PDA

View Full Version : 2014 annual preview


corvus
08-18-2014, 02:06 PM
Its been up for awhile but for those of you who haven't seen it https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.10152593024113279.1073742022.8473603278&type=1

ctt4lfecw
08-18-2014, 05:08 PM
very nice, cant wait

Panda_Kahn_fan
08-19-2014, 12:11 AM
That looks awesome! I can't wait to find out if the 'contest' Renet recriuted them for is the battle nexus, or stump asteroid!

Btown
08-19-2014, 03:51 AM
I actually think this is the only thing ill be picking up this week. so I'm looking forward to it

erik
08-19-2014, 04:30 AM
Glad they did it in color. But I'm not looking forward to the usual Hard-Stock Cover, which they always do to justify an $8 price.

Tazi
08-20-2014, 04:56 AM
Glad they did it in color
...sort of in color ;)


Read the Issue, it's really not my cup of tea. The art was good tho, it was much easier see whats happening then in the previous annual. The "coloring/toning" in the "other-world" parts looked great, and I'd prefer it any day over duo-tone, even if duo-tone is a classic.

SDCC
08-20-2014, 07:35 AM
Here's my review at SuperDStuff.com - http://www.superdstuff.com/2014/08/tmnt-annual-2014.html

I love IDW TMNT. I do not love this. Much like the first annual for me, which means a disappointment.

ChosenOne
08-20-2014, 10:12 AM
I just finished reading this, and it's definitely not as grating as the previous annual. While Kevin Eastman's style hasn't aged very well and feels off considering the plethora of great artists over on the main title and mini-series, it was a pretty fun little story featuring the Battle Nexus, Renet, Lord Simultaneous and the return of Zog. Can't go wrong with world-building that actually means something, unlike say introducing a dozen street punks and lowlifes with Irish names... :roll: Also, the shift from color to black and white, and back again at the end, was actually a bit cool and served the story, at least IMHO.

Veg
08-20-2014, 03:59 PM
It was pretty ****. I hated the first annual too. Turtles in Time is a much better use of Renet.

qt.bangerang
08-20-2014, 04:46 PM
This was pretty lame, nice to introduce a few characters, but nothing other then that. Not sure how this ties into Turtles in Time other then Renet.

erik
08-20-2014, 09:04 PM
Glad they did it in color. But I'm not looking forward to the usual Hard-Stock Cover, which they always do to justify an $8 price.

Opps -- spoke too soon! They did HALF of it in color. Eastman must really love his gray-tones!

I haven't gotten to reading it yet, but I'm glad I got it. I had to hoof it to another comic store to get a copy, because my regular one didn't get any copies! You'd think ordering a bit more TMNT comics, during the movie high, would be warrented - don't you think?

snake
08-20-2014, 09:36 PM
This issue sucked. Hard. I loved last annual, even if it was hard to see what was going on. This one felt so out of character for everyone.

CyberCubed
08-20-2014, 09:58 PM
I haven't read this yet, I think you guys must just not be used to Kevin's writing style.

Didn't Tom Waltz have to co-write his script last time to fix up some stuff? I dunno, guess Kevin was never much of a writer and always more of an artist.

corvus
08-20-2014, 10:04 PM
Zog again was cool...to bad he contributed nothing to the story. It was so simple yet so long. What the hell? Maybe we'd all be less disappointed if it came out on time.

MikeandRaph87
08-20-2014, 11:02 PM
I was underwhelmed by it because I built up in my mind Renet plus the Big Brawl storyline minus Usagi's involvement condensed for a comic book annual. I was thinking THE Battle Nexus but it was just a cheap nod to it. Got excited when I saw a tricaton thinking it Big Brawl minus Usagi con was Traximus but iwas Zog again.However, it was food to see a new ally with Balthazar. Also, nice to see the prank scenario and the turtles letting lose especially Donatello's involvement and Splinter while warning against did not outright put an end to it. It was nicely paced and annual well characterized.

snake
08-20-2014, 11:04 PM
What about the annuals placement? Donnie's at Harold's I believe, and Mikey and Raph are at Hob's.

