PDA

View Full Version : A Matter of Grave Importance


Wentos
06-13-2014, 07:45 PM
Is there any consensus among TMNT fans for classifying the IDW series? I'd like to call it v5, but it's kind of in a grey area since, up to this point, the only TMNT books to get volume designations so far are part of the original Mirage canon.

Not to mention that, if we're being super-technical, the ill-fated Dreamwave book based on the 4Kids cartoon should be v5.

So I ask you, the TMNT Illumnati, where the IDW book lies in the larger scheme of things. What do we call it, if anything?

Candy Kappa
06-13-2014, 07:49 PM
V1-4 is all within continuity, although V3 is by Laird considered non-canon, it's still labeled as Volume 3 and still more or less fits being canon with the rest of the volumes.

IDW is an entirely new story, a new world. Of anything it's the Earth-2 equivalent.

Redeemer
06-13-2014, 07:52 PM
I am no comic expert, by any means, but this is a completely different TMNT continuity, story, line. It has nothing to do at all story wise to the original Mirage run or tales or dream wave. ect.... This is IDW TMNT vol 1.

Rat_King
06-13-2014, 07:54 PM
I would just call it what it is and leave it as the IDW series. You hit the nail on the head hat the others were in the Mirage universe and therefore followed the volume progression. Even the Image run was originally counted as volume three since it was suppose to be canon and then later deemed not. And just like IDW, the Dreamwave books are always mentioned as just that and not as volume five.

CyberCubed
06-13-2014, 09:15 PM
IDW TMNT is what the "Ultimate" universe is to Spiderman.

Its a reboot. The only reason Volumes were used for Mirage is because it was all the same series.

thebrownranger
06-13-2014, 09:30 PM
I definitely would not consider IDW volume 5. It's a reboot/non-canonical.

CyberCubed
06-13-2014, 09:41 PM
There were 3 major TMNT Comic universes:

1. Mirage.

- Volume 1
- Volume 2
- Image (Volume 3)
- Volume 4
- Tales of the TMNT V.1
- Tales of the TMNT V. 2
- Various one-shot specials and mini-series

2. Archie TMNT Adventures.

- Main ongoing up to issue 72
- Mighty Mutanimals
- Archie specials and mini-series

3. IDW TMNT

- Main ongoing
- Micros, specials, annuals and mini-series


The other series is Nick animated adventures but its the same continuity as the cartoon, and the Dreamwave series which got canceled before it became separate from 4kids.

Ninjinister
06-13-2014, 11:05 PM
Why is this of grave importance?

Casey
06-13-2014, 11:41 PM
Why is this of grave importance?

I second this acquisition.

liugeaux
06-14-2014, 12:29 AM
IDW TMNT is what the "Ultimate" universe is to Spiderman.

I actually think this is the best way to refer to the IDW series, "Ultimate TMNT".

Wentos
06-14-2014, 12:59 AM
Why is this of grave importance?I second this acquisition.

The thread's title is in sarcastic fun. Only a complete nerd would care about something as pointless as shorthand for a volume of TMNT.

mrmaczaps
06-14-2014, 06:18 AM
I have been referring to it as IDW/Vol5 but call it what you like... :)

The Big Bad
06-14-2014, 07:15 AM
I call it Volume 6, based on the fact that it's the sixth series titled Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Canonicity doesn't enter into it.

CyberCubed
06-14-2014, 08:28 AM
Guys, Volume's were only used when the Mirage series restarted at issue #1 for each new series. That's why they used volume's to distinguish the beginning of Volume 2, Image and Volume 4.

Archie and IDW have nothing to do with Mirage and should not be considered volume's at all. I'm surprised this is even being discussed.

Davin
06-14-2014, 10:18 AM
I file it on my ipad and computer as V5. Why? I dunno, just seemed more organized to keep the latest series at the end of the folder structure alphabetically. Of course I contradict myself by keeping Archie books under TMNT Archie.

Whenever referring to the series verbally I definitely call it the IDW series. I think it's least confusing that way during discussions.

Candy Kappa
06-14-2014, 10:40 AM
So why is some calling it volume 5 ( or even 6) as the vol 1-4 is all about a singe canon, there is also the Archie comics, the Comic Strip, Dreamwave and Mutant Turtles/Super turtles/Gaiden. None of those are labeled as any volumes like the Mirage/Image books are.

