PDA

View Full Version : Do you have artists autograph items/books they had no part in making?


Sofistocat
03-19-2014, 09:03 AM
I'm curious to see what the masses say. I started this in the comics forums because that's my main interest. I know there is a big trend with getting figures signed too, feel free to post here and we can keep it consolidated.

Hypothetical: You're at a con and Kevin and Peter are both there. You have IDW books and post-Eastman Mirage books. Do you ask Pete to sign the IDW stuff and Kevin to sign the later Mirage stuff? If so, why?

My rule of thumb is to try and get signatures ONLY from the staff invloved on a certain project/comic. Some artists will sign anything, others will sign only the items they worked on. I'm trying to ascertain what the general public thinks. If there is a signature on an item that is not from a credited collaborator, does it change FMV +/- or rarity of said item?

DrSpengler
03-19-2014, 09:21 AM
I'm not an autograph collector, but my opinion is that asking someone to sign something they had no part in creating could be construed as ignorant on your part and the creator might take offense.

I understand the hypothetical situation you proposed; you want their signature but don't have any of their stuff on hand for them to sign. But in that case, we are talking about human interaction; you can always tell them, "Sorry, I don't have one of your comics on hand, I just really wanted your autograph".

I think in that circumstance, most creators would be understanding and accommodating. But if you just rolled up with an issue of the IDW comic and obliviously asked Laird to sign it for you because you "love his comics"... yeah, they might take that the wrong way.

I've heard stories about Harlan Ellison kicking people out of the autograph line for bringing blank pieces of paper for him to sign because they didn't have any of his books on hand. But Ellison is a notorious prick and most human beings are more sympathetic than that if you explain the predicament.

Sofistocat
03-19-2014, 10:00 AM
^ thx for the incite.

I asked Laird to sign an OA page of mine once. He said he wasn't involved with that specific page, but did sign the page. I could feel his hesitation, and understand why.

I asked Dooney to sign a "Out of my Skull" print by Talbot that had all the TMNT artist's name on headstones, he declined. Was a bit of a bummer, but I understood.

I have the color guide to the cover of Cable v.1 #1. Rob Liefeld had nothing to do with the comic, but happily signed the art and gave a nice impromptu speech about how "it shouldn't matter if you worked on something or not. The fan has a reason for wanting that specific thing signed". Though right after, he made a comment about signing for CGC SS, NM #87 and #98 and why he charges for those signatures(reseller aspect). He created Cable with Louise Simonson.

Prime Example: Do you have Eastman sign TMNT Vol. 4 #30 at FCBD? I would love to get KE's Jhonny Hancock on the book, but question the ethics of it. Yes I'm over-thinking it, which is why I started this thread. Given the situation(the FCBD TMNT artists will likely be in a assembly line fashion), is it poor form to say "please don't sign it" if the artist is in the middle of the line? Moral conundrum...

mrmaczaps
03-19-2014, 10:02 AM
With regards to Eastman/Laird, I have had both of them sign stuff that is Turtles because they are the creators. Regardless of incarnation, without them, there wouldn't be an IDW Turtles book.
Same with Jerry & Joe, if they were still around, I would have them sign just about any book with Superman in it if they were willing...
Now, if you are talking about say a random artist/writer, no, I wouldn't just have them sign any book I had on hand if they didn't write/draw/create a character used in that book. So I guess it depends... Per what you are talking about though... Sure, Kevin & Peter can sign anything Turtles... Funny how Turtles items work... I have a couple of items signed by Jim Lawson too that he didn't draw or anything, but its Turtles... Steve Lavigne signed a Nick Mikey giant figure/storage shell Turtle as well as the Mikey mini series from vol 4 and he didn't actually do anything for either of the creation process of those... but then he's the personality of Mikey...

mrmaczaps
03-19-2014, 10:06 AM
^ thx for the incite.

Prime Example: Do you have Eastman sign TMNT Vol. 4 #30 at FCBD? I would love to get KE's Jhonny Hancock on the book, but question the ethics of it. Yes I'm over-thinking it, which is why I started this thread. Given the situation(the FCBD TMNT artists will likely be in a assembly line fashion), is it poor form to say "please don't sign it" if the artist is in the middle of the line? Moral conundrum...

