PDA

View Full Version : X-Files Conspiracy: TMNT #1 preview/discussion


ToTheNines
02-16-2014, 02:45 PM
http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=preview&id=20300

For reference, if anyone cares, the cop was played by Luke Wilson in the X-Files episodes this follows up on (Bad Blood, it was called). And the pizza delivery guy was the fat kid from The Big Green and The Sandlot.

Out on Wednesday.

ToTheNines
02-19-2014, 10:13 PM
So I just read it and was underwhelmed. Walsh has nice art, and there were some neat bits, but I was just left feeling like there was no climax.

I hate to be so critical, but IDW really half-asses their "crossovers". I only read Ghostbusters from Infestation 1 and TMNT from Infestation 2 (both of which were really awesome stories), as well the the bookend main title comics, but after that and the Mars Attacks one from last year, it'd be nice to have actual crossovers. I know we got one here that laid off the dimension hopping, and I don't hate the Long Gunmen, but Mulder and Scully meeting the guys just would have been more fulfilling.

Anyways, I'm still glad they did it and we are getting spoiled with 4 original TMNT stories this month.

Jeff
02-19-2014, 11:13 PM
I wrote a spoiler-free review for it over at Rhymes With Geek (http://www.rhymeswithgeek.com/the-x-files-conspiracy-tmnt-1/)

BODYCOUNT
02-19-2014, 11:41 PM
I wrote a spoiler-free review for it over at Rhymes With Geek (http://www.rhymeswithgeek.com/the-x-files-conspiracy-tmnt-1/)

spot on review. i feel the same way ......:tcool:

Tazi
02-20-2014, 11:32 AM
I wasn't following IDW's X-Files, but this crossover is nice so far as a whole storyline. It wasn't did anything spectacular in this TMNT issue, but it is so far a nice overall experience as a story arc. Also, the art in this issue is quiet simple, but at the same time, it's kinda cool, I like how Walsh draws them tortoises. :)

ToTheNines
02-20-2014, 05:59 PM
http://m.ign.com/articles/2014/02/19/the-x-files-conspiracy-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-1

IGN gave it a 7.8

Jeff
02-24-2014, 12:49 AM
spot on review. i feel the same way ......:tcool:

thanks! i kind of wish we got 2 issues like we did with infestation 2, but i think 1 was just fine for this story. it would almost make northampton feel convoluted, with it reaching into 3 different titles...

SwiftNinjaFox
02-26-2014, 08:24 PM
My comic book store sold out of it. :(

Your signature is only adding insult to injury because my comic store used to be owned by those folks. :lol:

Toby Barrett
02-27-2014, 09:46 AM
This issue falsifies Michelangelo's relationship with anchovies.

spookycookies
02-28-2014, 04:51 PM
This issue falsifies Michelangelo's relationship with anchovies.

THAT'S THE CONSPIRACY!

But seriously though, it was alright as far as showing a brief scrape between the TMNT & the Vamp camp but I just find it strange that the Turtles would just let it go that they tangled with some freaky vampires. Sure they have much bigger fish to fry but this'll always just be an odd end. Honestly there was a lot of potential that just kind of didn't show up. I am though, glad that TMNT was included in the crossover AT ALL.

Now we just need a 2 part TMNT/Ghostbusters crossover.

nimajneb
03-12-2014, 05:44 PM
It did feel a little coincidental and forced but at the same time I thought it was ok, not quite as good as infestation 2 but I enjoyed it

bjaxx87
03-21-2014, 06:52 AM
I haven't read this issue yet, but I have a question...

Are the Lone Gunmen capable of some interdimensional travelling or how is this whole crossover possible? I mean, you can't tell me that Mulder, Scully, the Transformers, the Crow, the TMNT and the Ghostbusters live in the same world!

Back in the Infestation crossovers it was clearly depicted that TMNT, Transformers and Ghostbusters are different universes. And that makes 100% sense.

Did they really retcon this for the sake of doing a weird X-files crossover?

liugeaux
03-21-2014, 09:42 AM
Having read all of the issues in this crossover, its writing assuming all of these are in the same universe. The Lone Gunmen are just Crazy Dudes in a van, so they aren't dimension jumping. It been more of a The Lone Gunmen meet these characters. The status of these stories in the canon of each title is really a non-issue. With that said, its been a fun read.

