PDA

View Full Version : Least favorite IDW comic?


CyberCubed
07-17-2014, 08:49 PM
Other than the X-files crossover?

Powder
07-17-2014, 09:07 PM
Prolly Mikey's micro issue. I enjoyed Kuhn's main series run, but his art in that particular book was absolutely dreadful. The story was okay, nothing special, but the jarring inconsistencies with Mikey's size & proportions, among other details, really ruined my immersion. The art on the Animated Adventures issue that focused on Fishface was pretty bad too.

Though... Kevin's solo books might take the cake. I love looking at his work but #21 was mad predictable & didn't advance the story (nor feel in the tone of the IDW series), & his annual was human central. Like nooo turtles. Just a bunch of Irish drunks & petty thieves.

CyberCubed
07-17-2014, 09:36 PM
Yeah the first annual from Kevin wasn't that great. Here's hoping the second one coming out next month is much better.

thebrownranger
07-17-2014, 09:43 PM
Anything with Ross Campbell really. Andy Kuhn is also there with least favorites.

Love Mateus Santolouco's artwork. Only beef I personally have with his take on TMNT comics is the Nick influence, primarily with Mikey and Donnie.

Cipher
07-18-2014, 02:54 AM
#21, most likely. Sorry, guys.

Also, wasn't crazy about "City Fall" as a whole. :/

Prolly Mikey's micro issue. I enjoyed Kuhn's main series run, but his art in that particular book was absolutely dreadful. The story was okay, nothing special, but the jarring inconsistencies with Mikey's size & proportions, among other details, really ruined my immersion. The art on the Animated Adventures issue that focused on Fishface was pretty bad too.
I'll cut against the grain and say that was actually my favorite micro-issue of the lot. It was a fun one-off.

MikeandRaph87
07-18-2014, 08:42 AM
My least favorite would be #5 of the ongoing. It took me two arcs to get interested in the slow start but now its my favorite comic month after month. #5 revealed the reincarnation bit I don't care for and was one long flashback to ancient Japan that just lead to a family being hunted down and brutally murdered. A bit much in the violence and no Ninja Turtles fighting bad guys. The last page was the saving grace adding the familar mask. Just my opinion.

I didn't get the X-Files issue or Cthulhu company crossover two issues.After the mousers arc only Casey Jones featured oneshot did I find myself bored. Everything else has had me eager to turn the next page. The various artist does not bother me the least bit because of the strong cohesive story told by Tom.

CyberCubed
07-18-2014, 08:59 AM
#5 was what actually sold me on the IDW series and was the first issue that made me realize the potential of this series. The book did have a slow start but #5 is still among my favorites.

Leomaru
07-18-2014, 10:06 AM
I'm not a fan of Kuhn's artwork. Utrom Empire issues were OK since the focus was not on the turtles.

Sanjuro
07-18-2014, 11:22 AM
I'm starting to get into the IDW series finally.

The artwork and dialog in the very early issues are pretty cringeworthy. It has been improving, but I'm only around issue fifteen or so, so I don't have a lone issue which I can single out.

Joey Kamikaze
07-18-2014, 01:58 PM
We're not counting the X-Files crossover because it's a shoe-in, huh? :lol:

It would have to be the first annual. That book is just plain hard to read--the lack of color, the squashed too-dark panels, the jumping around in chronology and the focus on a bunch of same-looking human characters we'd never met before made it hard to tell what the hell was going on most of the time. It joins the X-Files crossover on the list of issue I'm likely to skip next re-read.

Not to jump on Kevin Eastman, but #21 is definitely in second place (or first if you only count the main series). It feels like a backup instead of a full issue.

Frankly, I like Kevin's covers but I'm not crazy about his full issues. Also, I liked the Mikey micro and Utrom Empire, but I'm not wild about Kuhn's work on the main book and I hope he stays on side projects only.

CyberCubed
07-18-2014, 02:15 PM
I think they reprinted the first annual in color later so you can see what's going on.

Joey Kamikaze
07-18-2014, 06:45 PM
I think they reprinted the first annual in color later so you can see what's going on.Sure, but IDW can **** off if they think I'm going to pay $30 for a color version of an issue that wasn't that great the first time.

