PDA

View Full Version : The MANY mutations of the NINJA TURTLES...from '83 - 2014


graphic_content
08-01-2014, 02:51 PM
https://i.chzbgr.com/maxW500/8272945408/h86F41E35/

trikuza
08-01-2014, 02:54 PM
cool. i wonder what else we'll see by the year 2035

Leo656
08-01-2014, 03:03 PM
At the rate they're going? Full-body mech armor.

IndigoErth
08-01-2014, 03:11 PM
Really is pretty amazing how far they've come in 30 years. The fact that they were simply a joke in the beginning and became so much more, makes me rather proud of them.

And prob even more-so that they were born into my generation of fans-to-be; I guess it kind of fits the Gen X theme, being disregarded from the get-go and proving your worth.


At the rate they're going? Full-body mech armor.
Don't they dare hide those muscles.... *innocent look*

trikuza
08-01-2014, 03:16 PM
Really is pretty amazing how far they've come in 30 years. The fact that they were simply a joke in the beginning and became so much more, makes me rather proud of them.

And prob even more-so that they were born into my generation of fans-to-be; I guess it kind of fits the Gen X theme, being disregarded from the get-go and proving your worth.



Don't they dare hide those muscles.... *innocent look*

:teek: oh boy..

IndigoErth
08-01-2014, 03:21 PM
Whaaaat.... :goof:

Lou 500
08-01-2014, 03:45 PM
https://31.media.tumblr.com/831dc2e2dd8bf8622a44b4cf65cec3bb/tumblr_n9n83yGUZ71td0w8do1_500.gif

Dammit Indigo just stop.

Yeah, I can't wait to see what other forms they take in the future either. One day I hope to see them look similar to this:

http://th01.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/i/2014/135/7/3/tmnt_fanart_by_kian02-d7ih78s.jpg

They look like humaoid turtles AND they're not creepy. That's not to say I'm creeped out by the new movie designs, I've grown to like them in fact. But if they looked like this I would be so happy.

Slade
08-01-2014, 04:09 PM
Ehh, that is kinda creepy, but kinda cool at the same time.

IndigoErth
08-01-2014, 04:13 PM
https://31.media.tumblr.com/831dc2e2dd8bf8622a44b4cf65cec3bb/tumblr_n9n83yGUZ71td0w8do1_500.gif

Dammit Indigo just stop.
Use Leo gif against me, hmph.:P


That design would be interesting. Gah, I'm in such a gray area though... I don't want them to be too human, nor too animal... I suppose that's a hard spot to hit.

A_Little_Too_Raph.9859
08-01-2014, 05:17 PM
https://31.media.tumblr.com/831dc2e2dd8bf8622a44b4cf65cec3bb/tumblr_n9n83yGUZ71td0w8do1_500.gif

Dammit Indigo just stop.

Yeah, I can't wait to see what other forms they take in the future either. One day I hope to see them look similar to this:

http://th01.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/i/2014/135/7/3/tmnt_fanart_by_kian02-d7ih78s.jpg

They look like humaoid turtles AND they're not creepy. That's not to say I'm creeped out by the new movie designs, I've grown to like them in fact. But if they looked like this I would be so happy.

Did you seriously say that is NOT creepy?? That's SUPER creepy...

Commenter 42
08-01-2014, 10:21 PM
https://31.media.tumblr.com/831dc2e2dd8bf8622a44b4cf65cec3bb/tumblr_n9n83yGUZ71td0w8do1_500.gif

Dammit Indigo just stop.


Agreed. The bestiality overtones are way creepy. It was funny at first, but now...

Yeah, I can't wait to see what other forms they take in the future either. One day I hope to see them look similar to this:

http://th01.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/i/2014/135/7/3/tmnt_fanart_by_kian02-d7ih78s.jpg


Still too human looking, and Mike looks like a Pig.

Bry
08-01-2014, 10:26 PM
Cool graphic! Neat to see all the designs in one place. Shows just how off-the-rails things went sometimes, but also highlights which designs just worked.

Commenter 42
08-01-2014, 10:35 PM
Can you provide a link to the source?

Bry
08-01-2014, 10:47 PM
Full-size version is here at HalloweenCostumes.com (http://www.halloweencostumes.com/blog/p-538-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-evolution-infographic.aspx).

There's a video version too:

ANAv0QKtSBE

IndigoErth
08-01-2014, 10:47 PM
Still too human looking, and Mike looks like a Pig.
That actually looks the least human to me other than the first sketch... Personally I'd place it as a transitional design between '83 and '84.


Now the Japan design I will never understand. Supposedly I guess it suited the particular cartoon era there, but still... what the hell.

Full-size version is here at HalloweenCostumes.com (http://www.halloweencostumes.com/blog/p-538-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-evolution-infographic.aspx)
Yay, thank you, bigger version than the one I saved originally.



(Geezus people, fine I take it back, read more into one short joking remark than what there even was to it why don't ya...)

The Shelf
08-01-2014, 11:04 PM
At the rate they're going? Full-body mech armor.

You mean like these? That was done long ago.
http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/63/1.jpg

TigerClaw
08-01-2014, 11:06 PM
You mean like these? That was done long ago.
http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/63/1.jpg
I remember that, Its from a story that took place 100 years in the future, With the Turtles as Adults, Its from the Archies Series comics.

Netkeeper
08-01-2014, 11:16 PM
Agreed. The bestiality overtones are way creepy. It was funny at first, but now...
Human+sentient non-human =/= bestiality.

That said, I'd totally tap a ninja turtle.

Werecat
08-01-2014, 11:39 PM
https://31.media.tumblr.com/831dc2e2dd8bf8622a44b4cf65cec3bb/tumblr_n9n83yGUZ71td0w8do1_500.gif

Dammit Indigo just stop.