Casey
03-21-2014, 12:15 PM
It just didn't feel fluid with the current TMNT run, but that wasn't really a surprise. I'm just glad two of my favorite properties got to meet each other and it didn't suck. I was most excited for this one, but the first crossover and the Ghostbusters were better. Not sure if I care to pay full price for The Crow and Transformers. I don't really care much for either one of those properties. I'll probably just get a digital copy after the price drops.

liugeaux
03-21-2014, 12:48 PM
The Crow wasn't very good, but the Transformers one was excellent and really funny.

Casey
03-21-2014, 01:08 PM
The Crow wasn't very good, but the Transformers one was excellent and really funny.

Thanks for the info. I will definitely check it out, but I'll probably save a couple bucks and wait for the price to drop.

Powder
02-23-2015, 08:41 PM
I just now got this, a year later.

While it's hardly the best turtle book ever, I think it's pretty neat. I found the plot to be super ironic though, given the live action film came a few months later with the same "blood draining" thing... Weird. The art was really cool in its simplicity for some parts, while others begged to be better detailed (IMO), but I did like the style overall. Writing was alright, I really enjoyed that there was a moment showing the whole "Donnie has faith in science & tech alone & therefore butts heads with the more spiritual Leo" thing IDW started (& needs to make better use of), but at the same time, they had Mikey upset at a lack of anchovies, when history has shown he typically only gets upset when they're included against his wishes. So they both gained & lost bonus points, with respect to turtle personalities. :trazz: Being I am not an X-Files fan, the absurdity of the foot fetish vampires story really threw me off. Dunno if that kind of tone/content is normal for the show or not, but it certainly doesn't make me wanna peep repeats. I mean, it's not weird that the turtles would tussle with vampires, they've done it in Mirage, Next Mutation, & quite possibly in the other cartoons (I can't recall at this moment) but the fact they had an obsession with stealing shoes, spoke so comically, & would temporarily end their blood lust to pick up flecks of pizza topping had me groaning. Oh, & uhhhh, they work in a pizza shop?! What about the whole weakness to garlic bit? It was really hard to take seriously (unless that's the idea... in which case, meh, that's too goofy even for me!). Nonetheless, it was better than I expected, & I enjoyed it well enough. Even after 12 months I only paid retail for a bagged/boarded NM copy, so it's all good.

Joey Kamikaze
02-23-2015, 11:06 PM
These vampires are repeated characters from an old episode of The X-Files (http://x-files.wikia.com/wiki/Bad_Blood). The shoe thing originated in that episode. In some folklore vampires have OCD traits and for example have to untie knots or count things (which is probably the joke behind the Count on Sesame Street).

ProphetofGanja
02-24-2015, 08:12 AM
In some folklore vampires have OCD traits and for example have to untie knots or count things (which is probably the joke behind the Count on Sesame Street).

oh shi that makes so much sense

Powder
02-24-2015, 03:28 PM
Huh. I still think it's kinda lame, but I can at least appreciate that it's rooted in history rather than being some random gag. Thanks for the tip!

ToTheNines
02-24-2015, 05:00 PM
Huh. I still think it's kinda lame, but I can at least appreciate that it's rooted in history rather than being some random gag. Thanks for the tip!

Yeah, I watched Bad Blood on Netflix the week before this came out, so all that didn't seem weird to me. Definitely an odd choice on the writers part.

sdp
03-01-2015, 11:17 PM
The turtles crossed over with the X-Files? Who else have they crossed over with in the IDW run. This is beyond stupid and makes no sense for either franchise, this coming from a fan of both franchises.

Duke Nukem
03-01-2015, 11:30 PM
Other than X-Files, there was Infestation 2 and TMNT/Ghostbusters.

sdp
03-02-2015, 10:05 PM
Infestation while I didn't agree in at least it dealt with Cthulu travelling through different universes so it was forgivable. But Ghostbusters and X-Files? ugh. This is even worse than Vol.3 taking place in the Image Universe, at least that universe is more consistent with the TMNT world.