Ninjinister
08-20-2014, 11:05 PM
So alright, isn't the Battle Nexus supposed to be THE Battle Nexus? Like the one in 2K3 is the same one as in Mirage, not two different versions (like how there's only one Cudley)?

So they're saying that the IDW Turtles traveled far back enough to inspire the creation of the Battle Nexus itself? :o

EDIT: Also there's no way that the villain's name being Nieli was an accident... especially since this book actually featured "Booyakasha"

corvus
08-20-2014, 11:35 PM
What about the annuals placement? Donnie's at Harold's I believe, and Mikey and Raph are at Hob's.

Assume it takes place before or after.


And I have a theory about Tenet leaving her helmet. Simultaneous was wise in making her wear it, without it herccontrol of the tome sceptre is unstable and pulls the turtles all over the timeline thus creating the events of turtles in time.

snake
08-20-2014, 11:37 PM
Assume it takes place before or after.

Ah. Okay. I read it right after I reread 34-36 so I was a bit confused.

corvus
08-20-2014, 11:59 PM
Usually when its a different title it takes place before or after the arch in the main title.

Wentos
08-21-2014, 12:27 AM
This annual was an improvement over the previous one, in that I understood what was going on this time without having to re-read it twice.

But man, talk about taking a neat premise and making it boring. Baltizar, one of the most grating, one-note "joke" characters I've seen in recent memory, got the lion's share of the dialogue. The council's decision to oust Nieli and turn the gladiator games into the Battle Nexus was REALLY contrived. And bookending the story with toilet jokes and a cartoony Rube Goldberg machine was not only hackneyed, it was totally out of place in the world that Waltz and Curnow have created.

I've said before that Eastman's art and writing style don't gel with the IDW style, but it's painfully obvious here that Eastman's work just doesn't belong. It's cool that IDW wants to give Eastman work, but either keep it to co-plotting and drawing variants, or have him play in the Mirage sandbox like he did in "Ready Set Go".

This book was over three months late and it was not worth the wait at all. I can't believe I'm saying this about an IDW TMNT book, but this was total junk. If I wasn't a completionist, I would definitely wave off a third annual.

EDIT: I forgot to mention something I actually liked about the annual so I don't look like too much of a Negative Nancy here. I really like the idea that the reason Renet seems so spacy to the turtles is because her experiences with the turtles and the turtles' experiences with her don't match up. In this annual the turtles are meeting Renet for the first time, but for Renet, this wasn't her first meeting with the turtles. At a later date, when she DOES meet the turtles for the first time, the turtles will already know who she is. I thought that was really clever, and could make for some really neat stories later on.

snake
08-21-2014, 12:52 AM
Would anyone enjoy this better if it was a tales or Vol.4 issue? Something in the mirage universe?

Joey Kamikaze
08-21-2014, 03:40 AM
Well it was better than the movie. :lol:

But yeah, neither annual has felt like it belongs in the IDW universe, and outside introducing Renet and her alternate-chronology-shenanigans (which are cool), this one felt like a throw-away story. Thanks to incessant monologuing the dialogue was as flat as the art. I liked the trap panels, and Eastman can draw a great action sequence, but his scripts just haven't worked for this TMNT universe.

Regardless, now Renet can pop up in the series whenever so we're coming out of this one ahead. She was one of my favorite supporting characters from Mirage. I'm curious how long the book will go on before Renet has her first meeting with the turtles from her perspective.

erik
08-21-2014, 07:29 AM
So alright, isn't the Battle Nexus supposed to be THE Battle Nexus? Like the one in 2K3 is the same one as in Mirage, not two different versions (like how there's only one Cudley)?

