PDA

View Full Version : IDW 2014 turtles design


Nederseth
12-25-2014, 10:34 AM
Hi everyone,

Because I am not a fan of the IDW current turtles design, I told Bobby Curnow about it here (http://boards.idwpublishing.com/3/viewtopic.php?f=33&t=10128&start=2775#p385868).

As I said there, I think the turtles now look more like children and therefore I by far prefer - for example - the 2012 design from the same artist, Mateus Santolouco.

I created this thread to have your opinion.
Am I the only one who prefers the 2012 design? Which design do you prefer?

http://plannedbanter.files.wordpress.com/2013/01/1352224873.jpg?w=440&h=240&crop=1
2012 design

http://fc03.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2014/318/e/6/e6ecf2908c165626bfdbf6d65d4985d3-d86erk8.jpg
Current/2014 design

Powder
12-25-2014, 10:36 AM
I definitely prefer the older style. I didn't care for his first style as the unique masks really turned me off, & I don't care for the new one as their foreheads are too large & they've got very pronounced noses. What he was doing in between these two styles was his absolute best, IMO, his start on the main run, which was similar to what Cory Smith is now doing.

Amaranthus
12-25-2014, 10:55 AM
12 year old mutant ninja turtles?

Nederseth
12-25-2014, 10:58 AM
I like Cory Smith's turtles very much. If Mateus doesn't change its turtle design, I hope Smith will work more often on the IDW ongoing.

EDIT:
12 year old mutant ninja turtles?What do you mean?

Rooish
12-25-2014, 11:09 AM
I really can't stand Santolouco's designs these days. Partly because I don't like the Nick designs he is trying to emulate. Michelangelo and Donatello particularly look like crap and that's the be all and end all of it.

Amaranthus
12-25-2014, 11:11 AM
I like Cory Smith's turtles very much. If Mateus doesn't change its turtle design, I hope Smith will work more often on the IDW ongoing.

EDIT:
What do you mean?

Because the second design in your first post makes them look like little kids.
I thought that was obvious enough.

TheBlueTurtle1
12-25-2014, 11:26 AM
2012 is way better.:ohwell:

Nederseth
12-25-2014, 11:37 AM
Because the second design in your first post makes them look like little kids.
I thought that was obvious enough.
Indeed, that was obvious, sorry :)
And yes, I also think they look like kids and that bothers me :(

Joey Kamikaze
12-25-2014, 11:42 AM
They looked best around SHotFC and City Fall, no doubt.

bushido
12-25-2014, 11:46 AM
I really can't stand Santolouco's designs these days. Partly because I don't like the Nick designs he is trying to emulate.

I think he is more influenced by Ross Campbell's "kawaii" design

AquaParade
12-25-2014, 12:01 PM
I think Mateus is an excellent artist. I even appreciate his changing of the turtles masks to better resemble their classic design. However, I really think the turtles faces need a change.

CyberCubed
12-25-2014, 12:35 PM
I do prefer his old look too, so perhaps he'll change his style again next year.

Sabacooza
12-25-2014, 12:38 PM
There's no need to emulate Campbell's stuff which is looking very cutesy these days. His stuff is better suited for a book more geared towards children like the New Animated Adventures.

Santolouco should just focus on drawing like Santolouco. He's still a phenomenal artist but his stuff shined the most when he wasn't emulating Campbell.

TonySiegel
12-25-2014, 12:43 PM
http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2012/180/5/3/tmnt_cover_11_by_dan_duncan-d55cxo3.jpg

wouldn't mind having dan duncan back...

Rooish
12-25-2014, 12:47 PM
I liked Duncan's stuff too, even when it got really rushed. I like when the Turtles aren't so different looking from each other.

Candy Kappa
12-25-2014, 12:54 PM
I wasn't too big on Santolouco in the beginning, but I think he have improved tremedously drawing the Turtles, although their snouts are still a bit weird at times. His humans are awesome, and the other mutants are really nice.

I really don't mind the turtles looking cute, but then again, I am a huge fan of Ross' artstyle.

