PDA

View Full Version : What's the best Idw sketch cover?


Jay $tarkiller
03-11-2014, 06:15 AM
Hi fellows,

I'm curious, what's the best sketch cover from Idw so far? I had a very glossy Detroit Fanfare cover, which wasn't that nice to handle for the artists. Also the Necra cover is quiet glossy. I haven't tried the phantom cover yet, but it seems as if it's a lot more blunt and easier to work with.

What are your favorites for artists to work with? Members like Mayhem and Sofistocat get quite a lot sketch covers done by different artists, so I'd love to hear some advice from you guys, too ;)

Rick Arthur and Mark McMurray are currently working on a Necra cover together, but Mark already told me, that he's worried how the ink will stick to the cover..so it would be great if all those members who got some experience to share, let me know which cover they prefer.

Thanks a lot, guys :tgrin:

mrmaczaps
03-11-2014, 06:37 AM
Hi fellows,

I haven't tried the phantom cover yet, but it seems as if it's a lot more blunt and easier to work with.



Buy the Phantom variants. Those are the best. And it helps that my friend Rich did those covers. :D
Hope that helps.

Jay $tarkiller
03-11-2014, 06:44 AM
Buy the Phantom variants. Those are the best. And it helps that my friend Rich did those covers. :D
Hope that helps.

I bought another 5 of them, just a week ago. I guess, this was a good move then:twink:

Thanks for the hint!

mrmaczaps
03-11-2014, 06:48 AM
Not a problem! I was trying to find a picture of my copy that Rich drew another Shredder on the back for me, but it seems to be "lost" on the interwebs... haha

Redrumh2o
03-11-2014, 09:55 AM
The newish shredder ones have a great stock....and are blank on the front which is good for CGG SS. They can be had for about $5....and you can always request the artist cover up the "Shredder" with a shadow or something.

Although expensive the Jetpack Annual has very nice stock as does the SHOTFC variant

I guess overall pretty much anything that isn't glossy works great....most of my sketches are on the Matte Detroit's and worked great

Sofistocat
03-11-2014, 10:11 AM
Great thread idea! I'm bored at work, so here is an objective look. The reviews are solely opinions, not the gospel... Apologies for the various pic sizes, this was done quick and shamelessly...

TMNT #1 Detroit Con Variant:
https://farm4.staticflickr.com/3405/13094481903_a5e858b171.jpg
2 versions were available, a matte(low tooth) cover and a glossy cover. The book had a limited run and is getting harder to find. The Detroit variant is one of the most used blank TMNT covers. Back of book is completely blank except for a UPC box, I think...

PROS: Large blank surface area, Matte book has quality paper(bristol like)

CONS: Price(going up and getting harder to find), glossy book paper is lesser quality than matte paper and can smear more easily
----------

TMNT #1 RI-D:
https://farm4.staticflickr.com/3734/13094658934_6301c977e7.jpg
These were the books KE worked on for his hand-drawn sketches that were the incentives for issue #1. I have not seen one of these in person yet, but they appear similar to the Detroit variant matte cover and for now I will treat them as such.

PROS: Same as Detroit Variant Matte

CONS: Good luck finding them... No seriously, you'll have better odds warding off an angry beaver...

TMNT #1 NECRA variant
https://farm4.staticflickr.com/3553/13094415515_6fcf84d4f1.jpg
I think it stands for "New England Comic Retail Assoc." Glossy paper with a 65% blank rear cover

PROS: Readily available, cost effective

CONS: REAR cover sketchable, glossy paper smears
----------

TMNT vol. 5 Jetpack RE's and TMNT Color Classics Jetpack RE's
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7395/13094485013_15a0f9af73.jpg
Front cover pics can be found HERE (http://www.jetpackcomics.com/comic-books/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles). Jetpack release 4 RE's in conjunction with vol. 5 issues 1 - 4 and released Color Classics RE's for issues 1 -7 and the Raphael and Michaelangelo one-shots. Some of the books have different covers than the regular books All rear covers have the 65% blank rear cover similar to the NECRA variant except the NECRA logo is replaced by the Jetpack logo.

PROS: Matte versions are nice! They were all 5 bucks at Jetpack's FCBD festival last year, most of the books have matte paper covers, reasonbly priced especially if you get them via Jetpack's group lots on eBay (http://www.ebay.com/sch/m.html?_odkw=&_osacat=0&_armrs=1&_ssn=cesradjr&_trksid=p2046732.m570.l1313.TR12.TRC2.A0.H0.Xninja +turtles&_nkw=ninja+turtles&_sacat=0&_from=R40).

CONS: Smaller blank area, the glossy paper covers(not sure which exactly) can smear, REAR blank cover is only sketchable area
----------

TMNT #22 Phantom and Jetpack RE's
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7339/13094421683_03d778a41d_c.jpg

Awesome Cover by Rich Woodall and Matt Talbot! Has a 90% blank rear cover on all 3 books

PROS: large matte surface sketchable area, Phantom Variant RE is readily available and cost efficient. Jetpack RE front covers are BADASS!

