View Full Version : IDW finally plans collections of Michael Zulli's TMNT work
John Pannozzi
05-19-2014, 01:46 PM
This will make several people on this forum very happy. (http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-Legends/dp/1631400517/ref=sr_1_3?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1400525029&sr=1-3&keywords=idw+publishing)
CyberCubed
05-19-2014, 01:48 PM
This is great, the only problem is its going to be colored. I'm not sure Zulli's art will have the same impact in color.
Redrumh2o
05-19-2014, 04:10 PM
hmmm....hardcover too!
CyberCubed
05-19-2014, 04:13 PM
This is part of a new "TMNT Legends" line...I'm not sure what the point of this is. Most of Volume 1 was already in the Classics and the only ones that aren't are Veitch's stuff or what they don't have the rights to.
IDW is creating too many confusing lines of collections. We have the Ultimate Collections, the Classics collections, the Tales of the TMNT collections, and now Legends? This is on top of the Archie and IDW trades.
I mean Volume 2 is already in the Classics collection #8...so what else can be part of Legends?
Sewer Sirens Podcast
05-19-2014, 04:14 PM
Not sure if I want this, since when they skipped over these issues in Classics, I just bought the individual comics.
Also, the 'Splinter in the Eyes of God' short story was included in the classics books, correct? Were the other two short stories?
rickwj324
05-19-2014, 04:16 PM
This is part of a new "TMNT Legends" line...I'm not sure what the point of this is. Most of Volume 1 was already in the Classics and the only ones that aren't are Veitch's stuff or what they don't have the rights to.
IDW is creating too many confusing lines of collections. We have the Ultimate Collections, the Classics collections, the Tales of the TMNT collections, and now Legends? This is on top of the Archie and IDW trades.
I mean Volume 2 is already in the Classics collection #8...so what else can be part of Legends?
AGREED! I'm trying to get back into reading Mirage books, but I'm overwhelmed by all of these "collections". I've tried to sort them all out..figure out what I need to buy in order to complete a run of the Mirage stuff in order. However, so far I've gotten frustrated and haven't ordered any of them.
CyberCubed
05-19-2014, 04:24 PM
AGREED! I'm trying to get back into reading Mirage books, but I'm overwhelmed by all of these "collections". I've tried to sort them all out..figure out what I need to buy in order to complete a run of the Mirage stuff in order. However, so far I've gotten frustrated and haven't ordered any of them.
To help you out:
- Ultimate Collections #1-5 collect all the major Peter/Kevin issues of Volume 1.
- TMNT Classics collect all the other Volume 1 issues not in the Ultimate Collections, the "filler issues" so to speak. However Classics #8 begins collecting Volume 2 of Mirage, which was the next major comic series.
- Tales of the TMNT collections collect exactly what the title suggest. The first 7 issues were collected in Tales #1-2, and Tales #3 begins collecting issues from the 2004 Tales series and onward.
- TMNT Legends collects Soul's Winter so far.
And then other than that there are the Archie TMNT Adventure collections and the IDW collections of the current series.
rickwj324
05-19-2014, 04:34 PM
To help you out:
- Ultimate Collections #1-5 collect all the major Peter/Kevin issues of Volume 1.
- TMNT Classics collect all the other Volume 1 issues not in the Ultimate Collections, the "filler issues" so to speak. However Classics #8 begins collecting Volume 2 of Mirage, which was the next major comic series.
- Tales of the TMNT collections collect exactly what the title suggest. The first 7 issues were collected in Tales #1-2, and Tales #3 begins collecting issues from the 2004 Tales series and onward.
- TMNT Legends collects Soul's Winter so far.
And then other than that there are the Archie TMNT Adventure collections and the IDW collections of the current series.
Thanks for that CC!! That is actually quite helpful! So I pretty much need to pick up all the Ultimate HC's (which I planned on doing anyway). I wasn't sure what the "TMNT Classics" were, so thanks for clarifying that. So they pretty much cover the holes left in the Ultimate books?! Why were the holes there to start with if they were able to produce them in the "classics" books?? :lol:
I get what the "Tales of" books are. I have no idea what "Legends" is or what "Soul's Winter" is. :(
So... with these current collections it's possible to get MOST if not all of the Vol 1 mirage stuff, right? Are they going to be collecting all of Vol 2? Vol 3 would be the Image stuff, right? Then there was another line after Image?! I know nothing of that series.