Yeah, I can't wait to see what other forms they take in the future either. One day I hope to see them look similar to this:

http://th01.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/i/2014/135/7/3/tmnt_fanart_by_kian02-d7ih78s.jpg

They look like humaoid turtles AND they're not creepy. That's not to say I'm creeped out by the new movie designs, I've grown to like them in fact. But if they looked like this I would be so happy.
The pic kinda looks like a reptilian cat-like humanoid. It looks interesting though. Definitely a good starting point for more creativity.

Leo656
08-02-2014, 12:51 AM
You mean like these? That was done long ago.
http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/63/1.jpg

Yeah, that was just a "variant" look, though. Had a feeling that'd come up eventually, though. Ah, the 90s. :lol:

Commenter 42
08-02-2014, 12:57 AM
Human+sentient non-human =/= bestiality.

That said, I'd totally tap a ninja turtle.

Hey, to each their own and all that, but Indigo has been non stop with the Leo lust.
Not to knock on Indigo, just, we totally get it, you're hot for the dude.

That actually looks the least human to me other than the first sketch... Personally I'd place it as a transitional design between '83 and '84.


Now the Japan design I will never understand. Supposedly I guess it suited the particular cartoon era there, but still... what the hell.


Yay, thank you, bigger version than the one I saved originally.



(Geezus people, fine I take it back, read more into one short joking remark than what there even was to it why don't ya...)

The super turtles were horrible, no question.

I like what the artist is going for in that group pic, I just prefer more turtle influence.

IndigoErth
08-02-2014, 01:35 AM
Hey, to each their own and all that, but Indigo has been non stop with the Leo lust.
Not to knock on Indigo, just, we totally get it, you're hot for the dude.
Lust? Oh come on now, sure, yeah, I've played along a little in those more awkward sorts of threads because it was hilarious and I would think the occasional harmless comment that is only meant in fun is not a big deal, but I'd hardly label myself as one of those kinds of fans.

If people can't deal with relatively minor comments, fine, I'll try to respect it and avoid saying such things. Though I find it a bit insulting that there are plenty of fictional female characters throughout a lot of media that have been ogled and spoken of forever, often in worse ways, often designed with that in mind, but a woman make some remark that's rather innocuous of human-like characters and goodness no that's too weird. You've certainly kept more of a tally on things I've said than I have.



Back to the actual thread topic. I love how the original sketch is the one that ended up being Mikey... Oldest in concept, but portrayed the youngest. lol

Commenter 42
08-02-2014, 02:08 AM
Lust? Oh come on now, sure, yeah, I've played along a little in those more awkward sorts of threads because it was hilarious and I would think the occasional harmless comment that is only meant in fun is not a big deal, but I'd hardly label myself as one of those kinds of fans.

If people can't deal with relatively minor comments, fine, I'll try to respect it and avoid saying such things. Though I find it a bit insulting that there are plenty of fictional female characters throughout a lot of media that have been ogled and spoken of forever, often in worse ways, often designed with that in mind, but a woman make some remark that's rather innocuous of human-like characters and goodness no that's too weird. You've certainly kept more of a tally on things I've said than I have.

Back to the actual thread topic. I love how the original sketch is the one that ended up being Mikey... Oldest in concept, but portrayed the youngest. lol

I wasn't keeping tabs on your remarks, but I think you might have been the only one that I've read to be making those sorts of comments, so they stuck out a little. Maybe I was starting to wonder if you were one of those fans...maybe.

Hey, as I said, I really don't care, and was actually just teasing you a little. Ogle all you want girlfriend, it's a free internet, (well for the moment anyway) We can be civil, yes?

IndigoErth
08-02-2014, 02:13 AM
We can be civil, yes?
Yes of course. Not much of one for debating or fighting.

Commenter 42
08-02-2014, 04:42 AM
I'm still hopefully that one day we'll see truly realistic ninja turtles.
It's times like these I wish I could draw, just to show you what I mean.
I don't think I've seen anyone get it right, or at least, right in my eyes.
Cartoons and comics are great, but translated to the real world is a tall order.

Candy Kappa
08-02-2014, 04:55 AM
I'm still hopefully that one day we'll see truly realistic ninja turtles.
It's times like these I wish I could draw, just to show you what I mean.
I don't think I've seen anyone get it right, or at least, right in my eyes.
Cartoons and comics are great, but translated to the real world is a tall order.

Personally, I think OotS did a outstanding job on taking the cartoony designs of the Nick comic and add elements of semi-realism, to the point I think the design would work very well in a live-action setting.

But, this guy's work is pretty solid as well.

http://www.deviantart.com/art/Raphael-Progress-V1-456198148

Jester
08-02-2014, 05:06 AM
Personally, I think OotS did a outstanding job on taking the cartoony designs of the Nick comic and add elements of semi-realism, to the point I think the design would work very well in a live-action setting.

But, this guy's work is pretty solid as well.

http://www.deviantart.com/art/Raphael-Progress-V1-456198148
Indeed. Here's all 4:
http://th00.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/f/2014/150/0/2/ninjaturtle__v1_theboys_by_onetruth-d7if9tf.jpg

RaphaelinSTL
08-02-2014, 08:33 AM
Wow, of anything the most terrifying is the musical look!

Netkeeper
08-02-2014, 11:16 AM
Though I find it a bit insulting that there are plenty of fictional female characters throughout a lot of media that have been ogled and spoken of forever, often in worse ways, often designed with that in mind, but a woman make some remark that's rather innocuous of human-like characters and goodness no that's too weird.
This is why you SHOULD be taking a stand and saying it anyway. There are many straight male fans of this franchise that give a continuity's take on April merit based on how hot they think she is, and that's it. I've literally heard fanboys scream in anger at particular Aprils because she "wasn't hot any more".

