View Full Version : The strangeness of IDW #21
Rooish
06-05-2014, 10:54 AM
Does anyone wonder if we will ever have a follow up on IDW #21, the one where Eastman did the art and Splinter acted like a weird little troll, testing his sons? It seemed a bit out of character / out of place in the IDW world, and I wonder if there were any emotional repercussions, such as the Turtles feeling a little betrayed by Splinter. Otherwise it feels like a bit of a filler/breather issue, which is totally okay, but I just think it felt out of place! What do you think?
Technogeek29
06-05-2014, 11:01 AM
Well Splinter/Yoshi was an assassin, I imagine he would have to go into espionage and pretend to be somebody else in order to get close to his targets. Him acting like a different persona is probably something he and a lot of Foot Ninja's can do naturally.
That's just my theory anyway.
Joey Kamikaze
06-05-2014, 04:14 PM
It felt more Mirage-y than IDW-y to me (same goes for the 2012 annual), but I liked it. I don't get any sense of betrayal, it's just a father teaching his sons. And it fits thematically where it goes in continuity, serving as a family-orientated prologue to "City Fall."
***First of Two Latin Kings***
06-05-2014, 04:27 PM
To me it made sense. If they stand a chance against him, they'll stand a chance against Shredder. He had to take on that other personality because if they figured out it was him, the test would be ruined.
Powder
06-05-2014, 05:32 PM
It felt more Mirage-y than IDW-y to me (same goes for the 2012 annual), but I liked it. I don't get any sense of betrayal, it's just a father teaching his sons. And it fits thematically where it goes in continuity, serving as a family-orientated prologue to "City Fall."
This. But I suppose I feel that way of virtually all that KE has contributed as of late. His style is synonymous with the old stuff. I love his work of course, but I wish he'd do something to make a distinction between the IDW & Mirage turtles when he draws 'em.
slingtheory
06-05-2014, 06:42 PM
doesn't really need a follow up I think. I can't see the turtles holding any grudge for it. Like others have said It was just splinter teaching his sons a a lesson. kind of a be ready for anything /learn to adapt kind of thing and I think they got it
AquaParade
06-05-2014, 09:39 PM
This. But I suppose I feel that way of virtually all that KE has contributed as of late. His style is synonymous with the old stuff. I love his work of course, but I wish he'd do something to make a distinction between the IDW & Mirage turtles when he draws 'em.
I can understand that desire but I love that the mirage spirit haunts the idw series in such a way. Eastman's turtles should always carry that distinguised look because it keeps the torch lit, if ya know what I mean.
Powder
06-05-2014, 09:45 PM
I can understand that desire but I love that the mirage spirit haunts the idw series in such a way. Eastman's turtles should always carry that distinguised look because it keeps the torch lit, if ya know what I mean.
Eh, I don't agree. If anything, this book (or its Mirage-crazy followers, at least) gets haunted by the ghost of the Fred Wolf series. :trazz: Eastman's turtles are super gritty, I can't see them as being the usually more smooth IDW turtles. If he just gave them wraps instead of pads, maybe some pupils, it'd make a world of difference.
Rooish
06-05-2014, 11:30 PM
Also do you really want KE to adjust his style and bring in a cucumber headed Don?
Cipher
06-05-2014, 11:49 PM
I could actually go for IDW mandating a little more design consistency, yeah.
I've written about this before, but the current approach of just "Whatever!" makes it difficult to tell what's just artistic indulgence and what's supposed to have in-story weight, often making no distinction between the two until an element happens to stick around.
Powder
06-06-2014, 12:03 AM
Also do you really want KE to adjust his style and bring in a cucumber headed Don?
Hahaha, noooo. No bean-shaped domes, please. But making things a little less angular and super detailed would help his work mesh better with this universe, I think. & using some of the accessories or design aesthetics the main artists came up with might help.
I could actually go for IDW mandating a little more design consistency, yeah.
