View Full Version : IDW, Archie or Mirage?
The Turtle Terminator
08-17-2014, 03:15 PM
Do you like IDW or Mirage better? Id have to pick IDW. The characters are perfect and some of the mini series are pretty sci fi epic
Red Robin
08-17-2014, 03:30 PM
I am missing Image here.
But I have to go with Mirage on this one.
The No-Kill-Policy of IDW is just blocking a more mature character for this series. And there are many points so far when some adult aspects would have great if they were included to the series.
I mean especially the City Fall-Ending. They all walk away with bloody noses? After such a big war? Really?
I love all of them, but overall Mirage was much better with adult topics, that IDW would not dare to explore. Archie had some of that, but the first half of their run wasn't really good. On the other hand Mirage also had a lot of goofy/boring/filler stuff.
I actually like more % of the IDW run then the Mirage one, but yet the best Mirage stories are still better then best IDW stories. Well, SHotFC is on the same level, and the Shredder micro, but Mirage still has more stories on that level.
Well, okay, it's Mirage.
CyberCubed
08-17-2014, 03:55 PM
They're all good.
Although I doubt the very best Mirage stories, like Return to New York or City at War, will ever be topped. However IDW is better than a lot of the other Mirage stories.
Redeemer
08-17-2014, 04:06 PM
I love all of them, but overall Mirage was much better with adult topics, that IDW would not dare to explore. Archie had some of that, but the first half of their run wasn't really good. On the other hand Mirage also had a lot of goofy/boring/filler stuff.
I actually like more % of the IDW run then the Mirage one, but yet the best Mirage stories are still better then best IDW stories. Well, SHotFC is on the same level, and the Shredder micro, but Mirage still has more stories on that level.
I agree with most your post except for the IDW "No Kill" Policy. Did not the head of the Savanti Ninja get his hand cut off and then killed by shredder????
I think IDW tries to stay away from killing unless its to advance the story.
Also I agree about IDW being more consistent quality stories, but Mirage has the top stories, except for Secret History of The Foot Clan, that is the only story that is on the same level as Return to NY or Leonardo micro ect...
I don't mind every major character surviving City Fall. It's still better then retconning or reviving them later.
I wanna see around issue #100, if they gonna build Lazarus Pits from Ooze... :lol:
Icegaze
08-17-2014, 04:52 PM
IDW by quite a distance.
Story-telling, artwork (Santolouco and Cory Smith especially) and the in-world setup.
Mirage was good for the first volume and City at War arc but aside those, I wasn't really that engrossed in the lore.
Not familiar with Archie nor Image.
CyberCubed
08-17-2014, 05:48 PM
Pretty sure the no-kill policy is only for the Turtles and Splinter. We saw Shredder kill the Savate leader, as well as Yoshi's sons in ancient Japan.
Although it is kinda silly that Leo and Raph have bladed weapons yet when they fight the Foot Soldiers they never get stabbed or sliced. The cartoons can't do this because the cartoons are aimed at kids, but, "Leo and Raph no stabby" when they're fighting hordes of Foot Soldiers doesn't make sense in the comic world.
Its not a big deal for me, but it should be something that's shown in the future. It doesn't even have to be violent, just minor slashes with the Foot on the floor with some blood on them.
TigerClaw
08-17-2014, 06:05 PM
I have to go with Archies, It was based on the 1987 series, But went on a different direction, and I loved the Characters and Stories that were in that Comic.
Redeemer
08-17-2014, 06:41 PM
I have to go with Archies, It was based on the 1987 series, But went on a different direction, and I loved the Characters and Stories that were in that Comic.
This is one reason I cannot vote, I have read only IDW and the first 20 issues + All of the Eastmen and Laird Hard Covers.
I have not read most Mirage or Tales, Image, or Archie
I wish IDW would release a good quality hardcover of Archie and the rest of Mirage.
Powder
08-17-2014, 07:14 PM
Mirage. It's not even close.
But don't go thinkin' I don't love the IDW books. :trazz:
& Archie too, of course!
Jester
08-17-2014, 07:22 PM
Need to read more Mirage. Loved Archie as a kid and it still had a place in my heart. Like the IDW series, but wouldn't call it my favorite. Probably Archie.
