PDA

View Full Version : TMNT #40 Discussion


SDCC
11-24-2014, 11:09 AM
Dudes and dudettes.

With the new issue not out until Monday but I thought I'd get some discussion going now.

My main question being...how are Bebop and Rocksteady going to be beaten? Can they be?

I knocked up a review over at http://www.superdstuff.com/2014/11/tmnt-40.html. There is a spoiler section but it's separate so you can avoid it :tgrin:

Am I correct in thinking that #50 is where it's all going to completely kick off? I try to avoid the solicitations.

snake
11-24-2014, 02:23 PM
The issue is out?

neatoman
11-24-2014, 02:32 PM
The issue is out?

This week but not today.

snake
11-24-2014, 02:33 PM
This week but not today.

Okay. SDCC got an early copy?

ProphetofGanja
11-24-2014, 02:47 PM
Dudes and dudettes.

With the new issue not out until Monday but I thought I'd get some discussion going now.

Wait what now? #40 isn't coming out til Monday?

Joey Kamikaze
11-24-2014, 05:23 PM
It's out Wednesday in the US AFAIK. SDCC always gets early review copies (lucky).

SDCC
11-25-2014, 03:27 AM
Hi guys,

Joey's right I do get early review copies, though I have to apologise as not only should it have said Wednesday, but it shouldn't have bee posted until today. I got a bit keen and jumped the gun.

But it will be back up a bit later. I am very lucky to get them! I write for a larger website and my reviews are written for both that site and my own blog. The main difference is I add the spoiler section on my blog.

There'll be a review for GB/TMNT #2 later this week too :)


EDIT - It's back up

ProphetofGanja
11-25-2014, 10:04 PM
can't wait til this issue drops on comixology so I can read it

MikeandRaph87
11-25-2014, 10:33 PM
SDCC,Mr. Waltz already opened a discussion for this issue when he posted the preview Friday afternoon. Venom, could you kindly merge/edit this thread with Tom's thread? Thanks.

As for the issue,I am quite curious how Bebop and Rocksteady are going to be made into a serious threat instead of a joke that just one of the up to ten opponents could take out with a simple leaping out of the way and having them run into something to k.o. themselves. Can they be cool? Fun? Serious? A mix of it all?

Perhaps I am jumping ahead but what could Stockman's role be in Attack On The Technodrome?

ChosenOne
11-26-2014, 09:35 AM
And the Golden Utrom for best fight scene yet in the IDW run goes to...

Seriously, what a great issue! Santolouco outdid himself! :thumbsup: And that last page, oooh boy!

SDCC
11-26-2014, 10:05 AM
Donnie really is treading a thin line I think.

Santolouco never fails to amaze me. I'm even starting to get used to the slightly odd looking bandanas that Leo and Donnie wear over their noses as opposed to Raph and Mikey.

snake
11-26-2014, 11:11 AM
This was the best fight in the book since Leo vs Krang. This really got me pumped for next month.

ChosenOne
11-26-2014, 01:53 PM
Donnie really is treading a thin line I think.

See, I'm not sure he is... I went back and reread issues 38-39, and Leo seems awful quiet after the offscreen talk he had with Donnie some time during 38. He never gets around to telling Mikey and Raph what it was about (at least that we know of), but what if Donnie reaching out to Shredder was Leo's plan all along? He did have an eureka moment in 36 that is yet to pan out. I think this is it, a plan to take out Krang and weaken the Foot in one fell swoop, pitting them against each other. Time will tell if I'm right.

neatoman
11-26-2014, 01:54 PM
I thought Bebop and Rocksteady were hilarious in this, the electrocution takes the cake.

hypnock
11-26-2014, 02:08 PM
For Raph and Alopex

http://i3.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/original/000/007/582/tumblr_lmputme3co1qa6q7k_large.png

Plasticplayhouse
11-26-2014, 03:31 PM
I loooved this issue! Great fight sequence and b&r were hilarious. Rabies, rabies was my favorite part. I actually lol'd! Story & art for the win!!

ProphetofGanja
11-26-2014, 03:49 PM
See, I'm not sure he is... I went back and reread issues 38-39, and Leo seems awful quiet after the offscreen talk he had with Donnie some time during 38. He never gets around to telling Mikey and Raph what it was about (at least that we know of), but what if Donnie reaching out to Shredder was Leo's plan all along? He did have an eureka moment in 36 that is yet to pan out. I think this is it, a plan to take out Krang and weaken the Foot in one fell swoop, pitting them against each other. Time will tell if I'm right.

