PDA

View Full Version : Turns Out David Wise Created the TMNT


Wentos
08-07-2014, 10:17 AM
http://screencrush.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-animated-series/

I just happened to come across this article today and... well, just see for yourself.

Even though he won the gig with his comic book geekdom, Wise admits that he wasn’t much of a fan of the source material. “I had the comics, but I didn’t think they were very good,” he says. “I liked the idea and the title and the fact that they were named after Renaissance artists. And the Japanese angle. But I knew this was going to take a lot of development.”

Wise had landed the job. But he knew it was going to be a tough road ahead. “I knew it was going to be a lot of work because there’s very little story in the first seven comics,” he says. “There is even less characterization. And their origin makes no sense as far as I’m concerned!”

It also turned out that Eastman and Laird’s highly stylized art was going to prove difficult to translate to the realm of animation. “This led to the designers of the cartoon version of the characters tearing their hair out,” Wise says. “These guys won’t animate! There’s no accurate anatomy anywhere in these comic books! It was going to be a headache all around.”

As the show moved through development, Wise sat down to transform the black and white parodies from the original comic book into characters who could sustain an entire cartoon series. His conclusion was simple: each member of the team had to represent a part of the title. Teenage. Mutant. Ninja. Turtle.

“We needed the ninja guy,” Wise recalls. “We needed the martial arts master. That should be the guy with the Katana, the Japanese sword. That was Leonardo. That’s why Leonardo leads.”

As for the mutant part of the title, Wise was drawn to science fiction. “They needed a gadget guy,” he says. “A kind of nerdy guy who was not the best fighter in the world, but great with a soldering gun. I just randomly picked Donatello.”

“Then we had the weird fact that they’re turtles,” Wise says. “You can’t do a show with this title and not have humor. The title is too goofy. Their names are just too out there.” Raphael became the audience conduit, the sarcastic wisecracker who knows who sees how silly all of this really is. “We needed somebody who sees the absurdity that these are four turtles who have been turned into humans running around the sewers and fighting evil.”

And finally, it was time to create the teenager. “These characters are young and still in a carefree state of life,’ Wise explains. “[Michelangelo] was the Sid Vicious of the Turtles. Sid Vicious couldn’t play or sing but he epitomized punk. Michelangelo epitomizes what the turtles are about.” The other big inspiration for the character? Spicoli from ‘Fast Times at Ridgemont High.’

Wise explains that he followed the “rule of four” when developing the characters, comparing his quartet to various other famous groups. Raphael is Groucho, the wiseacre. Leonardo is Zeppo, the serious one. Donatello is the Chico of the group, the schemer who’s not as smart as he thinks he is. Michelangelo is Harpo, the creature of pure spirit.

Most importantly, Wise emphasizes that each turtle represents a distinctive part of his personality. “I split [my personality] into four sections,” Wise says. “I took my geeky side, my sarcastic side, my fun-loving side and my serious side and put them into these four guys.”

“The stories needed to be serious, for-real action adventure stories with real consequences and real problems and just enough grounding in reality,” he explains. “And the Turtles themselves, by the nature of their personalities, would make it funny.” When asked if he drew any inspiration from the comic, which was intended to be a parody, Wise deadpans “The thing about a parody is that it’s supposed to be funny.”

Although Wise will never deny Eastman and Laird their success, he has complicated feelings toward the Turtles legacy. “[Eastman and laird] created them, but me and Playmates and Fred Wolf made them popular,” he says. “I put a lot of myself into that show. Cowabunga? That was me. The pizzas? That was me. All of the stuff that everyone loves about them? That was me. But everyone else got rich.”

So to sum up: The Mirage comics were terrible and Wise came up with all of the ideas that people love in regards to the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.

Bry
08-07-2014, 10:49 AM
You've gotta be kidding me. The Turtles' personalities and roles weren't established immediately in the comics, but did clearly begin to take shape with issue #2 in October 1984, three years before he show started.

David Wise is full of ****. He did play a key role in adapting them to that series, but to claim he created all of those elements is provably false.

snake
08-07-2014, 11:04 AM
Really?!?!!? I hope Peter or Kevin see this article, Wise is flat out lying.

Andrew NDB
08-07-2014, 11:08 AM
Congratulations, David, you created all of the elements I despise in TMNT. Bravo.

Wentos
08-07-2014, 11:14 AM
What I don't get is how he can possibly think he came up with the turtles' personalities. By Christmas 1985, the Michelangelo micro had come out and the four turtles' personalities had all been clearly established. The cartoon pilot didn't come out until two years after that.

Candy Kappa
08-07-2014, 11:17 AM
Good thing he randomly selected Donnie to be the science/fixer guy, since y'know. That's what he was.

snake
08-07-2014, 11:25 AM
Good thing he randomly selected Donnie to be the science/fixer guy, since y'know. That's what he was.

