View Full Version : Why the Turtles are Ugly: A Theory
FakeBritishAccent
07-13-2014, 05:26 AM
I just read through a separate thread about the new World Cup commercials. Despite the fact that it was MEANT to be a thread devoted to new footage of the movie, it quickly de-evolved into a discussion about the new Turtle design. While some were commenting about the Turtles new wardrobe, most people began bashing the Turtles physical appearances.
It's the same debate everyone's been having since we first saw that Mikey Halloween costume and those maquettes: Those who are FOR the design say the boys have taken on more human features because it's the only way to take full advantage of CGI; More human = better facial expressions. Those who are AGAINST the new designs say that the Turtles new faces (and to a degree, their body proportions) are unsettling and disturbing; that the use of CGI is a poor substitute for Jim Henson's puppet suits and they shouldn't have messed with a good thing.
I for one LOVE the new look...but the reason why has nothing to do with my interest in the technological advances of filmmaking. Ironically, I love the look for the same reason the haters DON'T.
I love them BECAUSE they're ugly.
All of the haters are right about their faces. The tiny eyes, the flared nostrils, the smaller lips and teeth. It's weird and unsettling and so different from the Turtles we grew up with: From Mirage to Nick, these Turtles are so warped from what we expected that it's caused many of us to bash on the movie even more than we did when we found out Bay was producing it. And that's just the faces! Their bulked-up, hunchbacked bodies are also very creepy.
Most people theories about why the Turtles have changed so drastically hinge on a few key opinions: Bay kept wanting to PUSH IT TO THE MAX. They wanted to sell toys. They wanted to push the technology. Or, they did it just because they could...to get a rise out of us long time fans.
But here's my theory, something I haven't heard mentioned before (and if it has been, sorry if this post is redundant...I didn't feel like digging through pages of pages of posts to see if I was being unoriginal).
The new Turtles are ugly because they're monsters.
There. That's it. Everyone who hates the new look can stop wondering.
What we have all forgotten about the Turtles is that they are all freaks of science (or sci-fi). They're not supposed to be cute and cuddly...they're mutants! They live in the sewer with their equally creepy giant rat dad! And they KNOW they're not supposed to be seen by the public for this very reason, hence all the trenchcoats and bald fat guy masks. One could argue that they secrecy has more to do with the Ninja code, but I don't buy it.
The Turtles and Splinter have always known they were monsters. Monsters with a purpose, with a goal to fight evil at every turn, but monsters nonetheless.
But we, as fans, have FORGOTTEN this very key point. We love the Turtles because they're fun-loving teens who eat pizza and always save the day. They laugh and joke and goof off, they watch TV and play videogames and read comics. They have unrequited crushes on redheads. They sometimes hate that their dad is so strict and controlling.
In short, we love the Turtles because deep down, they're just like us (minus all the ninja stuff, of course).
And after spending so many years with these guys in their various incarnations, it's hard to see them as the physical monsters they really are. And I think Liebesman and company wanted to remind us of that.
Is it because they want us to fear and be disgusted by the Turtles? Yes...but only until we get to know them again. From the first trailer, we know that April's initial reaction to the boys is shock (so much so that she faints). I'm sure the very next scene is her waking up in the sewer lair and freaking out again: These hideous giant reptiles have kidnapped me and now I'm going to die.
We all know that's not how it's going to turn out. No, she's going to slowly get to know the Turtles for who they really are on the inside. Not just mutants, not just ninjas, not just turtles...teens. Teens whom she will grow to trust and love and respect. And she will extend this trust and love and respect to their father as well.
I thought of this theory after the second trailer came out. Suddenly, after spending just 2 minutes and 43 seconds with these monsters, many of us realized that they were still the same guys we all grew up with. Those who initially boycotted the movies now decided to give it a shot. Those who were already excited for the film exploded in joy.
Though ugly, though unsettling, though monsterous, they are still the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
Sorry for the long post, but I just had to get that off my chest. To those of you who got through this, thanks for reading.
-Jonaas
Powder
07-13-2014, 05:29 AM
Can we put a ban on the word haters?
As one who is often referred to as a "hater", I think I speak for everyone "against" the designs when I say that we don't take issue with ugly, just this version of ugly.
I'm all for the turtles being grotesque & beastly, or even a bit of uncanny valley, but for me, that brings to mind the work of Zulli, Farley, characters like Tokka, Slash, not lips & noses (though those features can be done justice, a lot of us agree on that point when it comes to the designs of "Out Of The Shadows").
At any rate, this kinda stuff has been discussed to death, no "new" perspective is going to change how anyone feels. Folks on either side of this issue are very passionate & firm in their stance. I imagine this is just going to drum up more beef between the sides (who, I think, lately, have been getting along better).
FakeBritishAccent
07-13-2014, 05:38 AM
Can we put a ban on the word haters?
As one who is often referred to as a "hater", I think I speak for everyone "against" the designs when I say that we don't take issue with ugly, just this version of ugly.
I'm all for the turtles being grotesque & beastly, or even a bit of uncanny valley, but for me, that brings to mind the work of Zulli, Farley, characters like Tokka, Slash, not lips & noses.
At any rate, this kinda stuff has been discussed to death, no "new" perspective is going to change how anyone feels. Folks on either side of this issue are very passionate & firm in their stance. I imagine this is just going to drum up more beef between the sides (who, I think, lately, have been getting along better).
Fine, no more Haters. How about "Againsters?" :lol:
I was first a fan of the OT and the Archie Comics. The very first Mirage Comic I ever read was a Zulli comic in 1991. While initially freaked out by how they looked (NO BANDANNAS?!) I grew to love the look and when we first got a peek of the new designs, my memory harkened back to Zulli's take.
And I'm not trying to change anyone's mind here, but I am trying to share my perspective. Also, whether it's been discussed to death or not is not the issue: if it's something that people don't feel like reading about, they don't have to.
Jester
07-13-2014, 05:46 AM
Just a preemptive call for civility...because it seems like a necessity in most threads now-a-days.
FakeBritishAccent
07-13-2014, 05:50 AM
Just a preemptive call for civility...because it seems like a necessity in most threads now-a-days.
I second that nomination. My post wasn't attacking anyone despite Powder's umbrage at the "haters" remark. Let's all just agree to put the first person to throw stones on the ignore list.
Powder
07-13-2014, 05:53 AM
Just to be clear, I didn't think you were trying to be rude or biased. I'm just sick of that word. :trazz:
FakeBritishAccent
07-13-2014, 06:03 AM
Just to be clear, I didn't think you were trying to be rude or biased. I'm just sick of that word. :trazz:
Me too, sir. And IRL I only use it ironically!
Werecat
07-13-2014, 06:22 AM
Nice insight.
People are mainly complaining about the ugly faces for Michelangelo, Donatello, and slighty Raphael. Leo is the only turtle with a decent face. I mean look at it!
http://www.spotlightreport.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/tmnt-leonardo-movie-2014-600x350.jpg
He is like Brad Pitt. I think the TMNT Movie Facebook page chose Leonardo as their profile picture because he was the only one that looked decent instead of a hideous freak. While Michelangelo is like a cross between Shrek and Sloth from the Goonies. Donatello looks like a cross between a fish and rabbit, the unattractive type of rabbit. Raphael looks somewhat decent, he mainly resembles Azog from the Hobbit.
I think there would be less of a backlash from the fans if they just stayed with the face that Leo had and only made slight alterations. Leonardo barely looks humanoid and looks similar to the other TMNT designs, just with nostrils. Leo's face is the right mixture of mutant and humanoid features. They just screwed up on the others.
Candy Kappa
07-13-2014, 06:27 AM
I don't mind grotesque or "ugly" ninja Turtles, but. I personally don't find the PD Turtles that, just poorly designed. As Powder exampled Zulli's TMNT design is a perfect example on monstrous Ninja Turtles done good, and the OotS game did a great job on designing a semi-realistic take on the classic (Nick) Turtle designs.
The PD Turtles do have some good stuff on them, the textures are very nice, their hands and feet are beautifully modeled and animated. They have greatly improved the faces on all four turtles, but. I feel they could have fixed them even more.
But, I really can not stand their bodies. It's not just the face that look too human, but their bodies are shaped like the atypical powerhouse bodybuilder with the triangular body shape, broad shoulders narrow hips, buff muscles. The 90's superhero body, or a big wrestler like Cena. And I don't fancy that. If others do, kudos to them, but for me the appeal of the TMNT design is that they are turtles, humanoids, but turtle humaniods not human turtleoids.
The shell on the PD turtles looks like an after thought, like it's just mandatory because the turtles have shells. The shell bridges are removed for some strange design reason, the plastron is shaped like a sexy hunks muscled out torso, even showing the V line down their abdomen. And the Carapace don't look like it's an actual part of the turtle, it's huge and bulky and looks like it'll tear right off their skin as it can't be connected like it's supposed to be on a turtle.
Short. They just don't look like proper Ninja Turtles designs to me as a lot of the things that appealed to me is gone.
UGHShellshocked
07-13-2014, 07:05 AM
But what's really at stake here? Nothing. Unless you bet big money on if the Turtles in this movie would look like the Jim Henson film. The last time I watched TMNT other than the old series was Turtles Forever then the TMNT animated flick and my reaction to those were simply "That's good". I didn't put it over like I would have if I was still 5 years old, marking out to anything and everything TMNT.
I remember when I was a kid the local Walgreen's put an ad in the paper saying come see Michelangelo of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles so I begged my Mom to go, we got there and it was one of those goofy big foam suits that looked more like a football mascot but I still ate it up.
With anything there is bound to be disappointment. Look at the X-Men franchise. I absolutely cannot stand them but here they are going 7 movies deep. Has anyone protested Fox for having the rights to these movies? None of the characters look like their comic book counterparts but enough people go and see them enough to warrant sequels.
At this point I'm just happy that there is a Turtles film coming out. I'm not expecting much and I don't really mind the designs. I don't care to sit on the internets and nitpick every little thing to death which I might have done that years ago but not anymore. If this movie came out a years ago I might have headed right to Michael Bay's house with pitchforks and an angry mob but with time I have grown to like his movies. If the movie sucks then so be it. The fandom will still be going strong with another season of the Nick series, IDW Comic.
chrisdude
07-13-2014, 07:57 AM
As much as I love these designs, I've never thought designs were that important. I don't like what Man of Steel did with the Superman costume. Batman movies have never had a costume I've liked. Ironman has at least two new suits every movie, so if you like one, it's already gone. And like UGH said, the X-Men costumes look aweful (save First Class). I just never considered these things more than minor, minor aspects of the film. It really doesn't seem important enough to get bent out of shape over...
UGHShellshocked
07-13-2014, 10:07 AM
I don't think anything in this movie is worthy enough to get into fights and possibly get banned or suspended over. People are quickly to jump to conclusions when we have yet to see a full scene of this movie yet.
Things people have Nitpicked so far
Leo doing a flip and landing loudly on the roof being not ninja like. This was after Raph pulled April onto the roof for taking a picture of the four, the gig was up, why should he approach in a stealthy way?
The Turtles not doing karate or martial arts. I think they are saving the fights for us to be entertained but Mikey's kick looked cool
Shredder being a white guy. What's the big idea? Shredder is just a mantle and ultimately just a title. There have been numerous people to be the Shredder. There has been a Demon Shredder. A Dragon Shredder. A Human Shredder. A Clone Shredder that turned into a Shark/Human hybrid. An Android Shredder. 2 Women Shredders. Hell if one of us lived in the Turtleverse and put the armor on we too would become The Shredder. At least they have the guy who's lurking in the shadows in this movie that resembles the Nick TMNT Shredder.
The Turtles being an exaggerated 7 foot tall.
The Turtles wearing flair. We really don't know the reason for their choice of clothes.
April's not naturally red headed The first April I saw had Curly black hair and wore a blue jumpsuit its not a big deal is it? I personally wanted to see Jane Levy as April. Because shes fabulous and I have a mad celebrity crush on her.
The Foot using guns. *clears throat*
http://38.media.tumblr.com/50465ab4f8072f8d946c8a60f2ffb6d8/tumblr_mfvayy8Vf01ramnmyo1_500.jpg
http://www.figurerealm.com/userimages/customs/12500/12421-1.jpg
http://www.adventuresinpoortaste.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/0031.jpg
http://www.adventuresinpoortaste.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/0026.jpg
https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTzlm8t9K2QfLq4XvXM1mlsPK76ad9V0 RlqU58z6Fo6tXkJxJV_
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-XSbuluEJrI0/UGOWo0xYpsI/AAAAAAAAIpg/aeYbHkrc8Yo/s1600/14-2.jpg
Guns were everywhere!
Xiewin
07-13-2014, 10:12 AM
The fact that the turtles are bigger and uglier makes me love this movie even more.
slingtheory
07-13-2014, 10:38 AM
But what's really at stake here? Nothing. Unless you bet big money on if the Turtles in this movie would look like the Jim Henson film. The last time I watched TMNT other than the old series was Turtles Forever then the TMNT animated flick and my reaction to those were simply "That's good". I didn't put it over like I would have if I was still 5 years old, marking out to anything and everything TMNT.
I remember when I was a kid the local Walgreen's put an ad in the paper saying come see Michelangelo of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles so I begged my Mom to go, we got there and it was one of those goofy big foam suits that looked more like a football mascot but I still ate it up.
With anything there is bound to be disappointment. Look at the X-Men franchise. I absolutely cannot stand them but here they are going 7 movies deep. Has anyone protested Fox for having the rights to these movies? None of the characters look like their comic book counterparts but enough people go and see them enough to warrant sequels.
At this point I'm just happy that there is a Turtles film coming out. I'm not expecting much and I don't really mind the designs. I don't care to sit on the internets and nitpick every little thing to death which I might have done that years ago but not anymore. If this movie came out a years ago I might have headed right to Michael Bay's house with pitchforks and an angry mob but with time I have grown to like his movies. If the movie sucks then so be it. The fandom will still be going strong with another season of the Nick series, IDW Comic. hopefully nothing is at stake but I worry every now and then that if this movie is successful we might very well be looking at the future of the the franchise.
UGHShellshocked
07-13-2014, 10:51 AM
hopefully nothing is at stake but I worry every now and then that if this movie is successful we might very well be looking at the future of the the franchise.
IIRC Bay said he would like to do at least 5 movies.
Xiewin
07-13-2014, 10:52 AM
IIRC Bay said he would like to do at least 5 movies.
Wait where did he say that?
pdizzle
07-13-2014, 11:07 AM
Wait where did he say that?
I second this question????????
UGHShellshocked
07-13-2014, 11:08 AM
Wait where did he say that?
Can't find the article that I read but so far hes got Fichtner signed on for 3 more films, when its all done it might be Transformer franchise long.
Galactus
07-13-2014, 11:59 AM
IIRC Bay said he would like to do at least 5 movies.
FIVE? We're gonna have FIVE of these crapfests inflicted on us?
I'd rather this movie flopped and have no movie series for a decade than have Bay's vision for the franchise forced on us. A lot of the problems with this movie can't be fixed or improved with sequels like most film series.
Xiewin
07-13-2014, 12:17 PM
This is not going to get 5 movies. There is no way that is gonna happen.
TMNT is cooler than MOTU
07-13-2014, 12:54 PM
Can't find the article that I read but so far hes got Fichtner signed on for 3 more films, when its all done it might be Transformer franchise long.
Hopefully they can resist the urge to make a 3 hour TMNT movie.
UGHShellshocked
07-13-2014, 01:01 PM
Hopefully they can resist the urge to make a 3 hour TMNT movie.
A little over 90 minutes is a sweet spot for action films IMO.
arkangel
07-13-2014, 01:05 PM
Very thought provoking. You may be right on track with the intentions behind their design decisions. I've read all the arguments about how the new designs help facilitate expression and their ability to emote, but I like your idea more. The new look of the turtles show without a doubt that they are indeed mutants that must hide in the shadows and sneak off into the night. I like your perspective on this.
Those who are AGAINST the new designs say that the Turtles new faces (and to a degree, their body proportions) are unsettling and disturbing; that the use of CGI is a poor substitute for Jim Henson's puppet suits and they shouldn't have messed with a good thing.
Is that really what we're all saying, though? I do agree that their faces and body proportions are unappealing, and I prefer the Henson look a lot, but I'm not saying that the CGI itself is a problem or that they should still be using those exact designs. You can update their looks and even use the mo-cap technology effectively, but I think making them look more "human" makes them look worse, less interesting and "special". Less like, y'know, the Ninja Turtles.
Anyway. As a counterpoint, I feel like I made my case really thoroughly in the other thread, so I'll just link to that (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=1302153&postcount=273).
The only thing I can really add is, considering they went more "humanoid" with their look in this movie, if anything they look less like monsters. They're big and ugly, that much is true. And they may have been cuter-looking before, but they were also more inhuman-looking at the same time. When you look at the new designs, you can see the human features. I really think that takes away from the concept on a basic design level.
And I think they've always looked like that for a very good reason - the Turtles being small and sorta cute is part of the appeal, because you don't expect them to be as deadly as they are. It's something that been used to great effect, and you totally lose that when you turn them into giant, hulking monsters.
IIRC Bay said he would like to do at least 5 movies.
http://media.giphy.com/media/6ZaYjk1qC1Tby/giphy.gif
http://media1.giphy.com/media/vJuQAOM5EKGNa/giphy.gif
I just read through a separate thread about the new World Cup commercials. Despite the fact that it was MEANT to be a thread devoted to new footage of the movie, it quickly de-evolved into a discussion about the new Turtle design. While some were commenting about the Turtles new wardrobe, most people began bashing the Turtles physical appearances.
It's the same debate everyone's been having since we first saw that Mikey Halloween costume and those maquettes: Those who are FOR the design say the boys have taken on more human features because it's the only way to take full advantage of CGI; More human = better facial expressions. Those who are AGAINST the new designs say that the Turtles new faces (and to a degree, their body proportions) are unsettling and disturbing; that the use of CGI is a poor substitute for Jim Henson's puppet suits and they shouldn't have messed with a good thing.
I for one LOVE the new look...but the reason why has nothing to do with my interest in the technological advances of filmmaking. Ironically, I love the look for the same reason the haters DON'T.
I love them BECAUSE they're ugly.
All of the haters are right about their faces. The tiny eyes, the flared nostrils, the smaller lips and teeth. It's weird and unsettling and so different from the Turtles we grew up with: From Mirage to Nick, these Turtles are so warped from what we expected that it's caused many of us to bash on the movie even more than we did when we found out Bay was producing it. And that's just the faces! Their bulked-up, hunchbacked bodies are also very creepy.
Most people theories about why the Turtles have changed so drastically hinge on a few key opinions: Bay kept wanting to PUSH IT TO THE MAX. They wanted to sell toys. They wanted to push the technology. Or, they did it just because they could...to get a rise out of us long time fans.
But here's my theory, something I haven't heard mentioned before (and if it has been, sorry if this post is redundant...I didn't feel like digging through pages of pages of posts to see if I was being unoriginal).
The new Turtles are ugly because they're monsters.
There. That's it. Everyone who hates the new look can stop wondering.
What we have all forgotten about the Turtles is that they are all freaks of science (or sci-fi). They're not supposed to be cute and cuddly...they're mutants! They live in the sewer with their equally creepy giant rat dad! And they KNOW they're not supposed to be seen by the public for this very reason, hence all the trenchcoats and bald fat guy masks. One could argue that they secrecy has more to do with the Ninja code, but I don't buy it.
The Turtles and Splinter have always known they were monsters. Monsters with a purpose, with a goal to fight evil at every turn, but monsters nonetheless.
