PDA

View Full Version : Thoughts on reviews for the TMNT 2014 movie


ScrewtheMirageTMNT
08-05-2014, 09:54 PM
Ta-Dah, there. I will start off by saying that I find the complaints about the CGI in the movie to be rubbish.

TeenageMutantNinjaTurtles
08-06-2014, 03:22 AM
Ta-Dah, there. I will start off by saying that I find the complaints about the CGI in the movie to be rubbish.

Haven't watched the movie yet (will be tonight!:tgrin:), but I couldn't agree more. After dissecting every frame I could get my hands on, I continue to smile at all the detail in these characters.

ScrewtheMirageTMNT
08-06-2014, 03:27 AM
Their bandanas are amazing looking.

TeenageMutantNinjaTurtles
08-06-2014, 03:31 AM
Their bandanas are amazing looking.

I was just watching the behind the scenes clip where they are talking about the 3D work in the film. There was a close-up of Mikey, when Splinter is tempting him with pizza, and you can see every bump on Mikey's skin, loose orange thread, and even complete reflections in his eyes!

ScrewtheMirageTMNT
08-06-2014, 03:38 AM
Are you talking about one of the ILM presentation clips?

TeenageMutantNinjaTurtles
08-06-2014, 03:45 AM
Are you talking about one of the ILM presentation clips?

Yes. If nothing else, those clips continue to impress me with the amount of work put into this film.

From a technical standpoint I don't see how this movie is so generic as some critical reviews have stated.

Leo656
08-06-2014, 03:59 AM
You cats have read more than I have. Are they saying the CGI is what's "generic", or that the plot and the overall way the film is shot, technique, lens flares, etc., is what's "generic"? Because that's different.

I only read a couple, and they said pretty clearly that it was the visual style and the story/lack of story that was "generic", not the CGI itself. I think it's pretty clear they put a lot of work into the texturing. I think Splinter looks like crap, though, maybe I've only seen bad shots but he looks really unpolished compared to everything else. He looks like he's from a completely different movie, for some reason.

terrorblade
08-06-2014, 04:29 AM
The voice performances are fine (including Johnny Knoxville and Tony Shalhoub, as Leonardo and Splinter, respectively), but the creatures themselves look like blobs of clay that got kilned at different temperatures.(These CG versions are barely any better, and occasionally even more off-putting, than the costume-puppet version created by Jim Henson for the original live-action movies.)

With a realistic talking raccoon and walking tree in the next multiplex, these turtles should look a lot better than they do.

GotG is still fresh on some critics mind so i won't be surprised if most reviews will compare the two films. Which is kinda sad because a lot people say that GotG is probably the best Marvel film yet.

Leo656
08-06-2014, 04:34 AM
Yeah, that's never really fair. I mean, it's natural, but it's unfair. I remember when "Superman Returns" came out three weeks after "X-Men 3", and all anyone could say was, "X-Men had more fight scenes"; "X-Men had more stuff blowing up"... and even though they both were super-hero movies, they were completely different kinds of movies and shouldn't have been put against each other in that sense. History hasn't been kind to either of them, but anyone could still see that those movies have almost nothing in common other than, they came out within weeks of each other.

I think GotG and TMNT are a little more similar but still not a fair comparison to make. That always bothers me.

Sumac
08-06-2014, 04:49 AM
Flamebait thread from user with the flamebait name. Stupidity never ends.

MajorViolence
08-06-2014, 06:56 AM
I don't know what you're talking about, Sumac. Everyone knows nothing but good things come of people reacting to locked threads by creating a new one. I don't see what could possibly go wrong. Now excuse me, I need to get back to my naked knife juggling, because I fear my sarcasm might not translate clearly enough via text.

Radical Raph
08-06-2014, 08:46 AM
New review from Ain't It Cool News: http://www.aintitcool.com/node/68277

This is what I feared after watching most of the trailers:

So much of the movie is infected with “Look at how stupid this is!” lines that by the 20th or so time a character stopped the story to make sure the audience knew the filmmakers were aware how stupid the concept of the film is I wanted to throw my hands up in the air and go “You're right, this is stupid. What am I doing here watching this, then?”

And on the positive side:

I'll give the new Ninja Turtles movie credit for looking really sharp. There are a few action set pieces that really show off the character of each Turtle. That's when the movie is at its best, actually. They get the individual personalities of the four turtles right, but that only seemed to underline the dunderheaded over-complication of their re-jiggered backstory.

Roseangelo
08-06-2014, 08:57 AM
Haven't watched the movie yet (will be tonight!:tgrin:), but I couldn't agree more. After dissecting every frame I could get my hands on, I continue to smile at all the detail in these characters.

The problem with the CGI in the movie isn't the Turtles, it's Splinter. He looks just horrible and "cheap" as CGI goes. And when you get shots that are 100% CGI those don't end up looking very good, either.

graphic_content
08-06-2014, 09:04 AM
The problem with the CGI in the movie isn't the Turtles, it's Splinter. He looks just horrible and "cheap" as CGI goes. And when you get shots that are 100% CGI those don't end up looking very good, either.

In the ILM presentation, they admitted that they only used footage of Woodburn's performance as more of a 'reference', nowhere near the extensive capture used for the boys.

Which tells me two things...their focus really was the Turtles, and they used Woodburn's for his size, and nothing else. He was basically a glorified reference point.