ToTheNines
07-18-2014, 09:03 PM
#21 comes to mind first. Hated that one kinda. Although its events were brilliantly tied into Kitsune's brainwashing of Leo a couple issues later.

Only other issue that comes to mind is... I got nothing. Pretty consistent book.

ProphetofGanja
07-18-2014, 11:13 PM
I can't really think of one issue I strongly disliked, but the very beginning parts of the story where Raph was still on his own and Casey was just getting wailed on by his dad, I was like, "wtf is this?? I thought this was a Ninja Turtles book!" but things definitely picked up after that first arc, and I really haven't had any complaints since.

Well, I guess my only complaint is that I still can't get enough of this series!

Jester
07-18-2014, 11:30 PM
Prolly Mikey's micro issue. I enjoyed Kuhn's main series run, but his art in that particular book was absolutely dreadful. The story was okay, nothing special, but the jarring inconsistencies with Mikey's size & proportions, among other details, really ruined my immersion.

I'll cut against the grain and say that was actually my favorite micro-issue of the lot. It was a fun one-off.
I think that might be exactly why I DON'T like the Mikey 1-shot. Of the 4 his probably has tied back into the main continuity the least....I mean I can't think of any thing from it that has come to play later on.

Sanjuro
07-19-2014, 07:54 AM
I liked the annual issue probably the best. The color issues have been some of the worst things in the franchise, at least so far.

Redeemer
07-19-2014, 05:12 PM
Issue 21 is my least favorite in the on-going
Mikey is my least favorite one-shot
X-files cross over is my least favorite of the cross-overs

Sanjuro
07-19-2014, 05:39 PM
Just read #21 today. Probably the best in the series.

Powder
07-19-2014, 06:00 PM
You pretty much hate everything that's come from Viacom though, right? Barring new work from Mirage vets, anyway.

Sanjuro
07-19-2014, 06:12 PM
No. I have no issue with Viacom.

Wentos
07-19-2014, 06:53 PM
My answers are the same as everyone else's, so hopefully I can put a new spin on why exactly I don't like them.

The Michelangelo micro: Everyone hates on Andy Kuhn's art (and rightfully so), but the art wasn't the only problem. The premise of the issue was really contrived and not terribly well executed. And why does the story call so much attention to the Dresden and its unique radiation? Bobby's already said that nothing's going to come of it, so why even introduce the idea in the first place?

The annual and issue #21: The annual's story is a mountain of junk slapped together with no real rhyme or reason. Somewhere in the neighborhood of 20 characters are introduced, the chronology shifts constantly, the characters all look really similar, and the toning is really heavy-handed. It's almost impossible to discern what's going on. Issue 21 isn't nearly as bad in terms of story, but it feels like a waste of an issue, meant to showcase Eastman's fight choreography rather than move things forward. But honestly, my biggest beef with these issues is that they're drawn by Kevin Eastman at all. Not to say that Eastman's art is bad, but it's unmistakeably Mirage-era. Having Eastman draw and tone an issue of the IDW run just feels wrong to me. The IDW series has its own style and its own voice. It should be moving forward and blazing its own trail, not trying to ape a bygone era.

Overall, the IDW series is remarkably consistent. When a bad issue does come out, it's pretty unusual.

Sanjuro
07-19-2014, 07:15 PM
If one of IDW's primary goals was to distance themselves from the Mirage product, then they are definitely failing by your opinion.

Redeemer
07-19-2014, 07:21 PM
But honestly, my biggest beef with these issues is that they're drawn by Kevin Eastman at all. Not to say that Eastman's art is bad, but it's unmistakeably Mirage-era. Having Eastman draw and tone an issue of the IDW run just feels wrong to me. The IDW series has its own style and its own voice. It should be moving forward and blazing its own trail, not trying to ape a bygone era.

Overall, the IDW series is remarkably consistent. When a bad issue does come out, it's pretty unusual.