But we, as fans, have FORGOTTEN this very key point. We love the Turtles because they're fun-loving teens who eat pizza and always save the day. They laugh and joke and goof off, they watch TV and play videogames and read comics. They have unrequited crushes on redheads. They sometimes hate that their dad is so strict and controlling.
In short, we love the Turtles because deep down, they're just like us (minus all the ninja stuff, of course).
And after spending so many years with these guys in their various incarnations, it's hard to see them as the physical monsters they really are. And I think Liebesman and company wanted to remind us of that.
Is it because they want us to fear and be disgusted by the Turtles? Yes...but only until we get to know them again. From the first trailer, we know that April's initial reaction to the boys is shock (so much so that she faints). I'm sure the very next scene is her waking up in the sewer lair and freaking out again: These hideous giant reptiles have kidnapped me and now I'm going to die.
We all know that's not how it's going to turn out. No, she's going to slowly get to know the Turtles for who they really are on the inside. Not just mutants, not just ninjas, not just turtles...teens. Teens whom she will grow to trust and love and respect. And she will extend this trust and love and respect to their father as well.
I thought of this theory after the second trailer came out. Suddenly, after spending just 2 minutes and 43 seconds with these monsters, many of us realized that they were still the same guys we all grew up with. Those who initially boycotted the movies now decided to give it a shot. Those who were already excited for the film exploded in joy.
Though ugly, though unsettling, though monsterous, they are still the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
Sorry for the long post, but I just had to get that off my chest. To those of you who got through this, thanks for reading.
-Jonaas
I guess that's part of it too. Imagine if Tim Burton was behind the film instead.
slingtheory
07-13-2014, 01:38 PM
This is not going to get 5 movies. There is no way that is gonna happen.I'm just cynical enough about stuff like this to not count it out as a possiblity just like I'm cynical enough to think viacom might decide the whole franchise should look like this if it makes them enough money.
Warhorse
07-13-2014, 02:06 PM
Can we put a ban on the word haters?
As one who is often referred to as a "hater", I think I speak for everyone "against" the designs when I say that we don't take issue with ugly, just this version of ugly.
I'm all for the turtles being grotesque & beastly, or even a bit of uncanny valley, but for me, that brings to mind the work of Zulli, Farley, characters like Tokka, Slash, not lips & noses (though those features can be done justice, a lot of us agree on that point when it comes to the designs of "Out Of The Shadows").
At any rate, this kinda stuff has been discussed to death, no "new" perspective is going to change how anyone feels. Folks on either side of this issue are very passionate & firm in their stance. I imagine this is just going to drum up more beef between the sides (who, I think, lately, have been getting along better).
How long before this thread gets locked. But yeah, I agree with you here. I think we should just wait till the movie comes out, which is less than a month now, before we can get back to our brigades.
Sighphi
07-13-2014, 02:24 PM
I came up with this theory in that thread you mentioned.
The kids look waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay more disturbing than the adults.
I really dont know what the hell they are going for here.
Arent we supposed to think these things are cute so we can be on their side?
Right now i see is a bunch of weird ass monsters. This is more of a Hunchback thing going on than a fun anthro movie about turtle things that kick butt.
But i dont really see the point.
It's highly likely that the development from fear to acceptance in this movie is going to be 3 lines of dialogue so they took this tremendously long detour for nothing.
Hannurdock
07-13-2014, 02:31 PM
For mutants, they look amazing. Don't think they look ugly. Different, but not ugly
IndigoErth
07-13-2014, 02:48 PM
But here's my theory, something I haven't heard mentioned before (and if it has been, sorry if this post is redundant...I didn't feel like digging through pages of pages of posts to see if I was being unoriginal).
The new Turtles are ugly because they're monsters.
I've seen it said, but not too often.
Opinions and all that, though personally I don't agree, and for a big reason of:
In short, we love the Turtles because deep down, they're just like us (minus all the ninja stuff, of course).
The Turtles have always been in a weird spot. They shouldn't feel quite like humans, nor animals, but at the same time should feel like people. Beings we can connect with, who feel like just another person but aren't quite us. A brother from another species mother. If they're "monsters"... we lose that.
They're so much closer to us than most other "superhero" types are capable of being... It would be hard to connect with a character that has super powers we can never have. These guys how ever have no more super powers than we have. Maybe they are stronger, but their abilities come down to skill and training, and via an art that has it's real life equivalents that isn't entirely out of reach for real people. (Most of us would simply lack the actual reason to use it.) If they're over powered "monsters"... then it's like some part of them is just kinda.. gone.
There really isn't any reason that they couldn't have kept at least some degree of physical appeal other than simply choosing not to. MY theory... this is clearly a very youthful, 21st century masculine take on it. I believe the reasons they made them big and creepy looking is not too far off from the same reasons why many young male MMO game players, like on WoW, gravitate toward playing the creepier looking "bad" side. Because in the limited mentality of our society being a fugly monster that's possibly on steroids equals being cooler, more badass, more masculine. The 21st century does not believe you can be a badass and do it while being half decent looking.
I don't need them to look completely like the old style, nor do they need to be 100% adorable... but for christ sake, someone make some cuteagen for these guys, even just a light dab of it would do wonders.
My fake theory: they made them that way to help fend off the fangirls.
Edit: I suppose it also comes down to them having a very wide, mixed audience. I mean, a lot of media has a very specific gender/age target and while companies like Nick might AIM for that, these guys as a whole appeal to so many and probably for different reasons/aspects of them and really none of it is "wrong." Not really any reason it's wrong for someone to prefer them creepy, nor is it wrong to prefer them on the cuter side... but it needs to be understood and ok that if it leans too far to one of those sides (or some other side entirely) it's going to be a let down for some people but it's not wrong of them to feel that way...
Can we put a ban on the word haters?
Fine, no more Haters. How about "Againsters?"
Imo... "critics" would be a better term. Anyone can be a critic of something and it's not always a negative. Haters, againsters, etc. leans too strongly on an "us vs them" mentality... and no fanbase needs that.
Don't call me a "hater" for not likely their model facial choices and I won't refer those who are in love with it as "screen humpers."
People are mainly complaining about the ugly faces for Michelangelo, Donatello, and slighty Raphael. Leo is the only turtle with a decent face. I mean look at it! He is like Brad Pitt.
Oh god, I wish I could agree... :P I'm very glad that many seem to think he does look the best, in comparison, but being my adored fave I'm still a bit sad over what they've done... lol
Ironically enough if you look at the PD Turtles and then refer to Zulli's "monstrous" versions from Mirage Vol.1 you can see a huge resemblance in both. I even think that when the creative team behind the new look was studying reference materials they more than likely ran into Zulli's work and it became the inspiration for their designs. He even went as far as putting human lips on them at times.
SwiftNinjaFox
07-13-2014, 03:03 PM
I just think they aren't designed that great. They're less turtles mutated into humanoid forms and more human/turtle hybrids.
Like someone else said, it's not just the face. I hate the lack of actual plastron and it's just sculpted conveniently into the shape of muscular physique leading down to the v line towards the groin. The lack of a connection from plastron to shell and the shells look like they're just glued to their backs and in some images look like they're going to fall off (Don had a pic that REALLY looked like the shell wasn't connected from the shoulder blade area of his back upwards. And then their shells almost reach the top of their heads. There's just a lot "not turtle" about the design to me.
Turtle/human hybrids.
Warhorse
07-13-2014, 03:55 PM
My fake theory: they made them that way to help fend off the fangirls.
My friends and family think this is why they made them the way they did. They wanted this movie to be purely for the boys, that's why the human guy isn't cute, and the Turtles look horrible. I sure as hell hope that's not what they intended when making this movie, because I am pretty sure 50% of the fandom is female. It's very arrogant to ignore half the fandom in favor of the other half.
chrisdude
07-13-2014, 04:27 PM
They may not target every demographic equally, but I don't think anyone selling anything would try to "fend off" anyone.
EDIT:
I see the turtle's appearance like,
Turtle -----|----- Human
Is there only one correct position of that slider? Because when fan art pushes that slider to left, people around here eat it up.
jenna
07-13-2014, 04:30 PM
Making the turtles cute and cuddly (a la Nickelodeon) is a quick and easy way to endear audiences to them. I admit to being a bit shocked by these new 'ugly' turtles when I first saw the pictures / trailers, but I quite like the idea that they are monstrous in appearance, as they would be to us humans if this was real life. In addition, it means that to win over audiences they will need to appeal to a deeper aspect of us, beyond the slightly superficial attraction to 'cuteness'. Strong characterisation, emotive CGI animation etc. If handled well, the ugliness should cease to be a factor. I stress the word 'if'..... :)
IndigoErth
07-13-2014, 04:45 PM
Well, technically I meant in terms of saving the Turtles from fangirls... lol Although trying to target a demographic specifically would be a crying shame and would have to say/agree that there, at least so far hints, is a fairly clear lack of much estrogen on the design team. Dunno if they'd be doing it on purpose necessarily, but maybe it's just very limited minds who don't have the ability to do anything else... Get some more women involved and some might end up surprised by a "Michael Bay film" for once. :P (Personally the overused formula for making movies that 20-year-old guys will go see is getting kind of stale out of Hollywood.)
Xiewin
07-13-2014, 04:48 PM
There are so many Tmnt 2k14 fangirls on Tumblr, that it's impossible to count them all lol
chrisdude
07-13-2014, 04:53 PM
Well, technically I meant in terms of saving the Turtles from fangirls... lol Although trying to target a demographic specifically would be a crying shame and would have to say/agree that there, at least so far hints, is a fairly clear lack of much estrogen on the design team. Dunno if they'd be doing it on purpose necessarily, but maybe it's just very limited minds who don't have the ability to do anything else... Get some more women involved and some might end up surprised by a "Michael Bay film" for once. :P I don't think I'm so in tune to this kind of stuff. Attractive people *are not* usually what gets me to the theater.
There is a cuteness factor that the Nick cartoon wields deftly. It doesn't take long on tumblr see that. From what I'm hearing here, it's not present in this movie. But I don't see either look as cute or ugly...
Warhorse
07-13-2014, 04:54 PM
Well, technically I meant in terms of saving the Turtles from fangirls... lol Although trying to target a demographic specifically would be a crying shame and would have to say/agree that there, at least so far hints, is a fairly clear lack of much estrogen on the design team. Dunno if they'd be doing it on purpose necessarily, but maybe it's just very limited minds who don't have the ability to do anything else... Get some more women involved and some might end up surprised by a "Michael Bay film" for once. :P
Well, I as a woman never really had a hard time with a Michael Bay movie because he usually has good looking guys in there for the girls to look at. Bad Boys has Will Smith, The Rock had Nick Cage (back then, he was good looking) Pearl Harbor had Ben Affleck and Josh Harnette, Armageddon had Affleck and Willis, Transformers had Tyrese, Josh Duhamel, Mark Wahlberg and to a degree, Shia for the tweens. And while I'm not a fangirl in this, I did think Optimus Prime and Side Swipe were gorgeous and badass at the same time.
Galactus
07-13-2014, 05:02 PM
I think this brings up an interesting point that there's a certain divide with fans. To many people who like the Fred Wolf show think the movie should be light and outlandish whereas those who skewer more Mirage end would prefer a dark and realistic movie.
I don't think it's impossible to strike a balance that pleases everyone. Certainly the best example is the 1990 movie and to this day it still baffles me that when it comes to how to approach a movie they've ignored the one movie undeniably worked.
I think they've gone about striking the balance in their own "Michael bay" way and failed hence why no one can really make up their minds what this movie is. The designs are just a sign of that, I don't think anyone purposefully set out to make them ugly but they've taken what is a fine idea that mutated turtles wouldn't be ultra cute and cuddly but gone for overly hulking monster look but with friendly human faces. I don't think it crossed their minds this would look weird to people hence Bay-Mikey's nose was front and center all the initial promo.
That's been the process throughout the entire creation of this movie. They've been ultra stoked about something until severe backlash which leaves them confused. They've made changed to please fans - even while shooting on set and yet I don't think they've ever gotten why these approaches were wrong to begin with - hence why I have little faith they can fix them.
I see the turtle's appearance like,
Turtle -----|----- Human
Is there only one correct position of that slider? Because when fan art pushes that slider to left, people around here eat it up.
I think there's a reason that's the case - they're mutant turtles who originated as turtles, so them looking a bit more like turtles (or at least less human) makes sense. The more "human" they are, the more you get away from that - the more they look like humans who mutated into turtles, if that makes sense. It just doesn't look "right".
chrisdude
07-13-2014, 05:27 PM
I think this brings up an interesting point that there's a certain divide with fans. To many people who like the Fred Wolf show think the movie should be light and outlandish whereas those who skewer more Mirage end would prefer a dark and realistic movie.
I don't think it's impossible to strike a balance that pleases everyone. Certainly the best example is the 1990 movie and to this day it still baffles me that when it comes to how to approach a movie they've ignored the one movie undeniably worked.
I think they've gone about striking the balance in their own "Michael bay" way and failed hence why no one can really make up their minds what this movie is. The designs are just a sign of that, I don't think anyone purposefully set out to make them ugly but they've taken what is a fine idea that mutated turtles wouldn't be ultra cute and cuddly but gone for overly hulking monster look but with friendly human faces. I don't think it crossed their minds this would look weird to people hence Bay-Mikey's nose was front and center all the initial promo.
That's been the process throughout the entire creation of this movie. They've been ultra stoked about something until severe backlash which leaves them confused. They've made changed to please fans - even while shooting on set and yet I don't think they've ever gotten why these approaches were wrong to begin with - hence why I have little faith they can fix them.Such is the perpetual state of TMNT fandom. That's what happens when an adaptation is incredibly loose with the "source material," and is incredibly successful despite it. The Fred Wolf cartoon is the original in the eyes of many, if not most fans. This division is part of why I love IDW and Nickelodeon, because they're blending these elements into something cohesive. I feel like they are the first things that have tried to roll it all up into one. Maybe the next-generation won't be split...
But, with its wild success, awards, and warm fan reception, I would consider the Nickelodeon cartoon to be the balance that pleases everyone.
IndigoErth
07-13-2014, 05:37 PM
Attractive people usually what gets me to the theater.
Well, I as a woman never really had a hard time with a Michael Bay movie because he usually has good looking guys in there for the girls to look at.
Guess I just don't watch enough of his stuff. Couldn't he have used his producer cash to buy, I mean, hire one this time around... lol
Turtles movie... really my only fave 'person' as per usual would be Leo. If they'd at least have made Leo at least a little adorable I'd have been wanting to camp out in front of that damn theater. lol
But alas they didn't so I'm just reduced to being some silly 30-something woman going...
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-Vd9884OYUt4/Ueyd7XRQPDI/AAAAAAAABKg/5i0wDEL6asA/s1600/why.gif
https://p.gr-assets.com/540x540/fit/hostedimages/1380382497/740386.gif
(For the record don't take this as drama though... I laughed my ass off looking for gifs.)
Trying to find those bits I like (those blue eyes at least), but their choices don't make it easy.
Warhorse
07-13-2014, 06:19 PM
I think this brings up an interesting point that there's a certain divide with fans. To many people who like the Fred Wolf show think the movie should be light and outlandish whereas those who skewer more Mirage end would prefer a dark and realistic movie.
I don't think it's impossible to strike a balance that pleases everyone. Certainly the best example is the 1990 movie and to this day it still baffles me that when it comes to how to approach a movie they've ignored the one movie undeniably worked.
I think they've gone about striking the balance in their own "Michael bay" way and failed hence why no one can really make up their minds what this movie is. The designs are just a sign of that, I don't think anyone purposefully set out to make them ugly but they've taken what is a fine idea that mutated turtles wouldn't be ultra cute and cuddly but gone for overly hulking monster look but with friendly human faces. I don't think it crossed their minds this would look weird to people hence Bay-Mikey's nose was front and center all the initial promo.
That's been the process throughout the entire creation of this movie. They've been ultra stoked about something until severe backlash which leaves them confused. They've made changed to please fans - even while shooting on set and yet I don't think they've ever gotten why these approaches were wrong to begin with - hence why I have little faith they can fix them.
I personally, think they could make a TMNT movie that is both comical and outlandish like that in the 80's and also have dark and seriousness when called for. KickAss did a pretty good job doing that. Heck, the first TMNT movie did a pretty good job doing it. So did X-Men United.
Originally Posted by IndigoErth View Post
Guess I just don't watch enough of his stuff. Couldn't he have used his producer cash to buy, I mean, hire one this time around... lol
Turtles movie... really my only fave 'person' as per usual would be Leo. If they'd at least have made Leo at least a little adorable I'd have been wanting to camp out in front of that damn theater. lol
But alas they didn't so I'm just reduced to being some silly 30-something woman going...
Trying to find those bits I like (those blue eyes at least), but their choices don't make it easy.
Eh, I guess I'm just going to have to look for the action sequences. In the movie Watchmen, while I really didn't care for the movie as a whole, I totally digged Rorschach, despite him being the least appealing to the eye compared to the other guys in that movie. He just had the better character and the best action scenes.
So, who knows, maybe Raphael will do something that's stunning that we haven't seen before.
Slade
07-13-2014, 09:27 PM
I don't know if anyone has said this yet as I haven't read everything, but where the designs done when the old script was out? You know, while they where aliens? I actually think try look like thy because they where supposed to be aliens.
If the designs came after though then nevermind.
Werecat
07-13-2014, 09:34 PM
I don't know if anyone has said this yet as I haven't read everything, but where the designs done when the old script was out? You know, while they where aliens? I actually think try look like thy because they where supposed to be aliens.
If the designs came after though then nevermind.
I thought them all being aliens was actually a misconception. The Micheal Bay interview didn't specifically say they were aliens. I thought Bay mean the turtle would be created by an ooze from aliens. Such as the utroms, who created the ooze. The turtles are indirectly created by aliens. So I am thinking there was a bit of misunderstanding going on.
I thought them all being aliens was actually a misconception. The Micheal Bay interview didn't specifically say they were aliens. I thought Bay mean the turtle would be created by an ooze from aliens. Such as the utroms, who created the ooze. The turtles are indirectly created by aliens. So I am thinking there was a bit of misunderstanding going on.
An early draft of the script codenamed "The Blue Door" was leaked online a few years ago (http://www.latino-review.com/news/2012/08/exclusive-bays-failed-ninja-turtles-script-review). It was... amazingly terrible, and was promptly torn apart and mocked far and wide for its massive, wrong-headed changes to the very core of the concept. Bay himself confirmed its legitimacy, but claimed it was written before he was involved with the project. However, the script was dated 2012 and Bay joined the project in 2010, so that doesn't seem to be true. More likely he was attempting to distance himself from the controversy.
Galactus
07-13-2014, 09:51 PM
I thought them all being aliens was actually a misconception. The Micheal Bay interview didn't specifically say they were aliens. I thought Bay mean the turtle would be created by an ooze from aliens. Such as the utroms, who created the ooze. The turtles are indirectly created by aliens. So I am thinking there was a bit of misunderstanding going on.
Bay much later claimed it was a misunderstanding, that they were never meant to be aliens and that the Blue Door script that had the turtles and Shredder as aliens despite being real was from the other production company that had it before Platinum Dunes and was nothing to do with them.
The likelihood that he'd say the turtles are "from an alien race" and there's coincidentally a completely unrelated script that has them as aliens is slim even before taking into account the date on the script was after Bay personally got involved.
Bay and Leibesman had months and several interviews to clear it up if it really was a misunderstanding but we got clever dodging of the question until after it was reported the movie was delayed and being changed.
Also it should be noted several aspects of that script as still in the movie suggesting it was rewritten into what we have now.
So yes; the turtles were definitely going to be aliens.
IndigoErth
07-13-2014, 10:13 PM
If it WAS a misunderstanding, then Bay is either idiot with his wording or tries way too hard to sound all big and professional and junk. Personally he sounds like a jerky human being that will try to cover his ass if he feels necessary.
