PDA

View Full Version : To everyone against the clothing/gear


Wildcat
05-12-2014, 01:02 AM
I too was thinking they had a bit too much on and some things are unnecessary but I just realized...Bebop and Rocksteady had alot of clothing and stuff on too. Why didn't that bother anybody?

They had shirts, pants, shoes, pads and basically everything the new live action turtles have.

I know they were mutated humans but still just because the turtles were turtles first doesn't mean they have to be naked. The clothing isn't that strange the more you see it. Its really just ninja wear, except Mikey, which fits his personality and Don's backpack probably has a purpose.

electric_sheep
05-12-2014, 01:04 AM
I too was thinking they had a bit too much on and some things are unnecessary but I just realized...Bebop and Rocksteady had alot of clothing and stuff on too. Why didn't that bother anybody?

They had shirts, pants, shoes, pads and basically everything the new live action turtles have.

I know they were mutated humans but still just because the turtles were turtles first doesn't mean they have to be naked. The clothing isn't that strange the more you see it. Its really just ninja wear, except Mikey, which fits his personality and Don's backpack probably has a purpose.

Sunglasses, a bunch of crap on your back and a twigs armour ninja wear? Wouldn't that cause more noise that ninja's should make?
Bebop and Rocksteady started out as humans so it makes sense for them to wear clothes.

Wildcat
05-12-2014, 01:12 AM
Sunglasses, a bunch of crap on your back and a twigs armour ninja wear? Wouldn't that cause more noise that ninja's should make?
Bebop and Rocksteady started out as humans so it makes sense for them to wear clothes.Well fighting wear. Ya know what I mean. The turtles have never been portrayed as realistic ninjas...this has been brought up before this movie.

Refractive Reflections
05-12-2014, 02:01 AM
Bebop and Rocksteady were the stereotypical punks who were loud and attention-grabbing with their destruction and personalities; so why not also expect it with their clothes? They didn't concern themselves with stealth like ninjas are supposed to be, as one of the foremost principles of their fighting technique. Should we really expect the same loud and gaudiness from the Turtles who are supposed to be ninjas?

The main reason the gear/clothes fail in my eyes, is because it doesn't suit practicality, in fact some of the gear can be not only superfluous, but possibly even detrimental. I mean Donnie wearing glasses... seriously? He's going to be involved with physical combat and this Turtle can invent the craziest technology out there, but yet he can't even design contacts? Oh brother... All an enemy has to do is just knock Donatello's glasses off, and he'll be easy pickings since his vision is apparently so bad he needs these corrective lenses in physical combat.

Leo's bamboo armor? Cool looking perhaps. Practical when there are bullets being fired (which this 2014 movie seems to imply)? Not at all... and he's supposed to be the most strategic and knowledgeable about combat situations. At least if Leo wore some type of bulletproof armor then I could accept the design, but whatever...

Wildcat
05-12-2014, 02:15 AM
^ Ya, like I said some things are unnecessary, like Don's glasses which was one of the things I was referring too. Also the necklaces but I can see wanting to wear a personal item even its not practical. Not the glasses though.

The bamboo armor doesn't help in gun fights but if he did have some kind of metal/bulletproof armor I think people would complain even more for it being over the top. Thats actually something I would not like myself.

The clothing itself though is really just cover-up and fight wear.

Candy Kappa
05-12-2014, 02:39 AM
Not sure what Raph's loincloth thing is useful for? Or Mikey's waist sweater. And I have griped about the impracticality about Leo's shoulder plates that don't look properly secured as shoulder plates should be to be useful, he isn't in a larp.


For me, it's not as much as the turtles wearing different gear then the traditional look, it's what the designers chose and what we get on the turtles that bugs me. So not the concept of different clothes, but the execution.

slingtheory
05-12-2014, 05:13 AM
Just to add to what other people are saying bebop and rocksteady started off as humans and the clothes we see them wearing are the same as what they had on when they were mutated. It could be a case of old habits dying hard, a way for them to hold on to whatever humanity they have left or considering who we're talking about maybe they were just to lazy to take them off. And besides they're meant to be big guady and eyecatching powerhouses everything the turtles are not. The tmnt were never human and therefore don't have a human reference on things and none of the reasons to dress up thatb&r do. Its not something they would miss and its not a human practice they would imatate because they don't want to be human but just accepted by humans for what they are.
That being said I'm not against this look because its not traditional but because the most important word in the title to me is ninja. I just imagine that if the turtles, who spend 15 years living in a sewer training to perfect thier skills were going to wear anything it would be about ninja practicality. That's the beauty of the original design it was simple and functional just protective pads on the joints and belts tp carry their weapons. Very minimal, nothing that would hinder movement or slow them down. The movies gear looks like the complete opposite. It doesn't look functional or protective and a lot of it looks like they'd be worse off for wearing it. I'm not sure what purpose you get out of bamboo chest plates that look useless against not only bullets but pretty much everything or loincloths when you shouldn't have visable junk to begin with or swaeterss tied around your waist like you just stepped out of a 90s highschool. and poor Donatello has it the worst. not only does it look like he'd be weighted down by all that gear but you expect me to believe he can make or scavenge a pair of night vision goggles but not a pair of sports glasses. did anybody put more than 2 seconds of thought into this?

Candy Kappa
05-12-2014, 05:15 AM
As an add-on about Bebop and Rocksteady. In Archie, when they began getting memories of a "past" life as their respective animal, they also retire on a paradise planet filled with wildlife, and they ditch their clothes.

Donatello19
05-12-2014, 05:26 AM
Well, Bebop and Rocksteady started out as humans, so...

Myko
05-12-2014, 05:48 AM
As an add-on about Bebop and Rocksteady. In Archie, when they began getting memories of a "past" life as their respective animal, they also retire on a paradise planet filled with wildlife, and they ditch their clothes.

That really annoyed me as a kid. Why would they have memories of past animal lives they didn't have?

Candy Kappa
05-12-2014, 05:59 AM
It was odd for sure, but maybe the mutagen imprints memories to the victim that will eventually surface subconsciously, on adults.

Or maybe R&B just got a huge animal instinct spike for a period, yearning so much for a wildlife lifestyle they started to dream about it.

Radical Raph
05-12-2014, 08:07 AM
I look at it as them wanting to fit in with humans and/or show off their personalities. Why stop at just colored bandanas?

Splinter always wore clothes because he's dignified. I would think since he's basically their father, they would try to emulate him.

Candy Kappa
05-12-2014, 08:11 AM
I doubt it has anything to do with dignity, seems more like Rat!Splinter just likes robes or kimonos, maybe it's a memorabilia after Yoshi?

Cause Rat!Splinter don't use trouser or underwear, just a kimono.

Radical Raph
05-12-2014, 08:26 AM
I doubt it has anything to do with dignity, seems more like Rat!Splinter just likes robes or kimonos, maybe it's a memorabilia after Yoshi?

Cause Rat!Splinter don't use trouser or underwear, just a kimono.
I guess you could look at it that way. But then again, being a rat covered in fur and living underground doesn't exactly require you to wear clothes. I wear button up shirts because I like the way they look, but I wear clothes in general because, well, I'm too dignified to just walk around in the nude.

Candy Kappa
05-12-2014, 09:01 AM
Or, using clothes is a social norm. As it is in most modern societies, complete nakedness is a no no.

NoName999
05-12-2014, 09:37 AM
I too was thinking they had a bit too much on and some things are unnecessary but I just realized...Bebop and Rocksteady had alot of clothing and stuff on too. Why didn't that bother anybody?


They're not masters of ninjutsu.

Radical Raph
05-12-2014, 09:46 AM
Or, using clothes is a social norm. As it is in most modern societies, complete nakedness is a no no.
I would still argue that Splinter wears clothes because he sees himself as something more than just a rat which would translate to a more dignified being. The fact that his clothes also pay respect to his past only highlights this. Either way, I think the turtles probably wear clothes because Splinter does and because they are teenagers looking to fit in.

UGHShellshocked
05-12-2014, 09:52 AM
The way I see it the toy line had all kinds of costumes on, there were clowns turtles, cavemen turtles, astronaut turtles and even sumo wrestler turtles. So they wear Samurai armor/loincloth/gadgets/sweat shirt shouldn't be such a big deal.

http://dinosaurdracula.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/28.jpg

SwiftNinjaFox
05-12-2014, 11:50 AM
I look at it as them wanting to fit in with humans and/or show off their personalities. Why stop at just colored bandanas?

Splinter always wore clothes because he's dignified. I would think since he's basically their father, they would try to emulate him.

"April, why do humans want to make themselves look dumber than they already are?" - Raphael from OT

Raphael in Mirage said that humans wear clothes because their bodies are ugly. :lol:

There's always been a bit of wanting to be accepted for who they are, not be accepted for adopting human appearances.

I just think it's a bit unnecessary myself, though I kind of dig the bracers on Leo and his shoulder guards. The bamboo seems silly to me.

Not crazy about all of them having a form of loincloth and I've NEVER thought they look normal in pants. They ALWAYS look weird wearing pants to me, in every incarnation. ;)

Radical Raph
05-12-2014, 12:10 PM
"April, why do humans want to make themselves look dumber than they already are?" - Raphael from OT

Raphael in Mirage said that humans wear clothes because their bodies are ugly. :lol:

There's always been a bit of wanting to be accepted for who they are, not be accepted for adopting human appearances.

I just think it's a bit unnecessary myself, though I kind of dig the bracers on Leo and his shoulder guards. The bamboo seems silly to me.

Not crazy about all of them having a form of loincloth and I've NEVER thought they look normal in pants. They ALWAYS look weird wearing pants to me, in every incarnation. ;)
I would actually love it if Raphael still shares that point of view in this new version. Even though he's wearing clothes, it is the most minimal amount of the four and looks like something an ancient barbarian would wear if you excuse the sunglasses.

It's also not like they're wearing so much that they're disguising themselves as human. You can still clearly see they are mutants. But the clothes to me translate a desire to want to be accepted amongst humans while not completely disregarding their mutant/ninja origins. Raphael can still think of humans as ugly while wearing clothes since the turtles did kinda grow up being influenced by our culture.

I dunno man, even with all those blades, there's no way Shredder is going to be able to get past Leo's bamboo armor. :lol:

slingtheory
05-12-2014, 01:10 PM
The way I see it the toy line had all kinds of costumes on, there were clowns turtles, cavemen turtles, astronaut turtles and even sumo wrestler turtles. So they wear Samurai armor/loincloth/gadgets/sweat shirt shouldn't be such a big deal.

http://dinosaurdracula.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/28.jpg
that's one of the biggest issues I have with this. they look like left over action figure concepts from back in the day which in itself I think says a lot about how they view these characters. Its like they're over accessorized toys covered in a lot of useless junk instead of skilled formidable warriors. I seriously don't know how anybody can say this movie looks dark in tone with them looking like that

electric_sheep
05-12-2014, 01:12 PM
that's one of the biggest issues I have with this. they look like left over action figure concepts from back in the day which in itself I think says a lot about how they view these characters. Its like they're over accessorized toys covered in a lot of useless junk instead of skilled formidable warriors. I seriously don't know how anybody can say this movie looks dark in tone with them looking like that

They kinda look like a deviantart redesign....

slingtheory
05-12-2014, 01:19 PM
They kinda look like a deviantart redesign....

maybe some of the worst ones. most I've seen look much better than this. maybe because I can tell they put more thought into it.

SwiftNinjaFox
05-12-2014, 01:44 PM
I dunno man, even with all those blades, there's no way Shredder is going to be able to get past Leo's bamboo armor. :lol:

"Curse your bamboo stick armor, my metal blades are useless!!!" :D

Radical Raph
05-12-2014, 01:58 PM
"Curse your bamboo stick armor, my metal blades are useless!!!" :D
Lol, even the Foot soldiers with their machine guns will be no match.

samxsteal
05-12-2014, 01:59 PM
maybe some of the worst ones. most I've seen look much better than this. maybe because I can tell they put more thought into it.

sorry your so full Of it. hey The creature designer which you're dissing the crap out of, happens to be a member on these boards, how about you say all this to his face Huh?

YEah right like they didn't work hard on them at all SMH. I dont care if its your opinion your being a jerk.

im positive there was lots of thought put into every aspect of these turtles designs just because you dont agree doesn't make it any less true

Leo defined samurai look using Shin guards and armor with NYC buttons and belts and strapp All the way down to his Tsuba on his sword little detail loads of work.

Mikey from his Surfer wet suit pants two his converse shoes and little accessories yup never thought through,

Even donnie who might be over baring still has load of small tiny detail

electric_sheep
05-12-2014, 02:07 PM
sorry your so full Of it. hey The creature designer which you're dissing the crap out of, happens to be a member on these boards, how about you say all this to his face Huh?

YEah right like they didn't work hard on them at all SMH. I dont care if its your opinion your being a jerk.

im positive there was lots of thought put into every aspect of these turtles designs just because you dont agree doesn't make it any less true

Leo defined samurai look using Shin guards and armor with NYC buttons and belts and strapp All the way down to his Tsuba on his sword little detail loads of work.

Mikey from his Surfer wet suit pants two his converse shoes and little accessories yup never thought through,

Even donnie who might be over baring still has load of small tiny detail

And splinter went from lookling like wise old master to looking like a Fu Manchu pimp, gotta have that bling.

Radical Raph
05-12-2014, 02:12 PM
Speaking of the Foot soldiers machine guns... Does anybody else think that the turtles will have bullet proof shells? Especially after seeing Raph crash into that Humvee.

rickwj324
05-12-2014, 02:16 PM
...they look like left over action figure concepts from back in the day...

Yep, I agree. It feels like the old Jim Lee turtles (which I hated). I love Jim Lee's art (from the 90's as well as today) but those designs were ridiculous and didn't fit in with the turtles at all. And it all just seems so unneccessary. I don't mind the fact that their faces are ugly. Yes, the nostrils and lips look odd to me... but I can live with all that (trying to make them look more realistic, etc). However, the stuff they are wearing just looks awful, like some weird "alternate concept" line of action figures.

And before the fans of this movie decide to try to rip into me, I'm not insulting anyone and I'm not adding flames to the fire....I'm simply stating my opinions. I don't fault those that think this looks great. I respect your opinions. However, in my opinion these do look ridiculous.... :teek:

Sam... you stated "The creature designer which you're dissing the crap out of, happens to be a member on these boards". Do we all know who that is? And more importantly, would he be willing to discuss his design choices, etc?

GeneralTragg
05-12-2014, 02:16 PM
Speaking of the Foot soldiers machine guns... Does anybody else think that the turtles will have bullet proof shells? Especially after seeing Raph crash into that Humvee.

They did in Blue Door, and that's the basis for this film, so probably...

electric_sheep
05-12-2014, 02:22 PM
http://s30.postimg.org/bz6bi07mp/hgfh.jpg
Bitches ain't **** but hoes and tricks

slingtheory
05-12-2014, 02:24 PM
sorry your so full Of it. hey The creature designer which you're dissing the crap out of, happens to be a member on these boards, how about you say all this to his face Huh?

YEah right like they didn't work hard on them at all SMH. I dont care if its your opinion your being a jerk.

im positive there was lots of thought put into every aspect of these turtles designs just because you dont agree doesn't make it any less true

Leo defined samurai look using Shin guards and armor with NYC buttons and belts and strapp All the way down to his Tsuba on his sword little detail loads of work.

Mikey from his Surfer wet suit pants two his converse shoes and little accessories yup never thought through,

Even donnie who might be over baring still has load of small tiny detail

point him out sam because id really like to talk to him. maybe he could shed some light on some things for me about his work. I didn't say they didn't work hard on crafting the details but I don't believe much though went in to what the turtles do vs what they'll be wearing while doing it. id love to know the reasoning behind putting sun glasses on a character who lives underground and primarily comes out at night. or weighting down what's supposed to be an agile ninja with so much tech. its things like this that make the design look superficial to me and I don't think I'm being insulting by questioning it.

Glados
05-12-2014, 02:37 PM
sorry your so full Of it. hey The creature designer which you're dissing the crap out of, happens to be a member on these boards, how about you say all this to his face Huh?

What...?

Anyway, there's a hint of a point somewhere... drawings/paintings will always look better/cooler then realistic CGI-renders that has to be incorporated and interact with regular humans n' stuff. I'm sure that if concept art/marquettes of the PD turtles had just been fan art posted on DA the wast majority would praise them. The leap from a still image to (realistic) moving, talking 3D is a notoriously difficult one. Many designs would struggle with that leap, so I find it kind of unfair to compare the PD turtles to drawings and paintings, no matter how skillfully they are executed. Chances are they would face much of the same criticism as the PD turts if their fate was to end up in this movie.