I may get the Archie collections later. I have all of the IDW books (which I'm enjoying immensely and is one of the reasons I want to go back and collect all the Mirage stuff). I collected mirage books back in the late 80's and early 90's but got rid of them ages ago.
Thanks Amigo! I appreciate the info!! :tgrin:
John Pannozzi
05-19-2014, 05:41 PM
This is part of a new "TMNT Legends" line...I'm not sure what the point of this is. Most of Volume 1 was already in the Classics and the only ones that aren't are Veitch's stuff or what they don't have the rights to.
IDW is creating too many confusing lines of collections. We have the Ultimate Collections, the Classics collections, the Tales of the TMNT collections, and now Legends? This is on top of the Archie and IDW trades.
I mean Volume 2 is already in the Classics collection #8...so what else can be part of Legends?
Maybe some of the other one shots and minis, like the solo turtle minis, the guest creator specials, Challenges, Bodycount, and possibly random non-Mirage TMNT stuff (like the story from CBS Action Zone and the Playmates pack-in comics).
CyberCubed
05-19-2014, 05:51 PM
Hm good point. Perhaps we'll see the Turtle Soup specials as part of the Legends line, as well as the crossovers and stuff.
Sewer Sirens Podcast
05-19-2014, 06:00 PM
Thanks for that CC!! That is actually quite helpful! So I pretty much need to pick up all the Ultimate HC's (which I planned on doing anyway). I wasn't sure what the "TMNT Classics" were, so thanks for clarifying that. So they pretty much cover the holes left in the Ultimate books?! Why were the holes there to start with if they were able to produce them in the "classics" books?? :lol:
I get what the "Tales of" books are. I have no idea what "Legends" is or what "Soul's Winter" is. :(
So... with these current collections it's possible to get MOST if not all of the Vol 1 mirage stuff, right? Are they going to be collecting all of Vol 2? Vol 3 would be the Image stuff, right? Then there was another line after Image?! I know nothing of that series.
I may get the Archie collections later. I have all of the IDW books (which I'm enjoying immensely and is one of the reasons I want to go back and collect all the Mirage stuff). I collected mirage books back in the late 80's and early 90's but got rid of them ages ago.
Correct. Most of Volume 1 of Mirage are either in the Ultimate Collections or Classics 1 - 7. The issues that are missing from those (according to the records I've kept) are 24 - 26 (The River), 31, 35, 36 (Soul's Winter arc), and 41 (miscellaneous guest issue, Turtle Dreams [I believe]). I got all those (except The River) from Mirage's site: http://www.miragelicensing.com/html/catalog.html
I got my 'The River' issues from eBay. They were sort of hard to track down, but they were well worth it. Really love that arc. As for the Soul's Winter arc ... eh, it was okay. It's definitely a different take on the turtles (as a lot of the guest issues were, but this was even more so). Same goes for Turtle Dreams (that it's only okay). However, Soul's Winter and Turtle Dreams were a lot better than some other guest issues that were collected in Classics.
What is 'Legends'? Along with you, I have no clue. Don't get why they didn't include this with the 'Classics' line earlier, and what they plan on collecting in this 'Legends' line down the road.
From what I gather, they plan on releasing all of Volume 2, because why start it and not finish it? Volume 2 starts in 'Classics: Volume 8', which includes the first five issues. Haven't seen anything about Volume 9 yet, but since these Classics paperbacks release a few months apart, and Volume 8 isn't even out yet, I wouldn't worry.
Volume Three is the Image issues, correct. However, once Mirage started their comics back up again, Peter said the Image issues were basically non-canon. That's where Tales of the TMNT (Volume 2) come in. Some of those issues filled in the gap between Volume 2 of the ongoing Mirage and Volume 4 (it was still called Volume 4 even though they said Image was non-canon). Tales of the TMNT (Volume 2) basically jumps all over in turtles history. Each issue was usually a stand alone issue. It skipped around from before the turtles were created to the turtles in their old age! Although I haven't read them yet, I've heard their great. You can start collecting those in the Tales of the TMNT paperbacks from volume 3 onward. The first two volumes have tie-in issues with the original Volume One early Mirage stuff. Also, I'm not sure if the Image run will ever be printed by IDW (not sure if they have the rights).
Then we have Volume 4 (which I haven't heard any plans of printing, but that's understandable since their still working on Volume 2). This takes place (15 years?) later after Volume 2, and I've also heard highly of this Volume. The rights of TMNT went over to Nickelodeon while this was printing, so it never got a proper finish. However, Peter Laird has released issue 31 (which was never printed) on his blog, and issue 32 just got printed recently (Peter and team have put it out after a few years, since Viacom still let's them print a certain amount of comics per year).
