PDA

View Full Version : Does anyone else feel like IDW jumped the shark with issue 38?


Casey
12-01-2014, 11:37 PM
I'm sorry but Mondo Gecko and Herman the Hermit Crab? Gimme a break. Those characters don't belong in this universe.

I'm sure this has been discussed in other threads, but I just had to get it off my chest.

CyberCubed
12-02-2014, 12:04 AM
No, Old Hob constantly reminded us he was going to build a mutant army so its no surprise they're coming.

Since "The Mutanimals" are coming, it makes sense to see old favorites like Mondo Gecko returning. I also fully expect to see Man Ray and Wingnut/Screwloose as well, and we know Leatherhead is showing up.

snake
12-02-2014, 12:12 AM
They have a place in my opinion, and they've proven themselves to be pretty damn cool.

Powder
12-02-2014, 12:26 AM
How is it that they "don't belong"? There's always been a wacky assortment of aliens/mutants/etc. They made it clear the book was gonna be that way from the get-go, more or less, & there's a crap-ton of Fred Wolf influence in it. It balances things out by having just as many traditional ninja stories & otherworldly stuff. Everything is blended pretty well, so really, nothing is out of place in this series, as it is a mix of all things past.

Hob's army is awesome. Don't you dare knock Herman.

Tazi
12-02-2014, 02:17 AM
Dunno, even Mirage had goofy stuff like that, it does belong to the frenchise, and IDW definitely not overdoing it, ithey're still far away from Nick Tmnt.

Joey Kamikaze
12-02-2014, 03:23 AM
Mirage had a magic pencil that could create life, crossovers with everyone and their dogs, guest issues that read like drug trips, and the whole thing started as a Daredevil parody. So far IDW has been fairly grounded considering the source material...

And yeah, I've been looking forward to Hob's army for a while. This is a natural evolution of the story that was set up years ago in the run.

ChosenOne
12-02-2014, 04:30 AM
Nope. If anything, I was hoping for more new mutants in 38 to shake things up.

Tackleberr-- I mean, Herman, and Mondo are pretty damn awesome.

Candy Kappa
12-02-2014, 04:36 AM
I feel they very much belongs in this universe. Hob have his resources and it's not far fetched as he wanted an army.

And they are beautifully designed.

Plasticplayhouse
12-02-2014, 05:02 AM
Originally, a while back when there was some notion and a lot of speculation that the mutanimals were going to enter e story, I was against it. I'm not a fan of the original. However, Tom and crew pulled it off and very well so imo. I mean, could they end up going overboard? Maybe, but I think they will keep it somewhat controlled. These guys know what they're doing.

Herman is pretty frigin cool.

ToTheNines
12-02-2014, 11:27 AM
They fit fairly well. I mean they're a little goofy, especially mondo wearing his Reptile Tendencies shirt lol.

Their unique personalities don't make a ton of sense, but my head-canon is that they're reincarnated humans. While they may or may not remember their past lives, the serum helps their old selves shine through.

DrSpengler
12-02-2014, 11:40 AM
I, for one, take no issue with levity in my comics about anthropomorphic reptiles wearing robber masks who fight ninjas and monsters.

So no, I'm all good with "silly" mutants like Mondo Gecko and Herman the Hermit Crab.

funatic
12-02-2014, 11:51 AM
They fit fairly well. I mean they're a little goofy, especially mondo wearing his Reptile Tendencies shirt lol.

Their unique personalities don't make a ton of sense, but my head-canon is that they're reincarnated humans. While they may or may not remember their past lives, the serum helps their old selves shine through.

Hmm that's an interesting take, I might have to load it into my 'head-canon' as well because I was a little baffled how these brand new sentient animals suddenly had the urges to skateboard (let alone enough time to learn how to be good at it), and know military jargon without any military experience. Their costumes also suspend disbelief a bit. As you said, Mondo's shirts (which I love for their goofiness), are still out of place and kind of break the fourth wall, and how the heck did Herman get all that artillery into a dumpster?

I wonder if they'll address these potential past lives as humans at some point? It will give us a more solid explanation for their characters, but also make the turtles seem a little less special... Does that mean Hob & Slash were reincarnated too? On the contrary, their sentient animal selves are more well-rounded, and they wear street clothes or no clothes. They seem like "regular" animals-turned-humans, and it also falls in line with Hob's ANIMALS ONLY manifesto. Mutagen works in mysterious ways...

