PDA

View Full Version : Is IDW TMNT getting a little cramped with too many characters?


CyberCubed
09-09-2014, 12:20 AM
I can't help but realize how the main and villain cast in IDW TMNT has literally quadrupled recently, with a lot of characters competing for screentime:

Heroes:

- 4 Turtles
- Splinter (and Tang Shen)
- April
- Casey
- Angel
- April's parents
- Kirby Fan 01
- Fugitoid
- Renet
- Metalhead
- Neutrinos

Shredder's army:

- Shredder
- Kitsune
- Karai
- Hun
- Bebop and Rocksteady
- Koya
- Bludgeon
- Alopex (former)
- Foot Soldiers

Krang's army:

- Krang
- Traag and Granitor
- Baxter Stockman
- Utroms

Hob's gang:

- Old Hob
- Slash
- Pigeon Pete
- More mutants hinted

And on top of that we now have The Rat King, Leatherhead hinted, and Triceratons in the mix.

Anyone else think this is a hell of a lot of characters competing for screentime? I love the fact that IDW was able to introduce so many major TMNT characters so quickly, but now comes the problem of having this huge cast of characters and villains all competing and eating up each others screentime.

Anyone else curious how they're going to handle such a bloated cast, especially with new characters coming in every couple of issues?

spookycookies
09-09-2014, 12:47 AM
I don't think the Neutrinos or Pete are going to be eating up too many double spreads in the coming months. I agree that we do have a steadily growing cast and I think this will best be handled by the companion book. The Micros did a great job of adding in much needed depth and context during CityFall and Utrom Empire put the technodrome on everyones radar.

Turtles in Time seems to be have consequences throughout the series in a paradox-y way and word has been that Ghostbusters mini will be in-continuity. If you look at the numbered issues and the mini/micro issues there's been around 76 issues of IDW roughly and potential for everyone to get their 15 minutes.

Of course the main book is going to focus on the most important plot point of the moment... TMNT #37 spoilers 37 didn't feature the Turtles at all, the guys the book is named after, yet it was able to handle their absence more than gracefully.

I think that Harold & Nobody are due for their own issue, and I wouldn't mind seeing Slash tangle with some of Shredders mutants or even Metal Head for that matter.

The cast is getting bigger and bigger but I think that Tom, Kevin, Bobby and the rest of the gang are handling it very well and will continue to do so.

CyberCubed
09-09-2014, 01:26 AM
I'm just wondering how they're going to balance the screentime between all the new mutant henchmen. We now have Bebop/Rocksteady, Koya and Bludgeon all working for Shredder, along with Karai and Hun as his minions as well. How is this all going to work?

I mean they only have so many pages and issue to devote to characters before moving the plot forward, and unless we get new micro's I wonder if characters like Koya or Bludgeon will have any time to shine besides being fighting machines? I also hope Bebop/Rocksteady don't fade to the background because of more mutants.

neatoman
09-09-2014, 01:55 AM
I'm actually really fine with the amount of characters, just go look at a character list for let's say X-Men and you'll notice that it's not really that many characters by comparison, Hell, even solo hero titles like Spider-Man has more characters than this.

At least none of the characters feel like they're introduced just to be introduced instead of playing a role in the story, I'm actually far more worried about the Nickelodeon cartoon handle characters. Seriously, at least they haven't introduced over a dozen minor characters in less than two years.

shuriken
09-09-2014, 03:24 AM
It's fine. And no it doesn't feel cramped, Shredder wants an Army both Human and Mutant and that's what he has.

Icegaze
09-09-2014, 10:41 AM
Sorry, where did Renet make an appearance in the IDW comics? Did I miss something?
Or are we also including the Annuals?

Tazi
09-09-2014, 10:52 AM
Sorry, where did Renet make an appearance in the IDW comics? Did I miss something?
Or are we also including the Annuals?

Turtles in Time 1-3, Annual 2014

Why wouldn't we include the annuals? Those are part of the IDW canon.


I don't think there are so many characters yet, and soon we gonna reach #50 which one will have a bodycount anyway. Besides, not every character have to be flashed out. Hob can make 30 new mutants for his army, but 28 of them can be a "footsoldier/generic henchman" type of characters.

plastroncafe
09-09-2014, 11:18 AM
Answer: no.

