PDA

View Full Version : What are some real standout individual TMNT comics (from any series)?


ScOULaris
08-05-2014, 12:48 PM
A few months ago I devoured all of the Ultimate Collection books, which featured a selection of Volume 1 Mirage issues with which Eastman and Laird were directly involved. As many of you would probably agree, the contents of those collections amounted to somewhat of a mixed bag. Some of the oddball side-stories fell flat for me, but I loved the initial issues with the origin story and the Triceratons as well as the fantastic Leonardo one-off, the Raphael micro-series issue with Casey Jones' introduction, Return to NY, and finally City at War. Shades of Gray was pretty great as well.

That being said, I've now begun my search for other high-quality individual issues of TMNT comics across all of the various series. I'm open to suggestions from Tales of TMNT, the other volumes of the Mirage run, the Archie comics, and even the non-canon Image series. I'm just in a TMNT mood lately, so I want to read some of the best stuff out there. I looked through the excellent timeline on the TMNT Entity blog (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/), but there are so many comics out there that I figured I'd come to the community for recommendations.

http://i.imgur.com/q9FEwst.png
A snippet from one of my favorite TMNT comic scenes.

AquaParade
08-05-2014, 12:52 PM
One of my favorite stories is "The River" by Rick Veitch. You'll have to track down single issues but it's worth it. A unique take on the tutrtles if you ask me.

CyberCubed
08-05-2014, 02:00 PM
The stories in Classics V. 7. The two part Japan story and Leatherhead issue were great.

Bry
08-05-2014, 02:57 PM
Not sure if it's covered in the collections, but I've always loved "Halls of Lost Legends" in issue #43, by Paul Jenkins and A.C. Farley. so much so that I've got the turtle shield seen in the issue tattooed on my right shoulder blade. The ending is perfection, and I've always wanted to see it used as a "series finale" in a cartoon or a movie.

The Mirage Licensing site has a write-up/summary of the issue here (http://www.miragelicensing.com/comics/mirage/volume01/43/43.html).

RatKingLeo
08-05-2014, 03:52 PM
I, Monster from tales of the tmnt vol. 1

Red Mask
08-05-2014, 04:08 PM
I really like "Twilight of the Ring." (Mirage Vol 1. #37)

Red Robin
08-05-2014, 04:25 PM
Here are some of the stories I enjoyed besides the ones you already mentioned:

Michael Zulli's Soul's Winter (from Volume 1)
Tales of Leo - Blind Sight
Tales of the TMNT #36, #50, #56, #69, #70

Joey Kamikaze
08-05-2014, 07:32 PM
Issues of TMNTA that stand out in my mind:

#7, #37: The Stump Intergalactic Wrestling issues. I'd love to see Cudley and the gang show up in IDW at some point.

#10-13: The book's first major original story arc (though arguably it really started in #5). Includes the Rat King and Maligna's first appearances and some Jim Lawson pencils in #11.

#38-39 & Mighty Mutanimals #6: "United We Stand, Divided We Fall," the Mutanimals crossover where they fight Null & the Four Horsemen.

#42-44: The Future Shark trilogy, generally considered a major turning point for the series.

Tazi
08-06-2014, 02:37 AM
Those are multiparters, not really single issues.

ScOULaris
08-06-2014, 09:00 AM
Thanks for all the recommendations so far, everyone. I'm gonna start checking some of them out this weekend.

Sophie Campbell
08-06-2014, 11:21 AM
-TMNT vol. 1 #28, Sons of the Silent Age

-the 4 Turtle Soup vol. 2 issues, there are some dull stories in them but they also have a couple really cool AC Farley, Rick McCollum, Michael Zulli and Steve Murphy stuff. not sure if those count because they're anthologies but they're still great. the Farley and Zulli shorts are some of my favorite TMNT stories.

-i'll second TMNT vol. 1 #43, i'm not crazy about the story myself but the AC Farley artwork is stellar. also vol. 1 #29, another Farley one.

-TMNT vol. 1 #37 and #42, cool McCollum/Bill Anderson stuff.