Great breakdown overal and completely agree on why Eastman should not be drawing issues

Joey Kamikaze
07-19-2014, 07:23 PM
But honestly, my biggest beef with these issues is that they're drawn by Kevin Eastman at all. Not to say that Eastman's art is bad, but it's unmistakeably Mirage-era. Having Eastman draw and tone an issue of the IDW run just feels wrong to me. The IDW series has its own style and its own voice. It should be moving forward and blazing its own trail, not trying to ape a bygone era.Yeah. I mean, I'm looking forward to annual #2, but more because I want to see the fallout of introducing Renet into the IDW universe in future issues of the main book. I honestly have mixed expectations on the annual itself.

Tazi
07-20-2014, 03:03 AM
Oh god, I can't believe there's so much hate on Kuhn's awesome Mike Mignola-esque art! Sure his turtles are not that good, but at least he can draw human heads/faces properly unlike Bates or Eastman.

TomWaltz
07-20-2014, 11:21 AM
I think that might be exactly why I DON'T like the Mikey 1-shot. Of the 4 his probably has tied back into the main continuity the least....I mean I can't think of any thing from it that has come to play later on.

I LOVE the Mikey one-shot! We'll come back to those events and characters, never fear...

We gots all kinds of plans in the works... MWAHAHAHA! (Evil laugh)

Talk soon...

Tom W.

Cipher
07-20-2014, 03:29 PM
I think that might be exactly why I DON'T like the Mikey 1-shot. Of the 4 his probably has tied back into the main continuity the least....I mean I can't think of any thing from it that has come to play later on.
All-continuity-all-the-time has made the IDW series feel slightly myopic, though, and really stifled character development except for what ties directly into the plot at hand (because what else are you going to do?). I don't want everything to have major consequences later on. That feels contrived.

On a similar note, but for completely different reasons, I also enjoyed Annual #1. My only misgiving with it is how different the tone is from surrounding material. With just a slightly different presentation, I could have really dug the "And now we break for some noir zaniness" route it took.

Oh god, I can't believe there's so much hate on Kuhn's awesome Mike Mignola-esque art!
Kuhn is neither my favorite nor least favorite artist (I think) to have worked on IDW's series. I thought his style really fit the Michelangelo one-shot, Mike's size-changing shenanigans not withstanding.

mrjafunk
07-20-2014, 06:09 PM
Anything Ross Campbell touches! The art work is just so bad it ruins the whole story for me. The new TMNT in time looks like it would fit in with the muppets!

Sanjuro
07-20-2014, 06:16 PM
Anything Ross Campbell touches! The art work is just so bad it ruins the whole story for me. The new TMNT in time looks like it would fit in with the muppets!

Looks like I disagree with everyone on here now!

Awesome.

CyberCubed
07-20-2014, 06:22 PM
Looks like I disagree with everyone on here now!

Awesome.

He's the minority, Ross' art is loved here.

In fact he's probably my third favorite.

Sanjuro
07-20-2014, 06:26 PM
He's the minority, Ross' art is loved here.

In fact he's probably my third favorite.

His quality varies. He is probably my favorite though for the new blood. Maybe there has been different inkers or mood.

I still wish the books were in black and white personally.

Dan Duncan? Was he the first one for this series? I would say that has been my least favorite art so far.

SDCC
07-21-2014, 06:08 AM
Hate to ape what everyone else has said, but the annual takes it for me.

The artwork made it hard to discern what was going on and who was who. I found myself going back a few pages several times to figure out what was going on.

He may be their co-creator but I don't really like his style.

IDW has it's own way of doing things with this series. Santolouco, Campbell and Duncan in particular have been great. Forcing in this older style just shows it up.

The only issues I've not read are related to infestation I think. The X-Files issue was....not the best.

But the main numbered issues? I've found them awesome throughout.