CONS: REAR sketchable surface only, Jetpack RE's are cost prohibitive

I am not including the Eastman hand sketched RE's due to not being released yet
----------

TMNT 2012 Annual Jetpack Blank RE's
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7434/13084687573_784d5e358c_c.jpg

These are what I consider the Cadillac of TMNT sketch covers! They were offered in full blank covers or had 4 colored headbands at the corners. They have the largest sketchable surface for any book available to the public.

PROS: EVERYTHING! Paper is great, large matte surface for sketching, front cover sketchable

CONS: cost prohibitive, becoming harder to get
----------

TMNT Leonardo Micro Brett'sComicPile RE
https://farm4.staticflickr.com/3816/13094483183_3a8bf9929e.jpg

This cover is similar to the Phantom Variant #22 except for having a slightly smaller sketching area. This is due to the additional logo space.

PROS: Matte paper

CONS: Getting hard to find, cost prohibitive due to rarity, REAR sketchable surface
----------

TMNT Shredder Micro Subscription Variant
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7329/13094660684_925f141ef3.jpg

Full blank front cover, 80% sketchable. Matte paper, available to the masses.

PROS: Cheap, good matte paper, nice turtlesque border, readily available

CONS: Logo and Lettering are geared towards Shredder, not necessarily aesthetic
----------

TMNT SHOTFC #1 Jetpack RE
https://farm4.staticflickr.com/3249/13094368405_7bf0288b03.jpg

Great Cover with a large sketchable area. I believe the rear cover is also blank.

PROS: Good matte paper, large size sketching area

CONS: Cost prohibitive, limited run
----------

There were also REAL NICE fully blank SHOTFC covers that IDW limited released. They are not yet available to the public. They were given to artist's who had done contracted work for IDW. The paper on them is the best out of all the books IMO. Let's hope they become available to purchase. hint hint hint
https://farm4.staticflickr.com/3294/13094873774_f0e7411865_c.jpg
^^ Above is the Jetpack Treasury RE for TMNT Vo. 1 #50. It's an awesome OVERSIZED book that reprinted the rough layouts for the original issue.

PROS: Everything! It's big, it's bad, it's "not the mama"...

CONS: Cost prohibitive due to rarity, REAR sketchable cover

Jay $tarkiller
03-11-2014, 12:17 PM
Wow, Sofistocat, my man:tlol: You knocked it right outta the park:tlol:

Thanks a lot, Redrum.

I think I'll stock up on the Shredder blanks. I already got 5 of them, but I can get them pretty cheap here in a comicstore..Tip to the hat to Redrum, for the covering the shredder logo with a shadow or something idea:tlol: Never thought about it, but it really is a great idea.

Sofistocat
03-11-2014, 12:27 PM
Wow, Sofistocat, my man:tlol: You knocked it right outta the park:tlol:

Thanks Jay, I try... to not be so bored at work

Jay $tarkiller
03-11-2014, 01:27 PM
Thanks Jay, I try... to not be so bored at work

Fortunately for me, you've failed in that endeavor:tlol:

Sofistocat
03-11-2014, 01:36 PM
Fortunately for me, you've failed in that endeavor:tlol:

hahaha. proof is in the positive... I use 3 monitors at work, 2 for work and one for this kind of work...

Mayhem
03-11-2014, 03:46 PM
The Shredder micros do have good cover quality, having a few in my possession. Btw, I'm not deliberately getting artists to sketch on them heh, I'm buying them post sketch from the artists themselves.

Jay $tarkiller
03-11-2014, 04:09 PM
Btw, I'm not deliberately getting artists to sketch on them heh, I'm buying them post sketch from the artists themselves.

I didn't know that this is possible..

mrmaczaps
03-11-2014, 05:37 PM
Great thread idea! I'm bored at work, so here is an objective look. The reviews are solely opinions, not the gospel... Apologies for the various pic sizes, this was done down and dirty.

TMNT #1 Detroit Con Variant:
http://i.ebayimg.com/00/s/ODAwWDUxOQ==/$(KGrHqV,!hEE5ov!8PF2BOgk5r2Ywg~~60_3.JPG
2 versions were available, a matte(low tooth) cover and a glossy cover. The book had a limited run and is getting harder to find. The Detroit variant is one of the most used blank TMNT covers. Back of book is completely blank except for a UPC box, I think...

PROS: Large blank surface area, Matte book has quality paper(bristol like)

CONS: Price(going up and geting harder to find), glossy book paper is lesser quality than matte paper and can smear more easily
----------

TMNT #1 RI-D:
http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/IDW-1_RI-D_Kevin-Eastman-Sketch.jpg
These were the books KE worked on for his hand-drawn sketches that were the incentives for issue #1. I have not seen one of these in person yet, nut they appear similar to the Detroit variant matte cover and for now I will treat them as such.

