PDA

View Full Version : Real turtle names in IDW


TheWarrior97
08-29-2014, 01:54 PM
Shredder is Oroku Saki
Splinter is Hamato Yoshi

my question,
What are the Turtles first name in the IDW series (When they were human). I am assuming their last name is Yoshi.

This is for cataloging purposes.

Candy Kappa
08-29-2014, 01:55 PM
No, their last name would be Hamato, family name comes first in Japan.

Their human names have not as far as I know been mentioned.

TheWarrior97
08-29-2014, 02:21 PM
Thank you for telling me that. I have thought incorrectly since the first day I read his name on the back of the cardback in the 80's. You know what's even more ironic...I lived in japan for over 2 years, and I am married to a Japanese woman. She just now corrected me for the FIRST time when I asked her about this. I FEEL STUUUUUUPPPPPIIIIID!!!!!!!!!!!

Andrew NDB
08-29-2014, 03:05 PM
They've never been revealed and probably never will be. And probably should never be.

Candy Kappa
08-29-2014, 03:39 PM
If I remember correctly, they've established that life is over and the turtle names are now their real names. Second chance or something.

Davetello
08-29-2014, 03:44 PM
Not really strictly relevant to the topic, but since it's about the turtles as humans - it's really quite dark that it's implied that the boys are executed by decapitation. That is quite dark for a non-Mirage turtles iteration, if you think about it - children being beheaded.

darthsmozers
08-29-2014, 03:46 PM
Not really strictly relevant to the topic, but since it's about the turtles as humans - it's really quite dark that it's implied that the boys are executed by decapitation. That is quite dark for a non-Mirage turtles iteration, if you think about it - children being beheaded.

Like today in Iraq due to the monstrous terror group ISIS. :(

Davetello
08-29-2014, 03:47 PM
Like today in Iraq due to the monstrous terror group ISIS. :(

That's sorta what put the thought in my head, I guess. The whole situation over there is just angering and depressing.

It's an unbelievably medieval way to kill someone.

Joey Kamikaze
08-29-2014, 04:13 PM
They've never been revealed and probably never will be. And probably should never be.

This.

Not really strictly relevant to the topic, but since it's about the turtles as humans - it's really quite dark that it's implied that the boys are executed by decapitation. That is quite dark for a non-Mirage turtles iteration, if you think about it - children being beheaded.

There are a number of dark moments in IDW, stuff on par with the Mirage canon. The way they died back then, Casey's home life, Baxter just straight capping Old Hob, Shredder trying to psychologically break Alopex by burning down her homeland. IDW's just in color and not so 90's over-the-top violent so it doesn't always get as much credit for those moments. (I still think Leo should have killed someone in "City Fall," though.)

Davetello
08-29-2014, 04:18 PM
This.



There are a number of dark moments in IDW, stuff on par with the Mirage canon. The way they died back then, Casey's home life, Baxter just straight capping Old Hob, Shredder trying to psychologically break Alopex by burning down her homeland. IDW's just in color and not so 90's over-the-top violent so it doesn't always get as much credit for those moments. (I still think Leo should have killed someone in "City Fall," though.)

Agree with all of that - I just mentioned it because it loosely pertained to the thread and because I'd argue that that incident trumps everything.

Dark Leo was pretty disturbing in places. I agree he should have killed someone.

The Big Bad
08-29-2014, 05:53 PM
They've never been revealed and probably never will be. And probably should never be.

I would tend to agree, if not for the fact that the series seems intent in revisiting this era and its characters. Depending on what sort of focus these characters get, keeping them nameless may turn out to be impractical.

TheWarrior97
08-29-2014, 09:00 PM
I actually like the IDW story better than any other interpretation...by far. I feel like it actually makes sense...and is intriguing. Therefore, I feel in that respect, his children need names...Japanese names. So I wouldn't be upset at all if this is done later down the road.