Shame. Splinter would look amazing in a cg movie, but looks like a cartoon in this world.

Bry
08-06-2014, 09:22 AM
New review from Ain't It Cool News: http://www.aintitcool.com/node/68277

Oh, man.

The creative minds behind the new TMNT reboot seemed to be embarrassed about their characters. So much of the movie is infected with “Look at how stupid this is!” lines that by the 20th or so time a character stopped the story to make sure the audience knew the filmmakers were aware how stupid the concept of the film is I wanted to throw my hands up in the air and go “You're right, this is stupid. What am I doing here watching this, then?”

If this is the case, then they managed to break Rule One - the story only works if you don't play it as a total joke. It's a ridiculous premise and you can acknowledge that, but you should also be taking it seriously in-universe if it's going to make any connection at all. The original comic took it seriously and that was the joke. That's what made it work.

Leo656
08-06-2014, 09:25 AM
Yeah. :ohwell:

Sounds exactly like everything I was afraid of. It's uncanny.

Puddinpop
08-06-2014, 09:38 AM
Ta-Dah, there. I will start off by saying that I find the complaints about the CGI in the movie to be rubbish.
I agree. I really could care less about these "complaints" from some of these critics. But hey.. look at this first page and tell me that the same folks are trying to lock this one up also. Every thread has to be turned into a " This sucks.. epic fail " thread. But I give em credit for being persistent :lol:
Haven't watched the movie yet (will be tonight!:tgrin:), but I couldn't agree more. After dissecting every frame I could get my hands on, I continue to smile at all the detail in these characters.

They really do look incredibly detailed. Watched the ILM interviews last night and now the designs make even more sense. Not lazy at all. Actually quite impressive how much effort they've put into research and development for this film. The CGI tech is state of the art and never before used in a movie. Not this tech anyway. That scene with Raph? Destroys anything from the past in terms of emotion.. it's like they knew exactly what to have Raph say in that moment.. all the years of him being angry and insecure and to hear and watch that scene.. it was intense. A friend of mine saw the film the other night and said the characters look crisp and that the detail was impressive. He also said the film got a huge applause at the end. I see the movie at 7 tonight. 5 years of waiting and literally hours away. Seriously hasn't hit me yet. The promo guy from the radio station told us to come at 3 bc it's going to be crazy.

Anton Chigurh
08-06-2014, 09:45 AM
A thread for reviewing reviews????

whoa...:D

ScrewtheMirageTMNT
08-06-2014, 10:43 AM
The problem with the CGI in the movie isn't the Turtles, it's Splinter. He looks just horrible and "cheap" as CGI goes. And when you get shots that are 100% CGI those don't end up looking very good, either.

Um, how can the CGI of the turtles not be bad when they are in a shot with stuff that is nothing but CGI? I know that parts of the final battle are totally CGI cause the ILM presentation dude said so, I mean he said that New York stuff was CGI.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 10:59 AM
In the ILM presentation, they admitted that they only used footage of Woodburn's performance as more of a 'reference', nowhere near the extensive capture used for the boys.

Which tells me two things...their focus really was the Turtles, and they used Woodburn's for his size, and nothing else. He was basically a glorified reference point.

Shame. Splinter would look amazing in a cg movie, but looks like a cartoon in this world.
Well, I heard Splinter kicks ass in the movie, Maybe that's the reason why they didn't use any of his data, They needed splinter to be very agile.

graphic_content
08-06-2014, 11:05 AM
Well, I heard Splinter kicks ass in the movie, Maybe that's the reason why they didn't use any of his data, They needed splinter to be very agile.

true, but the still makes me feel bad that they used Woodburn for size reference alone. they obviously were never interested in his 'performance' evidence by the fact that the ILM just used his footage as a 'reference', and the fact they dubbed over his vocals with Tony Shaloub.

I would be upset if I were him too, but, Hollywood is just that kind of place.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 11:09 AM
Dont think anyone posted this one yet, Schmoes Know posted there review of the film.

qj2L7CJqvSk

AquaParade
08-06-2014, 11:12 AM
Seen this?
http://www.pinkisthenewblog.com/2014-08-05/movie-review-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles

DioLeo451
08-06-2014, 11:23 AM
Dont think anyone posted this one yet, Schmoes Know posted there review of the film.

qj2L7CJqvSk
Ouch:tsad:

Lou 500
08-06-2014, 11:31 AM
The current score on IMDB is 6.8, which is a new record for movies directed by Liebsman.

Vicky82
08-06-2014, 11:50 AM
The current score on IMDB is 6.8, which is a new record for movies directed by Liebsman.

Don't bother with IMDB score, apparetly they all voting it a low score before they even seen it.

MajorViolence
08-06-2014, 11:56 AM
The current score on IMDB is 6.8, which is a new record for movies directed by Liebsman.

Is that a record high or low?

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 11:58 AM
Going back to the ILM presentation thing, You guys noticed when Pablo Helman was talking the elevator scene, He said there was one R rated moment that they had to cut. And it was when Leo look like he was Twerking.

The Turtle Terminator
08-06-2014, 11:59 AM
Is that a record high or low?

