View Full Version : So will IDW take Archie's record of having the longest TMNT comic?
neatoman
01-31-2015, 05:29 AM
So side stuff aside, Archie had the longest TMNT comic ever with 72 issues. (I think Mirage still published more issues than Archie even when the side stuff is included, they just didn't number any series above 70).
But do you think it's possible for IDW to take that record? They obviously have plans until after issue 50 and to break the record they would just have to make it up until issue 73.
I think they can, unless they start doing that stupid thing Marvel and DC does where they decide to start over at issue 1 for whatever tiny little reason just to boost sales. Wolverine titles got 8 number 1 issues in the past 2 years. No really, Wolverine v5 (ended at 13), Wolverine v6 (ended at 12), Savage Wolverine (ended at 23), Wolverine and the X-Men v2 (ended at 12), Death of Wolverine (ended at 4), Death of Wolverine: The Logan Legacy (will end at 7), Death of Wolverine: The Weapon X Program (will end at 5), Wolverines (will end at 16).
As long as they don't do that, I think they can break the record.
ChosenOne
01-31-2015, 07:01 AM
I sure hope they don't go back to #1 after #50... This run deserves to break the record!
ProphetofGanja
01-31-2015, 10:00 AM
I highly doubt they would do that
ChosenOne
01-31-2015, 10:03 AM
I highly doubt they would do that
Mr. Curnow mentioned on the IDW Forums that it's a ongoing discussion, so it could happen. But I certainly hope not.
Leomaru
01-31-2015, 10:07 AM
I hope this story lasts long. 100 issues sounds reasonable :tgrin:
pingclang
01-31-2015, 10:15 AM
Is it still a fact that Tom Waltz is leaving the series with issue 50? I get the feeling they may take it back to issue 1 just because that's sort of how IDW does things, at least from my experience. If he stays on they may continue but if they go to a whole new creative team, I don't see it being as likely.
spookycookies
01-31-2015, 10:29 AM
Is it still a fact that Tom Waltz is leaving the series with issue 50? I get the feeling they may take it back to issue 1 just because that's sort of how IDW does things, at least from my experience. If he stays on they may continue but if they go to a whole new creative team, I don't see it being as likely.
wait back up here where did you hear that? :o
I'm hoping it goes beyond 50 moving forward but even if they feel like renumbering etc I hope that the universe that IDW built is still continued in any future books. I think if you included the side books there are at least 70 issues now.
snake
01-31-2015, 10:33 AM
I really hope they don't renumber. That would ruin it in my opinion.
Mike Lowrey
01-31-2015, 11:39 AM
If they re-number, then I'm done with the series.
...okay probably not, but I would be extremely upset.
spookycookies
01-31-2015, 12:12 PM
I really hope they don't renumber. That would ruin it in my opinion.
If they re-number, then I'm done with the series.
...okay probably not, but I would be extremely upset.
The numbering itself may not be the end of the world. The Mirage universe and turtles lasted through 3 volumes and 2 tales series. I admit that it would be very disappointing that the issue count could reset after a milestone because that's how comics get sales boosts, but if IDW maintains the established continuity of these books and the Turtles of volume 6 are the same ones as volume 5 then I'll go with it.
My biggest fear is that everything we've established will be scrapped and we will have to go through another reinvention and year's worth of origins. How many times now have we seen the TMNT first meet April, first fight the purple dragons, first encounter with Shredder. The narrative needs to move beyond the introductory phase that has been so finely tuned over the last 30 years.
Volume 5 has so much more just beyond Vengeance. Null, Triceratons, Kitsune's game and all the other stories that can be told in this world. Yes a lot of it has been built up around Shredder and Krang and we are now at the big payoff of their arcs, but if we can inch further there is so much more ground that this story can cover. I want to see Radical & Carnage remade for IDW, Hattori and Chote given the same new life that Bebop & Rocksteady were given. As much as there is to reinvent and renew there is also so much new material that can come from the IDW TMNT universe.