Hopefully that answers some of your questions. If you have any more, just let me know. Nice to see more people getting into these.
This makes me happy, since i'm just starting out on the Mirage run and don't want to miss any of it.
CyberCubed
05-19-2014, 06:05 PM
I'm pretty sure IDW will collect Image after Volume 2 ends.
Sewer Sirens Podcast
05-19-2014, 06:07 PM
I'm pretty sure IDW will collect Image after Volume 2 ends.
Do we know if they have the rights?
rickwj324
05-19-2014, 06:07 PM
I'm pretty sure IDW will collect Image after Volume 2 ends.
So they are doing Vol 2? As for the Image collection, I do hope they collect it although from what little I know of the Image run it kind of scares me a bit!!! :tlol:
CyberCubed
05-19-2014, 06:09 PM
Do we know if they have the rights?
They already said they do. Mirage owned the Image stories and Bobby was asked and they said they do. The only complications might be the issues where some Image characters crossedover like Savage Dragon, but I'm pretty sure I read Erik Larsen say he would allow IDW to reprint the issues with the Image characters in them too.
Sewer Sirens Podcast
05-19-2014, 06:10 PM
So they are doing Vol 2? As for the Image collection, I do hope they collect it although from what little I know of the Image run it kind of scares me a bit!!! :tlol:
Yes. They have started collecting Volume 2 in the Classics line, in Volume 8. This came/comes out this month.
rickwj324
05-19-2014, 06:18 PM
They already said they do. Mirage owned the Image stories and Bobby was asked and they said they do. The only complications might be the issues where some Image characters crossedover like Savage Dragon, but I'm pretty sure I read Erik Larsen say he would allow IDW to reprint the issues with the Image characters in them too.
Yes. They have started collecting Volume 2 in the Classics line, in Volume 8. This came/comes out this month.
Sweet and Sweet! ;)
Sewer Sirens Podcast
05-19-2014, 06:56 PM
Maybe some of the other one shots and minis, like the solo turtle minis, the guest creator specials, Challenges, Bodycount, and possibly random non-Mirage TMNT stuff (like the story from CBS Action Zone and the Playmates pack-in comics).
Hm good point. Perhaps we'll see the Turtle Soup specials as part of the Legends line, as well as the crossovers and stuff.
Hmm ... then maybe I will want to order these. I'll probably just wait 'til the price goes down though, unlike Classics, Tales of the TMNT, and the ongoing IDW story.
They already said they do. Mirage owned the Image stories and Bobby was asked and they said they do. The only complications might be the issues where some Image characters crossedover like Savage Dragon, but I'm pretty sure I read Erik Larsen say he would allow IDW to reprint the issues with the Image characters in them too.
Okay, sweet! Then, yeah, they'll probably collect those after Volume 2, except they may start a whole NOTHER line to collect them in. Not sure if they'd put them in Classics.
CyberCubed
05-19-2014, 07:07 PM
I thought Volume 2 would have its own collections, but since they put it under classics, I guess Image and Volume 4 will be under there too.
I'm honestly surprised IDW is starting this Legends line, because as said it can get very confusing.
Powder
05-19-2014, 08:56 PM
Uuuuuugh why must they color it? I'd buy it otherwise.
Cool they've finally got around to the Zulli stuff but I agree opening up another book line is getting quite crowded for how many TMNT book lines does IDW need? Without us veteran Dromers other fans with less knowledge wouldn't be able to know what to buy and what order, etc.
Wasn't thrilled IDW still thought they needed to recolor TMNT Classics Book 8. TMNT Vol. 2 run was already in color.
CyberCubed
05-19-2014, 09:21 PM
Uuuuuugh why must they color it? I'd buy it otherwise.
Because of casuals.
Cool they've finally got around to the Zulli stuff but I agree opening up another book line is getting quite crowded for how many TMNT book lines does IDW need? Without us veteran Dromers other fans with less knowledge wouldn't be able to know what to buy and what order, etc.
Wasn't thrilled IDW still thought they needed to recolor TMNT Classics Book 8. TMNT Vol. 2 run was already in color.
Did they really re-color Volume 2? I looked at the preview pages on Amazon and they looked the same to me.
I think they did. Maybe I'm wrong. Does anyone remember who colored the original issues (Oops just looked at Mirages site for issue credits). Its states who colored them. It lists names. The IDW Book Classics Vol. 8 trade states a "digital whoever" company as the colorists. So I think for sure it was recolored.
