PDA

View Full Version : How does IDW afford to put out so many TMNT trades?


CyberCubed
12-04-2014, 02:44 PM
IDW puts out a LOT of TMNT trades and collections. I'm honestly curious as to how well these trades are selling, because it almost seems like they're being awfully generous:

- IDW's main ongoing has trade collections of every 4 issues. Even all the one-shots, Turtles in Time, Secret History of the Foot Clan, etc. all have trades.

- 5 Ultimate Collections

- Classic Collections for Mirage material confirmed up to volume 10

- Tales of the TMNT collections up to Volume 6 so far, seems they're going to collect all of it

- TMNT Legends trades, currently for Soul's Winter

- The Works collections, which collect colorized issues of the same comics in the Ultimate Collections

- Archie TMNT Adventures Trades

- Nick TMNT Adventures trades


When you realize that the trades of each of these series are numbering around close to 10 releases or more now, how do they put out so much stuff?

Sabacooza
12-04-2014, 03:24 PM
I care less about how they do it and care more about them actually doing it.

neatoman
12-04-2014, 03:30 PM
As I understand it, printing in Korea is cheap... And you know, it's paper, not that expensive... And well... They're a comic book publisher, printing stuff is what they do.

If it's surprising to see so many TMNT trades now days compared to the past, there's a simple explaination:
Mirage is a small business in Northampton, Archie is an oddball on so many levels and Image was still in it's infancy when they held the license.

Mayhem
12-04-2014, 03:55 PM
Trades often sell better than the individual comics actually.

CyberCubed
12-04-2014, 04:32 PM
Trades often sell better than the individual comics actually.

Each IDW issue sells roughly 15,000-17,000 copies. Do the IDW trades which collect 4 of these sell anywhere that amount?

Venom
12-04-2014, 04:53 PM
I recall Bobby saying somewhere that Archie sold the least of their trades. They works collections are obviously the biggest profit centers in regards to the collections, and enough folks.want to see the old stuff in color to keep picking those up, plus IDW puts out a lot of trades in general. If its on a shelf, it'll sell eventually, and their stuff sells consistently enough that retailers are willing to order more.

Plus, the other side is this is the first time the Turtles' comics have been widely available, so mote trades mean more folks to pick them up.

CyberCubed
12-04-2014, 04:57 PM
I recall Bobby saying somewhere that Archie sold the least of their trades. They works collections are obviously the biggest profit centers in regards to the collections, and enough folks.want to see the old stuff in color to keep picking those up, plus IDW puts out a lot of trades in general. If its on a shelf, it'll sell eventually, and their stuff sells consistently enough that retailers are willing to order more.

Plus, the other side is this is the first time the Turtles' comics have been widely available, so mote trades mean more folks to pick them up.

Funny I thought "The Works" would be their least selling collections because everyone picked up the Ultimate Collections instead and they're the same issues.

I was wondering about the Archie trades because I don't know if they'll cancel those in the middle without completing it.

Do you know about the Tales of the TMNT trades? They're up to #16 now of Tales V.2.....but given this series has 70 issues it has a long way to go before completion.

Joey Kamikaze
12-04-2014, 08:44 PM
Funny I thought "The Works" would be their least selling collections because everyone picked up the Ultimate Collections instead and they're the same issues.

My guess is that the hard-core, longtime fans (say, the type likely to post on a TMNT messageboard) may prefer the black and white versions for purist reasons, but the average reader is going to go for the colorized versions.

Davetello
12-05-2014, 06:32 AM
Yeah, I saw that recently when I was reading wiki and turtlepedia. The sheer volume (no pun intended) of output is incredible. You'd need to be as wealthy as David Beckham to afford it all.

Tazi
12-05-2014, 07:22 AM
How does IDW afford to put out so many TMNT trades?
They save money on the coloring and the editor. :trolleye:

CyberCubed
12-05-2014, 03:04 PM
Yeah, I saw that recently when I was reading wiki and turtlepedia. The sheer volume (no pun intended) of output is incredible. You'd need to be as wealthy as David Beckham to afford it all.

I've been buying all the trades except for The Works and Archie collections and it's not that expensive.

neatoman
12-05-2014, 03:15 PM
I recall Bobby saying somewhere that Archie sold the least of their trades.

I... Can't say I'm surprised to be honest, the series has not aged well and the trades themselves are not very good.