Or Leo to be the leader! It's amazing how lucky he was when those were the personalities in the comic!

METALHEAD
08-07-2014, 11:26 AM
what a real self proclaiming sh!thead.:tmad:

Candy Kappa
08-07-2014, 11:30 AM
Or Leo to be the leader! It's amazing how lucky he was when those were the personalities in the comic!

It's like, the job was already done for him. :lol:

Discogod
08-07-2014, 11:42 AM
This is my favourite part:

Taking inspiration from Lois Lane, he created the character of plucky reporter April O’Neil to act as a “conduit of information,” the character who could tell the Turtles everything they needed to know about their latest adventure. When it came time to name her, Wise borrowed a name of a completely different character from the comic.

Yeah, totally different - Mirage April was a strong, intelligent, character, not some bimbo damsel in distress...:lol:

ScOULaris
08-07-2014, 12:02 PM
I can understand his frustrations with regard to other people making more money, but other than that I think he might regret some of the stances he's taking in this interview. As far as I'm concerned, the Eastman and Laird (Mirage) TMNT are the Turtles that I love. I thought the animated show was great when I was little, but the kid-friendly versions of the TMNT that spawned from Wise's influence haven't held my interest over the years.

I much prefer the Turtles when they're given a more grounded, serious treatment like in some of the better comics or the first movie.

Hero
08-07-2014, 12:23 PM
Sad to say David Wise has issues.

trikuza
08-07-2014, 12:47 PM
David wise...If you were the creator of facebook. You would have created facebook...

Lou 500
08-07-2014, 12:56 PM
E & L's response to this should be interesting...

Bry
08-07-2014, 01:10 PM
Hey, see this panel from TMNT #2 from 1984? With Leonardo clearly calling the shots, while Donatello is trying to shut down the Mousers with his technical/computer skills?

http://comicattack.net/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/tmnt5.png

Either Wise is losing his marbles or he's lying and using the current media attention from the movie for some self-promotion. Either way I feel bad for him. But I really can't stand someone trying to claim credit for something they didn't do.

Andrew NDB
08-07-2014, 01:12 PM
This is nothing new, though, folks. He's been saying these same things for years, even on the Shellshocked Podcast.

BubblyShell22
08-07-2014, 01:13 PM
Wow. Just wow. I think it's hilarious that he thinks he can claim credit for making the Turtles popular when the comics did it first. Granted, I became a fan because of the cartoon, but to say that the cartoon itself was the only thing that made the franchise popular is stupid.

Ninjinister
08-07-2014, 01:26 PM
Podcast.

This is 2014, brah.

ZariusTwo
08-07-2014, 01:43 PM
So should we add Wise to this thread (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=48594)?:P

MsMarvelDuckie
08-07-2014, 01:46 PM
And to think I had so much respect for the creators of the cartoon. Now? Not so much....

CyberCubed
08-07-2014, 01:55 PM
This is my favourite part:



Yeah, totally different - Mirage April was a strong, intelligent, character, not some bimbo damsel in distress...:lol:

Uh, what? Mirage April was useless most of the time. She didn't really ever do much of anything in Mirage actually.

Mewzard
08-07-2014, 02:00 PM
This is nothing new, though, folks. He's been saying these same things for years, even on the Shellshocked Podcast.

You know, I had almost forgotten he made those claims on the show...until this topic reminded me.

Their personalities and traits started to shine early on. Donatello was the tech guy from issue two. Leonardo was the leader pretty early as well (not as much perhaps as later, but things were building for it). If you had any doubts about who Raphael was in the first three issues, his one-shot certainly helped point out some of his good and bad sides. Michelangelo was probably the last to clearly show his side of things, but it still happened before the Turtles were driven out of New York.

Look, the guy can argue his work making the kid-friendly cartoon helped push the Franchise's popularity to new heights...but not that he created their personalities...or April. Changing April's career doesn't get one credit for her. <_<

I do find myself curious as to what Eastman and Laird will think of this...Well, I have an idea, but I mean exact words.

CyberCubed
08-07-2014, 02:01 PM
I don't see why it matters. He did essentially create the most popular incarnations of them.

Mewzard
08-07-2014, 02:03 PM
I don't see why it matters. He did essentially create the most popular incarnations of them.

Because he's stealing credit for aspects of the series he didn't create? If he wants to argue most popular incarnation creator? Fine.

But that doesn't give him the right to claim he made things that were established in the comic years before the cartoon was made.

Drose18
08-07-2014, 02:11 PM
So david wise made tmnt ******?
Thanks a lot asshole

CyberCubed
08-07-2014, 02:19 PM
Because he's stealing credit for aspects of the series he didn't create? If he wants to argue most popular incarnation creator? Fine.