So yeah, I still love this series, love the new characters, and it definitely didn't jump the shark. But throwing in 2 new mutants in action-figure-esque costumes whose personalities are little more than stereotypes, maybe... just maybe... it jumped the flounder. :trazz: But like those have said before, it's Turtles—in the end, anything goes... and as long as its well written and pretty to look at, I'm on board!

Tazi
12-02-2014, 11:56 AM
They jumped the shark with bludgeon (megalol)

funatic
12-02-2014, 12:01 PM
They jumped the shark with bludgeon (megalol)

I was gonna say...
http://i62.tinypic.com/2dwdz03.png
THE SHARK JUMPED US!

Mutant Ninja Anole
12-02-2014, 12:03 PM
Hate to pile on, but the OP is pretty much the first person I've seen not like Mondo and Herman. It was actually one of my favorite recent issues.

Redeemer
12-02-2014, 12:07 PM
Hate to pile on, but the OP is pretty much the first person I've seen not like Mondo and Herman. It was actually one of my favorite recent issues.

I am actually with Casey (OP) the book is getting crowded with all these mutants.
Love Herman best design of any of the new characters.

snake
12-02-2014, 12:31 PM
I am actually with Casey (OP) the book is getting crowded with all these mutants.
Love Herman best design of any of the new characters.

Bobby or Tom said that the book won't be adding new characters for awhile. I can't remember the exact time he said.

neatoman
12-02-2014, 02:52 PM
Mondo Gecko... Kind of sucks in concept to be honest, and Herman does feel too much like toy for a character who was not created to be a toy.

But I feel like they have not jumped the shark, Herman proved to be a quite charming character and Mondo at least had some cool powers this time around.

CyberCubed
12-02-2014, 03:02 PM
If Man Ray shows up do you think IDW will still write him with Steve Murphy's personality? I wonder if IDW will have a "save the enviornment" issue with Man Ray pledging to stop polluting the oceans and saving the forests.

neatoman
12-02-2014, 03:19 PM
If Man Ray shows up do you think IDW will still write him with Steve Murphy's personality? I wonder if IDW will have a "save the enviornment" issue with Man Ray pledging to stop polluting the oceans and saving the forests.

Murphy was known for going a little overboard with the environmentalism, but is part of what defines Man Ray, soooooo.... Yeah?

Powder
12-02-2014, 03:33 PM
I can't really see him fitting in all too well (Even though he's one of my all time favorite characters) but I think it'd be kinda dope if him & the gang raised hell over some new thing that was causing death in local wildlife or something.

CyberCubed
12-02-2014, 04:15 PM
Man Ray should whine about Krang's Burnow Island polluting the seas or something.

TomWaltz
12-02-2014, 07:20 PM
C'mon, folks -- jumping sharks is the coolest!!!

http://media.tumblr.com/cbdf73e8d6a465d7107fe88827234c37/tumblr_mjrcyqNYDN1qjn6dko1_400.jpg

funatic
12-02-2014, 07:23 PM
C'mon, folks -- jumping sharks is the coolest!!!

http://media.tumblr.com/cbdf73e8d6a465d7107fe88827234c37/tumblr_mjrcyqNYDN1qjn6dko1_400.jpg

Tom you're the Fonz of Turtledom! Hope to meet you at a con someday - come to the east coast next year!

DONATELLO DUZMACHINES
12-02-2014, 08:47 PM
Herman and Mondo are THE BEST! I love their inclusion in the book and they fit perfectly. As someone else stated the book has always done a good job of balancing the sci fi and otherworldly elements with the ninja elements, and though the cast is growing the issues never feel crowded. Also I rhink Herman and Mondo have some of the best designs, they really need figures based of these designs.

Redeemer
12-02-2014, 09:03 PM
Bobby or Tom said that the book won't be adding new characters for awhile. I can't remember the exact time he said.

So the Stage is set!!! :D
If they don't add anymore characters it will be fine by me. I hope they kill off characters before adding any new ones.

Man Ray should whine about Krang's Burnow Island polluting the seas or something.

That would be a pretty awesome idea!!! ManRay and LeatherHead being Krang's elite guards of Burnow Island!

Casey
12-02-2014, 11:26 PM
How is it that they "don't belong"? There's always been a wacky assortment of aliens/mutants/etc. They made it clear the book was gonna be that way from the get-go, more or less, & there's a crap-ton of Fred Wolf influence in it. It balances things out by having just as many traditional ninja stories & otherworldly stuff. Everything is blended pretty well, so really, nothing is out of place in this series, as it is a mix of all things past.

Hob's army is awesome. Don't you dare knock Herman.

It's just too cartoonish for me. It's a little less serious tone than they had prior in my opinion. I'm sorry, but I just can't deal with Herman lol.

