PDA

View Full Version : weak turtles


Albrecht
07-19-2003, 02:25 PM
how come in ep 11 in the last fight scene after the turtels take out a group of foot soldiers and run into shredder they just stare at him him and get there asses pummeld.

Aztec General
07-19-2003, 04:01 PM
Ummm......because Shredder wouldn't be a very exciting villian if they beat him up easily? Besides he's supposed to be a ninjitsu master.

XERO
07-19-2003, 06:27 PM
Yeah it's kinda like the Matrix.

Shredder hits so fast, they just slowed it down, so it looks like the Turtles are just looking at him. :D

That's my opinion.

Albrecht
07-20-2003, 10:15 AM
i know he wouldnt be exiting if they beat him up but if they atleast hit him and hes not a ninjitsu master cause splinter can kick his ass and he admits that he is not 1.

Ralph2003
07-20-2003, 10:04 PM
how come in ep 11 in the last fight scene after the turtels take out a group of foot soldiers and run into shredder they just stare at him him and get there asses pummeld.
Well the best fighter of the turtles is Leo, and as we saw right before the Shredder showed up all of them (especially Leo) were extremeley tired from fighting all the foot and Hun. Shredder showed up after they fighted his henchmen and jumped in at full strength and so Shredder was able to knock them down easily. And it really pissed me off when he sent his henchmen back in the fight and was jumping in behind them fighting his foot instead of fighting them like a true ninja. I was so happy when Splinter finaly kicked his ass!

Dane E5R
07-21-2003, 01:17 AM
Man, Shredder is definitely a ninjutsu master no matter what. Albeit without honor, there's no questioning it. Plus his armor adds to his skills. Either way, the only time the turtles have been able to take on the Shredder easily was in the old cartoon. But in everything else, he always kicks their asses. So I think everything happened as it should have.

Taloniss
07-21-2003, 09:16 AM
i know he wouldnt be exiting if they beat him up but if they atleast hit him and hes not a ninjitsu master cause splinter can kick his ass and he admits that he is not 1.

Shredder told Leonardo he was a master when they were talking in episode 10, if I remember correctly.

Albrecht
07-21-2003, 10:17 AM
Man, Shredder is definitely a ninjutsu master no matter what. Albeit without honor, there's no questioning it. Plus his armor adds to his skills. Either way, the only time the turtles have been able to take on the Shredder easily was in the old cartoon. But in everything else, he always kicks their asses. So I think everything happened as it should have.

return to new york mirage vol. 1

leo chopped saki's head of in a roof top battle

Dane E5R
07-21-2003, 12:01 PM
1, that wasn't the real Shredder, 2, Leo still had a tough time doing that.

XERO
07-21-2003, 04:21 PM
And 3, that was like 2 years later. Leo and the Turtles have improved their skills since the last battle.

Quiller-Bee
07-21-2003, 07:24 PM
. . . and 4.), that's still just a little more than the other three could claim. (Tough time or not, he still did it.)

Deathknight
07-21-2003, 08:22 PM
You wanna talk about the TMNT losing a lot of skill take a look at Shredder Strikes Back Park 2. The turles and Splinter have a much harder time taking on the foot ninja even though they're well rested. That was what I really didn't like about that episode, I just didn't believe that the TMNT would be that weak all of a sudden. The only time the turtles really showed the strength they truely had was when they take on the Shredder Elite in the shop. Other than that, they really seemed a lot weaker to me.

Albrecht
07-21-2003, 08:55 PM
cuase they had to worry about leo.and raph is is to chicken **** to stab sum1 so they just get back up.

Dane E5R
07-21-2003, 09:32 PM
. . . and 4.), that's still just a little more than the other three could claim. (Tough time or not, he still did it.)

Eh, I wouldn't say that. Donatello killed the ORIGINAL Shredder. And let's not forget, Raph did kick Leo's ass earlier in that story. :D

cuase they had to worry about leo.and raph is is to chicken sh** to stab sum1 so they just get back up.

Buddy, you're skatin' a figure 8 on thin ice. Raphael is not going to stab someone on a Saturday morning cartoon show. And of all the turtles you decide you call a chicken sh*t...

To quoth my favorite turtle, "words fail me.."

Aztec General
07-21-2003, 09:34 PM
I have a feeling it's more the animators being too "chicken ****" to show Raph stabbing people. But what can you do?

5) Leo took his defeat very personally see Vol. 1 #11. He trained his ass off to be the best he could be, and was thus able to kill the shredder.