ToTheNines
12-25-2014, 01:40 PM
I don't mind the current look, except something about Don looks extremely feminine. In the new Vengeance promo at least.

Santolouco is always on top of his game, but as far as designs go, he was probably rocking it best during early City Fall.

Redeemer
12-25-2014, 04:54 PM
I don't mind the current look, except something about Don looks extremely feminine. In the new Vengeance promo at least.

Santolouco is always on top of his game, but as far as designs go, he was probably rocking it best during early City Fall.

Agreed Don looks feminine especially.
Santolouco is an amazing artist, but I prefer his earlier 2012 designs, his current 2014 designs are just too damn childish. It could be the boys upstairs forcing him to draw them younger and more like the "Nick Toon". I really hope they change the design back bc at this point I actually might drop the book. the design is just killing me.

spookycookies
12-25-2014, 04:59 PM
I definitely prefer Santolouco pre Northampton. I think Ross's designs sort of spoiled what Mateus is up to now. Hate to spin the broken record again but they lean toward the adorable side a little too much for my tastes at times. Namely the button noses and giant anime eyes.

Joey Kamikaze
12-25-2014, 07:03 PM
I'm not crazy about Campbell's turtle designs either, at least not on this book. His chibi turtles would be fine on a book for kids but they don't fit in a book that leans teen to adult. And his influence on Santalouco is unfortunate. Now if they stuck Campbell on NAA I'd think he would fit right in.

(One thing I will give Campbell is he draws my favorite Renet thus far.)

boywonder26
12-25-2014, 07:52 PM
I love santolouco's art.his turtles are amazing.

mrmaczaps
12-25-2014, 08:04 PM
Oooh i'm ***NOT*** the only one who thinks they look horrible now!
Fugly looking tween TMNT... Great for a kids book... But eesh.
Anyways, I voted 2012 version.

liugeaux
12-26-2014, 10:25 AM
I actually prefer the newer designs, it serves as a reminder that the turtles are actually teens. 15 year old kids don't look like hulking muscle bound killing machines. Don't get me wrong, I loved Santolouco's old designs too but I think everyone (writers/fans/designers/etc.) need to remember that most kids don't start to look like actual adults until about 21 years old.

The turtles in his older work look 25-30 years old. That's like when they had 24 year old Tom Welling playing a "teenage" Clark Kent.

Even not taking the age thing into consideration, I still prefer his later designs.

boywonder26
12-26-2014, 10:39 AM
I voted for the new design..but I honestly love both of his designs.

Rooish
12-26-2014, 11:11 AM
Also guys, can we please talk about Mikey's buck tooth? Please? Like why is it there? What purpose does it serve? Why do I feel like I'm the only one who thinks it's hideous and kind of damaging to his character? Do I have to start a thread or will someone validate me on here?

Powder
12-26-2014, 11:19 AM
It's to kiddify him, I think, given this series follows in Nick's footsteps with the whole Mikey is the kid brother thing. I don't mind it much, but I could see why others might.

ChosenOne
12-26-2014, 11:39 AM
I can't make up my mind to vote. Everything Mateus has done so far is gold.

Rooish
12-26-2014, 12:05 PM
It's to kiddify him, I think, given this series follows in Nick's footsteps with the whole Mikey is the kid brother thing. I don't mind it much, but I could see why others might.

But why? Just because he's the youngest doesn't mean he's 6. He is supposed to be at least a little cool sometimes and the buck tooth makes that hard to achieve.

AquaParade
12-26-2014, 02:53 PM
Yes! I forgot to mention that I can't stand the tooth.

Donnieangelo
12-26-2014, 03:39 PM
2012, of course! :nod:

This new sudden change of art style makes my head spin! :(

liugeaux
12-26-2014, 04:12 PM
2014 Design = Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
2012 Design = Quarter-Life Mutant Angst Monsters

Cipher
12-26-2014, 04:39 PM
wouldn't mind having dan duncan back...
Ditto. Duncan's still my favorite artist to have worked on this series. Even when you can tell his drawings are a little rushed, they're still so full of energy and his Turtles look so good it doesn't matter.

