View Full Version : Issue #1 Signature question
halperin
04-15-2014, 09:57 PM
im in the market for a first print issue #1 so i have a few noob questions.
in your experience how much if any does a signature series book increase the value. say a 9.0 ss vs a 9.0 universal.
also, do you find that the signature and sketch on the front cover increases or reduces value.
thanks
MrPliggins
04-16-2014, 05:54 PM
To me a signature on the cover of an expensive book like TMNT #1 would reduce the value. Why not just get a 3rd printing signed and sketched? It's virtually the same cover.
In general though, a signature/sketch will increase the value slightly, but there will be less of a buyer pool. Similar to a CGC 9.8 TMNT #1. People will drool over it all day, but who is going to "shell" out $15k+? Very limited pool of buyers.
How much would the value increase? I rarely see signed #1s for sale. The last one I can see that sold is a 9.0 CGC SS which sold for $4,675.00 on Sept. 10, 2013 (Eastman and Laird signatures with sketches). But then, a 9.0 Universal sold just a month earlier for $4,250. So it seems the increase is minimal.
If you're in it for investment and eventual resell, get a 6.0-9.2 universal, which has a much larger pool of buyers who can afford it, thus still driving the price up.
If you're in it for the love of collecting and it would mean a great deal for you to get a first printing signed, by all means get it done. But I'd advise against getting it signed just to raise the value.
Careful buying a raw copy, especially if buying online. I bought one from Ebay that turned out to be fake, and I know of others who have had trouble with buying it raw. At least in a graded case you know it has no restoration or interior defects. You can always break it out of the case.
halperin
04-17-2014, 12:51 AM
thats interesting about investment.. i would imagine that the higher grades, while they do cost more and have a smaller buyer pool, hold their value more if things deflate because there are is such a small number of them that the few buyers wil stil drive price up.
thebrownranger
04-17-2014, 01:47 AM
To me a signature on the cover of an expensive book like TMNT #1 would reduce the value.
I feel exactly the same way. Personally, I don't like getting comics signed anymore whether they be a first printing or not. I feel like signing something like that just takes away from the originality/condition of it. That's just my opinion anyway.
MrPliggins
04-17-2014, 07:37 AM
The thing about 9.8 is, when more come out of the woodwork, the value goes down. Years ago a 9.8 sold for about $25k when there was 1 or 2 in existence. Now that more 9.8s have been graded, the price has settled down to around $15k. That's not to say it won't climb back up in the future. I'm just saying the lower grades are a safer bet investment-wise and an easier sell.
To me a signature is valuable only to the person who gets the signature and has the personal experience of meeting/communicating with the artist. I have no interest in buying signatures from ebay with no experience to go along with it.
And with rare/expensive items, such as TMNT #1, there are only so many to go around. Best to keep them in the best condition possible. However, if it is your thing, and you're doing it for personal reasons, go for it. In the end it's yours to do with what you please.
Sofistocat
04-17-2014, 07:55 AM
thats interesting about investment.. i would imagine that the higher grades, while they do cost more and have a smaller buyer pool, hold their value more if things deflate because there are is such a small number of them that the few buyers wil stil drive price up.
Good thoughts Pliggins, I concur. I'm starting to see more and more that TMNT #1 is becoming the copper age comic book to own. The signature may raise the FMV of the book at the offset that your also potentially reducing the market size of interested buyers. Many buyers do not want the sig's so it's kind of a wash IMHO. I do like SS slabs, but mostly due to the memories had in getting them signed and graded. I do not. and most likely will not, own any universal slabs. I keep it strictly yellow label.
halperin
04-17-2014, 09:14 AM
whats the difference between blue, yellow, green, and universal labels?
Sofistocat
04-17-2014, 09:15 AM
whats the difference between blue, yellow, green, and universal labels?
http://www.cgccomics.com/grading/label_description.asp
halperin
04-17-2014, 09:22 AM
awesome thanks for the link. its what i thought.
from what it looks like to me, i dont see a huge diff in price from a universal to a SS slab. just personal preference but i would tihnk that the majority of collectors would prefer no signature on cover. maybe inside cover would be nice. so its signed but doesnt hurt the display
Sofistocat
04-17-2014, 09:25 AM
awesome thanks for the link. its what i thought.
from what it looks like to me, i dont see a huge diff in price from a universal to a SS slab. just personal preference but i would tihnk that the majority of collectors would prefer no signature on cover. maybe inside cover would be nice. so its signed but doesnt hurt the display
Universal labels will note if the cover is signed on the inside. There are quite a few TMNT books like this. Personally, I don't see the point of slabbing and forever sealing the signature. Unless you were going to sell the book.
The Fifth Turtle
04-17-2014, 09:53 AM
I feel exactly the same way. Personally, I don't like getting comics signed anymore whether they be a first printing or not. I feel like signing something like that just takes away from the originality/condition of it. That's just my opinion anyway.