Refractive Reflections
07-13-2014, 10:20 PM
While I agree it could be an interesting thought to consider, but... this is a Liebesman and Bay film. And their work is not really noted for having any deep themes or using profound literary devices and visual symbolism. In addition, if their grotesque appearances were such a priority in the storywriting, why would their designs be so visually distracting with so much superfluous clothes and armor that stereotype their personalities even further? Furthermore, why stop at the faces? Why not push it further in having claw-like nails or completely redoing their carapace and/or plastron into something completely new? Why not let them grow body hair if they are supposed to be more humanoid?
So anyway, considering the previous works of Liebesman and Bay, it seems to be way more focused on aesthetic "bad ass" imagery (hulkish size and strength, brash clothing, etc.) and being teen male "cool" (by removing all cuteness) rather than some deeper metaphorical meaning.
IndigoErth
07-13-2014, 10:33 PM
focused on aesthetic "bad ass" imagery (hulkish size and strength, brash clothing, etc.) and being teen male "cool" (by removing all cuteness)
Yeah, exactly my thoughts. The sort of movie style that is superficially hyper masculine just to make a quick buck. Maybe as a whole it will turn out ok, I dunno... But possibly getting the treatment of that superficial film style makes me a bit sad to see it done to the Turtles, our Turtles.
chrisdude
07-13-2014, 10:35 PM
I meant to say that attractive people aren't usually what gets me to the theater. I was trying to say that I can't relate to ugly turtles being a problem.
Sometimes, when I'm on mobile, I like to dictate my text, and I didn't catch that mistake.
Werecat
07-13-2014, 10:51 PM
An early draft of the script codenamed "The Blue Door" was leaked online a few years ago (http://www.latino-review.com/news/2012/08/exclusive-bays-failed-ninja-turtles-script-review). It was... amazingly terrible, and was promptly torn apart and mocked far and wide for its massive, wrong-headed changes to the very core of the concept. Bay himself confirmed its legitimacy, but claimed it was written before he was involved with the project. However, the script was dated 2012 and Bay joined the project in 2010, so that doesn't seem to be true. More likely he was attempting to distance himself from the controversy.
Oh, I forgot about that. Oh yeah that was terrible.
plastroncafe
07-13-2014, 10:59 PM
I quite like that they're hideous freaks of nature.
I just wish they didn't fall quite so hard into the Uncanny Valley while doing so.
But...yeah, I could do without the LET'S TAKE THIS MASCULINE POWER FANTASY TO ELEVEN stuff, but that's just me. Someday Hollywood will remember that the Greatest American Action Movie Ever Made didn't star a 'roided out knuckledragger...but Bruce Willis in a tanktop.
Someday.
SwiftNinjaFox
07-14-2014, 12:25 AM
But...yeah, I could do without the LET'S TAKE THIS MASCULINE POWER FANTASY TO ELEVEN stuff, but that's just me. Someday Hollywood will remember that the Greatest American Action Movie Ever Made didn't star a 'roided out knuckledragger...but Bruce Willis in a tanktop.
Someday.
http://media.giphy.com/media/xLJE238iO1Cta/giphy.gif
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-14-2014, 12:29 AM
Yeah, exactly my thoughts. The sort of movie style that is superficially hyper masculine just to make a quick buck. Maybe as a whole it will turn out ok, I dunno... But possibly getting the treatment of that superficial film style makes me a bit sad to see it done to the Turtles, our Turtles.
not to defend the guy...but Bay is a spaz and i mean that in the nicest way
i once read an article where the writer literally put a disclaimer that said
" i did not know how to transcribe this so i put it word for word as i heard it"
reading it myself i found it was very hard to follow what he was trying to say
the guys thoughts and words are everywhere...he is like a 5 year old with add
graphic_content
07-14-2014, 12:33 AM
not to defend the guy...but Bay is a spaz and i mean that in the nicest way
i once read an article where the writer literally put a disclaimer that said
" i did not know how to transcribe this so i put it word for word as i heard it"
the guys thoughts and words are everywhere...he is like a 5 year old with add
not to be mean, because I like me some mindless action from time to time, but clearly Bay ISNT the most eloquent of speakers, he needs a teleprompter, and a script just to speak in public; obviously improv isnt his thing. :lol:
Werecat
07-14-2014, 12:33 AM
not to defend the guy...but Bay is a spaz and i mean that in the nicest way
i once read an article where the writer literally put a disclaimer that said
" i did not know how to transcribe this so i put it word for word as i heard it"
the guys thoughts and words are everywhere...he is like a 5 year old with add
Do you know the writer's name and what article? If it is one of the critically acclaimed writers then that is not good.
Newton Gimmick
07-14-2014, 12:44 AM
I'm more annoyed by their giant shells which don't look anything like real turtle shells and are closer to overstuffed backpacks, than any other part of the design.
But I think it's a pretty safe call to say that these are the worst designs of the turtles to date and if you had to come up with the worst TMNT redesign ever while still retaining the basic elements, this would be near to top of the list. So there's that.
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-14-2014, 12:46 AM
not to be mean, because I like me some mindless action from time to time, but clearly Bay ISNT the most eloquent of speakers, he needs a teleprompter, and a script just to speak in public; obviously improv isnt his thing. :lol:
oh no dont get me wrong i love me some mindless action, i love the expendable films and we all know stallone isnt the most clear when it comes to speaking
but when it comes to interviews the bays mind just doesnt sit still,
now that i think about it you can actually see why his movies are that way
Do you know the writer's name and what article? If it is one of the critically acclaimed writers then that is not good.
it was back when tf2 came out so i dont remember all the details but i will try to find it
graphic_content
07-14-2014, 12:47 AM
I'm more annoyed by their giant shells which don't look anything like real turtle shells and are closer to overstuffed backpacks, than any other part of the design.
But I think it's a pretty safe call to say that these are the worst designs of the turtles to date and if you had to come up with the worst TMNT redesign ever while still retaining the basic elements, this would be near to top of the list. So there's that.
personally i dig the high arch of the shell, reminds me the Kung Fu master, Oogway, from KUNG FU PANDA. but to each his own.
ProactiveMan
07-14-2014, 12:53 AM
I have a theory as to why they wear pants now. I think we are subconsciously supposed to assume that they have are capable of human(oid) relations... so to speak.
graphic_content
07-14-2014, 12:55 AM
I have a theory as to why they wear pants now. I think we are subconsciously supposed to assume that they have are capable of human(oid) relations... so to speak.
I genuinely hope you ARENT right. I've always hated the idea of ANY iteration of the Turtles falling for their human allies. Which is why I dont much care for the NICK show, for several reasons, including the whole Donnie/April thing, which for a smart, practical guy, youd think Donnie would understand that cultivating a romantic relationship with a human being, wont yield any dividends. dumb.
FakeBritishAccent
07-14-2014, 01:05 AM
Great replies, everyone! I've read through every post and I respect everyone's opinion. I'm also happy that everyone's been able to voice their opinion without matters erupting into a flame war.
Let me just say for the record that I am in no way trying to change anyone's mind or get him or her on my side. My theory was only an opinion (and I'm glad to see others have shared that opinion, even if their overall take on the PD Turtles isn't as favorable as mine). At the end of the day, I really just want to enjoy the movie (if it's enjoyable, of course). Whether or not the movie will be good is yet to be seen...but if I walk in with an already negative view on the film based on the design of the Turtles, I've already shot myself in the foot before the race has even begun.
That being said, in an effort to redirect the thread, I wanna take a quick survey. It may seem like an easy answer, but it's really not (especially since we all have conflicting views on the PD Turtles):
Who wants this movie to succeed?
I mean critically, commercially, and most importantly, in the eyes of diehard fans.
I have a theory as to why they wear pants now. I think we are subconsciously supposed to assume that they have are capable of human(oid) relations... so to speak.
Have you ever seen Animation Domination's "Real Life Ninja Turtles" short? Perhaps you're onto something here :lol:
While we're on the subject, I was was just wondering: Were Zulli's loin-clothed Turtles the first to hide their shame?
I genuinely hope you ARENT right. I've always hated the idea of ANY iteration of the Turtles falling for their human allies. Which is why I dont much care for the NICK show, for several reasons, including the whole Donnie/April thing, which for a smart, practical guy, youd think Donnie would understand that cultivating a romantic relationship with a human being, wont yield any dividends. dumb.
I for one believe the whole Donnie/April thing was just a bit of business to make Donnie more relatable. Not only that, his crush on April is what fueled Donnie's best moments. Making him a chivalrous hero gives him more dimension than just being the nerd. In any case, since April and Casey have shacked up, Donnie's crush is kind of a non-issue (unless his jealousy of him is played for laughs...which it frequently is and I LOVE. Remember that bit with the fear mushrooms?)
However, now that Karai is a mutant, how do you feel about Leo's supposed relationship with her? And I know this is going down a sticky road, what with the two of them kinda being brother and sister, but I wanna focus on just the interspecies angle for now.
graphic_content
07-14-2014, 01:11 AM
Who wants this movie to succeed?
I mean critically, commercially, and most importantly, in the eyes of diehard fans.
honestly, i would love it if some of the leery crowd left the theaters having actually enjoyed the film - not in a sadistic, 'ha, suck it, you were wrong' kinda way, but for me the more people that enjoy the film, the better i feel about TMNT's success and ongoing endurance.
as for critically - there is a youtube critic, Jeremy Jahns who I follow regularly, and he is hilarious, but has great insightful things to say about the films he reviews. for some reason, because I dig his videos so much, it would be great if he dug the film because he has a strong viewer base that take his word as gospel. every little bit helps.
I for one believe the whole Donnie/April thing was just a bit of business to make Donnie more relatable. Not only that, his crush on April is what fueled Donnie's best moments. Making him a chivalrous hero gives him more dimension than just being the nerd.
However, now that Karai is a mutant, how do you feel about Leo's supposed relationship with her? And I know this is going down a sticky road, what with the two of them kinda being brother and sister, but I wanna focus on just the interspecies angle for now.
i cant honestly say bro, my apologies. i stopped following the show after season 1 ended. but I do agree that Donnie, stepping out his shell (lol), have been his best moments.
I cant believe that Karai is a mutant now! :o (im behind - on the NICK show at least)
Shark_Blade
07-14-2014, 01:16 AM
They're not "ugly" to me.
They're amazing.
However, now that Karai is a mutant, how do you feel about Leo's supposed relationship with her? And I know this is going down a sticky road, what with the two of them kinda being brother and sister, but I wanna focus on just the interspecies angle for now.They're not technically siblings though.
IndigoErth
07-14-2014, 01:22 AM
I have a theory as to why they wear pants now. I think we are subconsciously supposed to assume that they have are capable of human(oid) relations... so to speak.
Shhhhh.... don't make me think of that. Again. I think most minds have gone there at his point, and not even just subconsciously. lol (Oh dear, turtle junk... *blush* When you know they leaned a little too human. lol)
honestly, i would love it if some of the leery crowd left the theaters having actually enjoyed the film - not in a sadistic, 'ha, suck it, you were wrong' kinda way, but for me the more people that enjoy the film, the better i feel about TMNT's success and ongoing endurance.
Well I have to admit that on the reverse I'd almost like to hear a few of the more fanatical say it was good but not quite as much as their own personal hype was expecting... just because some of them are just as annoying as their opposite counterparts.
Although I don't really fear any negative repercussions or anything on TMNT for this. These folks don't own them and even if their movie ended up sucking rotten turtle eggs, the Turtles will survive just fine I am sure... fans too.
FakeBritishAccent
07-14-2014, 01:55 AM
honestly, i would love it if some of the leery crowd left the theaters having actually enjoyed the film - not in a sadistic, 'ha, suck it, you were wrong' kinda way, but for me the more people that enjoy the film, the better i feel about TMNT's success and ongoing endurance.
Well said, sir. The Turtles were one of (if not THE) first properties to be successful in Every. Single. Medium. (I count the Out of the Shell tour as "Stage" :P ) I'm a childhood fan who fell off as a teen, rediscovered them through my nephew and the 2K3 show and reaffirmed my love with 2012 Turtles and the birth of my son. I'm just fascinated with the all the different turns the characters have taken and I can't wait to see what they'll come up with next.
I cant believe that Karai is a ------- now! :o (im behind - on the NICK show at least)
:teek: Oh, jeez...sorry for the spoiler! I will tell you, though...what I said isn't 100% spoiler and the ramifications of it are sure to be insane. This should really be in the Nick Forum so I'll get off the subject for now, but you should jump back into the series. The last episode was literally the best episode I've seen so far and is pretty much the culmination of the last two years of build up.
They're not technically siblings though.
Yeah, I know. And not even in that "we grew up together so I see her like a sister" kinda way either. But I know that if that relationship blossomed, so to speak, there'd be a thread devoted to the politics of Mutant on Mutant Quasi-Incest.
Well I have to admit that on the reverse I'd almost like to hear a few of the more fanatical say it was good but not quite as much as their own personal hype was expecting... just because some of them are just as annoying as their opposite counterparts.
Although I don't really fear any negative repercussions or anything on TMNT for this. These folks don't own them and even if their movie ended up sucking rotten turtle eggs, the Turtles will survive just fine I am sure... fans too.
I have to say I feel like I'LL be one of those Hyped-Up/Let Down folks if only because I've been absolutely nutty about every little bit of new pics/footage/toys etc. I know I'll enjoy it no matter what, but I also know there's no way it will be as amazing as I expected it to be.
Oddly enough, the last time hype got the best of me was Secret of the Ooze. As a 10 year-old of course I LOVED every bit of that movie, and without shame I blasted "Ninja Rap" from my mom's stereo during every car ride. Watching it again 20 years later was a bad mistake...ooh boy, that movie's a turd...especially after comparing it to the first film! I really should've left my memories of part II alone :ohwell:
Lil G
07-14-2014, 02:28 AM
Whether or not one would think the designs look good or not, I like the fact that they have us thinking about things we wouldn't normally think about. What's a form of entertainment without controversy? Boring.
Hannurdock
07-14-2014, 03:29 AM
I hope the movie succeeds. If nothing else, it brings another interpretation of TMNT into the mainstream. Always good :)
There is a theory going around that the new Ninja Turtles from the upcoming Michael Bay film are ugly.
I respect everyone's opinion on it; but I don't feel the same.
When I look at the new turtles, I feel in awe and plain excitement at their new incarnation. I don't love the turtles because they are cute and playful. I love the turtles because of their very distinct personalities and I love them no matter what package they come in.
As long as the fundamental aspects of their characters remains intact, I'm a very happy girl.
Splinter and Shredder look awesome, by the way :) I totally want to adopt Master Splinter right now. (I used to keep ratties, :lol: )
Leonardo
http://cdn.screenrant.com/wp-content/uploads/Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-2014-Leonardo.jpg
The design of our fearless leader is unbelievably cool. He looks slender almost in the above shot. Very muscular, toned and mutanty. I like the stuff he's clothed himself with, it gives a little Japanese edge to him. The only reason the roof is crumbling is because he leapt onto it with great force and its a ****** roof, damn cowboy builders! :lol:
Michelangelo
http://pbs.twimg.com/media/Bj3iZYTCQAA3TMM.jpg:medium
Okay, I do see a resemblance between Shrek and Mikey. He's green, after all. He has a broad face. He looks almost playful in this scene. I reckon he knows that April will pass out. :lol:
Donatello
http://media.charged.fm/media/file_53628046045f1.jpg
The only turtle I was actually unsure with at the beginning has grown in my estimations. I also love the shot of him in the Pizza Hut commercial. He seems a lot like Donny from the 2003 cartoon with his techno-advanced stuff and I'm glad.
Raphael
http://www.cinemablend.com/images/news/42812/_1398892219.jpg
Oooooo, the one I'm really excited about. Raph looks like a complete battle axe in the movie shots. He seems bigger than the others and a lot more threatening.
.......
0.46 ..... Oh, and you got it wrong! That's Leo, not Donny!!!! Grrrrrr ....
Sorry, just had to share because this winds me up every time I watch it.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-WgRkaMaB8
pennydreadful
07-14-2014, 04:42 AM
Hey Fake - well-thought-out post and it was a pleasure to read. I'd love to think that the creative decisions behind the new designs were meaningful... but honestly, I think it more came down to making it a more appealing action flick for the dude-bros in the audience. Hence why we also got Fox. :tgrumble:
As I've said before, I'm hoping that the guys' personalities will help me get over the faces, and that maybe the movie will somehow sell me on them.
I am still finding the size and weight of the shells quite startling... from what we've seen, obviously it's not impeding their movements at all, I'm just not used to seeing the Turtles mostly walking around in a hunched/crouched position, so it's giving me a little cognitive dissonance.
That being said, if the powers behind this movie thought that changing the designs would prevent lusty fangirls from writing tawdry fics about the fearless four... they don't know fangirls very well! :lol:
Great replies, everyone! I've read through every post and I respect everyone's opinion. I'm also happy that everyone's been able to voice their opinion without matters erupting into a flame war.
http://media.giphy.com/media/iVzrExLJNvwQM/giphy.gif
Cheers to that! I may not like how they look or agree with your opinions exactly, but I can appreciate your perspective, and it's nice for both sides to be able to express their opinions without being insulted or shouted down. Civil discussion! :tthumbsu:
Let me just say for the record that I am in no way trying to change anyone's mind or get him or her on my side. My theory was only an opinion (and I'm glad to see others have shared that opinion, even if their overall take on the PD Turtles isn't as favorable as mine).
Yeah, I can definitely appreciate that. And your take is interesting. I don't have much faith that the people actually making this movie have put anywhere near as much thought into their design choices as you have, but... that remains to be proven. Maybe I'm wrong.
That being said, in an effort to redirect the thread, I wanna take a quick survey. It may seem like an easy answer, but it's really not (especially since we all have conflicting views on the PD Turtles):
Who wants this movie to succeed?
I mean critically, commercially, and most importantly, in the eyes of diehard fans.
Hoo. Well, that's definitely not a simple answer. But... potentially yes, and potentially no, and it depends on if the movie is actually good or not.
Ultimately, I want a good new TMNT movie. Very, very badly. Something that satisfies most fans and critics, much like the Marvel movies have, and prove that this concept has more depth and potential than a lot of the general public realizes.
I have specific ideas of what a "good TMNT movie" would mean for me personally, and based on what I've seen this movie doesn't seem to do that. Which is fine - it doesn't have to be made for me specifically. But the history of the project, the track records of the producer and director, the character design, the visual style, and all of the trailers/ads I've seen so far, all make me pretty nervous about how it's going to turn out. I'm just not a fan of what I've seen so far. I'd love to be pleasantly surprised, but as of this point I'm completely unconvinced and don't plan to see it (well... at least not if I have to pay for it).
Basically, I don't want the movie to be successful just because it's a TMNT movie. I want a good TMNT movie to be successful. If this isn't a good movie, I'd rather see it fail and have the studio reboot the franchise and try something different years down the line.
SwiftNinjaFox
07-14-2014, 02:20 PM
I genuinely hope you ARENT right. I've always hated the idea of ANY iteration of the Turtles falling for their human allies. Which is why I dont much care for the NICK show, for several reasons, including the whole Donnie/April thing, which for a smart, practical guy, youd think Donnie would understand that cultivating a romantic relationship with a human being, wont yield any dividends. dumb.
Wouldn't that then be every iteration of the turtles ever in some way? Except IDW...so far.
IndigoErth
07-14-2014, 02:46 PM
Hey Fake - well-thought-out post and it was a pleasure to read. I'd love to think that the creative decisions behind the new designs were meaningful... but honestly, I think it more came down to making it a more appealing action flick for the dude-bros in the audience. Hence why we also got Fox. :tgrumble:
As I've said before, I'm hoping that the guys' personalities will help me get over the faces, and that maybe the movie will somehow sell me on them.