ProphetofGanja
09-09-2014, 11:38 AM
I do think it is a lot of characters but I think IDW can handle it, they have so far done a bang-up job of storytelling in this series. I do want to see more character development for Angel/Nobody, she seems to be one of the characters that's becoming more instrumental to the plot that has yet to be explored in great depth.

I think a lot of the secondary characters will get fleshed out in mini-series

CyberCubed
09-09-2014, 12:07 PM
I don't think there are so many characters yet, and soon we gonna reach #50 which one will have a bodycount anyway. .

I've thought of character deaths, but would IDW really have the guts to kill off iconic TMNT characters other than Shredder at some point?

I mean who would be the first to get killed off? They can likely get away with killing Pigeon Pete and maybe either Koya or Bludgeon at some point, but I think Old Hob is in it for the long haul as he's the breakout character for the series.

ctt4lfecw
09-09-2014, 12:41 PM
I think everything is fine. They know what they're doing.

Tazi
09-09-2014, 01:10 PM
I think Hun will die, and Shredder will get his body completely destroyed. Maybe Slash dies too. Something like this.

I hope they don't plan to kill off Hob, he is one of the reasons why I read this book.

ProphetofGanja
09-09-2014, 01:17 PM
I've thought of character deaths, but would IDW really have the guts to kill off iconic TMNT characters other than Shredder at some point?

I mean who would be the first to get killed off? They can likely get away with killing Pigeon Pete and maybe either Koya or Bludgeon at some point, but I think Old Hob is in it for the long haul as he's the breakout character for the series.


I think Hun will possibly die at some point, but who knows how soon.
Shredder I can actually see outlasting Hun, but being out of the picture for a long, long time
Krang I can see eventually being killed
I think the Foot losing either Koya or Bludgeon would be a huge victory for the Turtles and would make Shredder really step his game up
Pigeon Pete!?!? No!!! lol. Even though I think his character is mostly there for comic relief, I don't think they'd kill him off, because what's the point? He's not a threat so it wouldn't be worth anyone's energy to off him. But maybe he will just wander off and go do his own thing. If he doesn't get a shot of the psychotropic serum (or ooze or whatever it is now) I can see him going off to just hang out with regular pigeons
I can see Slash sacrificing himself for the Turtles if he had too

Coola Yagami
09-09-2014, 01:22 PM
No. Not at all. I mean do you ever read comics? Do you know how many characters batman and spiderman have? Do you think every issue of the xmen stars every member of the team ever??

Even the Archie comics had a huge cast of characters.

You're probably not used to the tmnt having a long ongoing comic series without volume breaks and whatnot. That's just how comics work.

And most of the charactes you listed are not characters that are obligated to be in every issue.

So no. The series is just fine character-wise. If anything it needs more non-krang and non-shredder related villains.

Tazi
09-09-2014, 01:34 PM
It needs more Bishop...

Technogeek29
09-09-2014, 01:40 PM
Continue wher Coola and tazi left off...

I'm not sure where Leatherhead will fit, most likely with Hob? But I don't count Kitsune part of the Foot clan Fold and her brother is definetly in it for himself. I'm very curious of Bishop's role if he appears? Of course he'll be going after Krang and I wouldn't be surprised if he's captured several of them already. Including other aliens

Candy Kappa
09-09-2014, 01:55 PM
No, don't be silly.

Tazi
09-09-2014, 02:26 PM
I just realized: If Leatherhead is created in hundreds of years ago without the psychotropic serum, that would explain his "bipolar disorder" that he has in 4Kids and Nick, if he has it in IDW too.
Also, it would make sense to add him for Krang's side for a while, because Krang has like no decent soldiers. Well he has Tragg & Granitor but even foot newbie mutants beat them. Even storyline wise he needs a better enforcer who can handle a fight with the turtles, and I'm pretty sure something like that will happen. Maybe Stockman will build him Chromedome, or he hires some assasin from Dimension X (Antrax?). Or he just creates some mutants too.

CyberCubed
09-09-2014, 02:38 PM
I think Baxter might betray Krang to Shredder soon. Baxter would probably much rather a human take over the planet than an alien who plans to kill all humans.

ChosenOne
09-09-2014, 02:49 PM
It needs more Bishop...