PROS: Same as Detroit Variant Matte

CONS: Good luck finding them... No seriously, you have better odds successfully warding off a Kodiak bear attack
----------

TMNT #1 NECRA variant
http://i.ebayimg.com/00/s/NzIwWDQ2OA==/$(KGrHqF,!oME8VonTOQEBPTT8yb!LQ~~60_3.JPG
I think it stands for "New England Comic Retail Assoc." Glossy paper with a 65% blank rear cover

PROS: Readily available, cost effective

CONS: Glossy paper smears
----------

TMNT vol. 5 Jetpack RE's and TMNT Color Classics Jetpack RE's
https://scontent-a-iad.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn2/t1/603026_409281315820429_1082373288_n.jpg
Front cover pics can be found HERE (http://www.jetpackcomics.com/comic-books/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles). Jetpack release 4 RE's in conjunction with vol. 5 issues 1 - 4 and released Color Classics RE's for issues 1 -7 and the Raphael and Michaelangelo one-shots. Some of the books have different covers than the regular books All rear covers have the 65% blank rear cover similar to the NECRA variant except the NECRA logo is replaced by the Jetpack logo.

PROS: They were all 5 bucks at Jetpack's FCBD festival last year, most of the books have matte paper covers, reasonbly priced especially if you get them via Jetpack's group lots on eBay (http://www.ebay.com/sch/m.html?_odkw=&_osacat=0&_armrs=1&_ssn=cesradjr&_trksid=p2046732.m570.l1313.TR12.TRC2.A0.H0.Xninja +turtles&_nkw=ninja+turtles&_sacat=0&_from=R40).

CONS: Smaller blank area, the glossy paper covers(not sure which exactly) can smear, REAR blank cover is only sketchable area
----------

TMNT #22 Phantom and Jetpack RE's
http://i.ebayimg.com/00/s/MTI0OFgxNjAw/z/mv0AAOxyf1dTHnEW/$_1.JPG

Awesome Cover by Rich Woodall and Matt Talbot! Has a 90% blank rear cover on all 3 books

PROS: large matte surface sketchable area, Phantom Variant RE is readily available and cost efficient

CONS: REAR sketchable surface only, JEtpack RE's are somewhat cost prohibitive

I am not including the Eastman hand sketched RE's due to not being released yet
----------

TMNT 2012 Annual Jetpack Blank RE's
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7434/13084687573_784d5e358c_c.jpg

These are what I consider the Cadillac of TMNT sketch covers! They were offered in full blank covers or had 4 colored headbands at the corners. They have the largest sketchable surface for any book available to the public.

PROS: EVERYTHING! Paper is great, large matte surface for sketching, front cover sketchable

CONS: cost prohibitive, becoming harder to get
----------

TMNT Leonardo Micro Brett'sComicPile RE
https://farm4.staticflickr.com/3314/13084774364_ce44d699af_c.jpg

This cover is similar to the Phantom Variant #22 except for having a slightly smaller sketching area. This id due to the additional logo space.

PROS: Matte paper

CONS: Getting hard to find, cost prohibitive due to rarity, REAR sketchable surface
----------

TMNT Shredder Micro Subscription Variant
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-MknazDdyrIQ/Up7Sf0W3DWI/AAAAAAAAE7Y/evpG9XG0AJ8/s1600/shredder1_coverC_Blank.jpg

Full blank front cover, 80% sketchable. Matte paper, available to the masses.

PROS: Cheap, good matte paper, nice turtlesque border, readily available

CONS: Logo and Lettering are geard towards Shredder, not necessarily aesthetic
----------

TMNT SHOTFC #1 Jetpack RE
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7334/13084291465_06a629dc3a_c.jpg

Great Cover with a large sketchable area. I believe the rear cover is also blank.

PROS: Good matte paper, large size sketching area

CONS: Cost prohibitive, limited run
----------

There were also REAL NICE fully blank SHOTFC covers that IDW limited released. They are not yet available to the public. They were given to artist's who had done contracted work for IDW. The paper on them is the best out of all the books IMO. Let's hope they become available to purchase. hint hint hint
http://crushcounty.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/tmntblankcovers-620x465.jpg

So that's my 2 cents, please tell me if there are any discrepencies. As I stated, this was fast and dirty.

Hey man, thats *MY* Mikey cover done up by Steve! woo hoo. I really love the #22 covers by Rich. Anything really thats not glossy works really well.

Sofistocat
03-11-2014, 05:58 PM
Hey man, thats *MY* Mikey cover done up by Steve! woo hoo. I really love the #22 covers by Rich. Anything really thats not glossy works really well.

Sorry, was the only "decent" pic I could find at the time. Now you're famous:tcool:

mrmaczaps
03-11-2014, 06:49 PM
Sorry, was the only "decent" pic I could find at the time. Now you're famous:tcool:

Now? lol
Thanks.