PDA

View Full Version : What does Nickelodeon not allow IDW to do?


neatoman
01-19-2015, 06:57 AM
So I've heard that Nickelodeon has to approve of everything IDW publish related to TMNT.

So is there anything Nickelodeon has outright said no on? It seems like there would not be much considering they allowed the decapitation of children, but it would still interesting to learn where the line goes...

Redrumh2o
01-19-2015, 10:16 AM
Nickelodeon says NO to many covers and requests changes. I have seen some from Lavigne and Lawson for the TPB that have been rejected, Petersen told me that Nickelodeon made him change a few covers (and the whole process turned him off from potentially doing a full issue), and I own the rejected Chris Allen cover from the 30th anniversary book because it didn't have enough "shenanigans" going on

http://i235.photobucket.com/albums/ee257/redrumh2o/20140629_111857_zpsctlbfy7p.jpg

https://multiversitystatic.s3.amazonaws.com/uploads/2014/05/TMNT_30th_cvrRE_HotTopic.jpg

TMNTChris1980
01-19-2015, 11:12 AM
I've heard they don't like the turtles doing graffiti, and stuff like that.

TigerClaw
01-19-2015, 11:39 AM
Nickelodeon says NO to many covers and requests changes. I have seen some from Lavigne and Lawson for the TPB that have been rejected, Petersen told me that Nickelodeon made him change a few covers (and the whole process turned him off from potentially doing a full issue), and I own the rejected Chris Allen cover from the 30th anniversary book because it didn't have enough "shenanigans" going on

http://i235.photobucket.com/albums/ee257/redrumh2o/20140629_111857_zpsctlbfy7p.jpg

https://multiversitystatic.s3.amazonaws.com/uploads/2014/05/TMNT_30th_cvrRE_HotTopic.jpg
Those were good covers, why would Nickelodeon reject these? Do they take issue with Ninjara? Since she appears a little busty in it?

Redrumh2o
01-19-2015, 11:47 AM
Those were good covers, why would Nickelodeon reject these? Do they take issue with Ninjara? Since she appears a little busty in it?

The top one was rejected, and the second one was the one they used

TigerClaw
01-19-2015, 12:03 PM
The top one was rejected, and the second one was the one they used
Why was the top one rejected, What was wrong with it?

oldmanwinters
01-19-2015, 12:24 PM
The biggest oddity with Nick's oversight of these Archie-OT era tributes is the apparent "No April O'Neil" policy:
https://doknowbutchie.wordpress.com/2014/05/25/the-strange-disappearance-of-april-oneil/
(courtesy of the Drome's own The Big Bad (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/member.php?u=864))
See also:
http://oldmanwinters.deviantart.com/art/TMNT-30th-Anniversary-Cover-479839965
So here's the unedited version of my Heroes' Haven Comics 30th Anniversary TNMT Special. As you can see April O'Neil was always meant to be a part of the cover, but it got edited out at the request of Nickelodeon. We fought the good fight but in the end the client is always right and we all need to respect that. The edited cover still came out epic and I'm very proud of the work everyone put in. - dovianax

I've yet to see anybody give a reason as for Nick's logic in removing April from the original spread completely. Her removal does free up more room to give Donatello more prominent placement.

Why was the top one rejected, What was wrong with it?

because it didn't have enough "shenanigans" going on



Both are nice covers, but I can see why the Nick editor would prefer something more dynamic as far as "action" goes. Considering this variant was so rare, though, I don't really know if it was worth the trouble.

TigerClaw
01-19-2015, 12:51 PM
It could be that Nickelodeon only wants TMNT on the covers for marketing

oldmanwinters
01-19-2015, 12:57 PM
It could be that Nickelodeon only wants TMNT on the covers for marketing

But... we've now had two clear appearances of Ninjara (on the Allan variant and one of the Archie collected TPB) and once in silhouette. The Mutanimals have now made some appearances once their story arcs have been featured in the collection. April has yet to make any appearances, despite her large prominent role in the mid-run Archie sagas. I'm curious as to whether we should expect her mini-series to be collected and reprinted any time soon.

TigerClaw
01-19-2015, 01:07 PM
What does Nickelodeon have against April?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-19-2015, 01:15 PM
At a guess, because they don't want to confuse little kids with April appearing as an adult instead of a teenager?

TigerClaw
01-19-2015, 01:19 PM
At a guess, because they don't want to confuse little kids with April appearing as an adult instead of a teenager?
That's one possibility.

oldmanwinters
01-19-2015, 01:27 PM
The Forum kinda kicked around some ideas about whether and why vintage April was being intentionally banned form merchandise. The Big Bad thought something was up, and I kinda thought such speculation was ridiculous (April rarely featured prominently in vintage Mirage TMNT art), but once the news of the variant cover edit came out, I had no choice but to admit something was unusual:
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=47293

I'm still more inclined to think Nick discourages featuring female characters on covers since there's a long standing corporate assumption that males/boys of certain target demographics don't want to buy stuff with girls on them, but Renet and Ninjara have both made appearances since then. Maybe they think vintage April looks too boring? On the other hand, Nick April has already been featured on at least three covers (more if you count all the variants) for the current New Animated Adventures comic.

CyberCubed
01-19-2015, 02:02 PM
Its pretty obvious Nick does hold IDW back from getting "too adult" or "too violent."

You can tell the IDW comic pushes the boundaries of what a cartoon would like Young Justice, Korra, Gargoyles, Justice League, etc. does but that's where it stays.

neatoman
01-19-2015, 02:18 PM
It does sound weird that Nick would have such petty concern as to not wanting female characters to be displayed on covers.

I have just checked the trades I have:

April, Renet, Shadow, Radical, Ninjara and Dale can all be seen on IDW's reprints of the 80's/90's stuff but not quite that prominently...
As for IDW's own series, I could only find a little less than 40 covers to feature female characters. Keep in mind here, this is not just the first 36 issues, it's also the 30 side issues and all the alt covers. Not to mention that many of these either features female characters in the background or it's characters like Alopex or Koya whom a casual buyer might not figure out is female.

I don't think it's intentional, I just think it kind of happens...

neatoman
01-19-2015, 02:24 PM
Its pretty obvious Nick does hold IDW back from getting "too adult" or "too violent."

