PDA

View Full Version : If you could select any artist whose worked with TMNT for an oversized HC....


Stugehen
06-20-2014, 02:46 PM
If you could select any artist whose worked with TMNT for an oversized HC gallery collection, who’d it be?

Additional details...


No restrictions as far as colors, inks, and/or pencils.
You should include your favorite piece in your submission which would serve as the cover of the collection.
The book must include their work with TMNT in any form, but wouldn't have to be restricted to only their TMNT pieces.



To start it out, I'll throw down my pick....

Michael Dooney.

Though he did get the Tundra sketchbook treatment. I'd love a current HC edition of his best pieces (and there are many). Of course the cover would have to be his classic Vol. 1 #4 2nd edition (aka NES game cover) piece.

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-aZ9xCzUqOeU/Tk7vdIlyK5I/AAAAAAAAGo4/_3SzbClah7M/s1600/NESBoxArt01.jpg

arkangel
06-29-2014, 08:55 AM
I'd love to see one by Eric Talbot or Ross Campbell. Their styles seem to be on opposite sides of the spectrum. Ross has an innocent look to his art, while Eric has very dark overtones. Both are favorites of mine and I'd also love to see what a collaboration between the two of them would look like.

Redrumh2o
06-29-2014, 01:30 PM
1) Talbot
2) Dooney
3) Lawson
4) Campbell

Princess Anri
06-29-2014, 10:17 PM
Definitely Campbell.

His art is great and it lends itself to less action-packed storylines and more character development type stuff which is when Turtles (and comics) are at their best.

Mr._Mutant_Man
06-29-2014, 10:30 PM
I'm going to go with Ross Campbell. Out of the more recent artists that have worked on TMNT, his style really stood out to me. I know I said before I'd stop bringing it up, but I liked the slightly heavier looking April. I'm normally indifferent toward the "every woman in comics has the same body type" argument, but it was cool to see something different.

I'd like to see Dooney too. One of my first comics was the TMNT cartoon adaptation, so seeing his art always brings back good memories.

Sophie Campbell
06-30-2014, 09:21 AM
aww, you guysssss! thanks so much. :D maybe someday.

TheBlueTurtle1
06-30-2014, 10:11 AM
aww, you guysssss! thanks so much. :D maybe someday.

Have you ever thought about re doing classic TMNT art, but in your style? I personaly would love to see it. The above NES poster would be awesome, or TMNT issue 1 cover!
;);)

Sophie Campbell
06-30-2014, 11:38 AM
Have you ever thought about re doing classic TMNT art, but in your style? I personaly would love to see it. The above NES poster would be awesome, or TMNT issue 1 cover!
;);)

i'm not crazy about homages/re-do's like that, even if it's just for fun i feel like i'd be setting myself up for failure because i'll never top the original image! something like that is all about evoking another existing picture in the viewer's mind, so i'm not sure why i'd want to do a drawing that reminds someone of a better, or at least more loved, drawing. :lol:

that said, if i had to do a new one, it would probably be the splash page of Donatello in Mirage issue #11 with the trashcan full of crumpled up paper. i love that one! or maybe AC Farley's cover for the second collected book.

anyway, the only ones i've done are this TMNT #1 cover sketch: http://mooncalfe.deviantart.com/art/vigil-351924534 and the "cover" to my fan-comic based on the TMNT 2 movie poster: http://mooncalfe.deviantart.com/art/the-search-for-a-beginning-435383275

:)

oldmanwinters
06-30-2014, 11:51 AM
i'm not crazy about homages/re-do's like that, even if it's just for fun i feel like i'd be setting myself up for failure because i'll never top the original image! something like that is all about evoking another existing picture in the viewer's mind, so i'm not sure why i'd want to do a drawing that reminds someone of a better, or at least more loved, drawing. :lol:

that said, if i had to do a new one, it would probably be the splash page of Donatello in Mirage issue #11 with the trashcan full of crumpled up paper. i love that one! or maybe AC Farley's cover for the second collected book.


You might not satisfy your own artistic standards with such homages, Ross, but 99.9% of all fans would SQUEE! with delight if you did.

DrSpengler
06-30-2014, 11:54 AM
The "worst" thing about being a TMNT fan is that we're so spoiled for choice when it comes to artists. We've seen a LOT of incredible talent over the past 30 years, so narrowing it down to a fav is rough.

But I'm gonna side with OP on the Michael Dooney one with exactly that cover. I suggest Dooney because he has a WEALTH of painted covers, posters and lithos in addition to sketches and panel work and even toy designs. His catalog could EASILY fill up an entire coffee table book and provide a massive amount of variety across numerous incarnations of the brand.

I'd like to see art books from a lot of Turtle artists, but I think Dooney's resume would lend itself to that sort of format better than most.

Whatswiththeheadbands?
06-30-2014, 12:49 PM
A bit off topic, but I wonder what a TMNT comic would look like if it was drawn by John Romita Sr. ...