But that doesn't give him the right to claim he made things that were established in the comic years before the cartoon was made.

True, he should have said his incarnation. Still a lot of what he came up with became staples for the rest of the franchise, like Splinter being Hamato Yoshi, Krang, Bebop and rocksteady, various characters or storylines pulled from the OT, etc.

So much of Nick and IDW's series is pulled from David wise.

TurtleTitan97
08-07-2014, 02:25 PM
Wow, who knew Wise was such a jerk. :trolleye:

shuriken
08-07-2014, 02:34 PM
Congratulations, David, you created all of the elements I despise in TMNT. Bravo.

:lol:

Someone sounds bitter.

Tazi
08-07-2014, 02:35 PM
he is actually not that wise...



megalol

Sanjuro
08-07-2014, 02:44 PM
I guess I'm not understanding the hatred here. He isn't off base here or anything, and he is one of the primary reasons the franchise is where it's at to this point in time.

Bry
08-07-2014, 02:57 PM
Also there's this:

“The [original 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles'] five part miniseries ends with the Turtles having to battle an alien armada that is coming through a gigantic black hole dimensional portal being projected in the sky directly above New York City. This dimensional portal projector has created a giant opening in the sky, with a whole alien armada coming through it. That’s what the turtles are facing. The way to stop it is to shut down the machine that’s generating the portal. All I have to say is: you’re welcome Joss Whedon!”

Man, what is this dude talking about? That's not how it happened at all. The last episode of the miniseries was mostly about the Turtles fighting a giant Krang, with the aliens taking about two steps through the Technodrome's control room portal at the very end of the episode before being sucked right back through in when Donatello rewires the thing.

It's funny how he seems to consistently "mix up" his details in a way that benefits his own image though, huh?

Sanjuro
08-07-2014, 03:02 PM
"There’s a sardonic humor to Wise that’s difficult to translate into print."

I think most of you are missing this point. Everything I've heard from him verbally, he is aware of the franchise's past and present, but he isn't a walking encyclopedia.

Powder
08-07-2014, 03:06 PM
What point? He takes credit for the turtles' personalities & said they had none in the comics. That's all bull.

Bry
08-07-2014, 03:07 PM
He's making specific claims that very provably aren't true, though. If he's joking, he should have clarified that. That doesn't seem to be the case.

Mewzard
08-07-2014, 03:09 PM
I guess I'm not understanding the hatred here. He isn't off base here or anything, and he is one of the primary reasons the franchise is where it's at to this point in time.

He's off base in that he claimed credit for things created in the comic stories before he started his work on the series.

I have no issue for the man taking credit for what he did on the show or that the cartoon he worked on helped increase the popularity of the franchise.

But he kinda talks crap about the comics while also claiming he came up with personality traits that predate his work. Kinda messed up.

Sanjuro
08-07-2014, 03:10 PM
He's making specific claims that very provably aren't true, though. If he's joking, he should have clarified that. That doesn't seem to be the case.

He wasn't conducting the interview or writing the article, so it's common sense that wouldn't come across like that.

Sanjuro
08-07-2014, 03:11 PM
What point? He takes credit for the turtles' personalities & said they had none in the comics. That's all bull.

“In the comics, you can’t tell one turtle from another,” Wise recalls saying to Wolf. “Even when they’re speaking they have no distinctive voices or characterizations.” Wolf already had that covered: they were going to give them color-coded masks and belts engraved with their initials. Wise was not satisfied.


That's fairly accurate. To that point, visually and verbally the turtles did not have wildly different and vivid personalities.

Dirty Blond
08-07-2014, 03:17 PM
LOL, all those characters are just archetypes, and even E&L did some borrowing here and there.

Cryomancer
08-07-2014, 04:35 PM
True, he should have said his incarnation. Still a lot of what he came up with became staples for the rest of the franchise, like Splinter being Hamato Yoshi, Krang, Bebop and rocksteady, various characters or storylines pulled from the OT, etc.

So much of Nick and IDW's series is pulled from David wise.

Pretty sure Bebop and Rocksteady were already invented by Playmates before the mini series writing began. The Visual History book certainly seems to state this, at least. Krang is obviously based on the Utroms. Splinter as Yoshi is the obvious route to go when you want to clean up the origin for a kid's show.

Bry
08-07-2014, 04:37 PM
Pretty sure Bebop and Rocksteady were already invented by Playmates before the mini series writing began. The Visual History book certainly seems to state this, at least. Krang is obviously based on the Utroms. Splinter as Yoshi is the obvious route to go when you want to clean up the origin for a kid's show.