Whatswiththeheadbands?
05-12-2014, 02:42 PM
I did an Edit of Movie Leo if anyone wants to look

Plug! Plug! Plug! (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=47300):P

Radical Raph
05-12-2014, 03:01 PM
point him out sam because id really like to talk to him. maybe he could shed some light on some things for me about his work. I didn't say they didn't work hard on crafting the details but I don't believe much though went in to what the turtles do vs what they'll be wearing while doing it. id love to know the reasoning behind putting sun glasses on a character who lives underground and primarily comes out at night. or weighting down what's supposed to be an agile ninja with so much tech. its things like this that make the design look superficial to me and I don't think I'm being insulting by questioning it.
I'm hoping that he only uses the sunglasses for the day scenes. Which would actually make sense since he's used to the dark.

electric_sheep
05-12-2014, 03:06 PM
I'm hoping that he only uses the sunglasses for the day scenes. Which would actually make sense since he's used to the dark.

They don't fall off or brake when he crashes into the hummer so my guess is that they are made of metal and are stapled to his skull.

SwiftNinjaFox
05-12-2014, 03:08 PM
They did in Blue Door, and that's the basis for this film, so probably...

"More like bullet resistant, but it still hurts like a bi-- Wait, who's this guy?" --Mikey

The more I thought about it, the more I'm okay with bullet resistant shells. Turtle shells can withstand quite a bit (2300 lbs of pressure from a crocodile's jaw was unable to break/crack a turtle's shell in one example I found. Photos were kind of funny). I just think it should be able to deflect at angles and leave chips and scratches on the shell.

Radical Raph
05-12-2014, 03:10 PM
They don't fall off or brake when he crashes into the hummer so my guess is that they are made of metal and are stapled to his skull.
Or maybe we're all wrong and the humvee is really made of fiberglass.

On another note, Donnie's must be rigged up the same way Raph's are. His don't move a beat while he's sliding down that snow mountain.

samxsteal
05-12-2014, 03:19 PM
point him out sam because id really like to talk to him. maybe he could shed some light on some things for me about his work. I didn't say they didn't work hard on crafting the details but I don't believe much though went in to what the turtles do vs what they'll be wearing while doing it. id love to know the reasoning behind putting sun glasses on a character who lives underground and primarily comes out at night. or weighting down what's supposed to be an agile ninja with so much tech. its things like this that make the design look superficial to me and I don't think I'm being insulting by questioning it.

you can find him im not going to single him out so you can patronize him, as far as i know he will not be able to say anything till after the movie is released

But he does seem bummed out people are tearing the designs apart, IM seriously shocked My self people would be so flippantly aggressive about the looks

electric_sheep
05-12-2014, 03:22 PM
you can find him im not going to single him out so you can patronize him, as far as i know he will not be able to say anything till after the movie is released

But he does seem bummed out people are tearing the designs apart, IM seriously shocked My self people would be so flippantly aggressive about the looks

Well then he should come out and defend some of the stupid choices he made...

Radical Raph
05-12-2014, 03:24 PM
Is this the same designer who did Transformers? Because they were similarly overdone.

And I'm not knocking the designs, I actually like them. But even I will still admit they're a bit over the top (mostly Donnie). I'm just going to assume that fits the style the movie is going for.

samxsteal
05-12-2014, 03:34 PM
Is this the same designer who did Transformers? Because they were similarly overdone.

And I'm not knocking the designs, I actually like them. But even I will still admit they're a bit over the top (mostly Donnie). I'm just going to assume that fits the style the movie is going for.

same designer who did concepts for ASM II and several other Major Summer block busters.

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm5516450/

Radical Raph
05-12-2014, 03:41 PM
same designer who did concepts for ASM II and several other Major Summer block busters.

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm5516450/
Ew, he did R.I.P.D., I, Frankenstein, and The Wolverine.

It's still hard to tell how much of his concepts were used in the final production. ASM2 was pretty good except for Electro's cheesy costume with the Power Ranger style lightning bolt. Hunger Games was good and Maleficent looks pretty good, too, just from a design perspective.

Well then he should come out and defend some of the stupid choices he made...
For all we know, the designer could be samxsteal...

SwiftNinjaFox
05-12-2014, 03:47 PM
you can find him im not going to single him out so you can patronize him, as far as i know he will not be able to say anything till after the movie is released

But he does seem bummed out people are tearing the designs apart, IM seriously shocked My self people would be so flippantly aggressive about the looks

If you're in that sort of business, you need a thick skin and shouldn't be surprised that people will nitpick and tear a design change apart, especially when it's a drastic change from tradition.

Not visual, but see the organic webshooters reaction for Spider-Man.
Visual, see the disagreement on the alteration of the Spider-man costume for ASM.
See the reaction to X-Men in black leather (some were fine, some outraged)

Even Superman's costume got some heat in both Superman Returns and Man of Steel. I'm not remotely surprised at the reaction to the looks, really, particularly on a TMNT focused forum.

You go to other forums outside of comic book focused communities and you'll get more varied reactions, I'd bet.

samxsteal
05-12-2014, 03:49 PM
For all we know, the designer could be samxsteal...

i am an artist but not techy enough for 3d animation hahaha i wish thought i wish lol.

But seriously there are fantastic artist work on this movie too seriously.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1291150/fullcredits?ref_=tt_cl_sm#cast

Check out i know the credit wont be 100% accurate but i huge majority of these people worked on fantastic movies

SwiftNinjaFox
05-12-2014, 03:49 PM
Well then he should come out and defend some of the stupid choices he made...

I really doubt he could even if he desperately wanted to talk about them. After August, he may be able to comment and if we're REALLY NICE AND LEVEL HEADED about it, perhaps he'd be willing to share some insight to the development process of the designs.

electric_sheep
05-12-2014, 03:51 PM
For all we know, the designer could be samxsteal...

That....Would make so much sense.
Though i don't blame the artist, usualy you have someone over the shoulder saying, Add the sunglasses there, yeah that rat really needs to look like Fu Manchu, Donatello, oh he needs more crap on his back, how else are kidds gonna know that he's a nerd?

slingtheory
05-12-2014, 03:52 PM
I'm hoping that he only uses the sunglasses for the day scenes. Which would actually make sense since he's used to the dark. I wouldn't be surprised if its only because they were going with a tough biker boy kind of style with raph based on the way they have him wearing his bandana. everyone knows sunglasses and tough guy bikers go hand in hand

you can find him im not going to single him out so you can patronize him, as far as i know he will not be able to say anything till after the movie is released

But he does seem bummed out people are tearing the designs apart, IM seriously shocked My self people would be so flippantly aggressive about the looks I have no intention to patronize. I am honestly and legitimately curious. I want to understand where they were coming from with this because as of now it looks like the same typical visual stereotyping micheal bay is notorious for. its unfortunate that his work is being criticized as much as it is but that's the risk you take when you deal with something that's stood the test of time. sad thing is its probably not even mainly his fault. producers and directors have to sign of on design if im not mistaken

samxsteal
05-12-2014, 03:53 PM
If you're in that sort of business, you need a thick skin and shouldn't be surprised that people will nitpick and tear a design change apart, especially when it's a drastic change from tradition.

Not visual, but see the organic webshooters reaction for Spider-Man.
Visual, see the disagreement on the alteration of the Spider-man costume for ASM.
See the reaction to X-Men in black leather (some were fine, some outraged)

Even Superman's costume got some heat in both Superman Returns and Man of Steel. I'm not remotely surprised at the reaction to the looks, really, particularly on a TMNT focused forum.

You go to other forums outside of comic book focused communities and you'll get more varied reactions, I'd bet.
This is true Twitter a blazes with positive after each release then dies down this goes negative then levels out being mostly positive.

Put like a wise man once said

"People are way more willing to make their negativity known"

People who are content tend not to go out of their way. People who are displeased are way more willing to be vocal and keep being vocal.

Candy Kappa
05-12-2014, 03:57 PM
I wonder how much the CG models differ from the concept designs, things change under the development, gets tweaked. Can even be slightly altered by the 3D modeler.

NoName999
05-12-2014, 04:00 PM
Thinking it over, I'm still against the idea of the turtles wearing so much stuff when fighting.

During casual Fridays, it's fine.

SwiftNinjaFox
05-12-2014, 04:12 PM
This is true Twitter a blazes with positive after each release then dies down this goes negative then levels out being mostly positive.

Put like a wise man once said

"People are way more willing to make their negativity known"

People who are content tend not to go out of their way. People who are displeased are way more willing to be vocal and keep being vocal.

Unfortunately, though, Twitter is a poor gauge. As a Forbes article pointed out (discussing Godzilla), Scott Pilgrim had phenomenal positive buzz and was trending daily on Twitter, but that didn't translate to box office success.

Though even then, you cite tons of positive feedback every time something comes out, yet when I look, I don't see the outpouring of positivity myself. Just that people ARE talking about it.

Then again, the show biz saying, there's no such thing as bad publicity (though Michael Bay saying they're aliens may have proven otherwise originally).

Thinking it over, I'm still against the idea of the turtles wearing so much stuff when fighting.

During casual Fridays, it's fine.

Would be funny if Splinter is shown to not approve of all their stuff, but has clearly given up trying to argue with the teenagers.

slingtheory
05-12-2014, 04:26 PM
Would be funny if Splinter is shown to not approve of all their stuff, but has clearly given up trying to argue with the teenagers. kind of reminds me of that scene in big daddy where sandler let's the kid dress himself

gettinshell
05-12-2014, 04:32 PM
Good post a lot of good points made on both sides. As for my 2cent I don't care to see all the flash on them. But it doesn't put me off to bad. With all the different artist and people that have been invovled with tmnt over the years I'm used to the characters changing slighlty. This movie could take place in a dimension where tmnts look like this. Lol seriously though just happy to see our boys on the big screen again

Jester
05-12-2014, 04:48 PM
It might have been said, but I'll repeat it, part of the reason Bebop and Rocksteady have all their gear and clothing is because they were initially designed that way. Much like the original TMNT design was the simplistic bandanna, belt, wrist wraps and elbow and knee pads, Bebop and Rocksteady were designed with their "signature looks". If they added more stuff on top of those base designs THEN we'd have a reference point, but most redesigns...much like Turtle redesigns aside from this movie (and arguably Next Mutation) keep the basics of the design intact.

Wherenoturtlehasgoneb4
05-12-2014, 05:55 PM
Bebop and Rocksteady as examples is a very poor choice for comparison, first, it was the 80's and in their bio/cards the creators insist that they're punks and that's it, punks wear stuff like that, and they actually wear less cloths that in human forms.
This turtles do look ridiculous not because they're wearing clothes, but for the UTTERLY RANDOM stuff they're wearing. Leonardo has a native american chest plate and Michelangelo has a mexican hippie necklace...

Huzzah
05-12-2014, 07:38 PM
Everyone knows that clothing is the way that people tend to make statements, especially teenagers. They don't have to be practical, but they show the personality and the way they wish to be viewed by the outside. Honestly, teenagers have questionable fashion sense anyway, and I imagine there's going to be someone calling someone' s outfit ridiculous among the four brothers. The fact that they are allowed to express themselves via their wardrobe, actually does help present them more as teenagers. As teenagers, they are dressing in a manner that allows them express how they feel their personality should be justified.

Michelangelo, he would most likely wish to be accepted as a normal person, tends to dress in a manner that is most similar to what he would believe would be an urban inspired fashion.

Leonardo, probably wishes to be viewed as a samurai warrior, and as such wishes to present that appearance by fashioning in armor that would make him appear as such.

Donatello, the techy one, probably has what he considers a good reason to carry all that equipment. Now, I will admit it seems a bit overkill, but there may be an explanation for the glasses, they are obviously Google glasses, and that made the flight was sarcastic.

Raphael, I can't really find a logical reason he's wearing what he's wearing, apart from the way he wears his bandana because everyone knows the bandana over the head just makes you look tough.

Sumac
05-13-2014, 02:55 AM
The problem is not so much with the clothing, but with how it is random and clumsy. It's like artist just threw random stuff on the Turtles, vaguely connected to what he assumed was their personalitites.

Puddinpop
05-13-2014, 07:57 AM
I look at it as them wanting to fit in with humans and/or show off their personalities. Why stop at just colored bandanas?

Splinter always wore clothes because he's dignified. I would think since he's basically their father, they would try to emulate him.

Exactly.. They're teenagers.. and teenagers express themselves through things like clothing. Teenagers are not always practical. The additions make sense.. Donnie the tech head geek.. Mikey the cool party dude.. Leo the leader with an interest in samurai.. Raph the brut fighter with a temper.. They obviously find accessories in the sewer..It all makes sense when you view them in the context of being teenagers, and teenagers often go overboard

http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQE95vOo_Wg2jXxjldjzPuQYgJwyG32d b21an5gSd-kvVC1WiR_http://i.crackedcdn.com/phpimages/article/4/9/8/24498.jpg?v=1
I could see them trying to fit into this strange world... Its something that no iteration really got into.. in depth anyway. I want to see this.. I want to understand the turtles more. If this is done right we could be in for something truly epic

A concept where these characters are trying to understand themselves and the world above them I find very intriguing. Remember Mikey saying.. " you think if we save enough people we'll be excepted?" They want to fit in. This along with a rich back story/mythology sounds really interesting and entertaining. This is a new iteration. Its a new movie. Something a little different and I find it refreshing. We've all discussed this multiple times in almost every thread so.. What it all comes down to is different people like different things. There is nothing practical about teenage mutated turtle ninjas lol.. nothing at all

SwiftNinjaFox
05-13-2014, 01:38 PM
I could see them trying to fit into this strange world... Its something that no iteration really got into.. in depth anyway. I want to see this.. I want to understand the turtles more. If this is done right we could be in for something truly epic

Sorry, but I think you're deluding yourself to expect that. Scratch Liebsman, scratch Bay, scratch the specific people.

This is HOLLYWOOD we're talkin' about here. Making a movie for kids for the purpose of making money and selling merchandise. Going into depth and really exploring their personalities isn't likely on the agenda. Don't develop the characters, just put them in a costume that visually makes it blatantly obvious what their personality is.

Again, I'm making this statement as a general attack on Hollywood, not even specific to the turtles in this movie.

slingtheory
05-13-2014, 02:20 PM
Exactly.. They're teenagers.. and teenagers express themselves through things like clothing. Teenagers are not always practical. The additions make sense.. Donnie the tech head geek.. Mikey the cool party dude.. Leo the leader with an interest in samurai.. Raph the brut fighter with a temper.. They obviously find accessories in the sewer..It all makes sense when you view them in the context of being teenagers, and teenagers often go overboard

http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQE95vOo_Wg2jXxjldjzPuQYgJwyG32d b21an5gSd-kvVC1WiR_http://i.crackedcdn.com/phpimages/article/4/9/8/24498.jpg?v=1
I could see them trying to fit into this strange world... Its something that no iteration really got into.. in depth anyway. I want to see this.. I want to understand the turtles more. If this is done right we could be in for something truly epic

A concept where these characters are trying to understand themselves and the world above them I find very intriguing. Remember Mikey saying.. " you think if we save enough people we'll be excepted?" They want to fit in. This along with a rich back story/mythology sounds really interesting and entertaining. This is a new iteration. Its a new movie. Something a little different and I find it refreshing. We've all discussed this multiple times in almost every thread so.. What it all comes down to is different people like different things. There is nothing practical about teenage mutated turtle ninjas lol.. nothing at all despite the fact that I disagree the turtles would ever have the same need to individualize themselves that normal human teenagers do I could live with that concept if it wasn't taken to these extremes. I don't mind the little details like leos arm guards and shoulder pads raphs over the head bandana or mikeys sneakers. its all the stuff that looks like it would hinder them from being stealthy and slow them down that really bothers me. its like no one took into consideration that these guys need to be agile swift and silent.

Sorry, but I think you're deluding yourself to expect that. Scratch Liebsman, scratch Bay, scratch the specific people.

This is HOLLYWOOD we're talkin' about here. Making a movie for kids for the purpose of making money and selling merchandise. Going into depth and really exploring their personalities isn't likely on the agenda. Don't develop the characters, just put them in a costume that visually makes it blatantly obvious what their personality is.

