PDA

View Full Version : Reprinting Image's Volume 3?


CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-08-2015, 03:29 PM
Hello,

I was just wondering if TMNT Volume 3 will be able to be reprinted by IDW, as there are numerous Image Comics' characters that appear heavily throughout the series. (Mako, Savage Dragon, Horridus, to name a few...)

Also, what would be the chances of including Andrew Modeen's fan-printed issues #24 and #25 as the proper conclusion to the volume if/when it does get reprinted?

CyberCubed
01-08-2015, 03:32 PM
They're only halfway into Volume 2 right now. The last Volume 2 collection comes out around May or so, after that I think we'll see Image.

IDW already said Image would give them the permission to reprint the issues that featured the Image superheroes like Savage Dragon, etc. I don't see any problems there.

No, IDW won't publish Andrew's Image conclusion since it was a fan project.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-08-2015, 06:55 PM
Just curious, when/where did they say that? I'm quite glad to hear it, however... I was worried this could end up like the "River" trilogy or how they skipped issues of Adventures (admittedly for quite different reasons).


IDW already said Image would give them the permission to reprint the issues that featured the Image superheroes like Savage Dragon, etc. I don't see any problems there.

CyberCubed
01-08-2015, 09:37 PM
I remember Erik Larson said that and then it was quoted and posted here on the forums months ago, sometime back in the middle of 2014.

Rat_King
01-09-2015, 01:57 AM
Erik Lason once told me like two years ago that he had a full conclusion to the Image story line that would have reverted things back to normal but the book got canceled not allowing him to do it. It would be great if IDW hired him to finish it out and finally make volume three canon.

Powder
01-09-2015, 02:00 AM
Whether or not they're official, the "fan"-made finishers do a plenty good job of giving us closure & solidifying canon status. Have you not read them? Carlson helped to script, they've got art/blessings from Eastman, Fosco, etc. So they're pretty legit.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-09-2015, 07:54 AM
Whether or not they're official, the "fan"-made finishers do a plenty good job of giving us closure & solidifying canon status. Have you not read them? Carlson helped to script, they've got art/blessings from Eastman, Fosco, etc. So they're pretty legit.

Hence my fervent hope that IDW does go ahead and reprint them. They are INCREDIBLE. And they're not just "fan" works, either.

Powder
01-09-2015, 08:24 AM
And they're not just "fan" works, either.

Heh, as one of it's contributors, I am quite aware & proud of it's star studded cast! :D

CyberCubed
01-09-2015, 08:29 AM
Andrew pitched the stories to IDW but they decided not to publish them, probably because its not a good idea for a professional company to publish fanfiction.

I can't think of many times in history a fan project got published. Usually companies look the other way and support fans though.

Rat_King
01-09-2015, 08:44 AM
It's certainly no offense to Andrew. His works are phenomenal but they are still fan works. If Larson read them and said they're close enough it would be one thing. My point is to include what the original intent or vision was for it's ending.

Powder
01-09-2015, 08:58 AM
It's certainly no offense to Andrew. His works are phenomenal but they are still fan works. If Larson read them and said they're close enough it would be one thing. My point is to include what the original intent or vision was for it's ending.

They did it with Erik's blessing/approval & Carlson's original notes... it really doesn't get better than that.

DrSpengler
01-09-2015, 10:13 AM
It's certainly no offense to Andrew. His works are phenomenal but they are still fan works. If Larson read them and said they're close enough it would be one thing. My point is to include what the original intent or vision was for it's ending.

I see where you're coming from. The ending Andrew published wasn't 100% what Carlson, Larsen and Fosco originally intended back in the 90s (it worked in numerous plot threads from works published afterward).

And I would like to see an alternate offshoot, myself, covering their original ideas (Lady Shredder was supposed to be someone else entirely, as I've read).

Though the ending we have, thanks to Andrew, is certainly "official" from a creator intent if not a "Viacom's legal division" intent, as official creators all contributed and approved of the work. Calling it "fan work" is a bit of a misnomer, I think, since it wasn't just fans who worked on it (Kevin Eastman even did cover inks!).