This is a great book and I'd like to see the universe stick even if the numbers dial back as per marketing.
AlZarkovski
01-31-2015, 12:51 PM
From IDW forum:
by Bobby Curnow » Thu Jan 29, 2015 8:08 pm
There's some debate about whether we should relaunch with a new #1 after #50. I'm personally against that idea, but it's an ongoing discussion. Regardless of numbering, expect the same storyline to continue. Tom and Kevin and I have a basic blueprint that leads to #100 (or... another #50) that we're excited about and that we should be able to do, if sales maintain their current state.
neatoman
01-31-2015, 01:22 PM
From IDW forum:
by Bobby Curnow » Thu Jan 29, 2015 8:08 pm
There's some debate about whether we should relaunch with a new #1 after #50. I'm personally against that idea, but it's an ongoing discussion. Regardless of numbering, expect the same storyline to continue. Tom and Kevin and I have a basic blueprint that leads to #100 (or... another #50) that we're excited about and that we should be able to do, if sales maintain their current state.
It's nice to know they're not at all planning on rebooting, it's still a bad idea to renumber after only 50 issues, try to get 100 at least.
TomWaltz
01-31-2015, 01:55 PM
Is it still a fact that Tom Waltz is leaving the series with issue 50? I get the feeling they may take it back to issue 1 just because that's sort of how IDW does things, at least from my experience. If he stays on they may continue but if they go to a whole new creative team, I don't see it being as likely.
Hey... Do you know something I don't know?
:)
Talk soon...
Tom W.
CyberCubed
01-31-2015, 02:21 PM
Please don't restart the numbering at #1 again after issue 50, its pointless. Its not going to boost sales either like DC and Marvel seem to think, since after the initial freshness sales decline again and go back to what they were.
The only reason Mirage restarted the numbering for Volume 2 was because of the switch to color. Then Image started with #1 again because it was their first published TMNT comic. Then Volume 4 was #1 again because PL took control over the series after Image.
But with IDW...there's no point. Same creative team, same writers, why restart?
ToTheNines
01-31-2015, 02:44 PM
It would boost sales for the new #1, but they would quickly return to normal.
But yeah, they're just continuing the same story and I don't feel like this impending conflict with the Kitsune/Rat King family really screams "good jumping on point". It's just going to end up disappointing a lot of people.
pingclang
01-31-2015, 03:53 PM
wait back up here where did you hear that? :o
I'm hoping it goes beyond 50 moving forward but even if they feel like renumbering etc I hope that the universe that IDW built is still continued in any future books. I think if you included the side books there are at least 70 issues now.
I can't remember the source. I think it was a rumor that got spread on here, so maybe I'm completely wrong...wellllll
Hey... Do you know something I don't know?
:)
Talk soon...
Tom W.
I guess it definitely was a rumor, lol.
Joey Kamikaze
01-31-2015, 04:26 PM
Put simply, returning to #1 would be dumb. Please don't be dumb, IDW. That kind of gimmicky crap is part of why I don't read anything by DC or Marvel.
Powder
01-31-2015, 04:53 PM
Yeah, don't do that. Please.
funatic
01-31-2015, 06:36 PM
Yeah the rebooting at #1 has been so overdone to the point that #1s on the shelf are overwhelming. As a turtle fan it would be mildly disappointing to see IDW's TMNT following this rehashed trend, and losing the hallmark of a high run. But more importantly, were I to take on the perspective of a potential NEW fan, I'm not going to start a comic series based on low numbers anymore because they are ALL low numbers. In fact, I might be more inclined to get into one of the few series that shows longevity. "Hey, if it's been on the shelf this long, it must be good!" And if you really need to hook the new guys in, just slap on a "GREAT JUMPING-ON POINT" in the corner. As an old fan, that's a gimmick I could deal with. :twink:
Redrumh2o
01-31-2015, 07:25 PM
Can't they boost sales with #50, #75 and #100?? I am sure there will be a million different variants.
pingclang
01-31-2015, 09:15 PM
The beauty of them going on past 50 would be the fact that the continuity would continue which is great in a period of time when everyone wants to be rind of their continuity. What IDW has built has been good and I really hope it keeps coming. I want to be there for the 100th issue of TMNT.