Metropoliskid41
07-21-2014, 08:53 AM
I can honestly say I have loved every single issue of this series and all of its tie-ins and one-shots. Not a single clunker in the bunch. As a fan of a lot of indy books (seriously people, go pick up Dark Horse Presents) I love the varying styles in art that we've gotten between the micro-series, mini-series tie-ins, and the rotating casts of artists. I've preferred some issues more than others, but truly loved them all. Kuhn's style was definitely different, but I still really like it, and honestly I thought the Mikey issue was one of his best. I dug the size change, I thought that was a conscious and intentional move on his part to reflect Mikey's state of mind, or how he was sizing himself up against the obstacles and challenges he faced during the issue. When times are tough, and he doubts himself and gets his but kicked by Raph, he's smaller than his opponent. When he's doing well, he's larger. It's like the art reflected his confidence, which was a nice touch of storytelling in my opinion.

I'm not sure why people are complaining about Kevin pencilling the issues, he does all of the layouts anyway for all of the issues he doesn't pencil, so his storytelling style has been imprinted into the IDW Turtleverse since its inception. How is him pencilling the occasional issue any different than any other guest artist pencilling over his layouts? His pencilled style is quite a bit different than it was during the Mirage days, and he very rarely (if ever?) completely laid out, pencilled, and inked an entire Turtles issue on his own, without either collaborating with Laird, Lawson, or Talbot, so I'm not sure why an issue he does all by himself would feel too "Mirage-ish" when there is no precedent for it during the Mirage era? If his current style was the same as his style during the Mirage days, and had he done long runs on the Turtles of entirely pencilling and inking the series by himself, then that what be a valid complaint. But that didn't happen.

Eastman does a cover for every issue anyway, making his current take on the Turtles the most consistent look of them over any other artist at this point. No other artist has done 37+ covers on the series. I think his style and take on the IDW turtles is just as valid (if not more so) as the definitive IDW look over any other artist that has drawn the Turtles on the series at this point.

Technogeek29
07-21-2014, 09:07 AM
I don't mind Kuhn's art style in fact I like it. Favorite being Dan Duncan I love the washed out graffiti style of his. if I had to pick a least favorite issue it would be 7 only because it didn't progress the narrative much. unlike the other early issues which both progress the story and had loads of dialogue.

Kara is the only one I see making an appearance later on down the line. But most likely not until the story shifts focus to Mikey. If I remember correctly Donnie was about to become the focus correct? Hep me out Waltz.:D

Sophie Campbell
07-21-2014, 04:49 PM
I'm not sure why people are complaining about Kevin pencilling the issues, he does all of the layouts anyway for all of the issues he doesn't pencil, so his storytelling style has been imprinted into the IDW Turtleverse since its inception. How is him pencilling the occasional issue any different than any other guest artist pencilling over his layouts? His pencilled style is quite a bit different than it was during the Mirage days, and he very rarely (if ever?) completely laid out, pencilled, and inked an entire Turtles issue on his own, without either collaborating with Laird, Lawson, or Talbot, so I'm not sure why an issue he does all by himself would feel too "Mirage-ish" when there is no precedent for it during the Mirage era? If his current style was the same as his style during the Mirage days, and had he done long runs on the Turtles of entirely pencilling and inking the series by himself, then that what be a valid complaint. But that didn't happen.

other than the early IDW issues, Kevin doesn't do all the layouts for every issue. i think he's done a couple here and there since then but as far as i know that's been it. at least, he's never done layouts for any of the Turtles issues i've drawn. ;) maybe Bobby or Tom will stop by and give more info.

anyway i totally agree with you, Kevin's IDW stuff, while having similarities obviously, doesn't feel like Mirage to me. they share aspects but his style is different enough now than it was then, plus him working alone or with new people like Tom and Bobby, makes it have a different tone to it. it's its own thing.

Metropoliskid41
07-21-2014, 05:09 PM
My mistake. Did he only do Layouts while Dan Duncan was pencilling then? Or when did he stop? I thought he was still advising layouts on the Ongoing, maybe that stopped so he had time to work on his solo issues like the Annuals and #21?

Bobby Curnow
07-21-2014, 06:06 PM
Kevin only did layouts for the first four issues. Everyone, Kevin especially, agreed it's better for the artists to just be able to do their own thing, especially to stay on schedule. I know Dan had a great time working with him on those first four issues, though.

neatoman
09-26-2014, 07:42 AM
Hmmm, well... If you're reading this, I'm sorry Kevin, but the annuals you did were pretty terrible. I mean I have a lot respect for you and all, but a lot of your solo work (or at least what you do the bulk of the work on) tends to be a bit of a cluster****. I've read both those annuals twice as well as that Untouchables parody from the old days, and I'm always confused as to what is going in them.