-IDW TMNT #15-16, a two-parter i know but the Andy Kuhn Slash story is one of my favorites.

-IDW TMNT Bebop & Rocksteady micro-series issue! sooo good.

-usually i'm pretty self-deprecating but i have to mention my IDW Alopex micro-series issue, i'm still pretty proud of that one. IDW issue #30, too.

Jay $tarkiller
08-06-2014, 11:48 AM
tales #55..love that story

ScOULaris
08-06-2014, 12:14 PM
tales #55..love that story

Ooh, that one sounds really good. I'm gonna put that on my list.

Sofistocat
08-06-2014, 12:31 PM
It's kind of hard to find, but Tales v.2 #70 is a banger, it's a great gap filler to what you've already read.

Not necessarily comics, but:

Shell Shock TPB
Michael Dooney's Challanges
Plastron Cafe 1 -4

were all good reads...

plastroncafe
08-06-2014, 01:03 PM
Seconding "Sons of the Silent Age."

"True Stories"
"Survivalists" might be my favorite Mirage issue overall.

"The Burning Man" from Tales Vol 2.

CyberCubed
08-06-2014, 01:19 PM
A lot of the Volume 1 guest issues are horrible, but there are some obvious gems which people have mentioned in this thread. Also many of the specials/one-shots are quite dire, and only existed to give people gag comics to write with TMNT characters.

plastroncafe
08-06-2014, 01:33 PM
Stay classy, Cyber.

I also really like the DreamWeave books, they were the tie in to the 2k3 toon.

Cipher
08-07-2014, 03:13 AM
Vol. 1 #28 "Sons of the Silent Age" - One of the best TMNT stories of all time

Vol. 1 #30s something? "Soul's Winter" - A three-issue alternate universe arc; getting an upcoming collection from IDW.

Tales Vol. 1 #4 "I, Monster"

Tales Vol. 2 #5 "Blind Faith"

Tales Vol. 2 #6 "Scars"

Tales Vol. 2 #13-14 "Loops"

Tales Vol. 2 #36 "To Serve and Protect"

Tales Vol. 2 #55 "Day in the Life"

Tales Vol. 2 #67 "Schooled"

Tales Vol. 2 #69 "Dark Shadows"

All of Mirage Vol. 2 is worth a read, especially if you liked the tone of "City at War," though its early issues are better.

Also, the Mirage universe is greatly enhanced by checking out all the future stories. Via the Tales series, they jumped around the timeline a bit and you can piece together endings for the characters. The issues you want to check out if you're interested are:

2007 Tales Treasury Collection - New frontispeices and epilogue (unfortunately long out of print; you may be able to find scans of the pages in question, which form a new narrative about old Donatello)

Tales Vol. 2 #13-14, #40, #41, #45, #55, #69

Plastron Cafe #1 (published in the '90s)

Puma Blues #20 - "Choices," a Raphael story (never collected)

"Survivalists" might be my favorite Mirage issue overall.
"Survivalists" is way good, for sure, and strangely foreshadows the tone of what the series would later become. Though it's included in the Ultimate Collections, so I assume the thread-creator has already read it.

And, while good, I tend to think what it does is done a little better in "Sons of the Silent Age." I think overall Murphy and Lawson scripted most of the series' one-off gems; they had a touch with nuanced characters Eastman and Laird never quite nailed (when Murphy was on his game, anyway.) Though Tristan Jones did great action issues in Tales Vol. 2 with lots of personality.

ScOULaris
08-07-2014, 08:55 AM
All of Mirage Vol. 2 is worth a read, especially if you liked the tone of "City at War," though its early issues are better.


Hm. I read the first couple of issues of Mirage Vol. 2, but at the time I didn't feel like continuing on. Maybe I'll pay that series a visit again. Is Volume 4 worth checking out at all? I know that Splinter dies of old age at some point in there, but is there anything else of interest?

DrSpengler
08-07-2014, 11:08 AM
Is Volume 4 worth checking out at all?

The ideas, character development and story arcs present throughout Volume 4 are all very fascinating and organic. It's more the execution of those storylines that doesn't appeal to everyone. The pacing, dialogue and characterization read VERY differently than every other TMNT comic and it... takes some acclimation.