Santaluoco's good, but he's never captured movement for me in that way. Not a fan of his choices with Donatello and especially Michelangelo's faces, either. It's impossible to take this Mike seriously whatsoever, which is a shame.

Rooish
12-26-2014, 05:36 PM
It's impossible to take this Mike seriously whatsoever, which is a shame.

I agree. And it makes me sad because Waltz et al. actually really tried to give this version of Mike a strong developed character that was cute but not goofy or incompetent. He just looks terrible for no good reason.

dlariv
12-26-2014, 09:29 PM
Santolouco is doing great job i think. Love is art. It's different, but i'm good with this.

Uki
12-27-2014, 05:41 AM
I like the new stuff. It's all been good, but they're kids. They should look like kids.

DarkFell
12-27-2014, 05:51 AM
Went along with the 2012 design. *Because it just screams Ninja Turtles. Even though they almost look more like adults than teenagers.*

2014 looks sorta chibi-ish to me. *This can be alright if they wanted to do a flashback story when the Turtles were younger.*

Like how the 2014 design defuses the seriousness of the 2012 design.

Candy Kappa
12-27-2014, 06:16 AM
Went along with the 2012 design. *Because it just screams Ninja Turtles. Even though they almost look more like adults than teenagers.*

2014 looks sorta chibi-ish to me. *This can be alright if they wanted to do a flashback story when the Turtles were younger.*

Like how the 2014 design defuses the seriousness of the 2012 design.

I highly doubt IDW will be doing flashback scenes of the Turtles as kids, unless it's about them as humans, cause in issue 1 the turtles are 15 months old as mutants, not 15 years.

Luckyday
12-27-2014, 09:42 AM
I still enjoy the current although that new image in the beginning thread post looks too chibi for my taste. It's the eyes that bothers me.

I think they look great when they look like this.
http://www.destroythecyb.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/tmnt_2.jpg

But if his artwork become even more chibi stylized then I would understand their plight.

I highly doubt IDW will be doing flashback scenes of the Turtles as kids, unless it's about them as humans, cause in issue 1 the turtles are 15 months old as mutants, not 15 years.

Plus they are fully grown after being mutated by the ooze.

LeotheLateBloomer
12-27-2014, 10:22 AM
The new style is actually what turns me off from the new IDW comics. Those designs look too cutesy. Yuck!

Has it ever been explained why the current comics are using the Nick cartoon designs?

Coola Yagami
12-27-2014, 11:40 AM
The new style is actually what turns me off from the new IDW comics. Those designs look too cutesy. Yuck!

Has it ever been explained why the current comics are using the Nick cartoon designs?

Probably to draw in the Nicktoon crowd into buying them too.

Within the comic itself it's kinda like those things where the characters aren't supposed to notice that they look different. I do like how they're drawn in the Ghostbusters art style though. Have them tackle an arc or two in the main series, at least to see the belt buckles back.

Rooish
12-27-2014, 02:06 PM
The new style is actually what turns me off from the new IDW comics. Those designs look too cutesy. Yuck!

Has it ever been explained why the current comics are using the Nick cartoon designs?

I don't get it either. I read comics to get away from that show.

Cipher
12-27-2014, 03:21 PM
I think they look great when they look like this.
http://www.destroythecyb.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/tmnt_2.jpg

I still hate that Mike.

Like, just straight up one of the worst designs ever applied to the character.

Which I feel weird even saying, because, again, Santoluoco is a good artist, and I'm not one to get hung up on new/different designs. But I can't wrap my mind around why he needs a set of traits that visually invalidate him as a character, and which aren't applied to the other Turtles. I just think it's a really, really bad choice.

Also, can I put something out there?