I am still finding the size and weight of the shells quite startling... from what we've seen, obviously it's not impeding their movements at all, I'm just not used to seeing the Turtles mostly walking around in a hunched/crouched position, so it's giving me a little cognitive dissonance.
That being said, if the powers behind this movie thought that changing the designs would prevent lusty fangirls from writing tawdry fics about the fearless four... they don't know fangirls very well! :lol:
Allll this...
I dunno, call me superficial, but whatever... people are always superficial about female fictional characters, so why shouldn't male characters get the same. It's like, you know... as a female fan, if you're gonna give us characters that are all muscly and human proportioned enough that one has to resist looking too much because they aren't frigging human and looking too much feels awkward but a little bit of looking can't be helped and then... if you're gonna make it such a challenge to not ogle muscles... gah! could at at least have made them a little cute. :goof: [cue dramatic old movie hand-to-forehead fainting scene because a lady just can not take this] Think of the women! lol
Also I've come to the conclusion that they're ALL wearing lather straps despite half not needing them for weapons because the shells are so big and heavy looking... Leather straps = shell support. Like a bra. :P
graphic_content
07-14-2014, 02:53 PM
Wouldn't that then be every iteration of the turtles ever in some way? Except IDW...so far.
and its bothered me every time. :lol:
Mr.Green
07-14-2014, 02:59 PM
They're not technically siblings though.
But they are since the Turtles mutated directly from Hamato Yoshi's DNA so they're more like half siblings.
Lou 500
07-14-2014, 03:40 PM
I don't think they look as ugly or as frightening as they could have been. This looks pretty fightening to me, though:
http://fc07.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2012/340/d/d/real_tmnt_ninja_turtles_concept_art_2014_by_onetru th-d4zb93x.jpg
I think it's the fact that it has human teeth that just seem to be pasted into his mouth, along with the black and red skin and 3-inch claws.
There's also this:
http://fc07.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2014/015/5/7/real_tmnt___raphael_by_kenbarthelmey-d4q8t9f.jpg
Which I also find pretty disturbing, but not as bad as the top one and closer to what we've got.
plastroncafe
07-14-2014, 03:52 PM
My high water mark for success isn't all that high.
I just want an entertaining movie that convinced me that Mutant Turtles are real for 90 minutes. The fewer plot holes the better. Bonus points for no sexism or racism.
I don't need this movie to be a financial success, or even to appease every fanboy on earth, I just need it to be a good story told well.
Galactus
07-14-2014, 04:00 PM
My high water mark for success isn't all that high.
I just want an entertaining movie that convinced me that Mutant Turtles are real for 90 minutes. The fewer plot holes the better. Bonus points for no sexism or racism.
I don't need this movie to be a financial success, or even to appease every fanboy on earth, I just need it to be a good story told well.
I think you may be out of luck on this one.
plastroncafe
07-14-2014, 04:17 PM
I think you may be out of luck on this one.
All the more reason I'm happy to be going for free.
IndigoErth
07-14-2014, 04:23 PM
There's also this:
http://fc07.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2014/015/5/7/real_tmnt___raphael_by_kenbarthelmey-d4q8t9f.jpg
Which I also find pretty disturbing, but not as bad as the top one and closer to what we've got.
Burn it with fire! Although at least the looks of that makes a tiny bit more sense if a lifetime of cigar smoking as been involved... lol
SwiftNinjaFox
07-14-2014, 04:32 PM
Burn it with fire! Although at least the looks of that makes a tiny bit more sense if a lifetime of cigar smoking as been involved... lol
Ironically, I personally see a lot of the movie Raph in that picture. Just more bulked up on muscles.
IndigoErth
07-14-2014, 04:41 PM
I can bring enough fire for two... >.> :goof:
plastroncafe
07-14-2014, 04:42 PM
Woah woah woah woah, "...won't yield dividends."
So...every single romantic relationship is worthless unless viable offspring are produced?
Wow, way to suck the romance out of, well...romance.
Refractive Reflections
07-14-2014, 06:12 PM
There's also this:
http://fc07.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2014/015/5/7/real_tmnt___raphael_by_kenbarthelmey-d4q8t9f.jpg
Which I also find pretty disturbing, but not as bad as the top one and closer to what we've got.
That reminds me more of the creatures from the film franchise Predator actually. :lol:
IndigoErth
07-14-2014, 06:44 PM
Woah woah woah woah, "...won't yield dividends."
So...every single romantic relationship is worthless unless viable offspring are produced?
Wow, way to suck the romance out of, well...romance.
Silly humans need to mind their own business... :goof: who cares what two consenting adults do. Granted first the Turtles need to be allowed to be adults because as long as they're still labeled as teens that should be weird/creepy for more than one reason! lol
(Imagine the wedding party. o.O Actually...I would not mind seeing the art someone with good talent might come up for that. :D )
slingtheory
07-14-2014, 07:14 PM
That being said, in an effort to redirect the thread, I wanna take a quick survey. It may seem like an easy answer, but it's really not (especially since we all have conflicting views on the PD Turtles):
Who wants this movie to succeed?
I mean critically, commercially, and most importantly, in the eyes of diehard fans.
.
A very good question. If I'm honest with myself then I have to say no I'm not really hoping for success here. Now before anybody gets the idea that I'm saying that just because I don't like let me make it clear that's not the case. I admit its a little disappointing that there's a new live action tmnt movie coming for the first time in 20 years and I'm just not into it but there's so many other places for me to get my turtle fix right now it doesn't bother me as much as it could. What does bother me is the road it could take us down.One of the things I've come to like most about this franchise is that there's a version for almost everyone. Doesn't matter if you're into dark and gritty, light hearted and silly. Or something in between there's a turtles story out there for you. Now we get to add testerone fueled and over the top to the list and that in itself I don't think is a bad thing on its own. Not as long as options exist as they always have. What bothers me is the thought that if this thing does big enough numbers some exec somewhere might make those options disappear in the name of brand synergy which worries me as I'm someone who like the concept for being a lot of things that it doesn't seem to be in this particular take. It doesn't help that I can't imagine anyone who wasn't already into these characters liking this movie and deciding to check out any other turtles stuff. Even if they do it'll be so different from the the film they fell in love with they probably won't be sticking around. Much more likely in my mind is the idea that if viacom wants to keep these new fans interested they)l have to make it all look like what they became interested in. With the co creators out of a position to veto any of the crazier ideas that's a scary thought
M-Frame
07-14-2014, 07:45 PM
FakeBritishAccent, I couldn't agree more. Hell, I said the Same Exact **** back in March in the the thread titled 'What do you think of the first Teaser?', but unfortunately I think it went unnoticed due to all the hate, butt-hurt, and nerd rage going around at the time.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=46665&page=271
....To me, their over-the-top abnormal appearance and immensity do a good job of emphasizing their differences from humanity and how it would be impossible for them to live among humans. That, and they just look menacing. They're miscreated sewer-dwelling mutant turtle men, after all. What would you expect them to look like? Their whole existence is the result of a freak accident. People argue that they're size isn't suitable 'cuz they're supposed to be ninjas, but they weren't created or meant to be ninjas. Hell, they weren't meant to 'be', period! They're freaks of nature, so the fact that they're so bizarre looking and colossal kinda works in that context, IMO.
IMO, the idea behind the designs is that if the Ninja Turtles actually existed then that's what they might look like, but I think that was lost on a lot of people. I don't get it. They're transfigured monsters, so what does it matter if they aren't cute or attractive??? Either get over it or skip the movie and continue watching the '87 cartoon and playing with that "Hose 'Em Down Donatello" action figure u love so much.
IndigoErth
07-14-2014, 07:55 PM
And when speaking of fictional beings, they "might" look and be in a lot of different ways. Sure, the crud inflicted on them might turn them into "monsters" or it might have the capability of combining the good in both sets of genetics in a really decent way. "Might" doesn't validate any arguments and there is little reason for rudeness over personal opinions that in the long run don't matter if people hold them or not. The debate is clearly very black and white for some people. Butthurt happens on both sides...
Mona_Lisa
07-14-2014, 08:53 PM
Nice insight.
People are mainly complaining about the ugly faces for Michelangelo, Donatello, and slighty Raphael. Leo is the only turtle with a decent face. I mean look at it!
http://www.spotlightreport.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/tmnt-leonardo-movie-2014-600x350.jpg
He is like Brad Pitt. I think the TMNT Movie Facebook page chose Leonardo as their profile picture because he was the only one that looked decent instead of a hideous freak. While Michelangelo is like a cross between Shrek and Sloth from the Goonies. Donatello looks like a cross between a fish and rabbit, the unattractive type of rabbit. Raphael looks somewhat decent, he mainly resembles Azog from the Hobbit.
I think there would be less of a backlash from the fans if they just stayed with the face that Leo had and only made slight alterations. Leonardo barely looks humanoid and looks similar to the other TMNT designs, just with nostrils. Leo's face is the right mixture of mutant and humanoid features. They just screwed up on the others.
This is how I fell, Leos face is way better, If they all looked like him I would not have gotten so worked up... Its those noses!!! LOL. But still, I AM going to give the move a shot. it has potential!
FakeBritishAccent
07-14-2014, 10:19 PM
Whether or not one would think the designs look good or not, I like the fact that they have us thinking about things we wouldn't normally think about. What's a form of entertainment without controversy? Boring.
I agree with this sentiment as an extension of the old adage "Art is meant to provoke" but I think my issues with the disagreements have to do with the factioning of fans. Now, it's the Internet...people are going to disagree FOREVER. But I guess I'm more bothered by in-fighting of a community devoted to a single property.
Although, yes, sunshine and lollipops 24/7 is definitely boring as all hell ;)
Hey Fake - well-thought-out post and it was a pleasure to read. I'd love to think that the creative decisions behind the new designs were meaningful... but honestly, I think it more came down to making it a more appealing action flick for the dude-bros in the audience. Hence why we also got Fox. :tgrumble:
As I've said before, I'm hoping that the guys' personalities will help me get over the faces, and that maybe the movie will somehow sell me on them.
You're probably right about the muscular nature of the boys being something that was pushed for by Bay and Co...but if the trailers are any indication, I believe the macho posturing and bravado will be limited to Raph and Raph alone (inasmuch as we actually see footage of the other three getting their asses beat).
And I have high hopes for their personalities shining through the roid-rage. From the little we've seen, we can already tell the boys are who they've always been. I imagine years from now, some enterprising fan is going to take the dialogue from the PD Turtles and sync it over clips of the first three movies "Nigg@ Turtles" style and it will seem completely normal.
Ultimately, I want a good new TMNT movie. Very, very badly. Something that satisfies most fans and critics, much like the Marvel movies have, and prove that this concept has more depth and potential than a lot of the general public realizes.
Basically, I don't want the movie to be successful just because it's a TMNT movie. I want a good TMNT movie to be successful. If this isn't a good movie, I'd rather see it fail and have the studio reboot the franchise and try something different years down the line.
I agree with you 100% here. But something to consider is that we're all definitely older than we were in 1992 when part II came out. That was a successful movie that we all thought was amazing. As I mentioned before, after rewatching it, I realized just how BAD I now thought it was. This could be due to age, or because my encyclopedia of great films has been widely broadened, but it just doesn't hold up for me (part one does COMPLETELY for me though. Such a great movie). That being said, I still understand that it is unfair to me to bash on part II now because I know for a fact that it brought me such joy as a child. And I think that's the reason why I'm so forgiving towards the supposed missteps of the PD Turtles: I really want to view the movie like a child would.
My high water mark for success isn't all that high.
I just want an entertaining movie that convinced me that Mutant Turtles are real for 90 minutes. The fewer plot holes the better. Bonus points for no sexism or racism.
I don't need this movie to be a financial success, or even to appease every fanboy on earth, I just need it to be a good story told well.
Short and sweet and perfectly said, sir. I honestly believe that April will escape the movie un-leered at. Maybe she'll be the target of some semi-flirty barbs, but those were evident in the first two movies as well! April has always been portrayed as a strong, hard-headed character so I doubt she'll bending over in cutoffs at any time during the movie.
As for the racism, I have sort of touchstone when it comes to Bay movies. It's usually the same scene: Some crazy ish happens and some Eastern guy in a cab or some Black dude on the street will make an highly accented comment about the insanity happening right in front of him. If it happens in PD Turtles, I shall loudly groan, and then through my entire box of Red Vines at the screen.
A very good question. If I'm honest with myself then I have to say no I'm not really hoping for success here. Now before anybody gets the idea that I'm saying that just because I don't like let me make it clear that's not the case. I admit its a little disappointing that there's a new live action tmnt movie coming for the first time in 20 years and I'm just not into it but there's so many other places for me to get my turtle fix right now it doesn't bother me as much as it could.
Oh, of course! Between the Nick show and IDW, we're pretty much covering all bases! If the film fails, none of us will suddenly say "Eff Turtles" and run off to Star Wars land (at least the diehard fans won't) but if it did suck, it would be a real, real drag. I guess we could say there's a lot riding on this film, as another live action take was a gamble that New Line and others refused to take for nearly two decades. I guess I don't want to be 50 before another Turtles flick comes out (but it would be nifty to see my son grow up and take HIS son to Turtles 2034...and me harping on them that Rian Johnson Jr.'s psychically powered cyborg Turtles have nothing on "Secret of the Ooze." :lol:
IMO, the idea behind the designs is that if the Ninja Turtles actually existed then that's what they might look like, but I think that was lost on a lot of people. I don't get it. They're transfigured monsters, so what does it matter if they aren't cute or attractive??? Either get over it or skip the movie and continue watching the '87 cartoon and playing with that "Hose 'Em Down Donatello" action figure u love so much.
Love it, love it, love it. Great minds think alike? Only you put it in a much more concise and accurate way then I did, sir. I will take offense at your "Hose 'Em Down Donatello" line because like all 32 year-old fathers, I still regularly play with my old Turtles :P
graphic_content
07-14-2014, 11:20 PM
Woah woah woah woah, "...won't yield dividends."
So...every single romantic relationship is worthless unless viable offspring are produced?
Wow, way to suck the romance out of, well...romance.
im all for romance (an odd thing to admit in the Turtle forum), just ask my wifey. but the whole interspecies thing? c'mon...even if for whatever reason April was attracted to Don, how would they get amorous, cause lets face it, enjoying one anothers company is one thing, but being physically attracted, is another thing, BOTH equally important....and...
...I need to stop, this conversation is taking a weird turn. At the end of the day, I want my Turtles to be badass Ninjas. End of story. As for romance, save it for Splinters 'stories'.
slingtheory
07-14-2014, 11:39 PM
FakeBritishAccent, I couldn't agree more. Hell, I said the Same Exact **** back in March in the the thread titled 'What do you think of the first Teaser?', but unfortunately I think it went unnoticed due to all the hate, butt-hurt, and nerd rage going around at the time.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=46665&page=271
IMO, the idea behind the designs is that if the Ninja Turtles actually existed then that's what they might look like, but I think that was lost on a lot of people. I don't get it. They're transfigured monsters, so what does it matter if they aren't cute or attractive??? Either get over it or skip the movie and continue watching the '87 cartoon and playing with that "Hose 'Em Down Donatello" action figure u love so much.I've said it before but what if yor problem with it isn't that they aren't cute and huggable but that you find folly with the idea of trying to map a humaniod face to something that's supposed to be a reptilian creature. That and the fact that they look big enough that its hard to imagine them hiding successfully from humanity at all let alone fitting into a manhole or being the agile ninjas they're supposed to be. I.t doesn't bother me one bit if the idea was to try to get across what a mutated freak of nature would look like. I've just seen it done way better in my opinion: I wouldn't exactly call this guy attractive
terrorblade
07-14-2014, 11:56 PM
They don't look ugly at all to me. And based on the fan edits I've saw, I think they look worse without their noses.
Shark_Blade
07-15-2014, 12:16 AM
They don't look ugly at all to me. And based on the fan edits I've saw, I think they look worse without their noses.
I agree, they just look odd and out of place without the nostrils with those designs.
What we have now is great. :tlove:
IndigoErth
07-15-2014, 12:35 AM
Look... I think it can prob at least be agreed on that we all love these guys, no matter what opinions are individually had, and want what's best for them; we just differ on perspective of what's best... I only see opinions in defense of them in one way or another, no matter the angle it's coming from, so snarky jabs and infighting is pointless.
FakeBritishAccent
07-15-2014, 12:52 AM
I've said it before but what if yor problem with it isn't that they aren't cute and huggable but that you find folly with the idea of trying to map a humaniod face to something that's supposed to be a reptilian creature. That and the fact that they look big enough that its hard to imagine them hiding successfully from humanity at all let alone fitting into a manhole or being the agile ninjas they're supposed to be. I.t doesn't bother me one bit if the idea was to try to get across what a mutated freak of nature would look like. I've just seen it done way better in my opinion: I wouldn't exactly call this guy attractive
Point taken, but your example just looks like a more aggressive version of the Nick Raph with more realistic shading and textures (kinda like when someone made "Real Life" photos of Homer Simpson, Charlie Brown, and Stewie Griffin with Photoshop. If I were to see that Turtle in the movie, my mind would go to similar live-action adaptations of animated TV shows like Garfield or the Smurfs films or Scooby Doo: Hyperreal, three-dimensional versions of the characters we love.
Sure, the new Turtle designs aren't for everyone, but no one can argue that they look out of place in the "real world." They really look like walking, talking, breathing turtle monsters.
Here's another BIG QUESTION for everyone:
How would you feel if the PD Turtles retained the exact same faces, musculature, textures, and body proportions that they do now...but instead of the rather distinctive outfits and accessories, they had the standard colored bandannas, brown belts, and knee and elbow pads? No sunglasses or beads, no doorags or hologram gauntlets, no shoes...just the same outfits that we've been familiar with for 30 years?
Look... I think it can prob at least be agreed on that we all love these guys, no matter what opinions are individually had, and want what's best for them; we just differ on perspective of what's best... I only see opinions in defense of them in one way or another, no matter the angle it's coming from, so snarky jabs and infighting is pointless.
Well said, sir, well said. However, I do have to point out that at the very least, snarky jabs and infighting in this particular thread have been kept to a minimum.
PEACE BE WITH Y'ALL!
terrorblade
07-15-2014, 01:02 AM
I'm just so used seeing them with clothes that I think removing them will make it seem like they are naked.
IndigoErth
07-15-2014, 01:15 AM
Here's another BIG QUESTION for everyone:
How would you feel if the PD Turtles retained the exact same faces, musculature, textures, and body proportions that they do now...but instead of the rather distinctive outfits and accessories, they had the standard colored bandannas, brown belts, and knee and elbow pads? No sunglasses or beads, no doorags or hologram gauntlets, no shoes...just the same outfits that we've been familiar with for 30 years?
Nah, I'm a weird one that kinda likes what they're wearing. If we're gonna humanize them more, then clothes/gear was the better way to go about it in my view.
(Though I'd like to know how Leo's shoulder gear is staying on...)
Commenter 42
07-15-2014, 01:33 AM
Sure, the new Turtle designs aren't for everyone, but no one can argue that they look out of place in the "real world." They really look like walking, talking, breathing turtle monsters.
This again? Please don't bait the argument. It sends the threads into chaos.
Suffice it to say, I veheomently disagree. Many would argue they do not look like turtles, or real. I won't say any more, just please don't make sweeping statements assuming we all are in agreement, as we definately are not.