Cipher
08-17-2014, 10:13 PM
Mirage by heads and shoulders. It's just a very different kind of series -- one that IDW can't be just by virtue of not being an independent book.
I've been hot and cold on IDW but upon a recent re-read, I have a lot more respect for it now. It's probably second, with Adventures, as much as I'm fond of its later portions and think it hits some genuinely stellar points, taking a necessary third. It's great for what it is, but it can't get around the fact that it has certain limitations that come with being a children's series and occasional toy-shilling device. Not to take anything away from Murphy, Mitchroney and Allan.
Casey
08-17-2014, 10:19 PM
They're all good.
Although I doubt the very best Mirage stories, like Return to New York or City at War, will ever be topped. However IDW is better than a lot of the other Mirage stories.
Agreeing with CyberCubed for once.
CyberCubed
08-17-2014, 10:27 PM
It's great for what it is, but it can't get around the fact that it has certain limitations that come with being a children's series and occasional toy-shilling device. Not to take anything away from Murphy, Mitchroney and Allan.
But the toy shilling in Archie is the best part. To see characters who got far too little or no screentime in the original cartoon get focus in the comics was great. Characters like Wingnut/Screwlose and Mondo Gecko wouldn't have been remembered half as much as they were if it weren't for the comics. Let alone seeing a proper Man Ray, Tattoo, Hothead, etc.
Archie's low-point was all of Murphy's eco-preaching, but the rest holds up very well.
thebrownranger
08-17-2014, 11:12 PM
Mirage is my #1 without a doubt. I haven't read Archie as much as Mirage, but I do love it still. I like IDW too, but I'm usually on and off about it.
snake
08-17-2014, 11:31 PM
IDW, but Archie and Mirage are right by it.
Cipher
08-18-2014, 12:12 AM
But the toy shilling in Archie is the best part. To see characters who got far too little or no screentime in the original cartoon get focus in the comics was great. Characters like Wingnut/Screwlose and Mondo Gecko wouldn't have been remembered half as much as they were if it weren't for the comics. Let alone seeing a proper Man Ray, Tattoo, Hothead, etc.
No, that's fine; it's part of the reason I enjoy it too. It just doesn't do anything to make it easier to recommend to those without nostalgia for it, and doesn't do a lot for the storytelling on its own.
Again, it had to have those constraints, and it's amazing what the creative team managed to turn it into. It's ten times better than it has any right to be, and is probably the best of the toy-shilling versions of TMNT.
ctt4lfecw
08-18-2014, 05:49 AM
As of now, I am enjoying IDW very much. They give me everything I want in a TMNT comic.
Panda_Kahn_fan
08-18-2014, 08:12 AM
In my opinion, Mirage is awesome with; The Fugitiod/utrom arc, Return to New york, City at War, the river, and the King Komodo arc from the image run. The rest is a horrid mess of magic pencils and characters being drawings, Cyborg turtles, pointless superhero knockoffs, and stories that don't really go anywhere.
I'll take IDW, thanks.:)
Icegaze
08-18-2014, 08:19 AM
In my opinion, Mirage is awesome with; The Fugitiod/utrom arc, Return to New york, City at War, the river, and the King Komodo arc from the image run. The rest is a horrid mess of magic pencils and characters being drawings, Cyborg turtles, pointless superhero knockoffs, and stories that don't really go anywhere.
I'll take IDW, thanks.:)
Agreed. I am seeing many nostalgic fans on this thread. From my standpoint, IDW is miles ahead of Mirage.
Cipher
08-18-2014, 05:06 PM
Agreed. I am seeing many nostalgic fans on this thread. From my standpoint, IDW is miles ahead of Mirage.
It has nothing to do with nostalgia, and I revisit the Mirage content fairly often. No rose-colored glasses here; some of it is rough.
But even the most underwhelming issues of Tales can go places IDW never could. It's not everyone's cup of tea. Mirage is a strange indie series that goes wherever its creators want it to, sometimes being tongue-in-cheek, a lot of times just being weird and somber and adult. IDW is a serialized action comic.
Like, even the goofy Dan Berger-written Tales Vol. 2 #8 starts off with this over-the-top gem from Leatherhead: "Beware! For the best-laid plans of mice and mutants often go awry! Those of us who traverse this world of sorrow know little of what the gaping maws of fate shall devour!"