I believe Eastman and Laird designed them for the toyline. Wise probably gave them their personalities, so he can definitely claim credit for that. But it still counts as a collaboration.

Candy Kappa
08-07-2014, 04:38 PM
B&R and fly (Baxter) mutant was iirc designed by Eastman & Laird early on for playmates.

Werecat
08-07-2014, 04:41 PM
David wise...If you were the creator of facebook. You would have created facebook...

Nice comeback lol

Werecat
08-07-2014, 05:00 PM
I don't see why it matters. He did essentially create the most popular incarnations of them.
The comic book was popular too, it out sold all the other comics. The cartoon was popular the first season but steadily declined to the point were the toy line was the only thing that kept it alive. The 1987 cartoon was good, I enjoyed it lots, but the rest of the seasons were just rehashed story lines.


That's fairly accurate. To that point, visually and verbally the turtles did not have wildly different and vivid personalities.
What are you talking aboot!?

The turtle bros did have distinct personalities in the original comic. Their personalities were described in the first issue through words and actions. Raphael was a bruiser who had the tendency to go berserk. Raphael's impulsive aggressiveness was contrasted by Donatello's peacefulness. Leonardo was spiritual, obedient, and the leader of the group. Michelangelo was the clown of the group. All of them trained intensively, not just Leonardo. Michelangelo and Raphael were noted as peeps who sparred endlessly. There is tons of personality in the original comic. You're just deluding yourself to make sense of the cray cray guy in the article.

Edit: I dunno how to make this into one post. Can someone else do it. Purdy please!

joe-eyeball
08-07-2014, 05:37 PM
He may have created new character elements of the turtles but thats it. If Kevin and Pete dont create the entire frickin foundation of turtles then Mr. Wise would never have his so called claim to fame. What a douche!!!

Candy Kappa
08-07-2014, 05:57 PM
Let's do Donnie, since Wise says he made him the tech guy at random.

In the second issue we can see on the first splash page he is tinkering with something that looks like a circuit board. And he is the one with April working on the computer stopping the Mourser.

Wentos
08-07-2014, 06:12 PM
Let's do Donnie, since Wise says he made him the tech guy at random.

In the second issue we can see on the first splash page he is tinkering with something that looks like a circuit board. And he is the one with April working on the computer stopping the Mourser.

Yeah, that's probably the most blatant example of him just making things up.

You can definitely argue that Wise took the characterization that was in the Mirage comics and amplified it to make each turtle more unique, but to say that he created their personalities wholesale is flat-out lying.

I also really resent the idea that the Mirage comics were terrible and Wise somehow "rescued" the concept. The guy has an ego the size of Pluto.

shuriken
08-07-2014, 06:12 PM
Let's do Donnie, since Wise says he made him the tech guy at random.

In the second issue we can see on the first splash page he is tinkering with something that looks like a circuit board. And he is the one with April working on the computer stopping the Mourser.

And this was 3 years before the toon right?
Leo was was always clearly the leader, and Donnie was clearly the techie.
Mikey and Raph were the most different from their cartoon counterparts.
Raph although sarcastic, was more of a hothead and bruiser than he ever was in the OT. He also had some decent mechanic skills.
Mikey was always the most mellow of the bunch, but he did have some impulsive traits that caused some trouble(like when they were captured by the triceratons HE was the one that fought them first). In the toon he was pretty much Spicoli that could fight and loved pizza.

ssjup81
08-07-2014, 08:26 PM
It seems that Wise skimmed the first few issues if the comic to make such statements, like how he chose Leo as the leader and Donny as the science guy.This is my favourite part:



Yeah, totally different - Mirage April was a strong, intelligent, character, not some bimbo damsel in distress...:lol:She wasn't a bimbo. Bimbos tend to be portrayed as airheads and dumb. OT April got in trouble because she was doing her job. The later red sky seasons she calmed down a lot. I also don't consider her a damsel in distress because she was the type to try and fight back and take no mess, but she wasn't a trained fighter. That was the turtles' specialty.

Sanjuro
08-07-2014, 08:27 PM
It seems that Wise skimmed the first few issues if the comic to make such statements, like how he chose Leo as the leader and Donny as the science guy.

He did. He admitted to having read the source material prior to the job. The Turtle Power documentary and various interviews confirm this.

ssjup81
08-07-2014, 08:38 PM
He did. He admitted to having read the source material prior to the job. The Turtle Power documentary and various interviews confirm this.I know, I saw it, but I question that. Skimming isn't reading. It's just glimpsing over a few things. To make those statements, I wonder if he actually did thoroughly read them.

Desslok
08-07-2014, 08:57 PM
I've always appreciated David Wise's contributions to the TMNT, but in this interview he comes off kind of... ungrateful. This doesn't change my feelings towards his work but it does make it seem that Mr. Wise doesn't truly appreciate the turtles at large. He kind of describes them as some sort of headache he had to sort out at work.