If you can get past that, though, there's lots of great stuff in there. I'll admit that I don't like all of it (the dialogue especially), but the ideas present are very interesting.

miru
08-07-2014, 11:26 AM
The Michaelangelo mirage one-shot is historically important as it marks the moment the TMNT's personalities had been established for good.

ScOULaris
08-07-2014, 11:57 AM
The ideas, character development and story arcs present throughout Volume 4 are all very fascinating and organic. It's more the execution of those storylines that doesn't appeal to everyone. The pacing, dialogue and characterization read VERY differently than every other TMNT comic and it... takes some acclimation.

If you can get past that, though, there's lots of great stuff in there. I'll admit that I don't like all of it (the dialogue especially), but the ideas present are very interesting.

And Volume 3 is worth skipping over, right? Since the Image run was basically written off as non-canon?

If that's the case, I'll work through Vol. 2 and then jump over to Vol. 4 afterward.

plastroncafe
08-07-2014, 12:07 PM
While Image's Vol3 isn't my favorite, it is kind of fun in a Time Capsule sort of way. I think they're worth checking out for the sheer GRIMDARKness of them.

DrSpengler
08-07-2014, 12:15 PM
And Volume 3 is worth skipping over, right? Since the Image run was basically written off as non-canon?

If that's the case, I'll work through Vol. 2 and then jump over to Vol. 4 afterward.

Well, just because it doesn't "count" doesn't necessarily mean something isn't "good".

The Image series is very much a product of its time, but it has a lot of great ideas going on in it. It starts out rather bumpy, but by the midway point it gears up and things drastically improve. There's a lot of character growth going on, some I like and some I don't, but I found elements superior to Laird's continuation in Volume 4.

It isn't for everyone, and it is VERY 90s, but it has some great stuff going on in the back half that's worth checking out.

liugeaux
08-07-2014, 12:17 PM
Personally I think the strongest stuff is found in the arcs, but I really like the original Raph one shot, the original Leo Blind Sight issue from Tales Vol. 2 and The Death of Splinter in Vol 4.

DrSpengler
08-07-2014, 12:23 PM
I agree with most of the examples offered in this thread (though I really, really don't like "Scars", but I may be in the minority on that one).

To go off the beaten path a little, though, one of the best guest issues was TMNT (Vol. 1) #16 (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2013/02/tmnt-vol-1-16.html) by Mark Martin. The craftsmanship to the narrative, every element of the storytelling is just superb. It's a comic that's fun to read and fun to look at and it uses a number of cartooning and scripting tricks that are just really neat.

But, you know. Don't read either of the sequels. They're really bad.

Unfortunately, it's not... much of a Ninja Turtle story. It's a great comic, but the Turtles are sort of guest cameos in their own book, which I understand is problematic in and of itself.

plastroncafe
08-07-2014, 12:36 PM
While I disagree that the sequels are bad, it's true that the first one is hands down the best.

(I just referenced Dale Evans McGuillicutty else thread. I think this might be the most that particular issue/arc has been talked about in decades.)

Cipher
08-07-2014, 12:37 PM
I agree with most of the examples offered in this thread (though I really, really don't like "Scars", but I may be in the minority on that one).
I think that's your one review where you and I have most parted ways. You seem to be caught up a lot in how it failed to set up its spotlight character in Cha Ocho, but even if he were never seen again I think it's an excellent character issue for Leo. And just a fun action-ish story on face value.

To go off the beaten path a little, though, one of the best guest issues was TMNT (Vol. 1) #16 (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2013/02/tmnt-vol-1-16.html) by Mark Martin. The craftsmanship to the narrative, every element of the storytelling is just superb. It's a comic that's fun to read and fun to look at and it uses a number of cartooning and scripting tricks that are just really neat.
I can second this. It's a good one to visit from the "guest artist" era.

Re: Vol. 2, I don't know how much it will improve for you from the early issues. What I really dig about them is how they continue the somber realism from "City at War," with each of the characters trying to find his/her own way. It kind of meanders toward the end due to having to come to a rushed conclusion. Your mileage may vary.