No IDW issues is ever going to start with a character discussing "this world of sorrow." But it's assumed in Mirage, regardless of whatever silly cyborgs or aliens they find themselves encountering that issue (and that sort of pulp-inspired randomness is part of their universe), that it's the general state of things.
Powder
08-18-2014, 06:37 PM
In my opinion, Mirage is awesome with; The Fugitiod/utrom arc, Return to New york, City at War, the river, and the King Komodo arc from the image run. The rest is a horrid mess of magic pencils and characters being drawings, Cyborg turtles, pointless superhero knockoffs, and stories that don't really go anywhere.
I'll take IDW, thanks.:)
Leave this earth.
CyberCubed
08-18-2014, 07:45 PM
IDW is best compared with the 4kids cartoon. IDW really feels like what the 4kids show would have been had Peter Laird allowed them to use 80's cartoon characters like Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady.
IDW Krang is almost exactly like Ch'rell, and everything else that happens in IDW mirrors the 4kids series in terms of tone and pacing.
Redeemer
08-18-2014, 07:59 PM
In my opinion, Mirage is awesome with; The Fugitiod/utrom arc, Return to New york, City at War, the river, and the King Komodo arc from the image run. The rest is a horrid mess of magic pencils and characters being drawings, Cyborg turtles, pointless superhero knockoffs, and stories that don't really go anywhere.
I'll take IDW, thanks.:)
Everyone talks about how great and consistent Mirage is, but I will just have to read it myself to find out :D
IDW is best compared with the 4kids cartoon. IDW really feels like what the 4kids show would have been had Peter Laird allowed them to use 80's cartoon characters like Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady.
IDW Krang is almost exactly like Ch'rell, and everything else that happens in IDW mirrors the 4kids series in terms of tone and pacing.
Pretty good comparison. I feel like the turtles themselves are actually darker in 2k3 than Mirage. Anyone else thinks so???
Holy crap Mirage just got a shot in the arm!!!!! lol IDW was in the lead, but now Mirage is by far!!!!
TigerClaw
08-18-2014, 08:17 PM
Speaking of IDW, An issue of the TMNT comic, was featured in an article on ComicVine for Best Battles in New Comics: 8/15/14, It features a battle between the Shredder and Krang
http://www.comicvine.com/articles/best-battles-in-new-comics-8-15-14/1100-149522/
But what caught my attention was, That there's a new character called Bludgeon, a Mutant Shark, When I saw that, I replied to a post on Twitter asking the question why they didn't use Armaggon, Which got retweeted by the Turtle Power Podcast, And this was the response.
https://twitter.com/TMNTPodcast/status/501470102798495744
@TMNTPodcast
@thedisastrix MT @TigerClaw305: Interesting, so the Comic has a mutant name Bludgeon? Whatever happen to Armaggon? Couldnt use him?
@thedisastrix
@TMNTPodcast @TigerClaw305 Was originally written as Armaggon, but that character has a unique personality and setting that we won't use.
@thedisastrix
@TMNTPodcast @TigerClaw305 So made sense just to make it a new character. Much the same as with Alopex/Ninjara.
Redeemer
08-18-2014, 08:33 PM
Speaking of IDW, An issue of the TMNT comic, was featured in an article on ComicVine for Best Battles in New Comics: 8/15/14, It features a battle between the Shredder and Krang
http://www.comicvine.com/articles/best-battles-in-new-comics-8-15-14/1100-149522/
But what caught my attention was, That there's a new character called Bludgeon, a Mutant Shark, When I saw that, I replied to a post on Twitter asking the question why they didn't use Armaggon, Which got retweeted by the Turtle Power Podcast, And this was the response.
https://twitter.com/TMNTPodcast/status/501470102798495744
Nice to see TMNT get some spot light in the comic community :D
But yeah everybody was asking in the comic forum why they named the shark bludgeon and not Armeddon or what ever his name is, was really bothering everybody, but after IDW explained why it made sense why they changed names.