Deathknight
07-21-2003, 09:49 PM
cuase they had to worry about leo.and raph is is to chicken sh** to stab sum1 so they just get back up.
If they had to worry about Leo and thus was the cause of their lack of skill then the Shredder Elite would've easily beaten them. The skill they used on the foot ninja would've never made them victorious over the Shredder Elite. The Shredder Elite are much faster and better at ninjitsu than the foot ninja. Leonardo was able to take on tons foot ninja yet he couldn't come close to beating the Shredder Elite. I just wanna know how they heck the Shredder Elite teleport like they do. Is that explained in a later comic or something?

Dane E5R
07-21-2003, 11:23 PM
Nah, they don't teleport in the comics.

Quiller-Bee
07-22-2003, 04:36 AM
With difficulty, Leo decapitated “Shredder”. Raph didn't.

Raph kicked Leo's ass? As I recall, Leo held back. Before Raph tossed him, Leo rather easily put Raph down. In any real, unbridled fight, Leo would own Raph's ass.

As for the first battle with the Shredder, Leo was the one who ran Saki through with his ninja-to. To be technical about it, Leo dealt the first truly lethal blow.

Furthermore, the first battle was a team effort. It took all four Turtles to wear down and ultimately defeat the “real” Shredder. No single Turtle could have beaten him at that point in time. When Leo faced down the regenerated “Shredder”, that wasn't quite the case.

Don't get me wrong, Raph's one of my favorites as well. Still, we can discuss the issue theoretically and hypothetically and talk around it all we want, but what happened happened . . . and it simply is what it is. In the end, that's all that truly matters.

Albrecht
07-22-2003, 11:04 AM
and don didn't really kill shredder the 1st time he just knocked him off the building and he blew him self up.he might have died from the fall but he only steped on the ledge so no 1 could atack him but it was as QB said a team effort.

Dane E5R
07-22-2003, 01:43 PM
[quote="Quiller-Bee"]With difficulty, Leo decapitated “Shredder”. Raph didn't.

Raph kicked Leo's ass? As I recall, Leo held back. Before Raph tossed him, Leo rather easily put Raph down. In any real, unbridled fight, Leo would own Raph's ass.
quote]

I didn't see ANY signs of Leo holding back in his fight against Raph. I saw him deal the first blow and slightly come back once. Nothing he did against Raph was done 'rather easily.' Raph totally owned him. How do you figure Leo "held back?"

Albrecht
07-22-2003, 02:28 PM
hes more mature and he didn't want to hurt the little bitch

Dane E5R
07-22-2003, 03:59 PM
hes more mature and he didn't want to hurt the little bitch

How about an opinion from someone that matters.

Quiller-Bee
07-22-2003, 05:13 PM
Leo's a superior warrior to Raphael in every way. Admittedly, Raph's physically the strongest (which is ironic since he's emotionally and mentally the weakest) and the most ferocious—not best—fighter. His poor attitude and lack of self-control are the reasons why he's not the best. Leo never truly “entered” the fight, and one way that I “figure” that is due to the fact that Leo always has had a much firmer grip on his emotions. The emotional, raging berserkers may make for cool and interesting comic book characters, but, in reality, they will always lose out to the level headed, calculating fighters. I think that's applicable in the Turtle's “reality” as well.

PanMan
07-22-2003, 05:14 PM
well, about the shredder strikes back second parter, the foot swarmed the tmnt and they didn't know what to expect. the foot were probably pumped that they nearly killed leo too, so that might have added fuel to their fire. and when have we ever seen the tmnt fight the foot without leo? it has always been a team effort. this time they were on their own (even though they had splinter to replace leo . . . shut-up :wink: )

Albrecht
07-23-2003, 10:00 AM
they would have thrashed the foot's asses if leo was there and if mr. jones had appeared earlier.(and imageine if the silver sentry showed up... jeez im an idiot.)

Dane E5R
07-23-2003, 04:24 PM
Leo's a superior warrior to Raphael in every way. Admittedly, Raph's physically the strongest (which is ironic since he's emotionally and mentally the weakest) and the most ferocious—not best—fighter. His poor attitude and lack of self-control are the reasons why he's not the best. Leo never truly “entered” the fight, and one way that I “figure” that is due to the fact that Leo always has had a much firmer grip on his emotions. The emotional, raging berserkers may make for cool and interesting comic book characters, but, in reality, they will always lose out to the level headed, calculating fighters. I think that's applicable in the Turtle's “reality” as well.