To help you out:
- Ultimate Collections #1-5 collect all the major Peter/Kevin issues of Volume 1.
- TMNT Classics collect all the other Volume 1 issues not in the Ultimate Collections, the "filler issues" so to speak. However Classics #8 begins collecting Volume 2 of Mirage, which was the next major comic series.
- Tales of the TMNT collections collect exactly what the title suggest. The first 7 issues were collected in Tales #1-2, and Tales #3 begins collecting issues from the 2004 Tales series and onward.
- TMNT Legends collects Soul's Winter so far.
And then other than that there are the Archie TMNT Adventure collections and the IDW collections of the current series.
Are there something that collects the 'Colored Classics' series too? I mean those issues have a TPB too, or maybe they not?
It's kinda wierd to have one half of the series in B&W and the other half in color. Or does the Classics TPBs (the fillerish ones) have B&W versions too?
I'm kinda confused with all this...
Btw, the Soul Winter re-release is epic stuff, I'm actually quiet curious about how they'll look in color. :)
Oh, and v2 recolored? Weird. They should rather focus on releasing B&W issues correctly, with no toning missing.
Does the Archie TPBs have color btw?
DrSpengler
05-20-2014, 07:52 AM
Are there something that collects the 'Colored Classics' series too? I mean those issues have a TPB too, or maybe they not?
TMNT The Works (http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-Works/dp/161377625X/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1400590256&sr=1-1&keywords=tmnt+the+works)
This one collects the Color Classics series.
Does the Archie TPBs have color btw?
Yep.
Plasticplayhouse
05-20-2014, 07:59 AM
i'm curious to see it in color, but i'm not promising i'd buy it. if it was b&w...i'd get it for sure!
TMNT The Works (http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-Works/dp/161377625X/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1400590256&sr=1-1&keywords=tmnt+the+works)
Oh, cool! Thanks! :)
So it's 5 different TPB series for mirage... :trolleye:
The Fifth Turtle
05-20-2014, 11:50 AM
Why a new line? Why not make it classics vol 9? Ugh that's dumb. Anyone know if they will also slap the classics label on this as well?
Heather Breckel
05-20-2014, 11:58 AM
I'm interested in seeing what it's going to look like in color! That story was pretty tone heavy.
Sewer Sirens Podcast
05-20-2014, 12:22 PM
Why a new line? Why not make it classics vol 9? Ugh that's dumb. Anyone know if they will also slap the classics label on this as well?
I think the reason they didn't want to make it Classics 9 is because they're in the middle of Mirage Volume 2 right now. They should've put this out, in the classics line, earlier.
CyberCubed
05-20-2014, 01:03 PM
I think the reason they didn't want to make it Classics 9 is because they're in the middle of Mirage Volume 2 right now. They should've put this out, in the classics line, earlier.
That and I think the Turtle soups and various Mirage specials will be collected under this Legends line.
Sewer Sirens Podcast
05-20-2014, 02:16 PM
That and I think the Turtle soups and various Mirage specials will be collected under this Legends line.
Not sure why they can't just collect those all in the Classics line. :ohwell:
Cipher
05-20-2014, 07:08 PM
Yes! Very excited.
Also, while I'm not big on adding yet another confusing subline to the reprints, I'm intrigued by the "Legends" moniker and the implication that it might be used for themed content/creator collections, which is something I've been hoping for for a very long time.
CyberCubed
05-20-2014, 07:14 PM
Yes! Very excited.
Also, while I'm not big on adding yet another confusing subline to the reprints, I'm intrigued by the "Legends" moniker and the implication that it might be used for themed content/creator collections, which is something I've been hoping for for a very long time.
I'd rather they not reprint stuff already seen in the other collections. I mean we already have the Colored Classics reprinted from the Ultimate Collections.
More likely we're going to see the Mirage specials like the Turtle Soups, Haunted Pizza, crossovers with Flaming Carrot and Savage Dragon, the Casey Jones North by Downeast, Bodycount, and other various specials collected under the "Legends" label.
Matches Malone
05-20-2014, 07:26 PM
Yes! Very excited.
Also, while I'm not big on adding yet another confusing subline to the reprints, I'm intrigued by the "Legends" moniker and the implication that it might be used for themed content/creator collections, which is something I've been hoping for for a very long time.
Same. Even if colored, I would finally start buying some of these IDW reprints if they start doing this.