Again, I'm making this statement as a general attack on Hollywood, not even specific to the turtles in this movie. to add to that how many bay or liebsman movies have been known to go in depth on character emotions and feelings. at best you get about four or five lines of dialogue on the subject before its overshadowed by the next action setpiece

Coola Yagami
05-13-2014, 03:58 PM
Um.... it's also how Bebop and Rocksteady ALWAYS looked since day one... It would be stupid if they did the reverse... just make Bebop and Rocksteady fight in casual tees and jeans. It's a matter of how the characters are supposed to generally look and act.

Nolan's Joker as serious as he was... still wore purple. They didn't make him wear a yellow tux or something. The TMNT were always wearing headbands and elbow/knee pads and such, and for whatever reason it worked. So leave it at that. Where were all these idiots back when the movies came out in the 90's arguing that their straps and things didn't work and the movies sucked because they weren't wearing a bunch of uneccesary gear?

SwiftNinjaFox
05-13-2014, 04:14 PM
Coola, that has kind of surprised me. A lot of arguments supporting these argue how much sense it makes, how "right" it is, etc. but there weren't calls for it prior to these, so I'm a bit amused to think "if it was so right and appropriate, why wasn't there a big demand for it for 30 years?" ;)

C'est la vie, I suppose.

ninja-zero
05-13-2014, 04:35 PM
Give these designs a chance.

I think this is a first fresh start on its new movie.

Jester
05-13-2014, 04:46 PM
But see...the IDW Turtles (now) have distinct looks that still hold very true to their classic look. Both Ross and Santolouco seem to add unique touches to each Turtle yet keep the uniform.

Heck, even Next Mutation was fairly uniform, aside from the headbands, which were most likely unique because Power Rangers.

SwiftNinjaFox
05-13-2014, 06:54 PM
Give these designs a chance.

I think this is a first fresh start on its new movie.

I can still give the film a chance without liking the designs.

Hell, to be honest, I could walk out LOVING the movie and still HATE the designs, believe it or not!

sethmartin
05-13-2014, 07:09 PM
I can still give the film a chance without liking the designs.

Hell, to be honest, I could walk out LOVING the movie and still HATE the designs, believe it or not!

I actually don't mind the designs but I agree with this! The turtles looked like ass in TMNT 3 but about five minutes into it, you get use to it and you are more invested in the "story". These new designs look like they fit in with the overall look and tone of the new movie. Even if they may be a little too human/ too over the top/ too Shrek like/ ugly/ etc. As long as they don't distract from the story and emotions of the film, I think you can still enjoy the movie while not being pleased with the designs of the characters.

Wildcat
05-13-2014, 07:13 PM
Well I read every reply. Some still felt the need to repeat what I had already stated, that I know Bebop and Rocksteady were humans first. Maybe they were a bad example but my point was having clothing is not weird.

Like some have said it makes sense and mostly fits with their personality. I guess a better question would have been what would you have picked as clothing? Its really not that over the top. Just basic cover-up and Leo's warrior wear. Glasses excluded...I already know (and whatever Don's machine is for).

Also asking why people didn't complain about the 90s live action turtles not having clothes...its just a different interpretation. Theres nothing wrong with the original designs...but theres also nothing wrong with having clothes of some kind.

Anton Chigurh
05-13-2014, 07:33 PM
The bottom line is hardcore fans and "casuals" will adapt to it and either hate love or just like it. It is what it is but I don't think it's so big of a change to distract ppl from the story (which is a good thing).

I mean I still don't like the nick series designs at all. However it is probably the best thing for the franchise since Fred wolf series. And I absolutely love it, but hate the design, the show is so good I forget how much I hate their look.

Galactus
05-13-2014, 07:38 PM
Well I read every reply. Some still felt the need to repeat what I had already stated, that I know Bebop and Rocksteady were humans first. Maybe they were a bad example but my point was having clothing is not weird.

Like some have said it makes sense and mostly fits with their personality. I guess a better question would have been what would you have picked as clothing? Its really not that over the top. Just basic cover-up and Leo's warrior wear. Glasses excluded...I already know (and whatever Don's machine is for).

Also asking why people didn't complain about the 90s live action turtles not having clothes...its just a different interpretation. Theres nothing wrong with the original designs...but theres also nothing wrong with having clothes of some kind.

Well I tend to think that the classic look has served the franchise well for 30 years and what are the odds you'd hit on another design that has anywhere near the same broad appeal? (That's why people are more open to fan-made redesigns as opposed to ones used in something like a major Hollywood movie were the whole world has to watch it for 90+ minutes)

Also it's not necessarily the fact that they have clothes - it's the specific clothes they chose. The maquettes were seen as good even though it did give them clothes it wasn't so over-the-top. I don't know whether it was a mandate from the higher ups that they needed "more stuff" but the finished designs are very overblown and not really aesthetically pleasing - or at least not to me.

Perhaps the designer (if he's reading) can take some solace that the worst part of the designs is something he was likely not responsible for which is those weird faces. Again this is why the maquettes were popular as they looked like the classic turtles that had been given a few tweaks. Now they just look strange to the eye.

Wildcat
05-13-2014, 07:56 PM
^ You mean those statues that were first revealed? Those are not different than what they are now. Just the glasses and such aren't there. Also they're not trying to change the classic look. Its just that for the sake of the movie they wanted each one to be distinct.

In general, regardless of this movie, I can totally see each turtle wanting to wear stuff besides mask and belts if they could. Im sure Mikey would want something hip, Raph something rugged, Don something useful to him, not necessarily "nerdy", and Leo something associated with fighting.

SwiftNinjaFox
05-13-2014, 09:28 PM
Bingo.

Someone who gets it.

You mean "someone who agrees with it."

Because anyone who doesn't obviously doesn't "get it" I suppose. ;)

DioLeo451
05-13-2014, 10:46 PM
No problem with the clothing whatsoever it's not like Donatello is going to wear all that through the entire flick:lol: but overall I think it's very creative and it makes each of the four bros distinct from one another then just having a different colored bandana

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=6892&stc=1&d=1400039028

SwiftNinjaFox
05-13-2014, 10:53 PM
Yet the image you linked doesn't have all the unnecessary gear on them and looks FRIGGIN' AMAZING :o

Seriously, that's awesome.

electric_sheep
05-13-2014, 10:55 PM
Yet the image you linked doesn't have all the unnecessary gear on them and looks FRIGGIN' AMAZING :o

Seriously, that's awesome.

It's clearly photoshop and a crappy one at that, you can see that Donnie's legs are from the 1990 movie...

SwiftNinjaFox
05-13-2014, 10:57 PM
That's exactly what I mean. Anyone salty over something so small is ridiculous.

Aesthetics are based on opinion. People think it looks loud and is unnecessarily complicated on something that's been well received for 30 years. I'm not sure how that's ridiculous. They prefer not adding stuff for the sake of adding stuff.

For me, though, it's primarily Leo's bamboo chest armor that's utterly ridiculous and Mikey's shell necklace that's kinda silly.

That and why all four of them are wearing loin cloths....I just don't get the loin cloths, man! Well, Mikey I don't get the pants. Think that's dumb. I'd trade the pants and keep his loin cloth equivalent of the hoody around the waist. I kinda like that, actually...it amuses me. :D

SwiftNinjaFox
05-13-2014, 10:59 PM
It's clearly photoshop and a crappy one at that, you can see that Donnie's legs are from the 1990 movie...

I'm not looking at it up close and nitpicking the details. The layout's sweet.

Thanks for making me look closer at Donnie's leg, though. Now I can't not see the problem. Don't think that's from the 1990 movie though...looks nothing like them. Doesn't look like photos to me, just artwork.

You can call it crappy photoshop if you want, but it's better than some professional photoshop I've seen. :lol:

SwiftNinjaFox
05-13-2014, 11:16 PM
There are people NOW who don't like the colored masks ;)

I don't think these are as minor as a color swap.

Though, the masks DO help. Hell, reading through the Ultimate Collections, I sometimes had to do a look back to know who was talking and in some panels there's just no way to have any clue who it is.

But again, the movie and the story are more important. I can get over hideously bad faces and horribly loud costumes in a movie, I'm sure I can overlook theirs if the movie itself turns out to impress.

Believe me, I wanna be back here in August saying I was wrong.

The Boston Ninja Turtle
05-13-2014, 11:21 PM
my issue isnt them wearing clothes...other wise id hate when raph wears a trench coat, or any variant figures from the 80's and 90's and trust me i bought them all


its all the extra unneeded crap..for the same reasons everyone else said, main one being..they are supposed to be swift and agile

you can't be swift when you have a proton pack on your back, as i've been told by my ghostbuster cosplay buds..99% cant even sit down with it on them

i can understand them not wanting to be barefoot, New York is the concrete jungle, and i am sure growing up in a sewer id want my feet covered too


as Jester brought up, Next mutation had them wear more without compromising the basic turtle look and giving each one their own look

The same goes with Fast Foward, they all had their own design without changing the basic arm/leg coverings . belt and mask look

so clothes are not the issue...i like Mikes hoodie belt thing, and Raphs wraps, as well as Leo's shoulder pads and Dons wrist cuffs...its all the extra stuff...the pants, the beads,the proton pack, the window shade,glasses are not needed


you can give them all their own style and still be subtle

SwiftNinjaFox
05-13-2014, 11:38 PM
To each their own.

I didn't like the overly complicated for the sake of complicated Transformers either, but I know some think they look cool.

Same here. I'm fine giving them extra gear, but I think they've been made overly complicated with how much.

Aelia
05-13-2014, 11:58 PM
The clothes are unnecessary, but don't find myself getting too bothered about it. It's such a miniscule thing.

slingtheory
05-14-2014, 12:08 AM
I bet Mirage purists in 1990 were all GRRRR why do they need to have different colored bandanas to more clearly define their uniqueness and personalities ... LOL, this minor update will be accepted in time by the rigid minded. Hell, great fan manips had the turtles with character defining clothing, and apparel years ago.

the thing about the headbands is that was the way the turtles were introduced to an entire generation of kids. that's why they stuck. and it wasn't too big of a change up at that. this look will probably go down the same way any alteration to a classic costume does. it might stick around for awhile if it catches on but sooner or later it'll disappear and become an embarrassing thing people laugh about.

SwiftNinjaFox
05-14-2014, 12:08 AM
Of course it's not necessary. Neither is bandanas, multi colored banadas, lettered belts, elbow pads, or wrist tape. But they work at differentiating the characters. Not necessary, but it helps. Adds dimension.

But not according to Mirage Raphael. (I did love that part where Mirage thought the colored masks were dumb, 2k3 Raph tried to deflect with the belt buckles. And at the end, Mirage Mike thought they were neat) :D

slingtheory
05-14-2014, 12:18 AM
Of course it's not necessary. Neither is bandanas, multi colored banadas, lettered belts, elbow pads, or wrist tape. But they work at differentiating the characters. Not necessary, but it helps. Addsdimension. well the colored bandanas and the lettered belts were because the people who made the cartoon were worried kids would have trouble telling the turtles apart.

Aelia
05-14-2014, 12:19 AM
Of course it's not necessary. Neither is bandanas, multi colored banadas, lettered belts, elbow pads, or wrist tape. But they work at differentiating the characters. Not necessary, but it helps. Adds dimension.

Like I said, I'm not too bothered about it. Ease of differentiation is always appreciated though.

Wildcat
05-14-2014, 12:29 AM
Not to get off topic but the Transformers are NOT over complicated. The original G1 and most cartoon versions are over simplified for a live action movie. The more detailed and intracate transformations look and work great to portray them as an advanced robotic race from another planet.

As for the turtles, like I mentioned a better question would have been "What would you have picked as wardrobe?"

Just saying the traditional designs has worked all this time isn't even an argument because that's not point. The point is, how do some people (not everyone I know) find it so farfetched the turtles would wear some form of clothing for personal or fighting purposes?

I think its weird-er to think the turtles would be so against clothing. They do have individual personalities and they were influenced by humans to an extent through TV, books and Splinter.

They're not aliens that crashed here, who have zero understanding of earth.

Technogeek29
05-14-2014, 12:38 AM
well the colored bandanas and the lettered belts were because the people who made the cartoon were worried kids would have trouble telling the turtles apart.

You know with all the extra things their wearing, why not go to the Uni headband look? At this point telling them apart would be child's play. How could you not tell them apart? Especially if they kept all that stupid crap they have now, you'd have to be literally blind.

Candy Kappa
05-14-2014, 01:38 AM
Of course it's not necessary. Neither is bandanas, multi colored banadas, lettered belts, elbow pads, or wrist tape. But they work at differentiating the characters. Not necessary, but it helps. Adds dimension.

Seeing as real life turtles are slow to heal wounds, I'd say the protection pads makes sense, and doing a lot of physical martial arts, the tape wrapping makes sense in the versions that have that.

And seeing that the Ninja Turtles are often depicted to sweat, something real turtles don't. I'm sure it's once to have a mask or a bandanna to keep the area out of their eyes since the Turtles don't have eyebrows.

Not to get off topic but the Transformers are NOT over complicated. The original G1 and most cartoon versions are over simplified for a live action movie. The more detailed and intracate transformations look and work great to portray them as an advanced robotic race from another planet

But they are by design "over complicated", they where given random bits and cogs to add for "realism". Personally I think Fall for Cybertron does a far more superior take on the TF designs and gives them an overhaul. They are intricate and detailed, but still not overly cluttered, and the majority of the name robots keeps their colors then just a handful of few.

electric_sheep
05-14-2014, 01:42 AM
You know damn well no real research went into defining why the turtles needed to wear pads, or bandanas.

Don't play around.

It's all unnecessary technically. It really is ...

It's obviously to protect their identities, duuuh...

Candy Kappa
05-14-2014, 01:58 AM
You know damn well no real research went into defining why the turtles needed to wear pads, or bandanas.

Don't play around.

It's all unnecessary technically. It really is ...

And Frank Miller gave the Bat insignia on Batman's chest a reason to be there years later.

Superman's chest symbol was just a S, now it's a Kryptonian symbol for Peace.

Puddinpop
05-14-2014, 02:13 AM
Sorry, but I think you're deluding yourself to expect that. Scratch Liebsman, scratch Bay, scratch the specific people.

This is HOLLYWOOD we're talkin' about here. Making a movie for kids for the purpose of making money and selling merchandise. Going into depth and really exploring their personalities isn't likely on the agenda. Don't develop the characters, just put them in a costume that visually makes it blatantly obvious what their personality is.

Again, I'm making this statement as a general attack on Hollywood, not even specific to the turtles in this movie.

I understand the skepticism.. But I calls it like I sees it. Hollywood has also made some great movies. It appears to me that some people " maybe not you " separate good movies that they like as if they didn't come from " Hollywood ". Hollywood has gotten it right many times. The Avengers came from Hollywood..Marvel movies come from Hollywood..
Going into depth and really exploring their personalities isn't likely on the agenda.
I cant see how you can just dismiss the that possibility.. I'm just not seeing any evidence to support that..It is a fact that Liebesman spent many hours in a room with Eastman pumped about making a true TMNT film and learning about the characters. I don't think I am deluding myself when taking the words of actors and directors and producers along with my own opinions of what I see. When looking at the set pics and reading all of the interviews it is reasonable to think that they are building a richer deeper story. It is reasonable to think that this film will delve deeper into the mythology of TMNT. I hope we get more than a little 15 minute flash back. Imo.. Just bc this movie is being made in Hollywood doesn't mean that there aren't people working on the film that feel very passionately about TMNT. I don't understand why just bc people make it in the film business and move to Hollywood somehow means that all of their respect and passion for material gets sucked right out of them. This notion that if your a big Hollywood director you automatically have absolutely no intention of learning about the characters, learning what makes them tick.. why they act a certain way, why they do the things they do and say the things they say. I'm sure there are some that could care less. Again I know you didn't say this and I'm not trying to put words in your mouth but I've read it many times here.. Imo it is not fair to lump every Hollywood director into a group of soulless money hungry scam artists out to make a quick buck just bc they've made it to Hollywood.. .. To a certain point I actually agree with you.. I just don't agree with the generalization. There are some really great directors in Hollywood. I'm just trying to defend my views and opinions.. I'm trying to say that it is not unreasonable to think that these are real possibilities. I understand that kids are one demographic here.. but it is obvious that this movie wont be solely geared towards children. It seems to have a very serious tone to it.. a more darker, gritty tone. I think they know that most of the fans are not kids. I think they know that they cant scoot by on another kiddie movie. Look what happened to the first trilogy. The more " kiddie" it got the worst it did. But i think they have every intention of telling this story in a more in depth way.

http://youtu.be/6BwLC4eTv8A
http://youtu.be/TbsGj2G0hQo
http://youtu.be/DDstNXFWtn4
http://youtu.be/xHYcbZVxdK8
http://youtu.be/-PA6AJBKdJQ
http://youtu.be/AaBtnJWnIfg
for this last one fast forward to the 20 minute mark. Not much but something.
http://youtu.be/cjA8l6q060Q

electric_sheep
05-14-2014, 02:16 AM
I understand the skepticism.. But I calls it like I sees it. Hollywood has also made some great movies. It appears to me that some people " maybe not you " separate good movies that they like as if they didn't come from " Hollywood ". Hollywood has gotten it right many times. The Avengers came from Hollywood..Marvel movies come from Hollywood..