Bry
08-07-2014, 09:24 PM
Listen. Nobody's trying to claim that David Wise didn't have a big part in the impact and development of the franchise. He did, and I acknowledge and respect that. And he isn't denied his due credit. But he is making claims here that are objectively, provably untrue. The Turtles' personalities and roles did pre-date his work on the cartoon. He took those qualities and made them more broad/one-dimensional and cartoon-appropriate, sure, but he was absolutely working from the characters as Kevin and Peter wrote them as their basis. To claim he created them all by himself, and that he based them on aspects of himself, is ludicrous. It's just not true.

And how about this part?

Taking inspiration from Lois Lane, he created the character of plucky reporter April O’Neil to act as a “conduit of information,” the character who could tell the Turtles everything they needed to know about their latest adventure. When it came time to name her, Wise borrowed a name of a completely different character from the comic. And her signature hair and jumpsuit? Wise borrowed that from the character of Fujiko Mine, a thief who occasionally posed as a news reporter on the anime ‘Lupine III.’

Sure. And in no way did you just take her outfit from her first appearance in the comic and give it a palette-swap to make it distinct from the other characters' signature colours:

http://img3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130406071716/tmnt/images/2/20/2372969-mirage_april_6.jpg

Actually, the colour versions were first published at the end of 1986, so it's possible there'd been some early work done on the show at that point. In that case, it's possible he had no colour version to go on and just assigned her yellow, with the overall "look" firmly based on that original character design from Eastman and Laird.

Galactus
08-07-2014, 09:41 PM
I don't doubt that David Wise believes what he's saying and that he remembers it the way he's describing but it's pretty much baloney and easily dis proven.

The first issue or Mirage's TMNT does have the turtles as dark avenger types with no distinguishing personalities save perhaps stating that Raphael didn't like living underground as much as his brothers. However the second issue did give them the turtles the individual personalities that have become synonymous with the characters from the very first pages.

http://i41.photobucket.com/albums/e280/klankandorbis/8222aaf1-cfa1-4c2b-8b3d-4fb4ac92a0a2_zpsb2172221.jpg

And displayed throughout the story when Donatello uses knowledge of things technical and Leonardo leads the the others.

http://i41.photobucket.com/albums/e280/klankandorbis/2bbdb880-445b-46e3-a055-e77382d467fd_zpsdd1779e4.png

Did Wise not pick up on this? Is anyone seriously suggesting he came up with the very same personality types for each specific turtle by pure coincidence?

In fact it seems that Wise picked up on a very specific personality trait. It seems that in addition to being the fun loving turtle Michelangelo was initially characterized as being almost as easy to lose his temper as Raphael. Now this would not be the case as the comic developed but think back to the animated series second episode "Enter the Shredder" were in training Michelangelo gets angry while practicing and is told by the others that he needs to learn to stay cool. It's a strange scene given the overall laid back characterization of the character but doesn't its inclusion make more sense now?

In fact quite a lot is culled from those early Mirage issues. A scene from the third episode of the show "A Thing About Rats" had Michelangelo using a manriki gusari and proclaiming himself the master of it. It's strange in the show to see the turtles weapons other than their signature ones until you see in #9 of the comic series a pre-teen Mike is shown practicing with that same weapon.

http://i41.photobucket.com/albums/e280/klankandorbis/bf4d10b4-e884-4472-8e17-0865bdd4b7d8_zps1798fcea.jpg

Doesn't the portal to another dimension in Donatello Micro Series #1 look like a smaller version of the Technodrome portal? Both inspired by Kirby.

http://i41.photobucket.com/albums/e280/klankandorbis/eba9da23-6013-4790-a3f5-931c4209db01_zps0423304e.png

Militaristic alien baddlies using flying cars? Who whould thunk it?

http://i41.photobucket.com/albums/e280/klankandorbis/eaf037c7-d3cd-4b17-a81c-3b184aa42a02_zps38424701.png

One thing that does strike me as very odd is the idea that the turtles anatomy was such a problem for the animators with their oversized limbs and such. You'd think working in the industry would have been aware that comic artists often defied realistic anatomy. Look at Jack Kirby when he took off at Marvel.

However Eastman and Laird continued to develop their art and the designs developed naturally with more "realistic" proportions and that's the kicker as the Fred Wolf turtles are the closest thing to those Eastman and Laird designs in animation we've ever had just with belt buckles and a color swap. Even the dark style of the environments was present, you can really see it in the visuals of the theme song.

http://i41.photobucket.com/albums/e280/klankandorbis/56a9acc5-e5e5-4ee1-8af6-c977e48af53e_zps723fbdf5.jpg

We can give him pizza and surfer slang though.

