View Full Version : Raphael vs Robin
MikeandRaph87
12-20-2014, 09:49 PM
Comicvine put together its latest versus poll and put IDW's Raphael against Damian Wayne as Robin. Raphael won on the fan poll. If I was Dick Grayson I do believe Raphael would have lost but a bit but any other Robin would fall to Raphael.
http://www.comicvine.com/articles/battle-of-the-week-robin-vs-raphael/1100-150701/#ftag=YHF6f45a36
Leo656
12-20-2014, 09:57 PM
Grayson would win, no contest. Tim would have a real shot because he's a brilliant tactician who even Bruce suspects could outshine even himself one day. (Least that's how it was pre-New Stupid 52)
Jason and Damien have no shot. I f***ing hate Damien. I wouldn't mind seeing Raph "forget" he was fighting a kid and twist his head around. Friggin' punk. I never thought anyone could irritate me more than Jason. It's like the writers who came up with Damien said, "Let's start with Jason and turn the Douche up to 11."
oldmanwinters
12-20-2014, 10:19 PM
I'd vote on Birdbrain. Regardless of the dude under the mask, Robins are considerably more tactical than ol' hothead snapping turtle!
Leo656
12-20-2014, 10:25 PM
Not Jason, Jason was only even Robin because Bruce was subconsciously trying to get back at Grayson. Kid never had the chops. He'd get his ass kicked in about 7.4 seconds.
The other guys I could see.
CyberCubed
12-20-2014, 11:00 PM
Raphael would beat Damian, Tim Drake, and Jason Todd.
Nightwing would probably be more evenly matched and could go to either.
Leo656
12-20-2014, 11:08 PM
I think people underestimate Tim. Tim Drake is a strategic genius AND a highly skilled martial artist/ninja. Even Grayson said that Tim might just about be his equal.
Oh, wait, you never met Tim Drake, only that imposter from the cartoon show. Guess you ain't heard, but he's a total pimp.
If nothing else he's a ton smarter than Raph. If he can beat King Snake, he can probably beat Raphael.
Coola Yagami
12-20-2014, 11:37 PM
Eh, Damian can hang with with Raph, and definitely take him. Especially since he'd remain calm while Raph will keep losing his cool and screw up.
Leo656
12-20-2014, 11:42 PM
He's like 4 feet tall and weighs 85lbs, maximum. Raph's a tank. That kind of sh*t was implausible even when they were using the GOOD Robins. :lol:
That's kinda why I hate Damien, he's written to be such an overly-perfect uber-"bad-ass" fan-wank character, when he's really just an arrogant little snot. Like that "Batman and Son" movie. That sh*t's just disgusting.
Now, I can see Tim kicking Raph's ass for the exact reasons you mentioned. Plus, Raph was trained by Splinter. Tim was trained by Batman. No contest.
Zulithe
12-20-2014, 11:46 PM
LOL i'd like to see this poll happen again once Robin's new superpowers are revealed.
Love Raph and also love Damian so it's a hard pick for me. Both trained in combat basically from birth, but Raph has more experience since he's older (oh, and he's got mutant enhancements etc.)
Don't even care that Raph won. Just the fact that they put him against a 10yo kid should show you what a badass Damian is. :P
Leo656
12-20-2014, 11:54 PM
Some things I just don't get. HOW can anyone love Damien? Like really, he's just such a piece of sh*t on purpose. It's not "edgy" or "bad-ass"; when kids in real life act like exactly the entitled little snot-rocket he acts, we as adults generally admit we would like to put them (or their parents) through a window.
Stick a cape on him, though, "Best Character EVAR!" I sincerely don't get it. I would f*cking shoot that kid in the face until I was out of bullets, reload, and start over.
B-Man
12-21-2014, 12:19 AM
Some things I just don't get. HOW can anyone love Damien? Like really, he's just such a piece of sh*t on purpose. It's not "edgy" or "bad-ass"; when kids in real life act like exactly the entitled little snot-rocket he acts, we as adults generally admit we would like to put them (or their parents) through a window.
Stick a cape on him, though, "Best Character EVAR!" I sincerely don't get it. I would f*cking shoot that kid in the face until I was out of bullets, reload, and start over.