Joey Kamikaze
08-18-2014, 10:34 PM
IDW has become my favorite iteration of TMNT. It's just so consistently great every month. Both the Archie and Mirage series could be really uneven. I like the "canon" bits of Mirage vol. 1 but otherwise never felt very pulled into that universe. There are times reading it when it feels all "Oh look at us, it's the 90's and we're so indy and edgy, that's why we get away with having kind of crappy art and uneven writing." TMNTA has a big place in my heart, and I love the bits with Null & the Mutanimals, the world tour arc in the #30's, the future issues, the Stump Wrestling crew, etc., but the eco-preaching can make it awkward to re-read as an adult. For just plain great storytelling every month without a bunch of ham-fisted political preaching or pointless random-quality guest issues, neither can touch the current IDW series.
Leo656
08-18-2014, 11:08 PM
I read Archie the most and have a sentimental attachment to it, and still haven't read a ton of IDW so I can't fully comment, but I don't love the reincarnation thing; it's alright, I just don't favor it. The book in general is pretty good, though, from what I've read. I find Mirage on the whole to be far too inconsistent for my taste, although the more recent "Tales" book was terrific, everything the "real" TMNT book should have been. As much as I dislike Vol. 4, is how much I enjoy "Tales".
So, as to which book I'd pick up first if each complete series was right in front of me, it'd probably be Archie, IDW, then Mirage. Image brings up the rear for me; some of the art was just completely wrong for a black & white comic and nearly impossible to look at, although to be fair it was more of an early problem that mostly got fixed later on.
Bobby Curnow
08-18-2014, 11:45 PM
I love conversations about this kinda thing, because it reveals a lot about why different people love TMNT— the franchise has covered a lot of ground.
I think anyone voting for IDW is secretly voting for Archie or Mirage without knowing it. Kevin still talks, as he and Peter always did, about standing on the shoulders of giants like Jack Kirby. IDW is very much standing on the shoulder of giants that have stood on the shoulders of other, larger giants. If we're doing anything right, it's mostly because someone else has done it right before us.
(But hey— we can get dark! we did start a mini-series with Fugitoid contemplating suicide! We got 32 Edge Points for that.)
Panda_Kahn_fan
08-18-2014, 11:50 PM
Leave this earth.
No. You have a right to your opinions, and I have mine. I read most of Mirage, and I didn't like it.
Panda_Kahn_fan
08-18-2014, 11:55 PM
I love conversations about this kinda thing, because it reveals a lot about why different people love TMNT— the franchise has covered a lot of ground.
I think anyone voting for IDW is secretly voting for Archie or Mirage without knowing it. Kevin still talks, as he and Peter always did, about standing on the shoulders of giants like Jack Kirby. IDW is very much standing on the shoulder of giants that have stood on the shoulders of other, larger giants. If we're doing anything right, it's mostly because someone else has done it right before us.
(But hey— we can get dark! we did start a mini-series with Fugitoid contemplating suicide! We got 32 Edge Points for that.)
Yes, I agree that all TMNT fans owe Mirage, Kevin and Peter a debt, no matter what version those fans prefer! :)
Redeemer
08-19-2014, 12:24 AM
I love conversations about this kinda thing, because it reveals a lot about why different people love TMNT— the franchise has covered a lot of ground.
I think anyone voting for IDW is secretly voting for Archie or Mirage without knowing it. Kevin still talks, as he and Peter always did, about standing on the shoulders of giants like Jack Kirby. IDW is very much standing on the shoulder of giants that have stood on the shoulders of other, larger giants. If we're doing anything right, it's mostly because someone else has done it right before us.
(But hey— we can get dark! we did start a mini-series with Fugitoid contemplating suicide! We got 32 Edge Points for that.)
I am sorry, but that just doesn't make sense :lol:
Powder
08-19-2014, 12:35 AM
No. You have a right to your opinions, and I have mine. I read most of Mirage, and I didn't like it.
I feel like that can't possibly be true if you read Tales vol. 2 in full or near it. Did you?
Darth Knuckles
08-19-2014, 12:36 AM
I had to vote Archie because that paired with the original cartoon was what made me a turtle fan. I really enjoyed them and still need to re-read them soon after I get done reading the Mirage comics I've been getting since the TMNT 25th Anniversary.
