PDA

View Full Version : Rarest TMNT Comics?


miru
07-16-2014, 09:20 PM
Which TMNT-related comics are the rarest. And no, it's not just Mirage, Archie, Image, and IDW. It can be anything. Manga, Fleetway, Dreamwave, even things like newspaper strips.

MrPliggins
07-16-2014, 09:35 PM
Turtlemania Gold (10 copies)
Turtlemania Silver (100 copies)

Mirage:
Gobbledygook #1 and 2 (if it counts for the TMNT ad on back cover) (50 copies each; some sources say 150 copies each)
TMNT vol 1 #1 6th printing hardcover (500 copies)
TMNT vol 1 #3 NYCC variant (500 copies)

Tales of the TMNT vol 2 #32 and #70 (final issue)

Volume 4 #25 and 26 seem very hard to track down.
Also #29 and #30 (1,000 copies each)

Archie:
The last few issues had a lower print run as Turtle mania had died down (72 was the last issue).

Image:
Also the last few issues of this series, same reason (I think 23 was the last issue).

IDW:
There are plenty of variants with low print runs, however I do not really collect them so I can't speak to which ones.

Those are the rarest from the top of my head.

CyberCubed
07-16-2014, 10:01 PM
Not counting stuff like first prints or limited covers, I'd say the rarest issues are:

- Later half of the Image run
- Archie Special #11
- Mutanimals #9
- Tales of the TMNT #32

ianke_2002
07-16-2014, 11:12 PM
[QUOTE=MrPliggins;1305012]

Volume 4 #25 and 26 seem very hard to track down.

[QUOTE]

Interesting that you mention 25 and 26. I got those without much problem but have never seen 28 and 29.

Red Robin
07-17-2014, 07:13 AM
I guess Vol. 3 #24 & #25 are also extremly rare.
Besides Volume 3 #15 - #23, Tales of the TMNT #68 - #70, Volume 4 #25 - #30.

The last Vol 4 #29 i saw, sold a few days ago for 275$. :o
Also #30 seems completely gone. After Mirage had them on their website for the second time the prices are rising to insane amounts. And the movie isn't even out yet.

thingy
07-17-2014, 10:36 AM
Only 50 copies of TMNT Adventures #∞ (http://tmntentity.blogspot.co.uk/2013/02/tmnt-adventures.html)
Well you said it could be anything.:teek:

Metropoliskid41
07-17-2014, 10:38 AM
[QUOTE=Red Robin;1305361]I guess Vol. 3 #24 & #25 are also extremly rare.
QUOTE]

Volume 3 (the Image run) only officially had 23 issues. Issues #24 and #25 are fan made productions written by Andrew who is a member on the boards here.

Joey Kamikaze
07-17-2014, 03:30 PM
Growing up I would have sworn TMNTA #13 and #16 belonged on that list. I didn't get to read either issue until the age of the internet began. Neither was ever available through Archie's back issue orders back in the day. I just finally found a copy of #13 maybe three years ago.

Jasper-X
07-17-2014, 03:42 PM
Growing up I would have sworn TMNTA #13 and #16 belonged on that list. I didn't get to read either issue until the age of the internet began. Neither was ever available through Archie's back issue orders back in the day. I just finally found a copy of #13 maybe three years ago.

i'm with you on #13, that one took me forever to track down, from the time i had the complete archie run except #13 it took me four years to track that one down

MrPliggins
07-17-2014, 05:17 PM
[QUOTE=MrPliggins;1305012]

Volume 4 #25 and 26 seem very hard to track down.

[QUOTE]

Interesting that you mention 25 and 26. I got those without much problem but have never seen 28 and 29.

It took me about a year to find #26. However I was patient and didn't want to pay a high price. I suppose it can be had at higher prices more often. Still, a search of current and completed listings on ebay turns up nothing.
Pretty much everything from 25 and up is rare to some extent (except 32 which at the moment is still available on Mirage's site. In the future it will be rare).

wilddiverse
07-17-2014, 05:37 PM
I don't know how sought-after it is, but the Cowabunga Comics - TMNT Benefit Book done by Mirage for the Friends of Children, Inc. charity in 1991 is not commonly found. No idea what sort of print run it had.

Archon_Turtle
07-21-2014, 04:03 PM
Turtlemania Gold (10 copies)
Turtlemania Silver (100 copies)

Mirage:
Gobbledygook #1 and 2 (if it counts for the TMNT ad on back cover) (50 copies each; some sources say 150 copies each)
TMNT vol 1 #1 6th printing hardcover (500 copies)
TMNT vol 1 #3 NYCC variant (500 copies)

Tales of the TMNT vol 2 #32 and #70 (final issue)

Volume 4 #25 and 26 seem very hard to track down.
Also #29 and #30 (1,000 copies each)

Archie:
The last few issues had a lower print run as Turtle mania had died down (72 was the last issue).

Image:
Also the last few issues of this series, same reason (I think 23 was the last issue).

IDW:
There are plenty of variants with low print runs, however I do not really collect them so I can't speak to which ones.

Those are the rarest from the top of my head.

Interesting thing about that Turtlemania Silver. While having double the print run, it seems to appear FAR less often than the Gobbledygook pair. I wonder if it is because it's difficult to tell the difference between the white and the silver without them sitting next to each other (or looking at the back), or because it's just lesser known....or both.

Nortock Diab
12-21-2017, 09:58 AM
Was there any change in rarity since this thread was opened?