Behind every good Holywood movie stands either a fan or a good director, we have none of those things here...

Netkeeper
05-14-2014, 02:25 AM
Honestly, I think I might be in the minority but I prefer it when the differences in the turtles' appearances are subtle; mask colours, skin tones, slightly different [but not cartoonishly exaggerated] body types, and maybe differing eye colours.

They don't need any more than that, otherwise to me, it comes across as trying way too hard to make each one different when they don't need to be. Their personalities do that enough.

Candy Kappa
05-14-2014, 02:28 AM
Yeah...

http://i.ebayimg.com/00/s/MzcxWDg4OQ==/z/NhUAAMXQHPhSK38V/$(KGrHqF,!qsFIdhkrtK0BSK38VDjBw~~60_57.JPG

electric_sheep
05-14-2014, 02:36 AM
Honestly, I think I might be in the minority but I prefer it when the differences in the turtles' appearances are subtle; mask colours, skin tones, slightly different [but not cartoonishly exaggerated] body types, and maybe differing eye colours.

They don't need any more than that, otherwise to me, it comes across as trying way too hard to make each one different when they don't need to be. Their personalities do that enough.

Here, here. Nick set the presitent for that and is seaping in every incarnation and really annoys me...

Puddinpop
05-14-2014, 02:39 AM
Behind every good Holywood movie stands either a fan or a good director, we have none of those things here...
Agree to disagree
Honestly, I think I might be in the minority but I prefer it when the differences in the turtles' appearances are subtle; mask colours, skin tones, slightly different [but not cartoonishly exaggerated] body types, and maybe differing eye colours.

They don't need any more than that, otherwise to me, it comes across as trying way too hard to make each one different when they don't need to be. Their personalities do that enough.

You may actually be in the majority.. I just appreciate how they seem to be elaborating on the whole " teenagers " thing. And when I think teenagers I think eccentric, potent personalities with a need to express themselves through accessories and clothes etc.. I guess its a preference thing. I'm just glad that they are taking this approach. If a grown up ever told me to " tone it down " with my clothes in High school I'd tellem to take a walk lol.

Wildcat
05-14-2014, 02:42 AM
and the point of those pictures were? The movie designs are not even close to being that over the top. Those look like futuristic superheroes.

I was gonna say I agreed with Puddinpop about the Hollywood thing. I mentioned this to someone here awhile back...its funny that everyone complains about Hollywood being money hungry big shots...but if said movie actually looks good and turns out to be good none of that Hollywood is evil talk is brought up.

You can't conveniently pick and choose when Hollywood does and doesn't care.

darthwahl56
05-14-2014, 02:43 AM
Honestly, I think I might be in the minority but I prefer it when the differences in the turtles' appearances are subtle; mask colours, skin tones, slightly different [but not cartoonishly exaggerated] body types, and maybe differing eye colours.

They don't need any more than that, otherwise to me, it comes across as trying way too hard to make each one different when they don't need to be. Their personalities do that enough.

That is the one of the main reasons I like the nick tmnt, they each look different physically and act different. Also I think the Nick turtles act more like teens in the newer show.

You may actually be in the majority.. I just appreciate how they seem to be elaborating on the whole " teenagers " thing. And when I think teenagers I think eccentric, potent personalities with a need to express themselves through accessories and clothes etc.. I guess its a preference thing. I'm just glad that they are taking this approach. If a grown up ever told me to " tone it down " with my clothes in High school I'd tellem to take a walk lol.

I was never quite this way when I was teenager. I got clothes from garage sales and places with nice clothing sales, but nothing I hunted for that strongly. I wore a big jean jacket most of the time. I was a card game player and liked hanging out with friends while I also drew as well, that was how I expressed myself. One kid even said one of drawings looked better than how I dressed. I usually had some jeans and a shirt. Expressing myself was never in the clothing. The best clothing was always expensive and unaffordable to me.

Candy Kappa
05-14-2014, 03:00 AM
and the point of those pictures were? The movie designs are not even close to being that over the top. Those look like futuristic superheroes.

Personally I find a lot of similar problems with Jim Lee's designs and the PD designs. And not only in the clothing department, but also in the body deign. Not just the faces, but the body, especially the torso.

Netkeeper
05-14-2014, 03:14 AM
That is the one of the main reasons I like the nick tmnt, they each look different physically and act different. Also I think the Nick turtles act more like teens in the newer show.
Mm, nope.

Nick cartoonishly exaggerates the varying body types too much. When I said "varying body types", I was thinking of the first film. Nick is trying too hard.

electric_sheep
05-14-2014, 03:21 AM
Mm, nope.

Nick cartoonishly exaggerates the varying body types too much. When I said "varying body types", I was thinking of the first film. Nick is trying too hard.

They come from the same mold, they four all make one singular fully rounded personality, they all look the same but they are not the same, and when you make them look to distinctive it kinda takes away something from that, for me atleast...

Wildcat
05-14-2014, 03:43 AM
Personally I find a lot of similar problems with Jim Lee's designs and the PD designs. And not only in the clothing department, but also in the body deign. Not just the faces, but the body, especially the torso.Ya I know alot of people don't like how big they are but thats a different subject. Personally I like it. I think they look cool. They've never looked like this before.

Puddinpop
05-14-2014, 04:11 AM
Mm, nope.

Nick cartoonishly exaggerates the varying body types too much. When I said "varying body types", I was thinking of the first film. Nick is trying too hard.

Nope? Yes its cartoonish bc its a cartoon.. You think that they exaggerate the body types too much? You think that this is trying to hard?
http://worstfanboyever.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/TMNT-header.jpg

I respect your opinion but I disagree. The Nick show does a GREAT job with characterization imo. I think they nailed the turtles and their teenage personalities. This is one of the biggest reasons why it is such a success. Kids relate and cling to their potent personalities and I think they will with this movie as well. I mean ill be 30 in December and I thoroughly enjoy watching the cartoon. I find myself laughing at Mikey constantly. I think its cool to have them have different body builds to accentuate their personalities. I don't want dull characters in any way shape or form. But that's me

Netkeeper
05-14-2014, 04:39 AM
Nope? Yes its cartoonish bc its a cartoon.. You think that they exaggerate the body types too much? You think that this is trying to hard?
http://worstfanboyever.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/TMNT-header.jpg

I respect your opinion but I disagree. The Nick show does a GREAT job with characterization imo. I think they nailed the turtles and their teenage personalities. This is one of the biggest reasons why it is such a success. Kids relate and cling to their potent personalities and I think they will with this movie as well. I mean ill be 30 in December and I thoroughly enjoy watching the cartoon. I find myself laughing at Mikey constantly. I think its cool to have them have different body builds to accentuate their personalities. I don't want dull characters in any way shape or form. But that's me
I think the Nick show does a **** job with characterisation. It remains inconsistent as to whether or not the turtles are more 'turtle' than 'human' and over-simplifies Mikey to the point of completely missing the reason he acts the way he does therefore misinterpreting the character as a whole.

I don't like the exaggerated body type and the huge eyes, either. Differing eye colours are a nice way to display each character's differences from one another, but when the pupils themselves are constantly showing or are really big, it makes it distracting. That's why I call it tryhard. To me, it feels as if the radically different physical appearances of the turtles say "we designed these guys this way because kids TOTALLY can't tell each turtle apart without MORE differences!" Which is completely untrue; children are not stupid. That's one big reason as to why I don't like it.

But going back to characterisation for a minute, I do definitely agree with you that the Nick turtles are probably much easier for kids to relate to and enjoy due to their lively nature. I just want to make that clear that I don't disagree with your entire post. Simpler characterisations are easier for children to relate to and project onto, so they're going to have more fun watching it.

But writing characters that way isn't as realistic, so it isn't what I prefer. I like the more grounded personalities present in 2k3 and to a lesser extent, the first films, but the arguement could probably be made that they're more "dull". I don't feel that way at all personally, since what I see on the screen are four teenagers with some fairly believable personalities, disregarding the fact that they're mutant turtles. Sometimes kids don't find that as interesting, though. I dunno. As a kid I certainly found the turtles in the first three films more interesting than the turtles in the 87 cartoon.

Wherenoturtlehasgoneb4
05-14-2014, 06:34 AM
Nickelodeon is doing a superb job with the series. The way the characters are portrayed is fantastic and the voice acting is incredible, and I love the designs; the body proportions are the closest to those from the original comic and the heads/faces look both cool and more aesthetic than ever, besides they look more flexible. Finally Leo is carrying his swords comic style with both together over his shell which is much more practical than the crossed way, and he isn't as perfect as in 2003 so he won't be constantly overshadowing his brothers, though he's still the best. I'm glad Raph got rid of the accent and there's something very satisfying in watching him stab and stab enemies all over again (footbots and krangdroids, but still); Mikey cracks me up, is the first time EVER that I find him genuinely funny, mostly because he switched from trying so hard to look and sound hip based on cliches to a playful and naive kid (IS SUPER AND MACHO, LENGUA Y QUESO :D). Donnie is awesome too and the way he fights with his Bo is the flashiest and coolest of his incarnations. They nailed perfectly both the daily aspects of their regular life and the serious ninja stuff, both reflected in the way they switch behaviour and eye color. The way they fight using all kind of ninja gear, takedowns, etc. is very well done too, even better than in 2003.
Though I have only good memories of the classic series and live action movies, those incarnations of the turtles where like 2003 Raph pointed out, clowns, and their personalities were the most simplistic ever. The way they "fought" was beyond ridiculous, even as a kid I could tell there was something wrong when the turtles human friend, the pizza delivery boy Keno kicked much more butt than the turtles themselves...
Let's see the new movie turtles being stealthy and invisible when they look like mutated football players on steroids covered in random and useless stuff (a native american chest plate? a mexican hippie necklace? a sweater tied to the waist? REALLY??) Leo's somersault in the trailer looks stiff and forced as hell, landing like a sack of bricks, oh yeah and Raph slamming his shell against a jeep like nothing, I fear that all the "ninja" stuff in the movie is gonna be property destruction like that.

Netkeeper
05-14-2014, 08:09 AM
Oh god this'll be fun

Nickelodeon is doing a superb job with the series. The way the characters are portrayed is fantastic and the voice acting is incredible, and I love the designs; the body proportions are the closest to those from the original comic and the heads/faces look both cool and more aesthetic than ever, besides they look more flexible.
they look like twigs. anthropomorphs that have spent over a decade doing constant martial arts training should have more muscle than those twigs. flexibility is about muscle and athleticism, and these turts dont look half as strong as the 2k3 ones


Finally Leo is carrying his swords comic style with both together over his shell which is much more practical than the crossed way,
actually it looks stupid as hell and i hate it lmao

and he isn't as perfect as in 2003 so he won't be constantly overshadowing his brothers, though he's still the best.
did you conveniently forget 2k3 leo had ptsd he was not ****ing perfect

he was overly critical of himself, forgot that the world didnt revolve around him, made a dumb and almost joined forces with the shredder, and had some control issues

I'm glad Raph got rid of the accent and there's something very satisfying in watching him stab and stab enemies all over again (footbots and krangdroids, but still);
2k12 raph's voice does not suit him at all so whatever merits the actor's performance or delivery may have fall flat

the accent was a great addition to his character and i hated to see him lose it

Mikey cracks me up, is the first time EVER that I find him genuinely funny, mostly because he switched from trying so hard to look and sound hip based on cliches to a playful and naive kid (IS SUPER AND MACHO, LENGUA Y QUESO :D).
what the hell are you even talking about

when was "being funny" mikey's one and only purpose

he is the turtle that takes it easy because he would much rather see the good in any situation and remain upbeat. he's the aang of the turtles. jokes are just a PART of his character they aren't the entire thing

also 2k12 mikey isnt v funny at least 2k3 mikey felt much more like a teenager rather than a 12 year old

Donnie is awesome too and the way he fights with his Bo is the flashiest and coolest of his incarnations.
1: flashy fighting is not always practical and in donnie's case the excessive spinning is really annoying and its lazily animated a good deal of the time anyway

2: why the hell does don need to be flashy in any way shape or form this is more of 2k12's butchering of his character and making him completely unrecognisable

i dont even wanna bother with the rest of that post since no1curr about fight scenes to that detail; the fight scenes in each series reflect its theme and they're all fine as is as far as i'm concerned

Radical Raph
05-14-2014, 08:34 AM
Aesthetics are based on opinion. People think it looks loud and is unnecessarily complicated on something that's been well received for 30 years. I'm not sure how that's ridiculous. They prefer not adding stuff for the sake of adding stuff.

For me, though, it's primarily Leo's bamboo chest armor that's utterly ridiculous and Mikey's shell necklace that's kinda silly.

That and why all four of them are wearing loin cloths....I just don't get the loin cloths, man! Well, Mikey I don't get the pants. Think that's dumb. I'd trade the pants and keep his loin cloth equivalent of the hoody around the waist. I kinda like that, actually...it amuses me. :D
The thing is, I don't even think he'd be able to wear that hoody. It wouldn't fit over his shell.

Coola Yagami
05-14-2014, 09:12 AM
Main issue is, the turtles never felt the need or desire to wear extra crap unless it was for disguise purposes or 'buy the latest toy now' variant purposes. So why now?

And again the bebop and rocksteady example was a lame one since they were basically wearing the same stuff before mutation and only added a few weapons. Plus that was their design since day one. It's not like they just wore shorts and then some new movie came out and decked them out in military gear.

But again if it's such a big deal now then why weren't people complaining about mikey never wearing surfer gear or Leo using samurai armor over the past 30 years.

It's like some new movie coming out in which batman can fly and transform into a bat or something stupid like that and have the internet bombarded with idiots explaining why 'it makes sense', why 'it always should have been this way' and why 'the movie just HAD to do it this way or it wouldn't work'.

Like the other guy said, like or hate the movie in always gonna think the turtle designs were ass. They're just real horrible and now we've seen enough clips and footage to confirm it. You'd think they'd try harder since they're the MAIN characters and all.

Kingoji
05-14-2014, 12:03 PM
I just want to throw this in here because I've seen it pop up a couple times; Michelangelo isn't wearing a shirt around his waist, he's wearing a surfer's wetsuit with the top half tied around his waist... which makes even less sense than any 'fashion' or 'individuality' argument.

Radical Raph
05-14-2014, 01:07 PM
How does everyone feel about this design?

http://fc03.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2013/341/d/2/ninja_turtle___redesigned_by_soulty666-d6x44o0.jpg

electric_sheep
05-14-2014, 01:09 PM
How does everyone feel about this design?

http://fc03.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2013/341/d/2/ninja_turtle___redesigned_by_soulty666-d6x44o0.jpg

I like the body, i like the head though i am not certain why does it look like Samuel L Jackson. Overal it's ok...

Radical Raph
05-14-2014, 01:26 PM
I like the body, i like the head though i am not certain why does it look like Samuel L Jackson. Overal it's awesome...
See, I think it's ugly. The body is okay, but the shape of the head bothers me and, like you said, it has a Samuel L. Jackson thing going on. "What are all these mother****in' mousers doing in my mother****in' sewer?!"

I think it's what the new designs could have become had they gone off in the wrong direction. That said, it does resemble a turtle more.

I wonder if people would have been okay with something like this:

http://fc09.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2012/123/e/9/raphael_by_monstrous64-d4yg7o1.jpg

slingtheory
05-14-2014, 01:46 PM
See, I think it's ugly. The body is okay, but the shape of the head bothers me and, like you said, it has a Samuel L. Jackson thing going on. "What are all these mother****in' mousers doing in my mother****in' sewer?!"

I think it's what the new designs could have become had they gone off in the wrong direction. That said, it does resemble a turtle more.