Sanjuro
08-07-2014, 09:44 PM
Wise credited Jack Kirby directly for elements of the show you just mentioned.

Galactus
08-07-2014, 09:54 PM
Wise credited Jack Kirby directly for elements of the show you just mentioned.

Certainly not all of them because Kirby was just one of the influences on the comic and the idea that Wise leapfrogged over the Eastman and Laird material and got eerily similar results is ridiculous.

This is only a fraction of the similarities between the comics and the show are way to much for him so casually dismiss it.

Leo656
08-07-2014, 09:55 PM
Just to be fair, I'm reasonably certain the guys who did the "Superman" radio show in the 40s never tried to proclaim "creation" or "ownership" of the character just because they gave him a literal voice, and added Kryptonite and "Up, Up, and Away" into the mythology. By Wise's logic, they could've. Far as I know, they never did. But it's the exact same thing; some of the most recognizable pieces of a pre-existing pop culture mythology came from a secondary source. Alright. That's expansion, though, not exactly "creation" or "ownership".

Maybe he could have gotten a few extra bucks for it along the way, but, again, I'unno if the Superman radio guys ever did, either. Fair? I'unno, there's lawyers for that. Wise does come off more than a little bitter, though, and his claims are a stretch.

Wentos
08-07-2014, 09:59 PM
Listen. Nobody's trying to claim that David Wise didn't have a big part in the impact and development of the franchise. He did, and I acknowledge and respect that. And he isn't denied his due credit. But he is making claims here that are objectively, provably untrue. The Turtles' personalities and roles did pre-date his work on the cartoon. He took those qualities and made them more broad/one-dimensional and cartoon-appropriate, sure, but he was absolutely working from the characters as Kevin and Peter wrote them as their basis. To claim he created them all by himself, and that he based them on aspects of himself, is ludicrous. It's just not true.

Couldn't have said it better. Wise obviously deserves a lot of credit for taking a very dark/violent comic and successfully marketing it towards kids. He's a huge reason why TMNT became and continues to be a household name. But he's exaggerating his role in the creation of TMNT lore in this article to the point of outright lying.

(I laughed when I read the part about Fujiko, when April was literally wearing a jumpsuit in her first appearance in the comics.)

Cryomancer
08-07-2014, 10:33 PM
To me this comes off less as a "I AM THE CREATOR" and more like "I did the groundwork and gruntwork for the popular adaptation for hire and am annoyed that I am not super rich". Sure he did a lot of stuff for the first show, and sure the first show is most likely the incarnation of TMNT with the most cultural and financial impact, but I'm sure he got a paycheck for it back then. Presumably Playmates hired him to do this job and he did it and got paid and now decades later he's annoyed that he isn't famous/rich for it.

hitmonkey
08-07-2014, 10:42 PM
I guess I'm not understanding the hatred here. He isn't off base here or anything, and he is one of the primary reasons the franchise is where it's at to this point in time.

He's completely off base. This would be like Christopher Nolan claiming to have created Batman.

Bry
08-07-2014, 10:56 PM
He's completely off base. This would be like Christopher Nolan claiming to have created Batman.

Ehh, he'd have almost as much claim as Bob Kane.

:P

Allio
08-07-2014, 11:06 PM
great, it's Ken Penders 2.0

pennydreadful
08-07-2014, 11:44 PM
David Wise made a notable and significant contribution to the Turtles franchise, but his comments could potentially be interpreted as being somewhat egotistical. Tone is hard to translate via text, so potentially he could've been making these comments in a more tongue-in-cheek context than it's coming off as. Or potentially, he is in fact taking more credit than he is due.

In the meantime - can't we all just get along?

http://uploads.neatorama.com/images/posts/882/56/56882/1356867920-0.jpg

There's no need to be hostile or name-calling. The mods shouldn't have to jump in every time there's a disagreement - you're all grown-ups (or at least old enough to know better) and you should know how to behave appropriately in the forums. Two wrongs don't make a right - if someone's annoying you enough that you're starting to see red when you reply, put them on ignore until the urge to strangle them has passed. ;)

snake
08-07-2014, 11:46 PM
great, it's Ken Penders 2.0

Ken Penders? Who?

Sanjuro
08-08-2014, 02:30 AM
He's completely off base. This would be like Christopher Nolan claiming to have created Batman.

He isn't completely off base. Your comparison actually works in a way.

If Eastman and Laird came out claiming to be the sole reason that the TMNT are popular, they would basically fall into the Bob Kane category unfortunately.

Whatswiththeheadbands?
08-08-2014, 04:48 AM
As the show moved through development, Wise sat down to transform the black and white parodies from the original comic book into characters who could sustain an entire cartoon series. His conclusion was simple: each member of the team had to represent a part of the title. Teenage. Mutant. Ninja. Turtle.