I've been very impressed with the original Mirage books. Even more so than I thought I would. About the first twelve issues plus the five micro-series and the Tales of the TMNT (Vol. 1) have all been great. Some of the other Volume 1 issues are a bit out there with the "guest era" issues. But all of the ones that continue the main plot have been great so far. I just finished up the "Return to New York" three-parter actually. Poor Zog too! :tsad:
IDW I just don't have time for really. I'm behind as it is with Sonic the Hedgehog and Sonic Universe....and soon to be Sonic Boom comics by Archie too.
Panda_Kahn_fan
08-19-2014, 01:10 AM
I feel like that can't possibly be true if you read Tales vol. 2 in full or near it. Did you?
Seeds of Destruction, Not Forgotten, Kung fu theater, The pantheon, and The burning man were okay. Worms of madness and Darkness Weaves were werewolf/vampire monster stuff I don't care for, and stuff like Hell's blacktop, Gangs all here, Heroes in a half cell, and there's no place like home are just too out there for me.
The 'maulitia'? A giant starro knockoff? Shredder the angry shark kidnapping Casey's daughter? Two wierdoes standing on each others shoulders swinging big knives at Rapheal and Shadow Jones? The wacky adventures of Leatherhead and Dr. X? oy vey!
Look, I understand other people like it, it's just not for me. I just don't care for the endless gang war stuff, and the overall tone and art style of Mirage. It is very high quality storytelling and art, I'll agree on that- but IDW is a bit more towards my Fred Wolf/Archie tastes.
discordiatookie
08-19-2014, 01:52 AM
Mirage wins it for me. I love both IDW and Archie (also Image), and there's been amazing stories in each of them, but my favourites come from Mirage.
TMNTAfan
08-19-2014, 02:34 AM
It's interesting. There are Mirage comics that are just perfect but I don't know whether the entire spectrum of Mirage moves me as much.
Archie is massively underrated and filled with tremendous ideas such as Maligna, Armaggon, the Mutanimals, the Turnstone arc, the black-costumed Raphael etc. It was incredibly ambitious and creative but also consistent and coherent which the series lacked until recently. Archie is also the one I have the most nostalgic affection for.
IDW is probably the best for having a single, coherent narrative that is always compelling and takes on the characters that are thoughtful and rounded. I really love it and I think it's going from strength to strength.
I think I have to give it to Archie because it's such a rich, vibrant and beautifully-characterised universe which unfolded over a substantial amount of time. But IDW could well surpass it if it continues at this quality. And Mirage, at its best, is just perfect.
Cryomancer
08-19-2014, 03:02 AM
Mirage for it's weirdness and length and downer-ism for sure. But IDW is pretty neat, and could eventually be equal or greater depending on how things shake out over time, who knows.
Check box poll, picked all because they are all cool.
Redeemer
08-19-2014, 03:04 AM
I had to vote Archie because that paired with the original cartoon was what made me a turtle fan. I really enjoyed them and still need to re-read them soon after I get done reading the Mirage comics I've been getting since the TMNT 25th Anniversary.
I've been very impressed with the original Mirage books. Even more so than I thought I would. About the first twelve issues plus the five micro-series and the Tales of the TMNT (Vol. 1) have all been great. Some of the other Volume 1 issues are a bit out there with the "guest era" issues. But all of the ones that continue the main plot have been great so far. I just finished up the "Return to New York" three-parter actually. Poor Zog too! :tsad:
IDW I just don't have time for really. I'm behind as it is with Sonic the Hedgehog and Sonic Universe....and soon to be Sonic Boom comics by Archie too.
You are cheating yourself my friend the IDW comics are great
neatoman
08-19-2014, 07:01 AM
The IDW comics.
The Mirage stuff may be a lot of fun to read through and there is some true art in it but it can also be a bit of an awkward downer at times, not to mention that it can be a little amateurish at times. Not bad but not that comprehensive all the time.
The Archie Stuff I'm not entirely sure I can judge yet since I've only read what IDW has put out and there's a little more than half left. From what I have read though, it's chaotic nonsense and bad artwork. Bad artwork and chaotic nonsense with it's heart in the right place mind you, but bad artwork and chaotic nonsense all the same.
The IDW comics though, even though I had watched the 4kids show in it's entirety and many episodes of the Fred Wolf cartoon by the time I started reading the IDW series, I had never been really into TMNT. Oh sure the 4kids cartoon is really enjoyable but it still wasn't good enough for me to really be into the series but the IDW did it for me.