Casey
12-02-2014, 11:28 PM
Mirage had a magic pencil that could create life, crossovers with everyone and their dogs, guest issues that read like drug trips, and the whole thing started as a Daredevil parody. So far IDW has been fairly grounded considering the source material...

And yeah, I've been looking forward to Hob's army for a while. This is a natural evolution of the story that was set up years ago in the run.

I'm not talking about in comparison. Mirage got way wackier than that, but IDW seems to have remained more serious and meditative, which I have appreciated.

Casey
12-02-2014, 11:30 PM
C'mon, folks -- jumping sharks is the coolest!!!

http://media.tumblr.com/cbdf73e8d6a465d7107fe88827234c37/tumblr_mjrcyqNYDN1qjn6dko1_400.jpg

Well, in context of that picture it is I guess. I've watched that episode before and not even The Fonz himself can make that one look cool.

Mayhem
12-03-2014, 04:20 AM
I like Mondo and Herman. Haven't really seen their full combat potential yet (my copy of #40 is in the mail so haven't read that!) but hopefully soon, instead of perhaps "making up the numbers". Mutanimals might do that too.

Well, in context of that picture it is I guess. I've watched that episode before and not even The Fonz himself can make that one look cool.
Henry Winkler was on a comedy show here in the UK within the last year, and was asked about the whole shark jumping episode of Happy Days. Have to see if I can find it online or something.

corvus
12-03-2014, 06:04 AM
I see where the op is coming from. It could have been executed poorly but it's not bad. And Hob being a 100% good guy feels forced.

Mutant Ninja Anole
12-03-2014, 09:19 AM
I see where the op is coming from. It could have been executed poorly but it's not bad. And Hob being a 100% good guy feels forced.

Not sure I'd call him 100 % good guy. He did start the fight with B&R more out of his odd racism, and he still wants to take over the human world.

Tazi
12-03-2014, 09:59 AM
Not sure I'd call him 100 % good guy. He did start the fight with B&R more out of his odd racism, and he still wants to take over the human world.

That's exactly what I wanted to say: he just attempted to murder someone with racist intent, an issue ago.

But I guess, if you ask someone with neo-liberal views, he will say that "calling Hob a racist is victim-blaming". :roll:

ProphetofGanja
12-03-2014, 03:13 PM
Not sure I'd call him 100 % good guy. He did start the fight with B&R more out of his odd racism, and he still wants to take over the human world.

I think it's interesting that as time has gone on Hob has taken to wearing more and more clothing. It'll be interesting to see him come to terms with the fact that not all humans are evil, not all mutants are good, and even his best intentions could be detrimental to his cause if implemented incorrectly

Raptor86
12-04-2014, 07:14 AM
I really loved the introduction of Herman and Mondo!
Mondo teaming up with Splinter was so cool IMO

Luckyday
12-06-2014, 01:23 PM
Mondo Gecko in a serious comic book doesn't make sense to me, and the guns on skateboards looks ridiculous and impractical.

The entire character would fit more on a kid focus show like Nick's TMNT then on here but I guess it because people reading IDW are people that watch OT as kids and I just don't have the nostalgia like the others.

neatoman
12-07-2014, 01:58 PM
How about we make a list of things that could be a sharkjump?


Nonsensical character development
Introduction of annoying characters
Sudden change in status quo
A load of stupid story points
Jumping over Bludgeon

snake
12-07-2014, 03:07 PM
How about we make a list of things that could be a sharkjump?


Nonsensical character development
Introduction of annoying characters
Sudden change in status quo
A load of stupid story points
Jumping over Bludgeon


Is this a jab at IDW or not? I can't tell.

Mutant Ninja Anole
12-07-2014, 10:05 PM
Mondo Gecko in a serious comic book doesn't make sense to me, and the guns on skateboards looks ridiculous and impractical.

The entire character would fit more on a kid focus show like Nick's TMNT then on here but I guess it because people reading IDW are people that watch OT as kids and I just don't have the nostalgia like the others.

I wouldn't put TMNT into the category of a 'serious' comic book. Has serious moments, but fundamentally we're talking mutated ninja turtle teens who go into space to help space elves fight the evil brain alien and his army of rock monsters. I just don't see Mondo Gecko as anything particularly unusual for the series.

FlogginMcMurryZombiePizza
12-07-2014, 11:18 PM
I don't really see the the inclusion of 2 low-tier TMNT characters from the 90s as jumping the shark.
And while I do enjoy the darker, more mature themes of the IDW comic, I wouldn't call it entirely "serious".