I think you're right on the money

I thought Bebop and Rocksteady were hilarious in this, the electrocution takes the cake.

They are equal parts hilarious and formidable. I don't know what it would take to keep them down permanently

This was a great issue. Waltz, Eastman, and Burnham are an incredibly skilled team and Santolouco's artistic execution is flawless. This is my favorite iteration of the TMNT, by far.

ChosenOne
11-26-2014, 03:58 PM
I think you're right on the money

Thanks. I could, of course, be wrong, but when you read those issues with that angle in mind, it all seems to fit perfectly.

And it would go a long way towards explaining why Raph and Splinter are "okay" with a Shredder team-up in the next arc, without wasting 1-2 issues on angsty family drama.

Kendamu
11-26-2014, 04:15 PM
First off, the brawl in this issue was really awesome! I was pumped!

Second, if Don and Leo are secretly plotting to pit the Foot and Krang's forces against each other to stop the Technodrome and weaken the Foot, I could see this leading to a Foot/Krang alliance. Basically, Krang and Shredder will blame the Turtles for both of their failures after Shredder realizes that he's been played. Then, they'll team up to take down the Turtles.

I don't think that alliance will last, though, if the future that the Turtles traveled to indicates anything. The world is split up into Foot and Krang territories in that future.

Icegaze
11-26-2014, 04:57 PM
This was the best fight in the book since Leo vs Krang. This really got me pumped for next month.

Was a good fighting chapter with a lot of balance, but the best in my opinion still remains Shredder vs Krang on the boat of doom.
Also, I wonder why Santolouco has done a 180 with his character designs. I really miss the City Fall arc artwork. That was his best IMO. Lately, his turtles look too cute, just like Ross Campbell. And did Alopex shrink or was she wearing high heels before? Sorry for the fuss but this is a pet peeve of mine. Great plot though which is what matters most.

Powder
11-26-2014, 05:12 PM
Some of Santolouco's illest work to date! I am so in love with Hob's army, man, they're great. I wasn't happy about the book taking a mutant-heavy turn, but these guys are awesome, I can't be mad. Psyched for their minis more than ever.

ProphetofGanja
11-26-2014, 09:03 PM
just reread the issue. Even though the issue was almost nothing but non-stop action, there was still plenty of character/plot development.

I loved seeing Raph open up to Alopex while they were trapped in the pigeon coop debris. I'm guessing he felt more comfortable confiding in her, both to help clear up the tension that was between them initially and because Raph would be self-conscious of his brothers viewing him differently

I loved that Pete got a chance to be helpful!

I loved Master Splinter calling Rocksteady "Rhinoceros Man" and then whooping his and Bebop's asses with ninja finesse

I loved how hard it was to take down Bebop & Rocksteady (even though it made me worried for Splinter and the Turtles!)

I LOVED that Angel and Alopex are partnering up to do whatever!

I loved seeing Hob show affection towards his comrades

I loved the implication that Don and Leo are planning to con the Foot into doing their dirty work for them

MikeandRaph87
11-26-2014, 09:53 PM
Are we using this thread or Tom's thread to discuss this issue?

Bebop and Rocksteady are indestructible,huh? Electrocuted and had a building dropped on them and still shrug it off!

Tender moment between Raphael and Alopex was defintely a callback to Raphael/Ninjara. I hope it will be more of a Leo/Karai relationship in the 2003 cartoon for Raphael and Alopex.

Hob actually in story refers to themselves as The Mighty Mutanimals. He offers Alopex and she actually turned him down. I bet most of us saw her joinning up. She could have taken Pete's place! Hob has a softspot for Pete,who needs the antrropic(sp?) Serum like Slash got! Hob looks to have, in wrestling terms made a babyface turn. Just don't kill the Mutanimals off this time! Pete I will be okay with but the rest? Heck no! Looking forward to Null and getting a backstory hopefully with him too this time around!

Don had guts going to Shredder though I thought Fugitoid already took care of trying to get Shredder on Krang in the event of the Technodrome being completed?

Joey Kamikaze
11-26-2014, 10:26 PM
Is it me, or was Hob drawn too cutely and written a bit too nicely at the end there? I don't want to see Hob become a good guy, I want to see him as an anti-hero at best.

Alopex and Angel teaming up is great (this could be a fun mini-series too), and I'm glad to see Don continues to be a major force in pushing forward the narrative post-City Fall. And damn is it great to see a giant Bebop and Rocksteady battle that isn't limited to 80's cartoon rules. Just an all around great issue, and one of the book's funner arcs on the whole.