Here's another BIG QUESTION for everyone:
How would you feel if the PD Turtles retained the exact same faces, musculature, textures, and body proportions that they do now...but instead of the rather distinctive outfits and accessories, they had the standard colored bandannas, brown belts, and knee and elbow pads? No sunglasses or beads, no doorags or hologram gauntlets, no shoes...just the same outfits that we've been familiar with for 30 years?
The clothes are not the problem, rather the abominations wearing them.
FakeBritishAccent
07-15-2014, 02:08 AM
This again? Please don't bait the argument. It sends the threads into chaos.
Thanks for the advice, dude!
slingtheory
07-15-2014, 10:08 AM
Point taken, but your example just looks like a more aggressive version of the Nick Raph with more realistic shading and textures (kinda like when someone made "Real Life" photos of Homer Simpson, Charlie Brown, and Stewie Griffin with Photoshop. If I were to see that Turtle in the movie, my mind would go to similar live-action adaptations of animated TV shows like Garfield or the Smurfs films or Scooby Doo: Hyperreal, three-dimensional versions of the characters we love.
Sure, the new Turtle designs aren't for everyone, but no one can argue that they look out of place in the "real world." They really look like walking, talking, breathing turtle monsters. fair enough. Its just to me he looks more like a big turtle monster in that pic then the movie versions do. There's a lot of things to that design that I would've liked to see on these guys. The lack of lips, nostrils that sit on the face and resemble a flattened snout more than a human nose, a carapace that looks like what it is instead of trying to resemble human musculature and goes on to connect to the shell which doesn't look like a massive hiking backpack, the marking on the skin that bring to mind those of a red eared slider. I look at that and see a big bipedel mutated turtle while when I look at the pd turtles I see an unholy union of man and reptile.
Here's another BIG QUESTION for everyone:
How would you feel if the PD Turtles retained the exact same faces, musculature, textures, and body proportions that they do now...but instead of the rather distinctive outfits and accessories, they had the standard colored bandannas, brown belts, and knee and elbow pads? No sunglasses or beads, no doorags or hologram gauntlets, no shoes...just the same outfits that we've been familiar with for 30 years?!
i'd prefer it if they just weren't as big as they are. sure there are elements of the outfits i'm not on board with and i'd prefer "naked" ninja turtles any way but i think i could get past that if they just werent so freaking huge. these guys need to look mobile and fast and like they could believably stay out of sight of the rest of the world. as it is they look too bulky and lumbering.
GrapeSoda
07-15-2014, 10:52 AM
Here's another BIG QUESTION for everyone:
How would you feel if the PD Turtles retained the exact same faces, musculature, textures, and body proportions that they do now...but instead of the rather distinctive outfits and accessories, they had the standard colored bandannas, brown belts, and knee and elbow pads? No sunglasses or beads, no doorags or hologram gauntlets, no shoes...just the same outfits that we've been familiar with for 30 years?
PEACE BE WITH Y'ALL!
i asked myself this same question a couple months ago: is it the design of the turtles that bothers me, or the clothing? so i threw together a "classic" Raph wearing the gladiator outfit, and the movie style Raph with just pads and a bandana.
my personal conclusion was interesting. both designs worked on their own. the faces and anatomy of the "movie" design was off-putting but not as offensive. to me, it's this crazy aesthetic discord caused by the turtle designs and the clothes combined.
Powder
07-15-2014, 11:13 AM
I agree with that 100%.
IndigoErth
07-15-2014, 03:30 PM
*sigh* Yes.. if we crop it just like that... Well hi there, Mr. Mysterious blue eyed, blue masked stranger. :tlove: Lord those eyes are pretty, even if the rest isn't... Once again they put me into a tug of war. (Dammit self, stop looking, it's just an illusion...)
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Bslap6JIgAAuT4e.jpg:large
http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fansites/notyetamovie/news/?a=103624
Added note, love the thumb prints on Donnie's lenses. That alone is enough reason for someone to be wearing at least a shirt to at least clean those off. :P
Those are no monsters... Just the victims of some wonky design choices.
*sigh* Yes.. if we crop it just like that... Well hi there, Mr. Mysterious blue eyed, blue masked stranger. :tlove: Lord those eyes are pretty, even if the rest isn't... Once again they put me into a tug of war. (Dammit self, stop looking, it's just an illusion...)
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Bslap6JIgAAuT4e.jpg:large
http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fansites/notyetamovie/news/?a=103624
Even then, Mikey's pronounced mammal-nose and Donnie's Stereotype-Me-I'm-A-Nerd glasses are just too jarring for me. It almost pains me how good they could have looked with the same technology and CGI but more "traditional" designs.
If it ain't broke, don't fix it!
IndigoErth
07-15-2014, 10:24 PM
If we're lucky.. if there are sequels, maybe they're just starting out in an awkward phase at the moment.:D I wish.
Btw, cropped down to just a chosen one, the mask/eyes pic make a stunning FB cover image.
Commenter 42
07-15-2014, 11:29 PM
Thanks for the advice, dude!
Your sarcasm is unwarranted.
pennydreadful
07-15-2014, 11:43 PM
Your sarcasm is unwarranted.
I thought he was being sincere? This is why I always use a million smiley faces in my responses; tone translates so badly over the internet...
Commenter 42
07-15-2014, 11:47 PM
I didn't read it that way...I'f I'm wromg, cool. Just trying to keep the thread from being locked the way they were in the past.
FakeBritishAccent
07-16-2014, 05:11 AM
I didn't read it that way...I'f I'm wromg, cool. Just trying to keep the thread from being locked the way they were in the past.
No, believe me. I was being sincere. If you read through this thread, I repeatedly mention how happy I am that people are maintaining a civil discussion on this thread and any time someone feels like I'm overstepping the line, I take whatever suggestions others throw my way.
FakeBritishAccent
07-16-2014, 05:14 AM
Even then, Mikey's pronounced mammal-nose and Donnie's Stereotype-Me-I'm-A-Nerd glasses are just too jarring for me. It almost pains me how good they could have looked with the same technology and CGI but more "traditional" designs.
If it ain't broke, don't fix it!
The glasses are indeed jarring, but for me, it balances out nicely when I see shots of Donnie deflecting bullets and flipping cars. Yes, the physics are nutty, but again, it's a movie about mutant turtles.
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 01:41 AM
The glasses are indeed jarring, but for me, it balances out nicely when I see shots of Donnie deflecting bullets and flipping cars. Yes, the physics are nutty, but again, it's a movie about mutant turtles.
This is precisely the problem. "It's a move about mutant turtles".
So that means all physics can go out the window? We toss logic and rational ideas aside?
Lazy thinking, to be sure.
It's not a huge stretch to imagine human/animal hybrids. It is possible to splice human genes into animals, hence the attempt to ban human/animal hybrids.
So, animal mutants, are an unlinkely, but very possible, reality.
Mutation itself is a regularly occurring phenomenon in your cells, hence things like the imperfect symmetry of your (or most peoples) face, skin imperfections like moles, and of course, tumors.
Mutation, check.
Ninjitsu still exists as an art form, and Shinobi did, at one time exist.
Ninja, check.
Turtles, exist; Teenagers too.
The mixing of the elements is unlikely, but POSSIBLE, as far fetched as it may be.
Why do they have bullet proof shells? How could their shells BE bulletproof? Was that neccissary? Why do they look like green apes? Why do they mutate from red eared sliders into giant ape tortoises with sea turtle skin? Why in a lab and not by chance? How does that serve the story of wrongfull revenge? Did it need to be changed? Are here not decades of material to work with to provide a story that might be more interesting? Why do they look like green apes?
The point I'm trying to make, is that this didn't need to be a low-brow, slap-stick, groan inducing retread, just because the premise is unlikely.
Every damned comicbook is bloody unlikely. Why do the turtles get the shaft?
Leo656
07-17-2014, 01:45 AM
http://www.wwe24seven.com/images/46/hollywood-hulk-hogan.jpg
Werecat
07-17-2014, 02:05 AM
Why do they have bullet proof shells? How could their shells BE bulletproof? Was that neccissary? Why do they look like green apes? Why do they mutate from red eared sliders into giant ape tortoises with sea turtle skin? Why in a lab and not by chance? How does that serve the story of wrongfull revenge? Did it need to be changed? Are here not decades of material to work with to provide a story that might be more interesting? Why do they look like green apes?
The point I'm trying to make, is that this didn't need to be a low-brow, slap-stick, groan inducing retread, just because the premise is unlikely.
Every damned comicbook is bloody unlikely. Why do the turtles get the shaft?
I read several science articles and from what I have read anything is possible. An animal can evolve into any form. Being bullet resistant is possible, several animals are bullet resistant such as bears and bulls. However, the power and velocity of the firearm counts a lot.
Also any animal can evolve into an apex predator
These are what tigers looked like before they evolved to the apex predator today
http://photos.mongabay.com/j/fossa.fossa1.568.jpg
They look like weasels. I see no tiger resemblance at all.
http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/01775/Amur-Tiger_1775801c.jpg
Don't you remember Mr Garrison's theory on evolution?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRBHxJBUv_A
Evolution changes a lot in appearance and capabilities. I really enjoy science so I know quite a bit. With my knowledge I can easily see the plausibility behind the turtles. It is very hard to get into a full lesson of science in one post. So I made it as small as possible. Just believe me when I say "Anything is possible" Science and evolution is awesome and proved that so much change in a short amount of time can happen. Change that some may disbelieve. It is very possible that the turtles can rapidly evolve (mutate) into a tank-like humanoid.
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 02:39 AM
I read several science articles and from what I have read anything is possible. An animal can evolve into any form. Being bullet resistant is possible, several animals are bullet resistant such as bears and bulls. However, the power and velocity of the firearm counts a lot.
Hilarious. Yes, evolution is amazing. No, bears have not magically become bullet ressitant, though rats have reportedly been getting smarter. I can site the article if you'd like, though it isn't from a reputable journal, so possibly it's a fabricted piece. Wait, maybe that makes it unreliable you say? Pshaw...I like the idea of super-smart rats, and I did read it online, so it must be true!
Oh, and no, you did not fully understand my point. Being bulletproof is an unnessisary addition to the TMNT. It's tinted windows on a Harley.
Also, spare me the "I can teach you science" bit. I can google too.
IndigoErth
07-17-2014, 02:45 AM
I read several science articles and from what I have read anything is possible.
So you're saying you can get me Leo then? Yay.
(Other fans may borrow but you have to give him back... Lusty fangirls void as prohibited.)
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 02:48 AM
So you're saying you can get me Leo then? Yay.
(Other fans may borrow but you have to give him back... Lusty fangirls void as prohibited.)
:lol::D:lol::D:lol:
Seriously! "Anything is possible"
Dude!
Leo656
07-17-2014, 02:59 AM
Yeah, I'm less concerned with what's scientifically possible, and more with what's just a poorly thought-out choice that's going to break the movie's internal logic for the sake of "being bad-ass."
They can crush bricks beneath their feet. Their own momentum can knock over and damage a Humvee. They have weapons that can flip over vehicles and other objects weighing thousands of pounds. They can twirl their weapons fast enough to deflect bullets fired at close range, and furthermore, they're bulletprooof!
Don't try and explain to me how it's scientifically possible, that's irrelevant. Explain to me how anyone, Cyber-Mecha-Super-Shredder or otherwise, is gonna convincingly take down FOUR of these guys. Where's the dramatic tension? There's no believable threat from the villains whatsoever anymore. Regardless of what they actually put on screen, it won't be the least bit believable, with how super-powered the guys are. When the bad guys are the underdogs, it kind of ruins the story.
Werecat
07-17-2014, 03:03 AM
Hilarious. Yes, evolution is amazing. No, bears have not magically become bullet ressitant, though rats have reportedly been getting smarter. I can site the article if you'd like, though it isn't from a reputable journal, so possibly it's a fabricted piece. Wait, maybe that makes it unreliable you say? Pshaw...I like the idea of super-smart rats, and I did read it online, so it must be true!
Oh, and no, you did not fully understand my point. Being bulletproof is an unnessisary addition to the TMNT. It's tinted windows on a Harley.
Also, spare me the "I can teach you science" bit. I can google too.
Your ignorance is hilarious. Bears are bullet resistant, their bulky muscle and fat can slow and stop low velocity bullets, preventing any serious harm. Just because the turtle's capabilities far exceed your laughable capabilities does not make it unbelievable. The turtles are not human. The turtles are mutated beasts! Beasts with superior capabilities.
The internet was built with the intention to provide free information to the public. If you haven't noticed, it is very easy to get in contact with any type of scientist and there are several scientists who have blogs, articles, videos, and Q & A. Plus some scientists are glad to share info with people who email them. You can learn more, beyond your bubble, if you closed the porn tab to use the internet to actually learn a few things.
You also seem to like personally attacking people. and so now I am personally attacking. So I am going to just walk away. I do not like resorting to attacks but you're the type of person that can bring the worst out of me.
Candy Kappa
07-17-2014, 03:04 AM
Bullet resistant seems a wee bit too far fetched on a turtle shell, even on a shell as huuuge as the PD Turtles, it'd be no more resistant then a human skull.
Plus, a turtle's shell is sensitive to touch, turtles can feel through their shell just as we humans can throw our finger and toe nails, maybe even more, as you can scratch an itch on a turtles shell, you can tickle a turtle through the shell. Turtles have nerve endings throughout under the scutes, so deliberately using their shell as a shield would be more painful then finding an actual cover that isn't their own body.
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 03:09 AM
I will say that I can't wait to see which way this thing breaks. Will it explode opening weekend or flop hard. Every site seems to tell a different story.
TF4 had crazy negative buzz, and still does, but huge take on the frame, and steam rolling along.
Could go either way.
Leo656
07-17-2014, 03:12 AM
Big opening weekend, mediocre-to-poor word-of-mouth, steep second week drop, and extremely polarized reviews. Will earn its budget back and a little more, and will do better in movie-starved countries like China than it does here. It should also have a very long tail on DVD, as even people who think it looks awful will still want to own it on DVD simply because of their reverence for the Turtles.
Pretty easy to call by this point.
Werecat
07-17-2014, 03:13 AM
Yeah, I'm less concerned with what's scientifically possible, and more with what's just a poorly thought-out choice that's going to break the movie's internal logic for the sake of "being bad-ass."
They can crush bricks beneath their feet. Their own momentum can knock over and damage a Humvee. They have weapons that can flip over vehicles and other objects weighing thousands of pounds. They can twirl their weapons fast enough to deflect bullets fired at close range, and furthermore, they're bulletprooof!
Don't try and explain to me how it's scientifically possible, that's irrelevant. Explain to me how anyone, Cyber-Mecha-Super-Shredder or otherwise, is gonna convincingly take down FOUR of these guys. Where's the dramatic tension? There's no believable threat from the villains whatsoever anymore. Regardless of what they actually put on screen, it won't be the least bit believable, with how super-powered the guys are. When the bad guys are the underdogs, it kind of ruins the story.
Now that is a valid argument. The turtle's strength has been enhanced to a point were it is unbelievable for any foe to stand a chance. A sense of danger is important for building tension and suspense. But the sense of danger goes out the window when the protagonists is a beefed up super mutant.
The only thing I have to ask is why are you so against the turtles being powerful? Do you enjoy it when the turtles are inferior to human capabilities? Just because something is stronger than you doesn't mean it is the end of the world.
I actually enjoy how powerful the turtles are in the movie. They are not push overs. They are beefed-up-super-mutant-martial artists who can rip apart a numerous amount of evil Foot soldiers! TMNT is about martial arts, which is fancy action pumped up a few notches.
Werecat
07-17-2014, 03:17 AM
Bullet resistant seems a wee bit too far fetched on a turtle shell, even on a shell as huuuge as the PD Turtles, it'd be no more resistant then a human skull.
Plus, a turtle's shell is sensitive to touch, turtles can feel through their shell just as we humans can throw our finger and toe nails, maybe even more, as you can scratch an itch on a turtles shell, you can tickle a turtle through the shell. Turtles have nerve endings throughout under the scutes, so deliberately using their shell as a shield would be more painful then finding an actual cover that isn't their own body.
Oh turtles can feel touch and tickles on their shell but they do not feel pain. Sense of touch and pain are two different things. Of course they will feel pain if you skin their shell off. But it is plausible that the shell would evolve to withstand a bullet when you consider the fact that they are mutated by an alien ooze!
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 03:27 AM
Your ignorance is hilarious. Bears are bullet resistant, their bulky muscle and fat can slow...
You're post was irrelevant, so I called you out on it. You also intimated that I did not understand evolution. You picked a fight, I responded.
Candy Kappa, on the otherhand, has supplied actual facts about the species in question, that further prove why bullet-proof shells are insulting to the audience.
You do have a point, as in a closed ecosystem, yes almost any animal can evolve to become an apex. I think though, I did clarify that even if some how a bullet proof shell made some sort of biological sense, it is an incredibly tacky addition, without merit.
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 03:37 AM
Big opening weekend, mediocre-to-poor word-of-mouth, steep second week drop, and extremely polarized reviews. Will earn its budget back and a little more, and will do better in movie-starved countries like China than it does here. It should also have a very long tail on DVD, as even people who think it looks awful will still want to own it on DVD simply because of their reverence for the Turtles.
Pretty easy to call by this point.
Sure, but the same was said of green lantern, john carter, the list goes on and on. After TED, they bet on Seth McFarlane, and his latest was a disaster. Edge of tomorrow tanked with a high 80's critic score, while TF garnered 17% but is breaking records. Godzilla opened big, but didn't maintain, and TAS2 only made back it's cost.
If I was to put money on it, I'd hedge with you, but the markets been really unstable the last 6 months.
Leo656
07-17-2014, 03:40 AM
Werecat: I just don't find it at all necessary for them, for those characters, to ever be that large, that strong, or that powerful to exist in the universe that they inhabit. Do they need the help? Aren't they cool and tough enough the way we've always known them? I didn't know I wanted a 7-foot tall Hulk Raph, and you know what... now that I've gotten that, I know for a fact I never wanted it.
I mean, seriously, would *these* guys even be ninjas? Nah. Not even. Like, if Bruce Wayne could knock over a tank, why would he even bother learning any martial art, let alone every one in existence? Likewise, why are these "ninja" turtles even bothering with it? Flair? If you're that big, strong, and dense, you don't need to mess with pizazz. It makes no sense why guys that unstoppable would even study martial arts, in the same way it makes no sense how "puny humans" could slow them down, guns or no. And the fact is, you can be buff and still limber, but nobody THAT big could be a master ninja anyways.
I just find it supremely disappointing that certain questionable design choices in this movie are explained away with "We're trying to be realistic", while others are countered with, "It's only a movie and this is a very fantastical fiction to begin with." It's like, pick a side and play it. The way the people making the movie keep going back and forth between the two just proves the real reason for it all is, "Because it looks cool to us (the filmmakers) on paper, so bite me if you don't like it." So they can have freakishly ugly faces because "mutant turtles would realistically be monstrous-looking", and at the same time, be essentially bullet-proof or strong enough to flip cars because "F*ck you, that's why." It's all just choices; none of it has anything to do with plausibility at all, so frankly I get a little annoyed when people try and use that argument.
And if it's not plausible, and it's not necessary, and it undermines some of the more important elements of the fiction, I'd rather not have Change For Change's Sake. Do we need bullet-proof Hulk Turtles? Couldn't they still have made a good movie if they were toned-down a little bit? Some of the stuff I'm seeing in these trailers is the kind of stuff I never, ever wanted to see in a TMNT movie. It's almost like a full-on parody of the genre, and I "get" that's what they're going for in a sense, I just don't agree with it. I think that's not the right way to direct the franchise. People can feel free to disagree, I just wanted a "real" movie.