I wonder if people would have been okay with something like this:

http://fc09.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2012/123/e/9/raphael_by_monstrous64-d4yg7o1.jpg

round out the face a little bit and I'd be down.

Whatswiththeheadbands?
05-14-2014, 02:35 PM
I like the body, i like the head though i am not certain why does it look like Samuel L Jackson. Overal it's awesome...

Raph: Enough is Enough! I've had it with all these Motherf***ing Foot ninja in these Motherf***ing Sewers!

SwiftNinjaFox
05-14-2014, 03:02 PM
Nope? Yes its cartoonish bc its a cartoon.. You think that they exaggerate the body types too much? You think that this is trying to hard?
http://worstfanboyever.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/TMNT-header.jpg

Have to agree with PUddinpop. Physically the Nick series isn't all that exaggerated. Don is the only one that's really a notable difference and Raph is just slightly wider, but I don't see vastly different designs amidst Raph/Leo/Mike. Don's just thinner and a bit taller and Mike's a tad shorter.

Doesn't seem too exaggerated to me at all.

The thing is, I don't even think he'd be able to wear that hoody. It wouldn't fit over his shell.

As in wear it like a jacket? I dunno, they've worn jackets before. He just had to find an XXXL, that's all. ;)

electric_sheep
05-14-2014, 03:03 PM
See, I think it's ugly. The body is okay, but the shape of the head bothers me and, like you said, it has a Samuel L. Jackson thing going on. "What are all these mother****in' mousers doing in my mother****in' sewer?!"

I think it's what the new designs could have become had they gone off in the wrong direction. That said, it does resemble a turtle more.

I wonder if people would have been okay with something like this:

http://fc09.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2012/123/e/9/raphael_by_monstrous64-d4yg7o1.jpg

http://s8.postimg.org/ntrg0xe3p/image.jpg
how about now? Wish i could have done something about that loincloth though, that really bugs me...

The Boston Ninja Turtle
05-14-2014, 03:10 PM
As in wear it like a jacket? I dunno, they've worn jackets before. He just had to find an XXXL, that's all. ;)

i know i did when i remade my jacket....and normally i am an XL

Radical Raph
05-14-2014, 03:11 PM
http://s8.postimg.org/ntrg0xe3p/image.jpg
how about now? Wish i could have done something about that loincloth though, that really bugs me...
That's better. Maybe if the head had more of the classic triangle shape.

electric_sheep
05-14-2014, 03:21 PM
That's better. Maybe if the head had more of the classic triangle shape.

http://s16.postimg.org/u4lo7serp/Untitled_1.jpg
I think this is the best i can do without turning it into cartoon...

Candy Kappa
05-14-2014, 03:43 PM
http://s8.postimg.org/ntrg0xe3p/image.jpg
how about now? Wish i could have done something about that loincloth though, that really bugs me...

Have the same shell issues as the Platinum Dunes Turtles.

Radical Raph
05-14-2014, 03:57 PM
http://s16.postimg.org/u4lo7serp/Untitled_1.jpg
I think this is the best i can do without turning it into cartoon...
Yes! Such subtle changes make such a huge difference. I could get on board with something like this.

SwiftNinjaFox
05-14-2014, 04:06 PM
http://s16.postimg.org/u4lo7serp/Untitled_1.jpg
I think this is the best i can do without turning it into cartoon...

Pretty good, I'd give it a shot.

Glados
05-14-2014, 04:31 PM
You're... actually making him more and more similar to the PD turtles. Give him a bit more of that classic triangle shaped head and you've kind of created a a cross between PD Raph and Leo!

I've said this before and I'll say it again: When you compare the new live action turtles from the trailers with still images of art work, the art will in most cases win with it's advantages of being a more or less stylized still image and not having to relate to anything else (real humans, movement, emoting etc.) I see many posting art work going "They should have looked like this!" and I'm thinking "That would have gotten equally/more complaints then what we got!"

Candy Kappa
05-14-2014, 05:21 PM
I'm curious what artists thought possess is when they omit the shell bridges connecting the plastron and carapace, and then make the plastron shaped to mimic a human's torso with scutes not only looking like breast plates, but acites made to look like a nice six-pack abs.

Does the ribcage sink I to the skin and then out again, as a inner bridge, or is the carapace just like a huge bone backpack connected to their skin like a giant fingernail, and the plastron just hangs there on their chest... It makes no frisking sense, which says a lot when it's TMNT.

Netkeeper
05-14-2014, 05:22 PM
How does everyone feel about this design?

http://fc03.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2013/341/d/2/ninja_turtle___redesigned_by_soulty666-d6x44o0.jpg
Original the character.

Also, butt-ugly. Beak isn't pronounced as much as I feel it should and the lips need to go the hell away. Sheep's final edit looks slightly better, but the nostrils seem too big for my taste. There's something else that's bugging me too but I can't quite put my finger on it.

NYShell
05-14-2014, 05:29 PM
No problem with the clothing whatsoever it's not like Donatello is going to wear all that through the entire flick:lol: but overall I think it's very creative and it makes each of the four bros distinct from one another then just having a different colored bandana

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=6892&stc=1&d=1400039028

This isn't official is it?

slingtheory
05-14-2014, 06:24 PM
I can't help but wonder what the outcome would've been if they would've went with the out of the shadows designs

electric_sheep
05-14-2014, 07:44 PM
Well it took some cheating but i finaly got it the way i wanted, almost...
http://s28.postimg.org/urrz110e5/image.jpg

Glados
05-15-2014, 07:18 AM
It's not bad... the trimmed-down the lower-legs make him look at bit sleeker, but I must say I think the head looks weird and way too humanoid in shape. The PD turtles actually look better to me personally, they have more of the classic head shape present. I think if they lost a lot of the cluttered attire they tossed on them and just shrinked them a tiny tad, they would look much better.

HOWEVER, I'd be a bit careful with editing other peoples art, not everyone is enthusiastic about getting their hard work nit-picked and edited on fan forums, which personally I find understandable.

Wherenoturtlehasgoneb4
05-15-2014, 08:44 AM
they look like twigs. anthropomorphs that have spent over a decade doing constant martial arts training should have more muscle than those twigs. flexibility is about muscle and athleticism, and these turts dont look half as strong as the 2k3 ones

Oh yeah I forgot that for some people even teenagers should look like steroids propaganda (I'm looking at you, 2014 movie). And where exactly did you want them to grow muscles? In the plastron? Or maybe they should have much bigger arms so between that, the shell on their backs and the plastron on ther abdomens they could have a very hard time moving them.
Ever heard about a guy named Bruce Lee? Great martial artist, constantly training for years? Guess what? he wasn't very muscular, some may even call him skinny.
And like I said before, 2012 turtles has the closest body proportions to the original Eastman-Laird work.

actually it looks stupid as hell and i hate it lmao

You HATE how Leo carries his swords comic style in a much more practical way than crossed over his shell? So you basically know better than the creators of the turtles themselves...Okay... :roll:

did you conveniently forget 2k3 leo had ptsd he was not ****ing perfect

he was overly critical of himself, forgot that the world didnt revolve around him, made a dumb and almost joined forces with the shredder, and had some control issues

And that made him the best fighter of the bunch, the more complex and interesting, the one who grew more as a whole of the four, the one who awakened the dragon spirit first, and the one who didn't receive a special weapon in the ninja tribunal because he didn't need it... And at the end he overcame his flaws.:D


2k12 raph's voice does not suit him at all so whatever merits the actor's performance or delivery may have fall flat

the accent was a great addition to his character and i hated to see him lose it

Why the hell would one of 4 brothers that were equally raised by the same guy in the exactly same place had a completely different accent than his brothers? And you were complaining about the 2012 turtles having slightly different builds and heights as "trying too hard"? and don't forget about the strikingly different skin colors of 2003.
I'm glad he lost the unexplicable accent and the stupid "you're in the hood" pseudo tough guy mannerisms.
Sean Astin is doing a great job with the sarcastic/angry personality of Raph.


what the hell are you even talking about

when was "being funny" mikey's one and only purpose

he is the turtle that takes it easy because he would much rather see the good in any situation and remain upbeat. he's the aang of the turtles. jokes are just a PART of his character they aren't the entire thing

also 2k12 mikey isnt v funny at least 2k3 mikey felt much more like a teenager rather than a 12 year old

Michelangelo was always the crowd pleaser. The one who tried too hard to seem cool and funny based in the limited to the US late 80's-early 90's surfer lingo and dumb jokes. 2003 Mikey with his obsession with limited edition action figures and comics didn't really feel like a cool teenager; he simply was too nerdy.
2012 Mikey is much more realistic and universal with his wandering mind and kid naiveness. Besides he's more versatile when fighting.


1: flashy fighting is not always practical and in donnie's case the excessive spinning is really annoying and its lazily animated a good deal of the time anyway

2: why the hell does don need to be flashy in any way shape or form this is more of 2k12's butchering of his character and making him completely unrecognisable

When using a Bo you're supposed to use circular movements and pokes unlike most Donnies incarnations that used it more like a baseball bat.
Unrecognisable? 2003 Don was unrecognisable from his 80's version. 2012 Don keeps his caring for people from 2003.


i dont even wanna bother with the rest of that post since no1curr about fight scenes to that detail; the fight scenes in each series reflect its theme and they're all fine as is as far as i'm concerned

Yeah let's not bother each other anymore with this conversation. You hate a lot of things just based in your opinion and not in facts, which is a very limited way to see the world, besides being too contradictory. There's no consistency in your arguments besides that you simply like more the 2003 show. I'm guessing you grew up with that one? is that it? nostalgia?
Get over it. Enjoy the new show. And let's avoid doing off topic, or better I'll unsubscribe from this one, I have better things to do than arguing with people about how they hate things without real reasons.

Radical Raph
05-15-2014, 08:53 AM
I always took Raph having a different accent as him spending more time on the surface than his brothers causing him to speak more like a common New Yorker. After all, he is the outcast of the group.

Speaking of that, for the new movie, I wonder if they will give Raph his accent? I have noticed you can hear a slight hint of it when he yells, "Donnie!", in the trailer, but still kinda hard to tell.

Wherenoturtlehasgoneb4
05-15-2014, 09:05 AM
I always took Raph having a different accent as him spending more time on the surface than his brothers causing him to speak more like a common New Yorker. After all, he is the outcast of the group.

Speaking of that, for the new movie, I wonder if they will give Raph his accent? I have noticed you can hear a slight hint of it when he yells, "Donnie!", in the trailer, but still kinda hard to tell.

For that he must've spend a lot of time on the surface speaking with people while growing up... And he isn't and outcast, at least not by his family.

Coola Yagami
05-15-2014, 10:24 PM
For that he must've spend a lot of time on the surface speaking with people while growing up... And he isn't and outcast, at least not by his family.

The accent thing was never really neccesary. They never made him talk like that in the comics... nor does it explain why Leo and Don don't have that accent as well (assuming Mikey would still keep the surfer accent). They were all born and raised in New York.. why is only one of them speaking like a New Yorker?

Netkeeper
05-15-2014, 11:21 PM
Oh yeah I forgot that for some people even teenagers should look like steroids propaganda (I'm looking at you, 2014 movie)...
i agree with you that the 2k14 turts are lookin real dumb with the over-the-top musculature

since you mention the shells i just wanted to say that 2k12 turts have some really thin shells that dont look like they can protect them from anything also having a lot of muscle mass doesnt restrict movement dumbass

Ever heard about a guy named Bruce Lee? ...
yes i have heard of him actually; ive watched fight scenes from his movies a whooooole lot growing up, my dad is a huge fan of his, and you are very right about all of those things. but have you ever SEEN him? he had some impressive musculature. the 2k3 turtles didnt look over-muscled to me idk what your problem is. youre acting like they were sporting some goku guns or some ****

You HATE how Leo carries his swords comic style in a much more practical way than crossed over his shell? ...
yes i do hate that. i dont like it in the comics either. does this mean i know what is better? no. did i ever say that? lmao, no, i did not. however, having them crossed over his shell has the benefit that he can unsheathe both swords at once with them like that [which he does plenty of in the versions where the swords are crossed]. you cant unsheathe both swords at once if theyre both located on the same side of your shell. thats why i think it looks stupid.

of course, i am arguing a point that is faulty at its core anyway since dual-wielding katana/ninjato is a dumbshit thing to do in the first place but its exactly what leonardo does. they werent made for that purpose. samurai had two swords of varying lengths because a shorter one was better-suited to close-quarters combat, not so they could have one in each hand. but this fault is present in every single incarnation of leonardo to date, so it really doesnt matter. if he were to wield his swords in a more practical style, guess where they would be located? not across the ****ing shell at all.

And that made him the best fighter of the bunch, the more complex and interesting...
yes, 2k3 does have the flaw of giving leonardo more spotlight and character development than the other turtles and this isnt fair. but youre claiming it makes him perfect when he is far from it. however i will give you points for calling 2k3 leonardo interesting. a lot of people call him boring, since he has the most balance of character traits aside from maybe donatello. not as many extremes are present in his characterisation, which makes it a little difficult to pin down what hes actually like, and it makes him seem dull.

youre completely forgetting that leonardo isnt the best fighter of the turtles at all, though. he just has the most dedication to his training and is the obvious teachers pet; early on he is still shown to not know how to do a split kick and couldnt pull off the technique until he used it in an actual fight. michelangelo has the most raw talent and potential [he just slacks off because he can get good at something really quickly], donatello learns the fastest and has more resourcefulness than all of them combined, and raphael is the most physically powerful with what i consider the most versatile weapon.

youre still forgetting that he almost made a dumb and joined forces with the goddamn shredder. leonardo has a lot of misguided ideas and he needs his brothers to keep him from making stupid decisions when it really matters. again, he has control issues. he has moments where he thinks because hes the leader, he can do no wrong.

if you think overcoming your flaws are things youre not supposed to do, you cannot possibly have a very good grasp on what good writing actually is. heroes overcome their flaws. leonardo had his ptsd, michelangelo had to his lazyness, raph had his temper, and donatello had to deal with same as it never was which tested his ability to come up with a battle plan in a very short period of time as well as overcoming his own over-protective tendencies during the battle nexus.

Why the hell would one of 4 brothers that were equally raised by the same guy in the exactly same place had a completely different accent than his brothers?
because hes being raised in new york where people have new york accents. ive seen this explained in a lot of various ways, with raphael's accent being natural and his brothers either putting on an accent for attention [mikey] or controlling their accents consciously [leonardo and donatello]; i've also seen it explained the other way round where raphael adopted the accent to sound tougher. but either way you're forgetting that mikey has basically always had an accent too. it's not absent from 2k12.

And you were complaining about the 2012 turtles having slightly different builds and heights as "trying too hard"? ...
2k12 still has the different skin tones. having vastly different voices has always been present with the tmnt, which is something you seem to be forgetting, and it's different than physical appearances because it's realistic for people to all sound different. that argument has faulty logic.

also, i think the mannerisms suit raph really well. he wants to be a tough guy, so he is going to try and sound like one. i don't see the problem with this.

Michelangelo was always the crowd pleaser...
just because he has always been the crowd pleaser doesn't mean that's all his character is meant to be or all it ever should be. his accent and slang usage include lingo and jokes that are exclusive to the states because... and this may come to you as a shock, but... he lives in new york.

yes, 2k3 mikey liked comic books and action figures and whatnot. what is the problem with this. that it's "nerdy"? why is that a problem? these are perfectly fine and healthy interests to have, but not only are they not his only interests, but they aren't even a large part of his character. you're completely misunderstanding his character on a fundamental level, so here, let me lay it out for you:

michelangelo is a pretty classic case of youngest child, regardless of whether not he actually IS the youngest as turtle ages are ambiguous. he comes across as the youngest since he tries very hard to gain acknowledgement and praise, but once he gets it, he calms down and moves to another subject or goal. living with three other brothers who all specialize in something, michelangelo developed a tendency towards attention-seeking because he doesn't know how else to distinguish himself, but this doesn't cause him any undue stress or self-esteem issues because he is an optimist at heart and enjoys life. combine these ideals together and it makes a lot of sense that he has idols in the form of comic book heroes. he wants validation and he wants to be recognised for the good he and his brothers do, so he latches onto superheroes. if this dream could be realised, he and his brothers could enjoy life topside without having to hide.

he is lively, energetic, and feels that every situation has a good side so he tries to communicate what he thinks this good side is. when he tells jokes, he is trying to liven up the mood, but you have to be perceptive of your surroundings in order to tell them effectively [which i feel that, for the most part, he is good at doing]. michelangelo knows his brothers better than anyone else, as demonstrated when he kicked raph's shell easily during the battle nexus despite not being as skilled [arguably]. he is able to repeatedly goad don into building whatever he wants don to build, because he knows how don works and how to get something out of him. when leo has his issues with ptsd, mikey is the first to realise what leo is going through and nobody is surprised (http://wtf-skittens.tumblr.com/post/77875907898/angeldormante-off-in-lalaland). because he isn't just a joke, he is insightful and his brothers damn well know this. this is very absent from 2k12, where is treated as a joke and never taken seriously at all.