Jeff
11-26-2014, 10:56 PM
A buddy of mine has a podcast called Pages and Panels and he invited me on yesterday to interview Mateus Santolouco about issue 40. Here's the link!

https://kyle-welch-c8u4.squarespace.com/blog/2014/11/25/pages-and-panels-51

Luckyday
11-27-2014, 01:31 AM
^ Santolouco sounds like a pretty cool guy.

neatoman
11-27-2014, 03:25 AM
Is it me, or was Hob drawn too cutely and written a bit too nicely at the end there? I don't want to see Hob become a good guy, I want to see him as an anti-hero at best.

I think it's misunderstanding between writer and artist, I think Waltz was going for Hob being happy that the first battle was successful and that the test could not have been possible without Pete, while Santoluoco thought it was more Hob becoming nicer.



Alopex and Angel teaming up is great (this could be a fun mini-series too), and I'm glad to see Don continues to be a major force in pushing forward the narrative post-City Fall. And damn is it great to see a giant Bebop and Rocksteady battle that isn't limited to 80's cartoon rules. Just an all around great issue, and one of the book's funner arcs on the whole.
Hopefully that's the Mini after Mutanimals, but I could see yet another set of Micros. Characters who don't yet have any are:

Angel
Koya
Bludgeon
Herman
Pete
Mondo
Slash
Rat King
Kitsune

ChosenOne
11-27-2014, 03:33 AM
The Mutanimals mini ends on the same month #46 comes out, so assuming the next mini is a companion arc for the run-up to #50, it's four issues as well.

MikeandRaph87
11-27-2014, 07:23 AM
The Mutanimals mini ends on the same month #46 comes out, so assuming the next mini is a companion arc for the run-up to #50, it's four issues as well.

No,I would rather see a set of four one shots based around the four immortal siblings. That is assuming Null is amongst the ranks of Rat King,Kitsune, and Chi-You. It makes the most sense especially since it would end when #50 hits and could act as an epilogue if Kitsune is saved for last. Null would go first Mutanimals mini would have just completed. Rat King and Chi-You can be interchangeable with #2 and #3. What do you all think? I hope I am onto something here!

ChosenOne
11-27-2014, 08:11 AM
No,I would rather see a set of four one shots based around the four immortal siblings. That is assuming Null is amongst the ranks of Rat King,Kitsune, and Chi-You. It makes the most sense especially since it would end when #50 hits and could act as an epilogue if Kitsune is saved for last. Null would go first Mutanimals mini would have just completed. Rat King and Chi-You can be interchangeable with #2 and #3. What do you all think? I hope I am onto something here!

Honestly, I don't think Chi-You gets a mini. I think his story will be done after TMNT/Ghostbusters, but I could of course be wrong.

PangolinFeets
11-27-2014, 11:19 AM
This issue gave me a lot of feels.

Yes, please continue to have B&R be basically indestructable because its way to much fun to see dozens of guys wailing on them to no avail. Meanwhile they're cracking jokes. XD This is why their micro is my favorite.
Loved Splinter action again. MS's artwork is seriously too notch. Absolutely loving these.

Raph and Alopex are too cute. Pretty soon he's gonna start calling her his fluffmuffin. :3 (Raphalopex? Aloaphael? Lawl)

BY FAR, my favorite thing about this issue is my BroTP hook up of Angel and Alopex. They make such a badass fun team. I can't wait to see some adorable snarky banter between those two.

The ending made me flip my ****. All I could think of was that Raphael might murder Donnie. o.o
I like the Leo fan theories though. That'd be awesome.

All I can say is that I CANT WAIT FOR MORE!!!!

ProphetofGanja
11-27-2014, 12:20 PM
So pumped for this. It'd be cool to see April join up with them for some missions
http://i1309.photobucket.com/albums/s625/a7-11/TMNTAlopexampAngel_zps022d1931.png~original

Seriously, these guys' stupidity is their only weakness
http://i1309.photobucket.com/albums/s625/a7-11/TMNTBebopampRocksteady_zps148a9251.png~original


The only comic series that leaves me waiting even more anxiously than IDW's TMNT is Saga by Image Comics. great series. Can't wait for the Attack on Technodrome arc to start!
http://i1309.photobucket.com/albums/s625/a7-11/TMNTFootClan_zpsb061c70d.png~original

funatic
11-27-2014, 12:29 PM
So pumped for this. It'd be cool to see April join up with them for some missions

Yeah, and maybe TMNT could pass the Bechdel Test for an issue. :trazz: (Tho maybe it happened with Karai/Kitsune & Alopex earlier?) Actually, that could be an interesting thread in itself collecting all the issues that pass.