Somehow I've managed to avoid getting ragged on [even though I've stated that I am attracted to Triceratons ffs] and I'm not even straight. So if anybody wants to give anybody **** for their fictional-lust, ****ing make it me, don't attack the women for showing their attractions. Women are allowed to be attracted to things and they're allowed to celebrate their sexuality.

I got yer back, Indigo. If they wanna rag on you, they can go through me first, because even if it was joking, I don't like it one lil bit. :V

Chuquison
08-02-2014, 11:27 AM
manga series? wow never knew I wonder if they are on dvd to check out

miru
08-02-2014, 11:30 AM
They left out the Soul's Winter turtles.

jestermon
08-02-2014, 01:22 PM
https://31.media.tumblr.com/831dc2e2dd8bf8622a44b4cf65cec3bb/tumblr_n9n83yGUZ71td0w8do1_500.gif

Dammit Indigo just stop.

Yeah, I can't wait to see what other forms they take in the future either. One day I hope to see them look similar to this:

http://th01.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/i/2014/135/7/3/tmnt_fanart_by_kian02-d7ih78s.jpg

They look like humaoid turtles AND they're not creepy. That's not to say I'm creeped out by the new movie designs, I've grown to like them in fact. But if they looked like this I would be so happy.

Those look super creepy to me, looking at the images and knowing about turtles since I have seen them they basically look the same through the whole history.

Commenter 42
08-02-2014, 02:45 PM
Personally, I think OotS did a outstanding job on taking the cartoony designs of the Nick comic and add elements of semi-realism, to the point I think the design would work very well in a live-action setting.

I agree that it was semi-realistic, but wasn't really on board with that design.
I do agree that those were way better than the 2014 movie.


But, this guy's work is pretty solid as well.
http://fc09.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2014/144/2/d/raphael_progress_v1_by_onetruth-d7jlwqs.jpg

Hard to tell. Looks unfinished. I like the idea though.

Indeed. Here's all 4:
http://th00.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/f/2014/150/0/2/ninjaturtle__v1_theboys_by_onetruth-d7if9tf.jpg

Well now, these are closer to what I meant, but I'm not sure I dig the different species of turtle.

But yes, This is closer to how I'd like to see them, though not as a comic book/cartoon drawing.

I really like that Leo. I think he looks the best.

Thanks for posting this!

TurtleTitan97
08-02-2014, 02:47 PM
Personally, I think OotS did a outstanding job on taking the cartoony designs of the Nick comic and add elements of semi-realism, to the point I think the design would work very well in a live-action setting.


^ This.

If the 2014 Turtles looked more like the OOTS Turtles, I'd be at least a bit more open to the movie.

Commenter 42
08-02-2014, 03:06 PM
Honestly, As much as I hate the new designs, the "out of their shells" rock tour/musical, is by far, the most terrifying, followed by Next Mutation - at least in this artists renderings. You can feel his hate for specific eras, and adding in venus is a nice "FU" touch.

I agree though... I think it could have included each of the official comic artists interpretations - would have shown the true the breadth of design over the years.

IndigoErth
08-02-2014, 03:37 PM
It's times like these I wish I could draw, just to show you what I mean.
Very much understand the feeling. This and other things I'm a fan of, I envy the artists a little behind some of the stuff I see on deviantART. I'm creative and all that, but drawing/illustration was not a skill I was blessed with... I can see it in my head but it just won't come out on paper, gahh!

Someday a mind reading app will solve this. :D


I got yer back, Indigo.
;) Sis/brofist

Commenter 42
08-02-2014, 04:10 PM
:lol:

If/when that day comes, it will be epic.

TMNT is cooler than MOTU
08-02-2014, 05:01 PM
https://31.media.tumblr.com/831dc2e2dd8bf8622a44b4cf65cec3bb/tumblr_n9n83yGUZ71td0w8do1_500.gif

Dammit Indigo just stop.

Yeah, I can't wait to see what other forms they take in the future either. One day I hope to see them look similar to this:

http://th01.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/i/2014/135/7/3/tmnt_fanart_by_kian02-d7ih78s.jpg

They look like humaoid turtles AND they're not creepy. That's not to say I'm creeped out by the new movie designs, I've grown to like them in fact. But if they looked like this I would be so happy.

Nifty! Has that artist done any other TMNT-related work?

Chuquison
08-03-2014, 08:18 AM
They left out the Soul's Winter turtles.

please explain

thebrownranger
08-03-2014, 12:01 PM
Personally, I think OotS did a outstanding job on taking the cartoony designs of the Nick comic and add elements of semi-realism, to the point I think the design would work very well in a live-action setting.

But, this guy's work is pretty solid as well.

http://www.deviantart.com/art/Raphael-Progress-V1-456198148
I'm not very fond of the Nick designs in general, but overall I personally feel that the Out Of The Shadows turtles were executed quite well. And yeah man, I too think they could work very well in a live-action setting given that their appearance be upgraded even further with more realism/turtle traits.

Indeed. Here's all 4:
http://th00.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/f/2014/150/0/2/ninjaturtle__v1_theboys_by_onetruth-d7if9tf.jpg

I like this one a lot. I like how it takes on the reptilian characteristics a turtle actually has. It would have been cool to see the artist depict them with bandanas as well, but I can't really complain, I'm really liking these designs.

I've always been fond of seeing TMNT with:
- tails
- longer claws/nails
- more than three fingers/two toes
- horizontally angled heads that turtles have
- beaks/nostrils
- different species skin colors/patterns
- different shell shapes/patterns etc.

snake
08-03-2014, 12:03 PM
No IDW or Archie look?

It's still a cool picture, I'd love to get it framed on my wall.

teslagirl
08-03-2014, 01:14 PM
This is why you SHOULD be taking a stand and saying it anyway. There are many straight male fans of this franchise that give a continuity's take on April merit based on how hot they think she is, and that's it. I've literally heard fanboys scream in anger at particular Aprils because she "wasn't hot any more".