Record high

graphic_content
08-06-2014, 11:59 AM
Going back to the ILM presentation thing, You guys noticed when Pablo Helman was talking the elevator scene, He said there was one R rated moment that they had to cut. And it was when Leo look like he was Twerking.

which is weird considering they put that in the trailers.

The Boston Ninja Turtle
08-06-2014, 12:02 PM
twerking grants an R rating?

MajorViolence
08-06-2014, 12:04 PM
It's weird, but knowing how weirdly prudish the ratings board can be, I can believe it.

Don't get me wrong, I'm glad it was cut, but I think the reason being that it's considered "R rated" is pretty stupid.

NinjaPug
08-06-2014, 12:08 PM
Review from Nerdist. They gave it a 2 out of 5:

http://www.nerdist.com/2014/08/review-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles/

There’s a surprisingly small amount of action in the film, save a couple of big sequences. The longest one is equal parts super entertaining and super confusing. The Turtles escape from Sachs’ compound in the snowy mountains (somewhere that’s only a short drive away from Manhattan in the springtime, by the way) with the help of April and Vern and end up sliding for a million miles downward in a semi truck while the Foot Clan in Hummers chase after them, firing electricity tethers. This sequence goes on SO LONG and is so kinetic and, I’ll say it, physically impossible, that I don’t even think falling down Mount Everest would take this long. Not to mention the Turtles hurl their bodies at cars and things and barely get hurt at all, much less the broken back or caved-in skull they probably would have gotten. That said, it’s actually fun to watch because it’s so fast-paced. Speed ramping happens too much, but hey, take what you can get.

MajorViolence
08-06-2014, 12:13 PM
Also Rotten Tomatoes is currently sitting at 36%.

beeshaw
08-06-2014, 12:19 PM
The problem with the CGI in the movie isn't the Turtles, it's Splinter. He looks just horrible and "cheap" as CGI goes. And when you get shots that are 100% CGI those don't end up looking very good, either.

In the ILM presentation, they admitted that they only used footage of Woodburn's performance as more of a 'reference', nowhere near the extensive capture used for the boys.

Which tells me two things...their focus really was the Turtles, and they used Woodburn's for his size, and nothing else. He was basically a glorified reference point.

Shame. Splinter would look amazing in a cg movie, but looks like a cartoon in this world.

Again, to reference the ILM presentations, they said the main reason the Turtles themselves are so humanoid is to 'sell' them as REAL. With Splinter you don't have the human features to sell it. And considering they didn't use mo-cap by the sounds of it, he's pretty much a fully animated character, which when put against the Turtles will make him look more cartoony...because essentially he is just a cartoon. Which is a shame. Hopefully there's a sequel and they can find a way to make Splinter 'work'.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 12:20 PM
Again, to reference the ILM presentations, they said the main reason the Turtles themselves are so humanoid is to 'sell' them as REAL. With Splinter you don't have the human features to sell it. And considering they didn't use mo-cap by the sounds of it, he's pretty much a fully animated character, which when put against the Turtles will make him look more cartoony...because essentially he is just a cartoon. Which is a shame. Hopefully there's a sequel and they can find a way to make Splinter 'work'.
in every incarnation, The Turtles always had a human like quality them, Splinter always look like a Rat in each incarnation, Its cause of his large Snout, While the Turtles have little Snouts on them.

beeshaw
08-06-2014, 12:23 PM
in every incarnation, The Turtles always had a human like quality them, Splinter always look like a Rat in each incarnation, Its cause of his large Snout, While the Turtles have little snouts on them.

I'm not knocking his design, just saying that it's obvious he'd look out of place from an FX standpoint since he's created differently.

You can always tell the difference between a mo-cap performance and one that was animated. It comes across even LESS real when it's straight animation. Even with the Turtles themselves, I'm sure there are some shots of the Turtles that are straight CGI where you can just 'tell', especially put against the mo-cap.

Purse Grabbin Puke
08-06-2014, 12:23 PM
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2014/08/emilys-experiences-at-la-premiere-of.html?m=1

Peter Laird's Daughter Emily saw the movie...

Also, a clip has come out, it's the elevator scene, and I have to say this just 100% sold me on the movie. I will love it.

https://www.yahoo.com/movies/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-beatbox-93977460722.html?src=rss

plastroncafe
08-06-2014, 12:33 PM
Fresh from The Nerdist:

http://www.nerdist.com/2014/08/review-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles/

A lot of people have been really worried about the new Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles movie “because Michael Bay.” Bay is a producer on the movie along with his company Platinum Dunes. It’s not a Michael Bay movie, that much needs to be established right away. Why? Because, while his fingerprints are all over Jonathan Liebesman’s film, from frenetic action you can barely follow to shots leering at parts of Megan Fox’s anatomy, the new Ninja Turtles movies actually DOES feel like it’s for kids, more or less. Not people around 30 years old who grew up with the first cartoon (which is actually terrible, by the way; I watched a couple of episodes recently and they do not hold up at all), but for kids today. The whole feel of it is that of a big, actiony movie for the under-twelves. That doesn’t make it any good, by the way; it just means, it’s just not for grown ups, so stop worrying...

ObiWanFan4life
08-06-2014, 12:35 PM
I somewhat expected this movie to recieve lukewarm reviews from critics.