I appreciate what you're saying though; a detailed idea of how the story would have original gone down in the 90s would be an interesting thing to read about in a "what could have been" sort of way.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-09-2015, 10:31 AM
I see where you're coming from. The ending Andrew published wasn't 100% what Carlson, Larsen and Fosco originally intended back in the 90s (it worked in numerous plot threads from works published afterward).

And I would like to see an alternate offshoot, myself, covering their original ideas (Lady Shredder was supposed to be someone else entirely, as I've read).

When I had a chance to talk briefly with either Erik Larsen or Gary Carlson years ago (I can't remember which of them it was and now I feel bad about it), he confirmed that Lady Shredder was indeed Karai and that her motivations would involve her late daughter (killed in "City at War"). I had asked specifically if she was trying to resurrect her daughter the same way Saki had been resurrected, which was always my theory why she would turn antagonist...

Bry
01-09-2015, 10:32 AM
Erik Lason once told me like two years ago that he had a full conclusion to the Image story line that would have reverted things back to normal but the book got canceled not allowing him to do it. It would be great if IDW hired him to finish it out and finally make volume three canon.

That's effectively what the Andrew's issues did though, right? And like Powder said, it was based on the original notes, got approval from the writer (I think?) and collaborators, and featured work from several "official" creators. Can't see why they wouldn't just make that official if they want to collect it with a proper ending, if it's already done and everyone's happy with it.

Powder
01-09-2015, 06:02 PM
When I had a chance to talk briefly with either Erik Larsen or Gary Carlson years ago (I can't remember which of them it was and now I feel bad about it), he confirmed that Lady Shredder was indeed Karai and that her motivations would involve her late daughter (killed in "City at War"). I had asked specifically if she was trying to resurrect her daughter the same way Saki had been resurrected, which was always my theory why she would turn antagonist...

Andrew told me that Gary told him she was in fact NOT Karai.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-09-2015, 06:27 PM
Andrew told me that Gary told him she was in fact NOT Karai.

Really? Oh well, it was ~20 years ago for those guys and ~10 years ago that I talked to one of them... SOMEBODY is bound to not remember the original intent correctly, or to remember what somebody said to them. And that somebody could very well be me! :tlol:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-09-2015, 06:30 PM
Andrew pitched the stories to IDW but they decided not to publish them, probably because its not a good idea for a professional company to publish fanfiction.

I can't think of many times in history a fan project got published. Usually companies look the other way and support fans though.

Personally, I'd imagine the reason IDW decided not to run with it is because they have no interest or desire to tell any new stories in the pre-existing universes, whether it be Mirage/Image or Adventures... the extremely well-written and well-received short stories in the 30th Anniversary Special notwithstanding, of course.

Venom
01-09-2015, 07:42 PM
Personally, I'd imagine the reason IDW decided not to run with it is because they have no interest or desire to tell any new stories in the pre-existing universes...

IDW isn't against revisiting those universes, it just has to make sense to do so.

Bobby has essentially said, as a fan, even he'd like to see Murph script the Forever War for TMNTA, but it would have to make fiscal sense to publish it under the IDW banner.

Remember, IDW has continued several old comics where they left of, most notably GI Joe, with Larry Hama writing it!

Shedder
01-13-2015, 09:59 AM
I know its a mini series that you either love or hate (with most adults saying the latter) but do you think IDW will reprint these with the Vol 3 stuff?
I haven't read it and am missing issue 4 so I would like to read it and see what all the talk is about

Andrew NDB
01-15-2015, 01:57 PM
Andrew pitched the stories to IDW but they decided not to publish them, probably because its not a good idea for a professional company to publish fanfiction.

While essentially true, that had nothing to do with it. IDW has been nothing if not supportive in any way they possibly could be. And IDW TMNT #1 hadn't even come out when Image TMNT #24 saw print.