I will agree that Leo is over all "the best," but even the best have their off days. This was definitely one of them. I disagree that Leo never really entered that fight, since he actually threw the first blow. Also, if he had such a greater sense of control and rationality, he would have stayed down when Raph told him to instead of continuing the fight. I only see one moment when Leo actually tried to flee... After kicking Raph in the face. And for the brief moment he had Raph on the ground, he looked pretty pissed to me. That was not one turtle going off on a berserker rage and the other turtle being calm cool and collected with a firm grip on his emotions, this was two turtles being pissed off at each other and getting INTO it. It was hardly a ninja fight. It was an all out brawl, in which Raph was undisputably victorious.

redsai4lex
07-30-2003, 03:26 AM
i know he wouldnt be exiting if they beat him up but if they atleast hit him and hes not a ninjitsu master cause splinter can kick his ass and he admits that he is not 1.Raph is the only 1 2 hit him :lol:

Quiller-Bee
07-30-2003, 04:49 PM
Yes, Raph did win that one, I don't disagree with you there.

Why did Leo not stay down when Raph told him to? Because Leo has a little "Raph" deep down inside of himself . . . most of us do. (That's one reason why they're my two favorite characters: because I see them as being flip sides of the same coin; examples of different paths taken. Both have qualities and flaws that the other possesses.) Raph brought out the worst in Leo, but I still don't think he was quite as pissed as Raph can get. He didn't go into "kill mode" and totally lose control. Leo simply wouldn't get that way with one of his brothers, as Raphael once did with Mikey. I think Leo simply works harder to keep that aspect of his own personality—among others—under control. If Leo had faced Raph in the same manner as he would the Shredder, the outcome might have been a little different. That, however, did not happen . . . the same way any of the other Turtles besides Leo killing the Shredder didn't happen.

Leo's greater sense of self control has been evident throughout the rest of the series, as has Raph's lack. He's not perfect, and that is exactly what that tussle displayed. As you said, even the best have their off days. However, Leo's generally got a better grip than Raph in the emotional department.

That being said, what I don't see is how Raph and Leo's little scuffle has any real bearing on the final battle between Leonardo and the “Shredder". When the Turtles first faced "Saki Shredder", it was made obvious to the reader that no single Turtle could have taken him alone. (It can, however, be justly argued that if Saki hadn't pulled the grenade, etc., he would have died from the fatal wound that Leo inflicted.)

Although Leo had been worn down by countless Foot, we're basically lead to believe that the regenerated Shredder kicked his ass in their first encounter. That wasn't the case in Return to NY, after Leo had healed and trained, etc.. At that point in time, Leo was the only Turtle who could have gone toe-to-toe with that or any other incarnation of the Shredder and have lived to tell about it, let alone defeat him. (How cool/imposing/intimidating would The Shredder seem if Leo simply "owned" him? Heroes are defined by the level of difficulty of the obstacles they overcome.) Eastman and Laird chose Leo for that task. It wasn't Mike, Don, Raph or all of the Turtles combined. It was Leo.

TheShredder
08-01-2003, 10:01 PM
Because if they killed me the show would be over!

Karpo_007
08-02-2003, 07:04 AM
No it wouldn't. In fact Shredder might bot even be in season 2.

Albrecht
08-02-2003, 10:41 AM
the comics lived on with out him, but his name is in the theme song and so is he.

Brodie
08-02-2003, 11:27 AM
hes more mature and he didn't want to hurt the little bitch

How about an opinion from someone that matters.

:lol:

Poor Garey, he doesn't matter to anyone.

Albrecht
08-02-2003, 11:49 AM
go away!

Deathknight
08-02-2003, 03:23 PM
I hope Shredder doesn't get killed off any time soon but he's not essential to the plot. His forces will live on though! The Shredder Elite are awesome, I hope they get some more appearances. And about Shredder being mentioned in the theme song, Shredder was also mentioned in the final theme for the original series and even though Dregg took Shredder's place as the turtle's nemesis the theme song didn't change.

Karpo_007
08-02-2003, 03:36 PM
I guess we just have to wait and see what happens in Return to New York...

Raven
08-02-2003, 03:59 PM
go away!

who are you telling to go away?

Albrecht
08-03-2003, 09:16 AM
brodie

Raven
08-03-2003, 10:10 AM
ok................thats really nice :roll:

Psycrow
08-03-2003, 02:29 PM
I believe it's the episode "The Shredder Strikes Part 1", where Leo single handily takes on his fellow TMNT with the greatest of ease.

Also, in the episode "Meet Casey Jones", Raph gets his shell handed to him by Mikey.

Why did I bring up this information? Just to stir up the pot a little. :D

heretic888
08-05-2003, 02:43 PM
Just thought i'd add some stuff....

1) Leo did hold back against Raph. Leo in fact had Raph beaten but purposely stopped slamming the bokken into his throat because he didn't want to maim his brother. Raph took advantage of this and "won" the fight.

In addition, Leo later saved Raph from the Shredder Elite that ambushed him on his way to Shredder's quarters. Leo also repeatedly beat him in sparring sessions just prior to City at War.