I think it has a lot to do with the fact that it's very easy to comprehend but still complex enough to keep your interest and it never feels directionless like Mirage, Archie, The Fred Wolf Cartoon, the last two seasons of the 4kids cartoon and sadly even the Nick cartoon can be at times. I would even go so far as to say that the IDW comics might just be the version of TMNT yet.
Mewzard
08-19-2014, 11:23 AM
Honestly I like them all, but Mirage has to be my number one (with IDW taking up the second place in the three). Each series stands on their own merit with a unique style of writing and art (which I enjoy all of the three), but there's just something magical about Mirage that bumps it up to the top for me.
A mix of style and substance that it had mostly kept for itself while the later adaptations took other bits. The writing's also pretty solid with stories that, while can get pretty dark, never go to the point of pure hopeless, but to that bittersweet point that makes things an emotional ride through the ups and downs.
I do have to give IDW credit for creating a world that's a melting pot of so many different interpretations while maintaining it's own identity without being overpowered by its "ingredients". There have certainly been some creative choices, and the tone is a good one for the most part.
If you weren't going to hand someone the first issue of the Mirage Comic, then handing them "Change is Constant" is a good second place for introducing them to Turtles (that or the first movie, like how I got into TMNT).
The Archie Series is interesting, because I'm not usually into the goofier side of TMNT too much (in small doses I'm okay, but I seldom go into stuff like the 80s Cartoon). The Archie Comic was really my first forray into it all that deeply, and while I'm only 11 issues in (I need to get more than the first 2 Adventures trades and the 100 Page Spectacular), it has been somewhat interesting.
I do like the idea of some of the more far out stuff (which can be done serious or silly to great effect either way, depending on what the audience wants), and it does feel like it works in the greater Turtles universe (going from one series to another as your mood and taste for the moment shifts).
I can't complain about any of them to be honest, Mirage just edges out the competition (with IDW taking a deserved Silver Medal).
Jephael
08-19-2014, 11:42 AM
I gotta admit I prefer the more lightheartedness of Archie and IDW, plus they deal with all sorts of different stories and characters, while Mirage sometimes feels a little too repetitive, always focusing on the Turtles' never-ending feud with the Foot Clan.
Dirty Blond
08-19-2014, 11:43 AM
Mirage, but Tales of the TMNT over the main book.
IDW does a great job with the ongoing and various other series.
I can't stand Archie.
Darth Knuckles
08-19-2014, 11:46 AM
You are cheating yourself my friend the IDW comics are great
I feel like you're really right from what I hear but I've got so many things I've got on the front burner. If it is anything like the Nick show winning me over when I didn't really want to get into a weekend morning cartoon show, then I may just have to read them somewhere down the line.
CyberCubed
08-19-2014, 11:50 AM
Its kind of funny that people aren't including Image as part of Mirage.
The Big Bad
08-19-2014, 12:08 PM
Although dealing with different continuities, I've come to realize that I like both the Mirage and Archie books for largely the same reasons: they're both books that are often less about stories and more about allowing the creators to explore whatever ideas they had in their heads, and to see where those ideas would take them. And while the destination may not have always been worthwhile, the path tends to at least be interesting, in a way other comic books rarely are, and there are enough genuine successes to make the exercise worthwhile.
So which of the two would I prefer? While the Mirage book's running time allows it to accrue a not-inconsiderable amount of weight, which allows it to tell stories that no other version of the turtles can, I think, in the end, I like the Archie book more, because it feels like it has a more favorable proportions of concept I actually enjoy. It also helps, to a degree, that there hasn't been terribly many attempts to replicate what the book did--it helps keep things less compromised--I'm not sure that's the word--to a degree.
neatoman
08-19-2014, 02:39 PM
Its kind of funny that people aren't including Image as part of Mirage.
Shhhhh, we don't talk about that...
Allio
08-19-2014, 04:59 PM
Its kind of funny that people aren't including Image as part of Mirage.
Because Peter Laird said it isn't canon (like when he said which issues of volume 1 isn't canon) and until Nick says otherwise, it is still non-canon
CyberCubed
08-19-2014, 05:11 PM
Because Peter Laird said it isn't canon (like when he said which issues of volume 1 isn't canon) and until Nick says otherwise, it is still non-canon
Why would Nick say anything? Peter Laird said most comics are non-canon including Tales V. 2 issues that Mirage published like the one Radical kisses Leo. It's canon and part of Mirage continuity.