CyberCubed
01-31-2015, 09:18 PM
Come to think of it, Volume 2 of Mirage should have just continued after Volume 1 with a #63 instead of restarting, especially since it was so short-lived at only 13 issues.
Usagi Miyamoto
02-01-2015, 04:27 AM
Understanding that this is a purely aesthetic kind of thing, I'd be fine with the change if it got more readers. However I don't know if that'd be the case and I'd prefer it kept going at #51.
Plasticplayhouse
02-01-2015, 11:06 AM
I hope the idw team sticks together, I love what they're doing and where they're heading. They have been able to take things that I never liked (mutanimals, neutrinos, etc) and provide them a great story, not the rediculousness that they have always emitted.
It would make more sense and be more comforting to continue beyond 50. #1's are for reboots. This can/should continue to grow and expand the wonderful universe they have created.
CyberCubed
02-01-2015, 11:13 AM
If IDW is ever rebooted (story-wise), they might as well just end it all.
There's no reason for IDW continuity to be rebooted at all. This is already a reboot of Mirage and the cartoons mixed together, we don't need a reboot upon reboots.
This is not DC or Marvel that needs an "infinite crisis" to streamline continuity.
ProphetofGanja
02-01-2015, 11:53 AM
I think the "Good Starting Point for New Readers!" sticker is the way to go, and keep on with #51
Leo656
02-01-2015, 12:28 PM
Yeah, that kinda thing is really all you need. Like after "Infinite Crisis", when DC did the "One Year Later" gimmick, that went over really well. A couple books got relaunched but mostly they just used the fact that all the stories were "fresh" as a way for new readers to hop on. The follow-through on some of the books wasn't great, but it was a good idea. You don't need to have new #1s.
As a collector I HATE that New #1 mess, because it can be really tough tracking down back issues if you're not sure which series an issue belongs to. Like, books don't always have dates or years on the covers, so if you're looking for, like, issue 24 of something, it's like, "Is this issue 24 of Vol. 1, Vol. 2," etc., and you end up having to rely on your knowledge of contemporary art styles unless you can physically open the book and check the publishing info, which, if they're already bagged, not every store will let you do. And, as others have said, the momentum a book gets from having a new #1 always wears off really fast anyways.
Back in the day when a book got a new direction or creative team, a tagline on the cover like "A New Era Begins Here!" was all you needed for people to jump on. I miss that. Most people see right through the #1 gimmick, so it's pointless.
pingclang
02-01-2015, 01:13 PM
Yeah, that kinda thing is really all you need. Like after "Infinite Crisis", when DC did the "One Year Later" gimmick, that went over really well. A couple books got relaunched but mostly they just used the fact that all the stories were "fresh" as a way for new readers to hop on. The follow-through on some of the books wasn't great, but it was a good idea. You don't need to have new #1s.
As a collector I HATE that New #1 mess, because it can be really tough tracking down back issues if you're not sure which series an issue belongs to. Like, books don't always have dates or years on the covers, so if you're looking for, like, issue 24 of something, it's like, "Is this issue 24 of Vol. 1, Vol. 2," etc., and you end up having to rely on your knowledge of contemporary art styles unless you can physically open the book and check the publishing info, which, if they're already bagged, not every store will let you do. And, as others have said, the momentum a book gets from having a new #1 always wears off really fast anyways.
Back in the day when a book got a new direction or creative team, a tagline on the cover like "A New Era Begins Here!" was all you needed for people to jump on. I miss that. Most people see right through the #1 gimmick, so it's pointless.
