PDA

View Full Version : Did Tales V. 2 from 2004 feel more like the 4kids series than Mirage?


CyberCubed
08-06-2014, 01:22 PM
I've been re-reading Tales of the TMNT V.2 and rewatching the 4kids show at the same time, and I can't help but feel like many of the Tales V. 2 stories don't feel like Mirage stories, but instead feel like episodes of the 4kids cartoon.

There are some exceptions of course, but Tales V. 2 almost reads like a cartoon. The fact that both series were going on at the same time probably accounts to this, but it feels like all those sci-fi and mystical adventures in Tales felt like they leapt right out of 4kids scripts.

Even the Turtles in Tales V. 2 act more like their 4kids counterparts than the Mirage Turtles. I don't know if its because Peter Laird's writing in Volume 4 was so different, (as Pete didn't write any Tales stories, just Volume 4), but there's a stark contrast. The Turtles even use catch phrases in some issues and Donatello starts building things like he does in the cartoons.

Tales of the TMNT V. 2 almost reads like lost episodes of the 4kids show to me, rather than part of Mirage.

oldmanwinters
08-06-2014, 02:29 PM
I felt the same way, even though my reading of the Tales Turtles line was somewhat sporadic. Once 4Kids villains started getting introduced in the comic like Hun, the comparison was even harder to ignore.

miru
08-06-2014, 03:02 PM
Yeah, it did feel very 4kids-ish, especially the art style, which had the same kind of cleanness as 2k3, rather than the rough look of old Mirage.

CyberCubed
08-06-2014, 05:30 PM
Yeah, don't forget the Foot Mystics showed up (looking exactly like they did in Season 1 of 4kids), Hun, and eventually some nods to 4kids storylines bizarrely.

oldmanwinters
08-06-2014, 08:44 PM
And the Mirage published 2007 movie prequel comics came out... and I had no idea what continuity was what anymore.

Triceratons....
The Ancient One...

Cipher
08-07-2014, 02:53 AM
Nah. I think you could make that argument for some of the more straight-forward issues, but even then ...

I'd say any similarities owe more to the 4Kids series being cut from the Mirage cloth than anything else. Tales Vol. 2 is still packed full of the kinds of stories no other version of the Turtles would ever attempt. Gritty crime, surrealism, all of the bittersweet future stories, lots of somber little endings, Raphael and Cha Ocho straight up abandoning a bunch of alien hostages, etc.

There's no way 4Kids ever touched anything like "Blind Faith," "Scars," "The Path" or "Loops." Even in terms of the most straight-forward action pieces, the approaches were different. The 4Kids show was never going to dive into cosmic weirdness the way the Donatello-Utrom issues tend to. It wouldn't send Raphael and Shadow to Paris just for a weird one-off serial killer encounter. As mentioned above, Raphael and Cha Ocho would never go out for beers and shrug off a bunch of hostages. Action in Tales, mostly, still kept to small set pieces, made it somber, or just kept it goofy and weird in a way that's still more reminiscent of an indie sounding board than a cartoon (the issue with Michelangelo's pet "rabbit" for example). It even contained the Professor Obligado backup, of all things, which is the Mirage-iest thing ... ever.

Not to mention the number of issues that are just firmly rooted in Mirage canon, tone aside.

There are a couple of 4Kids episodes I think could fit the Mirage series with light editing, though, or at least somewhat matched its tone.

neatoman
08-07-2014, 05:52 AM
Maybe? I heard that Steve Murphy worked closely on both projects so it would not surprise me.
The only concrete influences I know of so far (I'm reading the IDW reprints) are that it introduces Hun and that the new Foot Clan symbol replaced the human foot print look. You know this symbol:
http://img1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130409173548/villains/images/e/ef/FootClanModern.png

The funny thing is that the Nickelodeon cartoon is the only current version not to use it. The IDW comics use it and if look closely you can see that Shredder in the new movie has it on his chest. See almost at the end here:
http://youtu.be/zFXdadsCVF4

VaughnMichael
08-07-2014, 08:24 AM
Yes 100% even Volume 4 felt like it was Mirages version of Fast Forward.

CyberCubed
08-07-2014, 08:32 AM
Yes 100% even Volume 4 felt like it was Mirages version of Fast Forward.

Well I'm pretty sure that's where the concept of Fast Forward was based on anyway. I guess it would have been interesting to see FF adapt some Volume 4 storylines too, I remember people speculating about that when it was originally airing. They should have at least adapted those talking dinosaurs Donatello had to deal with in Volume 4.