01-30-2014, 02:20 PM
They also did it with the UK Transformers comics.
Back before Infestation, it was an idea that was floated, but I opted (at the time) to try something new. I'd still love to go back to the Mirage stuff, because it felt so natural writing it, and I've learnt a lot about the craft since then, so going back knowing what I know now and also not necessarily having the restrictions I had at Mirage (there weren't many, but y'know) would be a dream, but at the end of the day there's a process to all of it. Bobby's got to sign off on it, as do the rest of the guys at IDW, and then I'm pretty sure Nickelodeon have to sign off on it as well.
Kurai
01-30-2014, 02:20 PM
It would be interesting to see more stories set in the Mirage universe, that's for sure. I've not read anything outside the first volume (most of what I've read is in the two Ultimate Collection hardbacks I've managed to get my hands on), but I'm interested to read more stuff based in the Mirage universe
CyberCubed
01-30-2014, 02:20 PM
Why should another writer finish it? It's his story and nobody at IDW should complete it even if he does give then story details.
TristanHuwJones
01-30-2014, 02:33 PM
It would be interesting to see more stories set in the Mirage universe, that's for sure. I've not read anything outside the first volume (most of what I've read is in the two Ultimate Collection hardbacks I've managed to get my hands on), but I'm interested to read more stuff based in the Mirage universe
Make sure you pick up the "Tales of the TMNT" trades then. 70 issues with some pretty incredible little stories in there.
Cowabunga Carl
01-30-2014, 02:57 PM
Why should another writer finish it? It's his story and nobody at IDW should complete it even if he does give then story details.
Because it would be nice to see the end of the story and move onto the next. Why should that Universe just be over and done?
Bobby Curnow
01-30-2014, 03:30 PM
Peter still has the rights to print more Mirage TMNT should he so chose. That 'universe' is his, and any formal stories continuing from Mirage left off should come from him, or someone of his choosing, in my mind.
The last thing I want to do is try to do an "IDW Mirage". 1) We have our hands full as is. 2) It just wouldn't feel right-- it'd be artificial. There's something very pure about Mirage stories, and I wouldn't want to mess with that, or try to replicate what they did.
Plus there's the licensing issues to keep in mind-- Nickelodeon would have input and approval rights if we printed it, which raises a host of other concerns regarding Mirage material.
Cowabunga Carl
01-30-2014, 03:38 PM
So no chance of seeing at least Gang Wars finished up? Maybe like a collected edition of the story?
Andrew NDB
01-30-2014, 04:16 PM
I don't know that I'm really excited about reading new Mirage material that has to pass through Nickelodeon's filters. That said, a Gang Wars finisher from Tristan -- if, and only if, he's not censored and made to hold back -- would be fine to see. But a proper Peter Laird conclusion to Volume 4 straight through Mirage would trump all.
DrSpengler
01-30-2014, 04:28 PM
Yeah, Mirage isn't like Marvel or DC where storylines can have their creative teams changed up midway through.
Volume 4 completed without any input from Peter Laird would just be fanfiction.
CyberCubed
01-30-2014, 05:06 PM
The other thing is Mirage TMNT doesn't have to go on forever. They're not superheroes in that series, they don't need countless adventures saving the world and fighting crime.
Mirage TMNT could have ended with Volume 1 and it would have been fine. It's not like the cartoons or IDW where they have a new "big bad" come out of nowhere and have a story arc.
After Volume 4 ends I'd be content to never have a new Mirage story ever again. It's not the type of series that needs new storylines. Mirage TMNT get old and die.
Powder
01-30-2014, 06:07 PM
I'd be down for a Tales Vol. 3 if it were being overseen by Lawson & Berger, but outside of that and maybe some sort of storyline that involves a crossover, I'll pass.
Cipher
01-30-2014, 08:48 PM
The other thing is Mirage TMNT doesn't have to go on forever. They're not superheroes in that series, they don't need countless adventures saving the world and fighting crime.