The main reason #1's show up so much, and I'm pretty sure you know this, in the first place is they sell like mad. People still have the mentality that a number 1 will be worth a lot one of these days, not realizing they print so many that it just won't be. It is a gimmick, and makes a lot of money for the companies. I agree totally that having a headline like "It all starts here!" is a much better gimmick, if you can call it that. It's flashy, catches the eye and the dealer can point to the issue and say "Oh, you like Superman? Well, there's a new jumping on point like three issues back so here, check it out." I think that's intelligent and well designed marketing. I really hope IDW takes that to heart and maybe makes 51 a jump on point, with maybe some quick flashbacks to explain the must know stuff. Now, I'll be quiet as I'm rambling.
Leo656
02-01-2015, 01:30 PM
I'm not sure how many people still fall for the #1 thing anymore, or at least I'm not sure how many people still think they're going to be worth anything. Prices have gotten so outrageous, the only people who still buy comics are collectors, and most of those people are savvy enough to know that the only reason older comics are worth anything is because most kids' parents threw out their collections back in the day and the "collector's market" didn't even exist until the 80s, plus newsprint tends to crumble when not stored properly, so everything pre-'86 is scarce. Almost everything from then on tops out around $20, max, and most people know that by now.
So I don't think it has to do with people thinking they're going to get rich by selling off their #1s some day, I think it's just 1. It jumps off the shelf at you more than #395 does, and 2. It's just a "nice thing to have". Maybe a few younger kids might fall for it as a "Collector's Item" but they're the minority, by far.
True story? My Dad had a TON of comics from the 50s/60s, AND a Mickey Mantle rookie card, before his Mom sh*tcanned it all one day when he was at school when he was like 12. We'd have had, like, ZERO problems in life if she hadn't done that, and all the way up until the day she died, she insisted it was "just paper and junk" that was cluttering up the house. Tell her some of that "junk" was worth tens of thousands of dollars, and she'd insist "How? It's just stupid paper!" :roll:
pingclang
02-01-2015, 01:57 PM
You make some valid points, some I didn't really think about but having a couple friends who own and work at a comic shop together, I get their information. Some folks really do believe in the number 1 thing, they've been asked how much they're worth and a few times were told straight-faced that they're crazy for selling a number one at cover price. Still, I have to agree with what you're saying.
That's insane about your dad`s stuff. I can relate though as my dad grew up really poor, outhouse and everything in the 60's-70's and the only comics he ever got were from his cousins after they were done with them. All of these ended up being used as toilet paper after being read because everything was put to some kind of use. So my dad has wiped his butt with the comics I would kill for today, books worth a lot of money now. Insane.
Leo656
02-01-2015, 02:05 PM
That is a goddamn tragedy.
neatoman
02-01-2015, 02:12 PM
If IDW is ever rebooted (story-wise), they might as well just end it all.
There's no reason for IDW continuity to be rebooted at all. This is already a reboot of Mirage and the cartoons mixed together, we don't need a reboot upon reboots.
This is not DC or Marvel that needs an "infinite crisis" to streamline continuity.
It's obvious to everyone IDW is not in the same situation as Marvel and DC. While Marvel and DC still publish good stuff, I don't think anyone can deny most of their titles make up a cluster **** of neverending stories, too common crossovers and spin-offs. Rebooting/streamlining/retcons becomes a necessity sooner or later.
IDW's TMNT series is a fairly self contained series and a recently started reboot. I'm sure that eventually there will be another reboot of the TMNT comics but it won't be out of necessity, it'll be when when some other publisher gets the license or simply because someone just feels the it's time to end the current series and start over.
Come to think of it, Volume 2 of Mirage should have just continued after Volume 1 with a #63 instead of restarting, especially since it was so short-lived at only 13 issues.
Well, to be fair I don't think they knew going into it that it would be just 13 issues...plus, they were in color which was a pretty big change so I can sort of see how a Volume 2, #1 made sense. But in the case of what I'm gathering here about IDW, it seems they are thinking about doing it simply for the sake of doing so. Which I think would pointless at best and a mistake at worst.