“We needed the ninja guy,” Wise recalls. “We needed the martial arts master. That should be the guy with the Katana, the Japanese sword. That was Leonardo. That’s why Leonardo leads.”

As for the mutant part of the title, Wise was drawn to science fiction. “They needed a gadget guy,” he says. “A kind of nerdy guy who was not the best fighter in the world, but great with a soldering gun. I just randomly picked Donatello.”

“Then we had the weird fact that they’re turtles,” Wise says. “You can’t do a show with this title and not have humor. The title is too goofy. Their names are just too out there.” Raphael became the audience conduit, the sarcastic wisecracker who knows who sees how silly all of this really is. “We needed somebody who sees the absurdity that these are four turtles who have been turned into humans running around the sewers and fighting evil.”

And finally, it was time to create the teenager. “These characters are young and still in a carefree state of life,’ Wise explains. “[Michelangelo] was the Sid Vicious of the Turtles. Sid Vicious couldn’t play or sing but he epitomized punk. Michelangelo epitomizes what the turtles are about.” The other big inspiration for the character? Spicoli from ‘Fast Times at Ridgemont High.’

So What he is Basicly saying is he invented the Turtles' Personalities.

Netkeeper
08-08-2014, 05:01 AM
Ken Penders? Who?
Ken Penders used to do art/writing for the Archie Sonic comic. He tried to claim copyright on the characters he created for the comic himself and when he left [or got fired, I can't remember which], he tried to take the rights with him, and the whole thing was even taken to court [which, IIRC, the judge didn't even take seriously because this **** is ****ing ridiculous] but ultimately ended in some of the most important characters in the comic being rendered unusable except in Penders' own awful works.

He also tried to claim that Sonic Chronicles was infringing on his copyright because Shade looked like Julie-Su to him.

He's full of ****.

Type 97 Chi-ha
08-08-2014, 06:29 AM
He isn't completely off base. Your comparison actually works in a way.

If Eastman and Laird came out claiming to be the sole reason that the TMNT are popular, they would basically fall into the Bob Kane category unfortunately.

The creators of the Superman character lived in poverty through their lives when they asked for a raised from their employer DC Comics. However badly they were treated, they may have created the character but are not wholly responsible for Superman's being a household name.

I do have the book Batman And Me by Bob Kane, and I cannot verify its accuracy. But practically every comic I've seen with Batman in it features the line "Created By Bob Kane" on it.

Sanjuro
08-08-2014, 09:39 AM
The creators of the Superman character lived in poverty through their lives when they asked for a raised from their employer DC Comics. However badly they were treated, they may have created the character but are not wholly responsible for Superman's being a household name.

I do have the book Batman And Me by Bob Kane, and I cannot verify its accuracy. But practically every comic I've seen with Batman in it features the line "Created By Bob Kane" on it.

Bob Kane has a very interesting dirty history. I still give him the credit he is due, but you have your Adams, Aparo, Miller who added elements to the character's depth over the years. I would put Wise in that type of category.

Leo656
08-08-2014, 01:04 PM
Bill Finger had as much and probably (read: definitely) more to do with creating Batman than Bob Kane did. Pretty much everyone in the industry not named "Bob Kane" admits that. All Kane did was pretty much draw it and put his name on it. Bill came up with most of the concept ideas and wrote the earliest scripts. Kane didn't even draw it for very long before quickly adopting the then-industry standard of having a team of people draw ALL the books, while he just rubber-stamped his name on it. Sadly, Finger didn't really get much credit for any of it until after he was dead, which is further proof that having a good PR guy is more important than what you actually contribute.

"Batman created by Bob Kane" is kind of a long-running joke. Guy did as little as you could possibly do for such an inordinate amount of credit.

Refractive Reflections
08-08-2014, 01:05 PM
So I read the article closely to see where all of this emotion was coming from, and I found these parts:


“I’m always asked by fans who Patti Howeth is,” Wise cracks. “She’s the person who didn’t write the five part pilot!”

Later on, Wise would learn that he was not the first choice for the ‘Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles’ job. Another respected animation writer was approached first, but he was just about to move onto sitcoms. Having enjoyed Wise’s work at Marvel productions, he recommended him to Fred Wolf and Rudy Zamora Jr.

That writer? Chuck Lorre, who would go onto create ‘Two and a Half Men’ and ‘The Big Bang Theory.’ But Lorre’s unexpected involvement in the series doesn’t end there.

“In the original opening credits, there are some spoken words that go ‘We’re the world’s most fearsome fighting team!’ and ‘We’re really hip,’” Wise says. “That’s Chuck Lorre speaking those lines. His geek cred runs strong!”