Mirage TMNT could have ended with Volume 1 and it would have been fine. It's not like the cartoons or IDW where they have a new "big bad" come out of nowhere and have a story arc.
After Volume 4 ends I'd be content to never have a new Mirage story ever again. It's not the type of series that needs new storylines. Mirage TMNT get old and die.
I'm going to actually agree with CyberCubed (which ... is strange).
The most I'd want is for dangling plot lines to be resolved (Volume 4, some of the things in Tales, etc.), which I do want. But Mirage is already fairly finite; we know what happens to everyone. It's just irksome not getting a real tonal ending.
Vegeta
01-30-2014, 09:21 PM
The other thing is Mirage TMNT doesn't have to go on forever. They're not superheroes in that series, they don't need countless adventures saving the world and fighting crime.
Mirage TMNT could have ended with Volume 1 and it would have been fine. It's not like the cartoons or IDW where they have a new "big bad" come out of nowhere and have a story arc.
After Volume 4 ends I'd be content to never have a new Mirage story ever again. It's not the type of series that needs new storylines. Mirage TMNT get old and die.
Agreed. One of the strong suits of TMNT over other popular comic series is the smaller feel. The characters and the comics have often felt intimate and introspective at times as opposed to characters like Wolverine who are in hell, fighting in the uncanny x-force, running a school, and stuck in the savage lands all at the same time. Seeing the TMNT get older and end would be pretty nice.
Matches Malone
01-30-2014, 11:21 PM
Tristan Jones is my favorite TMNT writer. I'm not counting on it, but I'd be happy to see him write for either IDW or Mirage turtles.
CyberCubed
01-30-2014, 11:36 PM
All old TMNT universes come to an end, same for Mirage.
- The original cartoon ended in 1996 besides the Turtles Forever crossover.
- The original movie trilogy (or TMNT 4 if you count it) concluded
- Archie TMNT Adventures concluded with "Year of the Turtle."
- 4kids TMNT concluded with "Turtles Forever"
Mirage TMNT didn't end yet, but after Volume 4 is completed it should be allowed to sail off into the sunset,
Abnormal Freak
02-01-2014, 05:40 AM
Volume 4 completed without any input from Peter Laird would just be fanfiction.
Exactly. It's creator-driven entertainment. You can't just have somebody come in and finish it off. It's why Japanese comics are such a fascination to me because it's almost always the same writer and artist (who are usually the same person and not a team).
Chris
02-01-2014, 10:42 AM
I'd be up for some stand alone issues or mini series to wrap up open plot lines (Tristan's Gang Wars comes to mind) but like others have said trying to do more than that would feel artificial.
I wouldn't want IDW to finish Volume 4, that's Peter Laird's baby to finish. I'd accept Jim Lawson finishing it from Peter's notes and with his blessing but that's it. Like Spengler said, anything else would be fanfic no matter how good it is.
CyberCubed
02-01-2014, 11:54 AM
Peter Laird just turned 60, so he has another good 20+ years in him to finish Volume 4. He's in no rush.
Toby Barrett
02-01-2014, 12:38 PM
My grandfather died at 62, so you never know, he may only have one or two.
CyberCubed
02-01-2014, 01:51 PM
My grandfather died at 62, so you never know, he may only have one or two.
PL doesn't have any health problems though, I'm sure he's got a good 30 years left in him.
My grandparents died at 83 and 85 respectively, so I would hope he makes it that long.
Cowabunga Carl
02-01-2014, 05:42 PM
Just cause you have no health problems doesn't mean anything Cubed. My Mother died at 53 with no previous health problems. Somehow a blood clot developed and took her. My point is no one knows when they are going to go.
I'd love to see Liard finish vol 4, I just don't think he will.
CyberCubed
02-01-2014, 05:52 PM
He already said on his blog that he'd like to finish it, "someday" which means he hasn't completely ruled it out. However long, "someday" takes is up in the air though.
I do think he'll finish it eventually. I think he said he would like to wrap it up in only 6 issues too.