RossMay
06-14-2014, 11:12 AM
The Big Bad said it first, but I'll say it again because some people don't know how volumes work in publication. It indicates a new book or series of periodicals (magazines, comics).

If you say "it's a different continuity" that's fine, but that has nothing to do with the word "volume." The Image series is called volume 3 because it had the title Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, nothing else. Notice volumes can also change publishers.

The IDW series is volume 6 (1 and 2 at Mirage, 3 at Image, 4 at Mirage and 5 at Dreamwave). Other books, including Archie's TMNT Adventures, don't count because they have alternate titles. Also note that even though volume 4's cover is "TMNT," its official description inside is Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. That's another funny thing, that the title on the cover doesn't actually need to be the true name of the publication.

TMNT are a bit unusual not because it has changed publishers several times (happens a lot in publishing), but because technically the Dreamwave volume began while volume 4 was still ongoing, and now volume 4 and 6 are still ongoing concerns. But even this has happened with other publications before.

So that's how volumes work in publishing. Call the IDW series what you want, but if you wanted to catalogue it, it's still volume 6.

RossMay
06-14-2014, 11:15 AM
Oh, Candy Kappa brings up a point. There's also the newspaper comic strip Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. It doesn't count as a volume because it's a different form of publication, even though strips are quite similar to comic books. It's the same reason why you wouldn't count the cartoons or movies in the numbered volumes.

I'm an English teacher. Who wants to learn?!

Tazi
06-14-2014, 11:15 AM
The volume labeling is for making difference between seperate comic series with the same name. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Adventures, ミュータント・タートルズ外伝, etc. have a different name, they don't need to be called volume n. Technically current ongoing could be TMNT v6, but that's obviously misleading, cuz it's the IDW series which is not the part of the Mirage series, neither the Dreamwave one. I'd prefer calling it 'TMNT IDW v1'. If IDW ever end the current volume and continue it with v2, then that would be TMNT v7, and well... that would be pretty stupid.


EDIT: Heh, I was slow, already answered in the post before me. :)

CyberCubed
06-14-2014, 03:45 PM
IDW is not Volume 5, it's not in continuity with Mirage.

IDW may do its own Volune 2 someday.

Tazi
06-14-2014, 04:41 PM
IDW is not Volume 5, it's not in continuity with Mirage.

IDW may do its own Volune 2 someday.

Did you read Ross May's post?

Wentos
06-14-2014, 06:22 PM
I'm inclined to agree with RossMay. In comic book vernacular, volume numbers are used to catagorize different books with the same name, nothing more. It has nothing to do with publishers or continuity.

But if the fans can't come to a consensus on the shorthand, it doesn't mean much in the end. :ohwell:

CyberCubed
06-14-2014, 07:27 PM
Did you read Ross May's post?

Yes, but that's the way he views it and that's fine.

IDW is a reboot and a new series, so I don't consider it Volume 5 at all. I'm sure Tom and Bobby never referred to it as Volume 5 either, to avoid confusion with people thinking it would be a continuation of Mirage back in 2011 when it first came out.

The other reason this doesn't make sense is people don't count Archie as a volume. So why does IDW count and not Archie? Simply because Archie was based on a cartoon?

IDW is its own separate entity, its not Volume 5 and nowhere official was it ever stated to be it.

Wentos
06-14-2014, 08:00 PM
The other reason this doesn't make sense is people don't count Archie as a volume. So why does IDW count and not Archie? Simply because Archie was based on a cartoon?

It's because the name of the Archie book was Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Adventures. It differentiated itself through its name, so a volume designation was never required.

To reiterate, volume numbers are used to specify which book you're talking about when multiple books have used the same name. That volume numbers are used to specify continuity is an idea unique to the TMNT fandom AFAIK.

Punker Don
06-17-2014, 08:28 AM
I'd say its best to call the series "the IDW series" and leave it at that. All this talk about volumes is getting confusing. Heck, others have already explained that this series is technically a vol. 6! Calling it the IDW series is just easier and nobody will be confused by what you mean.

Tazi
06-17-2014, 08:47 AM
So why does IDW count and not Archie? Simply because Archie was based on a cartoon?
Because the name of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Adventures is not Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, but Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Adventures. That simple.