When using a Bo you're supposed to use circular movements and pokes unlike most Donnies incarnations that used it more like a baseball bat.
this is not proper bo technique. this is excessive flashiness. (http://gaylordsmansion.tumblr.com/post/77270548066/)

Unrecognisable? 2003 Don was unrecognisable from his 80's version. 2012 Don keeps his caring for people from 2003.
>2k3 don is unrecognisable from his 87 counterpart
>2k12 don cares for people and isnt an uptight asswipe
http://i.imgur.com/zz582z3.jpg

You hate a lot of things just based in your opinion and not in facts
wow, somebody has an opinion due to other opinions they hold. who would have guessed that's how opinions work

I'm guessing you grew up with that one? is that it? nostalgia? Get over it. Enjoy the new show.
i'm 23. i didn't even watch 2k3 at all until i was an adult. i grew up with the 87 and original films' turtles. also, no, i will not enjoy the new show because i do not find it enjoyable.

And let's avoid doing off topic, or better I'll unsubscribe from this one
oh nooooo he's threatening to unsubscribe from a thread i didnt even make whatever will i doooooo

I have better things to do than arguing with people about how they hate things without real reasons.
says the dude who hates 2k3 mikey because he "isnt funny"

Candy Kappa
05-16-2014, 02:35 AM
yes i do hate that. i dont like it in the comics either. does this mean i know what is better? no. did i ever say that? lmao, no, i did not. however, having them crossed over his shell has the benefit that he can unsheathe both swords at once with them like that [which he does plenty of in the versions where the swords are crossed]. you cant unsheathe both swords at once if theyre both located on the same side of your shell. thats why i think it looks stupid.

of course, i am arguing a point that is faulty at its core anyway since dual-wielding katana/ninjato is a dumbshit thing to do in the first place but its exactly what leonardo does. they werent made for that purpose. samurai had two swords of varying lengths because a shorter one was better-suited to close-quarters combat, not so they could have one in each hand. but this fault is present in every single incarnation of leonardo to date, so it really doesnt matter. if he were to wield his swords in a more practical style, guess where they would be located? not across the ****ing shell at all.

Niten Ichi-Ryu is an actual sword school that specializes in dual wielding. Now, real life dual wielding of Nihonto is a longsword (katana) and a short sword (wakishazi). This have "always" been represented wrong in TMNT history as Leo usually wears a pair of katana, and sometimes the katana is even depicted as straight bladed swords instead of a curved blade. But, it's easier to draw a sword with a straight blade then a curved.

In the Nick cartoon, they finally give Leonardo the right sword combination as he uses a katana and a wakishazi.

Edit: Just as an add-on, here's some schools that also have dual wield techniques.

Tenshin Shoden Katori Shinto Ryu
Tatsumi Ryu
Shingyoto Ryu
Suio Ryu

as an example, here's the the first kata from TSKSR

UiTj5LFSGeI

Tenshin Shoden Katori Shinto Ryu have about 4 different kata using two swords, as far as I know.

Edit 2: As for storing swords on someone's back. This is mostly fiction (at least the way it's presented), as it is hard to draw any sword from your back compared to the hip, especially using a katana.
The instances of factual real-life back carrying swordsmen are few, and usually used for transportation. I know of only one instance where swordsmen have their swords crossed over the back, the Thai warriors of the Ayutthaya (sp?) period.

SwiftNinjaFox
05-16-2014, 10:51 AM
yes i do hate that. i dont like it in the comics either. does this mean i know what is better? no. did i ever say that? lmao, no, i did not. however, having them crossed over his shell has the benefit that he can unsheathe both swords at once with them like that [which he does plenty of in the versions where the swords are crossed]. you cant unsheathe both swords at once if theyre both located on the same side of your shell. thats why i think it looks stupid.

Truthfully, like you stated, it doesn't matter how they're held on the back. Get a katana. Or get a straight bladed "ninjato" if you like. Slap that sucker on your back either way and try to draw it. Your dagblasted arms aren't long enough to go straight up far enough to properly draw it from the scabbard. Unless the scabbard is designed with a slit down the side for the blade to slip free from, I suppose.

Leo, despite cover art which is just meant to look awesome, also fought with only one sword at a time A LOT in the comics. He didn't actually dual wield all the time. :)

I've read speculation that realistically a ninja dual wielding would more logically have used two wakizashi, possibly even wakizashi stored in a katana's scabbard to hide the quickness of the draw's capability and have the opponent misjudge capabilities.

Also, like you said, that would kind of makes sense as a shorter sword is more appropriate for two handed fighting PLUS better for fighting in close quarters. There's a reason the longsword was replaced by the cutlass for pirates/privateers.

youre still forgetting that he almost made a dumb and joined forces with the goddamn shredder. leonardo has a lot of misguided ideas and he needs his brothers to keep him from making stupid decisions when it really matters. again, he has control issues. he has moments where he thinks because hes the leader, he can do no wrong.

A dynamic I feel is often overlooked. Leo/Raph dynamic is the most obvious - Raph NEEDS Leo to put him in his place from time to time, Leo NEEDS Raph to challenge his decisions from time to time. Their different personalities counter-balance one another.

I like how the Northampton arc in IDW had a little bit of interaction with the different brothers and how Leo/Don have actually been shown through the series to have some personality conflicts with Leo's being more spiritual against Don's scientific basis.

In the Nick cartoon, they finally give Leonardo the right sword combination as he uses a katana and a wakishazi.

They did? They still look to be the same length to me.

http://www.cartoonbrew.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Nickelodeon-Cast-Of-Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-Donatello-With-Bo-Staff-Raphael-With-A-Pair-Of-Sai-Action-Figures-Toys-Dolls-e1349276297847.jpg

Though sometimes they're longer, sometimes they're shorter. Honestly it's less authenticity and more about what looks good for the scene.

The Boston Ninja Turtle
05-16-2014, 12:02 PM
In the Nick cartoon, they finally give Leonardo the right sword combination as he uses a katana and a wakishazi.

i have noticed this too, one sword if def longer than the other

Radical Raph
05-16-2014, 12:35 PM
I just cannot wait to finally see Leonardo stab someone. That's all I'm sayin'.

Whatswiththeheadbands?
05-16-2014, 01:05 PM
>2k3 don is unrecognisable from his 87 counterpart
>2k12 don cares for people and isnt an uptight asswipe
http://i.imgur.com/zz582z3.jpg

I love a good Spider-man 1967 meme:D

Candy Kappa
05-16-2014, 01:24 PM
And, again. It's not just the clothes, but the whole design.And I am not only talking about the faces, so relax.

No, one of the main offenders for me, is the lack of turtle-y features. They have shells, sure. but the plastron looks more like a thick hide over their hunky man-abs rather then an actual plastron. The Carapace do not make me think of a turtle, or more closer a terrapin. A Box Turtle maybe, but that's because the shells of a Box Turtle is shaped more akin to a tortoise.

Their limbs are not very reminiscent of a turtle. Now, several incarnations lacks this as well mind you, but. With the current cartoon having such a nice sense of details, I feel it's a shame the movie don't do it either. A turtle's limbs usually are smaller at the shoulder/hip and widens at the paws, same does the Nick designs, and some of the IDW designs and early Mirage.

http://i34.photobucket.com/albums/d112/Slider4/Turtles/IMG_3752.jpg

For me, the PD Turtles looks like generic Reptilians then specific Bipedal Turtles.

And then comes the clothes on-top of these issues, and their faces, and their weapons.



They did? They still look to be the same length to me.

http://www.cartoonbrew.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Nickelodeon-Cast-Of-Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-Donatello-With-Bo-Staff-Raphael-With-A-Pair-Of-Sai-Action-Figures-Toys-Dolls-e1349276297847.jpg

Though sometimes they're longer, sometimes they're shorter. Honestly it's less authenticity and more about what looks good for the scene.

One of the swords are shorter, personally. I think it could be shorter, but it is noticeable shorter, on both on-screen and in toy form.

Radical Raph
05-16-2014, 01:52 PM
And, again. It's not just the clothes, but the whole design.And I am not only talking about the faces, so relax.

No, one of the main offenders for me, is the lack of turtle-y features. They have shells, sure. but the plastron looks more like a thick hide over their hunky man-abs rather then an actual plastron. The Carapace do not make me think of a turtle, or more closer a terrapin. A Box Turtle maybe, but that's because the shells of a Box Turtle is shaped more akin to a tortoise.

Their limbs are not very reminiscent of a turtle. Now, several incarnations lacks this as well mind you, but. With the current cartoon having such a nice sense of details, I feel it's a shame the movie don't do it either. A turtle's limbs usually are smaller at the shoulder/hip and widens at the paws, same does the Nick designs, and some of the IDW designs and early Mirage.

http://i34.photobucket.com/albums/d112/Slider4/Turtles/IMG_3752.jpg

For me, the PD Turtles looks like generic Reptilians then specific Bipedal Turtles.

And then comes the clothes on-top of these issues, and their faces, and their weapons.




One of the swords are shorter, personally. I think it could be shorter, but it is noticeable shorter, on both on-screen and in toy form.
http://images.bidnessetc.com/content/uploads/images/source3/nka-4fc848051e4459b8a6afeb210c3664ec.gif

Candy Kappa
05-16-2014, 02:23 PM
http://images.bidnessetc.com/content/uploads/images/source3/nka-4fc848051e4459b8a6afeb210c3664ec.gif

http://www.wormsandgermsblog.com/uploads/image/Turtle.jpg


...


...No.

Refractive Reflections
05-16-2014, 03:03 PM
Mm, nope.

Nick cartoonishly exaggerates the varying body types too much. When I said "varying body types", I was thinking of the first film. Nick is trying too hard.

I wouldn't say Nick exaggerates "too much" but the body forms are very cliche, and fits visual stereotyping to the smallest detail. Of course Raph is going to be the shortest (excluding Mikey) and have the most muscle, so it implies there's some underlying subconscious height envy/insecurity (about wanting to be seen as a leader). Donatello is tall, scrawny, skinny, egg-headish, and a gap in his teeth to highlight the "dorkiness" or nerd aspect of his character. Mikey has freckles, light blue eyes, and be the most petite to make him look the most innocent. Leo is stereotypically average in height and build, to suit the "well-rounded" aspect of his character.

I preferred the same body types in the earlier cartoons (OT and 2K3), the movies, and comics because at least it forced the audience/reader (who were unfamiliar with TMNT) to learn about the characters rather than presumptuously assuming their individual personalities by visual assessment.

This 2014 movie takes those Nick TMNT body forms to an absurd caricature degree and goes beyond "exaggerating", not only in body form, but in apparel as well. (I've come up with the theory that you can tell how much a reinterpretation is depending on stereotypes based on how much contrast there is between Donatello's vs. Raphael's appearances.) Really? We need THAT much visual reinforcement to know about Leo's traditional ways, or Donatello's consuming interest in technology, etc. that it makes their gear highly impractical in fighting? We can't just let the dialogue, and plot reveal and expand on each of the Turtles' personalities? ...And here society prides itself on being above visual stereotyping. :roll:

Sumac
05-16-2014, 03:06 PM
Unrecognisable? 2003 Don was unrecognisable from his 80's version. 2012 Don keeps his caring for people from 2003.
If anything they were different takes on the same idea. 87 Don was more "snobby", less patient, more leaderlike then even Leo at times. 03 Don was softer and more pacifistic, but they definitely have a lot of similarities.
If anything, it was Raphael who was VERY different in the 87 series and other incarnations. Seeing him as a "tough guy" in the 03 series took some time to use to. I didn't had such problem with others - I immediately accepted them as a new versions of the same characters. It was true even for the April. Not so much for the Casey, though. Not that I cared about his character back in the 87 series.

Sighphi
05-17-2014, 10:13 AM
the katana is even depicted as straight bladed swords instead of a curved blade. But, it's easier to draw a sword with a straight blade then a curved.


The Japanese had straight swords.
Maybe Leo picked a pair of those and learn with that not really knowing what they were.

Candy Kappa
05-17-2014, 12:27 PM
The Japanese had straight swords.
Maybe Leo picked a pair of those and learn with that not really knowing what they were.

Yes, back in the 10th century called Chokuto, AND are very different then the tachi and katana. It predates the tempering used for the tachi and katana. So no, Leonardo do not have those swords cause the swords clearly resemble a katana, but are incorrectly depicted as straight bladed.


And if you refer to the straight bladed "Ninjato", that is wrong, there is no historical evidence of straight bladed katana/Ninjato and was first surfaced back in the 1960's. In fact, if there even was straight bladed katana back in the feudal period, they would not be ideal Ninjato swords, because it would be far more costly to make straight swords compared to the curved swords, cause the tempering of the steel sword smiths used naturally curved the blade.

And Leonardo, who was taught by a martial arts master, should know what swords he holds in his hands, your reasoning there is way far fetched.

electric_sheep
05-17-2014, 12:38 PM
Isn't Katana supposed to be a two handed weapon, like lightsaber? He kinda looks silly holding two Katanas....

Candy Kappa
05-17-2014, 12:42 PM
A katana is primarily a two-hander, but it can also function as a one-hander.

samxsteal
05-17-2014, 03:32 PM
A katana is primarily a two-hander, but it can also function as a one-hander.
Musashi LIKE A BOSS best samurai ever

Netkeeper
05-17-2014, 04:04 PM
Truthfully, like you stated, it doesn't matter how they're held on the back. Get a katana. Or get a straight bladed "ninjato" if you like. Slap that sucker on your back either way and try to draw it. Your dagblasted arms aren't long enough to go straight up far enough to properly draw it from the scabbard. Unless the scabbard is designed with a slit down the side for the blade to slip free from, I suppose.
Yep. I've tried it before, and you're exactly right.

Leo, despite cover art which is just meant to look awesome, also fought with only one sword at a time A LOT in the comics. He didn't actually dual wield all the time. :)
Oh yeah, I do realise in the comics he used one sword at a time a lot. I hit character limit so I couldn't include that part in my post.

I've read speculation that realistically a ninja dual wielding would more logically have used two wakizashi, possibly even wakizashi stored in a katana's scabbard to hide the quickness of the draw's capability and have the opponent misjudge capabilities.
...I really like this idea. Holy **** I want to use this idea for a project I'm working on now.

A dynamic I feel is often overlooked. Leo/Raph dynamic is the most obvious - Raph NEEDS Leo to put him in his place from time to time, Leo NEEDS Raph to challenge his decisions from time to time. Their different personalities counter-balance one another.

I like how the Northampton arc in IDW had a little bit of interaction with the different brothers and how Leo/Don have actually been shown through the series to have some personality conflicts with Leo's being more spiritual against Don's scientific basis.
Yep. I feel the turtles are best characterised when each of them creates a foil for another; where you can pair any two of the turtles together and their personality differences are highlighted by the other. It just creates this sense of balance and I love it.

I wouldn't say Nick exaggerates "too much" but the body forms are very cliche, and fits visual stereotyping to the smallest detail. Of course Raph is going to be the shortest (excluding Mikey) and have the most muscle, so it implies there's some underlying subconscious height envy/insecurity (about wanting to be seen as a leader). Donatello is tall, scrawny, skinny, egg-headish, and a gap in his teeth to highlight the "dorkiness" or nerd aspect of his character. Mikey has freckles, light blue eyes, and be the most petite to make him look the most innocent. Leo is stereotypically average in height and build, to suit the "well-rounded" aspect of his character.

I preferred the same body types in the earlier cartoons (OT and 2K3), the movies, and comics because at least it forced the audience/reader (who were unfamiliar with TMNT) to learn about the characters rather than presumptuously assuming their individual personalities by visual assessment.