For those saying "what the shell is a Bechdel test?!": http://wikipedia.org/wiki/Bechdel_test

ProphetofGanja
11-27-2014, 12:44 PM
Yeah, and maybe TMNT could pass the Bechdel Test for an issue. :trazz: (Tho maybe it happened with Karai/Kitsune & Alopex earlier?) Actually, that could be an interesting thread in itself collecting all the issues that pass.

For those saying "what the shell is a Bechdel test?!": http://wikipedia.org/wiki/Bechdel_test

Two women walk into a bar. One says to the other,"Have you ever heard of the Bechdel test?" The other says,"Yeah, my boyfriend was telling me about it the other day!"

But seriously. I want to say at least a few issues have passed the Bechdel test but I can't recall for sure. Would it count if they were talking about the Shredder, because in their context he would be more of an obstacle and not a male person

funatic
11-27-2014, 01:16 PM
Would it count if they were talking about the Shredder, because in their context he would be more of an obstacle and not a male person

Hmm, I think it would still count as he's still reflective of the male power hierarchy. (Lol, I never thought I'd be throwing terms like that around in a turtles forum... :tlol:)

ProphetofGanja
11-27-2014, 02:02 PM
Hmm, I think it would still count as he's still reflective of the male power hierarchy. (Lol, I never thought I'd be throwing terms like that around in a turtles forum... :tlol:)

True. I'm eager to see if Karai will resume leading the Foot Clan if Shredder is incapacitated in some way at some point down the line

funatic
11-27-2014, 11:38 PM
True. I'm eager to see if Karai will resume leading the Foot Clan if Shredder is incapacitated in some way at some point down the line

I imagine she will, the question is if it will be in a more benevolent roll like we've seen in the Mirage universe, or will she follow in Shredder's footsteps? Kitsune could also come into the Foot power-play. I have a feeling Shredder and Krang are going to be neutralized by issue 50 and then the evil god siblings (do they have a group name yet?) will become the primary antagonists for the series.

ChosenOne
11-28-2014, 03:34 AM
I imagine she will, the question is if it will be in a more benevolent roll like we've seen in the Mirage universe, or will she follow in Shredder's footsteps? Kitsune could also come into the Foot power-play. I have a feeling Shredder and Krang are going to be neutralized by issue 50 and then the evil god siblings (do they have a group name yet?) will become the primary antagonists for the series.

I hope we get Bishop and a Triceraton invasion arc some time shortly after 50, too.

DONATELLO DUZMACHINES
11-28-2014, 10:42 AM
What an amazing issue. Ive loved Santolouco's work through out the entire series but this by far is some of his hest, the writing was excellent as always. This has been the best action this series haa seen and there have been some pretty good action in the past. This incarnation of B&R is my favorite by far, they were always some of my favorite mutants back in the old toon, but they're done so much better here. Their design, their strength, I love everything about them. This never felt to crowded either, everyone had a chance to shine. My favorite moments whwre everything with Herman and the Raph and Apolex moments. Such a great issue

martinitolove
11-28-2014, 11:44 AM
Honestly, I don't think Chi-You gets a mini. I think his story will be done after TMNT/Ghostbusters, but I could of course be wrong.

So Kitsune is the puppeteer of the Foot Clan.

Rat King manipulates the Turtles.

Null does the same with Mutanimals?

Who else from TMNT history could be a god?

"If someone asks if you are a god, you say "yes!"

Powder
11-28-2014, 11:56 AM
Pai Doth Noor should come back, that'd be stellar.

DrSpengler
11-28-2014, 12:07 PM
Full summary and review of TMNT #40 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2014/11/tmnt-idw-40.html)

Thanksgiving slowed me down, but I'm catching up with the TMNT books released this week.

That was a GREAT fight. Maybe the BEST fight. All 13 characters involved got their licks in, some more than others, but the fact that THIRTEEN characters got a spotlight between 18 pages was impressive in itself. Gotta love that "unstoppable juggernaut" vibe Bebop and Rocksteady give off; I just hope they don't ebb power with each subsequent appearance and retain their impenetrable stamina in the future.