I've written about this before, but the current approach of just "Whatever!" makes it difficult to tell what's just artistic indulgence and what's supposed to have in-story weight, often making no distinction between the two until an element happens to stick around.
I don't think it's made much of a difference, for the most part. It makes sense to me that the turtles would often change their wraps & gear, things get dirty/worn/bloody, and there may be a tiny bit of that 'ol 'teens like to express themselves' mindset. Stuff like Mateus' old bandanas were problematic in the way you describe, but they've since been taken out. Other than that I can't recall any jarring changes between different artists' takes as far as the overall look is concerned. I don't think we're gonna see someone give April long hair out of the blue or anything. Bobby & the gang stay on top of stuff that would mess up continuity or confuse readers.
...Well, there is the fact that post-Bates the turtles started to be in line anatomically with the Nick turtles, but I like that. *shrug* If they stick with it, it won't be a big deal, eh?
Joey Kamikaze
06-06-2014, 12:03 AM
The shifting art styles hasn't bothered me, personally, and I like the way the character models evolve as the artists change. Different artists on the book have drawn my favorite versions of different characters during the run so I'm fine with each artist having semi-free reign on character designs.
I figure if there's any cosmetic change to a character that's supposed to mean something it'll probably be fairly obvious, like Leo's blue -> black -> blue transformation or April's haircut.
Cipher
06-06-2014, 12:07 AM
I don't think it's made much of a difference, for the most part. It makes sense to me that the turtles would often change their wraps & gear, things get dirty/worn/bloody, and there may be a tiny bit of that 'ol 'teens like to express themselves' mindset. Stuff like Mateus' old bandanas were problematic in the way you describe, but they've since been taken out. Other than that I can't recall any jarring changes between different artists' takes as far as the overall look is concerned.
...Well, there is the fact that post-Bates the turtles started to be in line anatomically with the Nick turtles, but I like that. *shrug* If they stick with it, it won't be a big deal, eh?
Well, there was also a beat with Casey's masks that didn't play correctly because of artist liberties.
For me it's just the way things like Casey's mask, the Turtles' belts (are they hook-style or knotted? who knows?) can change on a whim. But then things like new gear or April's haircut are permanent in-story changes. Meanwhile, Shredder and Karai continue to wear the same clothes every day. I don't care about the physical approaches changing (where it's clear that it's just a different artistic approach) so much as I do non-anatomical design elements, where it's not.
It's not a major, or even minor, impediment to readability. It's just that it's all applied so arbitrarily and inconsistently I don't think it adds as much as it distracts.
Powder
06-06-2014, 12:14 AM
Huh. Casey's been my favorite non-turtle character for as long as I can remember, yet I never once noticed his mask being any different between issues. I guess I must not be giving it all that much attention... But maybe like the turtles' belts it's something you could explain away by saying they've got multiple choices and just switch things up once in a while? Hadn't thought about Shredder & Karai having cartoon syndrome, but that's true. Fairly sure we've seen Karai in a change of clothes or two, but not Shredder. Tsk tsk! :trazz:
Cipher
06-06-2014, 12:21 AM
Huh. Casey's been my favorite non-turtle character for as long as I can remember, yet I never once noticed his mask being any different between issues. I guess I must not be giving it all that much attention... But maybe like the turtles' belts it's something you could explain away by saying they've got multiple choices and just switch things up once in a while? Hadn't thought about Shredder & Karai having cartoon syndrome, but that's true. Fairly sure we've seen Karai in a change of clothes or two, but not Shredder. Tsk tsk! :trazz:
It wasn't that it changed. It was that Santaluoco gave him a new mask design (fine), and then it played really ... weirdly, with another mask being given as a gift in the Hun micro.