Somehow I've managed to avoid getting ragged on [even though I've stated that I am attracted to Triceratons ffs] and I'm not even straight. So if anybody wants to give anybody **** for their fictional-lust, ****ing make it me, don't attack the women for showing their attractions. Women are allowed to be attracted to things and they're allowed to celebrate their sexuality.

I got yer back, Indigo. If they wanna rag on you, they can go through me first, because even if it was joking, I don't like it one lil bit. :V

You. I like you.

Netkeeper
08-03-2014, 03:19 PM
You. I like you.
Aw, thanks! :tgrin:

Commenter 42
08-03-2014, 03:28 PM
I like this one a lot. I like how it takes on the reptilian characteristics a turtle actually has. It would have been cool to see the artist depict them with bandanas as well, but I can't really complain, I'm really liking these designs.

I've always been fond of seeing TMNT with:
- tails
- longer claws/nails
- more than three fingers/two toes
- horizontally angled heads that turtles have
- beaks/nostrils
- different species skin colors/patterns
- different shell shapes/patterns etc.

Good to see there's at least one person here that gets that a mutated turtle needs to express the traits of an actual turtle.

Not sure why some people can't understand that. I was never arguing that it's the only way to depict the designs, and variations are interesting to see - but if you're using real actors, why not do real turtles?

LeoRaDoMic
08-03-2014, 04:37 PM
https://31.media.tumblr.com/831dc2e2dd8bf8622a44b4cf65cec3bb/tumblr_n9n83yGUZ71td0w8do1_500.gif

Dammit Indigo just stop.

Yeah, I can't wait to see what other forms they take in the future either. One day I hope to see them look similar to this:

http://th01.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/i/2014/135/7/3/tmnt_fanart_by_kian02-d7ih78s.jpg

They look like humaoid turtles AND they're not creepy. That's not to say I'm creeped out by the new movie designs, I've grown to like them in fact. But if they looked like this I would be so happy.

Wow, these are looking amazing! I love realism (got 4 turtles myself) and I wish that these designs once are gonna be used. Also wish that the storylines are more realistic without all the bombastic things, other dimensions, aliens etc. Why don't they just stay in New York with thugs and Shredder, maybe 2 mutated enemies...

Cryomancer
08-03-2014, 04:43 PM
Now the Japan design I will never understand. Supposedly I guess it suited the particular cartoon era there, but still... what the hell.

The design they show there is what they transform into when they use the mutastones. It's probably actually supposed to look like an American superhero if anything. When not transformed, they look like the first cartoon, in fact you can pretty much consider the OVA episodes to be "expanded universe" OT episodes.

Commenter 42
08-03-2014, 04:57 PM
Very much understand the feeling. This and other things I'm a fan of, I envy the artists a little behind some of the stuff I see on deviantART. I'm creative and all that, but drawing/illustration was not a skill I was blessed with... I can see it in my head but it just won't come out on paper, gahh!

Someday a mind reading app will solve this. :D


I've decided to follow some online tutorials to learn to draw.
I thought this one was particularly helpful:
Drawing tutorial (http://youtu.be/6Kw12eGCtjY?list=UUPyRA_YAVp9Hh2M6GTm8mog)

IndigoErth
08-03-2014, 05:35 PM
:lol::lol: Ok, that is going on Facebook.

Commenter 42
08-03-2014, 05:35 PM
:lol::lol: Ok, that is going on Facebook.

Right? Share it. Help millions.

Netkeeper
08-03-2014, 07:34 PM
As an artist I can tell you with 100% accuracy that this is a good tutorial.

Commenter 42
08-03-2014, 07:38 PM
As an artist I can tell you with 100% accuracy that this is a good tutorial.

It's the amount of detail he puts in the eyes. Really helpful.

Parabellum
08-03-2014, 08:33 PM
Indeed. Here's all 4:
http://th00.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/f/2014/150/0/2/ninjaturtle__v1_theboys_by_onetruth-d7if9tf.jpg

Wow! That is awesome.

Specimen B
08-04-2014, 08:43 PM
Good to see there's at least one person here that gets that a mutated turtle needs to express the traits of an actual turtle.

Not sure why some people can't understand that. I was never arguing that it's the only way to depict the designs, and variations are interesting to see - but if you're using real actors, why not do real turtles?

hmm.
i think all of the incarnations express the traits of actual turtles, but, and this is especially true of the film designs, these creatures need to be capable of human movement and human speech on a believable level. so they have many, but not all turtle traits.

so, i don't think simply making them giant turtles with longer limbs will do.

in order to speak human words, they need a humanoid mouth. in order to move as ninjas move, they need to be capable of the full range of human movement.

i think this is what the film makers had in mind when they gave the turtles reduced, almost vestigial plastrons. on a sci-fi level, i think it's "ideal genetic compromise"- giving the TMNT the best of turtle and human traits.

MsMarvelDuckie
08-04-2014, 09:23 PM
Except for the fact that the turtles in ANY incarnation would never TRULY have the full range of human motion, for one simple reason- the carapace. Actually, the entire shell, but the carapace being the primary reason. Since their spine and ribs are fused to it, and it is rigid and inflexible, they would, for instance be incapable of doing things like stomach curls, bending backward, or any other movement that requires bending or flexing the spinal column and/or ribs in any way. (They could possibly compensate by using hips and shoulders more, but a side-bend? Never gonna' be possible.)

That said, Some versions have tried to make up for this by losing the bridge, which probably means they have actual ribs at least on the sides. But that still leaves a wide range of front-back torso motions they couldn't make.....