Agreed. Damian is a little c*nt. I watched 'Son Of Batman' & realized I was wishing harm on a child character lol
Zulithe
12-21-2014, 12:38 AM
The Technodrome being Raphael home turf I'm not even interested in defending Damian here, my time is more valuable than that. Just look at the comments on the comic vine article, you'll see plenty of detailed replies -- a lot of the ones who pit Raph as winning even give Damian some props. He has a lot of fans, I know I'm not alone in liking him and glad that he's returning to the comics. He's a hell of a lot more interesting than Tim Drake. Same for Jason Todd, although his transformation into Red Hood at least gave him his own vibe to set him apart from the other Robins.
Anyway guys, having such vulgar thoughts about harming a preteen child (fictional or not) is disturbing as it is. Did you feel that way about Hit Girl, who is pretty much a mirror image of Damian?
Leo656
12-21-2014, 01:02 AM
Hit Girl is supposed to be satirical. Damien is just a dick. I seriously can't wrap my head around a character whose entire gimmick being, "The most obnoxious, arrogant, unlikable personality imaginable", being openly embraced and worshiped to the degree he is.
If Damien was YOUR kid, and he talked to you the way he talks to his own FATHER, who happens to be BATMAN of all people, you'd tan his hide with every belt in your closet. Don't lie. We live in an era where the comments section of almost every single news article is full of comments by adults bemoaning what entitled little c*nts kids are nowadays, and here we get that taken to the Nth degree, played straight, and he's a HERO? And further, people LIKE him? The hell is happening to society? Seriously.
And how exactly is he "more interesting" than Tim? Because Tim is - by Bruce's own admission - a better detective than Batman himself, a computer genius, and - by Dick's own admission - a better fighter than Grayson was at his age? Oh, wait, but Damien's default solution to every confrontation is, "I'll just murder the f*ck out of everyone." Real goddamn heroic. Great example. Terrific role model behavior coming from what is supposed to be the "wish-fulfillment" character for the younger kids who read the book.
Also, Tim earned the job. Damien barged in and demanded it, and threw a fit until he got it.
There is literally not ONE redeeming thing about that character. Not a single thing. Grant Morrison has done a lot of stupid sh*t, but that one is unforgivable. This sh*t wouldn't be happening on Denny O'Neil's watch. He was quite crystal clear that "Son of the Demon" never happened in-canon, and that's why it was printed as an "Elseworlds" for years.
They should have the four Turtles fight the four Robins.
Leo656
12-21-2014, 01:52 AM
Mind Blown.
...No Steph then, huh? I kinda don't count her either, I was just checking.
I didn't know she existed. I was thinking of the sons of Batman vs the sons of Splinter.
Leo656
12-21-2014, 02:37 AM
Good call. Stephanie Brown aka Spoiler aka Batgirl #537 was briefly Robin during Tim's run, or at least she fancied herself as Robin, but people always debate about whether or not she counts. It was like for 5 minutes.
Leo656
12-21-2014, 04:01 AM
He also once presented a duffel bag of human heads as a trophy.
Adorable.
Shark_Blade
12-21-2014, 04:05 AM
I actually prefer Damian Wayne to the rest of the Robins.
He's so rude and rough for a littly tyke, love seeing him beating the **** out of things and people. He showed no mercy and is able to beat his target to a pulp, bloody and all. He's even capable of murder (the other Robins can't even compare to that lol). He was raised by Talia al Ghul after all.
But underneath that hardened exterior he does value kinship and loyalty from what I read of New Batman & Robin (aka Batman Reborn) comics - Dick Grayson as Batman. I have all series I think :D.
But eh, it's still great that Raph won. Although in a fight, I reckon Damian would win.
He also once presented a duffel bag of human heads as a trophy.
Adorable.
Yes love that moment. :tlol: Such a poster child.
Leo656
12-21-2014, 04:10 AM
So, I'm just gonna go ahead and ask, at the risk of being an asshole, I just have to.
So. The brain damage. Did you grow up living under power lines, or, as I suspect, was it a "parents built you a swing set less than three feet away from the back of the house" kind of deal? I've been dying to know, and I just can't hold it in anymore.
the_soub
12-21-2014, 07:42 AM
Jason and Damian are almost as hot-headed as Raph, so the control thing is pretty much a wash.
Nightwing, and Red Robin (pre New-52) take the win for sure.
At the end of Pre-New 52, Batman makes reference to how he thinks Dick would probably take him in a fight now, and that Tim might be the best detective in the world.