Usagi Miyamoto
02-01-2015, 05:17 PM
Yeah, even now the #1 issue gets a lot of purchases - it's why sales always dip after a first issue. If you look at the comic book purchases a #1 always occupies the top slot by a large margin. Honestly if someone is going to be that dumb that they'll buy a copy or even a few under the impression that it will be worth something then let them - it's their twenty bucks wasted.
So while a #1 issue will net them some cash and a bit of momentum, it might alienate the already existing fanbase, as this thread proves.
DrSpengler
02-01-2015, 07:42 PM
While my personal opinion is to keep the original numbering, I don't think the personal opinions of individual consumers are of any merit to the highers ups at IDW in this regard.
They're a company out to turn a profit and in the end they will choose whatever they think will make them more money. Since re-numbering has proven in the past to be a temporary sales booster ("temporary" being the operative word) then there's a better than even chance they'll go with that.
Money talks and as passionate as they are about their Turtle comics, "love" doesn't put bread on the table.
ToTheNines
02-01-2015, 08:00 PM
It just doesn't make sense though... TMNT is consistently IDW's best selling ongoing behind MLP, and the minis sell well too.
I know it's not a top 100 book but I also know for a fact that IDW is making plenty of money as is.
Cipher
02-02-2015, 11:52 PM
Can't say I much care either way -- if the business economics point to a new #1, so be it. 50 issues is fairly substantial for an ongoing series now.
That said, if they're going to pick up plot lines already using groundwork from the first 50 issues, as one would imagine has to be the case with the now-B-plot Kitsune/Rat King business coming to the fore (that's what we're all expecting, right?), it'd seem kind of odd and potentially confusing to renumber.
But whatever -- Grant Morrison's incredibly self-referential, single-story Batman run contains no less than four #1s. It'll all shake out in the end.
Sounds like there's going to be a real sense of finality in #50 in regards to the A-plots of this book though. Maybe even more than I'd expected.
pingclang
02-03-2015, 09:12 AM
If they give it some sort of closure, I would actually be okay with going back to number 1, since that's going to happen at some point that would be a perfect time. As you say though, it would be confusing to still have all these threads for plot floating around and then jump back to number 1. Either way, I'm confident in IDW, they usually please.
ProphetofGanja
02-03-2015, 11:05 AM
I still think it'd be cool if the higher-ups who make these calls decided to let IDW have the distinction of getting to 100 issues. I know I'll still be reading
Wentos
02-03-2015, 11:25 AM
Obviously it wouldn't be the end of the world if the IDW series relaunched with a new #1, but it would be a shame. I was really looking forward to the IDW series being the first TMNT comic with triple-digit numbering.
I love the old TMNT comics, but as a whole they've always felt fractured and disjointed to me. The first 25 years of TMNT comics are peppered with non-canon guest issues, relaunches, retcons, restarts, and loose ends. What sets the IDW series apart is the consistency of vision. The IDW comic feels coherent and planned and sprawling, and IMO the numbering plays a big part in that feeling. There's a sense of legacy, that everything that's happened before is just as important as what's happening right now.
If the IDW book does relaunch, I feel like it would lose a bit of the identity that it's carved out for itself over the last four years. And that would be a shame.
DrSpengler
02-03-2015, 11:40 AM
The double-edged sword of renumbering is that one man's "jumping on" point is another man's "jumping off" point. For every reader who says "Hey, a #1. I guess I'll give this book a try" there's another reader who'll say "Well, I guess this as good a time as any to get off the ride".
For those who follow the series exclusively through trades, I doubt they'll even notice. Those books are sequentially numbered and titled by story arc, so unless they actually read the indicia they won't even know about monthly volume and issue numbers.
I think only those of us who follow on a monthly basis will potentially be affected by a renumbering. And even then, the effect is more superficial. We already have to try and slot in microseries and miniseries issues between issues of the ongoing, so a newly numbered volume isn't actually going to make the reading experience more confusing than it already is (which all things considered, isn't that bad, especially when the editor pops in to help us out).