------------------------------------------------------------
I still don't get what the problem with Green Lantern was. :ohwell: I'm not entirely sure what they could have done differently than they did, other than maybe cut all the extraneous Hammond stuff. Other than that, the only problem I had with it was one of the same ones I have in this TMNT movie, all the "jokes" seem to be between "corny" and "terrible". It told the story and established the universe and it looked like Green Lantern in live action would look. I'unno, I think people over-sold how "bad" that one was.
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 03:47 AM
http://media.tumblr.com/9280b1791a028233a5d07e10b882d38f/tumblr_inline_n3d5f7oRwA1qzauve.gif
Yessir!
Green Lantern's problem was Ryan Reynolds. R.I.P.D. was another fabulous example of how much audiences don't like him.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 03:53 AM
One simple answer to why they are bulletproof and any other zany, far out questions you may have...when you bring the Mutagen into the equation all logic goes out the window! Why sit around and argue about it?
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 03:55 AM
One simple answer to why they are bulletproof and any other zany, far out questions you may have...when you bring the Mutagen into the equation all logic goes out the window! Why sit around and argue about it?
Are they playing the drums in your second sig?
Candy Kappa
07-17-2014, 03:59 AM
Oh turtles can feel touch and tickles on their shell but they do not feel pain. Sense of touch and pain are two different things. Of course they will feel pain if you skin their shell off. But it is plausible that the shell would evolve to withstand a bullet when you consider the fact that they are mutated by an alien ooze!
Scratches are fine, but deep cuts or gouges will hurt. Hence why drilling turtle shells are considered animal cruelty.
Plus, turtles are slow healers, seems stupid to put themselves in a obvious situations to get injured.
Leo656
07-17-2014, 03:59 AM
One simple answer to why they are bulletproof and any other zany, far out questions you may have...when you bring the Mutagen into the equation all logic goes out the window! Why sit around and argue about it?
Because, again, if that's your crutch, then your story has no conflict, drama, or raison d'etre. It's like how Superman III, IV, and really even the second half of part II were all progressively awful, when they just started inventing new powers for every scenario they came up with. It's lazy and insipid writing.
Green Lantern's problem was Ryan Reynolds. R.I.P.D. was another fabulous example of how much audiences don't like him.
*I* liked him. Costume aside, he looked exactly like Silver Age Hal Jordan. And Hal's always been kind of a smug, unlikable prick, so I kind of thought it was perfect casting. I'unno. My first choice would'a been Eric Bana, personally, but he's probably too old now.
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 04:05 AM
Cellophane S-shield anyone?
I just think most people think of the turtles as a brand, or a theme song, and this movie is a reflection of that.
Transformers, was at its heart, a melodrama of power and deception, loyalty vs obedience, and shifting political landscapes shaped by an civil war. The cartoon shares more similarity to house of cards than it does it's current blockbuster iteration. But they're robots, who transform, so that's all they are.
Leo656
07-17-2014, 04:08 AM
Cellophane S-shield anyone?
That, spinning the Earth backwards, and "Rebuild-The-Great-Wall-Of-China Vision" are things not to be spoken of.
Seriously, I'm surprised that Part IV didn't end with Superman literally just punching out the sun.
Candy Kappa
07-17-2014, 04:10 AM
I liked Ryan Reynolds as Green Lantern, to me he was one of the best part of the whole movie.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 04:11 AM
Are they playing the drums in your second sig?
They are dancing in an elevator! haha...it's awesome! Raph is basically back there keeping the beat it looks like by tapping the ends of his sai together
Candy Kappa
07-17-2014, 04:13 AM
I wonder if Psy will have a cameo standing on the other side of the elevator.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 04:13 AM
Because, again, if that's your crutch, then your story has no conflict, drama, or raison d'etre. It's like how Superman III, IV, and really even the second half of part II were all progressively awful, when they just started inventing new powers for every scenario they came up with. It's lazy and insipid writing.
*I* liked him. Costume aside, he looked exactly like Silver Age Hal Jordan. And Hal's always been kind of a smug, unlikable prick, so I kind of thought it was perfect casting. I'unno. My first choice would'a been Eric Bana, personally, but he's probably too old now.
How would we know what kind of side effects Mutagen would have on an animal? The shells are bullet proof but I'm sure their skin is not...
Leo656
07-17-2014, 04:15 AM
Kappa: What kills me is when you get movies like Green Lantern and Speed Racer that exist specifically to take advantage of heavy CGI, to essentially look "fake on purpose", and then some of the biggest criticism becomes, "it was too heavy on CGI." That blew my mind when I read some of the reviews. "Too much CGI" in Green Lantern. That is exactly the same as saying Star Wars had too many fights in outer space.
Raphael: You're missing my point. I don't care about pseudo-science. I'm saying these were design choices that are without merit, that have absolutely zero to do with "reality" and everything to do with "That's So Cool!" And I'm saying, that those choices are poor, and that even *trying* to explain it away "scientifically" or "realistically" is silly. There is no *good* reason to have 7-foot-tall Turtles who are bullet proof. Yes, you can come up with reasons. Absolutely Zero GOOD reasons, however.
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 04:19 AM
I wasn't a fan going in, definitely wasn't going out.
I have nothing against Reynolds, but he seems to rub fans the wrong way...ie dead pool.
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 04:22 AM
How would we know what kind of side effects Mutagen would have on an animal? The shells are bullet proof but I'm sure their skin is not...
We know because their shells were not bullet proof in any other version of the series.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 04:23 AM
Kappa: What kills me is when you get movies like Green Lantern and Speed Racer that exist specifically to take advantage of heavy CGI, to essentially look "fake on purpose", and then some of the biggest criticism becomes, "it was too heavy on CGI." That blew my mind when I read some of the reviews. "Too much CGI" in Green Lantern. That is exactly the same as saying Star Wars had too many fights in outer space.
Raphael: You're missing my point. I don't care about pseudo-science. I'm saying these were design choices that are without merit, that have absolutely zero to do with "reality" and everything to do with "That's So Cool!" And I'm saying, that those choices are poor, and that even *trying* to explain it away "scientifically" or "realistically" is silly. There is no *good* reason to have 7-foot-tall Turtles who are bullet proof. Yes, you can come up with reasons. Absolutely Zero GOOD reasons, however.
Honestly, I'm f*ckin sick and tired of all this "reality" bullsh*t! I want to go to a movie and just have a fun time without sitting there and worrying about whether this was realistic or that was realistic or how they would do such a thing. Why in the hell do people need realism in EVERY SINGLE DAMN MOVIE??!?! It's the "realism" lovers that are killing the magic of the movies...and this movie looks like it will be just that, a fun time!
Leo656
07-17-2014, 04:27 AM
God you guys are fast.
We know because their shells were not bullet proof in any other version of the series.
^^ Which, again, comes down to, It Was Just A Choice.
No "scientific rationale", just, "We felt like it, OK?" I really wish some people could just take things for what they are rather than what they'd like it to be. Love the choices, hate the choices, whatever, that's all subjective. But don't try and argue there was any deep thought put into any of it. Both the "realism" argument and "it's just a movie" argument are nothing but convenient yet flimsy shields to deflect criticism. You can literally deflect anything at all by picking one of the two counters for the appropriate argument.
I'd actually respect the guys making the movie a lot more if they just came out and spoke plain. "WE like it better this way." Okay then, fine. It's your ball.
Honestly, I'm f*ckin sick and tired of all this "reality" bullsh*t! I want to go to a movie and just have a fun time without sitting there and worrying about whether this was realistic or that was realistic or how they would do such a thing. Why in the hell do people need realism in EVERY SINGLE DAMN MOVIE??!?! It's the "realism" lovers that are killing the magic of the movies...and this movie looks like it will be just that, a fun time!
Fine, you can see it that way. I've had my fill of exactly those kinds of movies you seem to prefer, so we're equally fed up from opposite ends. For one, I don't have money to burn going to movies that don't speak to me, and have avoided many that were based on things I liked, because I didn't like how they did it. I don't embrace everything with an S shield or a TMNT sticker on it just because I'm a fan. And I am apparently at the exact polar opposite of you as far as preference in general. Which is fine, but I personally want more movies like "Batman Begins" that can elevate fantastical fiction into something everyone can enjoy, rather than more movies like "Transformers" and "Batman and Robin", which are made only for twelve year olds and those with the attention span thereof. I don't play the "it's all fake anyway" card, never have and never will. "Begins" was grounded yet utterly fantastic and still a lot of fun. I still argue it was the best of that trilogy, partly because it wasn't SO goddamn heavy and "real" as the two sequels were. It was far greater than the sum of its parts. It made people who never cared about Batman love Batman. I want more of that stuff. Elevation. As a fan, vindication. I don't want people "laughing with me" at the stuff I enjoy. I don't want the stuff I enjoy to be mocked, period. I want a movie that makes people who don't "Get It" say, "Ahh, okay, I totally understand now." I keep mentioning "Begins" because, for me, that movie did just that for so many people who used to give me crap about liking Batman and comics in general. That movie changed the way these kinds of movies are made - for the better - and now we have stuff like this, dragging movies back the other way into the "kitsch and camp" territory. And others can like it fine, but I think it's a shame to go backwards after we've seen we can have more than that.
I don't think it ruins anything to at least pretend to take things seriously.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 04:43 AM
We know because their shells were not bullet proof in any other version of the series.
I thought in one version that wasn't long running that they had bulletproof shells...or at least that's what I read one poster say
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 04:45 AM
God you guys are fast.
^^ Which, again, comes down to, It Was Just A Choice.
No "scientific rationale", just, "We felt like it, OK?" I really wish some people could just take things for what they are rather than what they'd like it to be. Love the choices, hate the choices, whatever, that's all subjective. But don't try and argue there was any deep thought put into any of it. Both the "realism" argument and "it's just a movie" argument are nothing but convenient yet flimsy shields to deflect criticism. You can literally deflect anything at all by picking one of the two counters for the appropriate argument.
I'd actually respect the guys making the movie a lot more if they just came out and spoke plain. "WE like it better this way." Okay then, fine. It's your ball.
Fine, you can see it that way. I've had my fill of exactly those kinds of movies you seem to prefer, so we're equally fed up from opposite ends. For one, I don't have money to burn going to movies that don't speak to me, and have avoided many that were based on things I liked, because I didn't like how they did it. I don't embrace everything with an S shield or a TMNT sticker on it just because I'm a fan. And I am apparently at the exact polar opposite of you as far as preference in general. Which is fine, but I personally want more movies like "Batman Begins" that can elevate fantastical fiction into something everyone can enjoy, rather than more movies like "Transformers" and "Batman and Robin", which are made only for twelve year olds and those with the attention span thereof. I don't play the "it's all fake anyway" card, never have and never will. "Begins" was grounded yet utterly fantastic and still a lot of fun. I still argue it was the best of that trilogy, partly because it wasn't SO goddamn heavy and "real" as the two sequels were. It was far greater than the sum of its parts. It made people who never cared about Batman love Batman. I want more of that stuff. Elevation. As a fan, vindication. I don't want people "laughing with me" at the stuff I enjoy. I don't want the stuff I enjoy to be mocked, period. I want a movie that makes people who don't "Get It" say, "Ahh, okay, I totally understand now." I keep mentioning "Begins" because, for me, that movie did just that for so many people who used to give me crap about liking Batman and comics in general. That movie changed the way these kinds of movies are made - for the better - and now we have stuff like this, dragging movies back the other way into the "kitsch and camp" territory. And others can like it fine, but I think it's a shame to go backwards after we've seen we can have more than that.
I don't think it ruins anything to at least pretend to take things seriously.
Well you take your realism and be happy while I'll sit and hope that Hollywood continues to make UN-realistic movies...just good, fun, popcorn flicks
Candy Kappa
07-17-2014, 04:47 AM
Kappa: What kills me is when you get movies like Green Lantern and Speed Racer that exist specifically to take advantage of heavy CGI, to essentially look "fake on purpose", and then some of the biggest criticism becomes, "it was too heavy on CGI." That blew my mind when I read some of the reviews. "Too much CGI" in Green Lantern. That is exactly the same as saying Star Wars had too many fights in outer space.
Personally I thought the CGI in GL was fine, it kinda have to be a lot of CGI in a movie like green lantern, there a lot you can do with practical effects and mattte paintings, but it havs it's limitations, especially in environments, with CGI you can now tilt the camera angle, or do a scene from a different angle without having a new matte painting in the background.
A pity the villains of the movie was... Lackluster, another cloud monster.
Leo656
07-17-2014, 04:57 AM
Well you take your realism and be happy while I'll sit and hope that Hollywood continues to make UN-realistic movies...just good, fun, popcorn flicks
Gotcha. Because the first "Fast & Furious" movie left so many burning, un-answered questions, they went ahead and made 80 sequels. The world absolutely needs more "Saw" films. Johnny Depp genuinely deserves to keep playing the same character in 8 movies a year. In short, there's no reason to make movies ever be more than fluff and swill. A'ight then.
Kappa: I was sad they saved Sinestro's heel turn for the never-to-be-made sequel. :ohwell: Sinestro was great.
Candy Kappa
07-17-2014, 05:00 AM
Yeah, I loved Sinestro, but. He felt so underused, and the heel moment was a sudden turn, as if it was mandatory for him to go evil in the movie.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 05:02 AM
Gotcha. Because the first "Fast & Furious" movie left so many burning, un-answered questions, they went ahead and made 80 sequels. The world absolutely needs more "Saw" films. Johnny Depp genuinely deserves to keep playing the same character in 8 movies a year. In short, there's no reason to make movies ever be more than fluff and swill. A'ight then.
Kappa: I was sad they saved Sinestro's heel turn for the never-to-be-made sequel. :ohwell: Sinestro was great.
Don't watch the Fast and Furious movies, or Saw...or Johnny Depp movies. Although he doesn't ALWAYS play the same character in every movie. He has a few good movies
Leo656
07-17-2014, 05:05 AM
Yeah, I loved Sinestro, but. He felt so underused, and the heel moment was a sudden turn, as if it was mandatory for him to go evil in the movie.
C'mon, a guy named "Sinestro" with an Evil Mustache IS evil by definition. :lol: No set-up required with that one.
How awesome would a sequel with Sinestro recruiting a bunch of Yellow Lanterns have been? Honestly. The absolute worst part of Green Lantern, is that it set up a sequel that probably would have been a thousand times better, that is never going to happen. It's like they blew all their money on plane tickets but didn't have any gas left to actually drive to the airport.
Raphael: Yeah, I know, I make broad generalizations to establish a point. I've seen several good Depp movies but nothing good since he did those insipid Pirate movies and resigned himself to being a living cartoon. I mean, I get it, but it's like that's his only speed, now. I mean, the first one was good, and then they just immediately started Xeroxing it, doing the exact same thing over however many movies. So pointless. So much wasted money and effort doing the exact same movie 5 times, just a little dumber each time. As clever and fresh as the original was when it came out, the sequels were equally vapid and brain-numbing. And they do that with everything now, which is why I'm annoyed with movies anymore.
FakeBritishAccent
07-17-2014, 05:16 AM
Everyone here knows they love TMNT, but here's another big question:
When did you realize that you were a TMNT fan for life? Was it when you first discovered them? Was it when all your friends started to not care about them? When did you truly know that the Turtles were something you wanted to share with your future children?
Leo656
07-17-2014, 05:23 AM
I think it was a little bit after the second movie came out, when everyone I knew stopped giving a sh*t and no longer wanted to play TMNT at recess anymore. Most of my friends still played the video games, and maybe watched the cartoon once in a while, but all of a sudden it wasn't "hip" to talk about anymore. Like most things I'm into, I just kind of suddenly realized I cared way, way more than anyone else I knew did.
I mean, from the start it was one of my very favorite things, so I probably was already a "lifer", but I knew it wasn't just a phase for me when I realized I still watched the movies and read the comics on a regular basis way after all my friends stopped, or at least stopped admitting it.
Werecat
07-17-2014, 05:47 AM
Everyone here knows they love TMNT, but here's another big question:
When did you realize that you were a TMNT fan for life? Was it when you first discovered them? Was it when all your friends started to not care about them? When did you truly know that the Turtles were something you wanted to share with your future children?
I realized I was a TMNT fan for life when the Nickelodeon series aired. I was a young adult at the time and still had an interest in TMNT. I was a teenager during the 2k3 and watched every episode, I have my criticisms of 2k3 but I still enjoyed watching it. I thought I would grow distant from TMNT once the 2k3 series ended and I basically have the time to move on. Could never move on from TMNT. I enjoy it too much and I enjoy how I can watch it with anyone without having to worry about age restrictions. So I guess I am a TMNT fan for life.
Galactus
07-17-2014, 09:38 AM
Honestly, I'm f*ckin sick and tired of all this "reality" bullsh*t! I want to go to a movie and just have a fun time without sitting there and worrying about whether this was realistic or that was realistic or how they would do such a thing. Why in the hell do people need realism in EVERY SINGLE DAMN MOVIE??!?! It's the "realism" lovers that are killing the magic of the movies...and this movie looks like it will be just that, a fun time!
Well better tell that to some of the actors and the head FX guy because they seem to think and sell this movie as being dark and serious and realistic.
Of course it's probably too much to expect that they come up with a consistent way to sell the tone of the movie but it's interesting to me that many of them have latched on to the idea of advertising this as "realistic" when relatively speaking this is the least realistic version we've ever had. I'm guessing that they know that darker, realistic comic book movies are considered cool now and trying to market it somewhat to that crowd despite it really not being that.
It's kinda the same as the idea that they are even name dropping the original Mirage comics and Eastman and Laird a lot of times. I've even seen articles quoting press releases which sound as if this is heavily inspired by the Mirage when save for one line it seems they've taken zilch from it but comic book movies are "in" now so that's how they are being marketed.
IndigoErth
07-17-2014, 09:47 AM
Everyone here knows they love TMNT, but here's another big question:
When did you realize that you were a TMNT fan for life? Was it when you first discovered them? Was it when all your friends started to not care about them? When did you truly know that the Turtles were something you wanted to share with your future children?
When the Nick series brought me back last year - after previously having put it all away in my teens against my own choice - heard about and found in pride the fact that were hitting 30 years, realized how awesome it still really is. And though my avatar may only be a fan-made version, when I saw that pic which looked to me like old Leo grown up I realized I'd missed the heck out of that guy. (*leaves room* :tcry:)
Honestly, I'm f*ckin sick and tired of all this "reality" bullsh*t! I want to go to a movie and just have a fun time without sitting there and worrying about whether this was realistic or that was realistic or how they would do such a thing. Why in the hell do people need realism in EVERY SINGLE DAMN MOVIE??!?! It's the "realism" lovers that are killing the magic of the movies...and this movie looks like it will be just that, a fun time!
*pat* Then don't.. Let the people who are worried about that worry about it on their own... I'm sure those who aren't worried about that will forget all about it the moment the previews start.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 09:50 AM
Well better tell that to some of the actors and the head FX guy because they seem to think and sell this movie as being dark and serious and realistic.
Of course it's probably too much to expect that they come up with a consistent way to sell the tone of the movie but it's interesting to me that many of them have latched on to the idea of advertising this as "realistic" when relatively speaking this is the least realistic version we've ever had. I'm guessing that they know that darker, realistic comic book movies are considered cool now and trying to market it somewhat to that crowd despite it really not being that.
It's kinda the same as the idea that they are even name dropping the original Mirage comics and Eastman and Laird a lot of times. I've even seen articles quoting press releases which sound as if this is heavily inspired by the Mirage when save for one line it seems they've taken zilch from it but comic book movies are "in" now so that's how they are being marketed.