-My opinion-

snake
08-29-2014, 09:07 PM
I actually like the IDW story better than any other interpretation...by far. I feel like it actually makes sense...and is intriguing. Therefore, I feel in that respect, his children need names...Japanese names. So I wouldn't be upset at all if this is done later down the road.

-My opinion-

I feel the same about IDW, although I don't think they need names.

spookycookies
08-30-2014, 12:45 AM
I don't know about them having previous names attached to their current identities as it would make the names April gave them somewhat less valid. Think of it this way, even though these brothers were born and raised in feudal Japan they are maturing now as turtles in modern New York. Part of growing up is finding yourself and establishing who you are and the Italian names are part of that. Yes their basic natures are present in their human lives but now as turtles they have come into their own and we should embrace that.

shuriken
08-30-2014, 01:40 AM
I actually like the IDW story better than any other interpretation...by far. I feel like it actually makes sense...and is intriguing. Therefore, I feel in that respect, his children need names...Japanese names. So I wouldn't be upset at all if this is done later down the road.

-My opinion-

They don't need names. It wouldn't add anything to the story.
What difference would it make if they were named Mako, Shen, Ryu and Jin in their passed life? Will they start using those names instead?
They are Leonardo, Donatello, Michelangelo and Raphael, and that's what matters.
Not trying to bust ur balls er anything I just personally feel its unnecessary.

neatoman
08-30-2014, 03:55 AM
Well they do have real names (it would be weird if Yoshi never called them anything before the reincarnation) but I don't think we'll ever find out what they are. Maybe Splinter can't remember or he prefers to not have the turtles know.

But that don't mean we can't speculate! So I think a good guess might be that they share names with Japanese artists same as they share names with Italian artists. Since I don't know the names of any classic Japanese artists I'm just going with Manga artists.

Leo = Osamu
Raph = Shotaro
Don = Hayao
Mikey = Kiyoshi

Venom
08-30-2014, 07:01 PM
(I still think Leo should have killed someone in "City Fall," though.)

You know, the act of killing and the consequences thereof was supposed to be a major theme in the second year of TMNT, yet all we got was Leo stabbing Slash and going emo a few issues. :ohwell:

Candy Kappa
08-31-2014, 04:50 AM
Some of the Foot Leo slashed in the micro comic, should have been dead, or at least presumed dead by Leo. One Foot was cut over his chest... That's usually lethal unless that Foot had some armor under those clothes.

ticktack
08-31-2014, 05:42 AM
Tang Shen also died, why she wasn't reincarnated?

Oroku Saki reincarnated though? (uhhhh, so, medievil Japan.)
·Oroku Saki is immortal.
·He dies sometime even if it was an aging problem.
__·Oroku Saki isn't straightly Shredder, there was some sort of magic in between so he is still he with a different body.
_____·He has a different name with a different body or remained with the same name.
_______· his name could have been an inheritage from older Oroku Saki-self to newer Oroku Saki self. Is his old self could be a great-grandfather type to his newer-self ...
____________·so is that from where he remembers his old-self name? Where/How Splinter knew his old-self name?
Position: investigative :tconfuse::tcool:

OP - TheWarrior97 you won't be bothered with such response, will you? :D

Candy Kappa
08-31-2014, 06:28 AM
Oroku Saki is the reincarnation of Takeshi Tatsuo. Tatsuo was the founder of the Foot Cal and was killed by Oroku Maji (Saki's father)

TheWarrior97
08-31-2014, 05:51 PM
They don't need names. It wouldn't add anything to the story.
What difference would it make if they were named Mako, Shen, Ryu and Jin in their passed life? Will they start using those names instead?
They are Leonardo, Donatello, Michelangelo and Raphael, and that's what matters.
Not trying to bust ur balls er anything I just personally feel its unnecessary.