Specimen B
08-04-2014, 11:26 PM
Except for the fact that the turtles in ANY incarnation would never TRULY have the full range of human motion, for one simple reason- the carapace. Actually, the entire shell, but the carapace being the primary reason. Since their spine and ribs are fused to it, and it is rigid and inflexible, they would, for instance be incapable of doing things like stomach curls, bending backward, or any other movement that requires bending or flexing the spinal column and/or ribs in any way. (They could possibly compensate by using hips and shoulders more, but a side-bend? Never gonna' be possible.)

That said, Some versions have tried to make up for this by losing the bridge, which probably means they have actual ribs at least on the sides. But that still leaves a wide range of front-back torso motions they couldn't make.....

you're right. if we were to get an anatomy lesson on mutant turtles that could move like humans, yet still retained their shells, i suspect we would see that the fusion point would be much more compact and not encompass the entire spine or all of the ribs. this might also explain or be related to the 2014 movie turtles being stronger and having bulletproof shells. shells with such a small contact area would have to be stronger to prevent being ripped off.

Commenter 42
08-05-2014, 12:09 AM
hmm.
i think all of the incarnations express the traits of actual turtles, but, and this is especially true of the film designs, these creatures need to be capable of human movement and human speech on a believable level. so they have many, but not all turtle traits.

so, i don't think simply making them giant turtles with longer limbs will do.

in order to speak human words, they need a humanoid mouth. in order to move as ninjas move, they need to be capable of the full range of human movement.

i think this is what the film makers had in mind when they gave the turtles reduced, almost vestigial plastrons. on a sci-fi level, i think it's "ideal genetic compromise"- giving the TMNT the best of turtle and human traits.

I don't think I could possibly disagree with you more. It's not about making them giant turtles, it's about retaining the animal's characteristics.

They also do not "move as ninja's move" in the film...the move like pro wrestlers, or football players, which is clearly not the same. (not that a pro wrestler couldn't be stealthy, but you get my point.)

They do not need a humanoid mouth anymore than a parrot needs a humanoid mouth to vocalize.

The 2014 versions are the absolute worst hybridization that could have been formulated, not the best.

I can't speak to what they filmmakers were thinking, but I really don't care either, as the result isn't familiar, or interesting.


this might also explain or be related to the 2014 movie turtles being stronger and having bulletproof shells. shells with such a small contact area would have to be stronger to prevent being ripped off.

You realize "bullet proof shells" is an unnecessary added absurdity right?
And how would the lack of a bridge make them stronger?

Also, please realize, none of this is personal, I just HATE the new designs.
I hate that with all the power they had, of the brilliant talent at ILM, this is where it landed.

Netkeeper
08-05-2014, 12:34 AM
They also do not "move as ninja's move" in the film...the move like pro wrestlers, or football players, which is clearly not the same. (not that a pro wrestler couldn't be stealthy, but you get my point.)
[Shouts into the distance]

HEY, LEO, CAN WRESTLERS BE STEALTHY?

Commenter 42
08-05-2014, 12:41 AM
[Shouts into the distance]

HEY, LEO, CAN WRESTLERS BE STEALTHY?

Hey now... I made a disclaimer!

I knew this would happen.

He's gonna hurt me now you know.

graphic_content
08-05-2014, 01:06 AM
to be fair, professional football players take dance lessons for the purposes of being 'light on their feet'...

...some have even gone to the extreme of learning martial arts to improve their techniques, when engaged with other players (blocking, etc.)

source (http://www.martialartsforfootball.com/team/bourne.php)

so while it may be pretty damn hard for someone so large to hide...(they can always use a billboard with a photograph of an underwear model...kidding)...its possible to have ninja-esque qualities. maybe. i guess.

Commenter 42
08-05-2014, 01:09 AM
to be fair, professional football players take dance lessons for the purposes of being 'light on their feet'...

...some have even gone to the extreme of learning martial arts to improve their techniques, when engaged with other players (blocking, etc.)

source (http://www.martialartsforfootball.com/team/bourne.php)

so while it may be pretty damn hard for someone so large to hide...(they can always use a billboard with a photograph of an underwear model...kidding)...its possible to have ninja-esque qualities. maybe. i guess.

Ugh...you guys.

Yeah, I played ball back in the day, I know.
Y'all just having fun with me today...

Leo656
08-05-2014, 01:15 AM
Sorry I'm late... but yes. :P

Jake "The Snake" Roberts (who incidentally, f*cking hates snakes) initially got his nickname for being very fluid and stealthy with his in-ring movements, often craftily "stalking" his prey before striking quickly and intensely like a viper.

I steal that. I blatantly steal a ton of sh*t. Especially in 3-way or 4-way matches. (creep, creep, creep) SNAP SUPLEX! (creep, creep, creep) DDT! I like to hit big moves and I do not like to run, so "stealthy" works out great. 8)

42: I did know what you meant, but they asked, so... :P

Commenter 42
08-05-2014, 01:23 AM
Sorry I'm late... but yes. :P

Jake "The Snake" Roberts (who incidentally, f*cking hates snakes) initially got his nickname for being very fluid and stealthy with his in-ring movements, often craftily "stalking" his prey before striking quickly and intensely like a viper.

I steal that. I blatantly steal a ton of sh*t. Especially in 3-way or 4-way matches. (creep, creep, creep) SNAP SUPLEX! (creep, creep, creep) DDT! I like to hit big moves and I do not like to run, so "stealthy" works out great. 8)

42: I did know what you meant, but they asked, so... :P

Ya...ulp...I just meant imposing, super strong, ... and good looking, did I mention good looking?

:-?

Okay hit me, just not the face...

graphic_content
08-05-2014, 01:25 AM
Ya...ulp...I just meant imposing, super strong, ... and good looking, did I mention good looking?

:-?

I don't share ANY of your views on this film, but your comments consistently make me laugh. (Meant as a compliment, not a jab)

Leo656
08-05-2014, 01:25 AM
:lol: My teeth are all chipped and crooked... but some say, it gives me "character".