I don't see how they could sell this as being DARK and SERIOUS and REALISTIC....I really don't see the seriousness , like at all
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 09:51 AM
When the Nick series brought me back last year - after previously having put it all away in my teens against my own choice - heard about and found in pride the fact that were hitting 30 years, realized how awesome it still really is. And though my avatar may only be a fan-made version, when I saw that pic which looked to me like old Leo grown up I realized I'd missed the heck out of that guy. (*leaves room* :tcry:)
*pat* Then don't.. Let the people who are worried about that worry about it on their own... I'm sure those who aren't worried about that will forget all about it the moment the previews start.
Yeah, you're right. Some people will say anything to make you see things their way. I'm all like, screw it...you see it however you want. I'm gonna go enjoy the movie
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-17-2014, 10:00 AM
i really dont get this whole.."They have to be ugly its realistic" mind set...nothing has to look like anything whether it be transformers or turtles it all boils down to how the artist behind the pen wants it to look
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 10:04 AM
i really dont get this whole.."They have to be ugly its realistic" mind set...nothing has to look like anything whether it be transformers or turtles it all boils down to how the artist behind the pen wants it to look
Well I would be kinda pissed if they had a HUGE change in the look of Optimus...so far I'm digging what we're getting
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-17-2014, 10:13 AM
Well I would be kinda pissed if they had a HUGE change in the look of Optimus...so far I'm digging what we're getting
but that was a HUGE change in Optimus' look....and and even bigger Change in the new movie
sure i like the transformers one but they work (for me) because we are talking mechanical beings over flesh,skin,blood and bone
then again i wasnt a transformers fan till beast wars so the movie looks have that beast wars feel for me
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 10:18 AM
but that was a HUGE change in Optimus' look....and and even bigger Change in the new movie
sure i like the transformers one but they work (for me) because we are talking mechanical beings over flesh,skin,blood and bone
then again i wasnt a transformers fan till beast wars so the movie looks have that beast wars feel for me
I can look at Opitmus and tell it's him...good enough for me really. I watched G1 but was never really a huge fan
fridaynightdestination
07-17-2014, 10:20 AM
It looks you all need to start singing this song:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wcLwtg98S-8
IndigoErth
07-17-2014, 10:21 AM
Yeah, you're right. Some people will say anything to make you see things their way. I'm all like, screw it...you see it however you want. I'm gonna go enjoy the movie
Yeah, and pretty much how I'm taking it. Some dislike more to it than I do, some are loving parts of it more than I am.. so be it. :) I'll go with what I like and enjoy it (I hope) from there.
i really dont get this whole.."They have to be ugly its realistic" mind set...
I do agree and sadly chalk it up to the period we're in right now with a lot of media, same mentality that being unattractive is more manly for characters.
I mean... they don't have to be completely adorable, but a little bit would have been nice. (I'm a woman who'd rather at least semi-cute male characters, so sue me.) Finding this movie REALLY depends on the angle and lighting... some shots are certainly more flattering than others.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 10:24 AM
It looks you all need to start singing this song:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wcLwtg98S-8
Nah, I'm not a singer...this ain't The Voice or American Idol haha
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-17-2014, 10:24 AM
I can look at Opitmus and tell it's him...good enough for me really. I watched G1 but was never really a huge fan
because that is the image of optimus we have been fed for close to 10 years same with bumblebee...they have evolved into a hybrid for of their movie counter parts
which is my personal fear for this TMNT
which in a way gets to the second question asked "do i want this movie to succeed?" and I admit, no I don't...if for anything because i hate how they look and i don't want them to influence any future TMNT designs, I hope this is just a tiny pebble in the giant pond that is TMNT not to make any ripples, id rather Next Mutation or Turtle Tunes come back and be the main stream than this project. maybe if they didn't look like hunchbacks i could overlook it but i hate the hunched over look more than the noses
I do agree and sadly chalk it up to the period we're in right now with a lot of media, same mentality that being unattractive is more manly for characters.
I mean... they don't have to be completely adorable, but a little bit would have been nice. (I'm a woman who'd rather at least semi-cute male characters, so sue me.) Finding this movie REALLY depends on the angle and lighting... some shots are certainly more flattering than others.
i am not gonna lie i am not a fan of the turtles having Multi Colored eyes...not just in this film but even in the 2k12 series
i grew to love the 3 brothers with brown eyes and Mike with blue..i remember in 2007 tmnt the directors joked it was do to mikey having a different mom the the other 3 since splinter also had brown eyes
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 10:30 AM
Well I hope it does well
IndigoErth
07-17-2014, 10:33 AM
Blue eyes are a mutation all their own, therefor this makes Leo and Mikey more awesomely mutated than their brothers.:P
Signed, a human mutant.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 10:41 AM
Blue eyes are a mutation all their own, therefor this makes Leo and Mikey more awesomely mutated than their brothers.:P
Signed, a human mutant.
I'm a mutant then too
Mutant and Proud!
slingtheory
07-17-2014, 11:38 AM
Honestly, I'm f*ckin sick and tired of all this "reality" bullsh*t! I want to go to a movie and just have a fun time without sitting there and worrying about whether this was realistic or that was realistic or how they would do such a thing. Why in the hell do people need realism in EVERY SINGLE DAMN MOVIE??!?! It's the "realism" lovers that are killing the magic of the movies...and this movie looks like it will be just that, a fun time! I agree with you to a point. It kind of annoys me now when they adapt a comic or whatever and they feel the need to ground the more outlandish elements to make it fit a real world setting better. Things like making galactus a storm cloud and all that. The way I look at it I feel that movies are supposed to make us believe in the unbelievable so why hold back on anything for fear the audience won't buy it. A good team of filmmakers should be able to make almost any character or concept look plausable. that being said though I think there should be realism at play in the way things react to other things. People have an easier time supending their disbelif when things they recognize from their daily lives aren't reacting to things in way they know they wouldn't. You push it too far you risk taking them out of the experiance. There needs to be a consistant logic to the world the characters live in as well as the fundamental laws of the universe operating the way they should or else you end up with a live action cartoon.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 11:43 AM
I agree with you to a point. It kind of annoys me now when they adapt a comic or whatever and they feel the need to ground the more outlandish elements to make it fit a real world setting better. Things like making galactus a storm cloud and all that. The way I look at it I feel that movies are supposed to make us believe in the unbelievable so why hold back on anything for fear the audience won't buy it. A good team of filmmakers should be able to make almost any character or concept look plausable. that being said though I think there should be realism at play in the way things react to other things. People have an easier time supending their disbelif when things they recognize from their daily lives aren't reacting to things in way they know they wouldn't. You push it too far you risk taking them out of the experiance. There needs to be a consistant logic to the world the characters live in as well as the fundamental laws of the universe operating the way they should or else you end up with a live action cartoon.
I mean I agree. If I hit you in the face your head should react...that's realism I'm down for. I have always thought that with all the horrible sh*t going on in the world that the movies should be an escape from reality. Not further embed me into reality. If I want to watch reality I'll turn on the news
Galactus
07-17-2014, 11:53 AM
I don't see how they could sell this as being DARK and SERIOUS and REALISTIC....I really don't see the seriousness , like at all
Well several of the actors have used those exact words to describe this movie most recently Megan Fox in her E interview and the head FX guy also said they were going for a realistic approach in the interview that was posted last night.
Truth be told different aspects of TMNT play better as with different degrees of realism and seriousness. Even the very comedic Fred Wolf and Nick show understands but it seems this movie this movie has gone about this in a very topsy turvy way. I'm sure no one ever cared that the turtles never had lips so they could speak but I guess they wanted to be realistic and then having Mike deflect bullets with his nunchuks so apparently realism is thrown farther than Bay movie Foot Soldier - sigh
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 12:02 PM
Well several of the actors have used those exact words to describe this movie most recently Megan Fox in her E interview and the head FX guy also said they were going for a realistic approach in the interview that was posted last night.
Truth be told different aspects of TMNT play better as with different degrees of realism and seriousness. Even the very comedic Fred Wolf and Nick show understands but it seems this movie this movie has gone about this in a very topsy turvy way. I'm sure no one ever cared that the turtles never had lips so they could speak but I guess they wanted to be realistic and then having Mike deflect bullets with his nunchuks so apparently realism is thrown farther than Bay movie Foot Soldier - sigh
If they say so
Lou 500
07-17-2014, 12:16 PM
I'm a mutant then too
Mutant and Proud!
All humans on earth are the result of mutations.
A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
07-17-2014, 12:41 PM
All humans on earth are the result of mutations.
say it isn't so!!!
Leo656
07-17-2014, 01:25 PM
I'm also gonna clarify that some ideas only work in certain context and play horribly in live action. Like, in some older, rejected Superman scripts from the late 90s, there's a much-hated plot element where Luthor and Brainiac "merge" to become "Lexiac" near the end, and then he and Superman have a fist fight. A lot of people have pointed out that the much-beloved Justice League cartoon used almost the exact same idea in an episode, and it went over really well. The thing is, in live action that whole thing would look completely ridiculous, but it "fits" within the more flexible "reality" of a cartoon show.
It's not as easy as, "Well, it works in one so it will work in the other." That's really tough to pull off. It's pretty clear (and people who saw the extended preview have confirmed) that the OT is a prime source of inspiration for this movie, and frankly, I can't think of a worse starting point for trying to do a live-action TMNT without sinking into "Next Mutation" territory. Some of the stuff that went over on that show just can't work in live action, be it the horrible, awful "jokes" or the insipid "fight scenes". And I'm glad they're clearly not being 100% faithful to that, but they are trying to stretch the limits of credibility just a little farther than a live action movie generally allows, IF they're trying, as they claim, to "keep it real". They are so definitely NOT keeping it real.
As I've said elsewhere, it seems as if they're using the movie as a meta-joke, parodying over-the-top action movies the way the Mirage books parodied over-the-top comics of the time. But seriously, that's going to go over absolutely everyone's head if that's the case, and I doubt it even is. But it IS excessive and gaudy to the point of self-parody, regardless. Some things just don't play well in live action and we've seen a bunch of that already.
Coola Yagami
07-17-2014, 06:50 PM
**agreed with everything Leo says even though I keep imagining Kevin Nash sitting behind the computer typing**
Most of the people liking the needless changes act like they forgot what the turtles are. I'm surprised they're not complaining that the turtles aren't mini hulks that can flip over humvees in the nick cartoon and the mirage comics.
Slade
07-17-2014, 06:57 PM
**agreed with everything Leo says even though I keep imagining Kevin Nash sitting behind the computer typing**
You too huh?
terrorblade
07-17-2014, 07:27 PM
I remember when the first trailer was released there are complaints that was it was too dark and a generic grim of gritty adaptation of a popular franchise. Now that we've seen a lot footage the complaint now it's too comedic and over the top. Awesome.
Most of the people liking the needless changes act like they forgot what the turtles are. I'm surprised they're not complaining that the turtles aren't mini hulks that can flip over humvees in the nick cartoon and the mirage comics.
I'm sure those people who like this film are not the kind people that would complain if they saw a different design for the TMNT.
Shark_Blade
07-17-2014, 07:32 PM
Haters will keep complaining. OMG too dark! OMG too humorous! Bah sissy whiners.
I love the mix of dark and comedy from what I've seen so far. :D I reckon it'll have the good balance similar to the first movie.
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 07:34 PM
All humans on earth are the result of mutations.
Exactly! Everyones a mutant!
Shark_Blade
07-17-2014, 07:38 PM
All humans on earth are the result of mutations.
Citations needed.
IndigoErth
07-17-2014, 07:39 PM
Exactly! Everyones a mutant!
lol Planet of the Apes is already real, it's just really...boring.
This is why we love the idea of fellow talking humanoid beings, we're a lonely species. *tear*
Shark_Blade
07-17-2014, 07:41 PM
lol Planet of the Apes is already real, it's just really...boring.
This is why we love the idea of fellow talking humanoid beings, we're a lonely species. *tear*
They don't have turtles dancing in an elevator that's why! :tlol:
IndigoErth
07-17-2014, 07:43 PM
Well I meant we are already the Planet of the Apes lol, but no, neither do we sadly, not off screen.
Science, we must make it real!
Slade
07-17-2014, 07:47 PM
Exactly! Everyones a mutant!
Nah, I'm an alien.
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-17-2014, 08:02 PM
well i guess it could always have been worse
https://fbcdn-sphotos-g-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-xpa1/t31.0-8/10518676_10101451883581068_583008527010763725_o.jp g
donatello looks like he belongs in planet of the apes and my girlfriend wants to know why they look like gorillas
Leo Looks like he is about to start singing a song
Wildcat
07-17-2014, 08:12 PM
Just because people like the designs, myself included, doesn't mean we're against the originals or otherwise different style. Its just liking an alternate version. So now Im not allowed to like both? Its original/traditional or nothing?
Ive kind of enjoyed reading all the over-blown negativity. Its funny in a way. I see this for alot of movies and I always think that back in the day people weren't that cynical. Youd see a trailer for something, youd get excited to see the movie and that was pretty much it. It never even occurred to you to nitpick it and automatically assume the worst about it.
I know the internet plays a part with leaks/updates but its not the internets fault for making people into naysayers. The best word I can think of is...its all very pretentious. Somewhere along the way people took on the mindset that Hollywood is out to get everyone. I really like though that if something looks good or is generally liked the "Hollywood is evil" thing doesn't come up.
Things were just better back then right? Ah the good old 80s and 90s...when Hollywood was not about money :lol:
IndigoErth
07-17-2014, 08:26 PM
Just because people like the designs, myself included, doesn't mean we're against the originals or otherwise different style. Its just liking an alternate version. So now Im not allowed to like both? Its original/traditional or nothing?
Well that would be for the best... Pains me though that I have seen comments too often online from people who apparently feel the need to suddenly insult or snub much of what the last 30 years has been in order to support this one, or used it that way to appear against those who don't agree with them.
I can accept this as just/yet another version... as long as it doesn't go setting a bar of what's acceptable or the only thing now that could be viewed as "realistic enough."
That said, to be honest, the people who have been in love with the whole thing from the get-go have been a fairly boring ride. Their cries of joy and excitement get rather redundant fast. It's been a lot more interesting to watch those who were very very uncertain at first and taken aback by it - and maybe even still to an extent - find their way in it, actually look it over in great detail, pay attention to every little thing that's been "nitpicked" and decide what they actually do like about it (or solidly don't).
well i guess it could always have been worse
https://fbcdn-sphotos-g-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-xpa1/t31.0-8/10518676_10101451883581068_583008527010763725_o.jp g
donatello looks like he belongs in planet of the apes and my girlfriend wants to know why they look like gorillas
Leo Looks like he is about to start singing a song
Appropriately enough, Leo's giving his best Blue Steel.
http://www.focusst.org/forum/attachments/focus-st-builds/19708d1378947064-blue-steel-zoolander.jpg
(Did somebody beat me to this? I feel like someone had to have beaten me to this.)
Leo656
07-17-2014, 08:40 PM
**agreed with everything Leo says even though I keep imagining Kevin Nash sitting behind the computer typing**
He IS my own Personal Jesus. :lol:
My thing about the movie being "Just another version"... see, I get it, but I personally prefer movies to be more straight adaptations of the source material, at least for the most part. More people, by far, see movies than watch cartoons or read comics. So, I much prefer that films present a more pure, "Iconic" take, and leave the "experimentation" for the cartoons and comics where you have more wiggle room and you're playing to people who are already invested in the material.
I think the job of a franchise movie is to present a broad-strokes version of a well-known property, one that smooths out the rough edges, discards what doesn't work and plays up what does work. By the time even the most casual fan gets done watching, they should know all the important details of the franchise and the characters, and that should *mostly* all line up cleanly with what's going on in the other media. I don't think it's good to raise more questions than answers when you're trying to attract a new audience. I mean, there's a cartoon show running right now that's going to bear absolutely zero resemblance to the film, and the discrepancies are SO many, that like it or not, it's going to limit accessibility to some degree.
So, that kind of explains where I'm approaching from when it comes to licensed movies. At the very least, the *first* film in a franchise should be played totally straight and "Iconic", like Superman or Batman Begins. Once you've established a trust with the audience, you have infinitely more room to make changes and go into an entirely new direction. So much of the stuff I/We don't particularly like in this TMNT movie, would go over SO much better if it were in the second or third film of a series, not the very first one.
Coola Yagami
07-17-2014, 08:52 PM
Ive kind of enjoyed reading all the over-blown negativity. Its funny in a way. I see this for alot of movies and I always think that back in the day people weren't that cynical. Youd see a trailer for something, youd get excited to see the movie and that was pretty much it. It never even occurred to you to nitpick it and automatically assume the worst about it.
uhh.... Didn't need the internet or whatever to not be excited over the trailer for the Mario Bros movie... or TMNT III with how awful the outfits looked.... and even in modern day, you don't need to turn on a computer or have any outside influence to NOT be excited about the Dragonball Evolution trailer.
Crap is crap. You don't have to 'cynical' to notice it.
Commenter 42
07-17-2014, 09:10 PM
Well I meant we are already the Planet of the Apes lol, but no, neither do we sadly, not off screen.
Science, we must make it real!
Working on it.. I'll post my results LOL...
Leo656
07-17-2014, 09:27 PM
uhh.... Didn't need the internet or whatever to not be excited over the trailer for the Mario Bros movie... or TMNT III with how awful the outfits looked.... and even in modern day, you don't need to turn on a computer or have any outside influence to NOT be excited about the Dragonball Evolution trailer.
Crap is crap. You don't have to 'cynical' to notice it.
Yeah man. I still remember when I was a kid, seeing the first three Batman flicks in theaters. I even liked "Forever" at first, although much less than the first two and it eventually got really old and I stopped liking it much at all. But, I remember getting all excited to see a Behind The Scenes on "Batman & Robin", got super-pissed that they were obviously going 100% camp with it, and subsequently passed on seeing it in theaters and still have not seen it in full. Literally everything about it offends me. And that was way before the internet.
Don't even get me started on how I felt when I was finally old enough to accept how awful Superman IV is. Bad stuff based on stuff you love is still bad. That's been true way before the internet.
Slade
07-17-2014, 09:30 PM
yeah man. I still remember when i was a kid, seeing the first three batman flicks in theaters. I even liked "forever" at first, although much less than the first two and it eventually got really old and i stopped liking it much at all. But, i remember getting all excited to see a behind the scenes on "batman & robin", got super-pissed that they were obviously going 100% camp with it, and subsequently passed on seeing it in theaters and still have not seen it in full. Literally everything about it offends me. And that was way before the internet.
Don't even get me started on how i felt when i was finally old enough to accept how awful superman iv is. bad stuff based on stuff you love is still bad. That's been true way before the internet.
we need like buttons!!!
Wildcat
07-18-2014, 12:19 AM
I did not say the internet was to blame. I said it's NOT the internets fault...I just said it played a part. Which is natural. News and updates create more speculation and such nowadays and if you don't like what you see in trailers you won't be interested.
Maybe I worded it wrong. Just meant we saw trailers for what they were and that was that. If the movie sucked, that was that. We didn't brand everything as terrible or Hollywood going downhill.
Which was my other point. Speculation and not liking the designs is one thing. I certainly don't like everything about everything but the strict judgement many of you have made without even seeing the movie is quite absurd. Like I said though I see it alot not just for this. Sometimes for movies that don't even have a trailer.
I just think its funny cause this level of cynicism wasn't apparent back then. Not that I could see. Bad movies have always existed...you just had to actually watch them to find out. Now we don't have too, I guess...pretty amazing :D
pennydreadful
07-18-2014, 04:05 AM
Yeah, I know, I make broad generalizations to establish a point. I've seen several good Depp movies but nothing good since he did those insipid Pirate movies and resigned himself to being a living cartoon. I mean, I get it, but it's like that's his only speed, now. I mean, the first one was good, and then they just immediately started Xeroxing it, doing the exact same thing over however many movies. So pointless. So much wasted money and effort doing the exact same movie 5 times, just a little dumber each time. As clever and fresh as the original was when it came out, the sequels were equally vapid and brain-numbing. And they do that with everything now, which is why I'm annoyed with movies anymore.