IDW is its own separate entity, its not Volume 5 and nowhere official was it ever stated to be it.
Indeed it's not. It's Volume 6, cuz it's the sixth volume of a printed series under the label 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles'.
It has nothing to do with the continuity/tmnt universe. Besides, following your logic, New 52 books should all be v1 at DC, cuz they're at least as much different in continuity from the previous volumes as IDW's TMNT was from Mirage. Also, following that logic Image's TMNT v3 should be TMNT v1, cuz it's also a different continuity, thus making Mirage's v4 to v3.

But why does that disturb you? We can still address (without confusion) the current series as IDW TMNT, even if it's the 6th line of TMNT titled books.

Btw, Archie has two volumes, v1 1-3, then v2 1-72. Just sayin.

liugeaux
06-17-2014, 10:32 AM
Yes, but that's the way he views it and that's fine.

Being a professional comic writer, I'm sure Ross knows more about the volume standards of comic publication. Its not about the way you view it. How you view it doesn't matter.

Technically, it is Volume 6, that cannot be argued...period. What we CAN discuss is how we will refer to it colloquially: IDW TMNT, Ultimate TMNT, TMNT Reboot Vol.1, The IDW TMNT Extravaganza, etc.

This discussion needs to put back on its tracks. We are arguing facts verses opinions and that never works.

CyberCubed
06-17-2014, 10:39 AM
Being a professional comic writer, I'm sure Ross knows more about the volume standards of comic publication. Its not about the way you view it. How you view it doesn't matter.

Technically, it is Volume 6, that cannot be argued...period. What we CAN discuss is how we will refer to it colloquially: IDW TMNT, Ultimate TMNT, TMNT Reboot Vol.1, The IDW TMNT Extravaganza, etc.

This discussion needs to put back on its tracks. We are arguing facts verses opinions and that never works.

Ross being a professional writer has nothing to do with IDW being considered a Volume of the TMNT comics.

Nowhere has IDW TMNT even been officially called a "Volume" and I've never seen Bobby or Tom say that either. It doesn't matter if it shares the same title as previous comics, its not part of that past continuity so it should not be considered a volume of it. By that logic why is the 2004 Tales called "Volume 2" of Tales of the TMNT, instead of Volume 5? Even the new 2004 Tales did not get considered part of the old volume's.

IDW TMNT is....IDW TMNT. That's what we refer to it as. If in the future the IDW ongoing TMNT comics are rebranded with a new #1 for some reason, then that will be considered "Volume 2" of IDW. But Bobby said he's not a fan of rebooting things with #1 so I don't think that will happen.

Tazi
06-17-2014, 01:13 PM
Ross being a professional writer has nothing to do with IDW being considered a Volume of the TMNT comics.

Nowhere has IDW TMNT even been officially called a "Volume" and I've never seen Bobby or Tom say that either.

They might not called it v6 officially, but they doesn't need to, it's the 6th series of TMNT named books, it's a fact, there's documented proof for it, IDW's official statement is nothing compared to verifyable history.
Again, it has nothing to do with canon/continuity/universe, for example v2 is not the second volume of the Mirage TMNT series, it's a second series of books with the name TMNT starting with issue #1.
I think I'm just repeating myself... I really hope that Bobby or Tom will show up here to restate how volume numbering works with comics, if that's what you need.


It doesn't matter if it shares the same title as previous comics, its not part of that past continuity so it should not be considered a volume of it.
It's not the volume of a continuity, it's a volume of the serias with a certain title. I'm asking again: What volume would you give to New 52 series?
If you decide by continuity only: What about v1 issues that has nothing to do with Mirage TMNT universe or the continuity or anything?


By that logic why is the 2004 Tales called "Volume 2" of Tales of the TMNT, instead of Volume 5? Even the new 2004 Tales did not get considered part of the old volume's.
I don't understand this question. Tales of TMNT v1 '87 went 7 issues. Then in '04 they restarted the numbering with issue #1, so it's Tales of TMNT v2.
At the same way Mirage restarted TMNT with issue #1 in '01, it was the 4th restart with #1 it's v4. Dreamwave restarted again with #1 in '04 it's v5. IDW restarted in '11 = v6. By that logic, Tales of TMNT v2 is Tales of TMNT v2.