This 2014 movie takes those Nick TMNT body forms to an absurd caricature degree and goes beyond "exaggerating", not only in body form, but in apparel as well. (I've come up with the theory that you can tell how much a reinterpretation is depending on stereotypes based on how much contrast there is between Donatello's vs. Raphael's appearances.) Really? We need THAT much visual reinforcement to know about Leo's traditional ways, or Donatello's consuming interest in technology, etc. that it makes their gear highly impractical in fighting? We can't just let the dialogue, and plot reveal and expand on each of the Turtles' personalities? ...And here society prides itself on being above visual stereotyping. :roll:
This is an AMAZING post and you should feel proud. That is all, I just wanted to point that out.

And if you refer to the straight bladed "Ninjato", that is wrong, there is no historical evidence of straight bladed katana/Ninjato and was first surfaced back in the 1960's. In fact, if there even was straight bladed katana back in the feudal period, they would not be ideal Ninjato swords, because it would be far more costly to make straight swords compared to the curved swords, cause the tempering of the steel sword smiths used naturally curved the blade.

And Leonardo, who was taught by a martial arts master, should know what swords he holds in his hands, your reasoning there is way far fetched.
I've done my reading on the ninjato, and I know you're completely right here. But I just want to point something out to you.

http://i.imgur.com/px0VKws.jpg http://i.imgur.com/XesgxvV.png
2k3 Leonardo is unmistakably wielding ninjato. You cannot tell me these are anything else. I'm not sure about the other incarnations since I never had a reason to identify the swords he carries in those [my brother is more the sword guy than I am], but this one's really obvious.

Candy Kappa
05-17-2014, 04:17 PM
I've done my reading on the ninjato, and I know you're completely right here. But I just want to point something out to you.

http://i.imgur.com/px0VKws.jpg http://i.imgur.com/XesgxvV.png
2k3 Leonardo is unmistakably wielding ninjato. You cannot tell me these are anything else. I'm not sure about the other incarnations since I never had a reason to identify the swords he carries in those [my brother is more the sword guy than I am], but this one's really obvious.

Thanks, captain obvious?

The swords are also straight in the live action trilogy. They have also been depicted as straight bladed in various comics. Doesn't make it any less incorrect.

I even mentioned that Leo's sword are usually depicted wrong in a previous post

Niten Ichi-Ryu is an actual sword school that specializes in dual wielding. Now, real life dual wielding of Nihonto is a longsword (katana) and a short sword (wakishazi). This have "always" been represented wrong in TMNT history as Leo usually wears a pair of katana, and sometimes the katana is even depicted as straight bladed swords instead of a curved blade. But, it's easier to draw a sword with a straight blade then a curved.

So, not sure why you needed to point it out to me?

Netkeeper
05-17-2014, 04:19 PM
Thanks, captain obvious?

The swords are also straight in the live action trilogy. They have also been depicted as straight bladed in various comics. Doesn't make it any less incorrect.

I even mentioned that Leo's sword are usually depicted wrong in a previous post

lmao, then excuuuuuuse me for missing that. No need to act all superior about it, since I wasn't trying to prove you wrong or anything.

Candy Kappa
05-17-2014, 04:21 PM
Okay... Well it was a part of a reply to one of your posts.

Netkeeper
05-17-2014, 04:28 PM
Ok. Still not sure why you were all huffy about it, since I'm not trying to piss you off or anything.

Candy Kappa
05-17-2014, 04:33 PM
Maybe I'm just overly passionate about historically incorrect swords...

Sighphi
05-17-2014, 04:34 PM
Yes, back in the 10th century called Chokuto, AND are very different then the tachi and katana. It predates the tempering used for the tachi and katana. So no, Leonardo do not have those swords cause the swords clearly resemble a katana, but are incorrectly depicted as straight bladed.


How do they "clearly resemble" katanas when the signature feature doesnt exist?

If you look at Leo's sword they are usually drawn with a big pommel. Guess what type of sword uses a pommel? The straight sword and not the Katana.


And Leonardo, who was taught by a martial arts master, should know what swords he holds in his hands, your reasoning there is way far fetched.

Leo was taught the ways of the ninja not the ways of the samurai. The weapon he uses does not matter, he got, found, whatever, a couple of Chokuto and was taught a style using those swords.

Candy Kappa
05-17-2014, 04:47 PM
How do they "clearly resemble" katanas when the signature feature doesnt exist?

If you look at Leo's sword they are usually drawn with a big pommel. Guess what type of sword uses a pommel? The straight sword and not the Katana.

The words "artistic interpretation" comes to mind.

Especially when most incarnations also depicts Raphael's Sai wrong.

Sighphi
05-17-2014, 04:57 PM
The words "artistic interpretation" comes to mind.

Especially when most incarnations also depicts Raphael's Sai wrong.

They artistically interpreted a Katana to resemble a straight sword ... why?
I think the problem came after when other people took over and they did start making it look more like Katanas. But originally Leo was just using straight swords.

And Raph is not using sais he is using Tekpis.

Candy Kappa
05-17-2014, 05:18 PM
Tekpi is the Malaysian name for the Sai, and there aren't a whole lot of differences between the Okinawan Sai and the Malaysian Tekpi. Another name for Sai is Tjabang (Chabang).


Edit: the idea of Leo actually using Chokuto under the guise as Katana is absolutely hysterical. First off, straight swords and curved swords are used very differently. Second, and this is the important part. The Chokuto is a extremely outdated Nihinto, so ancient that there (as far as I know, and looked) is no schools that teaches Chokuto techniques, it simply phased out as the Tachi came along as the much superior weapon.

SwiftNinjaFox
05-17-2014, 06:08 PM
They artistically interpreted a Katana to resemble a straight sword ... why?

Because Eastman and Laird are not martial artists nor students of Japanese history and at the time of the TMNT's creation, the 80s had seen a surge of ninja movies all using the straight bladed sword now generally called ninjato.

At the time, however, I think they were still generally called katana in said films. They were even used in Japanese live plays.

That's the real reason they artistically interpreted the straight blade - it was common in ninja movies at the time (and I believe Frank Miller & Co. were using them for Elektra and The Hand as well).

From there, it just stuck.

It's also probably a bit easier to draw. ;)

Sighphi
05-17-2014, 06:40 PM
Tekpi is the Malaysian name for the Sai, and there aren't a whole lot of differences between the Okinawan Sai and the Malaysian Tekpi. Another name for Sai is Tjabang (Chabang).

But the differences that exist clearly show which kind of sai Raph is using.
Wiki just happened to have an Okinawan sai with Indonesian tekpi pictured. Guess which is which.

http://i.imgur.com/JOzr63Z.jpg


Edit: the idea of Leo actually using Chokuto under the guise as Katana is absolutely hysterical. First off, straight swords and curved swords are used very differently. Second, and this is the important part. The Chokuto is a extremely outdated Nihinto, so ancient that there (as far as I know, and looked) is no schools that teaches Chokuto techniques, it simply phased out as the Tachi came along as the much superior weapon.

I think they looked for cool designs and instead of using the original names they picked the easier names. Tekpi doesnt roll off the tongue as easy as saying Sai.

Secondly, they are trained in Ninja techniques, again, ninja techniques, who knows what weapons they used and how they used them.

Candy Kappa
05-18-2014, 03:50 AM
But the differences that exist clearly show which kind of sai Raph is using.
Wiki just happened to have an Okinawan sai with Indonesian tekpi pictured. Guess which is which.

http://i.imgur.com/JOzr63Z.jpg



I think they looked for cool designs and instead of using the original names they picked the easier names. Tekpi doesnt roll off the tongue as easy as saying Sai.

Secondly, they are trained in Ninja techniques, again, ninja techniques, who knows what weapons they used and how they used them.

I'm curious if your research have gone any further then to the Tekpi and Sai Wikipedia entry, cause Sai/Chabang/Tekpi comes in different designs.

Here's a pair of Tekpi looking more similar to the Okinawan Sai from your Wikipedia image:
http://geligabunian.blogspot.no/2012/10/tekpi-bugis-dan-kerambit-melayu.html

And here is a photo of Taira Dojo in Okinawa, the Sai looks more akin to what you mean is a Tekpi.

http://www.karate-kobudo.co.nz/image/okinawa%202008%20011ab.jpg

So. The Sai, Tekpi and Tjabang is the same weapon, it's all about design and style.

This is also a Sai.

http://www.cidio.net/images/manji_sai.jpg
Called Manji Sai, due to the position of the prongs makes it resemble the Buddhist Manjj/Swastika symbol.


Ninja techniques don't include weapons that aren't used. The sword is so antique by the time the Ninja was operating that it is a obsolete weapon, it would be like modern Marines using Flint Lock guns.

And since we are onto Ninja Techniques and Shinobi No Jutsu, there is no such thing displayed in TMNT history, they are at best pop-culture Ninjas, based of fiction, movies and comic books. Not from real-life Shinobi.

The amount of research Eastman and Laird went into creating the turtles comes from Frank Miller's Daredevil stories and Frank Miller's Ronin.


Dude does it all the time. Get used to it haha, it's probably out of insecurity or something. He'll go extra dorky on you about insignificant knowledge, or moot details about meaningless things in an attempt to prove you wrong or something.. He'll reply to this in a passive aggressive way too.

:lol:

Do I now?
I don't think you should be the one talking about insecurities and passive aggressiveness, considering your usual posting style and latest thread.

Don't throw rocks in glasshouses, and all that.

Sighphi
05-18-2014, 05:29 AM
I'm curious if your research have gone any further then to the Tekpi and Sai Wikipedia entry, cause Sai/Chabang/Tekpi comes in different designs.

Here's a pair of Tekpi looking more similar to the Okinawan Sai from your Wikipedia image:
http://geligabunian.blogspot.no/2012/10/tekpi-bugis-dan-kerambit-melayu.html

And here is a photo of Taira Dojo in Okinawa, the Sai looks more akin to what you mean is a Tekpi.

http://www.karate-kobudo.co.nz/image/okinawa%202008%20011ab.jpg

So. The Sai, Tekpi and Tjabang is the same weapon, it's all about design and style.

This is also a Sai.

http://www.cidio.net/images/manji_sai.jpg
Called Manji Sai, due to the position of the prongs makes it resemble the Buddhist Manjj/Swastika symbol.


Ninja techniques don't include weapons that aren't used. The sword is so antique by the time the Ninja was operating that it is a obsolete weapon, it would be like modern Marines using Flint Lock guns.

And since we are onto Ninja Techniques and Shinobi No Jutsu, there is no such thing displayed in TMNT history, they are at best pop-culture Ninjas, based of fiction, movies and comic books. Not from real-life Shinobi.

The amount of research Eastman and Laird went into creating the turtles comes from Frank Miller's Daredevil stories and Frank Miller's Ronin.


I never said the tepki was not a sai. Of course they are all the same weapon but there are differences in style from where they originated. And, of course, those differences can travel through regions.

Now, i do find it strange that a few posts ago you were saying that Raph's sai are mostly depicted wrong but now apparently that "wrong" design does exist in Japan from this post. So i really dont know which side you are arguing for.

And if you are going to say that nothing in the turtles are real, it's all a comic book..... then why argue over what kind of swords is one turtle actually using? I mean, it's all fake, then. It's not a katana drawn wrong, it's an imaginary sword.

Candy Kappa
05-18-2014, 07:45 AM
I never said the tepki was not a sai. Of course they are all the same weapon but there are differences in style from where they originated. And, of course, those differences can travel through regions.

Now, i do find it strange that a few posts ago you were saying that Raph's sai are mostly depicted wrong but now apparently that "wrong" design does exist in Japan from this post. So i really dont know which side you are arguing for.

And if you are going to say that nothing in the turtles are real, it's all a comic book..... then why argue over what kind of swords is one turtle actually using? I mean, it's all fake, then. It's not a katana drawn wrong, it's an imaginary sword.

Okay. I see where you're going with the Sai Tekpi differences, and I want to clarify.

When I said that the Sai is for the most part depicted wrong in the TMNT franchise, I meant that the Sai usually is depicted like a full on dagger, where the middle tong is a dagger-like blade. So, it looks more like a stiletto. I did not mean the design of the outer tongs, so I apologize if I was misleading you on that regard.

It's the same kind of ignorance artists/writers have about martial arts weapons when it comes to depicting a katana being straight bladed. Be it ignorance from lack of research or laziness of drawing correctly. But, the good thing is that this have greatly improved.

GrapeSoda
05-18-2014, 11:21 AM
Dude does it all the time. Get used to it haha, it's probably out of insecurity or something. He'll go extra dorky on you about insignificant knowledge, or moot details about meaningless things in an attempt to prove you wrong or something.. He'll reply to this in a passive aggressive way too.

:lol:

You're just trolling. Stop!

You're not contributing to this topic in any way. And, newsflash, geeks like all of us know a lot of useless knowledge about a lot of random things that we find interesting.

fridaynightdestination
05-18-2014, 11:22 AM
The bamboo armor on Leonardo is a little over the top, I admit, but I'm OK with it. It isn't gonna ruin the whole movie for me.

Puddinpop
05-18-2014, 04:51 PM
The bamboo armor on Leonardo is a little over the top, I admit, but I'm OK with it. It isn't gonna ruin the whole movie for me.

Yea I didn't care for it at first either.. like I didn't care for Raphs mask going over his head like it does.. But it grew on me. I just wasn't used to it. I remember when I saw the new pictures of the turtles for the Nick cartoon and thought to myself.. Hmm not sure how that will play out.. but once I saw them in action.. their personalities and everything, I was pleasantly surprised. I love that new Nick toon.

Glados
05-19-2014, 06:51 AM
I actually dislike his shoulder guards more (despite the chest guard having even less of a practical function)! They just make him look like a football player, very top-heavy and un-elegant. They also would hinder arm movement, which is something I can't see Leo finding practical!

Hero
05-25-2014, 02:05 AM
Out of the loop a bit when it comes to forums :). I haven't seen this talked about anywhere else.

A France based ebay account has already listed TMNT Movie roleplay stuff (maybe the embargo date is different in Europe). An interesting note on 'this Donatello listing here' (http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Les-Tortues-Ninja-Role-Play-Set-Donatello-B-/151296370670?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_71&hash=item2339f767ee) shows what his staff will be like in the movie.

I quite like the extension idea there, as I find the thought of carrying around a 'broom handle' quite restrictive.

I will also be posting this listing link in a more relevant merchandise thread too.

pennydreadful
05-25-2014, 11:30 PM
I quite like the extension idea there, as I find the thought of carrying around a 'broom handle' quite restrictive.

I guess it does make sense that a retractable bo-staff would be easier travel-wise... I imagine in real life if you had one on your back you'd probably be knocking it on door frames all the time.

It just looks a bit unwieldy and clunky to me in general - I don't see how it could be particularly aerodynamic to try to use what looks like a pogo stick as a bo staff.

pennydreadful
05-25-2014, 11:37 PM
It looks as if it might extend at both ends, which would probably make it a bit more streamlined - but wouldn't you worry about the extendable bits snapping? I don't know; as I said previously, it's just a really bizarre choice and I'm struggling to wrap my head around it.

jestermon
05-26-2014, 12:29 AM
Also, turtles don't have visible sexual organs or butts, Bebop and Rocksteady would I am pretty sure every mutant had pants but the turtles, Slash, Joe Eyeball, that mutant bull thing in the cartoon.

Splinter didn't have pants but his areas were covered up.

Candy Kappa
05-26-2014, 01:45 AM
It looks as if it might extend at both ends, which would probably make it a bit more streamlined - but wouldn't you worry about the extendable bits snapping? I don't know; as I said previously, it's just a really bizarre choice and I'm struggling to wrap my head around it.

Yeah, a retractable real-life staff is for training only as using it as a striking tool would damage it. And Donnie being the tech wiz, it's nice to see him have what is often seen as a "simple stick" and wield that Bo masterfully.

To me, I don't think I can enjoy Donnie's combat moments seeing he isn't having a proper Bo, I love martial arts, and the Bo gotta be my second favorite weapon and seeing it being replaced by a practice tool and isn't made out of wood, kinda ruins the moment for me.

pennydreadful
05-26-2014, 03:40 AM
Yeah, a retractable real-life staff is for training only as using it as a striking tool would damage it. And Donnie being the tech wiz, it's nice to see him have what is often seen as a "simple stick" and wield that Bo masterfully.

To me, I don't think I can enjoy Donnie's combat moments seeing he isn't having a proper Bo, I love martial arts, and the Bo gotta be my second favorite weapon and seeing it being replaced by a practice tool and isn't made out of wood, kinda ruins the moment for me.

That's exactly right - I always enjoyed the dichotomy of Donnie having the simplest weapon. The beauty of the bo-staff is that it's sleek, elegant and effective.