Heck yes have him sign it, he might even do a quick sketch on the inside back page! If both of my copies of issue #30 from vol 4 didn't already have sketches, i'd have him sketch mine really quick with his signature!

FCBD is going to be insane if you are coming to Jetpack... be prepared to wait!

plastroncafe
03-19-2014, 10:13 AM
For what it's worthy, I do this at every con I go to.
I find a print that has the name of the con and the date on it, and then I ask creators to sign it a la a year book.

Actually, funny enough I tried to pass it off as something else to Sean Astin at last year's SDCC, and he was like:

"So it's a yearbook? You should just call it your yearbook. That's awesome."

So there's that.
I've found that after a bit of confusion, people are really cool with it. And if they're not...then I just thank them for their time and move on. No harm, no foul.

I've had more people just excited to see the turtles being represented.

Powder
03-19-2014, 11:13 AM
Rarely. If I have an issue or something where I'm collecting signatures from all involved at Mirage or IDW, then yeah, but otherwise, no.

Redrumh2o
03-19-2014, 11:15 AM
Only if I get group Mirage sigs on a blank our some reissue of #1

The Fifth Turtle
03-19-2014, 11:42 AM
For me I feel that Kevin and Pete can sign anything as they are responsible for the turtles' existence. Other artists I feel should sign something they worked on or as mentioned before a year book type piece.

Heather Breckel
03-19-2014, 02:30 PM
I've had a bunch of people have me sign some random My Little Pony Micro Series issues that I didn't work on. I've done all of the ongoing and some of the micro issues, so it's never bothered me to sign the micro issues I haven't worked on. If it's an adult I usually double check and let them know I didn't work on the issue, but I'll still sign it if it's okay with them. With kids I don't mention it, especially since it's usually the only issue they have on them and I don't want to potentially let them down.

I would think a lot of people would be the same way, provided you're not like coming up to the person with something completely unrelated to what they work on. (ie you wouldn't come up to an exclusively DC artist with a Marvel title they've never worked on ever)

MrPliggins
03-19-2014, 05:20 PM
Personally, I'd rather have artists sign things they had a hand in creating. I got some flack while in line for Stan Lee for having him sign some silver age classics (not even keys). I don't understand having him sign Hulk #181 or ASM #129. While he did have a hand in creating the main characters, he did not create Wolverine or Punisher, which is what those comics are known for.

I've been thinking about this myself..trying to decide what to get signed by Kevin at the Gem City Con in a couple of weeks. I'm thinking about having him add his signature to a few which I had signed by Laird in '93: TMNT volume 1 #1 3rd printing, #10 and #11. Also, I think #14 is a given. As for what else, I'm really not sure.

To me there are different things Kevin and Peter are suited to sign. I wouldn't get anything 2k3 or volume 4 signed by Kevin. Likewise I wouldn't have Peter sign any IDW issues (except maybe the cover he inked). This is just my personal preference, but there is no right or wrong answer.

Also, I have seen TMNT volume 1 #1s signed by the other Mirage guys. Not a fan of this either..

Roseangelo
03-19-2014, 07:24 PM
I'm not big into autographs, so I generally only get signatures on art/art prints that I'm buying directly from the artist. I would have absolutely no interest in getting someone to sign something they didn't do.

I get Kevin to autograph some stuff (mostly the IDW hardcovers, or the books he's put out through Heavy Metal), but mostly as a novelty factor and not as a thought of adding value to something. I actually cringe when I see someone have Kevin sign something like a first print #1. I don't understand the attraction of having a big-ol' Sharpie autograph on something like that at all. I do like vintage books with vintage signatures in pen ink.

When I saw Kevin in Sacramento a few weeks ago I couldn't think of much to have him sign, so I brought one of the recent Nickelodeon tin TMNT lunchboxes.

MrPliggins
03-19-2014, 08:22 PM
I agree about having really expensive items signed. I don't even want to handle my TMNT #1 let alone get it signed..I'm glad it's in a CGC case.

I'm looking forward to going as I've never met Kevin before, but I'm more interested in original art/sketches than autographs.

Plasticplayhouse
03-20-2014, 07:49 AM
I'm not an autograph collector, but my opinion is that asking someone to sign something they had no part in creating could be construed as ignorant on your part and the creator might take offense.



i feel the same way. i don't look down on those who choose to collect like that, i just don't share the same desire.