Looking over the arc, maybe Bobby's original title of "Territory" actually was more fitting than the one they ended up going with, "New Mutant order". The arc is very loose and maybe a little unfocused, but the unifying theme between the four issues is the concept of factions carving lines in the sand (Krang and Shredder going at it, the Mutanimals and the Turtles scrapping with Bebop and Rocksteady).

Bebop and Rocksteady do just sort of... wander into the story, facilitate a massive brawl, and then just sort of... wander right back out of it. It's very spontaneous, maybe a little gratuitous, but so what. The fight was awesome; totally worth it.

MikeandRaph87
11-28-2014, 01:57 PM
TMNT#40 showcased Comicvine's battle of the week.
https://games.yahoo.com/news/best-battles-comics-11-28-080000024.html

ChosenOne
11-28-2014, 04:20 PM
So Kitsune is the puppeteer of the Foot Clan.

Rat King manipulates the Turtles.

Null does the same with Mutanimals?

Who else from TMNT history could be a god?

"If someone asks if you are a god, you say "yes!"

I'd like to see Noi Tai Dar and the Warrior Dragon at some point, maybe even the Ninja Tribunal from the 2003 cartoon as a counter force if this series really gets to delve deep into the mystic stuff.

funatic
11-28-2014, 08:53 PM
I wouldn't be surprised to see Savanti Romero show up in the pantheon, though with his bull-like horns maybe Chi-You is him by another name. Though with those horns the same could also be said for Null... Time will tell!

Redeemer
11-28-2014, 11:28 PM
TMNT#40 showcased Comicvine's battle of the week.
https://games.yahoo.com/news/best-battles-comics-11-28-080000024.html

Awesome to see TMNT in the spotlight again.

Really liked this issues action freaking packed!!!!! Sometimes you just have to let loose with the action and thats exactly what it gave us!!!!!

Only critique is the awkwardness between Alopex and Raph. No IDW No....just No!!!!!!

Also I feel the ending (Pre-epilogue) was just too damn campy. I mean Alopex really joining Nobody???? I rather her join hob and the crew than Nobody.
Also Epilogue was an awesome reveal!!!!!

Powder
11-28-2014, 11:38 PM
Only critique is the awkwardness between Alopex and Raph. No IDW No....just No!!!!!!

Also I feel the ending (Pre-epilogue) was just too damn campy. I mean Alopex really joining Nobody???? I rather her join hob and the crew than Nobody.
Also Epilogue was an awesome reveal!!!!!

Agreed on both points, but especially the first. The "romance" if you wanna call it that, feels super forced & it seems to exist only to pander to shippers.

CyberCubed
11-28-2014, 11:56 PM
Its only because Alopex is an expy for Ninjara.

Tazi
11-29-2014, 08:45 AM
Only critique is the awkwardness between Alopex and Raph. No IDW No....just No!!!!!!
Agree with this... I think Tom is not really good with writing romantic relationships and stuff like that. I have the same problem with the Casey/Mr.O'neil dialogues, it's like the characters already know about the whole dialogue is about in advance, and they're preconsturcted all their sentences long ago, and they're just saying it, like they are performing a coreographed dance. I can't really explain it better, it's kinda cheesy, and unrealistic.

But I liked everything else, and a good issue overall! :)

snake
11-29-2014, 10:39 AM
Its only because Alopex is an expy for Ninjara.

Really? Is it true that Ninjara is a creator owned character?

Luckyday
11-29-2014, 10:59 AM
Agree with this... I think Tom is not really good with writing romantic relationships and stuff like that. I have the same problem with the Casey/Mr.O'neil dialogues, it's like the characters already know about the whole dialogue is about in advance, and they're preconsturcted all their sentences long ago, and they're just saying it, like they are performing a coreographed dance. I can't really explain it better, it's kinda cheesy, and unrealistic.

But I liked everything else, and a good issue overall! :)

So it feels scripted and rehearsed?

Tazi
11-29-2014, 11:12 AM
Yeah, something like. I know it sound a bit funny, I mean it's a written script, DUH, it supposed to feel scripted, right? :lol:

But what I mean it's not really life-like. On the contrary to that, the Krang/Stockman dialogues worked well before, I've been withnessed similar interactions IRL between bosses and employees.

Maybe Tom has more experience with unconfortable workplace situations then with destroying and fixing relationships... i'm sure a lot of us do. :D

Luckyday
11-29-2014, 11:17 AM
Yeah, something like. I know it sound a bit funny, I mean it's a written script, DUH, it supposed to feel scripted, right? :lol:

But what I mean it's not really life-like. On the contrary to that, the Krang/Stockman dialogues worked well before, I've been withnessed similar interactions IRL between bosses and employees.