I posted in the other thread discussing this (Movie 2014 merchandise) that I'm starting to think this is a combo bo-staff-something-else... it's the only thing that could really make any sense (though as to whether that's a good idea or not is a different conversation entirely.)

Puddinpop
05-31-2014, 04:13 PM
I think Mikey has two weapons himself. I saw a toy with him holding a three section weapon. It was yellow. You can see it in that picture of the Lair with Megan. I wonder what you call that kind of weapon.. anyone know?

Candy Kappa
05-31-2014, 04:17 PM
I think Mikey has two weapons himself. I saw a toy with him holding a three section weapon. It was yellow. You can see it in that picture of the Lair with Megan. I wonder what you call that kind of weapon.. anyone know?

The Japanese name of the three-section staff is Sansetsukon.

Although, basic 5 inch Mikey only comes 1 pair of nunchaku and a sansetsukon, a picture of the 12 inch Mikey had 2 pair, one similar yellow, while the other was dark brown. Could be a custom pice done by whoever owns that 12 inch figure.

Puddinpop
05-31-2014, 04:21 PM
The Japanese name of the three-section staff is Sansetsukon.

Although, basic 5 inch Mikey only comes 1 pair of nunchaku and a sansetsukon, a picture of the 12 inch Mikey had 2 pair, one similar yellow, while the other was dark brown. Could be a custom pice done by whoever owns that 12 inch figure.

Nice, Yea I get a little mixed up with the different toys.. but thanx for the name. So it's a Japanese weapon? Are all the Turtles weapons originally Japanese?

Candy Kappa
05-31-2014, 04:32 PM
The origins are very wiffy waffy, but the most popular theory is that the three-section staff originates from china, while the Sai originates from the Indian trisula, a trident weapon, and was allover Asia before it came to Okinawa.

Only the katana is originating from Japan, as it have a very unique way of forging. But all four main weapons plus the three-section staff have roots in Japanese martial arts history being imported from China.

But, what is most interesting is that the Sai and the nunchaku is an Okinawan thing, not Japanese per se. And the nunchaku was a weapon so poorly liked it has no traditional kata. :lol:

Puddinpop
05-31-2014, 04:40 PM
The origins are very wiffy waffy, but the most popular theory is that the three-section staff originates from china, while the Sai originates from the Indian trisula, a trident weapon, and was allover Asia before it came to Okinawa.

Only the katana is originating from Japan, as it have a very unique way of forging. But all four main weapons plus the three-section staff have roots in Japanese martial arts history being imported from China.

But, what is most interesting is that the Sai and the nunchaku is an Okinawan thing, not Japanese per se. And the nunchaku was a weapon so poorly liked it has no traditional kata. :lol:

That's interesting.. I'd love to learn how to use nunchaku the way I see some of these guys using them. It's crazy, but I'd probably give myself a black eye or two. I know a lot of people dislike this but I think it's kind of cool that Leo's swords are curved rather than straight. I wonder how quick he'll be with them.. they look like big ass katana's lol

rickwj324
05-31-2014, 04:56 PM
The origins are very wiffy waffy, but the most popular theory is that the three-section staff originates from china, while the Sai originates from the Indian trisula, a trident weapon, and was allover Asia before it came to Okinawa.

Only the katana is originating from Japan, as it have a very unique way of forging. But all four main weapons plus the three-section staff have roots in Japanese martial arts history being imported from China.

But, what is most interesting is that the Sai and the nunchaku is an Okinawan thing, not Japanese per se. And the nunchaku was a weapon so poorly liked it has no traditional kata. :lol:

CK.. your martial arts/weapons knowledge impresses me. I do find it interesting whenever you post these little tidbits of info. Thx!! --Rick

pennydreadful
05-31-2014, 05:00 PM
That's interesting.. I'd love to learn how to use nunchaku the way I see some of these guys using them. It's crazy, but I'd probably give myself a black eye or two.

Yeah, I imagine that if I ever picked up a pair, I'd do a pretty good re-enactment of April's nunchaku fail in SoTO. :lol:

Candy Kappa
05-31-2014, 05:02 PM
I fashioned myself a pair of nunchaku, as they are illegal to sell where I live (can buy foam rubber ones, but ther are no MA store in the city) and watching some how-to-do videos I tried to do the various moves you could do with them. I would often hit myself in the back head, groin and one time right on the nose. :lol:

I also prefer Leo's swords being correctly portrayed. One of the "Ninjato" myths are that the straight blades was cheaper, thus easier to dispose if the ninja as it necessary. But the truth is, the way Nihinto (Japanese swords) where forged, the curvature is a natural process, and is why Nihonto is curved past the 10th century. It would be more expensive to forcefully straighten the blade.

I do wish Leo would have a longsword and a short sword like he do have in the Nick cartoon. As that is the proper way to dual wield Japanese swords. But, equal length swords do often look better on an artistic standpoint.

I am curious if we'll see the turtles use more then just their signature weapons due to Mikey's sansetsukon. Maybe Raph can use a pair of jutte, which is like a Sai, only have one tong rather then two (Nick basic figure had a pair of those) and it would be cool to see Donnie use a Naginata or a yari. And I really wanna se some Shuriken use, something I feel the first trilogy lacked, they did some in the Imagi movie, but I'd love to see some actual Shuriken usage, especially Bo Shuriken as I've grown a bit tired of constantly seeing the hira Shuriken (star shape) or at least have different variations on the hira Shuriken.

And smoke bombs, although they use them in the Nick cartoon, their property is very fantastical in the show, acting more like a teleporter then a smoke screen. :lol: the Imagi movie had some great smoke bomb moments as it was treated more realistic despite being an animated movie.

I'd also love to see some actual Shinobi weaponry, like fire arrows or the grenades they made.

CK.. your martial arts/weapons knowledge impresses me. I do find it interesting whenever you post these little tidbits of info. Thx!! --Rick

Thank you. I try to learn as much as I can, particularly the weapons that are in my schools curriculum like the Bo, katana, wakishazi. But I also have a interest in the Sai, and I have been in a couple of discussions about it's depiction in pop-culture.

samxsteal
05-31-2014, 05:20 PM
I fashioned myself a pair of nunchaku, as they are illegal to sell where I live (can buy foam rubber ones, but ther are no MA store in the city) and watching some how-to-do videos I tried to do the various moves you could do with them. I would often hit myself in the back head, groin and one time right on the nose. :lol:

I also prefer Leo's swords being correctly portrayed. One of the "Ninjato" myths are that the straight blades was cheaper, thus easier to dispose if the ninja as it necessary. But the truth is, the way Nihinto (Japanese swords) where forged, the curvature is a natural process, and is why Nihonto is curved past the 10th century. It would be more expensive to forcefully straighten the blade.

I do wish Leo would have a longsword and a short sword like he do have in the Nick cartoon. As that is the proper way to dual wield Japanese swords. But, equal length swords do often look better on an artistic standpoint.

I am curious if we'll see the turtles use more then just their signature weapons due to Mikey's sansetsukon. Maybe Raph can use a pair of jutte, which is like a Sai, only have one tong rather then two (Nick basic figure had a pair of those) and it would be cool to see Donnie use a Naginata or a yari. And I really wanna se some Shuriken use, something I feel the first trilogy lacked, they did some in the Imagi movie, but I'd love to see some actual Shuriken usage, especially Bo Shuriken as I've grown a bit tired of constantly seeing the hira Shuriken (star shape) or at least have different variations on the hira Shuriken.

And smoke bombs, although they use them in the Nick cartoon, their property is very fantastical in the show, acting more like a teleporter then a smoke screen. :lol: the Imagi movie had some great smoke bomb moments as it was treated more realistic despite being an animated movie.

I'd also love to see some actual Shinobi weaponry, like fire arrows or the grenades they made.



Thank you. I try to learn as much as I can, particularly the weapons that are in my schools curriculum like the Bo, katana, wakishazi. But I also have a interest in the Sai, and I have been in a couple of discussions about it's depiction in pop-culture. What got me started with Nunchaku was a pair of cheapy Foam ones from an arcade, that i retro fitted with wood dowels and thin para-cord,

I have since made my own wood one bought a pair of pro chucks, and then Acquired Really heavy wood nunchaku, as well as ordering chained foam practice par I can do several tricks i need to practice with my left hand more. .

And to Get Iaito to practice.

Candy Kappa
05-31-2014, 05:29 PM
I love doing iai kata, been a long while though. The school have changed practicing hours to a time where I most often work, which makes me unable to fully join the training full on. And I don't own a iaito, as it was too rich for my blood when I was active.

I do own a crappy wall hanger sword that I used when I practiced at home, but the scabbard is broken in half, cause it's a $100 sword. I bought it years ago when I first got my own bank account card, which must have been 10-15 years ago. Unbalanced and just bad :lol: but for sheathing practice it did the job well enough.

I have been oogling at some iaitos at bugei.com, I might be able to save some and finally get me a proper training sword.

Puddinpop
06-01-2014, 03:24 AM
Yeah, I imagine that if I ever picked up a pair, I'd do a pretty good re-enactment of April's nunchaku fail in SoTO. :lol:

Yep :lol: you and me both. I've tried with plastic ones a few years ago and I got carried away..

pennydreadful
06-01-2014, 11:35 PM
Yep :lol: you and me both. I've tried with plastic ones a few years ago and I got carried away..

Totes - I envy anyone who has the grace and physical coordination to do any type of martial art (or dancing for that matter).

I move with all of the finesse of drunken flamingo - and that's on a good day. :lol:

Netkeeper
06-02-2014, 02:04 AM
I'm in the process of learning nunchaku myself. My father made me a pair from a broomstick. (http://24.media.tumblr.com/94fdc110d34df87ad26c194b18c49bf7/tumblr_mylv8agwEb1t33le8o1_500.jpg) He learned how to use them like 30 or 40 years ago and now he's teaching me.

So far I haven't done anything too damaging, but one time I went to a friend's for a few days and showed off for her and her roommates, then came back and as soon as I jumped into the shower I noticed I had some DARK ****in bruises on my hips. I don't actually remember hitting myself there, but apparently it happened.

My dad has some STORIES, though. He didn't use anything other than homemade wooden chucks for years, and the first time he picked up a foam rubber pair attached by a swivel chain in a martial arts shop the chain was longer than the cords he was used to, so when he tried to show off with them, he missed a catch and ended up hitting himself in the eyes which shattered his glasses. He had glass shards in his eyes.

HE CONTINUED TO USE THEM AFTER THAT.

He also had a pair he made from hollow airplane ladder pegs [he used to work on planes in the air force] and whenever he swung them they whistled. Currently he's got a pair he made from aluminium that he once broke a beer bottle with; when he was showing them off for a friend, the dumbass decided to toss his empty bottle at him and he shattered it. They've even got a dent to prove it.

And he told me that when he was still learning, every single house he lived in had to have the ceiling re-painted when he moved out because his chucks would make marks on the ceiling. It's what happens when you paint them yourself.

Candy Kappa
06-02-2014, 02:18 AM
And he told me that when he was still learning, every single house he lived in had to have the ceiling re-painted when he moved out because his chucks would make marks on the ceiling. It's what happens when you paint them yourself.

I managed one time getting my katana stuck in the roof, a good inch had pierced the thin wood. When I let go of the handle, the blade was hanging still on its own :lol:

pennydreadful
06-02-2014, 03:41 AM
My dad has some STORIES, though. He didn't use anything other than homemade wooden chucks for years, and the first time he picked up a foam rubber pair attached by a swivel chain in a martial arts shop the chain was longer than the cords he was used to, so when he tried to show off with them, he missed a catch and ended up hitting himself in the eyes which shattered his glasses. He had glass shards in his eyes.

HE CONTINUED TO USE THEM AFTER THAT.

He also had a pair he made from hollow airplane ladder pegs [he used to work on planes in the air force] and whenever he swung them they whistled. Currently he's got a pair he made from aluminium that he once broke a beer bottle with; when he was showing them off for a friend, the dumbass decided to toss his empty bottle at him and he shattered it. They've even got a dent to prove it.

And he told me that when he was still learning, every single house he lived in had to have the ceiling re-painted when he moved out because his chucks would make marks on the ceiling. It's what happens when you paint them yourself.

Netkeeper, I'm now half-convinced that your father is actually Chuck Norris! :D

I managed one time getting my katana stuck in the roof, a good inch had pierced the thin wood. When I let go of the handle, the blade was hanging still on its own :lol:

Dang, I think there needs to be a thread for martial-arts related mishaps - I bet some of you have some hilarious stories.

Puddinpop
06-02-2014, 03:55 AM
Totes - I envy anyone who has the grace and physical coordination to do any type of martial art (or dancing for that matter).

I move with all of the finesse of drunken flamingo - and that's on a good day. :lol:

Lmao I'm with you on that.. i used to be into karate when i was younger but as i got older i got into different things.. like playing music and cooking. My two biggest passions beside our green friends here lol. I wish I could fight like some of these martial artist. I admire them.

I keep watching this video of Splinters double and it amazes me that he doesn't smash his own face in lol. It is soo badass
/D6wjGL2NgoQ

pennydreadful
06-02-2014, 05:08 AM
Lmao I'm with you on that.. i used to be into karate when i was younger but as i got older i got into different things.. like playing music and cooking. My two biggest passions beside our green friends here lol. I wish I could fight like some of these martial artist. I admire them.

I keep watching this video of Splinters double and it amazes me that he doesn't smash his own face in lol. It is soo badass

Agreed, some of the stunt videos on here rock tits. Though my most-watched video is the TMNT Style one that was posted here a while back. I keep re-watching it and re-watching it...

http://img.pandawhale.com/8204-cm820404fcfd07280bc5gif-P4qO.gif

... and wish desperately that I had a tenth of that coolness, but then realise that it'd require me doing exercise - and I'm way too lazy for that. :lol:

gettinshell
06-02-2014, 10:04 AM
Lmao I'm with you on that.. i used to be into karate when i was younger but as i got older i got into different things.. like playing music and cooking. My two biggest passions beside our green friends here lol. I wish I could fight like some of these martial artist. I admire them.

I keep watching this video of Splinters double and it amazes me that he doesn't smash his own face in lol. It is soo badass
/D6wjGL2NgoQ

I was watching that clip and thinking how sick it would be to see someone try and mug that guy :tcool:

samxsteal
06-02-2014, 03:23 PM
Agreed, some of the stunt videos on here rock tits. Though my most-watched video is the TMNT Style one that was posted here a while back. I keep re-watching it and re-watching it...

http://img.pandawhale.com/8204-cm820404fcfd07280bc5gif-P4qO.gif

... and wish desperately that I had a tenth of that coolness, but then realise that it'd require me doing exercise - and I'm way too lazy for that. :lol:
The funny part is the guy who plays leo in the styles video is a stunt man in this movie which is amazing people have so little faith that the ignore that lol People saw that video and freaked out "i want this movie" " i want this kind of action in the new movie" well him and a bunch of other GREAT martial artist are in the this movie.

The stunt and Choreography team along with there whole second unit teams Should be enough to put some people worries aside, But nope

Glados
06-02-2014, 03:54 PM
The funny part is the guy who plays leo in the styles video is a stunt man in this movie which is amazing people have so little faith that the ignore that lol People saw that video and freaked out "i want this movie" " i want this kind of action in the new movie" well him and a bunch of other GREAT martial artist are in the this movie.

The stunt and Choreography team along with there whole second unit teams Should be enough to put some people worries aside, But nope

What it really depends on is how well they utilize the talents they have gotten on board. For everyone's expectations sake I really, really hope the next trailer will show us some martial arts, it would put some of my own worries to rest. I don't ask for much, just a few glimpses of actual ninja action, pretty please... Fingers crossed that it can deliver that.

samxsteal
06-02-2014, 04:33 PM
What it really depends on is how well they utilize the talents they have gotten on board. For everyone's expectations sake I really, really hope the next trailer will show us some martial arts, it would put some of my own worries to rest. I don't ask for much, just a few glimpses of actual ninja action, pretty please... Fingers crossed that it can deliver that.

i 0do to if only to calm others im mostly sold and i would like and love to see more but if this was all i have sen i would still go see it i dont like spoiler trailers lol But im to "gullible" to not watch them lol

kolaida
06-05-2014, 09:41 PM
The person who said that Mikey is wearing a wet suit with if half way down made my day! I laughed and laughed! Now, that does seem like Mikey. I think people express themselves different ways. In my teens, I didn't use my clothes for expression, but knew others who did. Anyway, I really like that wetsuit thing, it makes me giggly lol