So they're saying that the IDW Turtles traveled far back enough to inspire the creation of the Battle Nexus itself? :o

EDIT: Also there's no way that the villain's name being Nieli was an accident... especially since this book actually featured "Booyakasha"


Who is Nieli?

erik
08-21-2014, 07:36 AM
Assume it takes place before or after.


And I have a theory about Tenet leaving her helmet. Simultaneous was wise in making her wear it, without it herccontrol of the tome sceptre is unstable and pulls the turtles all over the timeline thus creating the events of turtles in time.

It mentions specifically that this took place before Turtles in Time. (Which I guess it also takes place before the Turtles separated as well.)

Read it last night. Good story. Silly, but good. I sort of liked the silliness; like a slight return to the parody aspect of the comics. And the change to the Battle Nexus Tournament was a nice touch.

Only problem, though -- you really had to work hard to keep track of which Turtle was which, since they didn't have their normal weapons.

I also think the issue would have been better if someone else did the dialogue. It seemed clear Eastman was writing the dialogue. Without Laird to back him up, you can see the results.

Sophie Campbell
08-21-2014, 07:51 AM
you guys are crazy, i LOVED this annual, it was so funny. i can't remember the last time a TMNT comic made me laugh out loud. i loved how weird it was, and Splinter on the toilet and the lair hijinks. now i want a spin-off comic of Renet baking the cake she promised the Turtles!!

MikeandRaph87
08-21-2014, 10:46 AM
you guys are crazy, i LOVED this annual, it was so funny. i can't remember the last time a TMNT comic made me laugh out loud. i loved how weird it was, and Splinter on the toilet and the lair hijinks. now i want a spin-off comic of Renet baking the cake she promised the Turtles!!

Here is an idea, why not in #51 when Renet returns following the mini-series she can bring them the cake and then show up with a little problem after the cake ice breaker? Showing Buldgeon wrecking havoc in the future with Armaggon's armor designed by Ross Campbell would be really cool!Right, Mr. Campbell? *nudge*

snake
08-21-2014, 10:59 AM
you guys are crazy, i LOVED this annual, it was so funny. i can't remember the last time a TMNT comic made me laugh out loud. i loved how weird it was, and Splinter on the toilet and the lair hijinks. now i want a spin-off comic of Renet baking the cake she promised the Turtles!!

Splinter was pretty funny.


"Holy S-ah, smokes"

Tazi
08-21-2014, 11:07 AM
So, will IDW follow Tales of TMNT v2 #71, and turn Baltizar into Savanti Romero? :D

Besides, what kind of name Baltizar is? Is it Balthazar with typos? :teek:

erik
08-21-2014, 11:08 AM
Here is an idea, why not in #51 when Renet returns following the mini-series she can bring them the cake and then show up with a little problem after the cake ice breaker? Showing Buldgeon wrecking havoc in the future with Armaggon's armor designed by Ross Campbell would be really cool!Right, Mr. Campbell? *nudge*

The cake is a lie. Didn't Portal teach us anything, if not that?

ctt4lfecw
08-21-2014, 09:32 PM
Splinter taking a dump was totally out of left field, but I lol'd. I think we got a glimpse of Savanti Romero(the warrior who said he was a servant) I thought that was cool.

Desslok
08-21-2014, 10:09 PM
While this did seem a bit out of place in relation to the ongoing books, I did enjoy it as a stand alone bit - I do like some off beat humor every now and then. And Renet is such a loveable klutz. :twink:

So while this one really does nothing to advance story it is a nice diversion if you're willing to accept it as something a little less serious.

Ninjinister
08-21-2014, 10:23 PM
Who is Nieli?

Ciro Nieli is the showrunner of the current TV series.

erik
08-23-2014, 06:50 AM
Ciro Nieli is the showrunner of the current TV series.