This. More Bishop, more Leatherhead, more Zog, more Rat King, more Cudley, more Null, more Maligna, more Wingnut & Screwloose, more Chromedome, more Savanti Romero, more elite Foot, more Armaggon, more, more, more.

IDW can handle it just fine.

Tazi
09-09-2014, 02:58 PM
This. More Bishop, more Leatherhead, more Zog, more Rat King, more Cudley, more Null, more Maligna, more Wingnut & Screwloose, more Chromedome, more Savanti Romero, more elite Foot, more Armaggon, more, more, more.
I hope this will be #50-100 at least! :)

Kilowog
09-09-2014, 05:08 PM
Given the creative team's track record and handling of the series, no

Rooish
09-09-2014, 07:14 PM
Yes.

I don't read other comics so I don't know if this is standard fare. But I really miss the turtles themselves. Seriously, if you are a Don fan you have not seen him for three issues, maybe four--I'm concerned #38 won't have the Turtles in it. It's too bad because they had awesome development. I guess the argument could be that they've gotten enough development; they can sit on the sidelines for a bit and it's still their comic. But in a monthly format, you start really getting psyched to read it again, to see your favourite characters again, and they are in it for like a quarter of the book if at all. The series is well written and each character is very cool, but yeah it's hard to juggle such a cast. Also Angel needs a micro!

qt.bangerang
09-09-2014, 07:30 PM
No.

I love that there is so much going on. It would be really boring if it was just the Turtles fighting the Foot every issue.

spookycookies
09-09-2014, 07:48 PM
Yes.

I don't read other comics so I don't know if this is standard fare. But I really miss the turtles themselves. Seriously, if you are a Don fan you have not seen him for three issues, maybe four--I'm concerned #38 won't have the Turtles in it. It's too bad because they had awesome development. I guess the argument could be that they've gotten enough development; they can sit on the sidelines for a bit and it's still their comic. But in a monthly format, you start really getting psyched to read it again, to see your favourite characters again, and they are in it for like a quarter of the book if at all. The series is well written and each character is very cool, but yeah it's hard to juggle such a cast. Also Angel needs a micro!

Yeah Donny hasn't been in the main book but if you check out Turtles in Time it doesn't feel like he has been missing at all. #32-#36 takes place all across a single night I believe just checking in and out all around town with Casey threading through each issue.

Joey Kamikaze
09-09-2014, 11:01 PM
Yes.

I don't read other comics so I don't know if this is standard fare. But I really miss the turtles themselves. Seriously, if you are a Don fan you have not seen him for three issues, maybe four--I'm concerned #38 won't have the Turtles in it. It's too bad because they had awesome development. I guess the argument could be that they've gotten enough development; they can sit on the sidelines for a bit and it's still their comic. But in a monthly format, you start really getting psyched to read it again, to see your favourite characters again, and they are in it for like a quarter of the book if at all. The series is well written and each character is very cool, but yeah it's hard to juggle such a cast. Also Angel needs a micro!

The point of the last arc was to split the turtles into individual stories that happened over a single night. #34 was Don (with April, Harold & Angel), #35 was Raph & Mikey (with Lindsey, Hob & Slash) and #36 was Leo (with Splinter and the Rat King). And we got Casey Jones' story across each issue. #37 happens around the same time as Turtles In Time, so the boys are absent. #38 picks up after TiT and should be back to business as usual.

Joey Kamikaze
09-09-2014, 11:17 PM
To actually answer the question, I want to keep seeing the cast expand so long as IDW is doing a great job using that cast, and so far they have. I wasn't expecting Hun to become interesting so quickly when he just kind of popped into relevance mid-City Fall, but he's been great in MM&M. There are classic characters I still want to see in IDW that haven't appeared yet, especially Null.

My expectation (which could be wrong) is that after the whole Technodrome story comes to its head around #50, both Krang and Shredder are going to be minimized in the story for a while, off to lick their wounds. They could even kill Krang I suppose, though considering how early TMNTA got rid of him too it would be a shame. But once those two are gone other antagonists like Karai, Old Hob, Kitsune, the Rat King and whomever else pops up will have time to shine.

neatoman
09-10-2014, 02:01 PM
Come to think of it, for now I think Hob's gang will mostly be treated as henchmen for now, like Koya and Bludgeon. It's probably for the best.

I know someone out there will be disappointed that such A-list characters like Perri Grey will just be henchmen but they can get more developed later on.