Billbeaux
02-01-2014, 10:04 PM
I'm a completist at heart, and I'd absolutely love to see the Mirage Turtles' saga as a fixed, bookended work. To that end, if I could wave a magic wand and make the impossible happen, I wouldn't go much beyond tying up loose ends. Of course there are the big ones:
*A Gang Wars conclusion by Tristan and the creative team of his choice...with one very minor (pizza)pie-in-the-sky caveat: that the story wraps the arc up in a satisfying, uncompromising manner WITHOUT contradicting the events of Volume 3. What can I say, I'm one of those "have my cake and eat it too" types. While opinions on the Image series run hot and cold, I'm personally of the opinion that the good (which, at its best, is great) outweighs the bad or the "meh," and would hate to have to mentally punt certain things in order to keep my idealized version of the canon intact.
(Lotta "I," "my," and "me" in that paragraph...then again, I'M the one with the magic wand.)
*A Volume 4 conclusion either written or authorized by Peter Laird. Same as before, I think the good outweighs the bad, and would genuinely love to see where he was going with the half dozen or so plot lines he left dangling. As to how it could/should end...simply a "life goes on" type fade out would be fine by me.
*No Shredder stories. I'm for leaving him alone entirely. While it would be fascinating to explore his character in miniseries format (something I'm honestly surprised Tales v2 never did, though I wouldn't be surprised if PL essentially issued an edict on the matter), I find that idea that Saki was more or less a cipher to be more fascinating. Being as we rarely get a POV from anyone other than the Turtles and their immediate "family," I'm content with seeing only as much of the Shredder as they did. If anything I think it adds a somewhat mythic quality to the character that, for obvious reasons, is lacking in other incarnations.
*One last Eastman/Laird team-up. Could be for the Volume 4 finale, could be just another "Let me tell you a story." Either way, it'd be great to see them get the band back together one more time.
Gotta say that's about it, unless there are any unresolved Tales story lines I've forgotten about. (For my own part, I've officially adopted the unlicensed Volume 3 conclusion as canon, so that clears up "Change of Power.) Even then, quite a few things--i.e., unsettling hints about the future--don't really need expounding on, as it seemed like the writers themselves were of a mind to let us make up our own minds.
mgambino
02-01-2014, 10:32 PM
I'd rather not see a vol 4 conclusion unless it was done by Laird, but I'm in the camp that would kill to get a Lawson-run Tales Vol 3.
CyberCubed
02-02-2014, 04:40 PM
I don't see the appeal of a new Tales. They pretty much told all the stories they could.
Ninjinister
02-02-2014, 05:23 PM
I'd be willing to do whatever I could to get T-Rex working on Turtles again. Gang Wars or not (though that is preferable), it's not beneficial to keep his talent away from the green guys.
CyberCubed
02-02-2014, 05:31 PM
I'd be willing to do whatever I could to get T-Rex working on Turtles again. Gang Wars or not (though that is preferable), it's not beneficial to keep his talent away from the green guys.
Technically all you have to do is ask the guys at IDW to greenlit him a mini-series. He hasn't written anything Turtles since Infestation, right?
Andrew NDB
02-03-2014, 12:41 PM
He already said on his blog that he'd like to finish it, "someday"
But he almost always follows such statements with a, "... but probably not."
Andrew NDB
02-03-2014, 12:50 PM
Even then, quite a few things--i.e., unsettling hints about the future--don't really need expounding on, as it seemed like the writers themselves were of a mind to let us make up our own minds.
That's where "Odyssey" comes in.
Now, about an actual Volume 4 conclusion, I would say the only way it should even be attempted is if Jim Lawson could be leaned on to extrapolate a loose outline of where he would know or foresee things going beyond where Volume 4 was left, and then develop a script for such. And commission Jim Lawson to draw it... though who knows if he'd even be willing to do so. Might get into ethical issues.
Ninjinister
02-03-2014, 01:14 PM
Technically all you have to do is ask the guys at IDW to greenlit him a mini-series. He hasn't written anything Turtles since Infestation, right?