I have in mind the 500 copies of Digital Webbing Presents #24 (TMNT cover) that I really can't find anywhere anymore.

mrmaczaps
12-21-2017, 10:30 AM
Turtlemania Gold (10 copies)
Turtlemania Silver (100 copies)

Mirage:
Gobbledygook #1 and 2 (if it counts for the TMNT ad on back cover) (50 copies each; some sources say 150 copies each)
TMNT vol 1 #1 6th printing hardcover (500 copies)
TMNT vol 1 #3 NYCC variant (500 copies)

Tales of the TMNT vol 2 #32 and #70 (final issue)

Volume 4 #25 and 26 seem very hard to track down.
Also #29 and #30 (1,000 copies each)

Archie:
The last few issues had a lower print run as Turtle mania had died down (72 was the last issue).

Image:
Also the last few issues of this series, same reason (I think 23 was the last issue).

IDW:
There are plenty of variants with low print runs, however I do not really collect them so I can't speak to which ones.

Those are the rarest from the top of my head.

Vol 4 #31 & #32 should be added here with a 1000 copy print run....

And I have a copy of either 25 or 26 for sale... lol.

funatic
12-23-2017, 11:29 AM
Was there any change in rarity since this thread was opened?

I have in mind the 500 copies of Digital Webbing Presents #24 (TMNT cover) that I really can't find anywhere anymore.

Man I once encountered a STACK of these at a comic con... why didn't I just buy them all!? lol

bgb1018
12-29-2017, 08:31 AM
Mirage volume 2 #10 was the one that took me forever to find cause it got delayed a few months due to the studio flooding so it didn't have a huge print amount compared to others. Got lucky that someone on here had one for sale when I posted about it a few years ago.

neatoman
12-29-2017, 08:37 AM
Only 50 copies of TMNT Adventures #∞ (http://tmntentity.blogspot.co.uk/2013/02/tmnt-adventures.html)
Well you said it could be anything.:teek:

Yeah that would certainly be it when it comes to semi-official TMNT comics.

I wonder how many people actually jacked off to it...

Nortock Diab
12-29-2017, 01:26 PM
The Fandom needs a new print of TMNT Adventures #∞.

mrmaczaps
12-29-2017, 10:14 PM
The Fandom needs a new print of TMNT Adventures #∞.

Please don't...

beardcore84
01-02-2018, 12:50 PM
Whats the deal with Tales #32? A few people mentioned it being rare. I think I got it a long time ago but I guess I'm not sure what makes that specific one rare.

Mayhem
01-03-2018, 04:19 AM
Not sure about the regular version, but there was a specific art gallery variant for Tales #32 which is very hard to find.

Chabrendeki
01-03-2018, 04:35 AM
The Fandom needs a new print of TMNT Adventures #∞.

Oversized IDW Deluxe Edition? :D

Nortock Diab
01-03-2018, 06:50 AM
Not sure about the regular version, but there was a specific art gallery variant for Tales #32 which is very hard to find.

#32 variant scarcity probably is the main cause behind regular #32 relative rarity. Some fans believed #32 was rare and bought it in priority compared to other Tales vol.2 issues and now it really is harder to find than other issues. At least that's my analysis of the situation :tsmile:.

Oversized IDW Deluxe Edition? :D

So impossible... But you can count me in anytime!
I really dig the story behind TMNT Adventures #∞ and the strangeness of the book :tgrin:.

HeroTurtlesFan
01-03-2018, 06:52 AM
A number of the later Hero Turtles comics from Fleetway are very hard to get hold of. Rare indeed.

Of course, that doesn't necessarily mean "in demand collectable". For me, to be that, something needs both rarity and desirability - some of these late Fleetway issues have the former, but I'm not sure about the latter.

Nortock Diab
01-03-2018, 08:03 AM
A number of the later Hero Turtles comics from Fleetway are very hard to get hold of. Rare indeed.

Of course, that doesn't necessarily mean "in demand collectable". For me, to be that, something needs both rarity and desirability - some of these late Fleetway issues have the former, but I'm not sure about the latter.

The same thing goes with some French printings which are literally impossible to come by while at the same time probably no one is really looking for them (but me :tgrin:).

bgb1018
01-04-2018, 10:02 AM
A number of the later Hero Turtles comics from Fleetway are very hard to get hold of. Rare indeed.

Of course, that doesn't necessarily mean "in demand collectable". For me, to be that, something needs both rarity and desirability - some of these late Fleetway issues have the former, but I'm not sure about the latter.

I've been wondering about the rarity and value of the Hero Turtle books for a few weeks now. My dad gave me 3 or 4 issues for Christmas that he found online. I had never heard of that run of books for the turtles before then.

DK2
01-05-2018, 06:52 PM
I'd like to think the misprint of the Tales TMNT #1/TMNT #4 2nd print should be in here too. Maybe 1000 or less survived the scrapping of the misprint. Doesn't seem any valuable though either. I think all the TMNT Vol. 4 issues #29-32 as they automatically only had the 1000 copies made, mail order from Mirage. What about the Creed/TMNT crossover? Or was that the misprint of the TMNT Vol. 2 issue with the Creed ad put on the front cover? I don't know anything else as I only go for the known issues out there. Yeah for sure the Image TMNT series. I'd say the last half is hardest to come by. It went bi-monthly later on after being a monthly series at first. More comic stores probably forgot about it in the solicits.