Matt2310
08-06-2014, 12:45 PM
Fresh from The Nerdist:

http://www.nerdist.com/2014/08/review-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles/

he was talking crap about the 87' cartoon this dudes a clown i wouldnt even read half of that review

tmnt182
08-06-2014, 01:36 PM
From the A.V. Club (review should be coming tomorrow)

"We're barely putting up with TMNT"

http://www.avclub.com/article/week-were-barely-putting-teenage-mutant-ninja-turt-207775

ScrewtheMirageTMNT
08-06-2014, 01:40 PM
From the A.V. Club (review should be coming tomorrow)

"We're barely putting up with TMNT"

http://www.avclub.com/article/week-were-barely-putting-teenage-mutant-ninja-turt-207775

It sounds like they really didn't like it.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 01:42 PM
From the A.V. Club (review should be coming tomorrow)

"We're barely putting up with TMNT"

http://www.avclub.com/article/week-were-barely-putting-teenage-mutant-ninja-turt-207775
Most of the negative reviews out there seem like, The movie wasn't made for them. They should've known that from the begining, This is a Nickelodeon movie, and its aimed at the Kids, Despite it being PG-13.

So they seem to be bashing this movie on the bases that, Its a Kids movie, Its very typical of the these movies reviews, Every time a family film comes out, They crap all over them.

Candy Kappa
08-06-2014, 01:46 PM
twerking grants an R rating?

That is hilarious. And kinda sad.

MajorViolence
08-06-2014, 01:53 PM
This is a Nickelodeon movie, and its aimed at the Kids, Despite it being PG-13

I don't know about you, but I find that in itself to be a huge problem.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 01:54 PM
I don't know about you, but I find that in itself to be a huge problem.
What is, That its Nickelodeon?

MajorViolence
08-06-2014, 01:59 PM
What is, That its Nickelodeon?

No, the idea that we're supposed to excuse it as being "for kids" despite it having a PG-13 rating.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 02:00 PM
No, the idea that we're supposed to excuse it as being "for kids" despite it having a PG-13 rating.
Nickelodeon has been promoting the film like Crazy.

GeneralTragg
08-06-2014, 02:01 PM
I was actually just thinking: of the reviews I've read so far, none of them have simply dismissed it as being a turtles movie, they're taking issue with plot and structure...

Shark_Blade
08-06-2014, 02:02 PM
People complaining it's too "kid friendly"...

Go see for yourself, there's tonnes of adult humors in it.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 02:02 PM
I was actually just thinking: of the reviews I've read so far, none of them have simply dismissed it as being a turtles movie, they're taking issue with plot and structure...
And some of those reviews don't even acknowledge the 1990 film and using that as a frame of reference.

MajorViolence
08-06-2014, 02:03 PM
Nickelodeon has been promoting the film like Crazy.

That doesn't give it a free pass on quality. The PG-13 rating means they obviously intend for audiences older than small children to see the film, so it doesn't deserve a free pass on the basis of being "for kids."

Bry
08-06-2014, 02:04 PM
I was actually just thinking: of the reviews I've read so far, none of them have simply dismissed it as being a turtles movie, they're taking issue with plot and structure...

Which is good, honestly. I don't want this movie (or any TMNT movie) judged purely on the concept/franchise alone. People shouldn't dismiss it or give it a pass just because it's the Ninja Turtles. It should be judged as an actual movie with an actual story first and foremost.

The Boston Ninja Turtle
08-06-2014, 02:09 PM
Im sorry but the "This is a Kids Movie" excuse is pure crap..just because its a kids film doesnt mean we should excuse things

we should demand more out of our movies no matter the studio or rating

Vicky82
08-06-2014, 02:12 PM
5 Seconds of Summer enjoyed the movie

5 Seconds of Summer ‏@5SOS · Aug 5
.@TMNTMovie us standing next to our relative turtle, movie was amazing!

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BuPHS8DCcAArXcl.jpg

ScrewtheMirageTMNT
08-06-2014, 02:14 PM
5 Seconds of Summer enjoyed the movie

5 Seconds of Summer ‏@5SOS · Aug 5
.@TMNTMovie us standing next to our relative turtle, movie was amazing!

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BuPHS8DCcAArXcl.jpg

Who in thee blue hell are these guys?

Bry
08-06-2014, 02:16 PM
Im sorry but the "This is a Kids Movie" excuse is pure crap..just because its a kids film doesnt mean we should excuse things

we should demand more out of our movies no matter the studio or rating

Check the caliber of the best kids' movies (http://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/bestofrt/top_100_kids__family_movies/?category=11).

A good kids' movie should still be a good movie. Being a "kids' movie" is no excuse at all. "It's a ____ movie" for anything is a bad excuse. Any kind of movie can and should be a good, regardless of genre or audience.

Vicky82
08-06-2014, 02:29 PM
Who in thee blue hell are these guys?

They are new pop rock band from Australia, there first single was 'She's so Perfect', They are pretty popular in the UK not sure about America though.

GeneralTragg
08-06-2014, 02:32 PM
Who in thee blue hell are these guys?

They are to one direction what the Street Sharks are to the Turtles...

Which is good, honestly. I don't want this movie (or any TMNT movie) judged purely on the concept/franchise alone. People shouldn't dismiss it or give it a pass just because it's the Ninja Turtles. It should be judged as an actual movie with an actual story first and foremost.

Exactly.

MajorViolence
08-06-2014, 02:33 PM
They are to one direction what the Street Sharks are to the Turtles...