I feel the same way. This line of thinking is how I view all collectibles. I will be having E & L sign my OT season 1 animation cels with original painted background (completed scene) but it is locked in an artist's board so they are only signing the plastic that encases the item and not the item itself. Best to go with a cheaper item then a more expensive item when it comes to sigs.
thebrownranger
04-17-2014, 10:29 AM
Right? I wonder how many unaltered/unadulterated 1st printings of Mirage vol. 1 TMNT #1 there are left in the world now. Would be a shame to see a majority of them altered and only a few handful of untouched originals left.
I remember buying a vol. 1 #1 (3rd printing), #2 (2nd printing), Raphael #1 (1st printing) all signed by Eastman and Laird from Ralph DiBernardo from Jetpack Comics back at NYCC '08. I didn't think much then because I was too excited because I bought them for dirt cheap then. If I bought a signed issue now I wouldn't feel the same way for many reasons because, 1) I'm not the one who got the comic signed so I wasn't there to witness it and can't trust the validity of the signature and 2) Like I said before, I personally feel like it takes away from the originality/value being altered and God only knows how many originals are left. I'm cool with having those signed issues now because I know I got it from a reputable source, so it's cool knowing that the issues I got are from the guy who helped Eastman and Laird at their first con (correct me if I'm wrong).
Eastman did a signing session at the end of the TMNT II: SOTO movie screening at The Alamo Drafthouse back in February; I met a guy who scored a fine condition TMNT #1 1ST printing for $800. It bugged me so much knowing that he was getting it signed. Of course, I kept my mouth shut; he can do what he wants. But man, if I ever score a volume one 1st printing for a reasonable price, I'm gonna case that thing up and leave it unaltered and untouched.
The Fifth Turtle
04-17-2014, 11:03 AM
But man, if I ever score a volume one 1st printing for a reasonable price, I'm gonna case that thing up and leave it unaltered and untouched.
I was lucky enough to score mine right before the new TMNT boom and it is at least an 8.5 (as per the ex CGC employee who pressed it for me). It is going to remain unslabbed, unsigned and untouched on my shelf til I'm buried with it.
Mayhem
04-17-2014, 12:44 PM
My issue #1 first print is signed (on the inside cover), but that's how I purchased it. Previous owner originally bought it in 1984 and got it signed in person in 1985 from both Kevin and Peter, so I'm only the second owner on it. Probably an 8.0 or so grade wise, but I'd never slab it because I don't do comic grading heh. It sits on my shelf along with all the other #1 printings.
Out of curiosity though, given yellow is SS but only in the presence of someone from CGC, what colour would my copy get if I got it graded?
The Fifth Turtle
04-17-2014, 12:47 PM
My issue #1 first print is signed (on the inside cover), but that's how I purchased it. Previous owner originally bought it in 1984 and got it signed in person in 1985 from both Kevin and Peter, so I'm only the second owner on it. Probably an 8.0 or so grade wise, but I'd never slab it because I don't do comic grading heh. It sits on my shelf along with all the other #1 printings.
Out of curiosity though, given yellow is SS but only in the presence of someone from CGC, what colour would my copy get if I got it graded?
It would receive a Green tag.
MrPliggins
04-17-2014, 04:57 PM
Actually if it's signed on the inside, it will still get a blue label, but the signatures will be noted on the label. The green label is qualified, which is for any cover signatures unwitnessed, or any large defect (ie. a coupon cut out). Green label is basically what the grade WOULD be without that large defect.
Also if it is under a certain grade but signed on the cover, it will get a blue label also. The reasoning is that if it's a low grade, writing on the cover doesn't really affect the grade much.
I kind of like stuff that was signed back in 1984. It adds to the history. But signing a first printing of #1 now just seems wrong for some reason. ::shrug::
I bought my TMNT #1 1st printing in a CGC case and it's still slabbed. It's the perfect protection for it. I'd be nervous if it was just sitting about raw. I like universal slabs for this reason, for the protection. If I ever get an Amazing Spider-man #1 or Hulk #1, it will also need to be slabbed. I don't normally collect slabbed books unless it's a really expensive one. Peace of mind.
The Fifth Turtle
04-17-2014, 06:39 PM
Ah didn't know that. I just thought that unwitnessed = green. Learn something new everyday.
Sofistocat
04-17-2014, 07:06 PM
Ah didn't know that. I just thought that unwitnessed = green. Learn something new everyday.
unverified exterior signatures/sketches by anyone after publication = Green label
at a certain point of criteria, the markings will be treated as a defect and begin to lower the grade regardless of the actual physical condition of the book.
Roseangelo
04-17-2014, 08:19 PM
Right? I wonder how many unaltered/unadulterated 1st printings of Mirage vol. 1 TMNT #1 there are left in the world now. Would be a shame to see a majority of them altered and only a few handful of untouched originals left.
Mine is "unaltered" and will be staying that way. I keep meaning to get it graded, but only for the extra protection of the case. I'd like to eventually do that for all the oversized books.
Eastman did a signing session at the end of the TMNT II: SOTO movie screening at The Alamo Drafthouse back in February; I met a guy who scored a fine condition TMNT #1 1ST printing for $800. It bugged me so much knowing that he was getting it signed. Of course, I kept my mouth shut; he can do what he wants.
I remember seeing a video of that guy getting the book signed. I couldn't help but think him an idiot.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.