You can't bust my balls :)

Since IDW are associating the turtles with the spirit of their human counterpart, I feel they should have names...just like splinter does and shredder does. IDW is creating a solid story that melds together. Solid stories have names. Just look at Eastman's 2012 annual...nearly every page Kevin introduces us to characters with a bold face name of someone that doesn't even last beyond the end of the comic. He thinks names are important.

If not your story might sound like this....this guy met this other guy who kicked this alien's rear and then the girlfriend ran away with the 1st cousin once removed of her neighbors closest friends son

Concerning keeping the names they have now, I highly doubt Hamato Yoshi knew the names of Renaissance painters at that time...thus they need Japanese names.

In my eyes, it signifies a solid past, and helps create a new beginning in present day New York.

Is Hamato Yoshi relevant to the story?

We also knew how they graphically died...shouldn't we also know their names...rather than son 1, son 2, son 3.

Finally, IDW made it a point to show them as human children of Yoshi...yet they didn't give us a name. Heck, they even went as far as matching colors.

Just a detail I thought should have been included that I hope shows up down the road.

TheWarrior97
08-31-2014, 06:00 PM
Well they do have real names (it would be weird if Yoshi never called them anything before the reincarnation) but I don't think we'll ever find out what they are. Maybe Splinter can't remember or he prefers to not have the turtles know.

But that don't mean we can't speculate! So I think a good guess might be that they share names with Japanese artists same as they share names with Italian artists. Since I don't know the names of any classic Japanese artists I'm just going with Manga artists.

Leo = Osamu
Raph = Shotaro
Don = Hayao
Mikey = Kiyoshi

I think that's a great idea, maybe IDEA + Works will give some thought to these names

Japanese names have meaning to them though. Names could be chosen based on the personality of the character...you know, to show more significance to what some people find insignificant. ;) (shuriken)

TheWarrior97
08-31-2014, 06:04 PM
Tang Shen also died, why she wasn't reincarnated?

Oroku Saki reincarnated though? (uhhhh, so, medievil Japan.)
·Oroku Saki is immortal.
·He dies sometime even if it was an aging problem.
__·Oroku Saki isn't straightly Shredder, there was some sort of magic in between so he is still he with a different body.
_____·He has a different name with a different body or remained with the same name.
_______· his name could have been an inheritage from older Oroku Saki-self to newer Oroku Saki self. Is his old self could be a great-grandfather type to his newer-self ...
____________·so is that from where he remembers his old-self name? Where/How Splinter knew his old-self name?
Position: investigative :tconfuse::tcool:

OP - TheWarrior97 you won't be bothered with such response, will you? :D

Truthfully, I need to reread the SHOTFC, because I got a little sidetracked. Once I do that maybe I can think about this better.

shuriken
08-31-2014, 06:31 PM
You can't bust my balls :)
.

Awesome.

Is Hamato Yoshi relevant to the story?

.
Totally He and Oroku Saki are the two feuding throughout various centuries. I respect your opinion I just don't agree with them needing names.

Coola Yagami
08-31-2014, 07:02 PM
I say why not? Anyone that disagrees just isn't on board with the reincarnation origin and just leave the comic shop. It's a part of the comic, like it or not, why not go all out?

I'd say we should at least know. It won't change the story, nor do they have a reason to suddenly start using their older names. If I found out I was some guy named Oscar in a previous life... I wouldn't suddenly change my name to Oscar now. I am who I am now, and I'll continue my own path. I say the Turtles, or at least, us as the readers should know for the sake of knowing. Like maybe some flashback from Splinter's point of view where he calls them by names. The turtles would never know, but at least the readers would.

Mikey Jones
08-31-2014, 08:20 PM
Not really strictly relevant to the topic, but since it's about the turtles as humans - it's really quite dark that it's implied that the boys are executed by decapitation. That is quite dark for a non-Mirage turtles iteration, if you think about it - children being beheaded.