I'm not a big an of the combination of Santoluoco's art with Rhonda Patterson's coloring. Which also feels odd, because they're both great at their jobs, and, visually, Patterson is the book's glue. But Santoluoco's designs really popped with the coloring in Secret History of the Foot Clan. Patterson's coloring, on the other hand, worked perfectly/unobtrusively with artists like Duncan, Khun, and the stint with Campbell (although his self-coloring is also great). Together, though, everything just looks kind of flat in a way I don't enjoy. I'm not sure what it is.

Candy Kappa
12-27-2014, 03:42 PM
I do hope Mikey's buck teeth eventually goes away.

Sabacooza
12-27-2014, 05:32 PM
I think they look great when they look like this.
http://www.destroythecyb.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/tmnt_2.jpgI agree with this. I like their look right here.

CyberCubed
12-27-2014, 05:36 PM
The Turtles in IDW always look different depending who is drawing them. Its not like the only IDW TMNT designs are from this artist.

Sabacooza
12-27-2014, 06:23 PM
The Turtles in IDW always look different depending who is drawing them. Its not like the only IDW TMNT designs are from this artist.I think you fail to grasp the point of this thread. True, Santolouco shouldn't be singled out just because his style happens to change a bit. Duncan's certainly changed later on when he was doing it the first go around and again when he did the last issue of Turtles in Time but the thread is about the cover image posted. I think the reason Santolouco's is pointed out is because it's more noticeable and also, he's a more prominent artist for TMNT. However, when Duncan was on it, people had gripes about his work as well. I still love Santolouco's work. He has some mad skills even if he does change his style a bit.

CyberCubed
12-27-2014, 08:10 PM
Isn't that why IDW alternates between artists? That way people can see different art styles and people prefer different artists over the other.

Sabacooza
12-27-2014, 08:23 PM
Isn't that why IDW alternates between artists? That way people can see different art styles and people prefer different artists over the other.I have no idea. I don't know the inner workings of IDW. Maybe they change because that's all the artist can commit to at the time. Maybe their contract runs out. Even though Santolouco's style change shouldn't necessarily be singled out because others have done it as well, the topic is specifically talking about Santolouco's change based on the FCBD cover.

Raven
12-27-2014, 08:47 PM
Isn't that why IDW alternates between artists? That way people can see different art styles and people prefer different artists over the other.

Dead lines, dead lines, dead lines.

This is usually 100% the reason why you see in any of the major comic publishers for switching artists. Unless that artist has a lot of pull, like Jim Lee or Andy Kubert then the publisher will hire out a helping hand to keep things on track.

Mateus inks his own work, which is going to slow him down considerably compared to other comic artists out there. But yes, sometimes there changing it up for what the story calls for. But 9 out of 10 times, its to keep the book on schedule.

Leomaru
12-27-2014, 10:01 PM
The older designs are better in my opinion. Santolouco's older designs are my favorite in IDW even though I always preferred white, empty eyes for the turtles.

I'm also pretty sure that I am not the only one who noticed how Santolouco's Alopex changed from a BAD*** to a fluffy kitten.

Sabacooza
12-27-2014, 10:05 PM
I'm also pretty sure that I am not the only one who noticed how Santolouco's Alopex changed from a BAD*** to a fluffy kitten.Again, most likely due to Campbell's influence.

pingclang
12-27-2014, 10:06 PM
I'm just another voice on the side of his old designs. When he did Secret History I was blown away and then he took over on the ongoing and his style changed and it just got rough. I still like how he draws humans but his mutants look terrible. If I had a say, I think Ben Bates should be the guy on pencils, but that's a whole other topic.

DONATELLO DUZMACHINES
12-27-2014, 10:26 PM
I love this design right here

http://www.destroythecyb.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/tmnt_2.jpg


Honestly though Im a fan of all of Mateus' s designs old and new, I think they all look amazing. This book has had some great artist but by far he is my favorite.

Nederseth
12-28-2014, 03:15 AM
As many people prefer Mateus Santolouco's older turtle design, I will contact him next weekend and tell him about this thread.
Therefore, by then, do not hesitate to post detailed opinions.