Oh my word - REALLY? Thats must have been a friendly joshing - naming a unscrupulous villain after the current TMNT showrunner!

pingclang
08-23-2014, 07:32 AM
I'm really surprised by all the negative comments this is getting. I thought it was frickin' fantastic and it felt Mirage, which isn't a bad thing. I want more Eastman writing because if this is the type of stuff we'd get, that would be awesome.

RaphaelinSTL
08-23-2014, 10:24 AM
It feels too Eastman over IDW?

Why didn't I pick this up sooner?

Oh and I'm not entirely knocking the IDW series, I'm just now starting to read it and obviously have some catching up to do. I've read a couple issues here and there throughout the years, but I need to just buy the paperbacks and catch myself up to where the series is now.

I'm really not digging the art direction so far though with the Turtles in the ongoing series. Too much of an influence from the Nick show. Especially Mikey...I'm not digging the bucktooth. Oh, but I'm looking forward to picking up the Annual! Might get that bad boy today.

Tazi
08-23-2014, 10:33 AM
It feels too Eastman over IDW?

Why didn't I pick this up sooner?

Honestly, it doesn't feel too much like Mirage, it's way too silly... But the main problem is the story, which is "the main heroes fight in an arena ending with overthrowing the oppressive ruler/governor". It's such a cliché. Like the "shy dude becames a hero, and bangs the hottest chick from school".

RaphaelinSTL
08-23-2014, 10:37 AM
Honestly, it doesn't feel too much like Mirage, it's way too silly... But the main problem is the story, which is "the main heroes fight in an arena ending with overthrowing the oppressive ruler/governor". It's such a cliché. Like the "shy dude becames a hero, and bangs the hottest chick from school".

Ahh gotcha. Well that's kind of a bummer.

Tazi
08-23-2014, 10:44 AM
But if you like Eastman art it won't dissapoint you. And Renet is sweet! :P

DrSpengler
08-23-2014, 02:28 PM
Here's my full review of TMNT Annual 2014 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2014/08/tmnt-annual-2014.html)

I thought it was bad. I don't want to be a downer, so I'll leave my post at that.

The Big Bad
08-23-2014, 03:09 PM
What an interesting book. Not sure if it's good, necessarily, but it's enjoyable in a way the IDW books--even those I like (a small but steadily increasing number)--rarely are.

If part of my issue with the IDW turtles is its somewhat uncommunicative quality: where something like TMNT Adventures or Volume 4 say a lot about their respective writers, and one can tell a lot about Ciro Nieli from the Nick cartoon, the IDW book offers little such hints, to the point where the book sometimes feels as if it is flavorless. This annual, on the other hand, is the opposite: this feels a book that could only be done by Kevin Eastman, and tells us a whole lot about him--for one, that his sensibilities don't seem to have changed much in three decades. This feels just like his Mirage work: rough, unsophisticated, confident. It does not care about being liked. I can respect that, even if the whole painting-on-the-side-of-a-van aesthetic isn't usually to my taste.

I am left wondering, though, how much of the Battle Nexus connection was Eastman's and how much of it was IDW / Nick editorial. The adaptation of the cartoon's whole "people aren't really getting killed" element, in particular, feels incredibly out of place here.

Also, we get our "first" taste of this version of Renet, which works mostly because she doesn't stray too far from the original, while looking a heck of a lot better. I have to say though, that as much as I like this design, I wish Eastman had stuck with the knee boots from the first few sketches. Fortunately, that earlier design seems to be the one being used by other artists. : ) More of her, please.

ctt4lfecw
08-23-2014, 10:54 PM
I say for Annual 2015/16 that Kev and Peter get back together and give us what we want.

snake
08-24-2014, 12:18 AM
I say for Annual 2015/16 that Kev and Peter get back together and give us what we want.

Or drop them all together. They wouldn't work in the IDW universe I assume, even if Peter joined. They are great in mirage, not IDW.

Just make Kevin do art instead of story.

Wentos
08-24-2014, 12:27 AM
I say for Annual 2015/16 that Kev and Peter get back together and give us what we want.