You can tell the IDW comic pushes the boundaries of what a cartoon would like Young Justice, Korra, Gargoyles, Justice League, etc. does but that's where it stays.

Uh... I don't remember Young Justice, Korra, Gargoyles and Justice League (unless you are talking about the direct to video movies) ever pulling something like this:
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11114/111140735/3554464-5476036026-IMG_1.png

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-19-2015, 02:25 PM
Biggest example being: brainwashed Leonardo not killing anybody in "City Fall." Sigh... :trolleye:

Its pretty obvious Nick does hold IDW back from getting "too adult" or "too violent."

neatoman
01-19-2015, 02:30 PM
Biggest example being: brainwashed Leonardo not killing anybody in "City Fall." Sigh... :trolleye:

Is it OK to ask why your reply always ends up above the quotation instead of under it?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-19-2015, 02:38 PM
Is it OK to ask why your reply always ends up above the quotation instead of under it?

I deliberately put it there. Is that an issue? If it's an issue or against the norm, I'm fine leaving it as is.

Mewzard
01-19-2015, 03:03 PM
Uh... I don't remember Young Justice, Korra, Gargoyles and Justice League (unless you are talking about the direct to video movies) ever pulling something like this:
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11114/111140735/3554464-5476036026-IMG_1.png

Well, the Gargoyles comic certainly went places:

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51ljrTQAq%2BL._SL500_.jpg

Couldn't find a bigger image sadly. Still, I think my point was made clear.

That's not counting the stuff that was edited in the TV cut of Gargoyles (especially that episode with Elisa and Broadway early on in the show).

neatoman
01-19-2015, 03:17 PM
I deliberately put it there. Is that an issue? If it's an issue or against the norm, I'm fine leaving it as is.

It is a bit confusing to be honest, reading a response before the message you're responding to makes it a bit hard to follow. I end up first thinking you're just writing something that isn't a response, only to discover that it is.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-19-2015, 03:54 PM
Sorry 'bout that. The precedent I'm used to is the opposite, but I'll try to keep that in mind.

Usagi Miyamoto
01-19-2015, 05:35 PM
The suggestion that it's to prevent an adult April from confusing readers makes the most sense, IMO. Also it's really not all that massively censored - though maybe Nick forced them to deage the turtles.

TigerClaw
01-19-2015, 05:49 PM
The suggestion that it's to prevent an adult April from confusing readers makes the most sense, IMO. Also it's really not all that massively censored - though maybe Nick forced them to deage the turtles.
It seems odd, Because you have the new TMNT movie, Which has an adult April in it, But don't see her image plastered in the covers or posters of the movie, there has to be something more to it, Perhaps its just that, They only want the main characters on the covers, April in the comics has always been a side character, Shes never at the center, Most of the time she needs rescuing.

The nick show on the other hand, is portraying April as someone who can defend herself, Especially since shes training with the Turtles often.

I think its all in the marketing, Nick sees TMNT appealing to a male demographic, and are forcing these guidelines that, They only want the Turtles in those comic book covers.

DevilSpooky
01-19-2015, 07:05 PM
It seems odd, Because you have the new TMNT movie, Which has an adult April in it, But don't see her image plastered in the covers or posters of the movie, there has to be something more to it, Perhaps its just that, They only want the main characters on the covers, April in the comics has always been a side character, Shes never at the center, Most of the time she needs rescuing.

The nick show on the other hand, is portraying April as someone who can defend herself, Especially since shes training with the Turtles often.

I think its all in the marketing, Nick sees TMNT appealing to a male demographic, and are forcing these guidelines that, They only want the Turtles in those comic book covers.

Archie April can defeat a bunch of Foot Soldiers and even defeated a demon alone, so it's not that. It's because of her age difference, I saw tons of kids complaining about the movie because she's an adult in it.

TigerClaw
01-19-2015, 07:13 PM
Archie April can defeat a bunch of Foot Soldiers and even defeated a demon alone, so it's not that. It's because of her age difference, I saw tons of kids complaining about the movie because she's an adult in it.
Well, Blame Nick then, I wonder whose idea was to make April a teenager in the first place.

Usagi Miyamoto
01-19-2015, 07:22 PM
She's a POWER GURL in Nicktoons to get demographic views. A young adult scientist that serves as more of a human aide to the turtles and not a psychic alien just isn't as appealing to kids, probably.

oldmanwinters
01-19-2015, 07:52 PM
She's a POWER GURL in Nicktoons to get demographic views. A young adult scientist that serves as more of a human aide to the turtles and not a psychic alien just isn't as appealing to kids, probably.

And, apparently, not even a world-traveling reporter who dabbles in occasional ninja weapons training under Master Splinter makes the cut either.

Leo656
01-19-2015, 10:08 PM
Well, Blame Nick then

I do, for lots of stuff.

I wonder if enough time has passed so that it's "okay" to say out loud that Nick getting their hands on this franchise was an AWFUL thing? Because aside from "More Product", it is. The cracks are starting to show, little by little.

Rooish
01-19-2015, 10:09 PM
But it gave us the IDW series instead of Volume 4?

Leo656
01-19-2015, 10:11 PM
Thank goodness for small favors.

TigerClaw
01-19-2015, 10:11 PM
I do, for lots of stuff.

I wonder if enough time has passed so that it's "okay" to say out loud that Nick getting their hands on this franchise was an AWFUL thing? Because aside from "More Product", it is. The cracks are starting to show, little by little.
With Nickelodeon setting the guidelines on what IDW can, and can't do, You'll never get a mature TMNT in the comics, movies, or TV. In there eyes, It's a kids property.

Its why the majority of the Merchandise you see out there, Is based on the TV show and not any other incarnation, With the except of some being based on the 80s series, But you never see any based on the IDW ones.

Rooish
01-19-2015, 10:14 PM
Okay. I know the good guys can't kill anyone in IDW, but at least it's much more mature than the show. We have the past lives Turtles being beheaded as children, plenty of mild swearing, some philosophical stuff, a very well crafted storyline, and plenty of discussion about killing! Lol. I think that the Nick show and the movie are not in the same league as IDW.

Maybe I still would prefer Tristan Jones's gang wars stories from Tales Vol. 2, but not everything from the sale is bad.

Still, WTF about no April on the covers.

TigerClaw
01-19-2015, 10:18 PM
Yet Nickelodeon has a problem having April O'Neil showing on a cover for the comics

Leo656
01-19-2015, 10:23 PM
With Nickelodeon setting the guidelines on what IDW can, and can't do, You'll never get a mature TMNT in the comics, movies, or TV. In there eyes, It's a kids property.

Its why the majority of the Merchandise you see out there, Is based on the TV show and not any other incarnation, With the except of some being based on the 80s series, But you never see any based on the IDW ones.

No kidding, and I knew however many years ago that was going to be the case. And I was against it.

People better enjoy whatever we have now, because this is as "good" as things under Nick's watch are ever gonna be. And they ain't great. It's only a matter of time until Nick gets nervous about IDW's portrayal and decides to pull the plug. Just wait.

Nick takes things and keeps them in a little box marked "Just For Kiddies". I understand it, but it's why I knew from the start that it was a huge mistake for them to get this property. I think Laird knew it, too, but was completely fed up and didn't care anymore. I mean, I get it, that's a lot of money he made off that deal, he never has to worry or care about anything ever again.

I just don't like it. Their "meddling" has been pretty small potatoes so far, but you can see how they're slowly digging their hooks in deeper.

CyberCubed
01-19-2015, 11:27 PM
I think you're going into conspiracy theory territory here. Nick isn't going to sabotage the IDW series or force them to cancel the book unless the series tanks in sales which shouldn't be for a good while yet.

Nick has allowed IDW to show death in the comic so its not like its a Saturday morning cartoon.

Leo656
01-19-2015, 11:58 PM
Like I said, it's gonna take a while, but it will happen. There ain't no "conspiracy", it's how business works and how They do business.

They "allow" the book to exist as a token gesture for the older fans. They also know nothing that happens in the book will affect fans of the TV show, because Nobody Reads Comic Books, and those who do are not the main audience for the cartoon. Yes, there is some cross-over, but it's minimal. Not everyone who reads the book watches the show, and most people who watch the show don't read the book. Comic sales across the board are slipping because of the ridiculous 3 and 4-dollar price point, so it's only a matter of time before Nick decides that they just don't want to keep the book going, especially since it's so contradictory to the "real" TMNT, the ones in the cartoons and movies.

Might take a few years, but it'll happen. First the books will get the ax, because they're not making any huge money from that arm of the business anyway; it's just a "Gift" for the older fans. Then, when the cartoon's ratings slip (and I don't know what the ratings are, but the plots they've been coming up with show they're already scraping the bottom as far as ideas, so that's also gonna happen sooner rather than later), that will get pulled as well. They'll still have the movies, until the box office drops around part 3 or 4 (which is what happens with every franchise of this nature), and by then, they'll be all out of patience and stick TMNT on a shelf entirely for at least ten years, until they decide it's "relevant" again. Or they could decide it's not worth it, and just keep it on the shelf and just make money off of DVDs forever, which is a great way to maximize profits while minimizing costs on their end.

It's really not at all hard to see how easily it can happen OR how likely it is. Nick as a company does not have a great track record for these kinds of things. It's just too Corporate.

CyberCubed
01-20-2015, 12:56 AM
But what you're saying is obvious, and happens with every franchise. It goes through a cycle and then comes to an end. I don't think anyone is expecting the IDW comic to run forever. Likewise the cartoon will probably last similar to the 4kids run.

I mean everything you're saying is common sense and we knew this back in the Mirage and 4kids days of the early 2000's too.

Leo656
01-20-2015, 01:09 AM
Except Nick isn't well-known for ever bringing that stuff back once it's outlived its peak popularity. Once it's "done" this time, it might be a loooong time, if ever, before they bring it back.

If you're cool with that, fine. But if this is the "last gasp" of the franchise, it would be nice if it were a little bit better across the board. And I have a strong feeling it would be, if Anyone Else were handling it.

CyberCubed
01-20-2015, 01:26 AM
Except Nick isn't well-known for ever bringing that stuff back once it's outlived its peak popularity. Once it's "done" this time, it might be a loooong time, if ever, before they bring it back.

If you're cool with that, fine. But if this is the "last gasp" of the franchise, it would be nice if it were a little bit better across the board. And I have a strong feeling it would be, if Anyone Else were handling it.

Its the third reboot, I'm fine if this is the last one for awhile. The Nick cartoon will probably last as long as the 4kids show, and the IDW comic will probably make it to issue 100 (and if you count their specials and mini's there are already nearly 100 IDW TMNT comics).

The only other older TMNT universe that can still continue is Mirage, and that's only until PL finishes Volume 4 anyway.

HeroTurtlesFan
01-20-2015, 07:00 AM
Wow, so many moans about the Turtles not killing anyone and it all being Nick's fault.

Am I the only one who is quite happy for my heroes not to be killers?

And for this to be a "family franchise" - meaning we get younger-skewed stuff (e.g. Half Shell Heroes), children/young adult (Nick TMNT - some of those episodes definitely aren't suited for very young children) and stuff aimed at us oldies too (IDW comic, the rash of Mirage/OT-based merchandise etc).

Leo656, I think you are being far too pessimistic about Nick and the current state of the franchise. Please don't take offense, just my opinion. You've also put me in the awkward position of agreeing with Cybercubed!

Cubed is right, though - all franchises will inevitably have highs, lows, very lows, time out of the limelight etc. I think Nick has done a great job with how it is managing the franchise, but I suspect in 4 or 5 years TMNT will take another break from the popular culture spotlight. And that's a perfectly healthy part of the lifecycle for these sorts of things. Even juggernauts like Star Wars and Transformers have had moments of inertia/decline.

Rooish
01-20-2015, 07:07 AM
Why wouldn't they just sell it then? I mean it would make lots of money!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-20-2015, 10:28 AM
Why wouldn't they just sell it then? I mean it would make lots of money!

Because some money you will make isn't as attractive as more money you may make by retaining the rights for some unspecified future windfall. I side with Leo656 on this.

I believe it is a direct correlation to Nick owning the TMNT that has prevented Leo from killing anyone in "City Fall" (which IMO neutered that entire story-arc) and has potentially forced all of the artists to mimic the cartoon with childish Turtles (especially Mikey and Don). THAT is my biggest pet peeve... man, I miss Dan Duncan from the first twelve issues. :tcry:

Sophie Campbell
01-20-2015, 11:02 AM
i wish i could go into some of the stuff Nickelodeon has had me change but i won't for the sake of professionalism, but i'm not working on TMNT at the moment and probably not for the foreseeable future, so i'll say more than i would otherwise. ;)

as far as i know the only main mandate from up high is that the Turtles can't kill. obviously i'm just an artist and a sporadic one at that, i don't know what goes on with the powers that be, but i was involved in the script process on the stories i've drawn and privy to the changes that were requested and made, but the changes are mostly relegated to individual cases. they were even cool with me suggesting my own ideas, like April's haircut in Northampton, or Pepperoni in Turtles in Time. same with the art, i've never been given any mandates on what i must do or can't do. there's no mandate that the Turtles look like the Nickelodeon cartoon Turtles, in fact Mateus has stated elsewhere that there was some concern that they SHOULDN'T look like the cartoon Turtles (also look at Andy Kuhn, Charles Wilson III, etc.).

from what i can tell the Nickelodeon higher-ups aren't involved, we deal with a couple freelance and in-house editors whose requests are vary on a case by case basis, and sometimes they change from day to day, like one day they'll remark on an aspect of character design that they don't like, but then it's fine in the next instance of the same thing. it all depends on the individual scene or drawing. the editors' personal preferences are probably the largest factor. they're people, too, they have their own preferences and dislikes like anyone does.

i've had a few battles with the Nick editors, i have no problem fighting with them and being a diva to get my way, and the little things that they fuss about can get on my nerves, but overall they're extremely lenient. the Alopex issue and Turtles in Time #1 in particular, those were a breeze, they didn't have me change anything art-wise. it was all me. aside from one huge fight, Northampton was also a great experience, they let me do anything i wanted. the worst experience i've had was when i pitched to write the April O'Neil micro issue, it was an awful, soul-crushing experience. the story was eventually rejected at the last minute.

i think the Nick editors have also gotten much more casual and lenient as the comic series has progressed, too, as it's settled into what it is and everyone knows more what it's about and it's less amorphous than it was in the early days. there's more leeway now. it seems like they're also much harder on writers than they are on the artists.

i see a lot of people speculating about what goes on behind the scenes with licensed comics, like the parent companies handing down lists of corporate mandates and restrictive marketing campaigns and all that, but most of the time that's not the case. with Nickelodeon and Hasbro, it's all really lenient and casual. all the TMNT stuff has to go through the approval process, yeah, but for the most part things end up how the artists want to draw them. you guys wouldn't believe how hands-off Hasbro is, i've seen people theorizing about all the behind-the-scenes corporate maneuvering on the Jem & the Holograms i'm working on now, but the art is seriously all me. they basically turned me loose to do whatever the hell i want. Nickelodeon is more restrictive, but they largely turned me loose, too.

anyway, i felt like i should step in here and give my two cents and tell you guys some of the experiences i've had personally. and of course i can't speak for the other TMNT creators, these experiences are my own.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-20-2015, 11:11 AM
Thanks for the inside scoop, Ross! I hope you enjoy your new gig!

And I gotta say, even though I'm not a fan of the Turtles looking younger, I LOVED your Alopex issue.

TigerClaw
01-20-2015, 11:22 AM
So Nickelodeon doesn't want an April O'Neil Micro Series? Why is that? what I want to know, is, what is the issue they have with April as a character?

Is it cause they don't want people confused with the two versions? Does Nick only want to acknowledge that the April that only exist, Is the cartoon version?

Are they concerned that, they only want the male demographic?

I'm sensing a whole lot of studio politics going around, and we hear about stuff like that all the time with other studios.

Powder
01-20-2015, 11:30 AM
So Nickelodeon doesn't want an April O'Neil Micro Series? Why is that? what I want to know, is, what is the issue they have with April as a character?

...She already got one.

TigerClaw
01-20-2015, 11:35 AM
...She already got one.
lol your right.

http://www.idwpublishing.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/tmnt07-april-cova11.jpg

Sophie Campbell
01-20-2015, 11:35 AM
So Nickelodeon doesn't want an April O'Neil Micro Series? Why is that? what I want to know, is, what is the issue they have with April as a character?

Is it cause they don't want people confused with the two versions? Does Nick only want to acknowledge that the April that only exist, Is the cartoon version?

Are they concerned that, they only want the male demographic?

I'm sensing a whole lot of studio politics going around, and we hear about stuff like that all the time with other studios.

edit: you guys beat me to it! ;)
there WAS an April micro-series issue! they just didn't end up going with my story for it. and there's no problem with the two Aprils being confused with each other, no. there's no problem like that existing for any other character with multiple versions, April is no different. every single thing IDW is doing isn't vetted by the big bosses at Nickelodeon.

i don't know why they didn't want her on that one 30th Anniversary cover, like i was saying a lot if it is simply personal preference, maybe the editors didn't like the particular drawing or something. i think fans have a hard time believing it but a lot of times it really comes down to something that simple.

Powder
01-20-2015, 11:36 AM
I always assumed their beef was with OT April's outfit, as some say it's too sexualized.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-20-2015, 11:37 AM
What was your idea? Always interested in alternate paths... or are you not allowed to say?

TigerClaw
01-20-2015, 11:38 AM
I always assumed their beef was with OT April's outfit, as some say it's too sexualized.
a yellow jumpsuit is too sexualized?

lilmotto
01-20-2015, 11:48 AM
The only thing that will kill the tv show is the current season.... please no more Seth Green.

Usagi Miyamoto
01-20-2015, 04:18 PM
Thanks a lot for the info, glad to hear that Nick doesn't keep IDW under chains.

And honestly, I'm fine with the turtles not killing, though I hope that if the story really called for it they'd be allowed to.

oldmanwinters
01-20-2015, 05:18 PM
I always assumed their beef was with OT April's outfit, as some say it's too sexualized.

I can understand their concern... possibly aggravated by some heavily circulated pics of fan art or cosplays. But one would think it might have just been easier for them to request the artist redraw her pose instead of deleting her altogether. Maybe they did make the request and there just wasn't enough time? The artist doesn't seem to desire to elaborate at length on the subject over at the Deviantart page.


April is no different. every single thing IDW is doing isn't vetted by the big bosses at Nickelodeon.

i don't know why they didn't want her on that one 30th Anniversary cover, like i was saying a lot if it is simply personal preference, maybe the editors didn't like the particular drawing or something. i think fans have a hard time believing it but a lot of times it really comes down to something that simple.

Thanks for sharing your experience, Ross! I am among those who would LOVE to hear a summary or breakdown on your idea for the April Micro!

Mutant Ninja Anole
01-20-2015, 06:37 PM
Was hoping to hear from one of the staff that post here. Thanks for the input Ross!

Sophie Campbell
01-20-2015, 06:38 PM
What was your idea? Always interested in alternate paths... or are you not allowed to say?

i probably shouldn't go too much into it, but whatever, haha. the story was while everyone else is out of town, April finds Alopex all beat up in an alley way, after receiving a beating from the Foot for continually failing her missions (in one version it was going to be Bebop and Rocksteady that beat her up, foreshadowing their mutation way earlier). April takes her home and nurses her back to health, and it would have introduced Klunk, too, April and Alopex were going to bond over getting him to warm up to them. then Alopex was going to prepare to kill April while she slept, but then April wakes up and confronts her, revealing that she knew Alopex was with the Foot all along, and Alopex spares her because April was the first person to ever show her any kindness. i wanted to show a strength that April had that wasn't punching or fighting like the other characters, something that got into her personality more.

anyway, that was the basic story without getting into the details. the April issue they ended up going with was great though, so it worked out. Marley Zarcone!! :)

oldmanwinters
01-20-2015, 06:47 PM
i probably shouldn't go too much into it, but whatever, haha. the story was while everyone else is out of town, April finds Alopex all beat up in an alley way, after receiving a beating from the Foot for continually failing her missions (in one version it was going to be Bebop and Rocksteady that beat her up, foreshadowing their mutation way earlier). April takes her home and nurses her back to health, and it would have introduced Klunk, too, April and Alopex were going to bond over getting him to warm up to them. then Alopex was going to prepare to kill April while she slept, but then April wakes up and confronts her, revealing that she knew Alopex was with the Foot all along, and Alopex spares her because April was the first person to ever show her any kindness. i wanted to show a strength that April had that wasn't punching or fighting like the other characters, something that got into her personality more.

anyway, that was the basic story without getting into the details. the April issue they ended up going with was great though, so it worked out. Marley Zarcone!! :)

It's a great concept! But I fear it might have come across as too similar to the Raphael Micro that already featured Alopex in a large capacity. Either way, I'm sure you would have knocked it out of the park artistically!

Sophie Campbell
01-20-2015, 07:07 PM
It's a great concept! But I fear it might have come across as too similar to the Raphael Micro that already featured Alopex in a large capacity. Either way, I'm sure you would have knocked it out of the park artistically!

thanks! yeah, that was one of the concerns, that it also involved Alopex being deceptive or whatever, despite the story around that being different. it was really similar. but basically i just wanted April and Alopex to have a sleepover. XD

oh another part i just remembered, duh, was that April could no longer relate to regular human people now that her life was all crazy with ninjas and mutants, and she stopped hanging out with her roommate Trish and her other friends. and when Alopex came along, April could relate to her because she was a mutant and she could understand April's new life. April didn't have to hide from Alopex like she has to hide from everyone else in the human world.

oldmanwinters
01-20-2015, 07:24 PM
Maybe it's all for the best how things ultimately worked out. It was on account of April that Slash received his opportunity to roam free... or at least tag along with Hob.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-20-2015, 07:38 PM
I have to admit, I do prefer the Slash setup if only because it gave us Slash. But I think overall you have a deeper grasp on the character of April O'Neil, Ross! The whole concepts of not being able to relate to humans anymore... I also loved your writing of the O'Neil family in "Northampton."

And KLUNK!!! :tgrin::tgrin::tgrin:

Who knows, maybe someday we can see it published in a later issue of IDW TMNT...


thanks! yeah, that was one of the concerns, that it also involved Alopex being deceptive or whatever, despite the story around that being different. it was really similar. but basically i just wanted April and Alopex to have a sleepover. XD

oh another part i just remembered, duh, was that April could no longer relate to regular human people now that her life was all crazy with ninjas and mutants, and she stopped hanging out with her roommate Trish and her other friends. and when Alopex came along, April could relate to her because she was a mutant and she could understand April's new life. April didn't have to hide from Alopex like she has to hide from everyone else in the human world.

i probably shouldn't go too much into it, but whatever, haha. the story was while everyone else is out of town, April finds Alopex all beat up in an alley way, after receiving a beating from the Foot for continually failing her missions (in one version it was going to be Bebop and Rocksteady that beat her up, foreshadowing their mutation way earlier). April takes her home and nurses her back to health, and it would have introduced Klunk, too, April and Alopex were going to bond over getting him to warm up to them. then Alopex was going to prepare to kill April while she slept, but then April wakes up and confronts her, revealing that she knew Alopex was with the Foot all along, and Alopex spares her because April was the first person to ever show her any kindness. i wanted to show a strength that April had that wasn't punching or fighting like the other characters, something that got into her personality more.

anyway, that was the basic story without getting into the details. the April issue they ended up going with was great though, so it worked out. Marley Zarcone!! :)

ToTheNines
01-20-2015, 07:50 PM
I'm glad Ross is posting in this thread because I was just gonna bring up : A turtle killed a Foot Ninja in Northampton!

We never see the deathblow, but you can see one of the assassin with their eyes x'ed out in one panel, then you only see three of them escaping with Koya.

Did this just sneak past the Nickelodeon people? Or is there a more interesting behind the scenes story?

Leo656
01-20-2015, 08:17 PM
Hey Ross, just wanted to say thanks for your insight. Much appreciated.

Joey Kamikaze
01-20-2015, 08:25 PM
I'm glad Ross is posting in this thread because I was just gonna bring up : A turtle killed a Foot Ninja in Northampton!

That's what cracks me up with the whole no killing thing. The turtles have tangled with the Foot on multiple occasions using those ninja weapons. You don't have those big battles and have them end with "and then everyone got better again" all the time. The turtles have killed in IDW whether they intend to or not, count on it.

Sophie Campbell
01-20-2015, 08:33 PM
I have to admit, I do prefer the Slash setup if only because it gave us Slash. But I think overall you have a deeper grasp on the character of April O'Neil, Ross! The whole concepts of not being able to relate to humans anymore... I also loved your writing of the O'Neil family in "Northampton."

And KLUNK!!! :tgrin::tgrin::tgrin:

Who knows, maybe someday we can see it published in a later issue of IDW TMNT...

Tom Waltz wrote Northampton, not me! although i was in charge of all the body language and facial expressions, which is just as important if i do say so myself. ;D

as i recall the final version of the micro that Bobby and i were working on did have a Slash setup but it was more like an after-credits stinger gag and he didn't show up in-panel. i can't quite remember how it went but Bobby had the idea that i think somehow Alopex knew about Slash and she told April about it but it was left a mystery what she'd told April until the very end, and the last line of the issue was April telling the Turtles and Casey "there's a fifth Turtle!" or something like that. we went through so many revisions that a lot of it is kind of jumbled in my head now, unfortunately. i still have the file somewhere, i should take a look at it.

I'm glad Ross is posting in this thread because I was just gonna bring up : A turtle killed a Foot Ninja in Northampton!

We never see the deathblow, but you can see one of the assassin with their eyes x'ed out in one panel, then you only see three of them escaping with Koya.

Did this just sneak past the Nickelodeon people? Or is there a more interesting behind the scenes story?

haha, the X eyes was just a joke i slipped in because i thought it was funny, i always put in lots of things into the artwork that weren't in the script, but as far as i'm concerned that ninja is totally dead! i actually wish i'd gone with a darker tone in the final Northampton fight and not done things like the X-ed out eyes. sometimes the scene got serious but looking back on it now there were a lot of lighter moments that i wish i'd toned down so the fight would have seemed more desperate and frantic.

anyway, i know the IDW Turtles aren't supposed to kill and there's no way my personal take on it is canon, but in my head they do, at least in the issues i've drawn. when i was doing the Leo micro i didn't draw any gushing blood but i absolutely intended for him to be killing those Foot ninjas. not only slicing them up but there are a couple panels where he throws ninjas off a building to their doom. there's no way they survived some of that stuff. in Northampton, i'll admit i didn't keep track of the number of Foot Assassins, i didn't have a set number that came along with Koya, the script never specified, but i personally intended for a bunch of them to be dead. also because i like the idea that after the fight, the Turtles had to clean up the farm and Beth O'Neil stands off to the side like O_O as she watches the Turtles get rid of all the ninja corpses, haha. April would be standing there checking her Twitter feed, totally inured to all the Foot baloney by that point. XD

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-20-2015, 08:41 PM
Well, the no-killing policy can be taken a bit out of context IMO. We know Leo and Raph are fighting with bladed weapons; and we know that they're fighting people trying to kill them. I don't have to see the blood or disembowelment to know that some Foot ninja are getting killed. And it stretches the mind far beyond willing suspension of disbelief to say that Leo and Raph haven't killed anyone.

But whatever keeps Nick happy, sure. <wink wink> SURE they're just knocking them out with those pointy-stabby-slicy things.

I think the only time in the IDW run so far where we needed to see an actual "on-screen" kill was Dark Leo and Victor of the Savate. But we all know that dead horse, so I'm just gonna drop my stick and walk away now. :trazz:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-20-2015, 08:44 PM
Then in hindsight, it's a good thing you didn't go with that Slash stinger "There's a fifth Turtle!" Fanboys would have burned the forums to the ground while screaming epithets against Venus de Milo. :tlol:

My favorite bit you've drawn was in Turtles in Time #1, when Raph says "Don't worry guys, I've got this" as he reaches for something to throw... and then the last we see of the Utroms, one of them is repeating the exact same mistake. :tlol::tlol::tlol:

Tom Waltz wrote Northampton, not me! although i was in charge of all the body language and facial expressions, which is just as important if i do say so myself. ;D

as i recall the final version of the micro that Bobby and i were working on did have a Slash setup but it was more like an after-credits stinger gag and he didn't show up in-panel. i can't quite remember how it went but Bobby had the idea that i think somehow Alopex knew about Slash and she told April about it but it was left a mystery what she'd told April until the very end, and the last line of the issue was April telling the Turtles and Casey "there's a fifth Turtle!" or something like that. we went through so many revisions that a lot of it is kind of jumbled in my head now, unfortunately. i still have the file somewhere, i should take a look at it.

Rooish
01-20-2015, 09:50 PM
Ross, I like your April-Alopex idea. You really like the female bonding don't you? I've seen your Deviantart! ;) I feel that your story would have helped make April a little less bland than she is in IDW.

Now as for whether the Turtles have killed anyone in IDW: so, what you're all saying is they've totally killed people? Don't get me wrong, I'd be okay with this, but it does not fit into what has been discussed ad nauseum in the actual pages of the comic. Splinter has a no kill rule. Leo explicitly never killed anyone, even Koya. It just contradicts the words that are spoken in the story!

Sophie Campbell
01-20-2015, 10:33 PM
Ross, I like your April-Alopex idea. You really like the female bonding don't you? I've seen your Deviantart! ;) I feel that your story would have helped make April a little less bland than she is in IDW.

Now as for whether the Turtles have killed anyone in IDW: so, what you're all saying is they've totally killed people? Don't get me wrong, I'd be okay with this, but it does not fit into what has been discussed ad nauseum in the actual pages of the comic. Splinter has a no kill rule. Leo explicitly never killed anyone, even Koya. It just contradicts the words that are spoken in the story!

yeah, like i said it's not canon, it doesn't actually work, that's just what i'm thinking when i'm drawing that stuff! ;) i'd never expect Bobby and Tom to make it canon. i guess i feel like it's different when it's just faceless goons being killed, i don't know. XD maybe i'm splitting hairs.

although, when i was drawing the scene with Leo and Koya, to me it's not about killing. it's not about whether Leo will kill her, and in my mind Dark Leo was never about killing or not killing, it's about Leo being able to choose his own actions, whether it's kill or not kill. so that Koya sequence where Leo has his sword up, for me it's not about whether he'll kill her or not, it's about whether he's able to choose for himself what he wants to do. even when he was Dark Leo, he wanted to kill but Shredder always stopped him, even then he was never in control of his own choices. him not killing Koya is him choosing for himself.

and again maybe i'm splitting hairs and way overthinking things, haha. XD

spookycookies
01-21-2015, 12:15 AM
yeah, like i said it's not canon, it doesn't actually work, that's just what i'm thinking when i'm drawing that stuff! ;) i'd never expect Bobby and Tom to make it canon. i guess i feel like it's different when it's just faceless goons being killed, i don't know. XD maybe i'm splitting hairs.

although, when i was drawing the scene with Leo and Koya, to me it's not about killing. it's not about whether Leo will kill her, and in my mind Dark Leo was never about killing or not killing, it's about Leo being able to choose his own actions, whether it's kill or not kill. so that Koya sequence where Leo has his sword up, for me it's not about whether he'll kill her or not, it's about whether he's able to choose for himself what he wants to do. even when he was Dark Leo, he wanted to kill but Shredder always stopped him, even then he was never in control of his own choices. him not killing Koya is him choosing for himself.

and again maybe i'm splitting hairs and way overthinking things, haha. XD

Good point Ross, I don't think the Dark Leo thing was about him becoming a killing machine or losing his soul to the foot in a moral way, but about choice. The 2 page spread you did for CityFall actually says so much about Leo's character up until then, being the leader among his brothers (but not his family,) Leonardo is obligated to follow and enforce Splinter's wishes despite his own feelings. At the end of Northampton I felt that the resolution wasn't that Leo was no longer a tool for evil but that he had finally found his own identity and independence. Leonardo post Northampton is much more decisive and vocal about his feelings especially now that they are aligning less with Splinter. To sum it up, CityFall & Northampton wasn't so much about "Will Leonardo kill or not?" but "Who is Leonardo?" (In the context of family, as a leader etc.)

It was very interesting to hear about your April Micro pitch. I am eagerly awaiting Klunk's debut in the IDW universe and I think you had some great idea's about April not fitting in with regular college culture after meeting the turtles. I know I only have your comments about it to work with but from what you summarized it seemed like the book lacked any sort of big action? There really is room in IDW TMNT for quieter more personal stories but maybe not at the top of year 2? Either way thanks for sharing I really enjoy glimpsing behind the curtain when it comes to this book.

pennydreadful
01-21-2015, 01:30 AM
Hi Ross - great to see you back on the forums! :tgrin:

Thanks so much for sharing your experiences - it's really cool to hear about your thoughts and such during your time on the comic.

(Looking forward to Jem coming out too - you're an amazing artist. :tlove: Hope all's well in your corner of the world!)

neatoman
01-21-2015, 06:01 AM
There is one thing I do wonder about wheter or not it was some kind of editorial demand. When the Purple Dragons are first introduced they're Angel's neighbourhood watch, but as the series progresses the Dragons become more like the version of them from the 2003 cartoon (a decent amount of members, Hun's leadership, the connection to the Foot, hell Dragonface is actually depicted on a cover!) which is arguably the most recognisable version of the Purple Dragons. I also think this might be the reason Hun will be added to the Nickelodeon cartoon soon, to make the Dragons seem more recognisable.

Sophie Campbell
01-21-2015, 02:21 PM
It was very interesting to hear about your April Micro pitch. I am eagerly awaiting Klunk's debut in the IDW universe and I think you had some great idea's about April not fitting in with regular college culture after meeting the turtles. I know I only have your comments about it to work with but from what you summarized it seemed like the book lacked any sort of big action? There really is room in IDW TMNT for quieter more personal stories but maybe not at the top of year 2? Either way thanks for sharing I really enjoy glimpsing behind the curtain when it comes to this book.

you're right, that was another obstacle, the lack of action. you're also right that it being early on in the series with an action-less issue was a concern. that was part of the reason we added in the suspense between April and Alopex, to give it some tension. that was really frustrating for me, i agree that IDW TMNT has room for quiet more lowkey stories, not every issue has to have fighting or a big plot or intrigue or whatever, especially focusing on a character like April.

Hi Ross - great to see you back on the forums! :tgrin:

Thanks so much for sharing your experiences - it's really cool to hear about your thoughts and such during your time on the comic.

(Looking forward to Jem coming out too - you're an amazing artist. :tlove: Hope all's well in your corner of the world!)

thanks so much!! :) i'm glad you enjoyed what i had to say. i hope you enjoy Jem, too! i'm excited about it.

ProphetofGanja
01-21-2015, 11:08 PM
Nickelodeon says NO to many covers and requests changes. I have seen some from Lavigne and Lawson for the TPB that have been rejected, Petersen told me that Nickelodeon made him change a few covers (and the whole process turned him off from potentially doing a full issue), and I own the rejected Chris Allen cover from the 30th anniversary book because it didn't have enough "shenanigans" going on

http://i235.photobucket.com/albums/ee257/redrumh2o/20140629_111857_zpsctlbfy7p.jpg

https://multiversitystatic.s3.amazonaws.com/uploads/2014/05/TMNT_30th_cvrRE_HotTopic.jpg

there is like 1000x more shenanigans on that second cover

TigerClaw
01-22-2015, 07:41 AM
Funny how Ninjara is on the 30th anniversary cover, Yet she's nowhere near in the comic itself, Perhaps someday she will appear, But she will have some competition with Alopex.

Though it would've been nice if you included Mona Lisa in the cover as well.

neatoman
01-22-2015, 08:41 AM
Funny how Ninjara is on the 30th anniversary cover, Yet she's nowhere near in the comic itself, Perhaps someday she will appear, But she will have some competition with Alopex.

Though it would've been nice if you included Mona Lisa in the cover as well.

Do you mean that she's not in the IDW series? Because she was in the 30th anniversary issue.

I'm assuming you're talking about the latter, in which case I think there's a reason Alopex simply isn't just Ninjara.

oldmanwinters
01-22-2015, 08:44 AM
Funny how Ninjara is on the 30th anniversary cover, Yet she's nowhere near in the comic itself, Perhaps someday she will appear...



Except... she totally is!
http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2014/05/paper-or-plastic.html

TigerClaw
01-22-2015, 09:47 AM
Do you mean that she's not in the IDW series? Because she was in the 30th anniversary issue.

I'm assuming you're talking about the latter, in which case I think there's a reason Alopex simply isn't just Ninjara.
I'm talking about the idw tmnt universe itself, That story took place in the Archie Comic universe.

neatoman
01-22-2015, 11:23 AM
I'm talking about the idw tmnt universe itself.

It's not that strange really, we don't have every important character from TMNT history in the IDW comic, it does not have to. The FW cartoon ignored most characters from Mirage (I think Baxter, Rat King, Casey and Leatherhead were the only ones taken from the comic aside from the main cast), the 4Kids series ignored the FW characters (for a very good reason) and the Nickelodeon cartoon pick and choose like crazy. I don't see why Ninjara would need to be in the IDW series.

Although it is a little odd that IDW does have a female ninja fox, who is not the same female ninja fox as the one in the most mainstream TMNT comic produced before IDW's run.

TigerClaw
01-22-2015, 11:34 AM
It's not that strange really, we don't have every important character from TMNT history in the IDW comic, it does not have to. The FW cartoon ignored most characters from Mirage (I think Baxter, Rat King, Casey and Leatherhead were the only ones taken from the comic aside from the main cast), the 4Kids series ignored the FW characters (for a very good reason) and the Nickelodeon cartoon pick and choose like crazy. I don't see why Ninjara would need to be in the IDW series.

Although it is a little odd that IDW does have a female ninja fox, who is not the same female ninja fox as the one in the most mainstream TMNT comic produced before IDW's run.
Which is interesting cause IDW has a mutant name Bludgeon, Whose a Hammerhead Shark, and the Archie Comic had Armaggon.

Usagi Miyamoto
01-22-2015, 01:14 PM
Although it is a little odd that IDW does have a female ninja fox, who is not the same female ninja fox as the one in the most mainstream TMNT comic produced before IDW's run.
Alopex reminds me of Bludgeon: a slightly different and pretty much better looking version of an animal with an existing mutation. For instance, if you're going to mutate a hammerhead you might as well use Bludgeon again, but if you're mutating a nurse shark chances are you're going to want to make it a new character.

CyberCubed
01-22-2015, 05:30 PM
It's not that strange really, we don't have every important character from TMNT history in the IDW comic, it does not have to. The FW cartoon ignored most characters from Mirage (I think Baxter, Rat King, Casey and Leatherhead were the only ones taken from the comic aside from the main cast), the 4Kids series ignored the FW characters (for a very good reason) and the Nickelodeon cartoon pick and choose like crazy. I don't see why Ninjara would need to be in the IDW series.
.

The original toon actually used almost every major Mirage character at the time except Fugitoid, Renet/Savanti, and some of the one-off human characters.

You have to remember the original cartoon started in 1987, the Mirage comics were only 3 years old at that point. They didn't even have much material to work with since the Mirage comic was in its infancy.

Still the fact that Fugitoid never made it into the original cartoon for even a single episode is bizarre.

ToTheNines
04-22-2026, 05:45 AM
i wish i could go into some of the stuff Nickelodeon has had me change but i won't for the sake of professionalism, but i'm not working on TMNT at the moment and probably not for the foreseeable future, so i'll say more than i would otherwise. ;)

as far as i know the only main mandate from up high is that the Turtles can't kill. obviously i'm just an artist and a sporadic one at that, i don't know what goes on with the powers that be, but i was involved in the script process on the stories i've drawn and privy to the changes that were requested and made, but the changes are mostly relegated to individual cases. they were even cool with me suggesting my own ideas, like April's haircut in Northampton, or Pepperoni in Turtles in Time. same with the art, i've never been given any mandates on what i must do or can't do. there's no mandate that the Turtles look like the Nickelodeon cartoon Turtles, in fact Mateus has stated elsewhere that there was some concern that they SHOULDN'T look like the cartoon Turtles (also look at Andy Kuhn, Charles Wilson III, etc.).

from what i can tell the Nickelodeon higher-ups aren't involved, we deal with a couple freelance and in-house editors whose requests are vary on a case by case basis, and sometimes they change from day to day, like one day they'll remark on an aspect of character design that they don't like, but then it's fine in the next instance of the same thing. it all depends on the individual scene or drawing. the editors' personal preferences are probably the largest factor. they're people, too, they have their own preferences and dislikes like anyone does.

i've had a few battles with the Nick editors, i have no problem fighting with them and being a diva to get my way, and the little things that they fuss about can get on my nerves, but overall they're extremely lenient. the Alopex issue and Turtles in Time #1 in particular, those were a breeze, they didn't have me change anything art-wise. it was all me. aside from one huge fight, Northampton was also a great experience, they let me do anything i wanted. the worst experience i've had was when i pitched to write the April O'Neil micro issue, it was an awful, soul-crushing experience. the story was eventually rejected at the last minute.

i think the Nick editors have also gotten much more casual and lenient as the comic series has progressed, too, as it's settled into what it is and everyone knows more what it's about and it's less amorphous than it was in the early days. there's more leeway now. it seems like they're also much harder on writers than they are on the artists.

i see a lot of people speculating about what goes on behind the scenes with licensed comics, like the parent companies handing down lists of corporate mandates and restrictive marketing campaigns and all that, but most of the time that's not the case. with Nickelodeon and Hasbro, it's all really lenient and casual. all the TMNT stuff has to go through the approval process, yeah, but for the most part things end up how the artists want to draw them. you guys wouldn't believe how hands-off Hasbro is, i've seen people theorizing about all the behind-the-scenes corporate maneuvering on the Jem & the Holograms i'm working on now, but the art is seriously all me. they basically turned me loose to do whatever the hell i want. Nickelodeon is more restrictive, but they largely turned me loose, too.

anyway, i felt like i should step in here and give my two cents and tell you guys some of the experiences i've had personally. and of course i can't speak for the other TMNT creators, these experiences are my own.

This is a very interesting post.