Sabacooza
12-28-2014, 10:32 AM
As many people prefer Mateus Santolouco's older turtle design, I will contact him next weekend and tell him about this thread.
Therefore, by then, do not hesitate to post detailed opinions.That's fine but keep it constructive and civil. At the end of the day though, Santolouco isn't obligated to change anything.

Coola Yagami
12-28-2014, 11:11 AM
So um... when are gonna see someone else do the art? I feel like the guy we got now has been doing this forever. At least since Cityfall and onwards. Artist change!!!!

I'm kinda feeling this new look has been around for so long that it's gonna become the staple of the series and whoever is next is gonna be kinda/sorta forced to emulate it the best they can so the art shift isn't so jarring. I know the style changes every 4 or 5 issues, but this is way beyond 4 or 5 issues. It's already becoming the established IDW TMNT look. I feel if the next guy in line draws them more like how they looked in the first few issues, short term readers are gonna be confused as to why the TMNT suddenly 'grew up' from one issue to the next.

ProphetofGanja
12-28-2014, 12:28 PM
So um... when are gonna see someone else do the art? I feel like the guy we got now has been doing this forever. At least since Cityfall and onwards. Artist change!!!!

I'm kinda feeling this new look has been around for so long that it's gonna become the staple of the series and whoever is next is gonna be kinda/sorta forced to emulate it the best they can so the art shift isn't so jarring. I know the style changes every 4 or 5 issues, but this is way beyond 4 or 5 issues. It's already becoming the established IDW TMNT look. I feel if the next guy in line draws them more like how they looked in the first few issues, short term readers are gonna be confused as to why the TMNT suddenly 'grew up' from one issue to the next.

You must not be paying attention...

Plasticplayhouse
12-28-2014, 05:32 PM
I love santolouco's art. I think all of his renditions are fantastic. I do prefer a more classic design...meaning more along the lines of the Mirage likeness, but I still appreciate the newer stuff. I take it all in stride. Art styles change several times over the years anyways, so I try not to get hung up on the little tweeks.

I feel that some fans are way too critical over the artists and their styles. The story is so good that if there was a short stint by an artist I may not be the fondest of, I can get over it and just enjoy the story.

Coola Yagami
12-28-2014, 10:14 PM
You must not be paying attention...

I have been paying attention, and if a new artist took over after City Fall ended, this new guy seemed to go with what came before, possibly adding his/her own touches here and there.... but it's still too similar to look like an all-out different style. For me, the art style hasn't really changed all that much since City Fall to current. Whenever we get someone that will draw them completely different... say the guy who's doing the Ghostbusters crossover, the sudden art shift is gonna be very jarring after sticking with this current style for too long.

Icegaze
01-03-2015, 05:35 PM
I'd like to start off by saying that I am a HUGE Santolouco fan. His artwork has the all round best quality for a TMNT characterization.
Actually, there are 3 different Santolouco art styles in this comics series:

- The 2012 one (Secret History of the Foot Clan)
- The 2013 one (City Fall arc)
- The 2014 one (post Northampton arc)

My favourite is the 2013 one because of the grit that it had which suited the plot.
The 2012 one was way too 90s movie like and made the turtles look older and agressive. I like the 2014 one albeit it does make the turtles seem too young at times.

A middle ground between the 2013 and 2014 designs can be made and that what I hope to see.
The biggest minus for me in the 2014 design is Alopex. Mateus has made her look more like a mutant pup instead of the beast-looking threat she was in City Fall.

I know Ross Campbell heavily influenced his change in art direction but I'd hope he doesn't continue down this "chibi" path.
So far, it is ok. But I'd hope for more consistency with the design of characters such as Alopex (e.g. height, mass).

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-08-2015, 03:33 PM
Actually, Ross' designs are what kept me away from the IDW comics for so long... I didn't know about them until he was the artist, and he mimics the Nicktoon designs way too much. Donnie and Mikey look TERRIBLE, and Mateus doesn't do much better.