Image's Vol. 3 is worth checking out, as others mentioned, in a time-capsule way (the '90s tropes are through the roof), though some of its character beats are genuinely good.

Vol. 4 I have mixed feelings on. Just on one level, its major events are incredibly important to the Mirage timeline, so knowing what happens helps immensely when jumping around Tales. And I really like where all its arcs were going. Laird took the approach of an ongoing "We'll see what happens" serial, juggling multiple increasingly strange beats at once. There's almost no action, so keep that in mind, but what it does should keep you hooked. On the other hand, the dialogue is really bad. Like, really verbose. Laird really needs a script editor.

DrSpengler
08-07-2014, 01:00 PM
Re: Vol. 2, I don't know how much it will improve for you from the early issues. What I really dig about them is how they continue the somber realism from "City at War," with each of the characters trying to find his/her own way. It kind of meanders toward the end due to having to come to a rushed conclusion. Your mileage may vary.

Yeah, that's the real sin of Volume 2. It starts out really well. Like, really, REALLY well. There's so much character potential being built up in those first 2 or 3 arcs that you're genuinely left hanging, anxious to see how the characters grow and change and what directions they move in now that the Foot Clan troubles are over.

And then the book got cancelled due to low sales and the last arc is a mad rush to tie everything up before doomsday. It's such a tremendous letdown, such an example of wasted potential that it sours the whole volume and overshadows all the genuinely GREAT things about it.

It's one of those things where you wish you could turn back the clock and give Lawson a second chance to continue the narrative the way he'd intended. But what's done is done and Volume 2 is what it is. If you can look at it from a retrospective POV and see where it was going and the things it was aiming for, it's an enjoyable read, yeah. But the real world shortcomings that forced it to end the way it did really do stick a fork in things.

CyberCubed
08-07-2014, 02:00 PM
Why would anyone willingly skip Image or Volume 4 if you're trying to get into Mirage? It's like skipping entire seasons of a TV show.

Matches Malone
08-07-2014, 02:12 PM
I second most of the recommendations in this thread and would like to add a few:

Tales V.2 #9: Nice character piece for Michelangelo; almost like a sequel to the Michelangelo micro exploring the more tragic side of his sentimental nature.

Tales V.2 #50: Actually among my favorite of Tristan's issues. While the urban street grit of his other issues are great, this is a fun action piece where the turtles have to deal more with being mutant scientific oddities than ninjas. Plus Leatherhead's in it!

Image has some of my favorite turtles art and my favorite storyline in the series is definitely when Mikey rescues Shadow from mobsters. Two-parter: #7 & #8.

ScOULaris
08-07-2014, 03:16 PM
Why would anyone willingly skip Image or Volume 4 if you're trying to get into Mirage? It's like skipping entire seasons of a TV show.

Maybe I'll give them a shot, keeping in mind that they're not "officially" part of the canon. I know some weird stuff goes down in Volume 3, so I'm curious to see how it unfolds.

CyberCubed
08-07-2014, 03:23 PM
Maybe I'll give them a shot, keeping in mind that they're not "officially" part of the canon. I know some weird stuff goes down in Volume 3, so I'm curious to see how it unfolds.

It's all part of canon.

ScOULaris
08-07-2014, 06:59 PM
Update: I read through the first eight issues of Mirage Vol. 2, and I have to say that I kind of like it. It's a shame to know that it's going to end very abruptly only five issues from now. The pacing could use some work and there is some strangeness that the writers felt content to just leave unexplained (like the gigantic snapping turtle in the sewers that attacked Leo), but overall it's interesting watching the Turtles grow older and further apart from one another.

I've also put a bunch of the recommendations in this thread on my to-read queue, so thanks again everyone. Sadly, it doesn't seem like very many (if any) issues of TMNT will ever rival the highlights from Vol. 1 like Return to New York, the Leonardo micro series, and the City at War saga. It's such a shame that SO MUCH of the TMNT comics in existence are too wacky and sci-fi for me to really enjoy. The IDW series is pretty good at finding a balance, though. I've enjoyed that so far.

