View Full Version : Flash-Back Talk-Back: Soul's Winter
Allio
11-29-2014, 05:03 PM
Since IDW has re-released the Soul's Winter. Let's talk about it, how did you you feel about this three part mini-series. If we were to ever have a tone like these again, would you want it? Which turtle had his hand cut off? Did they freeze to death?
also discussion of "Splinter in the eye of God," "Failed Instant"and "O-Deed"
I've been hesitated buying it, because the ultra-low quality of their last Motion Picture HC, is the Soul's Winter HC any better? I really want to have these stories, but I'll skip, if it's the same slobby job as last time... :ohwell:
The Big Bad
11-30-2014, 12:52 PM
The coloring was some of the best I've seen in any of the IDW TMNT reprints, although I'm probably not the best objective judge of the matter. There wasn't anything particularly book-breaking, and it all looked quite nice in general. Is there anything in particular you're watching out for?
neatoman
11-30-2014, 01:47 PM
My copy sucks, it has a few ripped pages, I know it's a fault with the printers as the tears could only have been caused in production given the fact that they come out from the spine of the book.
As for the story itself, it was really... Odd...
The coloring was some of the best I've seen in any of the IDW TMNT reprints, although I'm probably not the best objective judge of the matter. There wasn't anything particularly book-breaking, and it all looked quite nice in general. Is there anything in particular you're watching out for?
The Movie HC had stuff in like characters having different outfit colors on every panel, and tons of other mistakes from the similar kind. There were parts where the colorist could event kept himself from running out of the ink lines. (and they don't exactly color comics nowdays, like in the 80's, so there's no excuse that).
If the Soul's Winter HC don't have that crap, I'm fine, and gonna buy it. ;)
AquaParade
11-30-2014, 09:03 PM
Can anyone verify whetherbthe binding is sewn or glued?
Sabacooza
11-30-2014, 10:18 PM
Can anyone verify whetherbthe binding is sewn or glued?Looks like the individual signatures are sewn and then glued together to create the book block. It is not glued like your typical trade paperback.
Stugehen
12-07-2014, 11:07 PM
I've been hesitated buying it, because the ultra-low quality of their last Motion Picture HC, is the Soul's Winter HC any better? I really want to have these stories, but I'll skip, if it's the same slobby job as last time... :ohwell:
The coloring is better than the Motion Picture HC, but not great. Michael Zulli's TMNT stuff is best in black and white IMO. I wish they woud've released the HC as such, but it's nice to have a HC on the shelf to show off.
CyberCubed
12-07-2014, 11:10 PM
The coloring was very good in this, probably the best IDW has done so far.
The Big Bad
12-13-2014, 11:21 AM
The Movie HC had stuff in like characters having different outfit colors on every panel, and tons of other mistakes from the similar kind. There were parts where the colorist could event kept himself from running out of the ink lines. (and they don't exactly color comics nowdays, like in the 80's, so there's no excuse that).
If the Soul's Winter HC don't have that crap, I'm fine, and gonna buy it. ;)
You should be fine, then, I feel.
That's good to know, thanks! I'll be buying it soon then... :)
Cipher
12-14-2014, 04:56 AM
One of the best Turtles stories ever told. (And for what it's worth, I definitely include "Splinter in the Eye of God" in its canon).
A lot of what makes the Mirage universe great is encapsulated in this arc. It gives us wonderfully damning but decently nuanced portrayals of both Splinter and Shredder (actually, has any arc ever come down harder on Splinter, even if it's mostly implicit?), placing the Turtles as sort of woebegone accidents trying to find a sense of self-worth in a world they truly have no place in and can never realistically survive in.
It's a really special corner of the Mirage series that ought to top every Turtles fan's reading list and be one of the go-tos for newcomers. And the art, it goes without saying, sells every minute of it.
CyberCubed
12-14-2014, 12:41 PM
One of the best Turtles stories ever told. (And for what it's worth, I definitely include "Splinter in the Eye of God" in its canon).