But if you’re wondering if David Wise is currently bathing, Scrooge McDuck-style, in his pool of ‘Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles’ money, the answer is no.

“It was a job,” he explains. “I saw no benefits from it. I had no licensing money. The more successful it was, the more scripts I had to write. For years, that covered my bills … It was nice to see it successful, but there was the discomfort of knowing that you’re the one guy who’s not getting rich. I should have created my own thing.”

Although Wise will never deny Eastman and Laird their success, he has complicated feelings toward the Turtles legacy. “[Eastman and laird] created them, but me and Playmates and Fred Wolf made them popular,” he says. “I put a lot of myself into that show. Cowabunga? That was me. The pizzas? That was me. All of the stuff that everyone loves about them? That was me. But everyone else got rich.”

There’s a sardonic humor to Wise that’s difficult to translate into print. He insists that he’s not bitter. He’s proud of his work and the impact it’s had on people. He just wishes that he was getting paid. However, one lingering sore point is the live-action 1990 movie. Well, more specifically, the film’s poster. “It shows [the Turtles] coming out of the sewers and it says ‘Hey dude, this is no cartoon.’ Well, dude, you wouldn’t be saying dude if I hadn’t started saying that in the cartoon. That really pissed me off.”


According to this article, it's difficult to believe he's not "bitter" ("He insists that he's not bitter") but just having "discomfort" ("...but there was a discomfort of knowing you're not the one guy who's not getting rich.") when he's really stretching his claims here (with the Mirage Turtles not having distinct personalities). I think the bitterness is displaced on the wrong people (the Mirage comics, the public's perception) when it should be directed more toward the entertainment industry (having no licensing money from the series; aka: a bigger piece of the pie) and Playmates (the garbage catapult reference of how Wise "flipped out" over Playmates wanting it incorporated into the cartoon and he made sure it malfunctioned in the cartoon).

I don't know if Wise fully knows that the public does consider his influence a big part of the OT's and the franchise's success (as with the voice actors and animation teams) as a whole, since the general public has made the OT versions of the Turtles as the iconic figures of pop culture, and not the comic versions. From my perspective, it seems that the business executives who were handling the franchise didn't give Wise a more deserved, bigger piece of franchise's success. This seems to be synonymous with others who were a part of the OT's franchise, in not getting a more fair portion of the franchise's success. A couple examples are with Chuck Lorre not getting songwriting credit for the OT theme, and (I'm not too sure about this) I think it's rumored that Rob Paulsen left the series allegedly after season 9 because of the disputes about pay.

This kind of shady business practice isn't too surprising because it's found in the music industry as well where new, upcoming songwriters have to compromise in removing writing/royalty credit from their work, just so they can have it accepted by a major popular recording artist for a small, one-time flat amount (to have their name out there in the business), only to discover that it becomes massively successful and not getting a dime of that success.

On the outside of the OT franchise, didn't Laird mention he had a huge amount of legal headaches in dealing with the businesses commercializing the franchise too, and they had wanted to claim ownership of TMNT through the OT's success? (I think in a thread somewhere here, didn't Laird said he had to legally battle over the details?)

So it seems that the "blame" or bitterness should be toward the business executives since they were claiming they "created" Ninja Turtles toward Eastman and Laird (by using the concept and ideas that the OT crew had produced), but yet at the same time within the OT franchise, the business executives weren't fairly paying or giving credit to the OT crew who were making it successful in the mainstream.

It seems like big business was trying to shortchange everyone who was creatively involved and responsible with the franchise's success as a whole.

neatoman
08-08-2014, 01:39 PM
The guy who recycled the same scripts over and over again, expresses distaste of the material he's adapting, takes credit wherever none is given and inflates it until the truth comes out, turns out to be a lying piece of crap? What a twist!

Prowler
08-08-2014, 02:09 PM
Can't blame Wise for feeling like he deserves more recognition(as in "money") for his contributions to the FW series, but it's pretty low to claim credit for things you have not created or been responsible for. I'm guessing he has some score to settle with Laird and Eastman after all these years.

Anyway, he wrote the best episodes of the series, but then again, he wrote the most episodes out of all the writers of the show. The others didn't write more than 10-15 each while Wise must have written 50 or more. And yea, he did recycle some plots, which was a bit annoying but I can forgive him for that.

I've also liked some of the episodes written by the guy who wrote "Shredderville" whose name I've forgotten.

John Pannozzi
08-08-2014, 02:58 PM
I don't know if this was already mentioned in this thread, but I'll say it anyway. You know when Fred Wolf sued Eastman and Laird, claiming he and his studio came up with concepts like the Turtles living in the sewer and April wearing a jumpsuit. This is is like that.