That may be the saddest thing I've ever read.

GeneralTragg
08-06-2014, 03:25 PM
That may be the saddest thing I've ever read.

I'm here all week.

Sumac
08-06-2014, 03:38 PM
He said there was one R rated moment that they had to cut. And it was when Leo look like he was Twerking.
It's...*speechless*...never mind. :ohwell:

Radical Raph
08-06-2014, 03:40 PM
More reviews are in at RT. Down to 31% now.

zodiac brave
08-06-2014, 03:44 PM
Oh, man.

If this is the case, then they managed to break Rule One - the story only works if you don't play it as a total joke. It's a ridiculous premise and you can acknowledge that, but you should also be taking it seriously in-universe if it's going to make any connection at all. The original comic took it seriously and that was the joke. That's what made it work.

i guess, to me, it depends on the iteration. this rule is golden in regards to mirage, image and the '90 movie, but considering the main inspiration for this flick was the OT (where there was TONS of fourth wall breaking and self-referential, "hey we're wacky" humor) it seems par for the course. maybe still a little grating and cloying, but on point, nonetheless.

Um, how can the CGI of the turtles not be bad when they are in a shot with stuff that is nothing but CGI?

by not making the CGI of the turtles bad...?

i mean, why is it automatically bad just cuz theres lots of it?

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 04:37 PM
Here's another review, From CineFix

I7mjC-EAnoE

Radical Raph
08-06-2014, 04:44 PM
Here's another review, From CineFix

I7mjC-EAnoE
Well that's disappointing.

Warhorse
08-06-2014, 04:45 PM
You know what, I am not going to watch any of these reviews (unless it's JeremyJahn) until I see the movie.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 04:45 PM
Goddamn Is it really that bad
Interesting they did not reference the 1990 movie, Most reviews dont even mention about the original films.

JTH
08-06-2014, 05:34 PM
Seriously, this is literally the dumbest thing I've ever heard. Why do I keep seeing and hearing this argument: "Why are hating on Michael Bay? He didn't make the movie, he's only the producer."

Do these people even know what a "Producer" does or what the definition of "produce" is? :lol:

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 06:33 PM
Dont know if anyone posted this anywhere, But Peter Laird's daughter posted about her experience from the Red Carpet Premiere, And she also loved the movie.
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2014/08/emilys-experiences-at-la-premiere-of.html?m=1

pdizzle
08-06-2014, 06:35 PM
Dont know if anyone posted this anywhere, But Peter Laird's daughter posted about her experience from the Red Carpet Premiere, And she also loved the movie.
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2014/08/emilys-experiences-at-la-premiere-of.html?m=1
how refreshing....thx for this bro

Purse Grabbin Puke
08-06-2014, 06:36 PM
Seriously, this is literally the dumbest thing I've ever heard. Why do I keep seeing and hearing this argument: "Why are hating on Michael Bay? He didn't make the movie, he's only the producer."

Do these people even know what a "Producer" does or what the definition of "produce" is? :lol:

He was filming and promoting 2 movies while TMNT was being made, Pain and Gain and Transformers 4. How much could he POSSIBLY have been involved?? Brad Fuller seems to be the lead on this, considering he's the TMNT die hard.

It's funny, and I guess it's Paramount's fault for using Michael Bay's name specifically, but the same company produced The Purge movies, but they don't attach his name. I wonder if they only do that for movies they don't fully believe in. I think they used Bay's name for the Texas Chainsaw remake, and maybe even the Friday the 13th remake.

xChri5x
08-06-2014, 06:58 PM
Dont know if anyone posted this anywhere, But Peter Laird's daughter posted about her experience from the Red Carpet Premiere, And she also loved the movie.
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2014/08/emilys-experiences-at-la-premiere-of.html?m=1

It's kind of written like an advertisement.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 07:09 PM
The part where she talks about the movie.
We both loved the movie, which has a great blend of humor, action, and top notch special effects. While remaining respectful to the original material, the movie also brings its own spin to the Turtles. I can’t wait to see the movie again, and I think Turtles fans will really enjoy the movie, which opens in theaters Friday, August 8. After the movie we attended the after-party, which was decked out with games for the kids in attendance, drinks and, of course, pizza.

beeshaw
08-06-2014, 07:14 PM
Seriously, this is literally the dumbest thing I've ever heard. Why do I keep seeing and hearing this argument: "Why are hating on Michael Bay? He didn't make the movie, he's only the producer."

Do these people even know what a "Producer" does or what the definition of "produce" is? :lol:

Then it's time that:

Don Murphy
Tom DeSanto
Lorenzo di Bonaventura
Ian Bryce

take some blame for TF: Revenge of the Fallen. :tcool:

Oh wait, it's all on Bay right?

JTH
08-06-2014, 07:20 PM
Then it's time that:

Don Murphy
Tom DeSanto
Lorenzo di Bonaventura
Ian Bryce

take some blame for TF: Revenge of the Fallen. :tcool:

Since everything about the movie sucked...yes. :lol:

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 07:26 PM
I wonder what the cast of the Nick TMNT series think of the movie? Some of them were at the Red Carpet Premiere.

JTH
08-06-2014, 07:29 PM
I wonder what the cast of the Nick TMNT series think of the movie? Some of them were at the Red Carpet Premiere.
What they think? Or what they really think?