I really like the idea of Peter and Kevin working on a story together for IDW. Peter has admitted that he and Kevin were more than the sum of their parts. Maybe together they could rekindle a bit of the magic missing from the IDW annuals and Volume 4.

But I wouldn't want it to be an annual, at least not for the current ongoing series. Eastman and Laird have their own voice for the turtles, and it doesn't mesh at all with what Tom and Bobby are doing. Mirage is Mirage. IDW is IDW. And one pretending to be another just. Doesn't. Work. Not only do the styles clash horribly, it dilutes the uniqueness of the IDW TMNT.

Another out-of-continuity story like the 30th Anniversary Special would be wonderful, but leave the original creators out of the new series PLEASE.

Joey Kamikaze
08-24-2014, 02:47 AM
Yeah, these annuals would be perfectly serviceable Mirage TMNT material. They're goofy, but they're Mirage goofy like a lot of the early issues were. IDW has its own sense of humor, and I don't think these annuals gibe with that universe. I'd like to see Kevin working in the Mirage universe again too.

But to be honest if they're going to continue doing annuals I'd rather see someone else take a crack at it next year.

Enscripture
08-24-2014, 03:26 AM
Uh, I don't get the Splinter thing. When he mentions "Ventilation" he's on the toilet or something, walking to the toilet? Then he's upstairs (squatting?) staring at the corner. There's no flush thing or newspapers. Then he's on the toilet while the stupid turtles are laughing behind him? Then there's a wall behind him? Then a wall next to him when he flushes? wtf. This whole comic was a mess. I didn't even know there was a poop joke or whatever that was. I thought he was just reading.

ctt4lfecw
08-24-2014, 07:26 PM
Maybe Peter should exercise his right to do new comics and Kevin can come back.

VaughnMichael
08-25-2014, 08:49 AM
Wow so much hate for this!:o
I really enjoyed it and so much more than the last one Kevin did too.
I loved the nods to so many things like Zog!
I have to agree though with those that said this feels more Mirage than IDW.
It's quite an odd book but I really did enjoy it from front to back.
I'm honestly quite shocked by the inclusion of Battle Nexus as it seems everyone at Nick hates anything 2k3 related.

corvus
08-25-2014, 11:51 AM
The hatred for it probably comes from the delay. Everyone got hyped up. The first pages were brilliant then it got really redundant...then we saw Zog again and nothing came of his first meeting with the turtles. I'd say this issue confirms he's still alive but once you factor in time travel it does not.

snake
08-25-2014, 12:28 PM
Is Zog stupid in this or something? All he said was "Zog Smash!" instead of anything intelligent.

liugeaux
08-28-2014, 07:51 AM
There are SO MANY things to dislike about this issue...but I want to stick with the best positive I can get from it. The creation of the Battle Nexus sets up the possibility of a much more interesting and better executed 4 issue mini about it in the future.

spookycookies
08-30-2014, 12:20 AM
Just finished up with this one. My only real issue was with the dialogue which felt really out of place. I didn't mind the action or the Turtles inadvertently inspiring the Battle Nexus but Renet's exposition was really sparse. I guess the annuals are supposed to be more fun than anything and it accomplished that. I kind of got the feeling of Baltizar being sort of a Spicoli type and on the other end of the spectrum the guards reminded me of like, football coaches or drill sergeants. Anyone else catch that?

It could have been much better, and it does feel out of place lined up next to the rest of IDW TMNT but perhaps the point of it is to tune out and have a good time with Eastman.

Jay $tarkiller
09-08-2014, 01:38 PM
I say for Annual 2015/16 that Kev and Peter get back together and give us what we want.

That would be awesome as hell:tgrin:

I really don't know what to think of this annual. I'm a huge sucker for Eastman artwork, but the story was kinda weird. There were certain aspects that I liked, but the overall feeling remains being weird.