DrSpengler over at TMNTEntity, reviewing #28:
If anything in this chapter confused me, I suppose it might be Angel returning Casey’s hockey mask to him at the hospital. You see, in the Hun micro, he gives Casey a mask as a gift and it’s the mask he wore at the start of the series (angular shape, no perforations). The mask Angel gives him is the one he’s been wearing since Santolouco started drawing (round shape with perforations). I had always figured Casey just had one mask and Santolouco’s design differences were an artist's interpretation, but okay, I guess he had two masks all along. So Hun gives him his first mask and Angel gives him his second mask and I guess it’s… symbolic? Like, choosing which side he wants to be on is determined by which mask he prefers? But there’s no dilemma for Casey and hell, we don’t even see the two masks together. He actually only mentions the mask Hun gave him offhandedly.
So what we end up with is two dramatic moments in two different issues where someone offers Casey a hockey mask, like it’s setting up some big choice he’s going to have to make. But there’s no choice at all, not even for a second.
I dunno, it was just really half-baked, is all I’m saying. In fact, a part of me almost wants to think it was a hastily covered up instance of discontinuity. Like Hun returned Casey’s lost mask in the micro, but Waltz threw in a scene where Angel returns the same mask in this issue, so some slapdash dialogue had to be added to explain all the ****ing masks people keep giving Casey, goddamn.
And it's not clear if any of that was intentional, like if the different designs were supposed to have any weight in-story. Things like that.
I'm all for an approach of total freedom if that's what they want. It's just really difficult to do that and have actual plot beats involve design or costume changes, if they're only meaningful sometimes, when the script calls for them.
This probably seems like something that really bothers me now. It totally isn't, and it needn't take up any more of this thread. Just wanted to clarify where I was coming from.
Powder
06-06-2014, 12:28 AM
Guess I glossed over that. Oh well. There's a lot of writing that seems out of place in this book, to be fair. I guess it makes sense that there'd be some art kinks too. The book is young, after all.
Joey Kamikaze
06-06-2014, 01:47 AM
I thought Hun bought Casey a new mask, throwing around his money from the Foot and hamfistedly trying to get on Casey's good side with a gift. Then Angel shows up with his old mask and he keeps wearing that instead.
Cipher
06-06-2014, 02:55 AM
I thought Hun bought Casey a new mask, throwing around his money from the Foot and hamfistedly trying to get on Casey's good side with a gift. Then Angel shows up with his old mask and he keeps wearing that instead.
But Casey is wearing a new mask at the start of the "City Fall" arc because Santaluoco drew it that way. Then Hun shows up with a mask that looks like his original mask because the artist in the Hun micro drew it that way. Then Angel shows up with his all-new, all-different "City Fall" mask again and ... it's just not clear what any of it's supposed to mean or if it's intentional.
The old mask is the new mask and the new mask is the old mask.
Shredder had a few different shaped helmets and kneepads before, his design is definitely not more static then the Turtles'.
The things which ones are somewhat disturb me more are the changes they made on the body of the characters, not on the clothes. Like Krang having 3 (or more) different eye colors, Slash having a totally different body in April micro, Rocksteady having different eye color, tattoos, and shark teeth in B&R micro.
The colored classics/tales issues are even more disturbing, with having Foot ninjas in all colors of the rainbow. That coloring studio doing those, can't even decide on what color does Complete Carnage's skin have.
Oh, and Renet... as far as my knowledge goes, a natural orange skin color for humans does not exist. Maybe she took too much beta carotene?
ProphetofGanja
06-06-2014, 08:20 AM
The things which ones are somewhat disturb me more are the changes they made on the body of the characters, not on the clothes. Like Krang having 3 (or more) different eye colors, Slash having a totally different body in April micro, Rocksteady having different eye color, tattoos, and shark teeth in B&R micro.
I absolutely hated the way Slash was drawn in the April micro. Like what, all of a sudden he's not a snapping turtle anymore? Sheesh
ToTheNines
06-07-2014, 12:48 PM
Easily the worst issue of the whole run. They redeemed themselves by having it play into Leonardo's hallucinations and helping Kitsune turn him, but I wouldn't care if they left this one behind them.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.