CyberCubed
08-06-2014, 07:57 PM
The reviews are exactly what I predicted weeks ago. Mostly poor with a few people finding the film average at best.

This was never going to be a good movie. The signs were on the wall for months. I don't know why anyone is surprised.

Bmaga123
08-06-2014, 08:26 PM
The reviews are exactly what I predicted weeks ago. Mostly poor with a few people finding the film average at best.

This was never going to be a good movie. The signs were on the wall for months. I don't know why anyone is surprised.

Exactly, people had there minds made up before seeing the movie and it would of taken a masterpiece for a decision to be swayed.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 08:43 PM
just saw this. They had the guy who sang the vocals of the original Theme.

oynd7vLgasw

Black Nerd is at the Screening tonight, Will be interesting to hear what he thinks.

Warhorse
08-06-2014, 09:03 PM
Black Nerd is at the Screening tonight, Will be interesting to hear what he thinks.

I think he'll have his gripes, but will most likely enjoy the movie.

SwiftNinjaFox
08-06-2014, 09:27 PM
Exactly, people had there minds made up before seeing the movie and it would of taken a masterpiece for a decision to be swayed.

Or it could also be a pretty sub-par movie and not that they went into it with concrete decision already set.

TMNT III really isn't that great of a movie. TMNT (07) has its flaws. They're still TMNT movies. This one could be the same. Maybe it really is just average and not that good.

Could still be fun, though. At least, I'm hoping.

The only thing I'd like someone to spoil for me...
I'd be real happy if April's cell phone has the old "Channel 6 news theme" from the cartoon as ring tone. :D

Shadowsculptor
08-06-2014, 09:45 PM
Seriously, this is literally the dumbest thing I've ever heard. Why do I keep seeing and hearing this argument: "Why are hating on Michael Bay? He didn't make the movie, he's only the producer."

Do these people even know what a "Producer" does or what the definition of "produce" is? :lol:

Lol, do you? He barely had any involvement with it. it's simply a marketing ploy, that is obvious. The responsibility falls on the director. Yes, Even if the producer has a set guideline and provides the money through his production company, a TALENTED director can take that and elevate it, make it his own, and actually make a great film. This has been proven time and time again.

& Batman Forever certainly was nothing like a Tim Burton film. The "producer" of a film varies in involvement. We don't know exactly how much Michael bay had to do with the film, all I know is that the bulk of the responsibility should be placed on the director and his team.

Not trying to sound hostile or anything lol, don't get the wrong impression. just noting that the argument is 100% valid and I'm kind of sick of hearing "Michael Bays TMNT movie" JUST because his name is recognizable. That is all. Popular films have placed the actual director in that marketing position and not the producer. Recently "Bryan Singers X-Men" etc To grab people.

I never mind bad reviews though, I see what I want to see and actually like to form my own opinion,

Reviews are only worth reading AFTER you've seen the film for yourself, otherwise there will be a lot of people who hate in a film without actually seeing it. People's opinions are easily swayed in the internet age. People love taking sides without knowing their own views. *shrug*

The Boston Ninja Turtle
08-06-2014, 10:02 PM
Lol, do you? He barely had any involvement with it. it's simply a marketing ploy, that is obvious. The responsibility falls on the director. Yes, Even if the producer has a set guideline and provides the money through his production company, a TALENTED director can take that and elevate it, make it his own, and actually make a great film. This has been proven time and time again.

not always..a Producer can literally decide to undermine a director and decide to "Direct" it themselves

most producers are hands off but there are a good chunk who back seat direct..and if the Director doesnt listen they get fired

Commenter 42
08-06-2014, 10:17 PM
In Television, a Producer is king. In Film, The Director is king, UNLESS a studio is attached from the start. Then the Studio is king.

It certainly varies, but in a general sense, that's how it shakes out.

Shadowsculptor
08-06-2014, 10:46 PM
not always..a Producer can literally decide to undermine a director and decide to "Direct" it themselves

most producers are hands off but there are a good chunk who back seat direct..and if the Director doesnt listen they get fired

Yea, but that what I was trying to say. it varies so much, that even saying the producer is responsible for this and that is nonsense, unless the producer himself actually comes out and states the extent of his involvement.

People are just basing their impressions off of marketing and the name, not really knowing what the "producer" does or how much impact he truly has had on the film.

Honestly I really don't care anymore, lol I just want to see the film, and hope everyone gets a chance to judge it fairly.

Warboss74
08-06-2014, 10:50 PM
Yea, but that what I was trying to say. it varies so much, that even saying the producer is responsible for this and that is nonsense, unless the producer himself actually comes out and states the extent of his involvement.

People are just basing their impressions off of marketing and the name, not really knowing what the "producer" does or how much impact he truly has had on the film.

Honestly I really don't care anymore, lol I just want to see the film, and hope everyone gets a chance to judge it fairly.
To be fair, everyone working on the film has said that Bay had a lot of input during the making of the film.

SwiftNinjaFox
08-06-2014, 10:50 PM
If you get top billing on the film, you get top target for the ire.

Commenter 42
08-06-2014, 10:56 PM
I've heard the exact opposite, from people working on the film.