2) Raph is not hardly the best, either. Mike seemed to make a hobby out of kicking his ass in the early issues.

3) Shredder was only defeated the 1st time because all the turtles wore him down. Interestingly, only Mike and Leo could damage him during the one on one salvos.

4) The turtles were 13 when they first fought Shredder. When Leo fought the "new" Shredder, he was 16. Not to mention the farmhouse training put in. That all makes a difference.

5) The only turtle that really "trained" on his own during their farmhouse retreat was Mike. Leo just spent time in the woods hunting deer. Still, Splinter gave them all training (although it didn't seem to register that well with Raph, big suprise).

6) There is no reason to believe the other turtles could not have done just as well against Shredder, despite Quiller Bee's protests to the contrary. Well, maybe not Raph. But, c'mon, Mike downed two of those clones at once! :P

Dane E5R
08-05-2003, 03:52 PM
I will not accept "he didn't kill him" as proof of Leo holding back, because Raph could just have easily killed Leo if he had wanted. Leo in NO WAY had the fight that controlled, because if he did, he wouldn't have ended up through a wall. And how many times has Mike beaten Raph, exactly? I only remember the one time in issue 2. Based on what I've seen, I simply can't believe that Mike is that much better than Raph. And you're not going to tell me that Raph is the only turtle that couldn't have taken on the Shredder, because, well, that's just bullsh*t. If Don could do it, Raph could do it. 'Nuff said. Oh, and I hope you're joking about Mike taking out those two clones.. It's not as though he just opened up a regular can of ninjutsu whoop ass, he just hit one with a stick into another one. I can easily see any of the 4 turtles doing that. Especially Don since it's his stick! :D

Quiller-Bee
08-05-2003, 04:13 PM
1.) Agreed.

2.) Same here.

3.) Ditto.

4.) The first sentence in your statement can only be assumed, but I will say that it's at least a good ballpark estimate . . . unless, however, you have based this idea on factually stated information from some source other than issue #1. (When Laird gets his official timeline finished, maybe we'll know their exact age for sure. Until then, I'll opt for “not 100% certain” in regard to their age at that time.)

The remainder of #4: Agreed.

5.) This point also can only be assumed from what we were actually shown in the comics. A good bit usually happens “between the panels”, so the statement that Mike was the only one who trained on his own is merely an assumption.

6.) “Believe” being the keyword in your opening sentence, I'll agree with you. I personally believe that Leo was most likely the only one capable dispatching the Shredder at that point in time, as he did so by only a narrow margin. If any of the others could have done it, I think that Mikey would definitely have been next in line. However, we'll now never know for certain what the outcome of a one-on-one battle between the Shredder and any of the other Turtles might have been.

Psycrow
08-05-2003, 05:41 PM
In my experiences, and this is just my opinion, it appears Raph does the best when he fights "others" and not his turtle companions. Sure it always displays him as a losing figure when he spars with the rest of the TMNT, but when they are out fighting the foot or street thugs, he always looks like he is the tough one of the group and the main fighting force.

This is probably because he doesn't hold back and goes all out, but that's the way I see it.

Karpo_007
08-06-2003, 08:50 AM
Raphael is the most effective fighter against less skilled foes, like the basic Foot ninja. It's totally diffrent thing than fighting Shredder elite for example.

heretic888
08-07-2003, 12:24 PM
Well, relying on raw strength and speed works.... as long as you are fighting someone else relying on strength and speed and you happen to be stronger and faster than them!! :lol:

Despite Raph's strength and speed, however, sheer numbers will eventually overcome that. As well as skill. That is why Raph gets taken by guys like Leo, Mike, and the Elite.

And how many times has Mike beaten Raph, exactly? I only remember the one time in issue 2.

At least twice. And, in both instances, Mike had a noticable advantage over him. Very similar to Mike's fight with him in the Casey Jones episode.

I will not accept "he didn't kill him" as proof of Leo holding back, because Raph could just have easily killed Leo if he had wanted. Leo in NO WAY had the fight that controlled, because if he did, he wouldn't have ended up through a wall.

Look again. Up until the point that Leo stops himself from lobotomizing Raph with the bokken, he had a clear advantage. Also, right before City at War, Raph and Leo spar and Raph is repeatedly beaten.

Oh, and I hope you're joking about Mike taking out those two clones.. It's not as though he just opened up a regular can of ninjutsu whoop ass, he just hit one with a stick into another one. I can easily see any of the 4 turtles doing that. Especially Don since it's his stick!

Don was the one disarmed. Mike wasn't. Mike pelted that little freak right into the other one, and then proceeded to smack uzi-wielding foot soldiers with his nunchaku. That's skill, buddy.