Powder
03-02-2015, 10:13 PM
Sounds to me like you're just allergic to fun.

In all seriousness, what's the problem? These sorta things make sense, to me. They feel "right", & natural. It's all a matter of occult, funky, sci-fi, semi-horror stuff, which each series is popular for. Each crossover was pretty grounded, & I thought well executed. Not clunky, featuring those who act of character, not full of bad art or cliche tropes. Just good stuff.

spookycookies
03-02-2015, 10:38 PM
Sounds to me like you're just allergic to fun.

In all seriousness, what's the problem? These sorta things make sense, to me. They feel "right", & natural. It's all a matter of occult, funky, sci-fi, semi-horror stuff, which each series is popular for. Each crossover was pretty grounded, & I thought well executed. Not clunky, featuring those who act of character, not full of bad art or cliche tropes. Just good stuff.

Out of the 3 crossover stories I feel that each one of them have a justifiable premise and was executed well. Seeing the turtles explore the old sewers and find a cult, running into the nomadic pizza vampires and teaming up with the Ghostbusters were all very fun adventures. I probably would have rather have Mulder starring in the crossover rather than the Lone Gunmen but I guess the crossover demanded it be them to visit Northampton.

Ghostbusters felt like a big epic cartoon event and it worked perfectly in letting all of the characters rub shoulders and mingle in a really introspective way. The biggest payoff was everyone taking down Chi-You, which was probably one of the more impressive wins for the IDW incarnation of the turtles considering what they were up against.

Even though the X-files oneshot is the weakest of the 3 stories I feel like it was a good attempt at mixing up the franchises in an informed and entertaining way. I wish it could have been a two parter or something so that it really had room to tell more of a story. It was a strange brief encounter but it really was worth doing.

sdp
03-02-2015, 10:48 PM
I'm not anti-fun, I'm all for cross-overs that make sense, Power Rangers and TMNT are already pretty much out there or TMNT and most of the Image universe but their worlds are more consistent. Ghostbusters is a comedy for the most part and X-Files is actually trying to be realistic to a sense, none of those universes being together make sense. I'm sorry but I guess I just don't understand how people can enjoy these crossovers.

spookycookies
03-02-2015, 11:15 PM
I'm not anti-fun, I'm all for cross-overs that make sense, Power Rangers and TMNT are already pretty much out there or TMNT and most of the Image universe but their worlds are more consistent. Ghostbusters is a comedy for the most part and X-Files is actually trying to be realistic to a sense, none of those universes being together make sense. I'm sorry but I guess I just don't understand how people can enjoy these crossovers.

As for making sense, each one of the cross overs found some kind of middle ground to build the story on. The cult being in the same old sewer system as the turtles, the vampires who are known for working in a pizzeria as a way to find victims and the spiritual possession of Casey Jones all serve as catalysts for these stories. TMNT/Ghostbusters even establishes that these two franchises DO in fact exist is two different New York Cities but the story allows them to meet due to the teleport test on the turtles side.

The narrative is important and I don't think that IDW has broken it with any of the crossovers, one of the great things about TMNT is how flexible it is when it comes to telling so many different kinds of stories while still being balanced. As TMNT readers we are used to seeing a range of situations and characters from aliens to gangsters, mutants and ninja and it all somehow fits just right.

Joey Kamikaze
03-03-2015, 04:44 AM
The Infestation 2 crossover was one of the highlights of the first year of the run IMO. It felt like a lost issue of Tales of the TMNT, but set in the IDW universe. In a series that involves mutants, aliens, self-aware androids and warring gods, the Cthulhu mythos fits right in.

The Ghostbusters crossover worked too. These two properties are more similar than you might think, particularly the way the team dynamics work and the way they blend drama and humor. And again, when you're dealing with a TMNT universe where the dead are reincarnated as mutants and a scientist's soul can be trapped inside an android, the Ghostbusters don't seem out of place at all. Certainly the turtles fit right into the Ghostbuster universe too.

Now the X-Files crossover? Meh. But whatever, it's the one issue of the run that isn't canon anyway.