Sophie Campbell
09-10-2014, 04:27 PM
i'd be so pissed if they killed Koya.

CyberCubed
09-10-2014, 07:18 PM
i'd be so pissed if they killed Koya.

Other than Shredder, I imagine the first deaths of the comic will be some expendable mutant henchmen. And with Bebop/Rocksteady being too iconic, Alopex being connected to Kitsune, and Old Hob being the breakout character, I'd say any of the other mutant henchmen are expendable.

I can see Slash sacrificing himself for the Turtles like he did in Archie, but I'd rather he stick around for a while before it happens.

Coola Yagami
09-10-2014, 07:51 PM
Other than Shredder, I imagine the first deaths of the comic will be some expendable mutant henchmen. And with Bebop/Rocksteady being too iconic, Alopex being connected to Kitsune, and Old Hob being the breakout character, I'd say any of the other mutant henchmen are expendable.

I can see Slash sacrificing himself for the Turtles like he did in Archie, but I'd rather he stick around for a while before it happens.

Koya is kinda expendable until she gets more personality than 'kill kill kill'. I'm sure they'll develop her though. She has such a sweet kick-ass design it's a literal waste to get rid of her so easily.

Who or what is Bludgeon and what issue did he/she appear? The most recent one that just came out?

I'd also like to see more of 'normal intelligence' Slash before anything happens to him.

Kingoji
09-11-2014, 02:09 AM
Totally the cast should expand. That's healthy for any comic. If a book stuck to the same dozen or so characters without bringing in fresh blood then it would soon get boring.

However, if the question had been along the lines of "are they bringing in too many new characters too quickly" then I think it might be worthy of more consideration.

ProphetofGanja
09-11-2014, 10:55 AM
Totally the cast should expand. That's healthy for any comic. If a book stuck to the same dozen or so characters without bringing in fresh blood then it would soon get boring.


I don't think expansion simply for expansion's sake is ever a good thing, characters have to be brought in organically, for a reason

I think IDW has done a good job of that so far

Kingoji
09-11-2014, 11:32 AM
Well, obviously. What I mean is if the TMNT franchise had a policy of only using, say, the four bros, Splinter, Casey, April, Shredder and the Foot and say Karai and a couple of major hechmen/mutants, I doubt we'd still all be here 30 years later.

Of course, you do run the risk when a cast gets so big that a character that was someone's favourite may be all but forgotten for a very long time. *glances wistfully at own avatar*

corvus
09-11-2014, 12:06 PM
The only ones I think we haven't seen enough of is Bebop & Rocksteady and the Fugitoid. I'm taking into account how new the others are. Krang didn't get much attention for awhile but thats changing very fast. Triceratons, metalhead, Koya and Bludgeon are very new so its too early to say. Harold and Aprils parents shouldnt be in every issue.

ProphetofGanja
09-11-2014, 02:08 PM
Well, obviously. What I mean is if the TMNT franchise had a policy of only using, say, the four bros, Splinter, Casey, April, Shredder and the Foot and say Karai and a couple of major hechmen/mutants, I doubt we'd still all be here 30 years later.

Of course, you do run the risk when a cast gets so big that a character that was someone's favourite may be all but forgotten for a very long time. *glances wistfully at own avatar*

oh yeah of course

also, who is your avatar??

Kingoji
09-11-2014, 05:11 PM
That would be Ninjara.

miru
09-11-2014, 07:10 PM
I don't think there's too many just yet.

Chabrendeki
11-02-2014, 01:59 AM
I tend to say, yes, there are.

But this is not without reason - it's something like a soap: there is a huge story but without any recognizable shape and form, and the main dramaturgic function of the each parts is, to let the story floating further. (And so you can rarely have really dramatic peaks or end moments, but you can have slow and close character developments and 'secrets', that hook you up for a longer time - so it has his merits and his disadvantages.)

And that's the reason why there are so many characters and plots - so the writer can always switch from one to another and keep the story floating, with no end in sight.

Don't misunderstand me: I'm fine with this, this dramaturgy works fine, and is already established in many other media, and in other comics aswell. Just wanted to reason it, why we have so many characters.

snake
11-02-2014, 12:21 PM
No way. They handle the characters they have perfectly.

Chabrendeki
11-02-2014, 12:46 PM
I haven't said, they don't...