Maybe Tom has more experience with unconfortable workplace situations then with destroying and fixing relationships... i'm sure a lot of us do. :D

True but at least we have moment of them interacting with each other and getting a sense of what April's Dad is like which would never happen in Nick's TMNT. At least he not a walking plot device unlike Kirby O'neil.

Tazi
11-29-2014, 11:32 AM
Yeap, I agree on that.

Also the presence of April's parents is something new to TMNT, and I wonder where will this lead in the long run. :)

SwiftNinjaFox
11-29-2014, 03:36 PM
Only critique is the awkwardness between Alopex and Raph. No IDW No....just No!!!!!!


I have to agree with this too. As others said, it feels forced and pandering to shippers. Plus it DOES feel too much like retreading Ninjara all over again.

Since Northampton, I was hoping that Leo and Alopex would become a duo after him defending her from Raph and her watching over him to make sure he didn't do anything to hurt himself. Not a relationship, but just a pairing to handle some things outside of the group, what with them both being previously under Shredder's control in different ways there was that link there I thought would make them an interesting pairing. Allow for some introspective but Alopex's personality pushing Leo a little away from being too uptight from time to time. (And I'll admit, I was hoping for Raph to continue to dislike her for more fun disagreements if not squabbling fights. ;) )

Even though they're spending time with Casey and the O'Neils, Raph and Casey is a duo that's just fun. Mike's developing a friendship with Slash. Don can always be paired with Harold for some fun things (FOR SCIENCE!).

Leo is always pretty much with Splinter or the brothers. The guy never has any story or activity outside of them. Guess that's going to remain the status quo for my favorite turtle.

Wentos
11-29-2014, 03:47 PM
This series has stagnated since Northampton. About the only meaningful developments since then are the introduction of the Mutanimals (which IMO should have been done in a miniseries from the get-go), the introduction of Rat King (which was so out of left field it practically reads like a microseries as it is), and the breakdown of the Shredder/Krang alliance, which I admit was a kickass issue. What's been happening with the turtles? Donnie thinks they should go after Krang and Splinter thinks they should go after Shredder. Eight issues, and nothing's changed since Northampton! Don't get me wrong, I love this book's scale with all the characters and factions and subplots, but don't forget who the main characters are. The turtles should ALWAYS be center stage driving the plot forward, not just occasionally-contributing members of a cast of dozens.

And I'd be remiss if I didn't mention how boring/pathetic Casey's been lately. Can the guy do something other than get his ass kicked or hang out with April's parents please? At this point I'd rather see him written out of the book for a while then see him fix another kitchen appliance.

(Please remember, I say all this with love. This book is still my favorite on the stands, but praise doesn't really generate discussion or improve anything. If I don't say anything, assume I'm happy :))

snake
11-29-2014, 03:55 PM
This series has stagnated since Northampton. About the only meaningful developments since then are the introduction of the Mutanimals (which IMO should have been done in a miniseries from the get-go), the introduction of Rat King (which was so out of left field it practically reads like a microseries as it is), and the breakdown of the Shredder/Krang alliance, which I admit was a kickass issue. What's been happening with the turtles? Donnie thinks they should go after Krang and Splinter thinks they should go after Shredder. Eight issues, and nothing's changed since Northampton! Don't get me wrong, I love this book's scale with all the characters and factions and subplots, but don't forget who the main characters are. The turtles should ALWAYS be center stage driving the plot forward, not just occasionally-contributing members of a cast of dozens.

And I'd be remiss if I didn't mention how boring/pathetic Casey's been lately. Can the guy do something other than get his ass kicked or hang out with April's parents please? At this point I'd rather see him written out of the book for a while then see him fix another kitchen appliance.

(Please remember, I say all this with love. This book is still my favorite on the stands, but praise doesn't really generate discussion or improve anything. If I don't say anything, assume I'm happy :))
I think these past two issues put the turtles out of the picture to introduce a few new characters, nothing wrong with that. I'm sure they'll be the main focus once the attack on the technodrome starts.

Thoughtmirror
11-29-2014, 04:05 PM
I think this may have been one of my favorites so far. I really do love Alopex, but I don't want to see her shipped with Raph. I have nothing against romance, but I just can't see Raph and her hooking up. Angel has floored me. I didn't expect the direction they are going in with her. I am really starting to appreciate her. Slash is turning to be one of my favorites. He reminds me a bit like Leo. Very loyal and protective. Overall, I'm still in love with the IDW series.