The switch up with the color and black and white thing was kinda cool, but the dialogues were a bit lame sometimes.

However it did have that Mirage vibe to it, so that was comforting on the other hand.

Really can't make up my mind, whether I like it or think it's kinda lame..

ctt4lfecw
09-08-2014, 06:09 PM
That would be awesome as hell:tgrin:

I really don't know what to think of this annual. I'm a huge sucker for Eastman artwork, but the story was kinda weird. There were certain aspects that I liked, but the overall feeling remains being weird.

The switch up with the color and black and white thing was kinda cool, but the dialogues were a bit lame sometimes.

However it did have that Mirage vibe to it, so that was comforting on the other hand.

Really can't make up my mind, whether I like it or think it's kinda lame..

Thanks. But I do think now that maybe it would be better if we got Peter and Kev together for a Mirage reunion. IDW works best as its own thing.

spookycookies
09-08-2014, 07:11 PM
Thanks. But I do think now that maybe it would be better if we got Peter and Kev together for a Mirage reunion. IDW works best as its own thing.

Yeah the Zog cameo sort of makes me wonder if there will be any issues when he shows up again in the book. I mean I guess it is possible the Zog from the annual is an ancestor of Zog from Utrom Empire or something similar, I just hope Eastman isn't jumping too far away from whats going on in the grander scheme of the IDW universe.

Coola Yagami
09-09-2014, 11:26 PM
Probably won't blog about this one... been behind on my TMNT blogs as is....


It was interesting tale, though it kinda knocked me out of left field with Baltazar yelling out both Cowabunga and Booyakasha.

While I do like seeing the TMNT drawn classic Mirage style without the bandage wraps from time to time, their dialogue was a tad off. But they were goofy in the Mirage way. One has to remember that aside from all the more serious tales in the Mirage series... the Mirage TMNT were kinda cheesy with one-liners left and right. But it does feel out of place compared to how they talk and act in the IDW series.


Splinter's dialogue was WAY OFF, and it's just weird seeing a bathroom joke in a TMNT comic... especially coming from Splinter. And the cartoony booby-trap prank.... yeah, out of left field. I'm not even sure the Mirage Turtles would do this.

Powder
09-11-2014, 10:17 PM
Definitely tons better than the last one. In some parts I laughed & felt the suspense, in others it dragged along & was a bit hard to make sense of artistically. This book felt soooooooo Mirage, which is great for a casual read (it's my favorite universe, after all), but much like ALL of his work for IDW, it doesn't feel like it belongs in this universe at all. Change a few details & it could have come out 25 years ago. Makes me yearn for more Mirage, which is probably not what they're trying to do with such a book. Eastman should be better utilized, though I'm not exactly sure how, myself. God, I know they don't wanna step on Pete's toes, but I wish they'd get Kev, Dan, & Jim to put together a new Mirage series of some sort. *sigh* Anyway, ultimately, I think my biggest complaint is that Baltizar seems to exist solely to be the self-insert counterpart to Courtney Eastman, AKA Renet. I hate how all of Kevin's new stuff throws a ton of new throwaway human characters into the mix. We want turtles, man! All in all, it was pretty dope. I enjoyed it.

FlawedCoil82
10-09-2014, 11:43 PM
I am just now getting caught up. I hadnt gotten my comics for months at the shop and had a lot to get. I just got done reading this annual, and yea.....I totally get that Kevin Eastman was vital to the history of the turtles, but I found the artwork and dialogue to be pretty terrible (again). I just do not find any value in his art style. It looks like a kid with some semi-decent skills drew and wrote it, not a comic book legend. If these annuals disappeared, I wouldn't be sad in the least. I am not enjoying throwing $8 down the toilet to try and study art that is nearly impossible to determine who is who in the black and white panels (especially when they didn't have their normal weapons). If these annuals are representitive of how the old Mirage comics looked, then I know I didn't miss anything other than eye strain and confusion.