PDA

View Full Version : Why Did the CGI TMNT series get canned?


Ralph2003
07-23-2003, 11:36 PM
I mean don't get me wrong I love the new series, but I just saw the pilot and it put the current one to shame! I know there was talk a while back about John Woo directing a CGI turtle movie but that was put on the shelf. What they need to do is use the material from the pilot and make the movie because it would kick ass!

Leo656
07-24-2003, 12:02 AM
There probably just wasn't any demand at that point, or at least that probably played a heavy factor. I mean this new revival of TMNT is awesome, but it likely wouldn't be possible without the current trend of 80s nostalgia that brought He-Man, Transformers, Thundercats and G.I. Joe back. It's all about timing, in many cases. I think it's likely nobody really wanted to throw their support behind a new TMNT project a few years ago because there just wasn't enough interest to justify it.

Ninjatron
07-24-2003, 12:46 AM
I don't think the nostalgia boom has much to do with it at all. From what I've gathered, that was more of a coincidence than anything else, though I'm sure it did ultimately help in the public's eye.

Bottom line is they wanted to do a CGI series, they had the 5 min "pilot" made, and they shopped it around. There was some interest in it, but, as I understand things, there was more interest in doing a 2D show. Warner Bros wanted to animate a 2D show, so they went ahead in that direction and amde a pitch. Then, the big cheeses at Warners decided not to buy the pitch.

Somehow, and I don't know the details, but 4Kids entered the picture and all of a sudden TMNT is going to be on their recently purchased (at the time) block of time on Fox Saturday mornings. It was a big shock and I didn't see it coming because we'd been reading rumors about the whole Warner Bros thing.

So I suppose by the time 4Kids was involved they had simply changed focus to 2D. Though it's possible that they started from stratch again and the option of CGI was thrown around at 4Kids before moving back to 2D for whatever reason.

I want to say that cost could be a reason but I don't think there is such a huge difference in price between CGI and 2D TV animation anymore. Could have been a design decision or something regarding availability of resources. Who knows?

Whatever reason it was, it had to have been a good one, because Peter Larid seemed REALLY high on the CGI thing. Though I'm quite glad that 2D won out in the end.

The John Woo movie is a complely different and mostly unrelated thing. It was that same CGI pilot that got John Woo interested in doing a movie, however the deal they signed came with the condition of the TMNT getting on TV. Apparently the deal expired before that could happen, which seems a bit weird to me. Perhaps it was the switch from WB to 4Kids that delayed things.

Geez, this is complicated stuff! They could make a movie just about all of that!

Sayonara.

XERO
07-24-2003, 01:03 AM
I always thought they canned the show because it was too expensive.

Ralph2003
07-24-2003, 01:29 AM
I always thought they canned the show because it was too expensive.
They're stupid then, because from what I saw ratings could have been through the roof. But I have to say the new series is still great.

malignant
07-24-2003, 01:40 AM
It was based on the Money...ans CGI cost way more to make then a 2d cartoon.

Ralph2003
07-24-2003, 01:46 AM
It was based on the Money...ans CGI cost way more to make then a 2d cartoon.
Well on a toonzone.com article it said in a way with CGI it costs less because it takes less time and less people to make it.

The Master
07-24-2003, 08:45 AM
Well one reason they may have wanted to do 2D instead of 3D is because of the fact that the old cartoon was in 2D. And we all know the huge success of the old cartoon. So changing mediums may have been considered risky.

I mean, look at The Next Mutation. Yes, us Turtle fans don't like it cause it totally screwed them up, but kids don't care about that. The thing was, kids just weren't interested in it. Maybe because it wasn't traditionally animated like almost all other kids cartoons.

Also, with this huge popularity in Japanese anime, the prospect of a 2D show in kind of that same style is much less risky than something else. And I can see a lot of Japanese anime influence in the new TMNT, and the vast majority of new cartoons today, really.

Karpo_007
07-24-2003, 09:24 AM
Im not sure what was the reason why they wanted to make a traditionally animated cartoon, but it has proved to be a good choice. Animation in the new show is very detailed, very detailed CGI series would require a lot of time and money. CGI movie would have been neat, to bad it didn't happen.

Stone Ill
07-24-2003, 09:36 AM
Yeah, I suppose we'd be spoiled if we had both shows. But the new one's great. And, I guess I'm one of the few people who actually enjoyed The Next Mutation. I didn't really follow the plot, but I was just like "Hey, it's Ninja Turtles. I remember them." and me and my two bros started to watch it.

Aztec General
07-24-2003, 10:04 AM
Turtles return had to do with the popularity of the following:

1) 80's Action Cartoon Nostalgia- He-Man, G.I. Joe, Transformers (they never left but they got more popular), Thundercats
2) The Matrix- It got people interested in high action martial arts again. I mean jeez, how many movies ripped it off?
3) Anime- There's definitely some anime design influence in the new show.

Thus the timing was right for TMNT to make a return. I hope it lasts, because so far it's been fantastic.

Reznorite420
07-24-2003, 01:07 PM
I always thought they canned the show because it was too expensive.Pfft...think about this:

For a 2-D animated show, you have to keep re-drawing the same characters over and over again, thus using money at a rapid pace, eventually leading it down the drain. With 3-D computer models, you only need to actually "draw" the models one time, and they're done for the whole show! The only feat that needs to be accomplished from then on is the animation of the models and settings. Sure, the computers, software, and licensing may cost more limbs than 2-D animation, but the former 2 only need to paid for one time in life; once those are done, you can just keep re-using the same stuff (for a while anyway, considering the pace at which technology advances today). With 2-D animation, you constantly have to re-spend money on buying new paper, cells, drawing utinsels (sp?), and all other studio stuff.

Based on the insight I have provided, I doubt very much that money was even remotely an issue in the CGI series.

Raijin Z
07-24-2003, 03:25 PM
3) Anime- There's definitely some anime design influence in the new show.Well, when you farm out the betweening to Korea, and have Japanese supervision, of course it's going to start feeling like your average anime. That reminds me, I should write a thesis on anime, and how it doesn't exist. Stereotypical anime, yes, with the gigantic eyes on every character and the school-centric heroics, but not every show is like that. By the layman's description, Justice League is more Japanese than Jin Roh.

tormentedvagrant
07-25-2003, 07:19 AM
a major reason it appers to be like anime is because the martial arts styles and the animes come from the same place.