This bugs the crap out of me too. I'm a big fan of the old adage "leave 'em wanting more". These days, they have to milk every possible bit of fun in the originals for the sake of spinning out endless sequels, and it ends up making me lose interest in the entire premise.
Everyone here knows they love TMNT, but here's another big question:
When did you realize that you were a TMNT fan for life? Was it when you first discovered them? Was it when all your friends started to not care about them? When did you truly know that the Turtles were something you wanted to share with your future children?
I don't want children... :P
then again i wasnt a transformers fan till beast wars so the movie looks have that beast wars feel for me
Yeeeeeah, Beast Wars fans in the house say HOOOOOO! 8)
Haters will keep complaining. OMG too dark! OMG too humorous! Bah sissy whiners.
Sissies rule, Shark. And when you say it, it sounds so sexy. ;)
http://31.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lnysob8mkZ1qbkervo1_500.jpg
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-18-2014, 09:41 AM
Yeeeeeah, Beast Wars fans in the house say HOOOOOO! 8)
well thats just Prime
Leolead
07-18-2014, 09:46 AM
All humans on earth are the result of mutations.
:blanksta: Meh..... i'm God's creation
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-18-2014, 09:49 AM
Meh....i'm god's creation.
God should be capitalized ..unless you are speaking about multiple gods
since its a name....unless you mean Zues
Commenter 42
07-18-2014, 08:03 PM
I hate when religion enters the forums.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 08:08 PM
I did not say the internet was to blame. I said it's NOT the internets fault...I just said it played a part. Which is natural. News and updates create more speculation and such nowadays and if you don't like what you see in trailers you won't be interested.
Maybe I worded it wrong. Just meant we saw trailers for what they were and that was that. If the movie sucked, that was that. We didn't brand everything as terrible or Hollywood going downhill.
Which was my other point. Speculation and not liking the designs is one thing. I certainly don't like everything about everything but the strict judgement many of you have made without even seeing the movie is quite absurd. Like I said though I see it alot not just for this. Sometimes for movies that don't even have a trailer.
I just think its funny cause this level of cynicism wasn't apparent back then. Not that I could see. Bad movies have always existed...you just had to actually watch them to find out. Now we don't have too, I guess...pretty amazing :D
Yeah... I'm seeing the trailer for what it is. A preview to a movie that took my all time favorite series and franchise and just raped it to hell and back. But seeing as how Bay treated the transformers and other ppl made 21 jump street into a comedy with bumbling idiots as main characters I shouldn't be surprised. If anyone ever makes a thunder cats movie I'll be terrified.
terrorblade
07-18-2014, 08:11 PM
I hate when religion enters the forums.
Well I think the whole debate about this movie is kinda reaching religion and politics level already. Both parties think they are right and anyone who thinks otherwise is wrong.
Slade
07-18-2014, 08:11 PM
I hate when religion enters the forums.
Science is a religion too.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 08:22 PM
But seeing as how Bay treated the transformers and other ppl made 21 jump street into a comedy with bumbling idiots as main characters I shouldn't be surprised. If anyone ever makes a thunder cats movie I'll be terrified.
That's my thing; like, I only barely ever watched 21 Jump Street as a kid, but seeing the trailers for the movie, I was like, "What the hell?" Why name something after something completely different? Like Bane in "Batman & Robin". Other than the visual, that wasn't Bane at all. At ALL. Literally nothing alike. Not even "A different version", literally "Something completely different." That Superman movie they were trying to make where Krypton never blew up, and he didn't fly, and wore black leather. In what way is that the same character or story? That's not "A different take,", that's, "A different story, with different characters, but a brand name that people will pay money for."
Much as I, too, want the Thundercats movie, I'm dreading where they'll go with it. "Transformers" has conclusively proven that "Toy Franchise movies don't need anything but CGI to become super hits." We keep proving that by not letting them die when they're bad, we just go "Eh, it's supposed to be fluff." Well, then that's all it'll ever be, unless we say we want more than that. :ohwell:
Anton Chigurh
07-18-2014, 08:55 PM
Science is a religion too.
science is proven....
but let's save this for another forum
NYShell
07-18-2014, 09:22 PM
:blanksta: Meh..... i'm God's creation
Me too!! :-)
Well I think the whole debate about this movie is kinda reaching religion and politics level already. Both parties think they are right and anyone who thinks otherwise is wrong.
Lol pretty much
Leo656
07-18-2014, 09:29 PM
Only among people who have no idea what constitutes an "argument" and what constitutes a "debate", or who think everything is either Wonderful or Terrible.
Anyone who actually knows the distinction can just agree to disagree while still saying whatever the hell they want. Like adults. That's, like, three or four people, anymore. And fewer every day.
Leolead
07-18-2014, 09:38 PM
It hasn't happened yet, but i really hope this doesn't turn into a religous debate.... :ohwell: back on topic, well yeah i think the Turtles look awesome, i think this movie might suprise you guys, you never know;)
Raven
07-18-2014, 09:44 PM
:blanksta: Meh..... i'm God's creation
God should be capitalized ..unless you are speaking about multiple gods
since its a name....unless you mean Zues
Amen to both of these.
So we can throw around as many theories and hows as to why they look the way they do, personally their designs are starting to grow on me as long as I look at them in the same vain as the Next Mutation ones.
The motion capturing of them looks great, not as amazing as Planet of the apes but it is very impressive. The look of the turtles is hard to get use to, and I wish they would trim back on a lot of things but I'm willing to give this a shot and see what it turns out to be.
Slade
07-18-2014, 09:46 PM
science is proven....
but let's save this for another forum
Not all of it is, and religion doesn't mean something that isn't proven.
but, as you said. Save it for another forum.
Raven
07-18-2014, 09:51 PM
science is proven....
but let's save this for another forum
I think he was speaking more in terms that some elements of Science do take a great amount of faith to believe in just as much as Christianity or Islam or Judaism.
I'm not poking fun at any one or trying to start anything, but something like a big bang or evolution has not been successfully proven (but much evidence has been given to support the ideas, but never fully proven.)
Just as in the same as religions, its all a personal choice that everyone can make.
Okay sorry for the off topic subject matter
/end.
Powder
07-18-2014, 09:56 PM
It hasn't happened yet, but i really hope this doesn't turn into a religous debate.... ]
You're the one who brought it up. & this last page & a half shows why you shouldn't in the future. Because it more or less already is a religious debate.
Slade
07-18-2014, 10:01 PM
I think it might have started to brew on page 9. I helped with it. I'm done now though.
So, back to why the turtles are ugly....
IndigoErth
07-18-2014, 10:03 PM
So how 'bout them Turtles. Think they'll win the premiere offs this season?
Fortunately it seems that even if not too cute on the outside (damn) they may still may have cuteness intact on the inside.
Gotta say I was rather taken aback by the models for a long time, esp before we ever got any hint of their personalities. Pretty much left it to Leo's job to win me over to this movie... and I gotta say he pretty well has now. Prior I didn't even feel like these guys were them, but after all the new stuff and last night that snow scene just hurt to watch, to where now I just wanna hug him... something I wouldn't have thought a few months ago. Even if I don't care too much for their choices of how to make them look.. ah he's still got lovableness in his personality, thank god.
Slade
07-18-2014, 10:05 PM
I'm mad I didn't get to see any of that stuff last night. Yeah, I can post while I'm at work, but I got no t.v.
IndigoErth
07-18-2014, 10:09 PM
I'm mad I didn't get to see any of that stuff last night. Yeah, I can post while I'm at work, but I got no t.v.
If you still haven't seen it, Nick put it on their site, check the Turtles section. :)
Slade
07-18-2014, 10:16 PM
Ehh, there is a TON of stuff blocked on the work computers. Videos are one of them.
IndigoErth
07-18-2014, 10:39 PM
Ehh, there is a TON of stuff blocked on the work computers. Videos are one of them.
Well that's no fair. :( (Ok begin work I suppose it is, but still.. lol)
Commenter 42
07-18-2014, 11:36 PM
Science is a religion too.
Says the person typing a response on the internet into a computer.
Commenter 42
07-18-2014, 11:39 PM
Well I think the whole debate about this movie is kinda reaching religion and politics level already. Both parties think they are right and anyone who thinks otherwise is wrong.
Agreed. Or Mets v Yankees - a more apt metaphor perhaps?
Slade
07-18-2014, 11:44 PM
Do you really want to go there?
Let's stick with the fiction of TMNT, and leave the other fairy tale for another site.
Creationists; there's one on every board. :roll:
Ha, wow. Good job there buddy.
Says the person typing a response on the internet into a computer.
OH, no, don't change it now.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 11:47 PM
The only correct way to settle this is to simply say, "F*ck the f*cking Yankees" and move on.
Warhorse
07-18-2014, 11:49 PM
The only correct way to settle this is to simply say, "F*ck the f*cking Yankees" and move on.
I thought it was "F*ck the f*cking f*ckers"? :lol:
Leo656
07-18-2014, 11:51 PM
Same exact thing, really. :lol:
Commenter 42
07-19-2014, 04:43 AM
OH, no, don't change it now.
I was trying to think of a less inciediary response.
Again, you want to debate TMNT, have at it. I don't give a **** about your beliefs.
Back on topic...
With every new commercial, the cg looks less and less realistic. At first I thought the design was just ugly, but worse than that, it's simply a cartoon.
They clearly skimped on the render budget. Bay has always been cheap, but it's getting out of hand.
Shark_Blade
07-19-2014, 05:25 AM
Which part of the cgi is cheap looking? The snow chase? :-?
Leo656
07-19-2014, 08:09 AM
I personally can't recall specifics myself either, but watching the BTS there's still a few spots where you really gotta hope they're scrambling to touch it up. There were a few spots where the CGI clearly wasn't as smooth as others, by a lot. They said they're working on it, so we'll see. I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt, but seeing as how it's this late in the game already, I'll simply reiterate my wariness that they may have bitten off a little bit too much right from the start, by deciding on making a movie that relies so much on the CGI.
A lot of the visual choices for the film really accomplished nothing in the Big Picture except make the poor guys' jobs a million times harder. I've always questioned that.
Powder
07-19-2014, 08:37 AM
The turtle childhood scenes look... well, not as good as the rest. Which I hope will be fixed, as that's one of the things I think this film has going for it.
BubblyShell22
07-19-2014, 09:49 AM
Wow. What a thread. I do think your perspective is fine, but I don't like the way the Turtles look. The reason they have looked the way they have is to not only appeal to kids but to also fool enemies. No need to worry about these Turtles who look so cute and then BAM! They hit you where it hurts and you realize that despite their cute looks, they really are a deadly threat when they need to be. These Turtles are too strong and too powerful when they don't need to be. They should rely only on their martial arts skills and nothing more than that, but these Turtles aren't that way, and it's unsettling to me. Also the clothes just bug the heck out of me. Keep them traditionally without clothes and let their personalities and masks differentiate them. No need for the bulky clothing. That's just me though.
Do I want it to succeed? No because we still have the Nick show and the IDW comic to fall back on if it doesn't. I'll still see it once in theaters, but if I don't like it, I'm not going to bother seeing it again or getting the DVD.
I first discovered the Turtles with the 80's cartoon and loved them from there. Never liked Next Mutation at all, but most of the other stuff I was okay with.
If the Turtles could stay as they've been for this movie, maybe I wouldn't mind the designs as much. As I said, don't rely on brute strength and just focus on the NINJA aspect of the Turtles. They were trained in ninjitsu, so they don't have to have brute strength for that.
Again this is just me though.
Commenter 42
07-19-2014, 02:48 PM
Which part of the cgi is cheap looking? The snow chase? :-?
I'd say 3/4's of it.
Rendering is expensive, and I think, just like some of the Scenes in TASM2, they chose to cut corners to meet the deadline.
Different render engines handle images differently, and you can adjust the length of the render to suit delivery dates. If I had to guess, it's the sub vendors that are at fault, not ILM, but still, some really weak outputs for such a big budget film.
exhibit a:
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-JDszO6Zn6Gk/U8Xeq_QOcAI/AAAAAAAAQXs/EP3k2crOX_4/s1600/TMNT+-+Teenage+Mutant+Ninja+Turtles+2014+-+Fake+Looking+CG+-+Masks+Movie+Poster+-+ShelfPorn.jpg
Not sure how they arrived at this, but guessing that is the result of many people over many hours at a multi million dollar studio.
compare that with exhibit b:
http://www.cgfeedback.com/cgfeedback/attachment.php?attachmentid=24575&stc=1&d=1403500646
http://www.cgfeedback.com/cgfeedback/attachment.php?attachmentid=24458&stc=1&d=1402637183
one guy, alone, on his laptop, in a few days.
judge for yourself.
IndigoErth
07-19-2014, 02:50 PM
If the Turtles could stay as they've been for this movie, maybe I wouldn't mind the designs as much. As I said, don't rely on brute strength and just focus on the NINJA aspect of the Turtles. They were trained in ninjitsu, so they don't have to have brute strength for that.
I do hope there is more martial arts from the Turtles than what we're seeing in trailers. So far Leo has been kicking the crap out of people in some of it (yay), but hard to get a feeling of how much the other three may be doing. Poor Raph, maybe he's too bulky in this version and is limited to his fits... lol
That kinda brings me back to something I was thinking about earlier though... As with any other criticism, the "no/not enough ninjitsu" statements have previously been met with the now age-old routine defense and some have said it doesn't have to have it.
And no, it's an overpowered action sort of movie, I suppose it doesn't have to. But there are reasons it absolutely should include at least a fair amount. Aside from the fact that this is TMNT, think about it... If they use skilled martial artists as stunt doubles for the motion capture for parts of it, that also means that some of the Turtles' own moves are legitimately REAL. (Not that the original movies didn't have performers pulling off some of it as well, but I don't doubt there were more limitations of the costumes than there are in the motion capture suits. And cartoons of course are just going to be rough/embellished estimates/mimicry.)
Ok, so action movies are going to make it look crazier, but... People can't watch other fictional heroes and then go out there and learn to fly, or use webs, or have metal claws shot out of the backs of their hands. But you could certainly take up a martial arts class and try to learn some of the Turtle's legit moves. Do people know how awesome that is?? :D Making sure there is a fair amount of martial arts just helps add to the realism... is should by all rights be in it.
exhibit a:
compare that with exhibit b:
Well, to be fair it's also a difference in textures of course, the human textures look taken from a real life person rather than created by hand.
Warhorse
07-19-2014, 02:58 PM
I do hope there is more martial arts from the Turtles than what we're seeing in trailers. So far Leo has been kicking the crap out of people in some of it (yay), but hard to get a feeling of how much the other three may be doing. Poor Raph, maybe he's too bulky in this version and is limited to his fits... lol
I noticed this too. Yeah, he's been portrayed as the strongest of the group, but not to the point where he can't be swift and athletic. And, another thing, so far, I'm just seeing a brooding Raph. Yeah, we know he broods, but he also can be very funny with the sarcastic jokes and one liners. And I don't like how the Turtles are mean to April at first. They were never mean to her in other incarnations.:ohwell:
IndigoErth
07-19-2014, 03:03 PM
I noticed this too. Yeah, he's been portrayed as the strongest of the group, but not to the point where he can't be swift and athletic. And, another thing, so far, I'm just seeing a brooding Raph. Yeah, we know he broods, but he also can be very funny with the sarcastic jokes and one liners. And I don't like how the Turtles are mean to April at first. They were never mean to her in other incarnations.:ohwell:
I agree, I do hope they show some lighter sides to Raph and he's not mad all of the time and just make him look mean. He may be grouchy sometimes, but I wouldn't say he's a mean guy.
NYShell
07-19-2014, 04:32 PM
The only correct way to settle this is to simply say, "F*ck the f*cking Yankees" and move on.
Gasp. How dare you
pennydreadful
07-19-2014, 06:14 PM
But seeing as how Bay treated the transformers and other ppl made 21 jump street into a comedy with bumbling idiots as main characters I shouldn't be surprised. If anyone ever makes a thunder cats movie I'll be terrified.
Much as I, too, want the Thundercats movie, I'm dreading where they'll go with it. "Transformers" has conclusively proven that "Toy Franchise movies don't need anything but CGI to become super hits." We keep proving that by not letting them die when they're bad, we just go "Eh, it's supposed to be fluff." Well, then that's all it'll ever be, unless we say we want more than that. :ohwell:
Argh, yeah - I'm hanging for a live action Thundercats, but Bay had better keep his hands off it, by god. I'm sick to death of these sh*tty reboots that just suck the heart out of the concept entirely. Like that 21 Jump Street thing - gah, I can't even talk about that.
I agree, I do hope they show some lighter sides to Raph and he's not mad all of the time and just make him look mean. He may be grouchy sometimes, but I wouldn't say he's a mean guy.
Agreed - Raph is gruff and standoffish, but underneath he's a big marshmallow, with a heart the size of a planet. He puts up a wall because he cares about things so much, but he's not good at expressing it. If this movie makes him a tough-guy, 'roid-raging meathead who benchpresses his way through every problem, I'm going to be pissed. They have to show his softer side. Or else... I'mma throw a tantrum on the internet. :P
teslagirl
07-19-2014, 06:47 PM
Agreed - Raph is gruff and standoffish, but underneath he's a big marshmallow, with a heart the size of a planet. He puts up a wall because he cares about things so much, but he's not good at expressing it. If this movie makes him a tough-guy, 'roid-raging meathead who benchpresses his way through every problem, I'm going to be pissed. They have to show his softer side. Or else... I'mma throw a tantrum on the internet. :P
There are way too many behind the scenes shots of April holding Raph's hand (or this (http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-059tPXIq87Y/UeqWKAUYklI/AAAAAAAAAEU/fLNQfM8xiOM/s1600/Ninja-Turtles-set.jpg) shot) to think that he is at least willing to let her be comforting after his brothers are taken. (Which is what I assume the timeline for those photos are.) Mr. Grumpy Marshmallow may still be intact. (I hope, I hope.)
IndigoErth
07-19-2014, 07:05 PM
My question though, are photos like that taken during shooting/rehearsing, or are they just photos of on-set activity and not necessarily when actors are acting. I suppose rehearsing might have happened sans disguise first.
teslagirl
07-19-2014, 08:41 PM
My question though, are photos like that taken during shooting/rehearsing, or are they just photos of on-set activity and not necessarily when actors are acting. I suppose rehearsing might have happened sans disguise first.
Not sure, really, at this point it's all conjecture. But I can't really imagine they'd stand around between shots chilling and holding hands. :lol:
Galactus
07-19-2014, 09:21 PM
My question though, are photos like that taken during shooting/rehearsing, or are they just photos of on-set activity and not necessarily when actors are acting. I suppose rehearsing might have happened sans disguise first.
Wasn't there an implication that one seen Raph was walking around near entertainers dressed in childrens cartoon character outfits and so he was fine without a disguise as people would assume he was a guy in a costume.
Leo656
07-20-2014, 12:45 AM
Gasp. How dare you
Cuz "If It Ain't Wright, It Ain't Right", buddy. Let's. Go. METS.
Warhorse
07-20-2014, 12:56 AM
Wasn't there an implication that one seen Raph was walking around near entertainers dressed in childrens cartoon character outfits and so he was fine without a disguise as people would assume he was a guy in a costume.
Now, that got me thinking. Maybe we're going to get a quick nod in the movie to the 2k3 Raph centric episode "Lone Raph and Cub". It would be a nice and subtle way for his to show his soft side if some little boy or girl just wanted a picture taken with him, and he decided to do it.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.