Commenter 42
08-05-2014, 01:31 AM
I don't share ANY of your views on this film, but your comments consistently make me laugh. (Meant as a compliment, not a jab)

Nice dude...I can respect that. I prefer being civil here, no matter which "side" we're on, but some folks be asking for a whoopin', and they know who they are...

I honestly have never said whoopin' out loud before...

:lol: My teeth are all chipped and crooked... but some say, it gives me "character".

And a handsome character at that good sir!
Have I said how remarkable it is that wrestlers are exactly like Ninja's?

graphic_content
08-05-2014, 01:36 AM
Nice dude...I can respect that. I prefer being civil here, no matter which "side" we're on, but some folks be asking for a whoopin', and they know who they are...

I honestly have never said whoopin' out loud before...

:lol: sadly it's fallen into disuse, along with slang like 'dope', but that doesn't stop me from saying it and simultaneously dating myself.

Leo656
08-05-2014, 01:37 AM
I say "Radical" in public every single day and people think I'm a lunatic for it. It never fails.

Netkeeper
08-05-2014, 01:49 AM
Wicked, dude. Nothing beats wicked.

Commenter 42
08-05-2014, 02:13 AM
I say "Radical" in public every single day and people think I'm a lunatic for it. It never fails.

Okay, here's the thing, I was told the other day, that "Rad" is back. The kids are using it all the time.

Had a serious WTF moment.

Leo656
08-05-2014, 02:18 AM
Damn it. Now I gotta stop using it.

Candy Kappa
08-05-2014, 02:30 AM
Personally, I'd find it less questionable if the Turtles had a full shell and still moved flexible, then removing parts of the shell to make it seem like they are flexible.

One of the things I really like with the Nick cartoon designs are their proportions and the way their limbs are designed. With smaller shoulders and bigger forearms and hands, they look very turtle authentic as Sliders do have that sort of proportions in their limbs. And, their torso isn't a human shaped torso, like the male human torso being a triangle shape (wide shoulders, narrow hips) as most heroic characters have, especially in movies. The Nick turtles, and most TMNT incarnations have their torso in the proper shape of their shell.

those two things alone could have greatly improved the PD movie designs from green dudes with a shell on their backs, to humanoid turtles.

Commenter 42
08-05-2014, 02:40 AM
Personally, I'd find it less questionable if the Turtles had a full shell and still moved flexible, then removing parts of the shell to make it seem like they are flexible.

One of the things I really like with the Nick cartoon designs are their proportions and the way their limbs are designed. With smaller shoulders and bigger forearms and hands, they look very turtle authentic as Sliders do have that sort of proportions in their limbs. And, their torso isn't a human shaped torso, like the male human torso being a triangle shape (wide shoulders, narrow hips) as most heroic characters have, especially in movies. The Nick turtles, and most TMNT incarnations have their torso in the proper shape of their shell.

those two things alone could have greatly improved the PD movie designs from green dudes with a shell on their backs, to humanoid turtles.

Preach!

Why don't they understand? Please make them understand! It's the subtle differences, it's basic turtle anatomy...

Feels like I've been describing an alien to a frog who speaks German.
You get it. Someone needs to put you in charge.

Prowler
08-05-2014, 02:43 AM
I've always found the Musical Turtles kinda creepy looking. Those big eyes and those grins ugh

Leo656
08-05-2014, 03:25 AM
Haha, they made that sh*t for like fiiiiiiiiii' dollaz. :lol:

Probably. It was great when I was 7.

DarkFell
08-05-2014, 09:16 AM
I'm reserving judgment till I see the actual movie.

Fave variants of TMNT that I like are as follows;

The late 80's - 90's cartoons.
The 90's TMNT movies (I really enjoyed the first movie).
And -dare I say- The Archie Comics TMNT and Challenges done by Michael Dooney.

Glados
08-05-2014, 09:45 AM
hmm.
i think all of the incarnations express the traits of actual turtles, but, and this is especially true of the film designs, these creatures need to be capable of human movement and human speech on a believable level. so they have many, but not all turtle traits.

so, i don't think simply making them giant turtles with longer limbs will do.

in order to speak human words, they need a humanoid mouth. in order to move as ninjas move, they need to be capable of the full range of human movement.

i think this is what the film makers had in mind when they gave the turtles reduced, almost vestigial plastrons. on a sci-fi level, i think it's "ideal genetic compromise"- giving the TMNT the best of turtle and human traits.

Well put, I agree with a lot of this. Some of the more "realistic turtles with just longer limbs"-designs would just make me lol if they actually were realized in high-end cgi and then where bouncing around on the screen doing martial arts... And they would look out of place talking like humans, a hard beak doesn't allow for that... They would have to be talking like parrots and that just looks weird on screen and very "puppety".

Lou 500
08-05-2014, 10:41 AM
Personally, I'd find it less questionable if the Turtles had a full shell and still moved flexible, then removing parts of the shell to make it seem like they are flexible.

One of the things I really like with the Nick cartoon designs are their proportions and the way their limbs are designed. With smaller shoulders and bigger forearms and hands, they look very turtle authentic as Sliders do have that sort of proportions in their limbs. And, their torso isn't a human shaped torso, like the male human torso being a triangle shape (wide shoulders, narrow hips) as most heroic characters have, especially in movies. The Nick turtles, and most TMNT incarnations have their torso in the proper shape of their shell.

those two things alone could have greatly improved the PD movie designs from green dudes with a shell on their backs, to humanoid turtles.

Their heads are also very slider-shaped as well, most noticably in Raphael.

What I also find interesting is how in the new film, they really drive home that sliders were their original species - in the trailer there's the clip where one skull-bashes his glass box, and in one another April shows Bernadette a photo of a RES when she's tring to explain what she's seen.