Cipher
08-07-2014, 10:19 PM
I've also put a bunch of the recommendations in this thread on my to-read queue, so thanks again everyone. Sadly, it doesn't seem like very many (if any) issues of TMNT will ever rival the highlights from Vol. 1 like Return to New York, the Leonardo micro series, and the City at War saga. It's such a shame that SO MUCH of the TMNT comics in existence are too wacky and sci-fi for me to really enjoy. The IDW series is pretty good at finding a balance, though. I've enjoyed that so far.
While I think "City at War" is the best Turtles anything ever published, and don't think much can top it, I do want to say that several of the one-off issues suggested in this thread are very strong, so you don't need to feel as if everything is (that far) downhill from here.

There's also something to be said for just being familiar with all the broad strokes of the series and the narrative that presents. The overarching narrative of the Mirage series (as much as it exists to be put together) is also really rewarding, which is why I always suggest the future issues. Especially if you enjoy the aspect of the Turtles growing older and further apart. For all its weirdness, ninjas and aliens and unexplained giant snapping turtles included, at the heart of Mirage there's a very human story that acknowledges life doesn't always have happy endings.

I guess what I want to say is that the experience will only be enhanced by further reading, rather than dragged down, even if none of the other individual stories quite top what you've read.

ScOULaris
08-10-2014, 02:37 PM
Just wanted to check back in with an update.

Read through most of the Vol. 2 Mirage run, and now I am about 11 issues into Vol. 4. I have to say that I'm actually really enjoying Vol. 4. While I wouldn't put it in the same company as the best of Vol. 1 by any means, I like some of the plot choices that are having huge impacts on the world that the no-longer-teenage Ninja Turtles inhabit. It's a little too sci-fi at times and glacially paced, but I'm still interested enough in seeing how these thirty-something TMNT's soldier on now that they no longer have to hide from humanity. The artwork is something of a mixed bag too. Lawson actually does a great job with the turtles most of the time, but humans look absolutely bonkers and the few fight scenes that are in there are dull and confusing to follow compared to some of Eastman and Laird's best work.

Overall, I'd definitely recommend it to anyone who hasn't given it a shot yet. I wish that Mirage would release some trade paperbacks for these, though. They deserve it, seeing as how they are a continuous story arc.

AquaParade
08-10-2014, 03:51 PM
I have to chime in with love for volume 2.
Cipher and Dr. Speng mainly covered it but it's first nine issues really do hold up to City at War. Baxter in his new body is utterly creepy and everything just takes on such a surreal feeling - definitely due to Jim's pencils.

Cipher
08-10-2014, 04:32 PM
I have to chime in with love for volume 2.
Cipher and Dr. Speng mainly covered it but it's first nine issues really do hold up to City at War. Baxter in his new body is utterly creepy and everything just takes on such a surreal feeling - definitely due to Jim's pencils.
Yeah. "City at War" through the first half of Volume 2 is probably my favorite stretch of Turtles comics ever. I still have to pick up the IDW Volume 2 collections. I wonder how much is lost without the original coloring, as that definitely helped the tone as well.

I think I'm on the same page on Volume 4 as ScOULaris. Glad to hear you're enjoying the new status quo, as that's one of my favorite parts of the book.

Overall, I'd definitely recommend it to anyone who hasn't given it a shot yet. I wish that Mirage would release some trade paperbacks for these, though. They deserve it, seeing as how they are a continuous story arc.
IDW seems committed to getting the entire series out in trade. The expectation is that we'll see Volume 4 at some point, unfinished though it may be.

AquaParade
08-10-2014, 05:04 PM
My hope is that eventually Volume two will be gathered in hardcover.

ScOULaris
08-11-2014, 07:43 AM
I still have to pick up the IDW Volume 2 collections. I wonder how much is lost without the original coloring, as that definitely helped the tone as well.

Wait, what? IDW published a Vol. 2 collection somewhere?

CyberCubed
08-11-2014, 08:26 AM
Wait, what? IDW published a Vol. 2 collection somewhere?