Commenter 42
08-06-2014, 10:59 PM
just saw this. They had the guy who sang the vocals of the original Theme.

oynd7vLgasw

Black Nerd is at the Screening tonight, Will be interesting to hear what he thinks.

Who knew Heisenberg could sing? :lol:

Shadowsculptor
08-06-2014, 11:06 PM
I've heard the exact opposite, from people working on the film.

Yea I've heard the same, thus why I said it's nonsensical to say Michael bay is responsible for this or that, or that or this lol. Just let it die. Liebesman directed the film, responsibility should fall on him anyway, despite what the producers involvement is. If Liebesman doesn't want to elevate his career then that's fine.

Of course there are articles that feature people who work on the film, saying Michael Bay has heavy involvement, it's a god damn marketing ploy lol. If you can't see that, then that's a damn shame lol.

Warboss74
08-06-2014, 11:09 PM
Yea I've heard the same, thus why I said it's nonsensical to say Michael bay is responsible for this or that, or that or this lol. Just let it die. Liebesman directed the film, responsibility should fall on him anyway, despite what the producers involvement is. If Liebesman doesn't want to elevate his career then that's fine.

Of course there are articles that feature people who work on the film, saying Michael Bay has heavy involvement, it's a god damn marketing ploy lol. If you can't see that, then that's a damn shame lol.
Liebesman definitely said Bay was heavily involved, so I can only go by what's been presented.

Leo656
08-06-2014, 11:17 PM
Liebsman also isn't a very competent director on top of that. So there's that.

I think, more or less, Bay and the studio had some very specific ideas for parts that HAD to be in the movie - the snow scene, bulletproof turtles, and the basic story of Raph having to save the other three after they were captured, were all there in very early drafts, after all, way back when the TMNT were aliens - and a very specific vision for how it should look. They gave those instructions to Liebsman, and he made the movie "his way" based on their suggestions/guidelines/demands. He probably had to run a lot of it by Bay, to make sure it was in accordance with what the studio wanted. That's generally how it works.

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 11:23 PM
The Rating went up 36% on Rotten Tomatoes, 1 Fresh Review.
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/teenage_mutant_ninja_turtles_2013/reviews/

Puddinpop
08-06-2014, 11:24 PM
Wow. This film was F-ing awesome. The graphics were some of the best I've seen in a film. Esp the 3D. The Pizza scene being my favorite one with the slice of pizza looking like it was sticking out in your face it was crazy lol. The first half n hour really had a Batman Begins type atmosphere. The film set itself up well imo. Definitely Fox's best performance, she really seemed into this role.
I liked the " father-like" way they introduce Splinter and How the Turtles react when he catches them sneaking in. The fight scenes were well done. And these turtles may seem like " hulks " to some.. but when you see the film it becomes clear that they are definitely not invulnerable. They actually get their asses handed to them a few times. All of them. Raph gets a serious...serious ass kicking by Shredder. But my favorite part was definitely the last scene with them all on the roof. The fighting was just so much fun to watch. It didn't end quickly like in the last films. The turtles had quite a few goes at Shredder. Of course Mikey was really funny and that little "Shell " joke got a good reaction and it was also the only joke like that in the film. The rest of the April Mikey stuff was really innocent. That Raph scene at the end was the most emotional scene I've seen in a TMNT film.. and they ended that scene in a funny way even though it started out with so much sorrow and passion. The film was predictable and did go by in a flash.. probably bc of how much fun it was. Now my only issue with the film was that during the Splinter Shredder fight scene there was a small portion of it were I just wanted to jump into the film and scream at Liebesman to back the **** up from the fight so I could see what the hell was going on. And then once the gate shuts in the Lair he did. It's just that the fighting was so much fun to watch that even for a minutes if he got to close with the camera it was frustrating. But thank god it was only a small part of the fight scene. The rest of the fight scenes were fine.

One more thing. When you see this movies plot play out.. you'll realize that Shredder was always Japanese judging by how integrated he was into the story and how Sachs seemed separated from the Shredder role. Shredder has an extremely deep intimidating voice. And in the beginning when his hands are bound " I wont spoil it " he speaks Japanese and it's just intimidating. But when you see the film you'll realize that it wasn't just an " add on scene or two ". I know that I've been a supporter of this film so ill get the " Well of course you liked it.. your opinion doesn't mean anything". I don't care lol. I enjoyed every second of it and to here an entire theatre applaud for this TMNT film that has been threw hell with so much drama.. it was an awesome way to end the night. The critics can do their thing. Whatever lol. I think a lot of fans are going to enjoy this film. I just don't see it flopping.
I also loved how they ended it with this " the adventure continues" vibe. They did a really nice job setting things up for a sequel. Cant wait.

beeshaw
08-06-2014, 11:25 PM
Liebsman also isn't a very competent director on top of that. So there's that.

I think, more or less, Bay and the studio had some very specific ideas for parts that HAD to be in the movie - the snow scene, bulletproof turtles, and the basic story of Raph having to save the other three after they were captured, were all there in very early drafts, after all, way back when the TMNT were aliens - and a very specific vision for how it should look. They gave those instructions to Liebsman, and he made the movie "his way" based on their suggestions/guidelines/demands. He probably had to run a lot of it by Bay, to make sure it was in accordance with what the studio wanted. That's generally how it works.