FlogginMcMurryZombiePizza
12-08-2014, 01:55 AM
Each IDW issue sells roughly 15,000-17,000 copies. Do the IDW trades which collect 4 of these sell anywhere that amount?

Considering trades are carried in book stores where, maybe, the comic books are not carried.

But what do you mean the ones that "collect 4 of these"? Do you mean the spin-off books? Like Secret History/Turtles in Time/Utrom Empire? Because the normal trades for the ongoing are around 7 issues collected. There is a method to what they do... they are not going to skimp out on releasing trades for mini-series books just because they are not part of the ongoing.
And also... look at their website. They are releasing special edition, fancy-pants high-level collector stuff for $100s. They have money to be able to release a lot of things for fans, charge more and get even more money back to help them as a business grow.

HeroTurtlesFan
12-08-2014, 07:35 AM
Because the normal trades for the ongoing are around 7 issues collected.

Um, no they're not at all:

Vol 1 - issues #1-4
Vol 2 - issues #5-8
Vol 3 - issues #9-12
Vol 4 - issues #13-16
Vol 5 - issues #17-20
...and I can't be bothered to write the rest, but yeah, they've ALL been 4-issue trades, at least up to vol 8/#32.

THGhost
12-08-2014, 08:54 AM
Because they're loaded because TMNT is a popular property? :D

Like Sabacooza said:

I care less about how they do it and care more about them actually doing it.

FlogginMcMurryZombiePizza
12-08-2014, 11:32 AM
Um, no they're not at all:

Vol 1 - issues #1-4
Vol 2 - issues #5-8
Vol 3 - issues #9-12
Vol 4 - issues #13-16
Vol 5 - issues #17-20
...and I can't be bothered to write the rest, but yeah, they've ALL been 4-issue trades, at least up to vol 8/#32.

Well then that's different from normal trades from other companies. Maybe it costs more to put out a collection of 7 books versus a collection of 4 and that'll explain how they put out so many. I wouldn't know this 'cus I have most of the IDW single issues, and a variety of variants. I only own a trade of Secret History of the Foot Clan 'cus I loved the story so much and I generally keep my books in their B&B after a first read.

Again, they fact their are is what matters.

CyberCubed
12-08-2014, 08:37 PM
The trades are only 4 issues each, for both the IDW collections and the old Mirage collections. Sometimes there's 5 but that's rare.

Kind of a shame as I wish more could be collected at once.

FlogginMcMurryZombiePizza
12-08-2014, 09:34 PM
Yea I know the trades I own from Image, Marvel, and DC are all in the 7-issue range unless they were mini-series... like Space Ghost, The Return of Bruce Wayne, or RED,

HeroTurtlesFan
12-09-2014, 09:40 AM
Even other IDW trades usually offer more than 4 issues - "Transformers", for example, typically go from 5-6 issues a piece.

And as you say, it's not uncommon for DC to be 7-8, which is much better value.

neatoman
12-12-2014, 04:31 PM
So here's a question, I noticed that Marvel, DC, Darkhorse and Image all make use of a phonebook format for dirtcheap access, why don't IDW reprint the Mirage series that way?

It was almost entirely published in Black and White originally, so it would not be much corner cutting in quality to publish it that way.

PangolinFeets
12-12-2014, 04:58 PM
I'm terrible. I buy the issues, trades, and sometimes the digital versions too. And I'm pretty sure I'm not the only person that does that.

The trades make it easy to read a big chunk at once and I do a lot of comic-swapping so I don't feel bad about lending them out. And they're my go-to gift for a someone who's interested in the comic.

And digital is just the ultimate convenience. Having the Comixology app on my phone is the greatest.

CyberCubed
12-12-2014, 05:41 PM
I actually sold off my single issues after getting the trades, because as you said, its rather redundant and the trades are easy to read when I want to go back to them.

I don't care about digital though, but its good for people who want it.

Joey Kamikaze
12-12-2014, 07:25 PM
I buy the singles and I'm waiting on the omnibus versions with the micros inserted where they belong for trades. The current 4 issue trades at $18 a pop strike me as a bad deal, especially since the micros are collected separately and you'd have to go back and forth on rereads. I mean hell, that's $4.50 an issue, and are they even including the letter column? By comparison I picked up the first Sex Criminals trade with five issues for $10.

(Sex Criminals is a fantastic read, btw. Now it's on my pull list.)