Cipher
08-19-2014, 05:22 PM
Why would Nick say anything? Peter Laird said most comics are non-canon including Tales V. 2 issues that Mirage published like the one Radical kisses Leo. It's canon and part of Mirage continuity.
Speaking personally -- and I know there's a large part of the fanbase intent on including it and aided by things like Andrew's fan-lead conclusion (which I think is good on its own) -- it's a little different. I'm not usually inclined to include it in the series because the content that came after, including all of Volume 4 and Tales Volume 2, was written with the assumption that it didn't happen. And, frankly, I think the series reads a little more coherently if it didn't (though not by much, and all of Mirage is so scattershot and anthology-based you're free to include it or not at your leisure).
Point being, it's not crazy to think of them as separate branches as Laird and Mirage did when they returned to the series in 2002.
CyberCubed
08-19-2014, 05:48 PM
However Dr. X the Utrom first appears in Image and appears again in a few Tales issues. A lot of Images plot points including the Foot's fragile truce with the Turtles is alluded to in Volume 4 again which wouldn't make sense if you ignore Image.
Lastly we get to see stuff like Shadow as a kid and Leatherhead remaining on Earth after his failed attempt to rejoin the Utroms in that Tales story.
Cipher
08-19-2014, 05:54 PM
However Dr. X the Utrom first appears in Image and appears again in a few Tales issues. A lot of Images plot points including the Foot's fragile truce with the Turtles is alluded to in Volume 4 again which wouldn't make sense if you ignore Image.
When does Dr. X ever show up? I thought Glurin was the go-to named Utrom for most of Tales.
A tenuous truce with the Foot is exactly where "City at War" leaves the Turtles, though rogue factions of Shredder loyalists apparently continue to target them for the rest of their lives. Frankly -- and as much as I like it -- Raphael's stint as Shredder or Karai being excommunicated for any amount of time actually just kind of clutters that up.
Lastly we get to see stuff like Shadow as a kid and Leatherhead remaining on Earth after his failed attempt to rejoin the Utroms in that Tales story.
Nothing essential happens to Shadow in the Image volume that would have consequence in Volume 4 or Tales, though. In fact one of its major revelations -- her mob parentage -- is never brought up again. She even comments at some point in Tales she has no idea who her father is.
Leatherhead has his arc fully explained in Dan Berger's Tales Vol. 2 issues as far as I remember.
I have nothing against the Image book. You can easily patch it in if you want to. It just has a very different style and the latter half of Mirage isn't written with it in mind.
CyberCubed
08-19-2014, 06:16 PM
When does Dr. X ever show up? I thought Glurin was the go-to named Utrom for most of Tales.
He appeared in an issue with Leatherhead I remember, almost a reference to the Image comic. Can't remember which issue it was but it was later in the run. Even Andrew Modeen commented on it.
A tenuous truce with the Foot is exactly where "City at War" leaves the Turtles, though rogue factions of Shredder loyalists apparently continue to target them for the rest of their lives. Frankly -- and as much as I like it -- Raphael's stint as Shredder or Karai being excommunicated for any amount of time actually just kind of clutters that up.
Volume 4 was around 15 years after City at War though. They wouldn't have a tenuous truce if they never came into contact again over 15 years. However Raphael becoming the Shredder and leading the NYC Foot for awhile, then being betrayed by the Foot and Lady Shredder only for Karai to come in and clean up the mess makes sense. Even in that Tales issue where Casey and April propose almost had Karai and the Foot attack the Turtles again but they pulled back.
Leatherhead has his arc fully explained in Dan Berger's Tales Vol. 2 issues as far as I remember.
What about Leatherhead's healing factor which came up in Image first?
I have nothing against the Image book. You can easily patch it in if you want to. It just has a very different style and the latter half of Mirage isn't written with it in mind.
As you said Mirage is already all over the place with different tones because of different writers. Lawson, Murphy and Dan Berger all wrote entirely different types of stories let alone Tristan Jones stuff which felt like it didn't fit into Mirage's tone at all.
It doesn't really matter since people can think of it as canon or not, but it fits much better than ignoring it entirely.