I'd rather they not reprint stuff already seen in the other collections. I mean we already have the Colored Classics reprinted from the Ultimate Collections.
More likely we're going to see the Mirage specials like the Turtle Soups, Haunted Pizza, crossovers with Flaming Carrot and Savage Dragon, the Casey Jones North by Downeast, Bodycount, and other various specials collected under the "Legends" label.
In the Amazon description of the Legends line, it states it will collect seminal storylines, so various obscure periphery titles and crossovers don't really fit the bill. In all likelihood IDW hasn't completely figured out what they plan to use with this line, but Cipher's conjecture is definitely possible. Double (not to mention triple/quadruple/etc) dipping is easily in IDW's nature. Hopefully those specials do get collected in some form eventually though. The Classics collected a few shorts from Shell Shocked for padding in the first volume but none since as far as I know. Kind of sloppy, to be honest.
I still hate how IDW does these TMNT book lines. I mean I can't even just get "RTNY" as a color trade/single book. Its "the Works" book 2 or whatever with the Eastman & Laird issues that I don't hold as seminal to that arc. Same with "City at War". Even a black and white trade for the latter would be good. I mean they did such b&w tomes for John Byrnes Next Men. TMNT Vol. 2 and Vol. 3 as single trades would be good too. By the time IDW gets to Vol. 4 they'll color that too I gather. Where this latter series benefits to be in trades due to the story line structure. Thats just me though. I still haven't bought a single TMNT IDW compilation at all. Maybe when the Ultimate Collections or the colored "The Works" line goes to trades? Sure am hoping. I just hate HC's.
CyberCubed
05-20-2014, 08:27 PM
The Classics collected a few shorts from Shell Shocked for padding in the first volume but none since as far as I know. Kind of sloppy, to be honest.
Uh, what? More of the Shell Shocked stories were collected in the following Classics issues. I don't think they did all of them but they covered much more of them in Classics 5-7.
Matches Malone
05-20-2014, 09:16 PM
Uh, what? More of the Shell Shocked stories were collected in the following Classics issues. I don't think they did all of them but they covered much more of them in Classics 5-7.
Um, yeah, I stopped paying attention after the first couple, so my bad. Though I did have the qualifier "as far as I know."
The Fifth Turtle
05-21-2014, 07:09 AM
I'd rather they not reprint stuff already seen in the other collections. I mean we already have the Colored Classics reprinted from the Ultimate Collections.
More likely we're going to see the Mirage specials like the Turtle Soups, Haunted Pizza, crossovers with Flaming Carrot and Savage Dragon, the Casey Jones North by Downeast, Bodycount, and other various specials collected under the "Legends" label.
This I can get on board with. I want to see everything get collected eventually.......we can all dream right?
Wait... So, the Classics line collection issues were already released in B&W via Ultimate Collections? If that's the case, we might get another Ultimate from the Legends line in B&W. Would be coo :)
CyberCubed
05-21-2014, 08:18 AM
^ What? None of the Classics issues were in the Ultimate Collections.
Ah okay, I was mixed up something. Tho they should definitely do that... I mean releasing other Mirage stuff as B&W Ultimate Collections.
Warboss74
05-21-2014, 09:33 PM
I would venture to guess we get things like Return to New York, City at War, etc. in the Legends line. Maybe there's a chance we get The River arc in this line.
CyberCubed
05-21-2014, 09:44 PM
I would venture to guess we get things like Return to New York, City at War, etc. in the Legends line. Maybe there's a chance we get The River arc in this line.
Why would they do that? If they colorize those issues they would be part of, "The Works" collections where the other colored Ultimate Collection issues are.
Warboss74
05-22-2014, 05:47 AM
Why would they do that? If they colorize those issues they would be part of, "The Works" collections where the other colored Ultimate Collection issues are. I'm just thinking about what the description of the line might entail. It's not going to be just Zulli and potentially Veitch stuff. It might just be a way to recollect the guest era issues by author that wrote multiple issues in hardcover.
CyberCubed
05-22-2014, 08:05 AM
I'm just thinking about what the description of the line might entail. It's not going to be just Zulli and potentially Veitch stuff. It might just be a way to recollect the guest era issues by author that wrote multiple issues in hardcover.
But if that was going to happen those earlier guest issues wouldn't have been in the classics.
Warboss74
05-22-2014, 09:06 AM
But if that was going to happen those earlier guest issues wouldn't have been in the classics.
I think it's fairly clear that they're double dipping with this line. I doubt the classics are going to see hardcover printing because of that.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.