I'd much prefer to get the artist from the first 12 issues back, although the guy drawing since "Attack on Technodrome" started looks okay... I don't want chibi kiddy Turtles with weird heads. :ohwell:

Donnie
01-10-2015, 10:35 AM
When Duncan was the artist, it seemed hardly nobody liked his style, and complained. Everybody wanted Mateus. Funny how the wind changes.

I still like Mateus, and do not want Duncan back.

Usagi Miyamoto
01-10-2015, 11:47 AM
When Duncan was the artist, it seemed hardly nobody liked his style, and complained. Everybody wanted Mateus. Funny how the wind changes.

I still like Mateus, and do not want Duncan back.
I've personally always found his art to be close to perfect for the turtles and was disappointed when the artstyle shifts began, but that's just me.

Icegaze
01-10-2015, 03:57 PM
I've personally always found his art to be close to perfect for the turtles and was disappointed when the artstyle shifts began, but that's just me.

Agreed. Nothing can ever top the City Fall arc in terms of design/artwork.
Santolouco decided to conform with Ross Campbell's style. A bit of a miss, especially for the turtles and Alopex.

Right now, my favourite character designs are:
1. Cory Smith (volumes 37 and 41)
2. Mateus Santolouco (even right now he cannot be below 2nd)
3. Dan Duncan (without the egg head style for the turtles)
4. Ben Bates (Neutrino arc)

The rest of the artists in my opinion don't fit the main plot design-work, especially Andy Kuhn and Ross Campbell.

Usagi Miyamoto
01-10-2015, 08:54 PM
Like with Duncan and the egg heads, I'm not exactly sure what inspired the change and I'm not sure why Santolouco went for it, but oh well.

As for some other neat styles, I really digged the Bebop and Rocksteady micro art - Utrom Empire's as well. I think it was Bates who did B&R. The non-flagship comics are nice for some varying artstyles, though I wouldn't mind SHOTFC's being permanent.

Bry
01-12-2015, 02:16 PM
There's no need to emulate Campbell's stuff which is looking very cutesy these days. His stuff is better suited for a book more geared towards children like the New Animated Adventures.

I don't think it has to - he's drawn some awesome, rough-looking ninja action before. The "Turtles in Time" issue was more bright and cutesy by design, but I think/hope he can switch back to a "rougher" style when the story calls for it, like the Leonardo microseries.

As for the poll - gotta go with the 2012 version. Mateus is a great artist and we're lucky to have him regardless, but a more "classic" look is my preference. Though I think he (and the other artists) has done a good job with the specific gear on each Turtle - it gives them each a bit of a unique look without going overboard or losing the classic TMNT design like... some other things...

I get that they're playing up their youth - which they should, to a degree - but they might have gone a little too far with it? With Michelangelo specifically.

Mormegil
02-19-2015, 10:41 AM
Sorry to push this topic back to the top, but i keep thinking about this. I like the 2012 art a lot better.

I'm not saying the newer stuff is bad, it just doesn't feel like a good fit. I feel like the more childish design is to different from the other support characters, it pulls me out of the story when i notice it. I cringe whenever i see that gap in Donatello's teeth.

There's nothing wrong with the Nickelodeon designs but i think they should be kept far away from each other.

Diorm
02-19-2015, 11:28 AM
I better like the turtles from 2012, but prefer the Humans from 2014... I just can't stand to watch the cute look of those 2014 turtles. It gets better when there is a fight scene but it's not that much better.

Sabacooza
02-19-2015, 05:43 PM
He's drawn some awesome, rough-looking ninja action before.Okay, I'll give you that. I did like his older style.

Vegeta
02-19-2015, 06:38 PM
Secret History of the Foot Clan is the best art from Mateus. Not because of the turtle designs but because the colorist did an amazing job and the art looked like it had been labored over for months. Mateus is my favorite IDW turtle artist despite the changes. I think he should let Ross Campbell do Ross Campbell (though Campbell is my second favorite from this run). All that to say I don't mind any of his designs and I love his work, I just wish he worked with the colorist from Secret History all the time.