Bay himself said that everything went through him (when talking about the 9/11 poster specifically...of course that one thing didn't apparently). I'm sure that pretty much meant EVERYTHING. Visually you can also tell he had quite a bit of influence. He may not have been on set everyday or been involved in the nitty gritty of every minute detail, but you can bet all the broad strokes and big decisions needed his big stamp of approval before moving forward. Does that mean he's to 'blame' if this attempt fails.....?

DioLeo451
08-06-2014, 11:29 PM
Wow. This film was F-ing awesome. The graphics were some of the best I've seen in a film. Esp the 3D. The Pizza scene being my favorite one with the slice of pizza looking like it was sticking out in your face it was crazy lol. The first half n hour really had a Batman Begins type atmosphere. The film set itself up well imo. Definitely Fox's best performance, she really seemed into this role.
I liked the " father-like" way they introduce Splinter and How the Turtles react when he catches them sneaking in. The fight scenes were well done. And these turtles may seem like " hulks " to some.. but when you see the film it becomes clear that they are definitely not invulnerable. They actually get their asses handed to them a few times. All of them. Raph gets a serious...serious ass kicking by Shredder. But my favorite part was definitely the last scene with them all on the roof. The fighting was just so much fun to watch. It didn't end quickly like in the last films. The turtles had quite a few goes at Shredder. Of course Mikey was really funny and that little "Shell " joke got a good reaction and it was also the only joke like that in the film. The rest of the April Mikey stuff was really innocent. That Raph scene at the end was the most emotional scene I've seen in a TMNT film.. and they ended that scene in a funny way even though it started out with so much sorrow and passion. The film was predictable and did go by in a flash.. probably bc of how much fun it was. Now my only issue with the film was that during the Splinter Shredder fight scene there was a small portion of it were I just wanted to jump into the film and scream at Liebesman to back the **** up from the fight so I could see what the hell was going on. And then once the gate shuts in the Lair he did. It's just that the fighting was so much fun to watch that even for a minutes if he got to close with the camera it was frustrating. But thank god it was only a small part of the fight scene. The rest of the fight scenes were fine.

One more thing. When you see this movies plot play out.. you'll realize that Shredder was always Japanese judging by how integrated he was into the story and how Sachs seemed separated from the Shredder role. Shredder has an extremely deep intimidating voice. And in the beginning when his hands are bound " I wont spoil it " he speaks Japanese and it's just intimidating. But when you see the film you'll realize that it wasn't just an " add on scene or two ". I know that I've been a supporter of this film so ill get the " Well of course you liked it.. your opinion doesn't mean anything". I don't care lol. I enjoyed every second of it and to here an entire theatre applaud for this TMNT film that has been threw hell with so much drama.. it was an awesome way to end the night. The critics can do their thing. Whatever lol. I think a lot of fans are going to enjoy this film. I just don't see it flopping.
I also loved how they ended it with this " the adventure continues" vibe. They did a really nice job setting things up for a sequel. Cant wait.
Glad you enjoyed it man:tgrin:

TigerClaw
08-06-2014, 11:39 PM
It went back down again, To 33%

Here's a positive review from the Examiner, They gave it 3 out of 5 stars.
http://www.examiner.com/review/movie-review-michael-bay-s-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-starring-megan-fox

Chuquison
08-06-2014, 11:47 PM
Ok so How do I review this new TMNT movie... Its hard to do so without giving anything away... Most common question I have gotten is "Is it good?" "is it worth seeing?" I think I answer this like any other turtle fan.. You have to see it, if your a fan.. are you going to like it? that's a different story for a lot of different people. The story is a mixture of old history and some new history and it takes you back to your child hood then it doesn't.. people in the movie that where not fan seemed to enjoy the film quite a bit.
It is funny, does have pretty good fight scenes, and the story line is so so, I felt like Michael Bay tried to cram to much in such a short time. it feels like they are rushing the story in my opinion. Did the turtles look good? That question is also hard to answer, a lot of your cartoon fans may not like the way they look, but the turtles have gone through a lot in looks in years. from they first started in the early 80's which they where gruesome and the comics where graphic, to the bubbly cartoon to the movie puppets to the turtles on music tour, to the computer animated movie to the current cartoon on Nick. Lets not forget the biggest fail which where the turtles in suits show and the Japanese only power ranger turtles show called Super Turtles that where god awful. These turtles from Michael bay take you back almost to the 80's where they wherent so friendly and ugly mixed with new artistic views. in my opinion they are not terrible but they are not good.

in all I found the movie to be humorous and action packed but the story lacked alittle to me. When the movie is out for a week or so Ill explain more in another post to give people a chance to see it and Ill give you my reasons on my dislikes and likes so I don't ruin it for anyone.

trikuza
08-06-2014, 11:57 PM
Shredder's plot seemed like an afterthought. And the evil speeches the bad guys gave were loaded with cliches.

But the turtles' personalities were right on. And there was a lot of great action. The whole father-sons dynamic between splinter and the turtles was strong. I enjoyed watching the toddler turtles deal with being outcasts from the outside world. The cgi was really good, but people were right...in some scenes splinter's graphics seemed kind of choppy.

A good amount of the audience clapped at the end of the movie, and the kids were excited.

The movie could have used an extra 30 minutes for some character development.

DioLeo451
08-07-2014, 02:57 AM
Here is Chris Stuckmans Review
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XM54YuQsz8