No, the first 5 issues of Volume 2 come out this October as Classics V. 9.

Classics 10 was announced with issues 6-9 of Volume 2, so the whole thing will be done in 3 trades.

ScOULaris
08-11-2014, 10:29 AM
No, the first 5 issues of Volume 2 come out this October as Classics V. 9.

Classics 10 was announced with issues 6-9 of Volume 2, so the whole thing will be done in 3 trades.

Actually, it looks like Vol. 8 had the first five issues and 6-9 is coming in Vol. 9. Hmmm... I might have to pick these up. I actually think the new coloring looks good here, as opposed to some of the recent re-colorings seen in Vol. 1 Mirage stuff. I'll never forgive them for butchering The Shredder's color scheme.

Redeemer
08-11-2014, 11:41 AM
The Michaelangelo mirage one-shot is historically important as it marks the moment the TMNT's personalities had been established for good.

Im sorry what?????? I must have read that incorrectly can you clarify???

My personal favorite stand alone issue(s)
Mirage Leonardo One Shot
IDW 36
Mirage 19(I think??Cant recall the specific number)(Mikey in feudal Japan)

DrSpengler
08-11-2014, 12:40 PM
Im sorry what?????? I must have read that incorrectly can you clarify???

My personal favorite stand alone issue(s)


I think he might have meant that it was the first story to solidify a personality for Michelangelo; who up until that point in the Mirage comics had sort of been a hangeron without any notable qualities or quirks to speak of. The Mikey micro gives him his fun-loving, child-like attitude and big heart which would go on to define the character.

Joey Kamikaze
08-11-2014, 05:14 PM
I think he might have meant that it was the first story to solidify a personality for Michelangelo; who up until that point in the Mirage comics had sort of been a hangeron without any notable qualities or quirks to speak of. The Mikey micro gives him his fun-loving, child-like attitude and big heart which would go on to define the character.
That's how I took it, and I agree, though I'd take it farther. The turtles are largely just cardboard cut-outs in those first few Mirage issues, with their canon personalities just beginning to peak through. When I read those early issues, the TCRI issues and the Michelangelo one-shot strike me as about when not just Mikey but all four turtles (maybe with the exception of Raph, who had his solo issue first) are really settling into their individual personas.

ScOULaris
08-11-2014, 05:31 PM
That's how I took it, and I agree, though I'd take it farther. The turtles are largely just cardboard cut-outs in those first few Mirage issues, with their canon personalities just beginning to peak through. When I read those early issues, the TCRI issues and the Michelangelo one-shot strike me as about when not just Mikey but all four turtles (maybe with the exception of Raph, who had his solo issue first) are really settling into their individual personas.

While I think Leo had his focused, leadership persona already starting to take shape from the very first issues, I think that the Raphael/Casey Jones was the first real deliberate attempt to give individual Turtles more of a distinct personality. The Mikey one-shot was certainly in the same boat. I'd say that all of the character micro-series issues did a good job of fleshing out their personalities with maybe the exception of Donatello's. His was good but didn't delve too deeply into the personality traits that we've come to attach to him.

GreenDemon
08-20-2014, 02:44 PM
My earliest memories of the Mirage continuity revolve around these issues and one graphic novel;

- Vol. 1 #23 ("Totally Hacked"), #28 ("Sons of the Silent Age"), #32 ("Toitle Anxiety"), #41 ("Turtle Dreams"), and Challenges by Michael Dooney.

Matt Howarth's vision of the Turtles getting caught up in their own individual dream worlds was a concept I thought was fun and quirky.

Challenges intrigued me as I hadn't yet read the one-shot micro series' from Vol. 1. I was able to learn about their personalities and personal motivations from this little book.

GreenDemon
08-20-2014, 02:58 PM
Once I started reading it and immersing myself into it, I found the City at War story line was pretty influential to me as well. I had never seen the Turtles and their allies in such a fragile and tension filled atmosphere before. It had the perfect balance of action and emotion.

Casey, April, and the Turtles were all learning to deal with the consequences of their actions by themselves as well as a group even though they were at odds with each other through most of the series.