Call me old but I don't get the point of buying anything digitally. I feel like if you don't have a physical copy, you don't really own it. When people "buy" (lease) licenses to songs on iTunes and the like I just shake my head all "Haven't you heard of the Pirate's Bay?"

CyberCubed
12-12-2014, 08:41 PM
You can get the trades on amazon for $15 or less, not sure where you're getting $18 from.

Joey Kamikaze
12-12-2014, 08:49 PM
Retail on the trades is $17.99 regardless of the discount you might get elsewhere.

Besides, stuff isn't necessarily cheaper on Amazon once you factor in shipping.

PangolinFeets
12-12-2014, 09:41 PM
I buy the singles and I'm waiting on the omnibus versions with the micros inserted where they belong for trades. The current 4 issue trades at $18 a pop strike me as a bad deal, especially since the micros are collected separately and you'd have to go back and forth on rereads. I mean hell, that's $4.50 an issue, and are they even including the letter column? By comparison I picked up the first Sex Criminals trade with five issues for $10.

(Sex Criminals is a fantastic read, btw. Now it's on my pull list.)

Call me old but I don't get the point of buying anything digitally. I feel like if you don't have a physical copy, you don't really own it. When people "buy" (lease) licenses to songs on iTunes and the like I just shake my head all "Haven't you heard of the Pirate's Bay?"

Sex Criminals is ok. I enjoyed the first trade and I'll probably just keep picking up trades as they come. I'm not loving it enough to throw it on my pull list (its already pretty big). My other big fav of this year, other than TMNT, is The Wicked + The Divine. I'm dying for the next issue.

And yea, I think I pay $14 or $15 per trade at my local store. Then again, they have a membership which gives me discounts on trades. *ahem*

Digital is great for me simply because I work a lot so I need things portable. I do a lot of overnight and late shifts at hospitals, which I'd rather not bring nice fresh comics so I keep them all safe and secure on my phone. And I can access my Comixology account from anywhere to read them. Plus, they tend to be pretty cheap and do sales/giveaways all the time. I enjoy supporting creators so I only either buy digitally cheap or borrow/trade with friends. Not that I'm loaded, but I do ok for myself so $10 for some reading entertainment isn't going to break my bank.

funatic
12-13-2014, 01:58 AM
I'm terrible. I buy the issues, trades, and sometimes the digital versions too. And I'm pretty sure I'm not the only person that does that.

Thanks for keeping the franchise afloat! :trazz: I'm in the same boat as this guy:

I buy the singles and I'm waiting on the omnibus versions with the micros inserted where they belong for trades. The current 4 issue trades at $18 a pop strike me as a bad deal, especially since the micros are collected separately and you'd have to go back and forth on rereads. I mean hell, that's $4.50 an issue, and are they even including the letter column?

Yeah kind of a rip... you get cover galleries in most of the trades but that's about the only advantage over the singles, and nope, no letters. I hope they at least retain the cover gallery for the omnibuses (omnibi?). Has anyone looked in the big Transformers or G.I. Joe collections to see if they do?

ProphetofGanja
12-13-2014, 01:29 PM
Retail on the trades is $17.99 regardless of the discount you might get elsewhere.

Besides, stuff isn't necessarily cheaper on Amazon once you factor in shipping.

Amazon Prime membership is one of the best investments I've made. I've gotten all my IDW TMNT TPBs through Amazon, as well as TPBs for Saga, The Goon, Hellboy, B.P.R.D., and Lobster Johnson, all for about $15 each, tops. Old TPBs can be gotten used for a good price or if you want a new one the pre-order price is always great, only like $13 or $14

Nasubionna
01-23-2015, 10:38 PM
Personally, I am happy that IDW puts out trades on the regular for all these various turtles incarnations (animated, archie, ongoing). If I had lots of extra money to spare, I would buy single issues just to show my support, but I very much prefer having a nice big chunk to read at a time, and therefore prefer the trade paperbacks. So yeah, I don't know if/how it's difficult for them to do, I just hope they keep doing it! :)

spookycookies
01-23-2015, 11:19 PM
I'm a sucker for single issues and doubling up for variants if I like how they look. I had bought the trades for IDW volume 1 and the first 2 micro volumes but that was before I decided to have a complete run in singles. After I get the 2 City at War Ultimate Collections I'll have the full set of those and start moving on to some of the Classic Collections but I'll probably focus on getting the Tales trades first. I prefer reading Mirage volume 1 oversized and in black and white but I am looking forward to seeing a few stories in color like Distractions and Masks.