Luckyday
11-29-2014, 04:52 PM
Well I honestly hope they know what they going to do with because girlfriend supporting character that follows the main heroes isn't as interesting as it sounds.

I thinking that since kitsune in folk lore are known to possess people then maybe Kitsune is planning to her in the grand scheme of things in whether that may be.

Mutant Ninja Anole
12-01-2014, 01:59 PM
Okay, read it last week, but only now have a chance to write. This time, I'm going to try and be frugal with words.

A massive almost literally cover to cover battle is a lot of fun, and I like that Splinter took command in the situation. He's, ultimately, the most tested and proven leader in the group, and after Slash and Nobody, and maybe Herman with his full arsenal, probably one of the few characters that would be a problem for B&R one on one simpy because of his resourcefulness (remember, Karai was able to get the drop and have Rocksteady at her mercy in their micro). I do wonder, with a little bit of time, and no distractions like having to protect Mike, if Slash could take one or both of them down.

Hob has bit of cognitive dissonance going on there with his dismissal of Bebop and Rocksteady as freaks, which is funny. I'll point out, again, that it was Hob that started the fight in the first place.

I can see why Alopex rejected his offer. She was wholely dedicated to a group, to the point of killing not long before, and she was left broken. She's not going to jump into Hob's frankly insane project of conquest against the human race at the drop of a hat out of mutant loyalty or something. She's clearly been shadowing Angel for awhile and likes the idea of being hero.

As for her and Raph, well it makes sense for us to address how North Hampton went down. Her and Raph have been connected sincer her first appearance in his micro, and that seems likely to continue.

I'll be honest, I was disappointed we didn't get more Leo/Alopex interaction in the City Fall or North Hampton arcs, not so much out of any 'shipping' interest but that, as she said in the latter arc, they both have had Shredder in their head, they both are, or were, loyal to their master, till Alopex saw Shredder for who he was and Leo, well Leo had his faith in Splinter shaken, then restored, but now seems to be ready to disagree with him on the issue of Krang and Shredder (and if some people's speculation is correct, that Leo is sending Don to the Shredder, then things get really interesting).

However, I'm not opposed to Alopex and Raph growing closer, I think their personalities do mesh well, or perhaps are inclined to clash, which makes their relationship more fun. Now that Alopex and Nobody are doing vigilante work in the streets, will they run into Casey and Raph? I can totally see them bonding over kicking muggers in the face. Look, if Alopex and Raph are suddenly dating next issue then yeah, I'd probably say 'too soon,' but Raph and Alopex being friends, bonding, then eventually growing into something else? Aside from the whole, 'I'm a turtle, you're a fox' thing, no problem.

Oh, yeah, with regards to Casey, we seem to be in a project to move Casey from being a mere punching bag, and that's good. Maybe he won't be on board for more vigilante work in the future?

This...actually makes me think, could we see a 'family break up' in the future?

Don with Harold, along with Raph, Nobody and Alopex.

Mike and Splinter with the Mighty Mutant Animals (Slash connection, we've seen Splinter get along with them so far)

Leo...perhaps he stays with Splinter, I'm or with April and Casey? We've seen April working with Harold, both being scientists. Maybe I should group her, Casey and her parents with them.

EDIT: so much for frugality with words, one more thing, though it ties into solicit summaries for upcoming issues:

If it really is Leo's idea to team up with the Shredder, then stab them in the back with Splinter attacking the foot with the MM even as they are helping them deal with Krang...dang that would be awfully cold for our heroes. Not saying it's wrong but definitely outside the 'fight with honor' code we're used to.

ChosenOne
12-01-2014, 02:19 PM
If it really is Leo's idea to team up with the Shredder, then stab them in the back with Splinter attacking the foot with the MM even as they are helping them deal with Krang...dang that would be awfully cold for our heroes. Not saying it's wrong but definitely outside the 'fight with honor' code we're used to.

Actually, I feel that more heroes should pull stunts like that. Krang is trying to wipe out every single lifeform on Earth, and Saki has already killed them all twice both in the past and in the future. It's not like they'll be double-crossing any innocents.

Turtle Park
12-02-2014, 04:50 AM
Was a good fighting chapter with a lot of balance, but the best in my opinion still remains Shredder vs Krang on the boat of doom.
Also, I wonder why Santolouco has done a 180 with his character designs. I really miss the City Fall arc artwork. That was his best IMO. Lately, his turtles look too cute, just like Ross Campbell. And did Alopex shrink or was she wearing high heels before? Sorry for the fuss but this is a pet peeve of mine. Great plot though which is what matters most.

I notice that too. Because Splinter's ears are more...circle(?)and that does makes him a little cute.
Also the turtle's face looks slightly different as you see.

For some reason the change is already happened after City fall arc.
Now I really miss the previous design.

SDCC
12-02-2014, 08:04 AM
Mateus has mentioned how keen he was on Ross's designs, so I'm not surprised his own style has changed slightly. I'm cool with it personally, though I really enjoy both for their different takes.

I don't read solicitations as to my eyes it just seems to be crazy spoiler stuff months ahead. But I'm hoping that really all our heroes are on the same page and building up to something that is both cold and successful.

Mutant Ninja Anole
12-02-2014, 09:46 AM
Actually, I feel that more heroes should pull stunts like that. Krang is trying to wipe out every single lifeform on Earth, and Saki has already killed them all twice both in the past and in the future. It's not like they'll be double-crossing any innocents.

Fair enough, like I said, it's more just a different approach. That's if it goes down that way.

It could have consequences though. Any group the Turtles wish to team up with in the future would have to overlook how they treated the Foot Clan. With April, the MM, perhaps not an issue as well, they'd be in on it. But let's say they need to work with another group in the future, and their main reputation is that they will backstab you?

Not saying it isn't worth looking into, given the situation, but their are consequences to such actions.

The fact that this was apparently planted in Leo's mind by the Rat King may give me pause as well...

ChosenOne
12-02-2014, 10:24 AM
Fair enough, like I said, it's more just a different approach. That's if it goes down that way.

It could have consequences though. Any group the Turtles wish to team up with in the future would have to overlook how they treated the Foot Clan. With April, the MM, perhaps not an issue as well, they'd be in on it. But let's say they need to work with another group in the future, and their main reputation is that they will backstab you?

Not saying it isn't worth looking into, given the situation, but their are consequences to such actions.

The fact that this was apparently planted in Leo's mind by the Rat King may give me pause as well...

I get what you mean, and it might raise some issues if they ever have to team up with Karai as future leader of the Foot, for instance. But still... Conflict is the key to any good story. We're not even sure if that is how things will go down, and it's already a fun and thought-provoking idea, so good job, IDW!

Crabfight
12-03-2014, 07:37 AM
Mateus has mentioned how keen he was on Ross's designs, so I'm not surprised his own style has changed slightly. I'm cool with it personally, though I really enjoy both for their different takes.

Yup. In fact, if you read the Behind the Shell Interview in the back of #40, Mateus talks a little bit about this.

Redeemer
12-03-2014, 02:14 PM
This series has stagnated since Northampton. About the only meaningful developments since then are the introduction of the Mutanimals (which IMO should have been done in a miniseries from the get-go), the introduction of Rat King (which was so out of left field it practically reads like a microseries as it is), and the breakdown of the Shredder/Krang alliance, which I admit was a kickass issue. What's been happening with the turtles? Donnie thinks they should go after Krang and Splinter thinks they should go after Shredder. Eight issues, and nothing's changed since Northampton! Don't get me wrong, I love this book's scale with all the characters and factions and subplots, but don't forget who the main characters are. The turtles should ALWAYS be center stage driving the plot forward, not just occasionally-contributing members of a cast of dozens.

And I'd be remiss if I didn't mention how boring/pathetic Casey's been lately. Can the guy do something other than get his ass kicked or hang out with April's parents please? At this point I'd rather see him written out of the book for a while then see him fix another kitchen appliance.

(Please remember, I say all this with love. This book is still my favorite on the stands, but praise doesn't really generate discussion or improve anything. If I don't say anything, assume I'm happy :))

This makes a lot of sense. Leo and Alopex being good friends would make a lot of sense. A good mutual respect. Like Leo and Karia in 2k3 excepct Alopex won't double cross him.

MikeandRaph87
12-03-2014, 03:27 PM
She still might. She has a connection to Kitsune that is not clear beyond why Shredder's first experiment was an artkic fox.

snake
12-03-2014, 03:47 PM
She still might. She has a connection to Kitsune that is not clear beyond why Shredder's first experiment was an artkic fox.

Foxes are quiet and quick. It makes sense.