As morbid is it is, I liked this idea as the possible reason they were reincarnated as Turtles.
As some Turtles can retract their heads as a defence mechanism. :teek:

ProphetofGanja
09-02-2014, 04:29 PM
I feel like revealing the Turtles' previous-life human names is unnecessary. Now that we've had The Secret History of the Foot Clan mini-series and the Feudal Japan issue of the Turtles in Time mini-series, I don't see that time period being revisited in-depth for a while, so there's no need for their names to be revealed. I know it irks some people's nerves that we don't know their human names but like others have said, what would it add to the story? None of the Turtles would start going by that name instead. Even Splinter is now known as Splinter, even though he knows his existence is continuing on from when he was Hamato Yoshi. Hamato Yoshi is Splinter is Hamato Yoshi.

It's like in Samurai Jack. That's just his nickname, given to him by some dude he encountered right when he got to the future. Does not knowing his real name detract from the story? No, not at all

ctt4lfecw
09-02-2014, 05:14 PM
lol how about Hamato Blue, Hamato Red, Hamato Orange and Hamato Purple?

shuriken
09-03-2014, 06:49 PM
^^^YES
I say why not? Anyone that disagrees just isn't on board with the reincarnation origin and just leave the comic shop. It's a part of the comic, like it or not, why not go all out?

Oh don't get me wrong I love the reincarnation aspect of it. I find it a refreshing take and makes a lot more sense than any other incarnation. It works. And as I said I personally feel it doesn't add to the story and is unnecessary. But I am %100 against it? No why should I be? If they decide to do a flashback story then so be it.
I'm looking at it through this perspective: Would knowing their Japanese names add anything to the story and or bring about any interesting facts other than Donatello was named Hayoa in his past life?

chrisdude
09-05-2014, 06:19 PM
I think if they still haven't told us by Turtles In Time #2, they've made a decision not to. I think it would just complicate things anyway, and wouldn't really anything. While I don't mind the reincarnation angle, I do feel like it creeps in enough, if not too much, what with visions of Tang Shen and such. I would personally prefer to get past it...

Coola Yagami
09-05-2014, 08:56 PM
That's the thing though. It doesn't have to change the story. It's just a little fact to know. You know, like knowing Mikey's favorite pizza toppings or that Donnie keeps a little teddy bear named binky under his bed. Just a 'did you know' kinda thing. Not everything has to affect the overall narrative or else the characters are just trapped telling exposition all the time. As it is now it's ok but it does feel kinda odd to go into issue 100 and still not know.

Cryomancer
09-05-2014, 09:43 PM
What are some artists (perhaps weapon makers) that were famous in the time period? There you go.

Coola Yagami
09-05-2014, 10:46 PM
That's actually an interesting idea. It's like Yoshi (and Tang Shen) named their kids after their favorite artists.... and now in their new life, that character trait remained and Splinter re-named the turtles after his current favorite artists.

That's pretty clever.

Tazi
09-06-2014, 02:56 AM
and now in their new life, that character trait remained and Splinter re-named the turtles after his current favorite artists
Yea, but April named them.

Coola Yagami
09-06-2014, 09:39 AM
Yea, but April named them.

Oh damn. Yeah I forgot. I wonder how as normal turtles they remembered what April named them.

Tazi
09-06-2014, 11:37 AM
I think that can be explained with Splinter getting injected with the psychotrophic serum, and having above-rat intelligence, and human-like consciousness. He probably picked up how April and Lindsey called them.

chrisdude
09-06-2014, 06:16 PM
I think that can be explained with Splinter getting injected with the psychotrophic serum, and having above-rat intelligence, and human-like consciousness. He probably picked up how April and Lindsey called them.Thats the impression I was under.

Coola Yagami
09-07-2014, 01:11 AM
Thats the impression I was under.

I think that's how it went actually... man, it's been forever since I read those issues...

Tazi
09-07-2014, 04:00 AM
I think that's how it went actually... man, it's been forever since I read those issues...

Yeap, me too. One more reason to pick the HC in October. ;)