It's almost like the writers and director were trying to say "Look how informed we are about the lore! We know what their original species is!"

Commenter 42
08-05-2014, 01:34 PM
Show me the part of Monster Raph, that looks like a RES.
Show me how any of them, look like a RES.

IndigoErth
08-05-2014, 01:56 PM
I dunno, facially speaking in profile I feel like Raph is built a bit more like a bull dog or pug. I'd say, imo, that Leo is at least a bit more obviously snoutier, even if the designs still read a bit too primate to me. (Little more-so in some shots than others.. this one middle road.)


http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y13/Taurus01979/TempOther/0256e551-b094-43c0-b92e-5f851a3d590b_zps57b7f736.jpg

Little bit beakier would be a plus to me. Though we all clearly vary rather widely in design preferences. :)


It's almost like the writers and director were trying to say "Look how informed we are about the lore! We know what their original species is!"
LOL

Glados
08-05-2014, 02:24 PM
I dunno, facially speaking in profile I feel like Raph is built a bit more like a bull dog or pug. I'd say, imo, that Leo is at least a bit more obviously snoutier, even if the designs still read a bit too primate to me. (Little more-so in some shots than others.. this one middle road.)


http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y13/Taurus01979/TempOther/0256e551-b094-43c0-b92e-5f851a3d590b_zps57b7f736.jpg

Little bit beakier would be a plus to me. Though we all clearly vary rather widely in design preferences. :)



LOL

Raph is a little bulldog'ish in profile... which makes him kind of ugly-cute. But I really like Leo's profile, that's a nice blend of turtle and humanistic features for me! (I'm NOT in to "super realistic turtles" that just look like regular turtles standing on two legs, personally!)

Candy Kappa
08-05-2014, 02:38 PM
Personally, when it comes to the head in general. I think it's better to stay classic Ninja Turtle, then actual Turtle. First of, the head need more humanoid structure just to have the bandanna properly on, and a turtle, at least sliders have eyes set more to the sides like a animal of prey, rather the set forward like predators and humans. When a Slider looks right at you, they do it with one eye looking at you from the side. The actually can't see straight in-front of them.

That said, adding reptile features is fine. I'm falling back to the OotS and the way they handled their faces. It had the structure of the standard Ninja Turtle, but adding "new" elements, such as wider placement of the eyes, making it look more animalistic.

The PD Turtles heads do look much better then earlier pictures and the concept/promotional art.

IndigoErth
08-05-2014, 02:54 PM
Personally, when it comes to the head in general. I think it's better to stay classic Ninja Turtle, then actual Turtle. First of, the head need more humanoid structure just to have the bandanna properly on, and a turtle, at least sliders have eyes set more to the sides like a animal of prey, rather the set forward like predators and humans. When a Slider looks right at you, they do it with one eye looking at you from the side. The actually can't see straight in-front of them.
Definitely a good point and no doubt would be a determinant to the ninja skills. Gaining human depth perception would certainly be a plus in that regard.

Candy Kappa
08-05-2014, 03:05 PM
Yeah. turtles do have a good range of their sight, iirc they can't see directly in-front of them and directly behind them, so it's a 300 degree sight. But, a front set eyes with depth perception is probably a better trade-up, especially when it comes to aiming. I know my turtles can't aim for their life when I hand feed them. :lol:

Specimen B
08-05-2014, 11:24 PM
I don't think I could possibly disagree with you more. It's not about making them giant turtles, it's about retaining the animal's characteristics.

but where should that line be drawn? turtles don't have muscular humanoid arms, teeth, humanoid eyes, 3 digits on each limb, or any of the other features displayed throughout every version of the turtles.

i guess it's a personal taste thing.

They also do not "move as ninja's move" in the film...the move like pro wrestlers, or football players, which is clearly not the same. (not that a pro wrestler couldn't be stealthy, but you get my point.)

well, those still require the full range of human movement.

They do not need a humanoid mouth anymore than a parrot needs a humanoid mouth to vocalize.

are you saying that you want them to speak as parrots do? as much of an extreme as some may say the PD turtles represent, the turtles vocalizing like parrots with beaks would swing farrrr to the other extreme. personally, i think that would look silly. traditionally, it's always been portrayed that they speak the same way that humans do.

The 2014 versions are the absolute worst hybridization that could have been formulated, not the best.

i don't think i said they were the best? on the other hand i absolutely disagree that they are the worst.

I can't speak to what they filmmakers were thinking, but I really don't care either, as the result isn't familiar, or interesting.

to this i can only say that i'm sorry you aren't getting what you want. i myself am certainly curious, as i find the designs seem to make attempts at conceptual coherence (mutant turtles that need to move and speak as humans do)

You realize "bullet proof shells" is an unnecessary added absurdity right?
And how would the lack of a bridge make them stronger?

you realize that when you say "you realize", it comes off as really condescending right? so for the sake of civil discussion, maybe we cut back on that.

i think there's a bit of spider-man influence here- the proportionate strength of a turtle in this case. i'm not saying the lack of a bridge makes them stronger...i'm saying that if their shells have a smaller area of fusion (allowing for full human movement) then their greater physical integrity keeps their shells secure to their bodies.

Also, please realize, none of this is personal, I just HATE the new designs.
I hate that with all the power they had, of the brilliant talent at ILM, this is where it landed.

that's cool. i have my issues as well (the outfits). but i get the feeling a lot of designs were looked at and even tried at the animation stage, and that they didn't work. i suppose we'll find out eventually.

but i do think there was some thought put into the designs, and that it wasn't all about aesthetics.

Candy Kappa
08-06-2014, 01:42 AM
With the PD Turtles so big and tall, a head canon I can't shake off is that the PD Turtles actually are female Red-Eared Sliders.