MikeandRaph87
12-21-2014, 11:24 AM
Dick Grayson-the computer tech was only so developed when he was Robin for those 44 years. Still he was top his class through his education. 1984 was the year the first personal computer was commerically available and the year the internet was developed and the year he switched the Robin costume for the Nightwing costume.In other words he has the smarts just not able to show tech skills. Dick has the experience perhaps more than the turtles
Jason Todd was as said above just filling the void of Dick Grayson. The character was a clone in characterization then transformed into a ungrateful brat who got beat up by the lowly Craxy Quilt and Mad Hatter imposter before Joker and we fans offed him. Even now as a wannabe Punisher he could not stand a chance against Raphael who would be calm enough to outsmart him.
Damian is a 10 year old lab experiment with the personality of Jason Todd if not to the extreme.He would lose not so much to being roughly six years younger when age makes a difference but like Jason his overconfidence in himself and hotheaded nature uncontained will cause him to lose.
Tim while he could hold his own I don't see him winning. He might analyze Raphael but Raphael will be too quick for him and take him down with some effort. Dick probably would have experience over Raphael and Dick sets the bar for not just Rbin that will not be passed but for any sidekick character.I love both characters but Dick's diverse skill set does not make him the best detective or smartest in the room but his high flyer skills combined. With all of that allow him to win.
CyberCubed
12-21-2014, 12:29 PM
Its funny that after all these years Dick Grayson is still the only recognizable Robin to the general public. You ask most people who aren't into comics and they'll tell you they had no idea there are 4 Robin's. When Jason Todd died some people thought that was the original Robin, from what I read online.
They've been trying to include Tim Drake in the cartoons, he was in the last season of B:TAS and he was also in the second season of Young Justice. But in both shows he barely received any characterisation other than, "young, kid-like Robin."
The DC animated movies did include Jason Todd and Damian, but that's it.
Leo656
12-21-2014, 04:17 PM
No way Raphael is quicker than Tim, if only because he's likely way heavier, plus the cumbersome shell. I can go along with some of that other stuff but definitely not that one. Raphael Is Not Faster Than Tim Drake, nor could he possibly be as agile.
I think it could go either way with those two but I'd generally still give it to Tim, though not necessarily by the largest of margins. Don't forget he has an entire utility belt full of stuff that Raph possibly might not have any idea how to counter, either. The kid ain't no "junior sidekick". Even Superman has often commented on Just How Good this kid is. That's street cred, homie. Like, when Superman can't get Batman on the Bat-Phone, he doesn't leave a message, he asks TIM if he can help him out. How cool is that?
I swear people do underestimate the kid just because he doesn't get put in any movies. That's bogus.
oldmanwinters
12-23-2014, 01:48 PM
Not Jason, Jason was only even Robin because Bruce was subconsciously trying to get back at Grayson. Kid never had the chops. He'd get his ass kicked in about 7.4 seconds.
The other guys I could see.
Eh, I'll give you that one. However... Red Hood Jason would have to stand an even chance.
Bat-brand Utility Belts are the great equalizer. Kinda like YouTube and home economics.
Cipher
12-23-2014, 03:19 PM
Some things I just don't get. HOW can anyone love Damien? Like really, he's just such a piece of sh*t on purpose. It's not "edgy" or "bad-ass"; when kids in real life act like exactly the entitled little snot-rocket he acts, we as adults generally admit we would like to put them (or their parents) through a window.
Stick a cape on him, though, "Best Character EVAR!" I sincerely don't get it. I would f*cking shoot that kid in the face until I was out of bullets, reload, and start over.
*Damian
Because he's a colorful, whimsical comic-book character in a colorful, whimsical comic-book world. Because he's a subversion of the Robin-Batman role after 70-some years of uniformity? Have you read Tomasi's run with him, or the end of Morrison's? He's not supposed to be "edgy" or "bad-ass," except for possessing those qualities in the most superficial way (which the audience sees through). He's a fun character.
Basically,
If Damien was YOUR kid, and he talked to you the way he talks to his own FATHER, who happens to be BATMAN of all people, you'd tan his hide with every belt in your closet. Don't lie. We live in an era where the comments section of almost every single news article is full of comments by adults bemoaning what entitled little c*nts kids are nowadays, and here we get that taken to the Nth degree, played straight, and he's a HERO?
I think we part ways on the idea that he's played remotely straight, save for a few emotional beats in the runs mentioned above.
As for the thread topic: Who cares? You know who would win? Ambush Bug.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.