Because it's that simple.
CyberCubed
02-03-2014, 03:13 PM
I am confident Volume 4 will reach some conclusion within the next 5-7 years.
Peter Laird is going to want to put his "final mark" on the TMNT franchise before he gets too old and retires completely. Since Volume 4 was entirely his story it will be what he finishes.
In fact if you read the last issue he printed (or rather posted online, I remember #32 never saw print), you could tell the storylines were already heading toward their conclusion.
TristanHuwJones
02-04-2014, 10:20 PM
I'd be willing to do whatever I could to get T-Rex working on Turtles again. Gang Wars or not (though that is preferable), it's not beneficial to keep his talent away from the green guys.
I'm pretty sure there's a list of mystic relics of that need to be assembled in one place for something like that to happen... ;)
*A Gang Wars conclusion by Tristan and the creative team of his choice...with one very minor (pizza)pie-in-the-sky caveat: that the story wraps the arc up in a satisfying, uncompromising manner WITHOUT contradicting the events of Volume 3. What can I say, I'm one of those "have my cake and eat it too" types. While opinions on the Image series run hot and cold, I'm personally of the opinion that the good (which, at its best, is great) outweighs the bad or the "meh," and would hate to have to mentally punt certain things in order to keep my idealized version of the canon intact.
(Lotta "I," "my," and "me" in that paragraph...then again, I'M the one with the magic wand.)
That was actually the plan back at Mirage, but I'm sure if it ever happened Nickelodeon might have a different approach to things. I could probably incorporate Volume 3 if they let me (but more importantly if it worked... which it could... VERY easily).
At the end of the day, I'm just excited that they are finally collecting Tales Vol.2. I don't even have copies of my own comics anymore, so seeing them out there again is an exciting prospect. Curious to see what it'd look like coloured, too.
I'd also KILL to see Peter wrap Volume 4 and have it all collected in one place...
Lord Nightwalker
02-04-2014, 10:55 PM
I'm pretty sure there's a list of mystic relics of that need to be assembled in one place for something like that to happen... ;)
At the end of the day, I'm just excited that they are finally collecting Tales Vol.2. I don't even have copies of my own comics anymore, so seeing them out there again is an exciting prospect. Curious to see what it'd look like coloured, too.
Man...I'd like to see it colored too, but fully painted! No one freaking does that anymore. It would be great!
Ninjinister
02-05-2014, 12:05 AM
Although it'd be tough, I'd like to see all of what I always (in my head at least) called the "New Blood Mirage Team" work on something with IDW at some point.
Campbell's already there. Tristan did Infestation 2 but I crave more. We need to tag Tupper, May, and Black into doing something.
The only other one of this group I held in my head I can recall off the top of my head would be Remender and he's busy with 30,000 Marvel books.
Powder
02-05-2014, 12:40 AM
Totally with you on that. The Tales gang is full of talent. Would especially like to see Remender & Tupper aboard for something.
ianke_2002
02-05-2014, 02:11 AM
The only other one of this group I held in my head I can recall off the top of my head would be Remender and he's busy with 30,000 Marvel books.
Actually...not to go off topic, but I actually find his new book "Black Science" to be quite good. Story seems pretty compelling and art is fantastic.
Cowabunga Carl
02-05-2014, 09:06 AM
I would love to see Tristan back on the book, I've been vocal about this before and will probably continue to be vocal about it. I'd even love to see him bring in some of the characters he created for Gang War into Mirage.
Heck he talked about bringing in Bishop in Infestation, why not let him do so now?
CyberCubed
02-05-2014, 11:47 PM
I'd just like to see Tristan write Turtles again, period. Let him write another special for IDW continuity too.
It's a shame how underused he is.
Joey Kamikaze
02-06-2014, 02:51 AM
Yeah. I'm not familiar with his work in Mirage, but the Infestation issues were fantastic; one of the highlights of the first year.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.