TheBlueTurtle1
06-30-2014, 01:05 PM
i'm not crazy about homages/re-do's like that, even if it's just for fun i feel like i'd be setting myself up for failure because i'll never top the original image! something like that is all about evoking another existing picture in the viewer's mind, so i'm not sure why i'd want to do a drawing that reminds someone of a better, or at least more loved, drawing. :lol:

that said, if i had to do a new one, it would probably be the splash page of Donatello in Mirage issue #11 with the trashcan full of crumpled up paper. i love that one! or maybe AC Farley's cover for the second collected book.

anyway, the only ones i've done are this TMNT #1 cover sketch: http://mooncalfe.deviantart.com/art/vigil-351924534 and the "cover" to my fan-comic based on the TMNT 2 movie poster: http://mooncalfe.deviantart.com/art/the-search-for-a-beginning-435383275

:)

Your selling yourself far to short, your art is as good if not better than any!:)

pingclang
06-30-2014, 02:15 PM
Lawson. No question.

Stugehen
06-30-2014, 10:14 PM
Hey what a nice surprise. I started this thread 10 days ago and thought it was dead on arrival. All very good choices here!

I know it’s against the rules of my own thread, but I also would love seeing a collection of numerous TMNT artists work in one Ultimate Visual History-ish HC. Each artist could pick some of their favorite pieces and even throw a few comments about them. They could also pay homage to Mirage routes by adding in a few pieces done by some upcoming independent artists.

One can dream right? Awesome choices all around. I’d still love to see everyone’s favorite pieces by said artist(s) embedded in the thread. :tcool:

Chris
07-01-2014, 02:03 AM
If I had to pick just 1 I'd probably go with Dooney.

I'd actually love a book like this that contains all the original Mirage guys TMNT commissions, I think that would be great to see.

Of the new guys, Ross Campbell and Ben Bates would be my picks. Definitely my favourite of the IDW artists.

darthsmozers
07-01-2014, 05:07 PM
Chris Allan because I am a sucker for his art. I have a few unpublished sketches of his, one of which would make an awesome cover. (I'll have to find it and show a photo). Although the cover to Archie issue 50 could work. Work could include forever war partially completed artwork that we have all seen before, maybe some private sketches he has done for fans, and some of his other comic book artwork.

Powder
07-01-2014, 07:06 PM
Chris Allan because I am a sucker for his art. I have a few unpublished sketches of his, one of which would make an awesome cover. (I'll have to find it and show a photo).

Please do, I would love to see them! We have a thread for art in the collection section, everyone there would be excited at a glance of those works. Here's fine too, of course. :trazz:

I have to echo the want for Dooney & Lawson books. They both have such a rich catalog of covers, paintings, pin ups, posters, etc. that it would certainly fill up such a feature. Frank Fosco is one of my all time favorite TMNT artists, but I don't think he's got enough work under his belt to justify a big book (not that I wouldn't buy one regardless :trazz:)

AquaParade
07-01-2014, 10:52 PM
A.C. Farley of course, it would quite possibly give those of you who are waiting on commissions an early sneak preview.

Proof:http://i57.tinypic.com/seu26e.jpg

RedRocBoy
07-11-2014, 03:10 AM
A.C. Farley of course, it would quite possibly give those of you who are waiting on commissions an early sneak preview.

Proof:http://i57.tinypic.com/seu26e.jpg

Farley is a god. Really wish he would come back and do a couple issues.

Icegaze
07-11-2014, 04:04 AM
My favourite artist for whatever TMNT related material is and will always be Mateus Santolouco. And I don't understand why he does not get more recognition on this forum. His artwork is so detailed and stuning and with the inking of Pattison, it makes for a visual treat. Santo's artwork is the main reason why I am always so stoked for more of the current comics.

Cipher
07-11-2014, 04:25 PM
Thinking strictly of someone who I think best nails a tone in his stand-alone pieces:

A.C. Farley. Hands down.

Proof:http://i57.tinypic.com/seu26e.jpg
One of the greatest Turtles covers ever published. I love that piece.

Metropoliskid41
07-14-2014, 09:05 AM
IDW has done some awesome portfolio releases in the past, I love the GI JOE one they did about a year ago, I'd love for them to do a Dooney TMNT Portfolio, that would be awesome.

Leomaru
07-14-2014, 04:04 PM
Mateus Santolouco is my favorite artist. I don't have a particular favorite piece of art by him. I like the details he adds. Just look at how beautiful the shells are in City Fall, for example :tgrin:

I found this cool (unused?) cover:
http://yourfriendandy.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/1352224873.jpg

Andrew NDB
07-14-2014, 04:20 PM
Thinking strictly of someone who I think best nails a tone in his stand-alone pieces:

A.C. Farley. Hands down.

Of course, there's no questions about it.

Imagine, like, a hardcover TMNT graphic novel from A.C. Farley that's entirely painted in the style of those old Mirage trade covers.

thebrownranger
07-14-2014, 05:10 PM
Imagine, like, a hardcover TMNT graphic novel from A.C. Farley that's entirely painted in the style of those old Mirage trade covers.
https://warosu.org/data/tg/img/0326/92/1402439368534.gif

Powder
07-14-2014, 06:10 PM
I found this cool (unused?) cover:

That was just a pin-up he did for the hell of it, as far as I know, but it was eventually used as the back cover to the 30th anniversary collection.