A lot of what makes the Mirage universe great is encapsulated in this arc. It gives us wonderfully damning but decently nuanced portrayals of both Splinter and Shredder (actually, has any arc ever come down harder on Splinter, even if it's mostly implicit?), placing the Turtles as sort of woebegone accidents trying to find a sense of self-worth in a world they truly have no place in and can never realistically survive in.
It's a really special corner of the Mirage series that ought to top every Turtles fan's reading list and be one of the go-tos for newcomers. And the art, it goes without saying, sells every minute of it.
Did you buy the IDW collection? I'm curious as to your opinion on the coloring and if it changes the mood.
Cipher
12-14-2014, 01:06 PM
Did you buy the IDW collection? I'm curious as to your opinion on the coloring and if it changes the mood.
I apparently did, but had it on pre-order so long ago it shipped to my family's home instead of my current address. I guess I'll find out when I'm home for Christmas.
d_osborn
12-15-2014, 05:10 PM
Are there any samples of the colored pages online? I'm curious to see how it looks. I love the black/white originals.
Cipher
12-15-2014, 06:07 PM
Comixology has the first few pages up.
A bit disappointed already. The coloring looks to be of the same style as the "Classics" TPBs. Also, early error spotted: The "lips" of Shredder's demon mask are colored flesh-tone instead of silver like the rest, as if they didn't realize they were part of the mask at first glance.
: (
Oh well. Still glad to have this out in a collection I can point new fans to.
discordiatookie
12-16-2014, 02:55 PM
Absolutely love Soul's Winter. The art is beautiful, and the story is just as good. A great reimagining, I'd love to see an 'Elseworlds' line of TMNT comics.
Cipher
12-18-2014, 03:52 PM
Have it now.
The coloring actually is pretty good for Digikore. Probably the output I've liked most from them outside of maybe the first few Tales Vol. 1 issues. Only the Shredder's mouth issue stands out as an error (and it is an error, as it's corrected later in the first issue).
Everything works well enough as far as not overshadowing Zulli's art. Part of me wishes they'd used a lighter style, but then again, that might have been a distraction from the pencils and inks. By and large the work here does a decent job of not existing -- it's in color, but in such a generically acceptable way that the focus is still on the underlying art.
Props for how blood is handled this time around, though. There's some pretty brutal red splattering going on in the fight, as well as when Splinter vomits the totems into the snow, which is both a break from the normal approach to these books and something that serves this particular story well, which its more realistic, naturalistic take.
VaughnMichael
02-23-2015, 08:30 PM
I just got this over the weekend and I have to agree with the others that the coloring is some of the best IDW has done with the reprints.
The only odd thing for me in this one is when Splinter is in the dream scape or whatever it is he is brown and yet we see him as gray through most of the reprint.
This hard back is really nice though and I'd love to see the River done like this.
Mormegil
02-24-2015, 07:17 AM
Mirage still offers the 3 issues on their website for $3 each. I went ahead and bought those instead.
I don't really have a preference for either black and white or color. I just feel like you'll get the most out of a story reading it the way the writer/artist intended.
VaughnMichael
02-24-2015, 08:08 AM
Mirage still offers the 3 issues on their website for $3 each. I went ahead and bought those instead.
I don't really have a preference for either black and white or color. I just feel like you'll get the most out of a story reading it the way the writer/artist intended.
Well with this you get extras from Shell Shocked and Turtle Soup.
Mormegil
02-24-2015, 08:29 AM
Well with this you get extras from Shell Shocked and Turtle Soup.
are those collected anywhere else in the idw line?
VaughnMichael
02-24-2015, 12:11 PM
are those collected anywhere else in the idw line?
I'm not sure
And can anyone tell me what pages 110 and 111 are from? Are they new?
Powder
02-24-2015, 03:33 PM
I'm not sure
And can anyone tell me what pages 110 and 111 are from? Are they new?
They're the last two pages of O-deed, the story from Shellshock. The sequence of the shrinking turtle crossing the street is just Michelangelo's nightmare.
VaughnMichael
02-24-2015, 04:35 PM
They're the last two pages of O-deed, the story from Shellshock. The sequence of the shrinking turtle crossing the street is just Michelangelo's nightmare.
Ah ok thanks man! I've not looked at that trade in a long time.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.