On a strictly personal note, I would hate to see a renumbering because then I'd have to go through every article at TMNT Entity and every reference link and retitle them something like (IDW Vol. 1) and oh man, I really really REALLY don't want to do thaaaaaaaat...
Joey Kamikaze
02-03-2015, 11:35 PM
On a strictly personal note, I would hate to see a renumbering because then I'd have to go through every article at TMNT Entity and every reference link and retitle them something like (IDW Vol. 1) and oh man, I really really REALLY don't want to do thaaaaaaaat...
Hahaha, I bet.
Personally, it's not like I'm going to stop reading if they go back to #1. This is my favorite comic going, it's become my favorite version of TMNT period... this book is fantastic and it's clear the right people have the license; I hope they keep at it for years until the story comes to a natural end, whatever the numbering system winds up being. But I also want to see this book hit #100 and go beyond, and I'll grumble if they renumber it even though I'll keep buying issues.
shuriken
02-03-2015, 11:40 PM
I sure hope so. Not to knock Archie but I feel IDW is a much better mix of action and story tellling, while it avoids being preachy, which reaaaally bothers me for some reason.
jestergoblin
02-06-2015, 03:56 PM
If relaunching at number 1 gets more readers and allows the series to continue for another 50 issues, I'm fine with it as a new volume. If it is a reboot, then I'm against it because we've only ever gotten glimpses of TMNT beyond Mirage's original issues - which really isn't much in terms of "continuity." It's why I enjoyed the 2K3 series so much, it kept building.
The series is already awkward enough to go back and read in issues thanks to all the intermingled mini series and one-shots (some of which aren't even collected in trade), so going to volume 1 versus volume 2 wouldn't be a huge change of pace and trade readers probably wouldn't even notice.
CyberCubed
02-06-2015, 04:08 PM
They're not doing a reboot story-wise, obviously. They didn't set up a new universe just to kill it in only 50 issues.
IDW already has a second series going on with the Nick animated comic, so they have no reason to end main IDW continuity unless sales drop.
Mike Lowrey
02-12-2015, 10:49 AM
I'm not familiar with IDW's Ghostbusters, but wasn't it restarted after only 16 issues. Why did IDW do such a thing?
coreyrc87
02-12-2015, 01:17 PM
I'm not familiar with IDW's Ghostbusters, but wasn't it restarted after only 16 issues. Why did IDW do such a thing?
I think numbering restarted, but didn't it continue the story? I don't know, that's just what I thought for some reason.
But IDW's G.I. Joe series has had a lot of restarts, too. So much so that when I got a few issues behind, I never bothered picking back up.
They do seem to be handling TMNT much better, though. If they restart numbering but keep the ongoing story, I'd be ok with it, as long as they don't get "#1 fever" like Marvel has had for the last couple years.
pingclang
02-12-2015, 03:26 PM
Am I wrong or does it seem that the trend at IDW is to keep going now? Transformers is now in it's 20's I think as well as GI Joe. If I'm wrong sorry, but maybe they're taking notes on what's going on around them and sticking to their numbers.
DrSpengler
02-12-2015, 03:46 PM
I'm not familiar with IDW's Ghostbusters, but wasn't it restarted after only 16 issues. Why did IDW do such a thing?
Ghostbusters was one of their lowest selling titles so the renumbering was a gimmick to boost sales.
It worked for a few months, but then it slumped back down and got cancelled at #20 (the book was awesome, though).
TMNT might escape a renumbering because it's IDW's second highest selling title behind My Little Pony. They may decide it doesn't need a gimmicky sales boost.
Vegeta
02-17-2015, 05:10 PM
I think IDW turtles is the longest comic I've ever bought from the beginning monthly. It'd be a bummer to see the issues reset but as long as it isn't a reboot I'm happy. This is my favorite incarnation of the turtles ever but the series has built this world slowly. To see it start over would kill my interest.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.