Chabrendeki
10-27-2014, 12:01 PM
I really don't get it, why so many of you hated #21. I just read it for the first time, an I love it! My favourite issue from the IDW-comic so far.

I don't really like Dan Duncan's art, but the stories of the first issues were great, so I liked them too, if I had to choose an issue I didn't like so much, I would choose the Raphael micro.

The Gunslinger
10-28-2014, 11:03 PM
To this day, I have not made it through the first IDW TMNT annual. I gave up reading it because of how boring it was. Didn't help that I couldn't make out what was going on.
On a separate note, I have enjoyed every IDW TMNT artist so far with the exception of Andy Kuhn.

liugeaux
10-30-2014, 12:02 PM
I see that the first annual is what everyone is calling out, and I'm gonna be no different. In fact, the annuals are the only issues I have any real problems with. The second one is only marginally better than the first one. I've loved all of the micros and the minis have been solid (outside of the Utrom empire covers being kinda misleading).

ctt4lfecw
05-07-2015, 10:21 AM
Kevin's first Annual is sick. And I don't know what everyone is talking about, I perfectly understand what's going on. I always enjoy going back to it. I will admit the 2014 Annual could've been better story wise, and also in that one it's hard to tell which Turtle is talking at times because they're holding different weapons. So that one I'll say is the worst, 2014 Annual.

Panda_Kahn_fan
05-07-2015, 10:52 AM
I think the dislike for#21 is helped by the fact that we already saw the story it was telling in an online web comic that Nick made right before the 2012 series started. My least favorite comic is annual #1 because it has a lot of pointless characters and I can't tell what going on. Annual #2 with Renet is awesome though.

shuriken
05-07-2015, 11:15 AM
^^ Yes Annual #1 was a bit of a mess with characters that we never got to see again. And if we did they tended to either die or just get beaten up.

ProphetofGanja
05-07-2015, 12:23 PM
I liked the 2012 Annual a lot, it had to grow on me though. Since it is in black & white it can be hard to decipher some details but all in all its good. The two Scottish boxer characters will probably never be vital to the plot but they're enjoyable enough, I liked seeing Santolouco draw them too.

The 2014 Annual though, I just don't get it. The dialogue is bizarre and the story as a while feels so out of place in the IDW Turtleverse. And Balthazar is just a joke, I can't take any part of the issue seriously. I appreciate humor in this series but this issue was just whack

Joey Kamikaze
05-07-2015, 02:08 PM
The dialogue in Annual #2 is terrible. How many times do you have to explain the same cliche plot points in as many words as possible? What's more, it's a bland story that's been done to death and isn't being done particularly well in this case. So add it to my list too.

I would really love to see someone else do the annuals from now on.

mrjafunk
05-07-2015, 06:09 PM
The entire Northampton story arc was lame and cringe worthy.

mrjafunk
05-07-2015, 06:12 PM
Oh, yeah and everything from Ross Campbell art wise is just plane bad. It felt like I was reading a Muppets version of the TMNT.

Powder
05-07-2015, 07:16 PM
There's nothing bad about their art, quite the opposite. You just don't like it, which is fine, of course. It's just important to make the distinction, I think.

Cipher
05-07-2015, 07:32 PM
Praise be to Kevin, but it's #21 by a country mile.

Danetello
05-10-2015, 08:53 AM
Due to personal circumstances, I had to put on hold reading the comics for the longest time, but was able to keep up with the TV show pretty well.
Now that my life is back to normal, I recently started reading all the comics again, and I literally just yesterday got to the first annual (I've been reading in the suggested timeline order), and I have to say it was the worst thing I've read so far, by a mile. I really hated the art and the heavy blacks. The story was uninteresting and I had a real hard time get into it and following what was happening.
My next least favourite one would be the Mikey issue, but even that is a million times better than the annual!