Honestly I was pretty stoked to see Mondo. Herman... whatever, I can take or leave him but that's no different from the bird, I think Kyio was its name? And I'm sorry, I'm getting burned out on Alopex. Maybe because the character feels a little too "furry" to me (The character was used very well in Secret of the Foot Clan).

But the series has been bringing in many new mutants, exclusive to this IDW world, and throwbacks (personally when I saw the shark fin I was hoping it was Armaggon).
If Bebop and Rocksteady can exist and work, I dont see why Pigeon Pete and Mondo Gecko can't get a chance. The Turtles do need more on their side than an educated Slash and Hob and his army. Hell, Mondo never seemed much different to me than Mikey, I think the 2 will play off well against each other.

neatoman
12-08-2014, 01:27 AM
Is this a jab at IDW or not? I can't tell.

It's not, it's just a list of things typically tied to sharkjump, that last part is just a joke though.

snake
12-08-2014, 05:47 AM
It's not, it's just a list of things typically tied to sharkjump, that last part is just a joke though.
Okay, but you've got 2 out of those 5 things happening, 4 if you really hate this comic. That must be it! Issue 50 is Raph preparing to jump Bludgeon.

ChosenOne
12-08-2014, 05:58 AM
Okay, but you've got 2 out of those 5 things happening, 4 if you really hate this comic. That must be it! Issue 50 is Raph preparing to jump Bludgeon.

My money's on Mikey. :trazz:

snake
12-08-2014, 05:59 AM
My money's on Mikey. :trazz:

But Raph is the cool one! He has to jump him!

ChosenOne
12-08-2014, 06:41 AM
But Raph is the cool one! He has to jump him!

Mikey's the one who will make a joke out of it, I just know.

Powder
12-08-2014, 02:09 PM
Well, he ought to now. Tom, write in a scene where Mikey hops over Bludgeon & says "Hey dudes, check it out- TMNT just jumped the shark!". Please.

Casey
12-15-2014, 10:42 AM
I wouldn't put TMNT into the category of a 'serious' comic book. Has serious moments, but fundamentally we're talking mutated ninja turtle teens who go into space to help space elves fight the evil brain alien and his army of rock monsters. I just don't see Mondo Gecko as anything particularly unusual for the series.

I disagree. That argument could be made for any comic especially over the history of big hitters like Batman and Superman. I think that the turtles are just as wacky as most superhero comics, BUT I just feel like Herman was too far.

Tazi
12-15-2014, 11:32 AM
I wouldn't put TMNT into the category of a 'serious' comic book.
Are you new to comic books?

ChosenOne
12-15-2014, 11:37 AM
I disagree. That argument could be made for any comic especially over the history of big hitters like Batman and Superman. I think that the turtles are just as wacky as most superhero comics, BUT I just feel like Herman was too far.

Why do you feel that way towards Herman, specifically?

Casey
12-16-2014, 06:55 AM
Why do you feel that way towards Herman, specifically?

Good question. I think it might specifically be his military jargon and attire. It is over the top.

Commenter 42
12-16-2014, 07:32 AM
If Man Ray shows up do you think IDW will still write him with Steve Murphy's personality? I wonder if IDW will have a "save the enviornment" issue with Man Ray pledging to stop polluting the oceans and saving the forests.

This is taking trolling to a whole new level, don't ya think?
You know, considering what's going on today?
http://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/s--ED9LUyjV--/17nbjqjpqvx27jpg.jpg

Mutant Ninja Anole
12-16-2014, 11:48 PM
Are you new to comic books?

No, my definition of 'serious' probably falls in the line of something like Maus or A Contract with God.

Andrew NDB
12-17-2014, 11:45 AM
I have a soft spot for the Mutanimals, always will, but the whole Bill & Ted/sk8er boi archetype Mondo Gecko has always embodied was fine when he first came onto the scene in the cartoon and Archies... but now he sort of stands out as a strange sort of relic of the 80s/early 90s.

Casey
12-17-2014, 10:00 PM
I have a soft spot for the Mutanimals, always will, but the whole Bill & Ted/sk8er boi archetype Mondo Gecko has always embodied was fine when he first came onto the scene in the cartoon and Archies... but now he sort of stands out as a strange sort of relic of the 80s/early 90s.

I agree with this as well.

Leo656
12-17-2014, 10:07 PM
but now he sort of stands out as a strange sort of relic of the 80s/early 90s.

((Blinks))

...the F*CK is wrong with THAT, exactly?!

Seriously, guy, I'm standing, like, righthere... :tgrumble: