View Full Version : What is the logic behind Adventures vol 9?
neatoman
01-23-2015, 05:24 AM
So I just read volume 9 of IDW's Adventures reprints and felt like I was missing something important. At first I just thought it was that they reprinted Mutanimals #6 while skipping first 5 issues but no, not only did they skip over Mutanimals 1-5, they skipped over Adventures 32-37. Why would they ignore 6 issues of the series? Wouldn't it make more sense to have 32-37 be volume 9, while Mutanimals #6 and 38-40 would be volume 10?
As a side note, I found amusing that Dreadmon adressed Leo as "Leo, mon". That has no signifigance, I just liked the unintended association.
ToTheNines
01-23-2015, 05:58 AM
IDW trying to be PC, I reckon. Those stories deal with China's oppression of Tibet, fictional depictions of Mecca, and an illustrated portrayal of the prophet Mohammed.
evan2000
01-23-2015, 07:45 AM
Mighty Mutanimals #1-5 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/mutanimals/01/01.htm) is a spin-off arc telling the Mutanimals' adventure (without the turtles) that took place immediately after Mr. Null/Maligna's joint-arc (which consist of TMNT Adventures #19 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/19/19.htm) and Mighty Mutanimals Mini-Series #1-3 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/mutanimals/miniseries/01/01.htm)) and right before the United We Stand, Divided We Fall arc (which consist of TMNT Adventures #38 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/38/38.htm), Mighty Mutanimals #6 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/mutanimals/06/06.htm) and TMNT Adventures #39 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/39/39.htm)).
Note that chronologically the Mutanimals spin-off arcs are usually happening in parallel with the main issues. For instance, the MM Mini-Series #1-3 are happening in parallel with TMNT Adventures #20-22 (Raphael was with the MM gang in these 3 issues, which explains his absence in #20-21 and his return at the end of #22). After that, Mighty Mutanimals #1-5 was chronologically happening in parallel with TMNT Adventures #23-37, followed by the MM gang meeting the turtles again in #38.
But yeah, IDW decided to leave out #32-37 due to controversial content involving religion and whatnot. So new readers could just assume a hiatus happened after #31 and the story skipped straight to #38 when it returns.
If you want to find out more about the full chronology, you can check out the thread (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=50782) I recently made about it.
DrSpengler
01-23-2015, 08:05 AM
On the bright side, we won't all have to invest in "Je Suis IDW" t-shirts anytime soon.
oldmanwinters
01-23-2015, 08:39 AM
On the bright side, we won't all have to invest in "Je Suis IDW" t-shirts anytime soon.
http://i.imgur.com/9fuxsnM.gif
This actually reminds me that I probably need to start keeping an eye out for original back issue copies of TMNTA #32-37 due to potential increased demand in the collector's market.
neatoman
01-23-2015, 09:16 AM
IDW trying to be PC, I reckon. Those stories deal with China's oppression of Tibet, fictional depictions of Mecca, and an illustrated portrayal of the prophet Mohammed.
Mighty Mutanimals #1-5 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/mutanimals/01/01.htm) is a spin-off arc telling the Mutanimals' adventure (without the turtles) that took place immediately after Mr. Null/Maligna's joint-arc (which consist of TMNT Adventures #19 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/19/19.htm) and Mighty Mutanimals Mini-Series #1-3 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/mutanimals/miniseries/01/01.htm)) and right before the United We Stand, Divided We Fall arc (which consist of TMNT Adventures #38 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/38/38.htm), Mighty Mutanimals #6 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/mutanimals/06/06.htm) and TMNT Adventures #39 (http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/39/39.htm)).
Note that chronologically the Mutanimals spin-off arcs are usually happening in parallel with the main issues. For instance, the MM Mini-Series #1-3 are happening in parallel with TMNT Adventures #20-22 (Raphael was with the MM gang in these 3 issues, which explains his absence in #20-21 and his return at the end of #22). After that, Mighty Mutanimals #1-5 was chronologically happening in parallel with TMNT Adventures #23-37, followed by the MM gang meeting the turtles again in #38.
But yeah, IDW decided to leave out #32-37 due to controversial content involving religion and whatnot. So new readers could just assume a hiatus happened after #31 and the story skipped straight to #38 when it returns.
If you want to find out more about the full chronology, you can check out the thread (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=50782) I recently made about it.
Oh OK then. It would at least have been nice if they included some kind of explaination for they ignored 6 issues or a vague enough summary of said issues like they did with those outdated versions of the Transformers reprints (which ironically I traded in when I purchased this trade...).
On the bright side, we won't all have to invest in "Je Suis IDW" t-shirts anytime soon.
The attacks on Jyllands-Posten,Lars Vilks and Charlie Hebdo are all instances of mockery of Mohammed. Granted even a respectful depiction of Mohammed could be considered offensive but I doubt it would have drawn nearly as much attention, although with recent events in mind, yeah it's probably best for IDW to stay as far away from that issue as possible...
CyberCubed
01-23-2015, 02:16 PM
So let me get this straight, a kids comic in the 90's could be printed with no problem about Islamic culture and Tibet, etc....yet IDW comics printed in the year 2015 aimed mostly at adults can't do the same thing?
ToTheNines
01-23-2015, 03:30 PM
It's not just "Islamic Culture", the fact that Chris Allan drew Mohammed would be very offensive to most Muslims. Like neatoman said, it wasn't in mockery so I'm sure it would fly under the radar, but Muslims are iconoclastic and would consider it unholy.
funatic
01-23-2015, 04:11 PM
So let me get this straight, a kids comic in the 90's could be printed with no problem about Islamic culture and Tibet, etc....yet IDW comics printed in the year 2015 aimed mostly at adults can't do the same thing?
Thanks to the internet the world is quite a bit smaller now than it was in the 90s, add in heightened tensions in lieu of recent events, and yeah - IDW in 2015 has to take a bit more precaution.
CyberCubed
01-23-2015, 05:14 PM
It's not just "Islamic Culture", the fact that Chris Allan drew Mohammed would be very offensive to most Muslims. Like neatoman said, it wasn't in mockery so I'm sure it would fly under the radar, but Muslims are iconoclastic and would consider it unholy.
Couldn't they just edit that one page or something? I mean one missing page would be a whole lot better than skipping 7 comics entirely.
Especially for new readers who never read Archie before, and this is their first exposure to the series and now they're missing issues. Its a bigger deal than the 5 Volume 1 guest issues they skipped, which had no impact on canon so it didn't matter too much, (although I still hope "The River," "Sky Highway" and "Turtle Dreams" get collected eventually)
Joey Kamikaze
01-23-2015, 05:36 PM
It's especially annoying for new readers because these issues are when TMNTA is evolving rapidly as a series. The shift in tone that's obvious by #42 begins with "Midnight Sun" and carries through the skipped issues. It's a shame to skip an arc just as the book hits its stride.
And besides, some of these skipped stories (especially the Tattoo issue and "Stump'd Again") are fun reads.
CyberCubed
01-23-2015, 07:55 PM
I'm glad I never picked up these Archie trades. I was holding out just to see if any screw-up would happen and sure enough it did.
Still sucks for new people who never read the series before, I'm glad I still have all my old single issues.
oldmanwinters
01-23-2015, 08:01 PM
Thanks to the internet the world is quite a bit smaller now than it was in the 90s, add in heightened tensions in lieu of recent events, and yeah - IDW in 2015 has to take a bit more precaution.
I do miss the days when this old world was a great big place full of mystery and adventure.
Nasubionna
01-23-2015, 10:20 PM
I, too, was confused until I noticed that they skipped all those issues. Pretty disappointing. And unfortunately, those particular issues aren't ones that I have in my old collection of original Archie comics, so I'll have to try and get my hands on them off eBay or something now. Bummer.
darthsmozers
01-25-2015, 10:16 PM
It's especially annoying for new readers because these issues are when TMNTA is evolving rapidly as a series. The shift in tone that's obvious by #42 begins with "Midnight Sun" and carries through the skipped issues. It's a shame to skip an arc just as the book hits its stride.
And besides, some of these skipped stories (especially the Tattoo issue and "Stump'd Again") are fun reads.
It's a shame the Stump'd Again issue wasn't included, at the least. Also, if the image of the prophet was to blame, then surely yes, that single page could have been edited (read: censored)... As it is, those issues set up a lot of content for the next set of issues, including the upcoming villains. I hope THOSE aren't edited out.
I'm sure overall it was a difficult editorial decision, but I agree that in lieu of editing/censoring the originals, at least some sort of synopsis (with key panels?) should have been included as well as a reason, however generic, as a sort of "forward" to this trade. Or, throw us a bone and include the missed MM issues as well. They were short issues once you subtract all the ad space...
The Fifth Turtle
01-31-2015, 08:15 AM
So as a collector of the trades should I assume that the skipped issues from the main volume will remain skipped? In other words should I track down the originals or is there a chance that IDW will edit these issue(s) and release them at some point?
darthsmozers
01-31-2015, 07:56 PM
So as a collector of the trades should I assume that the skipped issues from the main volume will remain skipped? In other words should I track down the originals or is there a chance that IDW will edit these issue(s) and release them at some point?
Probably track them down... In the current terroristic climate.
MightyMutanIMAL
02-09-2015, 12:31 PM
I recently contacted the guys in charge of collections at IDW and asked about both the possibility of Mighty Mutanimals being collected (what with the new mini-series starting this week) and whether issues 32-37 of TMNTA would be collected.
They dodged the TMNTA question, but said this about Mutanimals:
'"Mutanimals Classics” will be considered for its own collection at such time as the success of our new series can be determined. At the moment our TMNT reprint program is quite robust, and we see no reason to add another title into the mix.
Thanks for your questions."
CyberCubed
02-09-2015, 12:56 PM
You should have told them the Mutanimals series is only 9 issues, its not like its a huge series they have to collect. They can reprint it all quickly.
MightyMutanIMAL
02-09-2015, 01:42 PM
Yeah, I would have presumed that they knew that, but the way they're talking they make it sound like some big commitment.
Maybe they're thinking about the Merdude and Donnie/Leatherhead miniseries too, but that seems unlikely.
CyberCubed
02-09-2015, 03:18 PM
Yeah, and didn't they already re-printed the first 3 issue Mutanimals miniseries and issue 6 already? So they would only have 8 issues to reprint.
I haven't been following IDW's trades since I own all the old Archie issues but it sucks for new people who never read the series before/
Duke Nukem
02-10-2015, 10:51 PM
I get why they don't want to publish anything that offends Muslims, because they tend to kill people when they're offended. It's easy for some of us to not care about that, but I'm sure many of IDW's staff have families that don't want to be blown up just so some comics can be re-released, the same reason Kevin Smith gave for not wanting to produce Dogma 2.
There's also the issue with offending China regarding Tibet. PRC takes its territory disputes quite seriously and definitely wouldn't like the content. After hearing about IDW's troubles with the ports, maybe their comics are printed there ? I wouldn't expect that to continue if they republished it The Red Dawn remake went through the same thing, having to change the plot of the movie so that it could be sold in China.
Still, I don't understand why they're skipping so much, since editing out the questionable material would accomplish the same thing. It doesn't make a difference to me personally since I own most of the single issues and eventually will have all of them, but it would be good for new readers to be able to properly catch up.
Either way I'm opposed to censorship on moral grounds but realize it's necessary and unavoidable for practical purposes here.
Diorm
02-11-2015, 07:22 AM
Like CyberCubed said, they should have just edit the pages. Now I'll miss on those issues.
plastroncafe
02-11-2015, 10:50 AM
I'd rather them not reprint them at all, rather than censor them for content.
It's not as if these stories aren't out there to be found, either in scans or back issues.
Diorm
02-11-2015, 11:40 AM
I'd rather them not reprint them at all, rather than censor them for content.
It's not as if these stories aren't out there to be found, either in scans or back issues.
Yeah but they are not in a TPB. :tcry:
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.