He appeared in an issue with Leatherhead I remember, almost a reference to the Image comic. Can't remember which issue it was but it was later in the run. Even Andrew Modeen commented on it
If I can recall it correctly there was even a small backup story with Dr X drawn by Lawson...
Cipher
08-19-2014, 07:06 PM
He appeared in an issue with Leatherhead I remember, almost a reference to the Image comic. Can't remember which issue it was but it was later in the run. Even Andrew Modeen commented on it.
Huh. Really? I guess I just don't remember that, then. Can anyone back that up?
Volume 4 was around 15 years after City at War though. They wouldn't have a tenuous truce if they never came into contact again over 15 years.
Sure. Why not? Where they start Volume 4 in terms of Foot-interaction is exactly where "City at War" leaves them. They don't have any real antagonism with the main branch controlled by Karai, but they're not super great friends, which makes sense because the Turtles are basically good people and the Foot is still a bunch of murderous ninja criminals.
Even then, though, Karai is able to call on Leo for favors. The gang doesn't even have a problem inviting Cha Ocho into their home sometime shortly prior to Volume 4.
At the same time, we learn through Tales Vol. 2 that splinter elements like the Foot mystics and the few remaining Shredder Elite have continued to target them. Makes sense to me.
What about Leatherhead's healing factor which came up in Image first?
That just means it's doubly explained in Berger's Tales Vol. 2 #8 then.
As you said, there are stories all over the place in Mirage that don't quite fit the tone or aren't referenced afterward. But for me, the fact that none of the large or longstanding changes introduced in the volume are referenced again in the series is enough to put it at more of a default distance than even some of the questionably canonical guest-artist issues. It's not just one wacky adventure -- it's a long series of major events that never get so much as a "Remember when?" in subsequent material.
Again, nothing to stop anyone from including it, but I don't think it needs to be or should be something included in the Mirage narrative as a default for discussion.
Toxin45
01-31-2019, 05:35 PM
IDw for me Mirage/Image and archie are alright but IDW is my personal favorite.
Utrommaniac
01-31-2019, 05:38 PM
I went IDW, hardcore
daggio
01-31-2019, 06:21 PM
IDW for me.
Originally, I was a little apprehensive about reading cuz of the very different origin story, but decided to give the book a shot after seeing how many characters from previous incarnations appear in it. I'm definitely glad I did read it.
pferreira
02-01-2019, 01:23 PM
I voted Mirage mainly because from what I've seen of IDW's TMNT I wasn't a big fan. Having said that my memories of Mirage are really of Volume 1.
Toxin45
02-01-2019, 04:05 PM
I voted Mirage mainly because from what I've seen of IDW's TMNT I wasn't a big fan. Having said that my memories of Mirage are really of Volume 1.
Then You never red volumes 2,3,and 4 before you kind missed out on that dued along with tales of the tmnt.
Igglet
02-01-2019, 05:12 PM
Then You never volumes 2,3,and 4
I ALWAYS volumes 2, 3 and 4.
Toxin45
02-01-2019, 05:19 PM
I ALWAYS volumes 2, 3 and 4.
I mean read mirage volume 2,3,and 4 plus tales vol 1 and 2.
Igglet
02-01-2019, 05:27 PM
I mean read mirage volume 2,3,and 4 plus tales vol 1 and 2.
Yeah I got it I was just kidding but still, I think you kind of missed their point. Just because they associate the Mirage run with Volume 1 doesn't mean they didn't read it. From the way they phrased it, I'm pretty sure they did.
Toxin45
02-01-2019, 05:42 PM
Yeah I got it I was just kidding but still, I think you kind of missed their point. Just because they associate the Mirage run with Volume 1 doesn't mean they didn't read it. From the way they phrased it, I'm pretty sure they did.
They just didn't like it is all at least not as much as volume 1 is what I am guessing.
pferreira
02-08-2019, 02:21 PM
Then You never red volumes 2,3,and 4 before you kind missed out on that dued along with tales of the tmnt.I'll read it all eventually. Waiting for the collections. :D
Rooish
02-09-2019, 07:32 PM
That was hard. I truly love the best parts of Mirage, but overall I voted for IDW because of its character development, and for being a bit more consistently good. The best parts of Mirage crush IDW though.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.