Commenter 42
08-06-2014, 03:36 AM
you realize that when you say "you realize", it comes off as really condescending right? so for the sake of civil discussion, maybe we cut back on that.


Maybe I sound condescending because you were rationalizing why they added bullet proof shells. I just don't think there is any justification for that. It's a deux ex machina so that the foot could be a militia, instead of ninja, and carry guns.it lets bay shoe horn in military into yet another property, and it diminishes the entire idea of "ninja". If they had also been 4'6"-5 feet tall,instead of 7 foot monsters, they wouldn't be such easy targets, negating the need to be bullet proof.


But i get the feeling a lot of designs were looked at and even tried at the animation stage, and that they didn't work. i suppose we'll find out eventually.

but i do think there was some thought put into the designs, and that it wasn't all about aesthetics.

I'm not saying they need beaks, I'm just saying they took the humanity too far. Outside of this forum, few people say, "hey those designs look great!" Every review so far begins with, "While you may not like the turtles new faces" or something to that effect.

I'm not the only one to have gripes, but I'll concede, I'm one of the few who think the that turtle anatomy is important. I may also be the only one that thinks a turtles face is far more pleasing than the Skrek/Ed O'neil faces. Sure, they're mutants, but there was no need to accentuate the ugliness to such a degree.

To me, nature is always right when it comes to design, and when you stray to far from it, you end up with something artificial.

And that part where they say in interviews, they tried different things, and it just "didn't work"? I'll believe that when i see it.

If I come off hostile, again, It's nothing personal, Your responses are even keel, and thorough. You seem like a nice person, so kudos'.

Leolead
08-06-2014, 09:16 AM
https://31.media.tumblr.com/831dc2e2dd8bf8622a44b4cf65cec3bb/tumblr_n9n83yGUZ71td0w8do1_500.gif

Dammit Indigo just stop.

Yeah, I can't wait to see what other forms they take in the future either. One day I hope to see them look similar to this:

http://th01.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/i/2014/135/7/3/tmnt_fanart_by_kian02-d7ih78s.jpg

They look like humaoid turtles AND they're not creepy. That's not to say I'm creeped out by the new movie designs, I've grown to like them in fact. But if they looked like this I would be so happy.

I hope we get that for the next reboot!

Commenter 42
08-06-2014, 03:53 PM
I hope we get that for the next reboot!

I just hope we get a reboot. :D

IndigoErth
08-06-2014, 04:21 PM
I just hope... Oh I dunno what I even hope anymore. lol

As many movies of these guys as people want to make, in various versions, as long as they do them proper justice. (And no more screwy crap, secrets and/or miscommunication - i.e. aliens, Shredder, etc.)

Not personally into that kind of design, and have had to get used to this newest one, but if people would keep putting stuff out now and then rather than a decades long gap I can deal with one sometimes being someone else's version.

Commenter 42
08-06-2014, 05:08 PM
I think they should have been more transparent from the start.

If you know the fan base is rabid, and you want to maximize your dollar, being secretive works against you. There was no reason to be so hush hush over the course of preproduction, and they could have saved themselves a lot of money if they released the designs very early on.

They just don't understand the Fandom, and try to keep them in the dark, thinking they "know better" or "people don't know what they want until they see it". Typical hollywood arrogance.

Can't wait for it to backfire.

Warhorse
08-06-2014, 05:14 PM
I think they should have been more transparent from the start.

If you know the fan base is rabid, and you want to maximize your dollar, being secretive works against you. There was no reason to be so hush hush over the course of preproduction, and they could have saved themselves a lot of money if they released the designs very early on.

They just don't understand the Fandom, and try to keep them in the dark, thinking they "know better" or "people don't know what they want until they see it". Typical hollywood arrogance.

Can't wait for it to backfire.

I don't think it has anything to do with them understanding or not understanding the fandom, they just don't care about the fandom at all. They were probably like, hey, we got one of the creators on board as a consultant, so hey, that is about as much fan service as we are going to give. Everything else is what we believe will get us maximum dollars at the box office. Only thing they forgot was, unlike Transformers, which didn't have a hot running cartoon or previous live action movies to be referred to, TMNT does. I guess we'll find out not this weekend, but the next weekend, if their idea worked. If not, then maybe they should look to see what it was that kept the TMNT chugging along for 30 years. I'm pretty sure alot of it had to do with us, the fans.:)

IndigoErth
08-06-2014, 05:54 PM
Agree with you both. Hollywood, suppose it comes down to it just sniffing out something that might be a summer cash cow. That's prob been one of my biggest anxieties (so to speak) over it, not wanting to see them used and abused for profit.

Transformers... sure, I had a couple toys as a kid, they're still around somewhere. But they aren't the ones who slept in the little bunk bed I made out of popsicle sticks and scrap fabric when I was young, that was my Turtles figures. They unlike other stuff probably never spent a moment thrown into my toy box. (A very nice toy box, but that was a place for toys that had their off time, TMNT was too beloved and cared for to ever spend any time there.)

Commenter 42
08-06-2014, 06:21 PM
I don't think it has anything to do with them understanding or not understanding the fandom, they just don't care about the fandom at all. They were probably like, hey, we got one of the creators on board as a consultant, so hey, that is about as much fan service as we are going to give. Everything else is what we believe will get us maximum dollars at the box office. Only thing they forgot was, unlike Transformers, which didn't have a hot running cartoon or previous live action movies to be referred to, TMNT does. I guess we'll find out not this weekend, but the next weekend, if their idea worked. If not, then maybe they should look to see what it was that kept the TMNT chugging along for 30 years. I'm pretty sure alot of it had to do with us, the fans.:)
http://media.giphy.com/media/H6CW8SL6vgVb2/giphy.gif
http://media.giphy.com/media/16lbjcxmPkY00/giphy.gif